hunting wave hill: a research proposal · no ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal
Cultural observers embraced an ethnographic impulse that looked
outward, at worlds beyond their own, as a means of marking the
social coordinates of a self ...
(Neumann: 1996)
No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of
everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination—
the imagination that is, of both those who make history and those
who write it.
(Comaroff & Comaroff: 1992)
Name: Charlie Ward
Department: English, Creative Writing and Australian Studies
Supervisor: Ass. Prof. Rick Hosking, Flinders University
Co- Supervisors: Prof. Lynette Russell and Dr. Nathan Hollier (Monash University)
Date: 23 March, 2011.
Word Length: 6,034
![Page 2: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Contents
1. Abstract……………………….………………………………………………..…………….3
2. Topic Summary…………….………………………………………………..…………….4
3. Research Question ……………………………………………………….………………6
4. Rationale: Creative Work ....................................................................7
„Peoples‟ history‟
The Walk-off and Orality
Subjectivity, Race and Ethics
5. Rationale: Exegesis ............................................................................15
6. Research Methodology .......................................................................18
Auto-ethnography: the self in the text
Oral History: a research method
7. Literature Review and Originality…………………...................................23
8. Structure of Creative Work (Total of 60,000 words)...............................26
9. Elements of the Exegesis (Total of 40,000 words)…………………………………….32
10: Research Plan and Special Considerations.………………………………….34
11: Works Cited..…………………………………………………………………………....35
12. Preliminary Bibliography……………………………………………………………41
![Page 3: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
1. Abstract:
The Wave Hill Walk-off, an Indigenous protest by remote Northern Territory Gurindji
pastoral workers in 1966, is widely regarded as one of the key catalysts of the Land
Rights movement in Australia, which in turn formed a key part of a 1970s liberal
Indigenous policy agenda initially titled „self-determination.‟ As a result of the dialectic
between espoused Gurindji goals and government policy implementation, two
residential „communities‟ were formed during this period. The subsequent
development of these communities remains largely unexplored in an academic context
to date.
This research contains two strands. In the creative work of my thesis, I will creatively
represent the factors influencing developments at Wattie Creek from 1966-1986
through a social history interspersed with reflective memoir. In the exegetical
component of the thesis, I will examine the above social history with a view to its
implications for current Indigenous policy and service delivery.
This project is being submitted for consideration in the Faculty’s Doctorate program
due to the requisite scale of the proposed work and its contribution of original
knowledge to the field.
![Page 4: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
2. Topic Summary:
On 23 August 1966 Gurindji workers and their families left their work and place of
residence at Wave Hill Station as a statement signifying their rejection of the position
they had occupied in the pastoral industry since European settlement.1 For several
months afterwards, the Gurindji camped next to the local depot of the government
agency responsible for Indigenous welfare. They then re-located to Wattie Creek,
where they began to build homes and work towards providing their own livelihood. In
time the Welfare Settlement location was chosen by government as its preferred site of
housing and service provision for the Gurindji and was re-branded „Kalkaringi.‟ The
Gurindji‟s home of choice on the banks of Wattie Creek was named „Daguragu.‟
After the election of the Whitlam government in 1972, the Gurindji were ostensibly
among the greatest beneficiaries of the new policies of self-determination, and yet
within a few years social dissonance grew significantly and key aspects of their vision,
as they had articulated it, had floundered. The details and causes of this erosion of
both Gurindji and government goals at Daguragu and Kalkaringi are largely
unexamined. The general precepts of „self-determination‟ policy remained
unchallenged throughout the 70s, 80s and 90s. In recent years some orthodoxies of
Indigenous policy have been questioned (Sutton: 2009, Altman & Hinkson: 2010),
though little overall discussion that contextualises the „self-deterministic‟ policy era
1 See Long:1992; Riddett:1997; Atwood: 2000; Bunbury: 2002.
![Page 5: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
versus the „assimilative‟ one that preceded it has appeared. By focusing on these topics
at the geographic, cultural and political nexus of Wave Hill, this research represents a
contribution of new knowledge to the field of Indigenous studies.
From 2004-06, I worked for the Gurindji‟s then local government body, and in a sense
was witness to the contemporary outcomes of the Walk-off. My lifelong interests in
social history and Australian identity were inherited from my father Russel Ward, who
was a significant cultural historian. In encountering the dialectical intersection of
these tropes with my passion for Indigenous issues at Wave Hill, as history and in my
lived- experience, both my inherited and personal political and ideological beliefs were
challenged.
It is recognised that even within the scope of a PhD, there may be too many connected
issues— in both methodology and subject— to progress each to the depth that may be
desirable. It is also expected then, that through the research process some elements
will gain precedence over others, and that they will then form the more significant
motifs of the thesis.
![Page 6: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
3. Research question:
By closely charting the development of Kalkaringi and Daguragu between 1966 and
1986, including the achievement (or otherwise) of Gurindji Walk-off era goals, and
juxtaposing this with personal reflection, the research asks: „what lessons can be learnt
about the implementation and effectiveness of “self-determination” policies and the
role of non-Indigenous „helpers‟ in the context of Indigenous engagement and
governance in north Australia?‟
Using the formation of the Gurindjis‟ Muramulla Cattle Company as a case study in the
Creative Work, the interplay of mainstream economic, urban-liberal, and Gurindji
ideologies, beliefs, policies and practices will be examined. Lessons arising from this
for current Indigenous policy-makers and non-Indigenous „helpers‟ at Daguragu and
other, similar, remote Indigenous communities will then be explored in the Exegesis.
![Page 7: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
4. Rationale: Creative Work
... The more I uncovered about the „local‟, the more I came to see the
best way of explaining the „national‟ was to focus on the „local‟. Through
the history of one area, I could perhaps explain how Australia had
become so deeply divided ...
(McKenna: 2002)
Recent scholarship and public debate has described the profusion and inter-mingling
of nominally non-fictive literary and newly-accepted academic approaches to history,
anthropology, ethnography and life-writing (Clendinnen: 2005, Chang: 2008, Denzin:
2006). I propose to use a blend of these approaches, which will be discussed in more
detail later. Here I shall address the creative non-fictional aspect of the work, and then
the use of an auto-ethnographic approach within this. The use of auto-ethnographic
methods will be explored further in the section on Methodology (p13).
It is appropriate to address the topic using a creative approach for several reasons.
Although the Wave Hill Walk-off is a historic event, it is also a legendary story with a
rich symbolism and historiography. As a popular and emotive act, the Walk-off lends
itself to a „people‟s history‟ approach (See below; p 8). My goal is to tell a story for a
![Page 8: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
popular audience, and I am aware that there is a greater readership for such topics if
they are addressed both within an academic environment and beyond it.
It is through the process of attempting to understand my own experiences that I have
been led to pose the research question. The use of the first person at points in a
history of this type is appropriate as without an identified narrative presence, the
inquiry lacks immediacy to the reader.
The creative work distinguishes itself from much in the field by using two of the most
common standards in the genre as departure points from which a third approach is
adduced. Ethnographic memoir and historic non-fiction are two traditionally distinct
genres that would provide the most obvious approaches to the topic. The creative work
will hybridize these.
Within travel, autobiographical and ethnographic writing genres, there exists a long
tradition in the Western canon of ethnographic memoir. The traditional form is that of
the (male) European outsider describing his experience as a witness to, and sometimes
as a participant in, the lives and cultural behaviours of another (usually Indigenous)
race. Post-structuralists such as Mary Pratt (1992) and Edward Said (1978) have
contributed enormously to the deconstruction of this genre through the articulation of
![Page 9: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
its dialectics of power, and the processes by which the idealised European rational self
(the „seer/see-er‟) sought self-definition through the construction of the Indigenous
„other‟. The genre has been further complicated by the arrival of „insider‟ and „native‟
ethnographies, as well as a growing stable of „life-writing‟ approaches, which can
utilise any number of auto-ethnographic techniques. Ellis and Bochner identify a total
of forty such, which range from ethnographic memoir to collaborative autobiography
(2000). These developments have contextualised the literary focus on the „other‟ in the
text, if not supplanted it with the shifting subjectivities of the writer/researcher. A
parallel process has been at work in the field of Australian historiography. Greg
Dening (2004), Katrina Schlunke (2005) and Henry Reynold‟s (1999) works include
their own life histories and subjectivities as reference points framing their historical
enquiries.
The depth of description in ethnographic memoir varies, often depending on the
longevity of the author‟s relationships with their subjects, or their proximity of contact,
and can at times border on superficiality. The author‟s inner world of meditation,
conjecture and reflection are often bought to the fore, not as a source of insight on the
topic (as in auto-ethnography), but through the use of the writing process to
comprehend the actions of Indigenous subjects. While I have written much in the way
of first-person memoir describing my time at Kalkaringi with the Gurindji between
2004 and 2006, this genre, on its own, is limited in its scope, relevance, ethical
integrity and literary appeal.
![Page 10: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
The other genre which could be harnessed to address the research question is that of
„straight‟ historical non-fiction. With an antecedent such as the Wave Hill Walk-off, it
would be productive to write a history that merely attempts to chronicle its subject. To
do so however, would preclude some of the creative work‟s contemporary relevance,
and create an illusion of separation between the worlds of the writer and the subject.
It is only by combining these approaches and tracing the relationship between the
historic subject and my more contemporary experience that the research accrues
greater relevance and narrative strength than that of either genre. Some historians,
such as Tom Stannage, see this—making explicit the connections between the past and
the present—as essential to their task. Stannage argues that „the historian must re-
open that dialogue between the past and the present. That is the legitimate, indeed
legitimising function of the historian, and extends the range of facts with which the
historian interacts‟ (cited in Nile: 1998). Through reading of the author‟s recent
experience in a composite historic narrative, the reader is able to connect the history
described with the contemporary discourse of Indigenous affairs.
![Page 11: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
‘People’s history’:
With little in the way of official or comprehensive historiography on the topic, the
memories of the people involved— or in some cases, their unpublished
correspondence— form a significant repository of information about the topic. This
necessitates the use of oral history, which is in keeping with existing representations of
the Walk-off. By recognising the „ownership‟ of Walk-off history by its participants,
supporters and critics, the creative work will accrue a more vivid, biographic quality;
akin to a „people‟s history‟ approach.2 This approach will not be taken at the expense of
government or other official records (which will also be used extensively), but rather
even in such cases, it attempts to highlight the personalities and ideologies of the
individuals involved in their creation.
Interweaving the recollections of individuals with a narrative describing the larger
movements and trends in which they participated imbues both with context and
colour. It also creates a mechanism whereby historical truisms can be measured by the
experience of those who participated in the events they describe. In the words of
historian Isabelle Bertaux-Wiame, „it is by finding recurrent patterns throughout a
series of life trajectories that we infer the existence of socio structural processes‟, and
discover how „conversely the aggregated practices of isolated actors may eventually
influence macrosocial processes‟ (cited in Barman: 1989).
2 It is recognised that this process is not, despite best intentions, truly democratic and impartial; that
my own socio-political proclivities will inevitably colour the processes of selection and representation.
![Page 12: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
The Walk-off and Orality:
It is appropriate to draw on oral sources in addressing the topic for many reasons. The
over-arching practical issue is the fact that there are few personal written records
relating to the topic. Most of my primary sources (from individuals, as opposed to
organisations or departments) on the topic are oral history recordings. The orality of
the Walk-off narrative is mirrored by the fact that the Gurindji are primarily oral,
performative historians (Hokari: 2000a, 2000b, 2002), and two popular songs are the
main means by which the Walk-off story has entered popular knowledge subsequent to
the event.3 Frank Hardy‟s book on the Walk-off, which I address on page 19 in the
Literature Review and Originality section, also used oral recordings to allow some
Gurindji men, (who were unable to write), to tell their own stories.
Reliable record-keeping is also one of the issues that hamper the administration of
remote communities.4 To research my topic is it is necessary to locate and interview
staff members that have worked with the Gurindji through the assimilation, self-
determination and self-management eras of policy, and senior Gurindji leaders, to
develop a collective biographic account. In this way a record of the Gurindjis‟
3 Poor Bugger Me, Gurindji by Ted Egan, 1973, and From Little Things Big Things Grow, by Paul Kelly and Kev
Carmody, 1991. 4 The Victoria River flooded in 1998 and many records of the Daguragu Community Government Council were
destroyed.
![Page 13: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
experiences as both subjects and objects of „self-deterministic‟ governance will be
composed.
Subjectivity, Race and Ethics:
The subject matter and the field of enquiry are riven with serious ethical issues that
must be taken into consideration. Contention around issues of intellectual property,
cultural appropriation and confidentiality are often exacerbated in the context of
Australian Indigenous research, due to a history of cultural insensitivity,
misrepresentation and abuse of research privileges (Cowlishaw, 1999).5 Importantly,
the oral history component of the research— some of which will be conducted with
Indigenous interviewees— has been granted Ethical Approval by the Social and
Behavioural Research Ethics Committee (SBREC) of the University (SBREC: Project
number 4770). This ethical approval is for the research aspect of my candidature,
although more complex ethical challenges may arise in writing about contentious
issues in a way that respects the integrity of the informants, the opinions of the writer,
and the historical record.
This task will be ameliorated somewhat. Some of the most dangerous traps of
postcolonial writing will be avoided here: rather than representing the „other‟ (which,
5 In the Gurindji context, an example of this occurred in 1967 when a Welfare Officer was directed to assess the
sanctity of the Gurindjis’ sacred sites. After sharing much detailed and restricted information with him, the Officer
reported that the sites were not sacred. This information was used by the Government as further grounds to refuse
the Gurindji rights to their traditional land. See ‘Sacred Sites: Wave Hill Area’, Report to Director of Welfare
Branch, 29 May 1967, National Archives of Australia (E242). K66/1/1, District Welfare Officer Reports, Wave
Hill Area. Darwin.
![Page 14: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
as the author is a European male, would be representing the Indigenous strikers) as
the primary focus of the inquiry, the text will primarily seek to unfold, explore and
understand the behaviours, practices and ideologies of the Gurindji‟s non-Indigenous
interlocutors, be they pastoral employers, activist-supporters, or public servants.6
It is primarily „my‟ side of the intercultural encounter that I am attempting to
understand, in the hope that this may shed further light on the current practices of my
professional field: the Indigenous service industry. As advanced by Commaroff and
Commaroff, „ … the conundrum of similarity and difference is only to be resolved by
turning anthropology on itself, by treating modernity (and postmodernity) as a
problem in historical ethnography‟ (1992:45). Although this approach is complicated
by the fact that distinguishing the „ownership‟ of different narratives is at times
complex in a history of cross-cultural interaction, to attempt to write a history from
the Gurindji‟s point of view would be clearly inappropriate and likely to fail. Although I
will draw on Gurindji oral history, as a non-Indigenous writer I recognise both that the
Gurindji are critical to the story I wish to tell, and that a Gurindji point of view or
subjectivity is out of my reach. It is not my intention, or (without fluency in Gurindji,
Mudbra and Ngarinman languages or anthropological training) within my ability, to
attempt this; that particular project must remain in the preserve of a future work
which will preferably be authored by a Gurindji individual.
6 This direction has also been taken in part because there are many Gurindji accounts of the period on record
(Kijngayari, 1996; Ngumiari, 1970; Daguragu Community Government Council, 2000).
![Page 15: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Notwithstanding the considerations outlined above, the research will broach a range of
difficult issues. The creative work is intended to identify a range of post-Walk-off
outcomes at Kalkaringi and Daguragu, and to look at the causality of these. Where
necessary the dynamics of the changing Gurindji communities will be described in
non-specific terms and no individuals will be named unless they or their family (if they
are deceased) so wishes. It is intended that this will be done in such a way that
responsibility, if it is seen as such, is apportioned to amorphous collectives rather than
individuals and that the principles of Indigenous research identified by the Aboriginal
Institute for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies (AIATSIS: Unknown), the
Australian Council for the Arts (ACA: 2007), and the Desert Knowledge Centre for
Cooperative Research (DKCRC: 2008) are observed at all stages of the project.
![Page 16: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
5. Rationale: Exegesis
It is intended that the exegesis will be comprised of a complementary, though not
sequential, series of essays. At points in the creative work, issues too oblique, or too
large for consideration in a popularly readable work, will arise. These contain the seeds
of a topic or topics that will be appropriately explored via a more standard academic
treatment. As the creative work is history-based, the exegesis becomes the locus in
which it is possible to explore further the ramifications of each historic topic in the
contemporary context, being primarily that of current Indigenous policy delivery and
governance.
Issues addressed will include the parallel development of neighbouring Wave Hill
(Kalkaringi) and Wattie Creek (Daguragu) as a model for the relations of power and
governance with remote Indigenous people in Australia and the subsequent
institutionalisation of cross-cultural „Wattie Creek‟ relationships in the aboriginal
service industry (and similarly the paradox that the self-determination era
significantly increased the role of government and non-Indigenous professionals in
remote Indigenous life). The vexed question of the causality of the Wave Hill Walk-off
will also be considered; drawing particularly on recent interviews with some strikers
and the scholarship of Minoru Hokari .
![Page 17: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Recent writings from the fields of anthropology (Cowlishaw, Sutton), ethnography and
whiteness studies (Lea, Batty, Kowal), policy (Maddison, Coombs, Griffiths),
economics (Schwab, Sanders, Altman) and journalism (Neil, Rothwell) will inform the
exegesis in conjunction with much of the primary material informing the creative
work. Some quantitative data such as departmental and commissioned reports on
Indigenous health and wellbeing, housing and employment will also be used as
comparative tools.
![Page 18: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
6. Research Methodology
There is a complex range of data collection techniques intended in the project. These
range from the use of archival sources, ethnographic practice, the collection of new
oral histories and the use of existing ones, and a range of auto-ethnographic
techniques that include the use of the self as the research subject.
A plenitude of research sources and informants clustered into historically-polarised
groupings generate a diversity of viewpoints on the causality and effects of the Walk-
off. Both the creative work and exegesis therefore attempt to incorporate a multitude
of perspectives on the events in question. The aim of the narrative is also to create and
describe a physical, cultural and authorial space that allows and explains the
dialectical commingling of the ideological, personal entities in the text. This approach
is close to that described by theorist Hayden White as a „contextualist‟ mode of
explanation (1978:65). Paradoxically, the emergence of divergent viewpoints in the
subject matter thereby assists the evolution of an „internal‟ narrative space which
reconciles these to some degree.
The development of a facilitative narrative space is supported by my use of the
communications theory and praxis of „Deep Democracy‟ as developed by post-Jungian
psychologist Arnold Mindell and associates, both in my interviewing and writing
process. Deep Democracy is a form of conflict facilitation (not resolution) that
![Page 19: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
attempts to unfold the signals from all sides of a conflict, to identify their core meaning
and create an awareness that is inclusive of all sides of the debate. I have argued
elsewhere that Deep Democracy techniques are transposable to the authorial sphere
and are of particular utility in discussing historical conflicts (Ward: 2010).
Auto-ethnography: the self in history
The key ethnographic theme of the research topic is the experiences and interactions
of non-Indigenous „helpers‟ with the Gurindji and each other. As I work in the remote
Indigenous services sector, I represent a contemporary incarnation of this tradition,
which adds an important dimension to the research. The interaction between a non-
Indigenous author, with all his attendant personal and professional subjectivities—in
the context of contemporary Indigenous affairs—with the descendants of the Gurindji
strikers „problematises‟ past developments and discourses that occurred within that
setting.
This approach fits within the rapidly growing archive of auto-ethnographic approaches
to non-fictional literature that bridge both personal and cultural analysis. According to
Chang, „auto-ethnography shares the story-telling feature with other genres of self-
narrative but transcends mere narration of self to engage in cultural analysis and
interpretation‟ (2008:43). Auto-ethnographic approaches also encourage the
engagement of readers with the text by virtue of their identification with the author‟s
![Page 20: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
reflexive mandate: to uncover, explore and finally resolve the idiosyncrasies and
personal dilemmas that emerge through the enquiry. In this sense, the narrative
project of the research is a personal one. A by-line of the enquiry can be stated as
follows: can the history, and historiography, of the Wave Hill Walk-off be resolved in
an ostensibly impartial, non-identified account? Or is it only once the events are
harnessed and engaged with by a storyteller, or an historic actor-recorder, that the
history is vivified, subjectified and hence able to be integrated?
To its proponents (among whom I include myself), the subjectivity of an auto-
ethnographic approach creates a valuable departure point to historiography. It is
possible however that auto-ethnography can overshadow its subject. Chang describes
this as the first danger of using such an approach (ibid). In social accounts that are
saturated by an author‟s personal reflection, the nominal topic is easily overshadowed
with the authorial presence: The Unlucky Australians has been criticised for this
reason (Freeman: 2006). The auto-ethnographic strand of the creative work will
therefore appear as a distinct and infrequently recurring thread, rather than the
centrepiece.
When there is an obvious correlation between firsthand experience and historical
events in the narrative, a „critical incident biographical approach‟ (Béatrice, B. B:
2004) will be adopted. An exploration of such „critical incidents‟ is productively
![Page 21: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
included to describe the way that such events elicit information about my own
worldview as a researcher and professional in Indigenous affairs, thus also shedding
light on my journey (parallel to the reader‟s) as a historic guide and narrator. In this
way the sparing use of first-person narrative compliments the main story-theme of the
work. Successful examples of this genre include: Stasiland, by Anna Funder; The
Secret of the Sierra Madre, by W. Wyatt, and in a more auto-ethnographic and post-
structural mode, Bluff Rock, by Kathleen Schlunke and Jonathan Raban‟s Passage to
Juneau. In all these books it is the author‟s fascination with the topic rather than their
personality that is communicated to the reader, and which drives the narrative.
Oral History: a research method
‘A historical ethnography ... must begin by constructing its own archive.’
Comaroff & Comaroff, 1992
The primary research contribution of the project will be the generation of a substantive
Oral History collection on the topic. This will be achieved through conducting
unstructured interviews with a large number of individuals who were present at key
events. This qualitative research will provide a valuable means by which a „living
history‟—or at least a richer, more idiosyncratic and raw addendum— can be generated
to complement primary material drawn from archival sources. Barman acknowledges
![Page 22: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
the valuable addition that Oral History can make to existing sources: „Unlike
traditional historical research, limited to materials that happen to exist, oral history
makes it possible to actually bring data into being‟ (1989). The collection of Oral
History is a „two way‟ process that allows the researcher to interact during an
interview, if not with history itself, at least unwittingly with its interpretation. The use
of Oral History as a research method thereby further adduces the role of the researcher
in the historiographic process.7 As Portelli describes the fate of the oral historian: „the
narrator, from outside the narration, is pulled inside and becomes a part of it‟ (1981).
This deeper engagement demands a critical, auto-ethnographic, reflexive approach.
7 The majority of Interviews collected for the project will be donated to the Northern Territory Archives Service
(NTAS) and the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies (AIATSIS).
![Page 23: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
7. Literature Review and Originality:
The most cursory Literature Review reveals that the only book written specifically
about the Walk-Off is The Unlucky Australians, by Frank Hardy, which appeared in
1968. The events described in The Unlucky Australians form the foundation and
background to the research topic, which is notable for the lack of detailed
historiography and other scholarship on it. One likely reason for this is that on the
whole the story „on the ground‟ since the 1975 lease handover by the Whitlam
government has not been overly positive. Loyalty to the Gurindji and the climate of
conformity that has permeated the Indigenous affairs sector in the Northern Territory
during the 80s and 90s has also prevented possible commentators from doing so
(Sutton: 2001, Hempel: 2010, Richardson, 2010).
The work of Frank Hardy must be acknowledged regarding the reportage, literature
and success of the Gurindji protest. A successful writer on leftist and nationalist
themes and an Australian exponent of „the New Journalism‟ of the 1960s, his
confrontation of the ethical issues connected with his own subjectivity as an activist in
a cross-cultural context (and the responsibilities entailed in the representation of that)
prove Hardy as an early and advanced poststructuralist in the field of Australian
postcolonial literature. Like Hardy, it is my subjectivity that draws me to the research
topic, and it is this dialectic attraction that animates my research.
![Page 24: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Broadly speaking, there exists a well-established non-Indigenous literature of remote
Aboriginal Australia, to which the creative work would loosely belong. Pseudo-
ethnographic and auto-ethnographic books such as Raft (Goldenberg), Balanda
(Jordan), Sing for me Countryman (Murray) and Someone Else’s Country (Docker)
form contemporary addenda to historic titles such as Faces In the Sun (Holmes) , I,
The Aboriginal, The Lizard Eaters (Lockwood), Life Among the Aborigines (Harney)
and The Vanished People (Idriess). Hardy‟s The Unlucky Australians and the current
work display a hybridised treatment of the themes of this genre.
Academic scholarship has been partial: specific elements of the subject have been
written about in some journal articles, though few use creative non-fiction or auto-
ethnographic technique. Only Lyn Riddett, one of my interviewees, has written briefly
of her experience as a „do-gooder‟ at Wattie Creek (1997). Bain Atwood has
comprehensively addressed the question of Gurindji and non-Indigenous agency in the
strike (2000). Minoru Hokari has examined the Gurindji‟s own narratives about the
Walk-off and the skill of their historians (2000a; 2000b).
A PhD by Tina Jowett (1990) covers the same topic as the proposed work, however
Hunting Wave Hill differs from Jowett‟s thesis and provides a more detailed
treatment of the topic in several important ways: in my opinion Jowett‟s thesis draws
on too narrow a range of archival sources; it does not include the „parallel journeys‟ of
![Page 25: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
people that were at Kalkaringi and Daguragu with the Gurindji; it does not include a
personal narrative; it lacks the reflexivity to examine its own position in relation to the
Walk-off and it does not specifically address the repercussions of its findings for
current Indigenous affairs policy.
The historiographic approach of Hunting Wave Hill is similar to that adopted by
Helen Klaebe, who wrote a „historical biography‟ of the Australian branch of the
Outward Bound organisation drawing primarily on her collection of oral history
interviews. The „Creative Work‟ of her PhD Thesis was published in book form (2005).
![Page 26: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
8. Structure of Creative Work (Total of 60,000 words):
Introduction (5,000 words).
Summary: The Wave Hill Walk-off protest forms the foundation on which the thesis
rests. Although it is unnecessary to describe the event itself in great detail, it is
necessary that the reader is familiar with the facts of the story, to contextualise the rest
of the research. This needs to be done early in the creative work so that the reader is
engaged by the narrative. It is also necessary to introduce the narrator as an agent in
contemporary Indigenous affairs—particularly pertaining to the Wave Hill area—to
support the reader‟s ability to engage with the enquiry and narrative drive of the work.
2006; a car crash I witnessed en route to Wave Hill: bringing together the place,
the Walk-Off, my father and the question of non-Indigenous „support‟;
The Walk-off: event and parable;
Brief account of Wave Hill history and conditions, pre 1966.
Part One: 1967-1971. (20, 000 words).
Summary: After dealing with the Walk-off strike, Part One of the work describes
events as they played out for the Gurindji in the following years. This was a period of
both political conservatism and social change. Support for the Gurindji increased
among the liberal urban set, as well as among union and student groups. At the same
![Page 27: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
time the McMahon coalition government was resistant to calls for action supporting
the Gurindji emanating from within the polity and amongst their own advisors.
Exponents of both positions were present at Wave Hill and Wattie Creek. he
Gurindjis‟ supporters provided both financial and administrative support while the
Government ignored their requests for Land Rights . 1971 is a natural time to
conclude the first part of the creative work as by then the Land Rights debate was near
to resolution and Government support for the Gurindjis‟ cattle enterprise had been
delivered.
Strike incentive and origins;
Pastoralism in the north: a big beef with Vesteys;
Strikers‟ arrival at the Wave Hill Welfare Settlement;
Welfare Branch and the black list;
Frank Hardy and Bill Jeffrey;
What now? Articulating a vision;
Tours and protests: recruiting the South;
Abschol and the Unions: support arrives;
Council of Aboriginal Affairs: Gurindji allies?
The McMahon Government response: intimations of a poisoned chalice;
The formation of the Muramulla Cattle Company;
Growth of the broader debate.
![Page 28: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Part Two 1972-1975. (20, 000 words):
Summary: The impasse at Wattie Creek was broken with the election of the Whitlam
Government in late 1972 and this forms a natural point to begin the main part of the
work. Immediately the situation at Wattie Creek was changed by the Government‟s
announcement that it would cede land rights to aboriginal groups. Whitlam‟s
government increased Indigenous funding enormously, and public servants at Wave
Hill, as elsewhere, were promptly re-trained and numbers increased. Part Two
explores the effects of these changes on the Gurindji and their supporters. In late 1975
the Gurindji were granted a pastoral lease over a portion of their country and the
Whitlam government was sacked. Almost a decade after the Gurindji‟s protest, they
were again left facing an uncertain future. It was unclear whether the Fraser
Government would deliver Land Rights legislation while the mixed effects of
Whitlam‟s „self-determination‟ and social security policies became entrenched at the
same time.
Whitlam to the rescue? Self -determination;
Settlement Managers to Community Advisors: Governance reprogramming
begins;
Wattie Creek and Wave Hill: too many whitefellas?;
Growing Pains: unemployment benefits, grog and rumours of starvation;
First steps for Muramulla;
The Handover.
![Page 29: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Part Three: 1976-1986. (10, 000 words)
Summary: In 1976 the Northern Territory Land Rights Act was introduced. The
Gurindji‟s Cattle company was finally established in the form that it would retain until
its demise. Exploring this and the social changes wrought by policies of self-
determination—branded „self-management‟ under the Fraser government— form the
main thrust of the final section. The Gurindji received freehold title over their land in
1983 — sixteen years after their petition for Land Rights to the Governor General. At
the same time their leaders were incapacitated by old age and their cattle operation
was further imperilled by the rigorous conditions of the Brucellosis and Tuberculosis
Eradication Campaign (BTEC) that were imposed on it. By 1985 I will show that the
momentum and vision displayed by the Gurindji had been largely dissipated by time,
erosive policies and the social dynamics of the new „community‟ model of remote
Indigenous life. The Gurindji‟s decision to lease their land to a non- Gurindji manager
(a situation which has lasted to the present day) is a natural point at which to abandon
this exploration of the Gurindjis‟ Walk-off visions. By this time the basic template of
current remote Indigenous life was in place, the Northern Territory Emergency
Response of the Howard and Rudd governments notwithstanding.
Fraser government and self-management;
Abschol leave;
The struggle continues: tenure;
![Page 30: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
End of the road for Muramulla: funding, infrastructure and BTEC (Disease
eradication program);
Generation gap;
Freehold at last;
Vestey‟s withdrawal and subsequent demise;
Fallout of the new policy era.
Epilogue. (5, 000 words):
Summary: In the final part of the creative work I intend to return to its beginning in
a sense and address some issues raised in the body of the work. To achieve this I will
explore the current situation of the Gurindji (somewhat obliquely), and that of their
former masters, the Vestey group. Questions will be posed as to the current status quo
in remote governance in the Northern Territory.
My arrival, 2004: Vincent Lingiari‟s grave marked with a star picket;
40th anniversary: a tale of two hamlets;
Vestey‟s evicted from Venezuela;
The death of Hoppy Mick; the last Walk-off leader.
![Page 31: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
9. Elements of the Exegesis (Five chapters of 8,000 words, comprising a
total of 40,000 words):
The paradoxical role of government: resistance and dependence …
the bureaucratic enablers
Using data drawn from Parts Two and Three of the creative work, this section uses
Wave Hill as a case study to explore the paradox that the self-determination era
significantly increased the role of government in remote Indigenous life. Drawing
on work such as that of Rowse (1998), Kowal (2006, 2008) and Batty (2005 ), the
implications of this co-dependent relationship between systems of governance and
Aboriginal citizens will be explored.
Indigenous people and their non-Indigenous supporters: the
institutionalisation of ‘Wattie Creek’ relationships in the aboriginal
service industry.
Examining the relationships of Gurindji supporters with the Gurindji as an early
instance of the current political partnership between non-Indigenous liberals and a
rights-focused section of urbanised aboriginal professionals, this section examines
![Page 32: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
issues of representation, authenticity and development. This dialectic is explored in
the context of the policy outcomes that characterise organisational and political
reproduction in the Indigenous affairs sector.
The Wave Hill / Daguragu model: A template for the poisoned
chalice of Indigenous affairs.
Representing a number of related events and issues: Daguragu houses: eventually
delivered, but in a different configuration; a school is delivered, but to the wrong
location; a Gurindji shop opens, but not Gurindji controlled; the cattle enterprise:
externally- appointed, culturally ignorant advisors obligatory.
This section will draw from Foucauldian concepts of spatial representations of
power and material ethnography. It explores the failure of successive governments
to accede to, and provide for, Gurindji wishes; to „go the extra mile‟ in both real and
figurative senses towards the Gurindji homeland of Daguragu, and to explore
whether Daguragu itself is symbolic of an authentic expression of Indigenous
sovereignty, and whether this is why its development was not endorsed by the
McMahon, Whitlam, Fraser or Hawke and Keating governments.
![Page 33: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Lessons from the Gurindji on ‘Self-determination.’
This chapter is a crystallisation of the main theme arising from the creative work
and underlying the other chapters of the exegesis. At Wattie Creek, the Gurindji
leadership clearly understood that the success of their vision was dependent on
their children becoming educated to a degree that would allow them to administer
European-style services and facilities: seemingly a sure alignment between
Indigenous and government goals. „Self-determination‟ was designed with the
Gurindji clearly in mind ( no other group had as clearly and doggedly—or as
publicly— articulated a „self-deterministic‟ vision). This facilitates the exploration
of Daguragu and Kalkaringi history as litmus test of self-determination policy
implementation. In this way the eventual development and entrenchment of the
„self-deterministic‟ ethos—and its success, or otherwise, can be seen as the product
of events at Wattie Creek.
Men of Roper River: a contribution to Indigenous rights
Dexter Daniels‟ role as the primary instigator of the Wave Hill Walk-off is
recognised in existing literature. However, Daniels was one of a clique of men from
the Roper River area who led the Indigenous struggle for Indigenous rights in the
Northern Territory during the 1960s and early 70s. In this chapter I will seek to
contextualise the work and goals of Daniels and other Roper River men, drawing
primarily on oral history collected from their descendants and contemporaries.
![Page 34: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
10: Research Plan and Special Considerations:
Date Semester Activity
Jan-June 2010 Year 1, Sem I Ethics Approval, Annotated Bibliography, Literature
Review, Draft of initial chapter of creative work.
July-Dec 2010 Year 1, Sem II Create research activity database, Oral History
interviewing, archival research.
Write second draft chapter.
Jan-June 2011 Year 2, Sem I Research Proposal and presentation, transfer to PhD,
apply for research funding. Oral History interviews,
July-Dec 2011 Year 2, Sem II Bulk of archival research, Oral History Interviews,
research/conference presentation, continued writing,
draft of initial exegetical chapters, apply for
scholarship.
Jan-June 2012 Year 3, Sem I Progress draft of thesis
July-Dec 2012 Year 3, Sem II Submit draft of thesis
Special Considerations: Funding is required to conduct two parts of the research
required to execute the Project. Oral History interviewing with approximately twenty
interviewees is necessary. The interviewees (whose consent has already been obtained)
live mainly in rural Queensland and New South Wales. Also, a significant body of
archival material required to inform the project is held in Canberra in institutions such
as the National Library of Australia, the Noel Butlin Archive Centre at the Australian
National University, and the National Film and Sound Archive. Funding will be sought
from the University to conduct this research.
![Page 35: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
11: Works Cited:
AIATSIS (Unknown). Guidelines for Ethical Research in Indigenous Studies.
http://www.aiatsis.gov.au/research/docs/ethics.pdf. (AIATSIS). Canberra, Australia,
AIATSIS.
Altman, J. &. Hinkson, M. (Eds). (2010). Culture Crisis: Anthropology and Politics in
Aboriginal Australia. Sydney, University of New South Wales Press.
Australia Council for the Arts (2007). Protocols For Producing Indigenous Australian
Writing. Surry Hills, N.S.W, Australia Council for the Arts (ACA).
Attwood, B. (2000). "The Articulation of 'Land Rights' in Australia: The Case of Wave
Hill." Social Analysis (44(1)): 3-39.
Barman, J. (1989). Constructing the Historical Ethnography of Childhood Through
Oral History. Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association. San
Francisco, California.
Batty, P. (2005). "Private Politics, Public Strategies: White Advisers and Their
Aboriginal Subjects." Oceania 75: 209-221.
Béatrice, B.-B. (2004). "Auto-Interviewing, Auto-Ethnography and Critical Incident
Methodology for Eliciting a Self-Conceptualised Worldview " Qualitative Social
Research 5(1).
Bloodworth, S. (Unknown) Henry Lawson and the "Australian Legend." Marxist
Interventions. http://www.anu.edu.au/polsci/marx/interventions/lawson.htm
Accessed 17/10/2010.
Bunbury, B. (2002). It's Not the Money, It's the Land: Aboriginal Stockmen and the
Equal Wages Case. North Fremantle, Western Australia, Fremantle Arts Centre Press.
![Page 36: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
36
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Chang, H. (2008). Autoethnography as Method. Walnut Creek, California, Left Coast
Press.
Clendinnen, I. (2006). "The History Question: Who Owns the Past?" Quarterly
Essay(23): 1-72.
Comaroff, J. & Comaroff, J. (1992). Ethnography and the Historical Imagination.
Boulder, Colarado, Westview Press, Inc.
Coombs, H. C. (1994). Aboriginal Autonomy: Issues and strategies. Melbourne;
Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Cowlishaw, G. (1999). Rednecks, Eggheads and Blackfellas: Racial Power and Intimacy
In North Australia. Sydney and Michigan., Allen and Unwin with Michigan University
Press.
Denzin, N. K. (2006). "Analytic Autoethnography, or Deja Vu All Over Again." Journal
of Contemporary Ethnography 35(4): 419-428.
Desert Knowledge CRC. (2008). Desert Knowledge CRC Protocol for Aboriginal
Knowledge and Intellectual Property. Retrieved 25 August 2010:
http://www.desertknowledgecrc.com.au/resource/DKCRC-Aboriginal-Intellectual-
Property-Protocol.pdf
Dixson, M. (1999). The Real Matilda: Woman and Identity in Australia- 1788 to the
Present. Sydney, University of New South Wales Press.
Ellis, C & Bochner, P. (2000). “Autoethnography, Personal Narrative, and Personal
Reflexivity.” Handbook of Qualitative Research. Denzin, N & Lincoln, Y (Eds),
Thousand Oaks, California, Sage.
Freeman, M. (2006). Personal Communication, Kalkaringi, Northern Territory,
Unpublished.
Funder, A. (2002). Stasiland. Melbourne, Australia, Text Publishing.
![Page 37: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
37
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Griffiths, M. (2006). Aboriginal Affairs 1967-2005: Seeking a Solution. Dural, N.S.W.,
Rosenburg Publishing.
Hardy, F. (1968). The Unlucky Australians. Melbourne, Nelson Publishing.
Hempel, R. (2010) Interview with Ray Hempel by Charlie Ward, Darwin, 2010, Oral
History Collection, Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609, BWF 7.
Hokari, M. (2000a). "From Wattie Creek to Wattie Creek: An Oral Historical
Approach to the Gurindji Walk-off." Aboriginal History 24: 98-116.
(2000b) “Gurindji Perspectives on History, Body, Place, Memory and
Mobility.” Habitus 2000: A Sense of Place
(2002). "Reading Oral Histories from the Pastoral Frontier: A Critical
Revision." Journal of Australian Studies: Jumping the Queue 72.
Jowett, T. (1990). Walking to Wattie Creek- The History of the Gurindji People and
Their Struggle for Land Rights Sydney, University of New South Wales. Bachelor of
Arts with Honours.
Klaebe, H. G. (2005). Onward Bound: The First Fifty Years of Outward Bound
Australia. Tharwa, A.C.T, Australia, Outward Bound Australia.
Kowal, E. (2006). The Proximate Advocate: Improving Indigenous Health on the
Postcolonial Frontier, University of Melbourne. PhD.
(2008). The Politics Of The Gap: Indigenous Australians, Liberal
Multiculturalism and the End of the Self-Determination Era. American
Anthropologist 110(3).
Kijngayari, J. (1996). 'The Wave Hill Strike'. This is What Happened: Historical
Narratives by Aborigines. Hercus L. S. and Sutton P. (Eds), Canberra, Australian
Institute of Aboriginal Studies.
![Page 38: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
38
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Lea, T. (2008). Bureaucrats and Bleeding Hearts: Indigenous Health in Northern
Australia. Sydney, University of New South Wales Press.
Maddison, S. (2009). Black Politics: Inside the Complexity of Aboriginal Political
Culture. Sydney, Allen & Unwin.
McKenna, M. (2002). Looking for Blackfella's Point: An Australian History of Place.
Sydney, University of New South Wales Press.
McQueen, H. (1970). New Britania: An Argument Concerning the Social Origins of
Australian Radicalism and Nationalism. Ringwood, Victoria, Penguin.
Mindell, A. (1992) Leader as a Martial Artist. An Introduction to Deep Democracy.
Harper, San Francisco.
(1995) Sitting in the Fire: Large Group Transformation Using Conflict and
Diversity. Lao Tse Press, Portland Oregon.
Neill, R. (2002). White-out: How Politics is Killing Black Australia. Crows Nest.
Neumann, M. (1996). “Collecting Ourselves at the End of the Century.” Composing
Ethnography: Alternative Forms of Qualitative Writing. Ellis, C & Bochner, A. (Eds.)
Walnut Creek, California, Alta Mira Press.
Nile, R. (1998). “Here‟s Luck,” in Paul Hasluck in Australian History: Civic Personality
and Public Life. Stannage, T, Saunders, K and Nile, R. (Eds). St. Lucia, Queensland,
University of Queensland Press. 13-27.
Numiari, P. (1970). Pincher Numiari- Gurindji Plans and Attitudes: an Interview by
Warwick Neilley. Abschol and Save the Gurindji Campaign, Sydney.
Portelli, A. (1981). "The Peculiarites of Oral History." History Workshop Journal
12(Autumn 1981): 96-107.
![Page 39: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
39
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Pratt, M. L. (1992). Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation. Oxon, United
Kingdom, Routledge.
Raban, J. (1999) Passage to Juneau, Picador, London.
Reynolds, H. (1999). Why Weren't We Told? : A Personal Search for the Truth about
our History. Ringwood, Australia, Penguin Books.
Richardson, J. (2010) Personal Communication.
Riddett, L. A. (1997). "The Strike that became a Land Rights Movement: a Southern
Do-Gooder reflects on Wattie Creek 1966-74." Labour History 72(May): 50-65.
Rothwell, N. (2006). “The Frontline of Fable.” The Australian. August 12-13.
Sanders, W. (2009). Ideology, Evidence and Competing Principles in Australian
Indigenous Affairs: from Brough to Rudd via Pearson and the NTER. Discussion
Paper. CAEPR. Canberra. 289.
Said, E. W. (1978). Orientalism. New York, Pantheon Books.
Schlunke, K., M. (2005). Bluff Rock: Autobiography of a Massacre. North Fremantle,
Western Australia, Curtin University Books.
Schwab, J. & Hunter, B. (1998). “The Determinants of Indigenous Educational
Outcomes.” Discussion Paper. CAEPR. Canberra. 160.
Smith, D. (2004). “From Gove to Governance: Reshaping Indigenous Governance in
the Northern Territory.” Discussion Paper. CAEPR. Canberra. 265.
Sutton, P. (2009). The Politics of Suffering: Indigenous Australia and the End of the
Liberal Consensus, Melbourne University Press.
Ward, C. (2010). Deep Democracy and the Wave Hill Walk-off: the Application of
Process-Oriented Psychology Theory to a Historic Debate. Sydney, Australia, Pathways
Psychology Institute.
![Page 40: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
40
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Ward, R. (1958). The Australian Legend, Oxford University Press.
(1971). "Home Thoughts from Abroad: Australia's Racist Image." Meanjin
Quarterly 30(2): 149-156.
White, H. (1978). Tropics of Discourse: Essays in Cultural Criticism. Baltimore, Johns
Hopkins University Press
![Page 41: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
41
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
12. Preliminary Bibliography:
Audiovisual Material
Brodie, L. (2010). Oral History interview Recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Eames, G. (2010). Oral History interview Recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Fardell, B. (2010). Oral History Interview Recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Harvey, R. B. (1979). Oral History Interview recorded by Daniel Bacon. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 1942.
Hempel, R. (2010). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Lingiari, V. (1975). Vincent Lingiari interviewed by Ted Egan. Oral History Collection.
Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 226.
McConvell, P. (2009). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Middleton, H. (2009). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Oke, R. (2009). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Phillips, J. (2010). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Rangiari, M. (1987). Interview with Mick Rangiari recorded by Jack Doolan. Oral
History Collection,. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 226.
![Page 42: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
42
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Richardson, L. (2010). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Riddett, L. A. (2009). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS
Thorpe, A. (2010). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Warmuth, E. (2010). Oral history Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS
Watts, C. &. D. (2010). Oral History Interview Recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service NTRS 3609.
Williams, R. (2009). Oral History Interview recorded by Charlie Ward. Oral History
Collection. Darwin, Northern Territory Archives Service. NTRS 3609.
Newspaper Articles
(1967). Aboriginals in Vic. 'Are Badly Off'. Herald Sun? Melbourne.
(1967). '...Another fantastic character is Bill Jeffrey....'. Herald Sun? . Melbourne.
(1968). More Gurindji Quit NT Stations. The Australian ??
(1968). Students Will Build with Aboriginals. The Sun.
(1970). Governments Destroying Aboriginal Race. The Australian.
(1971). Claims Gurindji‟s Political Football. Northern Territory News.
(1971). NTA Agronomist Doubts Aboriginal Leases Program. Northern Territory News.
(1975). Some Earth from Wattie Creek. Nation Review.
![Page 43: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
43
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Dearn, A. (1970). Refused Permit to Visit Aborigine. The Advertiser. Adelaide, S.A.
Dunn, M. (1970). Baptist Among Gurindji. Sydney Morning Hearld.
Forsyth, C. (1967). Wentworth stirs up a whirlwind in the north. The Australian.
Hardy, F. (1970). Land Rights Row Heads for Climax. Sunday Observer.
Hardy, F. (1970). Wattie Creek Revisited. The Australian.
Holmes, C. (1970). The Unpermitted. The Australian.
Minogue, D. (1976). The Dreaming- Wattie Creek's Black Cattlemen Look to the
Future. The Age. Melbourne.
Radic, L. (1968). When the Tribe Went on Strike. The Age. Melbourne.
Rigg, J. (1970). Support Swells for Gurindji Land Claim. The Australian.
Books, Essays and Articles
Petition by Gurindji People to Governor-General re Wave Hill Pastoral Land, Northern
Territory. Canberra, National Archives of Australia. A1734: 185.
Anonymous (1967). "Gurindji Claim to Wave Hill." Smoke Signals Six(One).
Anonymous (1968 July). "A Historic Debate." Aboriginal Quarterly. Abschol,
Australian National University, Canberra.
Bern, J. (1976). "Reaction to Attrition: The Ngukurr Strike of 1970." Mankind 10(4):
213-224.
Clendinnen, I. (2006). "The History Question: Who owns the past?" Quarterly Essay.
(23): 1-72.
![Page 44: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
44
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Daguragu Community Government Council (2000). From the Darkness into the Light:
Gurindji Freedom Banners. Pamphlet, Darwin.
Denoon, D. (1970). "Guilt and the Gurindji." Meanjin 29: 253-265.
Flowers, D. (1970). "Imponderables in the Outback: The Settlement at Wave Hill."
Farrago.
Fox, P. (1970). "Welfare- Another Arm of the Law." Aboriginal Quarterly. Abschol,
Australian National University, Canberra.
Hardy, F. (1985). In Fear of a Town Called Welfare. The Bulletin: 64-73.
Harney, W., E. (1969). Life Among the Aborigines. Adelaide, Rigby.
Hempel, R. (2005). "Breaching The Wall." The Bennelong Society Occasional Paper.
Hokari, M. (2002). "Reading Oral Histories from the Pastoral Frontier: A Critical
Revision." Journal of Australian Studies: Jumping the Queue, 72.
Howson, P. (2004). "No More Sit-down Money." Quadrant: 19-25.
Idriess, I., L. (1955). The Vanished People. Sydney, Angus and Robertson.
Jeffrey, J. W. (1968). "Aboriginal Intelligence." Farrago- Melbourne University
Student Newspaper.
Jeffrey, J. W. (1968). "One Man for Justice." Farrago- Melbourne University Student
Newspaper.
Kelly, J. (1969, March). "A Stain on the Past." Aboriginal Quarterly. Abschol,
Australian National University, Canberra.
Kimber, J. (2009). 'A Right to be Troublesome': The Arrest of Dexter Daniels and the
Politics of Vagrancy Laws. Labour History in the New Century,. B. Oliver. Bentley,
Western Australia, Black Swan Press: 167-180.
![Page 45: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
45
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Lockwood, D. (1962). I, the Aboriginal. Adelaide, Rigby.
Long, J. (1996). "Frank Hardy and the 1966 Wave Hill Walk-off." Northern Perspective
19(2) North Australian Research Unit. Darwin.
McConvell, P. (2002). “Changing Places: European and Aboriginal Styles.” The Land is
a Map: Placenames of Indigenous Origin in Australia. Hercus, L. Hodges, F. and
Simpson, J. (Eds). Canberra, Pacific Linguistics and Pandanus Press, 50-61.
McLaren, G. (2000). "Land-Rights: The Cattlemans' Side." Quadrant 44(6).
Riddett, L. A. (1996). "Living With the People Who Live on the Ground." Northern
Perspective 19(2): 11-15. North Australian Research Unit. Darwin.
Riddett, L. A. (1997). "Getting 'Grown-Up' at Wattie Creek." Overland 146(Autumn):
68-71. Melbourne.
Riddett, L. A. (1997). "The Strike That Became a Land Rights Movement: a Southern
Do-Gooder Reflects on Wattie Creek 1966-74." Labour History 72(May): 50-65.
Rowse, T. (1998). White Flour, White Power: from Rations to Citizenship in Central
Australia. Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press.
Smith, S. (1969). "A Contentious Issue." Aboriginal Quarterly, Abschol, Australian
National University, Canberra.
Smith, S. (1969, June). "A Non-Interview with Harry Giese." Aboriginal Quarterly,
Australian National University, Canberra.
Stanley, O. (1976). "Aboriginal commnities on Cattle Stations in Central Australia."
Australian Economic Papers 15 (December): 158-170.
Wentworth. William, C. (March 1969). "Aborigines and the Future." Aboriginal
Quarterly, Australian National University, Canberra.
![Page 46: Hunting Wave Hill: a Research Proposal · No ethnography can ever hope to penetrate beyond the surface of everyday life.. unless it is informed by the historical imagination ... Topic](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081605/5b418ec17f8b9ac2668b52dd/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
46
Master of Arts in Creative Writing: Research Proposal
Hunting Wave Hill by Charlie Ward
Wyatt, W. (1980). The Secret of the Sierra Madre: The Man Who Was B. Traven. New
York, Double Day and Company.