hacettepe university institute of health sciences medical ethics and history ph d program 1

HACETTEPE UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE OF HACETTEPE UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE OF HEALTH SCIENCES MEDICAL ETHICS AND HEALTH SCIENCES MEDICAL ETHICS AND

HISTORY HISTORY PH D PROGRAMPH D PROGRAM

11

22

HACETTEPE UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE OF HEALTH HACETTEPE UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE OF HEALTH SCIENCES MEDICAL ETHICS AND HISTORY PH D SCIENCES MEDICAL ETHICS AND HISTORY PH D

PROGRAMPROGRAM

This PhD program is designed for all healthcare This PhD program is designed for all healthcare professionals and academicians in health area. professionals and academicians in health area.

The purpose of this program is to teach the skills necessary The purpose of this program is to teach the skills necessary for the health workers to identify, analyze and resolve for the health workers to identify, analyze and resolve ethical problems in patient care situations, and choose ethical problems in patient care situations, and choose among the options that can be done and those that ought among the options that can be done and those that ought to be done, for a given patient in a given clinical setting.to be done, for a given patient in a given clinical setting.

We will help the health workers gain insight into the We will help the health workers gain insight into the patient-physician relationship from the patient's patient-physician relationship from the patient's perspective as well as the physician's. perspective as well as the physician's.

33


PROGRAMPROGRAM

Doctoral study consists of two stages:Doctoral study consists of two stages: completing a number completing a number of courses and research. of courses and research.

Students are required to take a minimum of seven-credit Students are required to take a minimum of seven-credit hours for three semesters (total of seven courses, 32 hours for three semesters (total of seven courses, 32 credits minimum). credits minimum).

The student is evaluated according to the grade s/he The student is evaluated according to the grade s/he receives and has to complete the courses successfully in receives and has to complete the courses successfully in order to continue the program.order to continue the program.

When a student successfully completes the first stage, s/he When a student successfully completes the first stage, s/he has to take a comprehensive/qualifying exam to pursue has to take a comprehensive/qualifying exam to pursue PhD thesis work. PhD thesis work.

44


PROGRAMPROGRAM

If the student has been successful in the comprehensive If the student has been successful in the comprehensive exam, s/he then proceeds with the thesis research and exam, s/he then proceeds with the thesis research and writing his/her dissertation to be completed in 4-8 writing his/her dissertation to be completed in 4-8 semesters. Upon the completion of his/her study, the semesters. Upon the completion of his/her study, the student has to defend his/her thesis before a jury/panel of student has to defend his/her thesis before a jury/panel of five examiners, at least one of whom is external to the five examiners, at least one of whom is external to the university. If the jury finds the student successful in the university. If the jury finds the student successful in the defence of the thesis, s/he is awarded a PhD degree.defence of the thesis, s/he is awarded a PhD degree.

Doctoral study has to be completed within a given Doctoral study has to be completed within a given timeframe. The students have to complete all the timeframe. The students have to complete all the requirements for a PhD degree in eight semesters. If the requirements for a PhD degree in eight semesters. If the student cannot complete the requirements within this time student cannot complete the requirements within this time period, s/he can get an extension of four semesters. period, s/he can get an extension of four semesters. Otherwise, the student is dismissed from the programOtherwise, the student is dismissed from the program

55

PLACE OF THE COURSE IN THE PLACE OF THE COURSE IN THE CURRICULUMCURRICULUM

Study Consists of 2 PhasesStudy Consists of 2 Phases Coursework, Followed by a Comprehensive Coursework, Followed by a Comprehensive

Exam (4 Semesters, Exam (4 Semesters, aa mminimum inimum oof 3f 366 ccredits)redits)

Thesis Research (4 Semesters)Thesis Research (4 Semesters)

Total Number Of CredTotal Number Of Crediit Pot Poiintsnts:: 3366

66

MANDATORY LECTURESMANDATORY LECTURES

2 hour/per week- 2 credits2 hour/per week- 2 credits/One /One SemesterSemester

Medical EthicsMedical Ethics 202202 The Methodology of HistoryThe Methodology of History 202202 The Ottoman Turkish Language IThe Ottoman Turkish Language I 202202 The Medical LawThe Medical Law 202202 Bioethics Bioethics 202202 Research Ethics Research Ethics 202202 The History of ScienceThe History of Science 202202 The Ottoman Turkish Language IIThe Ottoman Turkish Language II 202202 Patient’s Rights Patient’s Rights 202202 Clinical Ethics Clinical Ethics 202202 History of MedicineHistory of Medicine 202202 Biostatistics Biostatistics 303303 Seminars on Medical EthicsSeminars on Medical Ethics 020020 History of Medicine of TurksHistory of Medicine of Turks 202202 The Methodology of Research on Health SciencesThe Methodology of Research on Health Sciences 303 303 Seminars on History of MedicineSeminars on History of Medicine 020 020

77

OPTİONAL LECTURESOPTİONAL LECTURES

Academic Ethics Academic Ethics 101101

Publication Ethics Publication Ethics 101101 Ethics in PhilosophyEthics in Philosophy 202202

Applied Ethics Applied Ethics 202202

Genetics and Ethics Genetics and Ethics 101101

Research on Animals and Ethics Research on Animals and Ethics 202202

The Allocation of Health Care The Allocation of Health Care Resources and Ethics Resources and Ethics

202202 Professional Ethics Professional Ethics 303303

88

ACADEMIC DISCIPLINES OF THE ACADEMIC DISCIPLINES OF THE

STUDENTSSTUDENTS

Medicine Medicine PharmacyPharmacy DentDentiistrystry NursNursinging BBiiomedomediical Engcal Engiineerneer

99

MANDATORYMANDATORY STUDY STUDY MATERIALSMATERIALS

Vanderpool, H.Y.: Introduction and Overview: Ethics, Historical Case Vanderpool, H.Y.: Introduction and Overview: Ethics, Historical Case Studies and the Research Enterprise. The Ethics of Research Involving Studies and the Research Enterprise. The Ethics of Research Involving Human Subjects. Ed. : H.Y. Vanderpool. Univ. Publishing Group, 1996, Human Subjects. Ed. : H.Y. Vanderpool. Univ. Publishing Group, 1996, Maryland.Maryland.

Clinical Medical Ethics Cases and Readings, David C. Thomasma, Patricia A. Clinical Medical Ethics Cases and Readings, David C. Thomasma, Patricia A. Marrshall.Marrshall.

Deciding Together Bioethics and Moral Consensus, Jonathan D. Moreno, Deciding Together Bioethics and Moral Consensus, Jonathan D. Moreno, Oxford University Press, 1995. Oxford University Press, 1995.

Beauchamp TL, Childress TF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 4th edition. Beauchamp TL, Childress TF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 4th edition. Oxford University Press, 1994. Oxford University Press, 1994.

Jonsen AR, Siegler M, Winslade WJ.Jonsen AR, Siegler M, Winslade WJ. Clinical Ethics, A Practical Approach to Clinical Ethics, A Practical Approach to Ethical Decisions in Clinical Medicine. 3rd ed. USA:McGraw-Hill Inc; 1992Ethical Decisions in Clinical Medicine. 3rd ed. USA:McGraw-Hill Inc; 1992

Veatch RM. Medical Ethics. Boston: Jones and Bartlett Publishers; 1989Veatch RM. Medical Ethics. Boston: Jones and Bartlett Publishers; 1989

1010

MANDATORY MANDATORY STUDYSTUDY MATERIALS MATERIALS

Advances İn Bioethics : Bioethics for Medical Education.Advances İn Bioethics : Bioethics for Medical Education. Author: Edwards, Author: Edwards, R; İSBN: 0.762.305.592; Publisher: Jai Press; Published: 1999R; İSBN: 0.762.305.592; Publisher: Jai Press; Published: 1999 Media: Hard Media: Hard cover book.cover book.

Basics of BioethicsBasics of Bioethics Author: Veatch, R; İSBN: 0.130.839.760; Publisher: Author: Veatch, R; İSBN: 0.130.839.760; Publisher: Prentice- Hall Pres; Published 1999.Prentice- Hall Pres; Published 1999.

Becoming a Good Doctor: Place of Virtue and Character in Medical EthicsBecoming a Good Doctor: Place of Virtue and Character in Medical Ethics Author: Drane,J, İSBN: 1556122098; Publisher: Sheed and Ward; Published: Author: Drane,J, İSBN: 1556122098; Publisher: Sheed and Ward; Published: N/A.N/A.

Beyond Regulations: Ethics in Human Subjects ResearchBeyond Regulations: Ethics in Human Subjects Research Author: King, N; Author: King, N; İSBN: 0.807.824.682; Publisher: Univ N Carolina; Published: N/AİSBN: 0.807.824.682; Publisher: Univ N Carolina; Published: N/A

Bioethics : Health Care Law and EthicsBioethics : Health Care Law and Ethics Author: Furrow, B; İSBN: Author: Furrow, B; İSBN: 0314227768; Publisher: West Publishing; Published 19970314227768; Publisher: West Publishing; Published 1997

History of Medicine: Byzantine and Islamic MedicineHistory of Medicine: Byzantine and Islamic Medicine, , Author: Prioreschi, Author: Prioreschi, ISBN: 1.888.456.043; Publisher: Horatius Press; Published: 2001.ISBN: 1.888.456.043; Publisher: Horatius Press; Published: 2001.

1111

MANDATORY STUDY MATERIALSMANDATORY STUDY MATERIALS

Biomedical EthicsBiomedical Ethics Author: Mappes, T; İSBN: 0.072.303.654; Publisher: Author: Mappes, T; İSBN: 0.072.303.654; Publisher: Mcgraw-Hill İncorp; Published: 2000Mcgraw-Hill İncorp; Published: 2000

Case Studies in Medical EthicsCase Studies in Medical Ethics Author: Veatch, R; İSBN: 067409932X; Author: Veatch, R; İSBN: 067409932X; Publisher: Harvard Univ. Pr, Published: 1989.Publisher: Harvard Univ. Pr, Published: 1989.

Casebook of Medical EthicsCasebook of Medical Ethics Author: Ackerman, T; İSBN: 0195039173; Author: Ackerman, T; İSBN: 0195039173; Publisher: Oxford Univ Pr ; Published: 1989 Publisher: Oxford Univ Pr ; Published: 1989

Reich WT. Ed. Encyclopedia of Bioethics, Volume1-2, the Free Press, 1982Reich WT. Ed. Encyclopedia of Bioethics, Volume1-2, the Free Press, 1982

Harris J. The Value of Life. 2. nd.Ed., Routledge Press, London and New Harris J. The Value of Life. 2. nd.Ed., Routledge Press, London and New York, 1991.York, 1991.

Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of HumanityGreatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity Author: Porter, Author: Porter, R; ISNB:0.393.319.806; Publisher: Norton, W.W.& Com; Published: 2002.R; ISNB:0.393.319.806; Publisher: Norton, W.W.& Com; Published: 2002.

1212

RECOMMENDED STUDY MATERIALSRECOMMENDED STUDY MATERIALS

Oğuz NY, Tepe H, Büken NÖ., Kucur D. Oğuz NY, Tepe H, Büken NÖ., Kucur D. Bioethics Terminology DictionaryBioethics Terminology Dictionary; Supported ; Supported by the Bioethics Section of the Turkish Philosophy Institute, published by the Turkish by the Bioethics Section of the Turkish Philosophy Institute, published by the Turkish Philosophy Institute. Ankara, 2005.Philosophy Institute. Ankara, 2005.

Çağdaş Tıp Etiği (Modern Medical Ethics),Çağdaş Tıp Etiği (Modern Medical Ethics), Demirhan Erdemir A., Öncel Ö., Aksoy Ş.Demirhan Erdemir A., Öncel Ö., Aksoy Ş.(Eds). Nobel tıp kitabevleri. 2003. (Eds). Nobel tıp kitabevleri. 2003.

Etik Bunun Neresinde! (Where is the Ethics in This?)Etik Bunun Neresinde! (Where is the Ethics in This?) Publication Committee: Akpınar Publication Committee: Akpınar C., Aslan F., Büken NÖ., Çalıkoğlu E., Çay F., Oğuz NY. C., Aslan F., Büken NÖ., Çalıkoğlu E., Çay F., Oğuz NY. Önder E. Öztürk H. Yetener M. Önder E. Öztürk H. Yetener M. 1st ed. 1st ed. Ankara. Ankara Medical Society Publ. No: 1. 1997.Ankara. Ankara Medical Society Publ. No: 1. 1997.

Yaşama Dair Etik Bir Bakış (A Glance at Ethics Concerning Life)Yaşama Dair Etik Bir Bakış (A Glance at Ethics Concerning Life), Arda B. Büken NÖ. , Arda B. Büken NÖ. Duman YÖ. Öztürk H. Şahinoğlu S. Yetener M. Yıldız A. (Publication Committee). Duman YÖ. Öztürk H. Şahinoğlu S. Yetener M. Yıldız A. (Publication Committee). Ankara Medical Society Publ. 2002. Ankara Medical Society Publ. 2002.

Kadına Yönelik Şiddet ve Hekimlik Sempozyumu Bildiri Kitabı (Violence against Kadına Yönelik Şiddet ve Hekimlik Sempozyumu Bildiri Kitabı (Violence against Women and the Medical Profession Symposium Proceedings Book)Women and the Medical Profession Symposium Proceedings Book), ATO Publ, 2003., ATO Publ, 2003.

Buken NO.Buken NO. The Importance Of Anatomy In Medical Evolution and Andreas Vesalius The Importance Of Anatomy In Medical Evolution and Andreas Vesalius The Journal ofThe Journal of Syndrome,Syndrome, 18(11): 75-82, 2006, Istanbul. 18(11): 75-82, 2006, Istanbul.

1313


Buken NO Sahinoglu S. “Buken NO Sahinoglu S. “Critique of medical history education in Turkey's Critique of medical history education in Turkey's medical faculties”, medical faculties”, VesaliusVesalius, Jun; 12(1): 44–9., Jun; 12(1): 44–9.

Buken E.Buken E. Buken NOBuken NO.. Sahinoglu S. “Sahinoglu S. “Evaluation of the Turkish Penal Code Evaluation of the Turkish Penal Code Draft Bill from a Woman's Viewpoint”, Draft Bill from a Woman's Viewpoint”, Journal of International Society for Journal of International Society for the History of Islamic Medicine the History of Islamic Medicine (JISHIM),(JISHIM), Vol:4, Number:7, April 2005. Vol:4, Number:7, April 2005.

Buken NOBuken NO.. Buken E.Buken E. “ “HIV/AIDS in Turkey and an HIV (+) Child's Right to HIV/AIDS in Turkey and an HIV (+) Child's Right to Education: Turkey's Example”, Education: Turkey's Example”, Journal of International Society for the Journal of International Society for the History of Islamic Medicine History of Islamic Medicine (JISHIM(JISHIM), Vol:4, Number:7, April 2005.), Vol:4, Number:7, April 2005.

Buken E. Buken E. Sahinoglu S. Buken NOSahinoglu S. Buken NO. . “Statutory Disclosure in Article 280 of “Statutory Disclosure in Article 280 of the Turkish Penal Codethe Turkish Penal Code”, ”, Nursing EthicsNursing Ethics 13 (6): 573–591, 13 (6): 573–591, November 2006.November 2006.

Büken EBüken E. . Büken NÖ. “Brain Death In Organ Donation From A Perspective Of Büken NÖ. “Brain Death In Organ Donation From A Perspective Of Jurisprudence And Medical Ethics”, Jurisprudence And Medical Ethics”, The Journal ofThe Journal of SyndromeSyndrome 18(11): 65- 18(11): 65-72, 2006, 72, 2006,

1414


Buken NO Sahinoglu S. Violence Against Women In Turkey and Buken NO Sahinoglu S. Violence Against Women In Turkey and The Role Of Women Physicians.The Role Of Women Physicians. Nursing EthicsNursing Ethics 13(2)13(2), , March 2006.March 2006.

Oguz N.Y., Miles SHOguz N.Y., Miles SH, , Buken N.O., Civaner M., "End of Life Care in Buken N.O., Civaner M., "End of Life Care in Turkey", Turkey", The Cambridge Quarterly of Health Care EthicsThe Cambridge Quarterly of Health Care Ethics, 12(3): , 12(3): 279-284 (Sum 2003).279-284 (Sum 2003).

Buken NO.,Buken NO., Buken E., “Emerging Health Sector Problems Affecting Buken E., “Emerging Health Sector Problems Affecting Patient Rights in Turkey”. Patient Rights in Turkey”. Nursing EthicsNursing Ethics, , 11(6), 2004.11(6), 2004.

Buken NO, Yegenoglu S., “Physician-Industry Relationships and Buken NO, Yegenoglu S., “Physician-Industry Relationships and Promotion Ethics in Turkey.” Promotion Ethics in Turkey.” Clinical Research and Regulatory Clinical Research and Regulatory AffairsAffairs, Volume 20, Issue 4, pages: 379-389 (2003)., Volume 20, Issue 4, pages: 379-389 (2003).

Buken NO., "Turkey's Position Regarding Clinical Drug Trials", Buken NO., "Turkey's Position Regarding Clinical Drug Trials", Clinical Research and Regulatory AffairsClinical Research and Regulatory Affairs,, Volume 20, Issue 3: 349- Volume 20, Issue 3: 349-355 (2003).355 (2003).

1515


Buken NO., Buken E.Buken NO., Buken E. “Tıp Etiği ve Tıp Hukuku Açısından Klinik İlaç “Tıp Etiği ve Tıp Hukuku Açısından Klinik İlaç Araştırmaları” (“Clinical Drug Research From Medical Ethics and Araştırmaları” (“Clinical Drug Research From Medical Ethics and Legal Perspectives”). Legal Perspectives”). Türk Psikiyatri Dergisi (Turkish Journal of Türk Psikiyatri Dergisi (Turkish Journal of Psychiatry)Psychiatry), 14(4): 289-299 (2003)., 14(4): 289-299 (2003).

Buken NO, Büken E. "The Rights Experimental of Subjects and Buken NO, Büken E. "The Rights Experimental of Subjects and Patients in Clinical Drug Researches". Patients in Clinical Drug Researches". FABAD Journal of FABAD Journal of Pharmaceutical SciencesPharmaceutical Sciences, 27, 173-185 (2002)., 27, 173-185 (2002).

Büken NÖ. "Büken NÖ. "History of Research Done on Human Subjects", History of Research Done on Human Subjects", The The Journal ofJournal of SyndromeSyndrome,, 14(9): 130-139 (2002). 14(9): 130-139 (2002).

Büken NÖ. Büken E. “Placebo ve Placebo Effects”, Büken NÖ. Büken E. “Placebo ve Placebo Effects”, The Journal of The Journal of Syndrome,Syndrome, 16(3): 98-103 (2004). 16(3): 98-103 (2004).

Oğuz NY, Tepe H, Büken NÖ., Kucur D. Oğuz NY, Tepe H, Büken NÖ., Kucur D. Bioethics Terminology Bioethics Terminology DictionaryDictionary; Supported by the Bioethics Section of the Turkish ; Supported by the Bioethics Section of the Turkish Philosophy Institute, published by the Turkish Philosophy Philosophy Institute, published by the Turkish Philosophy Institute. Ankara, 2005.Institute. Ankara, 2005.

Çağdaş Tıp Etiği (Modern Medical Ethics),Çağdaş Tıp Etiği (Modern Medical Ethics), Demirhan Erdemir A., Demirhan Erdemir A., Öncel Ö., Aksoy Ş.(Eds). Nobel tıp kitabevleri. 2003.Öncel Ö., Aksoy Ş.(Eds). Nobel tıp kitabevleri. 2003.

1616

UNESCO DOCUMENTSUNESCO DOCUMENTS

The Universal Declaration on the Human The Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights. Genome and Human Rights.

A Declaration on Human Genetic DataA Declaration on Human Genetic Data

The Establishing Bioethics Committees The Establishing Bioethics Committees Guide No. 1,2 Guide No. 1,2

1717

EVALUATION OF THE STUDENTSEVALUATION OF THE STUDENTS

• Essay(s)Essay(s) 5000– word length / pages: 20 / number of essays: 1-2 /per 5000– word length / pages: 20 / number of essays: 1-2 /per lecturelecture

• Essay topics:Essay topics: look the name of the topics in PhD look the name of the topics in PhD programprogram

• AttendanceAttendance

• Oral examinationsOral examinations

• Participation in seminarsParticipation in seminars

• EVALUATION OF THE COURSEEVALUATION OF THE COURSE

• Every YearEvery Year

• WrWriitten tten aand Oral Feedback From Studentsnd Oral Feedback From Students

hacettepe university institute of health sciences medical ethics and history ph d program 1

Documents

phd program

hisher thesis

student successful

health workers

thesis research

health area

phd thesis work

given patient