gundih ccs pilot project – indonesia: … to public engagement for ccs in blora district dr. farah...

RoadtoPublicEngagementforCCSin

BloraDistrict

Dr.FarahMulyasariPertaminaUniversity

CCOPCO2StorageMappingProgram(CCS-M)CCS-MSeminar6(S6):

Seminar/WorkshoponCO2GeologicalStorageandCO2forEOR7-9June2016,Hanoi,Vietnam

GUNDIHCCSPILOTPROJECT–INDONESIA:

ADB

IntroducZonu Reasonsfor

DevelopmentofPublicEngagementPlan

u MethodologicalStructureforPreliminaryPublicEngagementPlan

DataCollecZonu Stakeholder

Analysisu Opinion

ShapingFactors

RecommendaZonsu ArgumentsforCCS

GundihPilotProjectinBloraDistrict

u MessagingFramework

u CommunicaZonAcZonPlan

u LessonsLearnt

Outline

WayForwardu NextSteps


IntroducZontoPreliminaryPublicEngagementPlan


ReasonsforDevelopmentof

PublicEngagementPlan

MethodologicalStructureforPreliminary

PublicEngagementPlan

•  EngagethestakeholdersinClimateChangemiZgaZonasanefforttotransiZontoagreenerandmoreresilientsociety

•  Publicengagementplanisinaccordancewith/andaspartofEnvironmentalImpactAssessment

•  Engagelocalstakeholdersofpilotprojectarea(BloraDistrict,CentralJava)inmanagingperceivedrisks

•  StakeholderAnalysiso  Mappingo  Views&InterestofStakeholdersinBlorao  SocialSiteCharacteriza;on

•  OpinionShapingFactors

IntroducZontoPreliminaryPublicEngagementPlan

4Seminar/WorkshoponCO2GeologicalStorageandCO2forEOR7-9June2016,Hanoi,Vietnam

DataCollecZon


AcZvityofPublicEngagementStudy

ObjecZve Status/Progress

Stakeholdermapping Iden;fica;onofprojectstakeholdersandcharacterizingtheposi;oningofthevariousstakeholderswithrespecttotheCCSinBlora

June-August2014

Socialsitecharacteriza;on

Gathering&evalua;nginforma;oninobtainingaccurateportraitofstakeholdergroups,theirpercep;ons&concernsaboutCO2storageinBlora

July2014

MediaLandscape Iden;fica;onofeffec;vecommunica;onchannelsatlocallevel(Blora)

August2014

FocusGroupDiscussion Developmentofopinionshapingfactors,argumentmap,andkeymessagingframeworkforproposingstructuredengagementac;vi;esinpreliminarypublicengagementplan

28August2014

Ques;onnaireSurvey(BaselineSurvey)

Iden;fica;onthethoughtsandunderstandingoflocalpublicinBloraaboutCCSanditsengagementac;vi;esintheirarea

NextStep

6

DataCollecZon

  Toolsforfordevelopmentofpreliminarypublicengagementplan


7

DataCollecZon

BloraDistrict,CentralJavaProvince,846.432people(BDA,2013)

Central Processing Plant

Corbon Storage Well (Jepon Well-1)


CCS Gundih Pilot Project

Public

Funding Organization

Government of Indonesia

Media Legislative

PERTAMINA

SKK MIGAS

DITJEN MIGAS

DITJEN DIKTI

UKP4

National

National MG

Local Senators

National Senators

Local MG

ADB

JICA/JST

Norwegian Embassy

Climit Program (Norway)

Local Public of Gundih

People of Indonesia

International communities

Kyoto University

Nedo (Japan)

DNV-GL CMR University of Bergen

Kenso Technos

DataCollecZon

8 Seminar/WorkshoponCO2GeologicalStorageandCO2forEOR7-9June2016,Hanoi,Vietnam

Local Public Of Gundih

Area

Media

Community Representative

Local Government of Blora District

State Owned Enterprise

Sub-districts Villages Service Agencies

CBOs Elderly Head of communities NGOs

Diva Blora Newspaper Community Radio

PERTAMINA CEPU PERUM PERHUTANI REGIONAL CENTRAL JAVA PROVINCE

LevelofClimateChangeandCCS

knowledgeConcernsand

IssuesLevelofSupportorResistance

ExpressAbtude

StakeholderAnalysis

MappingViews&InterestofStakeholdersinBlora

DataCollecZon

9

  StakeholderMapping


LocaleconomiccondiZons Localempowerment Underlyingviews

•  Agriculture(rain-fedricefield,seasonalcrops)

•  Teakforest(teakwoodandrootsproduc;on)

•  Oldwells(crudeoilproduc;on

•  Formalorganiza;ons:Forest-VillageCommunityBody,VillageCoopera;veUnit,WomenWelfareAssocia;on,FarmersGroupandWomenFarmersGroup.

•  Non-formalorganiza;ons:ReligiousMosquegroup/MajlisTa’lim

•  Overarchingviewsonfossilfuel-basedenergy,oilandgasproduc;on

•  Interested&takingpartinthediscussionforums,listeningtolocalauthori;es

DataCollecZon

  SocialsitecharacterizaZon


Environment Energy Trust Media

•  Damages:Roads(overburdenedtransporta;on)Teakforest(oilgasexplora;on)

•  Solu;on:FillingupwithlimestoneReforesta;on

•  Local&Regionalsourcesofenergy-Oil-Gas

•  Localgovernmentofficers(headofsub-district,headofvillage)

•  Keypersonincommunity(elderly/wise-man)

•  Stronglocalmediapresence(DIVAnewspaperofBlora)

•  Sourceofinforma;on:Localgovernmentofficers,newspapers,television&communityradio

DataCollecZon



DataCollecZon

LocaleducaZon/Localknowledge

LocaltrafficcondiZons Localhazards

•  Primary–Highschools•  Nohigheracademic

ins;tu;ons(universi;es)•  Opportuni;estocollaboratefor

educa;onalprograms•  Localwisdom/events(Annual

EarthThanksgiving)

Impactsofprojectconstruc;on&implementa;ononlocaltrafficconges;on•  Busiestatbusterminalduring

day;me•  Poten;aloftrafficconges;on

eitherbytwo-wheeled/four-wheeledvehicles,coupledwithdensepopulatedarea

•  Narrowroads&Cepumarket

•  Poten;altoearthquakerisks:LocatednearthefaultlineDrillinginanarea/theCO2

injec;onmaycausedEQTheabilityofCO2injec;on&

storageinfrastructuretowithstandhurricanes

•  Poten;altofloodrisk:Noproperditches(streets&

riveroverflowingduringtherainyseason)




Television(NaZonal)Government:TVRI

JawaTengahCommercialTV

Radio(Local)CommunicaZonandInformaZonServiceAgency

Internet(LocalGovernmentSite)

InfoBloraBappedaBlora

Newspaper(Local)DIVABloraJawaTengahPos

DataCollecZon

  LocalMediaLandscape

ExplaintheneedtomiZgateglobal

warming

ExplainCCSasameasureformiZgaZng

globalwarming

ExplainbothstrengthsandweaknessesofCCS

ProvidebasisfordecisionsconcerningimplementaZonofCCS

Explainothermeasurestolimitglobalwarming

Explainbothstrengthsandweaknessesofothermeasures

DataCollecZonIllustraZngimpactsofglobalwarmingon

everydaylife


Premise'General'support'is'gained'

na2on3wide'regarding'the'importance'of'CCS'

Acceptance'of'nega2ve'impacts,'risks'associated'with'CCS'

Build'local'rela2onship'of'trust'

Get'permission'to'implement'CCS'in'

Blora'

Recogni2on'of''benefits'associated'with'CCS'(improved'environment,'health,'infrastructure,'and'

local'job''Opportuni2es)'

DataCollecZon


•  Levelofknowledge/understandingofCCS

•  ArgumentandmoZvaZonoflocalpublicaboutCCS

•  Localpublicengagement/involvementofCCS

•  intheirarea

o  UnderstandingofCCandCCSo  SourceofCCSinforma;ono  HopeaboutCCSplaninBlorao  Posi;veandnega;veimpacts

ofCCSforBloraandtheirfocus

o  RoleofinvolvementinCCSo  Communica;onmodeand

CCSmediao  Importantstakeholder(s)to

beinvolvedinCCScommunica;on

¡  Sub-districts(7)andVillageleaders(26)

¡  LocalGovernmentWorkingUnits(LGUs)

¡  MediaGroup

16

DataCollecZon  FocusGroupDiscussion


RecommendaZons


LessonsLearnt

ArgumentsforCCSGundihPilotProjectin

BloraDistrict

MessagingFramework

CommunicaZonAcZonPlan

18

RecommendaZons


ArgumentsforCCSGundihPilotProjectin

BloraDistrict

o  7sub-districtsand26villageslocatedwiZhintheareaofCCSGundihPilotProject

o  IniZatestheprocessofintroducingplaned

CCSacZviZestoBlora’scommuniZeso  Tooltocreatethemessagingframeworkin

providinglocalpublicconvincingCCSinformaZon

o  ToolforspokespeopleoftheCCSGundihPilotProjecttoprepareforadialogue

o  GenericargumentsforCCSacZviZesinBlora:Climate,Energy,Environment,Safety,Economics,andEthics

o  AroundtheposiZveandnegaZveimpactsofCCSacZviZes

o  FocusingonposiZveimpactsofCSS

RecommendaZons


UlZmateGoalCCSGundihPilotProjectinBloraDistrictisapilotprojectasalearningstudyincomba;ng

GreenhouseGasasimpactofClimateChange

UmbrellaMessageIntroducinganewcleanandsafeenergytechnologytoreducetheCO2emissionsin

IndonesiaandBloraDistrictPosi;veimpactsofCCStopublicinBloraDistrict

MessagingCriteria

Thetypesofins;tu;onsthatarebehindthe

communica;onofCCS

ThelanguagesinwhichCCSwillbe

communicated

HowCCSwillbecommunicated&media

willbeused

Towhatextent,CCSisportrayedfroma

suppor;ve,neutralorcri;calperspec;ve

TheextenttowhichCCScommunica;oneffortsare

evidence-based

ThewaysCCScommunica;onis

fragmentedorlinkedacrossins;tu;onsand

sites

HowCCSistaughtineduca;onalseings

FurthereffortsmightneededonhowCCS

communica;oncouldbedeveloped

RecommendaZons

MessagingFramework


CommunicaZonAcZonPlan

RecommendaZons

21

OutgoingAcZons(AcZvaZng)

ProjectStage

EngagementobjecZve

Stakeholdergroup

Channel EngagementAcZvity

ResourceRequirement

When Whatdoessuccesslooklike

IncomingAcZons(Monitoring)

ProjectStage

Channel Whatarewelookingfor?

Howdelookforit? ResponseStrategy

ObjecZves&mainstagesofCCSacZviZesforGundihPilotProjectwithfocusonpublicengagement

ProjectStage ObjecZves AcZviZes

ProjectpreparaZon

SubmissionandreviewoftheinjecZonplan

InjecZonandmonitoringprocess

Closure&disseminaZonofresultsandCCSacZviZes


c

Tiered/StageCommunica;on

FacilitatedCommunica;on

DirectCommunica;on

Note:

RecommendaZons

  Sub-districtandVillageCommunicaZonPlan

Sub$district+leaders+

Village+leaders+

c"

Local+Residents+Government+of+Blora+District+

(BAPPEDA)+

CCS+Pilot+Project+

Management+

Community+Health++Center+

WWA+

Formal+&+Informal+Gathering+

Youth+Union+

Religious+Session+

Community+Facilitators+


c

DirectCommunica;on

FacilitatedCommunica;on

Note:

RecommendaZons

  LocalGovernmentUnitCommunicaZonPlan

23

Government)of)Blora)District)

(BAPPEDA))

CCS)Pilot)Project)

Management)Local)Residents)

Village)leaders)

Community)Health))Center)

WWA)

Formal)&)Informal)Gathering)

Youth)Union)

Religious)Session)

Local)Government)Working)Units)

Environment)

EducaKon)

InformaKon)and))

CommunicaKon)

TransportaKon)

Economic)


Mass$Media$

Local$Residents$

Government$of$Blora$District$

(BAPPEDA)$

CCS$Pilot$Project$

Management$

Newspaper$

Radio$

Television$

Internet$/$Website$

Social$Media$

(FB$etc.)$

c

Two-wayCommunica;on

Two-wayCommunica;on

Note:

OnewayCommunica;on

24

  LocalMassMediaCommunicaZonPlan

RecommendaZons



RecommendaZons

Facilitated)Communica/on)•  Formal'and'Informal'Gatherings'

•  WWAs'and'YUs'mee7ngs'

•  Integrated'health'center'ac7vi7es'

•  Religious'ac7vi7es'

Community)Tradi/onal)Event)•  Local'Wisdom:'Earth'Thanksgiving'

•  Village'Cleaning'

Media)and)Tools)•  3D'mini'CCS'mobile'interac7ve'model'

•  Posters'pamphlet:'o  Village'community�informa7on'board'

o  Coffee'stalls,'local'markets,'electricity'paying'shops'

SUB:DISTRICT)&)

VILLAGE))

Television)•  Covering'all'project'ac7vi7es'and'support'the'socializa7on'

•  Local'TV'develops'and'broadcast'community'service'ads'

•  Pos7ng'informa7on'through'TV'social'media'account'(FB,'TwiQer)'

Newspaper)•  Covering'all'project'ac7vi7es'and'support'the'socializa7on'

•  Press'release,'feature,'and'opinion'

•  Pos7ng'informa7on'through'Newspaper'social'media'account'(FB,'TwiQer)'

Radio)•  Covering'all'project'ac7vi7es'and'support'the'socializa7on'

•  Community'service'adds'and'jingles'

•  Talk'show'•  Pos7ng'informa7on'through'Radio'social'media'account'(FB,'TwiQer)'

MASS)MEDIA)

Local)Event)•  Organize'Poster'and'Video'clip'contest'

•  Exhibi7on''

Direct)Communica/on)•  Socializa7on'to'all'LGUs''

•  Seminars'and'FGDs'•  Community'gatherings'•  School'Campaign'

Media)and)Tools)•  Billboards'and'ads'•  Distribu7on'of'posters'to:'o  Schools,'police'sta7ons,'hospitals,'mail'office,'markets'

•  Ac7ve'in'social'media'•  Develop'YouTube'persuasive'video'

LOCAL)GOVERNMENT)

UNIT)

25

  PreliminaryPublic

EngagementPlan

LocalGovernment

Unit

MassMedia

Sub-DistrictandVillage

EngagingthelocalmediagroupinBloraaspartnerwithagreedac;vi;es

•  DevelopingMediaandTools

•  OrganizeCommunityTradi;onalEvent

•  ImplementFacilitatedCommunica;on

•  BaselineSurvey

•  DevelopingMediaandTools

•  OrganizeLocalEvent•  ImplementDirect

Communica;on

Mid2015-2017

Mid2015-2017 Mid2015-2017 Post2017

•  Reachingmorewidelylocalpublic(scienceexhibi;on,localCCSforumofBlora,sitevisit)

•  Rou;neeventswithschools,lectures

RecommendaZons

  TimelineofthePublicEngagementPlan



StakeholderMapping•  Remotestakeholder(s)are

equalimportantaslocalpublicinthestakeholderengagementplanningprocess

•  Localpopula;onrelieson

government.Ensureearly&con;nuesengagement.U;lizeitascommunica;onchannelforpubliccommunica;on

SocialSiteCharacterizaZon•  Earlyobserva;on&factfinding

enhancedunderstandingofthesocialcontextinplannedCCSpilotproject

•  Ensuresufficientlocal

resourcestounderstandlocalcondi;onsbejer

OpinionShapingFactors(FGD)•  Term“Gundih”isnotverywell

knownbypublicinBlora.•  Testourassump;onswhen

consideringusingterminologyorjargoninwiderstakeholderconsulta;on

•  Opinionabouttheprojectinfluencedbyhowitwillbringvaluetolocalpublic.Discussandtesttheideaswiththem

Messaging(FGD)•  ‘Transla;ngtheterm‘CCS’•  Posi;veframingoftheCCSpilot

projectintermsoflocalmerits(addressinginaconsistent,open&honestway)

•  Involvementoflocalleadersaslocalambassadors(guidance&supportneededinedu-materials)

CommunicaZonAcZons(FGD)Localstakeholders:•  interestinunderstandingCCS.

Crea;ngeasilytransportableeduca;onalmaterials,includesaphysicalmodeloftheCCSpilotinstalla;on.

•  havingcon;nuescommunica;onwiththeproject&trustcommunica;ngwithsameprojectrepresenta;ves 27

RecommendaZons

  LessonsLearnt

WayForward


NextSteps

o BaselinepublicsurveyonCCSo  FurtherrefinementofCCSmessaging

framework

o TrainingoflocalprojectambassadorsanddevelopmentofeducaZonaltooltosupportlocalambassadors

o EngagingthemediagroupatearlystageasthepartnerincoveringCCSprojectacZviZesanditscommunicaZonacZons

o SetuppublicengagementtaskforcewithintheCCSprojectstructure

http://www.scifun.ed.ac.uk/fusion/fusion-case1-CCSI.html

CreaZngeasilytransportableeducaZonalmaterials,includesaphysicalmodeloftheCCSpilotinstallaZon.

WayForward


o BaselinepublicsurveyonCCSinBloraDistrict

WayForward

30

DevelopingCommunica;onofCCSand

PublicOutreachStrategyforcertainTargetAudience

Topopulateandmeasure:§  baselinepercep;onsofissuesand

impacts,§  posi;veandnega;vethataremostrelevanttolocalstakeholdersinBlorarelatedtotheapplica;onofnewtechnologyinoil,gas,andenergysector(CCS)

1

TofindoutthelevelofknowledgeoflocalstakeholdersrelatedtoCCS 2

Crea;ngvarioustypesofcontentandac;vi;es,related

toCCSeduca;on

Dissemina;nginforma;onandimplemen;ngac;vi;es

(engaginglocalpublic)throughselectedmediums

Toiden;fybestmethodsinconveyingCCStolocalstakeholders 3

Objec;ves




WayForward

31

SurveyStructure&Content

DemographicItems:Informa;onaboutpar;cipantsthemselves,includinginforma;onthatwilliden;fywhatstakeholdergroupstheyarelinkedwith.

IssuesandImpactsItems:MeasuresofhowtheCCSprojectisperceivedtointeractwithcontextinwhichitoperates,bothnega;velyandposi;vely.

RelaZonalItems:MeasuresofhowtheCCSprojectisperceivedtointeractwithitsstakeholders.

OutcomeItems:MeasuresofhowstakeholdersperceivetheCCSproject’sreputa;on,theiracceptanceandapprovalofCCSac;vityandtheirbehavioralinten;ontowardstheCCSproject.

1

2

3

4


WayForward

32

Schedule

DescripZon Time

§  Comple;onofsurveytemplate

² MidJune2016

§  BaselinepublicsurveyonCCSinBlora

²  September2016

§  Analysisandreportofthebaselinesurvey

²  September–November2016

§  Prepara;onforPublicEngagementAc;vi;esforCCS(referringandinlinewithCCSProjectac;vi;es)

²  December2016

§  PublicEngagementAc;vi;esforCCS(basedonthesurveyanalysis)

²  Star;ngJanuary2017


ThankyouforyourakenZon!

Thepresenta;onispartoftheReportofPreliminaryPublicEngagementPlan(February,2015)thatwasmadebyIns;tutTeknologiBandung,(FarahMulyasari,currentlyaffiliatedatPertaminaUniversity),supportedby

UniversitasPembangunanNasionalVeteran-Yogyakarta(PujiLestari,PrayudiAhmad,AndiSungkowo,RenyTriwardani,EkhaYogafanny,andAmyUtami)andreviewedbyDNVGLNorway(AnastasiaIsaenkoandEelcoKruizinga).

ThesupportofUPNteammembersinsocialsitecharacteriza;onandFGDaswellascommentsfromDNVGLNorwayareacknowledged.ThesupportofPlanningandDevelopmentAgencyofBlora(BappedaBlora)isappreciated.

PublicEngagementPilotStudyforCarbonSequestraZonandMonitoringinGundihArea,CentralJavaProvince,IndonesiaINSTITUTTEKNOLOGIBANDUNGBasicScienceBuilding-B,3rdFloor,FacultyofMiningandOilEngineeringJl.GaneshaNo.10,Bandung40132,IndonesiaTel/Fax:+62-22-253-4205Mobile:+62-813-2189-2276Email:[email protected]:hjp://ccs-gundih.ttm.itb.ac.id

PERTAMINAUNIVERSITYCommunicaZonScienceDepartmentFacultyofCommunicaZonandDiplomacyJl.TeukuNyakArief,Simprug,JakartaSelatan12220,IndonesiaTel:+62-21-2904-4308Fax:+62-21-2904-4316Email:[email protected]:universitaspertamina.ac.id

gundih ccs pilot project – indonesia: … to public engagement for ccs in blora district dr. farah...

Documents