herrera airport group 2 michael ming hei caltech maría c araya rsn cecilio morales funvisis dorian...

20
Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix Haiti Gov

Upload: isabelle-pine

Post on 31-Mar-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

Herrera Airport

Group 2

Michael Ming Hei CalTech

María C Araya RSN

Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS

Dorian Restrepo CMU

Kenny García FUNVISIS

Claude Jean-Poix Haiti Gov

Page 2: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

Outline

MethodsHVSRREMIMASWSPAC

Results

Conclusions

Herrera Airport (ReMI, Masw and SPAC)

HSVR West Profile

HVSR East Profile

N

Page 3: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

HVSR

HVSR

Profile1 and Profile2

N

West Profile

East Profile

Page 4: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

HVSR

Page 5: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

HVSR

Page 6: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

HVSR Result

West Profile

East Profile

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 80

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

Period profile

West-1East-1East-0West-0

Stations from South to North

Peri

od T

(sec)

Page 7: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

ReMi – MASW Profiles

3 profiles

Remi & MASW 1

Remi 2

Remi 3

Page 8: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

ReMi

Page 9: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

MASW

Page 10: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

ReMi Profiles ReMi Airport 1shear velocity (m/s) Depth (m)layer best deviation best deviation

1 680.621 3% 0 8%2 1211.829 3% 24 13%3 1114.129 4% 39 11%4 1278.423 4% 94 9%5 2092.552 6% 172

ReMi Airport 2shear velocity (m/s) Depth (m)layer best deviation best deviation

1 793.319 4% 0 15%2 965.06 8% 27 20%3 1064.38 4% 42 14%4 1330.011 10% 104 6%5 2113.582 2.50% 149

ReMi 3shear velocity (m/s) Depth (m)layer best deviation best deviation

1 394.319 3% 0 11%2 619.908 7% 14.8 18%3 904.862 7% 24.4 18%4 1082.958 5% 51

Page 11: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

MASW Profile

MASW Airport 1shear velocity (m/s) Depth (m)layer best deviation best deviation

1 408 6% 0 10%2 832 10% 9.5 20%3 1486 4% 24.54 1278 40

Page 12: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

ReMi & MASW Profiles

670 IBC Class C

768 IBC Class B802 IBC Class B518 IBC Class C

Vs30

MASW

ReMi

Page 13: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

Methods

SPAC Two Arrays

Array 2

Array 1

Page 14: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

Geopsy Spac2dis

p dinver

SPAC: Three step procedure

TARGETED PROFILE

Page 15: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

Results At Herrera Airport400 800 1200 1600 2000 24000

40

80

120

160

200

Shear Velocity (m/s)

Depth

(m

)

SPAC South

ReMi 1 (Black solid line)

Page 16: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

Results At Herrera Airport0 1000 2000 3000

0

40

80

120

160

200Shear Velocity (m/s)

Depth

(m

) SPAC North

ReMi 2 (Black solid line)

Page 17: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

ConclusionsHerrera Airport

Page 18: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

ConclusionsHVSR

3 periods for each site

discarded the biggest cause of high uncertainty.

The other 2 were between 0.3 - 0.4 hz and 0.8 - 1.4 hz

MASW The only profile was

compared with REMI showing a good fit between them

REMI 5 layers Max depth around 160m

and > 2000 m/s for Vs. Low velocity layer between

45 - 100m of depth Airport soil is Class B

SPAC No low frequencies at the p-f

plot, which make it difficult to identify this range.

Spac results present high misfit. They however are in good agreement with other methods

Page 19: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

Conclusions

HVSR High influence on high

frequencies. Uncertainty in the analysis. Provides a fast estimate of

the basin shape and depth.

MASW Easy to make the site

caracterizacion but it takes more time for the acquition of data.

REMI Easy to classify a site

and do the caracterization.

Very fast analysis, and good resolution of penetration.

SPAC Time consuming on data

acquisition and analysis. Special needs for the

site to be able to do the acquisition.

Page 20: Herrera Airport Group 2 Michael Ming Hei CalTech María C Araya RSN Cecilio Morales FUNVISIS Dorian Restrepo CMU Kenny García FUNVISIS Claude Jean-Poix

Thank YouAny questions?