4/14/2015 How To Win Your Referendum | Totally Dublin - Latest News & Events in Dublin

http://totallydublin.ie/more/how-to-win-your-referendum/ 1/11

HOW TO WIN YOUR REFERENDUM

Laura Dowling and 721 others like this.Like

Tweet 67 Share 3

When I was approached for ideas about how to present our support for the Marriage Equalitycampaign in Totally Dublin, the editor and I tossed around various ways that we could think of thatwould show TD readers all the good, glorious and gay old reasons to expand the scope of civilmarriage to include our LGBT selves, family, pals and peers.

The thing is though, if you care about getting this referendum passed, you already know thesereasons. The difficulty is in explaining them to those who are unsure and unwilling.

Being successful in any campaign is just as much about delivery as it is about content. It has beenadmirable and inspiring to see the LGBT community and its many allies rally with words of support,and reasons why we all should be voting Yes. What we need now, however, is a discussion abouthow we relay our message, how to talk to yer man next to you in the pub, how to approach thiswith your Aunty Bridie, how to assure them and, if needs be, how to change their minds.

Talking about the referendum is tricky. Emotions are easily and often embroiled. Anger andaccusations of bigotry bubble up. Deep dividing trenches are dug on either side, ammo is fired andsuddenly soldiers forget that those on the other side are human. Go back to your Junior CertHistory and remember the Christmas Eve Truce of 1914. The British and the Germans along theWestern Front dropped their enmity for a day, clambered out of their trenches, and crossed noman’s land for some seasonal chat and a game of footie or two. This was part of the famous ‘Liveand Let Live’ phenomenon of World War I, military behaviour and tactics which were characterisedby conflict-avoidance and non-aggression. They remembered their opponents were humans, andtreated them with respect.

722Share

4/14/2015 How To Win Your Referendum | Totally Dublin - Latest News & Events in Dublin

http://totallydublin.ie/more/how-to-win-your-referendum/ 2/11

Any debate is a war of words. If we want to win, we need to drop the hate and hostility, get out ofour trenches and start to engage with others: those who won’t vote, those are confused and eventhose who are voting the other way.

Disclaimer: I am not the guy to tell you how to win this referendum. Like much of the Yes lobby, Iam a young liberal fighting for his cause for the first time. In comparison, the conservative No sidehave been at this for years. From the decriminalisation of sodomy, to abortion to divorce, religiousinstitutions and the political right have found a way to influence people that has had profound andlasting effects, long after society steered firmly away from the Church’s control. We are putting up agood fight, but we could no doubt use the help of those who have trod this path before, and what’smore, won against the odds.

Enter Anne Connolly. From illegally importing and selling contraceptives throughout the early 1980sas founder and former director of the Well Woman Clinic and sitting on numerous state boardsincluding An Post, to setting up her own business consultancy firm and the Ageing Well Network,Connolly is a shining beacon of this radical old vanguard, and a mentor from whom we can learnmuch. Full of Delphic wisdom and contagious energy, rocking a short, spiked, pixie cut anddressed like a Kooples model, Anne is like a Mary Robinson-Annie Lennox lovechild and a totallefty legend.

4/14/2015 How To Win Your Referendum | Totally Dublin - Latest News & Events in Dublin

http://totallydublin.ie/more/how-to-win-your-referendum/ 3/11

 

 

Between tearing away at the patriarchy and climbing the corporate ladder, Anne was part of theteam that helped bring divorce into Irish law. This was during a second Divorce Referendum in1995, which won by the smallest margin ever in Irish history, a mere 0.6% of the votes cast.

Connolly told me about previous political battles lost, and how she and others responded. ‘I wasinvolved in both the ’86 and ’95 divorce referendums, and by the time it came around to thesecond, a number of us decided to stand back. We had had the experiences of losing tworeferendums in the 1980s. It was no surprise we lost in ’83 on abortion, but the surprise was doingas well as we did, getting one third of people to vote No [to the 8th Amendment]. It was different in’86 though, we shouldn’t have lost the that divorce referendum.’

‘A group of us met together to analyse and get a better understanding of why we lost, and to learnand apply those lessons. We brought together an eclectic group of people, a school teacher whoreally understood grassroots communities, Michael McDowell, a very senior member of thejudiciary, people from marketing backgrounds, people who understood consumers, behaviouraland attitudinal analysts, people from different political parties.’ Having assembled her politicalGuardians of the Galaxy, Connolly set about understanding what had gone wrong. What peoplesaid and what people did proved to be very different things.

4/14/2015 How To Win Your Referendum | Totally Dublin - Latest News & Events in Dublin

http://totallydublin.ie/more/how-to-win-your-referendum/ 4/11

‘The main issue that came out was that people have a whole range of different fears. Quite often,they’re ashamed to articulate these so, when they’re being surveyed, they may be inclined to saythey’re voting one way and then vote the other. They never got a chance to articulate the thingsthey were concerned about.’

Connolly noted that this was as much a product of their previous political lobbying as it was socialphenomenon: ‘We had effectively created an environment that shot down these fears, or positionedthese as being luddite, conservative, reactionary or unsympathetic to the plights of people whofound themselves in broken marriages. We had been effectively saying, “You’re uncool if you wantto vote No to divorce”. The more we created a confrontational, conflictual positioning, the more wewere actually pushing them into a No vote mode. We needed to get a deeper understanding as towhat those fears were about, and not just poo-poo them.’

These are pitfalls any lobby should be wary of. The force of their first campaign had proved to beabrasive and alienating. A new route was needed.

‘Our second move was about tone. It had to be a lot warmer, more inclusive and understanding,more aimed at the mainstream. We had to position what we were saying as “You don’t necessarilywant this for yourself – and that’s fine – but it is possible to be very generous and think of othercitizens who want to behave differently”. It was then about collecting people who could then speakto those fears… theologians across most faiths, journalists and social commentators. And we justfacilitated a discussion.’

When I asked Connolly how we could apply these lessons this time round, both in campaigns andin a personal capacity, she said that you need to know who you’re talking to and then work outwhat you’re likely to achieve.

‘You need to work with an assumption that there’s a hard Yes vote and a hard No vote. You’re notinterested in those. But there’s also a soft Yes and a soft No, and then a soft “don’t know”. This isyour territory. The first step then has got to be insight into why people might be considering votingNo. Get an insight to what the fears and concerns that they feel embarrassed to articulate areabout. Nobody wants to be seen to be anti-gay any more. It’s just not on, and people know that. 20years ago it would not have been an inhibition.’

4/14/2015 How To Win Your Referendum | Totally Dublin - Latest News & Events in Dublin

http://totallydublin.ie/more/how-to-win-your-referendum/ 5/11

The name of the game is respect and understanding. Righteousness and anger alienate. Changingopinions and convincing someone is a process. ‘If they’re attacked before they’re given a chanceto go past a gut instinct, they just go on the defensive. People close down if they feel like they’rebeing put under attack.’ It’s about getting on the same level as someone, allowing them to feel safeso they can voice their concerns. ‘People need to go on a journey with these things,’ said Connolly,‘and we need to help them by facilitating revelation and providing reassurance.’

What Connolly says sounds simple, but achieving it is undoubtedly a difficult feat. There are layersof emotion, vulnerability and the fear of strange, new changes to contend with. These truths havebeen affirmed from a most-unlikely source: a convert. Following Dublin Pride 2009, Brenda Powercontended in a Sunday Times piece on July 5th 2009, entitled ‘You Can’t Trample Over theWedding Cake and Eat It’, that, ‘Marriage is a legal and religious union between a man and awoman. That’s a definition, in the same way as Irish stew is a dish made with lamb, spuds andturnips. You can, of course, substitute wild boar, aubergines and pilau rice, and you will have aperfectly delightful meal that will satisfy more sophisticated palates. But it won’t be Irish stew.’ Thedistaste for same-sex marriage in her writing is evident, along with a readily patronising attitude.Power later summarised this article, and its fallout, as having ‘caused a bit of a stir.’

During a piece on RTÉ Radio One’s Drivetime on Friday 13th February this year, Power came outas a Yes vote. Allegorising an apocryphal tale about the USS Lincoln, Power told a cautionary tale

4/14/2015 How To Win Your Referendum | Totally Dublin - Latest News & Events in Dublin

http://totallydublin.ie/more/how-to-win-your-referendum/ 6/11

to the Yes lobby. The American air-craft carrier was ploughing full steam ahead toward a set ofsmall lights in the distance and demanded that it change it’s course 15 degrees North. ‘Divertyour course South 15 degrees’ comes the reply from the small lights. Upon barking ‘This is the USSLincoln, the second largest ship in the Atlantic Fleet. I demand you divert your course orcountermeasures will be taken!’, the small lights respond, ‘This is Cobh Lighthouse. Your call.’

Power renders her point clearly: ‘No matter how important and unstoppable you think you are, nomatter how much righteousness and authority you have on your side, it is always good idea toknow what you’re up against.’

She articulates a pitfall what she thinks the Yes lobby are often liable to fall foul of. ‘Anyone whodares voice a dissenting view is attacked as a homophobe, “soft in the head”, at best sufferingfrom an irrational fear of gay people… The problem is demonising an opinion you do not like, doesnot change it, it just masks it.’

Falling in line with what Anne Connolly and her comrades detected in the referendums gone by,Power feels shaming and attacking push real concerns and truths into the shadows. ‘As long as theYes lobby continue to deride its opposition, the No side will grow stealthily, staying below the radaruntil it is too late and too large to avoid. If you can’t see what you are up against, you will not knowwhen you are heading full steam for the rocks.’

Spanning decades, issues and the political spectrum, the message is the same: berating andshaming achieve little. An electorate becomes estranged by righteous name-calling and politicalone-upmanship. It is only empathy, personable interaction and human assurance that caneffectively change and convince the confused or wary. To quote Power, ‘This referendum will bewon by whomever shows the most respect for the opposing view, rather than the one that mocks itmost gleefully.’

This tactic is not freshly-minted. In fact, it has successfully underpinned entire political movementsin other countries, including what is arguably the most politically-polarised in the Western world,the United States. Researchers from Columbia University and the University of California haverecently empirically shown the worth of this style of political lobbying in relation to canvassingundertaken in the aftermath of Prop 8, which outlawed same-sex marriage by popular vote inCalifornia in 2008.

Using a group of activists volunteering with the LA LGBT Center led by Dave Fleischer, the studyshowed the enduring power of persuasion which human interaction can have on the undecided andthe unwilling. Going from door-to-door in strategically chosen neighbourhoods, volunteersconducted structured but highly personal and intimate interviews with voters on the issue of same-sex marriage. One tool often deployed was the interviewer coming out to the interviewee as LGBT,in order to connect on a deeper emotional level. This key moment of vulnerability was often aturning point in the persuasion process. Lasting on average 20 minutes, these conversationsfostered a safe environment where real feelings and issues could be divulged and dealt with.Studied against control groups over time, the study showed that Fleischer’s teams proved to haveprofoundly lasting and exponentially affecting impacts on interviewees, as well as their families andneighbours.

4/14/2015 How To Win Your Referendum | Totally Dublin - Latest News & Events in Dublin

http://totallydublin.ie/more/how-to-win-your-referendum/ 7/11

People are starting to have the difficult conversations. Trinity College’s Student Union recentlyunveiled the #RingYourGranny campaign encouraging students voting Yes to pick up the phoneand call someone near and dear to ask if they’re voting, which way and why. In the video launchingthe campaign, a number of students put their phones on loudspeaker and make the call. Theresponses are, in turns, encouraging and telling. One grandmother’s ambivalence shows her fearsaround the difficulties same-sex marriage faces when it comes to parenting. After having engagedwith her grandson and confirmed that she plans to vote Yes, the woman sagely says ‘people haveto be informed and be given the other side…’ and warns to ‘not let people be self-conscious aboutit’. Answering her queer daughter’s question of whether she will vote Yes, one Mam reassuressimply, almost scoffingly, ‘of course I will!’ Her response is poignant enough to reduce any viewerto the weepy-face emoji.

We need to learn from the lessons of the past. Gaining insight into people’s fears in order to speakto them got divorce over the line in 1995. We have been scolded for bad behaviour this time roundand learned, as Brenda Power would suggest, ‘It might be a good idea to show some respect for[others’] views, rather than taunting them as backward and ignorant.’ We can look further afield andabroad and see that engaging humanely and appealing with respect, sincerity and heartfelt emotioncan have powerful enduring effects.

It’s time to climb out of our trenches. To your next-door neighbour, namecheck Fr. IggyO’Donovan, who recently concluded in the Irish Times, ‘respect for the freedom of others who differfrom us is part and parcel of the faith we profess. For these and for other reasons I will be votingYes’. Explain to your local, well-meaning Helen Lovejoy that ‘there is no scientific evidence thatparenting effectiveness is related to parental sexual orientation. That is, lesbian and gay parents areas likely as heterosexual parents to provide supportive and healthy environments for their children’as recently affirmed by The Psychological Society of Ireland.

Be persistent, but be kind. We all have to live with one other, now and after Friday 22nd May. Thisreferendum will not wave a magic wand to change Irish society. But it will be a big first step. There

4/14/2015 How To Win Your Referendum | Totally Dublin - Latest News & Events in Dublin

http://totallydublin.ie/more/how-to-win-your-referendum/ 8/11

will be other battles, and we will have to fight another day, so ultimately, it would be astute to makehumans of those at the other side of the trenches.

Words: Jack Gibson

Illustrations: Fuchsia MacAree

Portrait: Malcolm McGettigan

ANNE CONNOLLY BRENDA POWER DAVE FLEISCHER DIVORCE REFERENDUM 1995 FR. IGGY O’DONOVAN

MARRIAGE EQUALITY MARRIAGE REFERENDUM REFERENDUM TCD SU

PECHA KUCHA DUBLIN #1

HOME FROM HOME: KARL ON LONDON

CELLULOID STORIES: THE HISTORY OF DUBLIN CINEMA DESIGN

TOTALLY DUBLIN WEEKENDER | FEBRUARY 5 – 8

FOLLOW US

@totallydublin That's right! We've got a double pass for each night of @12pointsfest to give

Search

RECOMMENDED READING