hypopharyngeal cancer – chemoradiotherapy or surgery, the ... patrick gullane...surgical...
TRANSCRIPT
Dr. P. Gullane
Wharton Chair Head & Neck Surgery Professor
Department of Otolaryngology -Head & Neck Surgery University of Toronto
Controversies in The Management of Head and Neck and Thyroid Cancer Royal College of Physicians
London, December 5-6, 2013
Hypopharyngeal Cancer – Chemoradiotherapy or Surgery,
The Debate Continues
Wharton Head and Neck Centre
The Toronto General Hospital
Carcinoma of the hypopharynx
“Carcinoma of the hypopharynx is an awful disease with a terrible prognosis” Randal Weber 2005
Purpose of Presentation
Review Treatment Principles and Options in Hypopharyngeal Carcinoma
Review Options for Pharyngo-Esophageal
reconstruction-A Head and Neck Perspective.
Anatomy of Hypopharynx
Hyoid bone to the inferior border of the cricoid cartilage
3 subsites - Piriform Sinus - Posterior pharyngeal wall - Postcricoid region
Incidence
5-10% of upper aerodigestive cancers
3000 cases/year in U.S.A.
> 95% are squamous cell carcinoma
Age > 50 years
M6:1 F
Frequency of Occurrence • Piriform Sinus - 60-70% - 75% clinical or occult nodes • Posterior pharyngeal wall - 25-33% - 60% clinical or occult nodes • Postcricoid Region - 3-5% - 40% clinical or occult nodes
At Presentation
• 25% Unresectable – palliation • 60% Advanced - organ preservation • 15% Early neoplasms - surgery or irradiation • 65% Nodal metastases at presentation
Diagnostic Evaluation
Clinical Examination • History/physical • Complete head and neck examination - Fiberoptic evaluation and biopsy - Extent of neoplasm-stage - Nodal status, size, site, mobility
Diagnostic Evaluation Imaging • CT/MRI of neck and primary - Cartilage invasion - Lymph node evaluation • Chest x-ray vs CT > 12%
Look for 2nd primary • PET-CT
Diagnostic Evaluation
• Examination under anesthesia and biopsy • Establish extent of neoplasm - Possible tracheostomy
“Role of Panendoscopy” • Prospective study of U. of T. Group - 4 of 154 pts (2.6%) had synchronous primary - Head and Neck 22: 449-455, 2000
MRI/PET/CT
Issues: Value of PET CT: ↑ FDG on the Lt BOT but MR lesion was on the Rt; why↑ FDG @ rectoanal junction
PET CT (3/26/08):
MR (3/26/08): R2A node
Principles of Treatment-Multidisciplinary care
• Radiation Oncologist • Surgical Oncology • Medical Oncologist • Dentist • Speech Pathologist • Oncology Nursing • Nutrition
Treatment Policy • 25% of patients unresectable at presentation • 15% early neoplasms (T1 T2) • 60% advanced T3, T4 (stage III-IV) • “Organ preservation” must be offered to the
patient.
Principles of Treatment • Primary Disease Control • Regional Nodal Control • Preservation of Function
– Speech – Swallowing
Not just organ preservation BUT
Preservation of a functional organ.
Evolution of Organ Preservation Strategies Cancer of the Larynx, Hypopharynx
• 1960’s – Laryngectomy/Pharyngectomy • 1970’s – Laryngectomy alone
Planned radiation with surgery for salvage • 1980’s – Irradiation +/- Chemotherapy (5FU, Mitomycin C) • 1990’s – VA Trial, (Neoadjuvant Chemo/Rad or Laryngectomy) • 2000’s – Adoption of Organ Preservation Approaches. • 1960 2013
100% TL 40% TL Functional Larynx?
Quality of Life?
“I have seen the future and it doesn’t work.” Robert Fulford
Treatment • Early (T1, T2) carcinoma - Piriform sinus - Posterior pharyngeal wall
Laser excision ± neck dissection Partial pharyngectomy + neck (II, III, IV) Primary RT or ChemoRT
• Overall survival @ 3 yrs. – 70%
Problems • Inability to completely resect • Dysphagia • Locoregional recurrence
T2 N0 L. Piriform Fossa Lateral Pharyngotomy
Carcinoma
Transhyoid approach
Study Number of Patients Local Control Laryngeal Preservation 5-Yr Disease Specific
Survival
5-Yr Overall Survival
Open
Laccourreye et al, 1993 (127) 34 (T2) 95% - 56% -
Chevalier et al, 1997 (126) 48 (T1/T2) - - - 47%
(78% T1,
38% T2)
Chung et al, 2013 (136) 58 (T1-T4) - 86.2% 77.6% 78%
TOLS
Steiner et al, 2001 (103) 129 (T1-T4) - - 95% (Stage I/II)
69% (Stage III/IV)
71% (Stage I/II)
47% (Stage III/IV)
Rudert and Hoft et al, 2003
(124)
29 (T1-T4) - 100% - 58% (T1)
48% (T2)
Martin et al, 2008 (142) 172 (T1-T4) 84% (T1)
70% (T2)
75% (T3)
57% (T4a)
- 96% (Stage I/II)
86% (Stage III)
57% (Stage IVa)
68% (Stage I/II)
64% (Stage III)
41% (Stage IVa)
Karatzanis et al, 2010 (143) 119 (T1/T2) 85.4%
90% (T1)
83.1 (T2)
- 72.6%
77.8% (T1)
70% (T2)
-
Outcomes of Partial Conservation Surgery in Hypopharyngeal Cancer
Treatment
• Advanced T3, T4 carcinoma – Concurrent Chemo-radiation – Hyperfractionated RT – Laryngopharyngectomy and Adjuvant RT or
ChemoRT
Study Number of
Patients
Stage/Site Local Control Regional Control Laryngeal
Preservation
5-Yr Disease
Specific Survival
5-Yr Overall
Survival
Lefebvre et al,
1996
194 (100 pts in ICT
arm)
T2-T4, N0-N3/ PS,
AEF
17% 23% 35% 25% 30%
Bensadoun et al,
2006
163 (20 Hyp
tumors in CRT arm)
T3, T4, N0-N3 - - - 44.5% (2 yrs) 37.8% (2 yrs)
Lefebvre et al,
2009
450 T2-T4, N0-N2 (231
Hyp)
- - 30.5% ICT Arm
36.2% CRT Arm
- 48.5% ICT Arm
51.9% CRT Arm
Prades et al, 2010 71 T3 PS - - 68% ICT Arm
92% CRT Arm
(2 yrs)
36% ICT Arm
41% CRT Arm
(2 yrs)
-
Lefebvre et al,
2012
194 (100 pts in ICT
arm)
T2-T4, N0-N3/ PS,
AEF
- - 62.5% (10 yrs) 26.97% (10 yrs) 13.1% (10 yrs)
Lefebvre et al,
2013
Phase II
116 (ICT + CRT vs
ICT + BRT)
Stage II, III, IVa (69
Hyp)
95% ICT+CRT
93% ICT+BRT
(3 months)
Randomized Trials of Chemoradiation Therapy in Hypopharyngeal Cancer.
Surgery & Radiation Therapy for Carcinoma of the Hypopharynx
S + RT (n=132)
• Locoregional Control 61% • 5 yr OS 30% • 5 yr DFS 41% Kraus DH, Zeleksky MJ, et al, Otolaryngol
Head Neck Surg 116: 637-31, 1997
Is Pharyngolaryngectomy Palliative?
• Shah J. Carcinoma of the hypopharynx. Am J Surg. 1976;132:439 » 1950 - 1970: 301 untreated patients » Overall 5YS 26% » Early stage (T1N0) > 43% 5YS
• Spiro R. Gastric transposition for head and neck cancer. A Critical update. Am J Surg. 1991;162:348
» 1973 - 1990: 120 patients » Overall 5YS 27% (hypo 32% > cerv esoph 21%)
• Wei W. Currant status of pharyngolaryngo-esophagectomy and pharyngogastric anastomosis
» 1966 - 1995: 317 patients » 1979: 5YS 18% » 1995: 5YS 25%
Outcome in 41 patients of Gastric Transposition
• Goldberg M. Freeman J. Gullane PJ. Patterson GA. Todd TR. McShane D. Transhiatal esophagectomy with gastric transposition for pharyngolaryngeal malignant disease. J Thor Cardiovasc Surg. 97(3):327-33, 1989
– 41 patients (21 prior high dose RT)
– Mortality 20%
– Morbidity 46%
– Fistula 22%
– Mean LOS 31 days
– Overall 35% 2YS
Triboulet JP. Surgical management of carcinoma of the hypopharynx and cervical esophagus: analysis of 209 cases.
Arch Surg. 136:1164, 2001
Surgical Salvage Following Irradiation ± Chemotherapy
Problems - Extent of recurrence - neck only - neck & primary - Hostile wound - High fistula rate - Need for flap repair
The Ideal Reconstruction after Laryngopharyngectomy
• Single stage procedure. • Restore gastrointestinal continuity. • Low or minimal surgical
morbidity/mortality. • Low rate of distal stenosis. • Allow the development of functional
fistula speech. • Minimal technical/surgical expertise. • Ability to discharge the patient early.
Menu of Options in Reconstruction
Reconstruction Swallowing Speech Morbidity
Gastric Transposition
++++ + ++++
Jejunum ++ + ++
Gastro-omental ++++ +++ ++
Anterolateral Thigh
+++ ++ +
Forearm +++ ++ +
Current Treatment Philosophy
For Total Laryngopharyngectomy Avoid Gastric Transposition In high performance patients with no previous
laparatomy-Gastro-Omental Flap In poor performance patients-Anterolateral thigh flap with
salivary stent
Algorithm of Pharyngeal Reconstruction in an Era of Organ Preservation 2010
Circumferential Defect
Primary Surgery
Thigh Thickness
Radial Forearm Anterolateral Thigh
Salvage Surgery
Initial Therapy
Standard Radiotherapy
Chemoradiation/ high dose altered
fractionation
Performance
Gastro-Omental Flap
Poor
Adequate
Summary Management of Carcinoma of the Hypopharynx
Primary Disease Control and Organ Preservation in appropriate patients
Management of the Neck and Regional Control Aggressive use of complex reconstructive techniques
in concurrent chemoradiation failure patients
Treatment of Hypopharyngeal Carcinoma-PMH approach
Small Primary Tumors Primary surgery(laser or partial pharyngectomy) + Neck
Management + Post-op RT vs Primary RT or Concurrent Extensive Tumors-T4a Primary Laryngopharyngectomy + Postop RT vs
Concurrent ChemoRT and Salvage Unresectable Concurrent ChemoRT or Clinical Trial