how to rescue a high visibility program
DESCRIPTION
An Overview of what causes projects to fail and how to rescue those that are in trouble or heading for failure.TRANSCRIPT
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
www.windward.wswww.windward.ws770770--846846--08280828
David V. Tennant, PE, PMPDavid V. Tennant, PE, PMPWindward Consulting Group, LLCWindward Consulting Group, LLC
dvtentdvtent@[email protected]
Problem Projects: How to Rescue aProblem Projects: How to Rescue aTroubled HighTroubled High--Visibility ProgramVisibility Program
Presentation at PMI Atlanta PDD, August 26, 2006
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Presentation Overview
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
- How do projects get into trouble?
- Five key problem areas.
- A realistic approach…
Think for a Moment. How do projects go off track? What are the key problems that contribute to, or cause, project failure?
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
• Poor Planning or Scope Definition• Continuous Scope Changes• Inadequate or Wrong Resources (people)
• Lack of Management Support• Poor Communications• Lack of Accountability• Conflict Between Departments • Poorly Defined Roles & Responsibilities• Objectives Not Clear • Changes in Goals or Resources• Dysfunctional Organization• Failure to Heed Warning Signs• Unrealistic Expectations
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility ProjectsGeneral problems contributing to project failure:General problems contributing to project failure:
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
For today’s discussion, let’s focus on thefollowing five causes:
1.1. Continuous Scope ChangesContinuous Scope Changes
2.2. Poor PlanningPoor Planning
3.3. Wrong People in ChargeWrong People in Charge
4.4. Dysfunctional OrganizationDysfunctional Organization
5.5. Unrealistic ExpectationsUnrealistic Expectations
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
1. Continuous Scope Changes1. Continuous Scope Changes
The continuous, unauthorized, changes to a project that results in the expansion or addition to the project scope.
Scope Creep:Scope Creep:
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
Even with a reasonable project plan, a process for managing scope is necessary
Project Plan
ApprovedRequest
for Change
Project Continues per Plan
Review Change Impact
•Cost & Benefits•Resources•Schedule•Quality
Change Approved NOYes
Revise Proj Plan(re-baseline)
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
2. Poor PlanningPoor Planning
Why do seemingly intelligent people Why do seemingly intelligent people skip the most important part: project skip the most important part: project planning?planning?
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Execution ClosingPlanningInitiation
Typical Phases of the Project Life CycleTime
Lev e
l of E
ffor
t
Project Control
Many times, teams try to Many times, teams try to jump from concept to jump from concept to execution.execution.
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
Proper Project Scope Development
� Develop and confirm client requirements (SOW)� Develop detailed WBS� Obtain input from all key stakeholders� Perform initial risk review (impacts to WBS)� Develop a full project plan covering the 9 areas of PMBOK� Obtain client and Sr. Management sign-off on the plan
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
3. The wrong people are in charge.3. The wrong people are in charge.
How does this happen?How does this happen?
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Position Title: Sr. Program Manager
Professional Requisites: 10+ years in software development; 5+ years in management of software development and teams.
Position Description
Our client is looking for an experienced PM to head up the entire software development and scientific teams. This position will report to the VP, Services. The job will include the following responsibilities:
Qualifications
• Strong management skills is a must - should have managed teams in excess of 50 people; must be organized, disciplined, and able to manage multiple teams across geographies (including internationally)• Design, implementation, and management of imaging and computer vision systems• Design, implementation and management of data warehousing and analytical systems• Ability to integrate and work within in a small, dynamic, and entrepreneurial organization is essential• Strong project management skills and the ability to manage multiple product development streams, along with occasional operations-support projects.• In-depth knowledge of object-oriented processes, methodologies and software product development/release best practices.
������������� ����� �������� �������
������������������� ������ ������ ��� � ����������������� ����������������������� ������ ������ ��� � ����������������� ���� ������� �������
������������������������������ ���������������������������������� ����
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
TechnicalManagerial
The Fork in the Road of Your Career!(~ 5 to 7 years)
Career Decision TimeCareer Decision Time
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
Project Managers need key managerial skills more than technical skills:
• Strong communication skills—written & verbal• Ability to grasp situations and their implications• Can sell ideas and obtain executive support
(negotiations)• Motivates the team• Staying focused on the deliverables and end results• Managing client expectations• Resolving conflict
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
4. Dysfunctional Organization
Just like families, organizations sometimes need therapy…..
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
Companies may have good people and strong support services. However:
� Many upper level executives fail to understand what project management is all about and how it can help them—it is considered a “lower-level” tool.
� Very little process—PM or functional
� Too much in-fighting
� Project responsibilities split between departments
� The organization has a history of little accountability, lack of discipline on the part of PM’s, and few requirements in the selection of project managers.
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
5. Unrealistic expectations� Project end dates are dictated, not derived
� Budgets are arbitrarily cut (or dictated prior to project scoping)
� Solution to problems is to throw more people or money at it….
� We need to add scope but remain within the original budget….
� Bid proposals are based on “getting the job” rather than realistic costs
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
���������� �������������� ��!����� ������������������ ����������"
Answer:� #�������� $���������� ������� �� #���� ������� ��%��&���������'� (�!���������� ���
� )��%������� � �������!�!�������������������������������� ���*%%
Gulp!
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects(Implementation)
CloseProject
Plan &Authorize
Project
DevelopBusiness
Case
A Project in Progress
Time
Lev e
l of E
ffor
t
DesignProject
ConstructProject
Gate 1(Project Identified &
Budget Approved)
Gate 2(Final Project Approved)
(Change Control)
Gate 3(Project
Deliverable)
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Disaster RecoveryWhen Do I Escalate to Upper Management?
� When a significant risk event is triggered.
� When you are showing a consistent trend in budget or schedule overrun and you need assistance from the executive team with corrective action.
� A majormajor scope change request is received.
� A major supplier performance issue is discovered.
Status reports should keep everyone informed; therefore, there should not be any surprises.
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
(KEY POINT: A project will never succeed without executive support)
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Disaster RecoverySuggested steps
I. Assessment
1. Where is the project currently? Does it match up with the original goals and objectives?
2. Look at the project plan: does it cover the nine key areas of project management? (probably not)
3. Review the financials and milestones to determine how far off the budget and schedule you are.
4. Determine if any risks have been identified and if they have come to fruition.
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Disaster RecoverySuggested steps
II. Recovery Planning
1. Develop a new plan (9 areas) that clearly delineates goals and objectives, roles, schedule, WBS, etc. Be sure to identify the new critical path and new budget.
2. Determine what resources are needed. Compare this to what you currently have.
3. Get upper management and the client to sign-off on the plan.
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
RESET EXPECTATIONS!RESET EXPECTATIONS!
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
4. Meet weekly (or daily, if needed) to track project more closely.
5. Keep upper management/client informed of issues & progress: communicate.
6. If negative trends appear impossible to turn around, it may be time to cancel the project or perform a new business case.
Disaster RecoverySuggested steps
II. Recovery Planning (continued)
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Control Techniques,Tips and Guidelines
Among the things a project manager must do:� Insist on good documentation—it will CYA� Monitor results to assure that specs and contract conditions are
being met� Insist on revised SOW, WBS, schedule, and budget when major
changes occur—document scope changes through a change form� Monitor and control direct contact with customer and prevent
unauthorized changes in SOW and contracts� Personally participate in any trade-off agreements made between
functional managers and customer representatives
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
How do we deal with Crises? What should be my actions?
1. Prepare for new/additional problems (Risk Planning)
2. Surround yourself with good people3. Hold people accountable
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
4. Obtain facts, data and information as quickly as possible
5. Do not manage an emergency by long distance6. Maintain relationships with stakeholders
(A crisis is no time to start looking for friends)7. There should be only one person in charge
(i.e. you need the authority, not just the …. responsibility)
8. Set up a war-room
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
A few pointers on what to expect in crisis situations:A few pointers on what to expect in crisis situations:
1. It is extremely stressful2. You will probably not get much sleep until project is
stabilized3. Multi-tasking is an understatement4. You will have to provide continuous updates5. You may have to deal with the media
(everyone will want answers “now”)6. You may have to replace (i.e. fire) some of the team7. Fire-fighting will be the norm until you get a grip on
project risks8. You may experience personnel turnover9. You will be between a rock and a hard place
Rescue of HighRescue of High--Visibility ProjectsVisibility Projects
© 2006 Windward Consulting, LLC
Thank You!Thank You!