guided wave technology
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 Guided wave technology
1/4
Guided Wave Technology Aims To Help As ECDA Tool - NDT Folks
Another tool to help the direct assessment of external pipeline corrosion appears to be gaining
the attention of operators. Long-range guided wave ultrasonic testing (LRGWUT) technology is
being viewed more widely as another tool to help. The increasing visibility of the technique canbe attributed to capability improvements, an increased understanding of the decisions that must
be thoughtfully made about where to use the technology and, equally important, the importance
of employing professional data interpretation.
LRGWUT is being looked at to provide another arrow in the external corrosion direct
assessment (ECDA) quiver. The technology is not new to pipeline inspection, yet has had its
most notable success on in-plant inspections when it is necessary to detect metal loss defects
while the pipe under scrutiny is surrounded by insulation or other coverings.
In its more recent use in field pipeline corrosion detection, it has been found to be particularly
advantageous for use at rail and road crossings, especially with cased pipe. It also has shown
usefulness when used on above-ground pipe sections and when applied to non-piggable
portions of the pipeline. As such, it can serve as a verification tool in conjunction with other
ECDA methods and as a principal instrument for specific pipeline investigations.
LRGWUT systems utilize single or multiple circumferential probe rings of either electromagnetic
or piezoelectric transducer configurations. The transducers surround the pipe, needing only
minimal clearance with which to operate. The equipment, available for pipe diameters ranging
from 3-42 inches, can generate three wave types--longitudinal, torsional or flexural--sending the
waves in both directions from the probe transducer to inspect the entire pipe wall.
The transmitted wave detects echoes from corrosion defects in the pipe and reflects the signalback to the transducer from the defects or circumferential pipeline welds. The reflections can
then be analyzed independently for each direction. A typical assessment range of +/-100 feet
can be expected in either direction from a single test point under normal conditions. Under ideal
situations, the technique has proven effective at lengths of more than 300 feet forward or
backward from the transducer.
The distance of signal propagation depends largely on the pipeline size and wall thickness as
well as the condition and type of the pipeline's coating and the compactness of the materialssurrounding the pipe. Increased signal attenuation from compacted soil, certain types of
1 / 4
-
7/30/2019 Guided wave technology
2/4
Guided Wave Technology Aims To Help As ECDA Tool - NDT Folks
coatings, increased soil depth and obstacles such as concrete can be expected and can limit
the range to less than 30 feet in either direction.
Field Testing
While laboratory tests using LRGWUT systems have been conducted with mixed outcomes, the
most usable results come from field testing on pipelines in service or on controlled field
applications. IONIK was recently involved in three projects that effectively tested the
applicability of guided wave technology.
A field demonstration was conducted at the operations facilities of a major pipeline operator on
reclaimed 4-inch and 6-inch diameter pipe sections, approximately 300 feet in length.
Conditions were provided to test the technology on bare pipe in air, bare pipe surrounded by
compacted soil cover, on pipe-in-pipe to simulate cased crossings and on water-filled
pipe-in-pipe to replicate flooded casings or underwater conditions. In all cases, minute
anomalies were machined into the pipe in either longitudinal or circumferential directions. Using
LRGWUT technology, the imperfections and areas of metal loss were accurately pinpointed
(Graph).
For the second case, LRGWUT was used as part of a multi-year study to assess the overall
state of integrity on more than 120 miles of a natural gas distribution system, of which
approximately 10 miles were under paved surfaces with numerous road and rail crossings. In
that capacity, the technique was used as part of a multi-technology toolbox in an ECDA
assessment of coal-tar wrapped and fusion bonded epoxy-coated pipe varying from 4 to 12
inches in diameter. The tool was used to supplement pipeline current mapper (PCM) and
alternating current voltage gradient (ACVG) sensing in designated locations where verification
was necessary or access was limited.
The assessment included data collected and interpreted by IONIK to ascertain the extent of
coating damage, corrosion depth measurements and soil conditions. The guided wave
technique was used to inspect 6-inch and 8-inch cased road crossings at I I sites necessitated
by the technical limitations of the other indirect inspection tools at those locations. The length of
the measurements varied between 22 and 100 feet.
2 / 4
-
7/30/2019 Guided wave technology
3/4
Guided Wave Technology Aims To Help As ECDA Tool - NDT Folks
The guided wave technology was able to detect several minor indications, likely related to
corrosion at failed coating. The smallest area of metal loss was 4% of external metal loss on an
8-inch line, to give an idea of the technique's sensitivity. It was further able to ascertain that
there were no moderate (10-19% metal loss) or severe (>20% metal loss) anomalies that
required further investigation.
The LRGWUT technique was also used as a complementary technology in the Direct
Assessment process at two cased road locations on an 8-inch coal tar-coated carbon dioxide
pipeline in close proximity to a major urban area (Photo). The two digs were 46 total feet (6 feet
forward in the flow direction and 40 feet backward) and 45 total feet (40 feet forward, 5 feet
backward). The digs detected no severe indications of more than 20% metal loss, but did reveal
two minor anomalies--one under 9% and one moderate imperfection of between 9-20%. The dig
locations, and consequently the anomalies, were accurately pinpointed through sub-meter GPSreadings.
Interpretation Is Key
The data generated by a LRGWUT tool is valuable for identifying anomalies on pipelines,
particularly in hard-to-inspect locations. As is the case with all the techniques available for thatpurpose, correct interpretation of results is critical in the ECDA process. One could use an
analogy of a NASCAR owner who funds a high-performance race car and then turns over its
operation to an inexperienced driver. The results are most likely going to be undesirable.
Similarly, in looking for detection of minute pipeline anomalies, the guided wave tool can provide
the data needed for detection, but needs to be set up correctly in the field, closely monitored
during its operation and the data interpreted correctly by a knowledgeable technician.
New generations of the technology are available that are able to focus wave energy precisely
on areas where there is metal loss. Additionally, multi-mode technology, simultaneously using
longitudinal and torsional waves, is being introduced to add a higher degree of accuracy. Once
again, experienced technicians are required to make in-process adjustments on the instrument
and to correctly interpret the results. With recent capability improvements, proper applications
and professional interpretation, LRGWUT technology is bidding to increasingly find a spot in the
ECDA toolbox. P&GJ
3 / 4
-
7/30/2019 Guided wave technology
4/4
Guided Wave Technology Aims To Help As ECDA Tool - NDT Folks
Dirk L. van Oostendorp, Jos H. Garcia and Mark A. Ortiz, IONIK Consulting, Houston, TX
Authors:
Dirk L. van Oostendorp, Regional Manager-The Americas, for IONIK Consulting has more
than 26 years experience in energy and infrastructural engineering projects, including onshore
and offshore pipelines. This includes project management, corrosion control, pipeline integrity,
inspection technologies and risk assessment. He regularly lectures at NACE venues on pipeline
integrity, corrosion and diagnostics.
Jos H. Garcia, Senior Materials Engineer, has more than 21 years of energy industry
experience in both operations and services, with extensive work in the areas of inspection, NDT
quality assurance and materials selection. He has also provided technical support on the repair
of OCTG, wellhead equipment, pipelines, pressure vessels, process equipment, as well as
rotating equipment.
Mark A. Ortiz, Senior Pipeline Engineer, has more than 12 years international experience in
both pipeline engineering and operating company environments!. He has worked with advanced
computer modeling software (PipeSim Net, Pipephase, Caesar 11), is a NACE Corrosion
Technologist and experienced in cost estimating, pipeline construction and repair, and
operations management.
4 / 4