high heels

1
1383 HIGH HEELS.—"DUPLEX THERAPY." - tourth day as against eight to ten days in untreated - cases. Moreover buboes invariably resolve; when serum ’its given on the second day, half the cases suppurate ,and thereafter there is no difference in this regard. There are, however, certain drawbacks inseparable - from the use of serum So-called serum disease _prolongs convalescence and has to be set off against the rapid neutralisation of the toxins. Vegetarians .almost entirely escape its manifestations. Parsees -and Mahommedans, who are non-vegetarians, suffer in a certain proportion, Europeans most of all. Acute anaphylaxis has been observed whilst the ,serum is actually running into the vein ; coryza, Jacrymation, pyrosis, and urticarial wheals. In ,other cases, severe rigors supervene a few hours .after intravenous injection of even 50 c.cm., followed by high temperature with cardiac distress and weak- ness. The temperature falls gradually in a few hours, .and all the graver symptoms disappear. Death but rarely occurs. I am, Sir, yours faithfully. N. H. CHOKSY. HIGH HEELS. To the Editor of THE LANCET. SIR,-Mr. Roth says that high heels do not project -the weight of the body to the fore part of the foot to a greater extent than low heels. This is the crux .of the matter. I admit that, when standing still, the weight distribution is not disturbed, but, when walking, I say that high heels do project the weight to the fore part of the foot. Observation during the period of short skirts has repeatedly shown me -that when walking in high heels, women hold their knee-joints flexed about 15 per cent. permanently. This means that the tibia is inclined in a more forward -direction than normal, and, on Mr. Roth’s own .admission, it follows that the weight of the body will be distributed to a greater extent to the fore part of the foot. Only if very minute mincing steps are taken can the knees be fully extended. Incidently, it will also be found that if anybody tries to walk extra fast he will find himself keeping his knee-joints slightly flexed and his body inclined forward. It is not therefore surprising that a woman won a walking race in high heels. A mathematical calculation - could doubtless be made showing the exact difference of weight distribution consequent on this flexion of the knee-joint. Statistical evidence could also be .obtained from any out-patient department. Take 200 men and 200 women consecutively and enumerate the numbers of cases of fallen metatarsal arches. I wager the greater number will occur among the women-that is, among the wearers of high heels. It may well be that women, who do a lot of standing, find that high heels relieve the strain on the instep, but, unless they change into low heels for walking, the relief is purchased at the cost of fallen metatarsal arches. Mr. Trethowan taught me that the way to prevent flat-foot was to throw the weight of the body to the outer aspect of the feet by walking with the feet straight or even slightly turned in, and, if necessary, by raising the inner border of the sole and heel. That this is the right method my experience in ,general practice and in an infantry regiment for three years has proved to my satisfaction. Women have told me that they have found flat heels not less but more comfortable and that they can walk miles in them, whereas before they could not do so. Nevertheless, I admit that the human body was not constructed for long continued standing, and useful work could be done in driving this fact home to the public, and so preventing the prolonged standing, usually quite unnecessary, that some occupations demand from pure force of custom. I am. Sir. vours faitlrfullv. P. D. H. CHAPMAN. " DUPLEX THERAPY." To the Editor of THE LANCET. SIR,-In your last issue (p. 1333) I noted with interest the report on Mr. G. G. Blake’s lecture delivered before the Royal Society of Arts on what he terms " duplex therapy." By this he means the simul- taneous applications of diathermy currents with some other current employed in electrotherapy. Reading the resume of his address, one is given the impression that Mr. Blake is unaware of the fact that the filtering device, which he makes use of and which he praises, has been used for some time by the medical profession to superpose other currents on high-frequency currents. Not knowing exactly at what moment Mr. Blake evolved his apparatus, I might do him an injustice by claiming that I applied the same circuit to medical electricity before him, but J wish to point out that at my suggestion a British firm constructed a diathermy machine incorporating the necessary chokes and condensers well over a year ago. This, after I had experimented and had satisfied myself of the value of combining diathermy with other currents. It is regrettable that Mr. Blake should not have acquainted himself with the literature available on the subject or even perused an electro- medical apparatus manufacturer’s catalogue before alluding to his apparatus as a new contribution to medical science. The " contactometer " which he demonstrated, and the importance of which was grossly overrated by the lay audience, was certainly a most ingenious if elaborate piece of apparatus. It is, however, worthy of note that although thousands of diathermy treatments on eyes have been carried out by myself and my assistants, not once would the apparatus have had an opportunity of cutting off the current, to exhibit the importance with which it was invested by the lecturer. For, as your reporter justly remarks, " damage would already be done when the contactometer gave evidence of it," and as he further suggests, correct technique should preclude any possibility of accidents happening. I fear I cannot however agree with his conclusion as to " the need for the physicist interested in biology in the investigation of problems that confront the prac- titioner of physical medicine." The need is a sound knowledge of physics in the practitioner of physical medicine. I am, Sir, yours faithfully, Wimp ole-street, W., Dec. 15th, 1931. PH. BAUWENS. DONATIONS AND BEQUESTS.-Among other bequests the late Mrs. Rose Ray Coyne Goldberg, of Grosvenor House, Park-lane, W., left jE2000 to the Hospital for Sick Children, Great Ormond-street, for cots to be known as the " Arthur Hilton Greaves " and " The Ray Greaves" cots; 91000 each to the Royal Hospital for Incurables, Putney, the Hospital for Consumption, Brompton, Guy’s Hospital, St. Thomas’s Hospital, and the London Hospital ; and the ultimate residue of the property equally between the last-named five hospitals.-The late Lady Battersea left, in addition to many private and personal bequests, 610,000 between the Cromer Hospital, the Metropolitan Hospital, Kingsland-road, the Jewish Association for the Protection of Girls and Women, and the Jewish Board of Guardians, and oE1000 to the Metro- politan Hospital Convalescent Home. PH. BAUWENS.

Upload: pdh

Post on 05-Jan-2017

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: HIGH HEELS

1383HIGH HEELS.—"DUPLEX THERAPY."

- tourth day as against eight to ten days in untreated- cases. Moreover buboes invariably resolve; when serum’its given on the second day, half the cases suppurate,and thereafter there is no difference in this regard.There are, however, certain drawbacks inseparable- from the use of serum So-called serum disease

_prolongs convalescence and has to be set off againstthe rapid neutralisation of the toxins. Vegetarians.almost entirely escape its manifestations. Parsees-and Mahommedans, who are non-vegetarians, sufferin a certain proportion, Europeans most of all.Acute anaphylaxis has been observed whilst the,serum is actually running into the vein ; coryza,Jacrymation, pyrosis, and urticarial wheals. In,other cases, severe rigors supervene a few hours.after intravenous injection of even 50 c.cm., followedby high temperature with cardiac distress and weak-ness. The temperature falls gradually in a few hours,.and all the graver symptoms disappear. Death butrarely occurs.

I am, Sir, yours faithfully.N. H. CHOKSY.

HIGH HEELS.

To the Editor of THE LANCET.SIR,-Mr. Roth says that high heels do not project

-the weight of the body to the fore part of the footto a greater extent than low heels. This is the crux.of the matter. I admit that, when standing still,the weight distribution is not disturbed, but, whenwalking, I say that high heels do project the weightto the fore part of the foot. Observation duringthe period of short skirts has repeatedly shown me-that when walking in high heels, women hold theirknee-joints flexed about 15 per cent. permanently.This means that the tibia is inclined in a more forward-direction than normal, and, on Mr. Roth’s own

.admission, it follows that the weight of the body willbe distributed to a greater extent to the fore part ofthe foot. Only if very minute mincing steps are

taken can the knees be fully extended. Incidently,it will also be found that if anybody tries to walkextra fast he will find himself keeping his knee-jointsslightly flexed and his body inclined forward. It isnot therefore surprising that a woman won a walkingrace in high heels. A mathematical calculation- could doubtless be made showing the exact differenceof weight distribution consequent on this flexion ofthe knee-joint. Statistical evidence could also be.obtained from any out-patient department. Take200 men and 200 women consecutively and enumeratethe numbers of cases of fallen metatarsal arches.I wager the greater number will occur among thewomen-that is, among the wearers of high heels.It may well be that women, who do a lot of standing,find that high heels relieve the strain on the instep,but, unless they change into low heels for walking,the relief is purchased at the cost of fallen metatarsalarches.

Mr. Trethowan taught me that the way to preventflat-foot was to throw the weight of the body tothe outer aspect of the feet by walking with the feetstraight or even slightly turned in, and, if necessary,by raising the inner border of the sole and heel.That this is the right method my experience in

,general practice and in an infantry regiment forthree years has proved to my satisfaction. Womenhave told me that they have found flat heels notless but more comfortable and that they can walkmiles in them, whereas before they could not do so.Nevertheless, I admit that the human body was not

constructed for long continued standing, and usefulwork could be done in driving this fact home to thepublic, and so preventing the prolonged standing,usually quite unnecessary, that some occupationsdemand from pure force of custom.

I am. Sir. vours faitlrfullv.P. D. H. CHAPMAN.

" DUPLEX THERAPY."

To the Editor of THE LANCET.SIR,-In your last issue (p. 1333) I noted with interest

the report on Mr. G. G. Blake’s lecture deliveredbefore the Royal Society of Arts on what he terms" duplex therapy." By this he means the simul-taneous applications of diathermy currents withsome other current employed in electrotherapy.Reading the resume of his address, one is given theimpression that Mr. Blake is unaware of the factthat the filtering device, which he makes use of andwhich he praises, has been used for some time bythe medical profession to superpose other currentson high-frequency currents. Not knowing exactlyat what moment Mr. Blake evolved his apparatus,I might do him an injustice by claiming that I appliedthe same circuit to medical electricity before him,but J wish to point out that at my suggestion a Britishfirm constructed a diathermy machine incorporatingthe necessary chokes and condensers well over a

year ago. This, after I had experimented and hadsatisfied myself of the value of combining diathermywith other currents. It is regrettable that Mr. Blakeshould not have acquainted himself with the literatureavailable on the subject or even perused an electro-medical apparatus manufacturer’s catalogue beforealluding to his apparatus as a new contribution tomedical science. The " contactometer " which hedemonstrated, and the importance of which was

grossly overrated by the lay audience, was certainlya most ingenious if elaborate piece of apparatus.It is, however, worthy of note that although thousandsof diathermy treatments on eyes have been carriedout by myself and my assistants, not once would theapparatus have had an opportunity of cutting offthe current, to exhibit the importance with which itwas invested by the lecturer. For, as your reporterjustly remarks,

"

damage would already be done whenthe contactometer gave evidence of it," and as

he further suggests, correct technique should precludeany possibility of accidents happening. I fear Icannot however agree with his conclusion as to" the need for the physicist interested in biology in theinvestigation of problems that confront the prac-titioner of physical medicine." The need is a sound

knowledge of physics in the practitioner of physicalmedicine. I am, Sir, yours faithfully,

Wimp ole-street, W., Dec. 15th, 1931. PH. BAUWENS.

DONATIONS AND BEQUESTS.-Among other bequeststhe late Mrs. Rose Ray Coyne Goldberg, of GrosvenorHouse, Park-lane, W., left jE2000 to the Hospitalfor Sick Children, Great Ormond-street, for cots to beknown as the " Arthur Hilton Greaves " and " TheRay Greaves" cots; 91000 each to the Royal Hospitalfor Incurables, Putney, the Hospital for Consumption,Brompton, Guy’s Hospital, St. Thomas’s Hospital, and theLondon Hospital ; and the ultimate residue of the propertyequally between the last-named five hospitals.-The lateLady Battersea left, in addition to many private andpersonal bequests, 610,000 between the Cromer Hospital,the Metropolitan Hospital, Kingsland-road, the JewishAssociation for the Protection of Girls and Women, andthe Jewish Board of Guardians, and oE1000 to the Metro-politan Hospital Convalescent Home.

PH. BAUWENS.