green tier clear water initiative charter...2017/07/06  · 1 green tier clear waters initiative...

20
1 Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative Charter 2017 Annual Report The Charter The Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative (GTCWI) is a charter authorized under the laws of the State Wisconsin, Act 276, sections 299.83 and 299.85 Wisconsin Statutes. The GTCWI was formally signed by all parties on February 9 th , 2006 and renewed in 2011 and 2016 by unanimous agreement of the signatories. Mission Statement The mission of this Charter is to cause a meaningful reduction, beyond current state standards, in the sediment and nutrient delivery to lakes, streams, and wetlands in Dane County resulting from land disturbing activities and to develop alternative approaches and practices that will result in better erosions control and long-term stormwater management. Furthermore, the mission is to explore new business and regulatory practices that result in improved regulatory certainty for Charter Participants and increased regulatory efficiency by regulatory agencies. The Charter Signatories will explore the development of practices that minimize the environmental impact of developments. This effort will focus on sustainable practices and will include measures for 1) conservation of surface water and groundwater; 2) conservation of energy; 3) reduction of air emissions; and 4) maximizing recycling. 2017 Summary In 2017, the Charter’s Board of Directors met 8 times February 9, April 06, May 25, July 6, August 17, September 28, November 9 and December 21. The agendas from the meetings are attached. The Board’s focus remains on construction site erosion control. The signatories continue to find value in the Charter for the exchange of technical information and ideas. They value the single point of contact within each entity. They appreciate the ability to affect change whether in a product, a technique or regulatory standard. The Charter signatories and our regular attendees are sincere in their efforts to influence not only the local erosion control and stormwater management standards but statewide standards to improve water quality. The Charters’ standards are being accepted by others and have proven to perform better than other currently accepted practices. This year, GTCWI’s efforts included: signatories’ outreach. the annual compliance inspection of construction sites that shows signatories’ sites in compliance more often than non-signatories. multiple discussions on chlorides affecting area groundwater and use reductions. the media-filled tubular geotextile review. the Fall/Winter terrace cover pilot. the continued commitment to the permeable surfaces test plot maintenance and research NOI processing times. 1. Mission Statement Reassessment, 2017 Goals Progress Assessment and Establishment of 2018 Goals In the process of Charter renewal and at our annual review, the signatories agreed that the mission statement remain the same. It was agreed that the Signatories would continue the goal reflecting the groundwater conservation, energy conservation, air emissions and recycling as they relate to the

Upload: others

Post on 09-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

1

Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative Charter

2017 Annual Report

The Charter

The Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative (GTCWI) is a charter authorized under the laws of the State

Wisconsin, Act 276, sections 299.83 and 299.85 Wisconsin Statutes. The GTCWI was formally signed

by all parties on February 9th, 2006 and renewed in 2011 and 2016 by unanimous agreement of the

signatories.

Mission Statement

The mission of this Charter is to cause a meaningful reduction, beyond current state standards, in the

sediment and nutrient delivery to lakes, streams, and wetlands in Dane County resulting from land

disturbing activities and to develop alternative approaches and practices that will result in better erosions

control and long-term stormwater management. Furthermore, the mission is to explore new business and

regulatory practices that result in improved regulatory certainty for Charter Participants and increased

regulatory efficiency by regulatory agencies.

The Charter Signatories will explore the development of practices that minimize the environmental

impact of developments. This effort will focus on sustainable practices and will include measures for 1)

conservation of surface water and groundwater; 2) conservation of energy; 3) reduction of air emissions;

and 4) maximizing recycling.

2017 Summary

In 2017, the Charter’s Board of Directors met 8 times – February 9, April 06, May 25, July 6, August 17,

September 28, November 9 and December 21. The agendas from the meetings are attached. The Board’s

focus remains on construction site erosion control.

The signatories continue to find value in the Charter for the exchange of technical information and ideas.

They value the single point of contact within each entity. They appreciate the ability to affect change

whether in a product, a technique or regulatory standard.

The Charter signatories and our regular attendees are sincere in their efforts to influence not only the local

erosion control and stormwater management standards but statewide standards to improve water quality.

The Charters’ standards are being accepted by others and have proven to perform better than other

currently accepted practices. This year, GTCWI’s efforts included:

signatories’ outreach.

the annual compliance inspection of construction sites that shows signatories’ sites in compliance

more often than non-signatories.

multiple discussions on chlorides affecting area groundwater and use reductions.

the media-filled tubular geotextile review.

the Fall/Winter terrace cover pilot.

the continued commitment to the permeable surfaces test plot maintenance and research

NOI processing times.

1. Mission Statement Reassessment, 2017 Goals Progress Assessment and Establishment of 2018

Goals

In the process of Charter renewal and at our annual review, the signatories agreed that the mission

statement remain the same. It was agreed that the Signatories would continue the goal reflecting the

groundwater conservation, energy conservation, air emissions and recycling as they relate to the

2

Charter mission statement but the primary goal is erosion control to improve water quality of our

lakes and streams. Additionally, GTCWI intends to continue most of the 2017 goals into 2018, with a

few modifications.

Goals for 2017:

GOAL 1: Continued outreach to potential new members of the charter. Outreach efforts in 2017

will continue to target specific individuals & municipalities and will include personal invitations to

Board meetings. Grow Charter by one signatory.

2017 Progress: No new signatories were added in 2017 but we continue to attract interested parties

to our meetings and some return on a regular basis. A Department of Safety and Professional

Services’ Unified Dwelling Code staff and the City of Fitchburg’s Environmental Project Engineer

were frequent attendees.

GOAL 2: Complete annual inspections comparing compliance between sites of Charter members

and non-Charter members.

2017 Progress:

3

Completed. The results show that GTCWI signatories’ sites have better erosion control than non-

members.

Total Sites Inspected 21

Number of Green Tier Sites 12

Number of Non‐Green Tier Sites 9

Overall Lot‐Level Ratings

Adequate: 68%

Inadequate: 32%

Green Tier Overall Lot‐level Rating

Adequate: 100%

Inadequate: 0%

Non‐ Green Tier Overall Lot‐level Rating

Adequate: 22%

Inadequate: 78%

GOAL 3: Participate in educational seminar(s) or webinar(s) of BMPs for a professional audience.

2017 Progress: GTCWI signatories participated in a number of educational seminars including:

Vegetated Swale Technical Standard Committee

Waterways News letter

Saltwise partner

Rain Garden Construction Workshop

Sennet Elementary School - Rain Garden Construction

Elvhjem Elementary school- Rain Garden Construction

Permeable Surfaces Tour- MaMSWAP

Draft DNR Leaf Guidance was released based on the USGS, City of Madison Leaf Study

results.

GOAL 4: Continue discussion on how the Charter group can provide a greater focus on all of the

objectives defined in the mission statement (energy conservation, air emissions, recycling, etc.).

2017 Progress: The Charter signatories continue to identify and implement ways to improve their

energy conservation, air emissions and recycling. This goal wasn’t an agenda item this year but

occasionally the subject matter is incorporated into other issues. For example, the City of Madison is

now using LED lights for arterial street and has a solar installation program.

GOAL 5: Signatories will tour a construction site to view stormwater management and erosion

control practices; and a business associated with these practices.

2017 Progress: The signatories toured construction sites during the annual compliance monitoring

and visited the pervious surfaces test plot.

GOAL 6: Improve the products and practices that the signatories use through continued involvement

in development and piloting of new standards or practices.

a. Signatories will continue to support and participate in the Permeable Pavement Technical

Standards Council and on-site study.

2017 Progress: The permeable surface test plot was reconstructed in 2017. A tour of 9 sites in Dane

County was held on ( 6/27/2017). 30 people participated in the tour.

4

Bill Selbig of the USGS discusses the test plot and results. Then a water truck showed the pavement

in action.

b. Evaluate the piloted Fall terrace practices for winter and spring construction.

2017 Progress: Veridian Homes developed and GTCWI signatories are piloting and evaluating new

practices that are installed in the Fall so that while construction continue in the winter, winter and

spring runoff will not increase. Evaluation continues. The practice appears to be successful.

The pilot consists of placing rock in the terrace. Contractors accessing the site drive over the

‘tracking pad’. The terrace also catches runoff from the lot.

Additionally, signatories also participate in the Vegetated Swale and Exit Control technical standards

committees and on-site studies.

GOAL 7: Maintain open communication related to adaptive management issues and explore areas

for cross coordination.

2017 Progress: Signatories are participating in a number of different adaptive management/cross

coordination issues including Yahara WINs (Watershed Improvement Network), the Rock River

Coalition’s stream monitoring and the Clean Lakes Alliance Community Board.

5

GOAL 8: Review and modify the combined Municipality/DNR 30 Waterways and Stormwater

Permitting for GTCWI signatories.

2017 Progress: No progress was made on this goal. Appendix 6 describes a process that has never

been implemented. For several years, DNR’s Stormwater Program staff and the Waterway and

Wetland Program staff have been giving signatories’ applications priority for quicker processing.

Goals for 2018

GOAL 1: Continued outreach to potential new members of the charter. Outreach efforts in 2018

will continue to target specific individuals & municipalities and Organization and will include

personal invitations to Board meetings. Grow Charter by one signatory.

GOAL 2: Complete annual inspections comparing compliance between sites of Charter members

and non-Charter members.

GOAL 3: Participate in educational seminar(s) or webinar(s) of BMPs for a professional audience.

GOAL 4: Continue discussion on how the Charter group can provide a greater focus on all of the

objectives defined in the mission statement (energy conservation, air emissions, recycling, etc.).

GOAL 5: Signatories will tour a construction site to view stormwater management and erosion

control practices; and/or a business associated with these practices.

GOAL 6: Improve the products and practices that the signatories use through continued involvement

in development and piloting of new standards or practices.

a. Signatories will continue to support and participate in the Permeable Pavement Technical

Standards Council and on-site study.

b. Review and make recommendations to the manufacturers of framed inlet protection bags.

c. Evaluate the piloted Fall terrace practices for winter/spring construction.

GOAL 7: Maintain open communication related to adaptive management issues and explore areas

for cross coordination.

GOAL 8: Review and modify the combined Municipality/DNR Chapter 30 Waterways and

Stormwater Permitting for GTCWI signatories.

2. Assessment of Charter agreement

The signatories renewed the Charter in 2016. The current Charter is on the website.

3. Assessment of Appendixes

The signatories reviewed and updated the Appendices in 2016. Appendix 6 needs to be modified to

meet the signatories’ needs as well as being able to be implemented by DNR staff.

4. Assessment of Board operating procedures

a. Chairperson election – Jeremy Balousek, Dane County and Phil Gaebler, City of Madison, will be

the Board Co-Chairs for 2018.

b. Frequency of meetings – The Board agreed to continue to meet at the frequency of every six

weeks on Thursday mornings.

6

5. Recommendations to the Department for improvement

Our Charter continues to recommend that Green Tier should be available to and encouraged in all

state agencies. We have made this recommendation several times before and still feel it is valid.

7

ATTACHMENTS:

Meeting Agendas

o February 9, 2017

o April 06, 2017

o May 25, 2017

o July 06, 2017

o August 17, 2017

o September 28, 2017

o November 09, 2017

o December 21, 2017

8

Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative Board MeetingThursday, November 9, 2017, 8:30 a.m.

Hosted by: City of MadisonTraining Room, 1602 Emil Street, Madison

----- Minutes -----

Attendance: Lisa Ashenbrenner Hunt, Daniel Olivares, Lyle Updike, Gary Danz, Elliott Mergen, Chris Homburg, Phil Gaebler, Eric Rortvedt, Bill Balke, Nadine Resler, Kristie Kasbohm, Lenny Kanter, Jeremy Balousek

DNR Excavator/Contractor Training – Lisa Ashenbrenner HuntSmall business hotline 855.889.3021○[email protected]

Board Member Reports – AllSun Prairie ­ not present○DNR

Webinar on SOC Standard 1002 ­ Site Evaluation in DecemberNASECA contractor trainingRevision to USLE spreadsheet and user guideArtificial wetland regulations ­ working on simplifying

HomburgVery busy, starting new jobs

VeridianPouring concrete is over todayBusiness in good. Inventory is way down.Interest rate forecasted to remain stable through 2020New phases coming online. New property in Milwaukee.

MadisonContractors starting without permitsUsing a lot of TRM vs rip rapMonroe Street ­ use framed inlet protectionTracking issues in October

Dane CountyPermit numbers on par with 2016, projects much largerPushing framed inlet protection

Green Tier Meeting 11-9-17

As­built certification formLakes and Watershed Commission

Most of budget going towards the jailUWQGSaltwise Program

DSPSOnline submittal system for residential permitsNew rules for rural primitive hunting cabinMove to Hill Farms in July 2018

OthersFitchburgNASECA WI

Tracking Grates for Site Access ­ SOC Tech standard on construction exits ­Chris

Consensus to install new grates as part of Green Tier as pilot○Cross Hill and Congress apartments installed○Language to be changed from entrance to exit, may not require for entrance.

Recap of Annual Site Audit ­ All•

Next Meeting: December 21st, 2017 hosted by DNR•

For next meeting:Procedure for adding new members○Update on tracking grates and construction exits○Annual Site Audit○Annual Report/2018 Goals○

Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative Board MeetingThursday, February 9, 2017, 8:30 a.m.

Hosted by: Veridian Homes6801 South Towne Drive, Madison

­­­­­ Minutes ­­­­­

Attendance: Tom Veith, Carla Fischer, Chris Homburg, Mike Hackel, Holly Powell, Cory Horton, Gary Danz, Scott Kerr, Josh Harder, Phil Gaebler, Christal Campbell, Jeremy Balousek, Rick Eilertson, Wendy Peich, Eric Rortvedt

Board Member Reports – AllSun Prairie

Daryl has retired. Short staffed, trying to get bids out○Hiring combo DPW/City Engineer○Big project is Menards, started grading work.○Streamlining EC inspection form and process○

o

HomburgVery busy this year, fewer bidders on projects○Tough winter for EC compliance○Prices will be increasing this year○

o

FitchburgRick has left for AECOM○Working with Dane County○

o

VeridianUp 19% over last year (on pace for 500 homes this year)○Opened up lots in Cross Plains○Increases in Milwaukee market○Also a tough winter for EC controls○Test site with stone in terrace is performing very well○Staffing ­ having a hard time with framing contractors○

o

MadisonPermits are up○Weather is making EC controls fail○Having quite a few wet basements○Next phase of Thousand Oaks is only plat level○Royster has great control by digging large hole.○Street projects are about to be bid, earlier than normal.○

o

Dane CountyMost permits that have ever seen.○Working with Fitchburg○

o

Green Tier Meeting 2-9-17Thursday, February 09, 2017 8:30 AM

Tenney Dam work○Engineer position○Infiltration TAC○

MAMSWaP Permeable Pavement Workshop – Christal CampbellLooking to host workshop/field trip in JuneoWould like charter to partneroTarget audience would be municipal staff and consultantsoConsensus is to partnero

Possible City of Verona membership and case study – Rick Eilertson, AECOMWould like to have one point of contact, especially for current projectoTalking to DPW and mayor about joining charter.o

Charter Operating ProceduresJeremy and/or Phil will facilitate the meetings.oWho will develop and send out agendas ­ Jeremy and PhiloDo we want minutes/notes ­ JeremyoEric Rortvedt is now Single Point of Contact for DNRoWho will write the annual report ­ Phil oAre there other administrative functions that need to be covered ­ not at this time.o

2016 Annual Report –AllGet any last minute revisions to Phil by February 24th.oDue March 1 to Laurel Sukupo

Waterway/Wetland Permitting Legislative Changes – Wendy PeichNo actual Legislative changesoDormant wetland guidance changesoApplies only to projects that stalled due to recession in 2008 and 2009oDoes not take away DNR jurisdiction or permitting authorityoGP may be in the works to address dormant sites (next meeting)oDocument make be found at: http://dnr.wi.gov/news/input/documents/guidance/DormantWetlandsGuidanceFinal.pdf

o

ASNRI designation has been modified to remove blanket designation for Yahara River and Lakeso

Next Meeting: Thursday, March 23, 2017, 8:30 am oCity of Sun Prairie, 300 E. Main Street, Sun Prairieo

Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative Board MeetingThursday, May 25, 2017 8:30 a.m.

Hosted by: Dane County5201 Fen Oak Drive, Madison, Conference Room AB

----- Minutes -----

Attendance: Daniel Olivares, Tom Vieth, Lyle Updike, Gary Danz, Christal Campbell, Elliott Mergen, Josh Harder, Chris Homburg, Phil Gaebler, Lenny Kanter, Andrew Homburg

Board Member Reports – AllSun Prairie

Hired a "Director of Public Services" ­ Tom is now what Daryl did.Large commercial projects underway ­ working on permit issues

Lakes and Watershed CommissionStormwater TAC ­ joint meeting with LWC and CARPCSaltwise Project ­ application rates

HomburgRain and weather have been tough ­ soil is saturatedHave good crew so labor hasn't been as much of a struggle.Lots of work out there.Bidding wars on homes ­ people putting themselves in bad positions without contingencies

VeridianStruggling with escrow work ­ 2+ weeks behind right now.Plat work is all behind due to weather (wet spring)Had busiest first quarter ever ­ starting to lose some sales due to wait time. No home inventory right now.Test site with stone in terrace is performing very wellStaffing ­ having a hard time with framing contractorsLumber tariffs from Canada (30% and can't get it even if you want to buy it)Predict demand will be strong into the future ­ price is going up fast

MadisonThousand Oaks ­ building Watts Rd.Woods Farm ­ eastside near Hwy 30 and I90

Dane CountySame permit numbers as last yearFitchburg contractTenney Dam workEngineer position ­ Elliott MergenInfiltration TAC ­ link to report on CARPC website: http://www.capitalarearpc.org/wp­content/uploads/2017/05/StormwaterTAC_Report_Final_May2017_COMPLETE.pdf

Green Tier Meeting 5-25-17Wednesday, May 24, 2017 3:18 PM

DSPSUDC person is moving on (worked for 11 months)Hope they can hire soon

Verona Membership ­ Jeremy will make contact•

Permeable Pavement Tour: June 27th8­noon, may be a little longer○Joint tour with MAMSWaP○Homburg will make a water truck available.○

Erosion Control Reporting Improvements/streamliningCity of Madison working on submitting of photos for sites for self reporting○Homburg used a proprietary software for DOA site ­ Plan Grid○

"Construction Site Soil Loss and Sediment Discharge Calculation Guidance" Seeking Public comments until June 7th.

Tech Standard 1002 ­ Site Evaluation: Review coming soon•

Next meeting: July 6th at Sun Prairie•

For next meeting:Native vegetated mats ­ bioretention pilots•

7/6/2017 8:30 AM

Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative Board Meeting Thursday, July 6, 2017 8:30 a.m.

Hosted by: Sun Prairie 300 E. Main Street, Sun Prairie

‐‐‐‐‐ Agenda ‐‐‐‐‐

Attendance: Adam Schleicher, Tom Vieth, Lyle Updike, Gary Danz, Elliott Mergen, Chris Homburg, Phil Gaebler, Mike Hackel, Eric Rortvedt, Holly Powell • Board Member Reports – All

o Sun Prairie Adam Schleicher, Director of Public Services Looking to hire erosion control staff - very busy with commercial

projects and capital projects Looking for way to do mobile inspections

o Homburg Contractors Took a long time to find good staff Busy with road projects Waiting on several large projects Lots of work available right now, opportunities to bid

o Veridian Homes Struggling to get escrow work done due to wet weather Lot development is behind due to weather Out of lots, not much selection, so sales are down. Have found some good hires

o Madison No new plats for a month Garver Feed Mill Project Doing work to catch up after last week's 10 year storm

o Dane County Permits have leveled off - about the same as last year Large increase in impervious surfaces over 2016 Kevin Connors retirement, July 20th open house, see Attachment

o Lakes and Watershed Commission

Looking into Infiltration TAC implementation Meet with executive committee tonight

o Fitchburg Lots of redevelopment Big demand for single family lots About to do outfall inspection

o DNR Slightly above permitting over last year (11 county area) Evaluation of MS4's this year - Sun Prairie Positions have been frozen (Sue Josheff and Greg Serle positions)

• Verona Membership - Jeremy

• Permeable Pavement Tour: Recap – Jeremy and Phil

• Erosion Control Reporting Improvements/streamlining - Phil

• Tech Standard 1002 - Site Evaluation for Infiltration: Review - Jeremy and Eric

o Requires pits over borings o Mounding analysis requirement o Method for compacted soils o Method for existing swales o Published standard this fall

• Native vegetated mats - bioretention pilots – Elliott and Jeremy

o Question about infiltration rate through mat o Different seed mixes available o $35 sq.yd.

• Topics for next meeting?

o NVM o Tech Standard 1002 o Western Tech College virtual tour? o Filter Tech Standard, Construction Entrance

Next Meeting: August 17th, 2017 hosted by Homburg at Monona State Bank

Green Tier Clear Waters Initiative Board MeetingThursday, August 17, 2017, 8:30 a.m.

Hosted by: Homburg at Monona State Bank­ 6430 Bridge Road

----- Meeting Minutes -----

Attendance: Daniel Olivares, Lyle Updike, Gary Danz, Elliott Mergen, Chris Homburg, Phil Gaebler, Mike Hackel, Eric Rortvedt, Holly Powell, Cory Horton, Rick Eilertson, Nadine Resler, Jose Maria, Scott Kerr

Board Member Reports – AllSun Prairie○Homburg Contractors

Rain has been a challengeJust finished Crossfit GamesWaiting on permits for other projectsResidential development is briskNew cyclonic cleaner test at permeability test plots ­ Excellent resultsSOC Tech standard on construction entrances

Veridian HomesNow caught up on escrow workVisiting builder from Kansas City3x spending on erosion control this year

MadisonRain has been a challenge for EC practicesDaniel Olivares ­ erosion control inspector for City EngineeringScott has moved to traffic engineering ­ Nadine Resler has taken his duties.Changes to Building Inspection

Dane CountyPermits have leveled offTenney Locks completeLYRT set to open Labor Day weekend

Lakes and Watershed CommissionBudget resolutions finalizedSupports programs

Legacy Sediment□Salt Wise□

Green Tier Meeting 8-17-17

Joint work group on stormwater □Fitchburg

Lots of plat workHaving a lot of issues with soil boring/drilling rigs and dewateringAbout to do outfall inspection

DNRSalt storage for WSOR ­ 2 acres under tarpsPermits are up from last year

NWM and Western Tech College Photo Tour•

Erosion Control Tour:Date: 9/30 in 2016.○Sites

Get locations to Phil by September 15th.○

Artificial Wetland ExemptionOpportunity for Green Tier Members to Screen for exemption?○

"Construction Site Soil Loss and Sediment Discharge Calculation Guidance" •http://dnr.wi.gov/news/input/documents/guidance/USLEGuidance.pdf

Tech Standard 1002:•http://dnr.wi.gov/news/input/documents/guidance/TS1002Draft.pdf

Comment period has closed.•Looking at changes based on comments•

Next meeting: September 28, 2017•Hosted by: Tour

For next meeting:SOC Tech standard on construction entrances○NVM for bioretention basins for 2018○Agrecol for future meetings ­ Matt Weber○Artificial Wetland Exemption ­ Eric will talk to Cami○

Dane Co. Permeable Pavement Tour – June 27th, 2017

SMALL ACTIONS MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE

Promega Corp. da Vinci Building- 5511 Bjorksten Place, Fitchburg Promega’s da Vinci building in Fitchburg was completed in early 2014. The building houses the tools and personnel needed to provide facility services to Promega’s main campus and branches. The project included two areas of permeable pavers (see photo). Permeable pavers were chosen instead of pervious concrete or porous asphalt primarily because of aesthetics. The da Vinci project was primarily a redevelopment project, but included some new impervious areas. The site is within the watershed of a regional, public stormwater management facility, but the regional facility does not provide full treatment for new impervious, specifically it does not provide 80% sediment removal. The regional facility does provide the required treatment for redevelopment standards. Permeable pavement was used to reduce the amount of new impervious area added to the site so that stormwater management requirements for new development were not triggered, just redevelopment standards. The permeable paver design included a bedding course directly under the pavers, a layer of AASHTO No. 57 stone over a minimum 6” layer of AASHTO No. 2 Stone subbase. The design included an underdrain as well as a 2’ deep storage layer under the underdrain. During installation of the eastern area of permeable pavers, the landscape contractor inadvertently used a sand filler which became impervious when exposed to water. The contractor had to chisel out the impervious filler and reinstall the correct filler material. The permeable pavers have not required maintenance to date. According to Promega personnel, the pavers have been holding up and performing very well.

Permeable paversPermeable pavers

Fearings Audio- 722 Walsh Rd., Madison Permeable asphalt is located on east and west side of the building. Permeable was used to meet stormwater requirements, but also allowed contractor to flatten out grade on east side of building. The design meets current permeable pavement standards. It’s a heavily used site installed about 3 years ago. Owner performs regular maintenance including: vacuuming, washing, leaf blowing and sweeping. Permeable asphalt used on left side of picture (left) and drive, parking on right is on standard asphalt. The photo to the right was taken during an intense rain event.

Permeable Pavement Test Site- Sycamore Ave., Madison USGS is currently leading a study to measure performance of permeable pavement. The study site was built in the summer of 2014 adjacent to the overflow parking lot serving the Madison Streets Division East Office on Sycamore Rd. The study area is split equally into three smaller study plots, each receiving similar volumes of runoff from the adjacent parking lot. These plots test three types of pavement: permeable pavers, permeable concrete, and permeable asphalt. Each plot is equipped with instrumentation to measure reductions in runoff volume (water quantity) and pollutants (water quality). Both the concrete and the pavers were replaced during the summer of 2016. Maintenance was also performed using a street cleaner in April 2016. The study is scheduled to continue through 2018. For more information visit https://www.usgs.gov/science/evaluating-potential-benefits-permeable-pavement-quantity-and-quality-stormwater-runoff?qt-science_center_objects=1#qt-science_center_objects

Quarry Vista Porous Asphalt Path- Fitchrona and Lacy Rd., Fitchburg (adjacent to Elan Apartments) The Quarry Vista plat Phase 1 improvements included approximately 825 lineal feet of porous asphalt multi-use path and 240 lineal feet of standard (impermeable) asphalt path, adjacent to Lacy Road and Fitchrona Road rights of way, around the south and west sides of the Elan Apartment site. The paths were installed in September, 2016. Porous asphalt was chosen to be consistent with the other public multi-use paths within the plat, which are asphalt per Fitchburg standards. Permeable pavement was used to meet stormwater management requirements because of the difficulty of routing the runoff from the path to a stormwater facility for treatment. The design included 3” of porous asphalt over a 12” minimum open graded base storage reservoir. It did not include an underdrain. The original design included porous asphalt for the entire length along Lacy Road. Prior to construction, steeper areas were reevaluated and changed to standard (impermeable) asphalt to minimize concerns over sub-base preparation.

Lexus Dealership - 8000 Airport Rd., Middleton Permeable asphalt was installed in 2005 on the north side of the dealership prior to any permeable pavement standards. The project includes a 4’-5’ deep aggregate storage layer with drain tile below the pavement. Little maintenance has been done on the site other than normal lot cleaning. Surface condition is fair and the permeable pavement is still performing though at a reduced level of efficiency. The photo on the right was taken during a moderate storm event.

City of Fitchburg Library- 5530 Lacy Rd, Fitchburg Permeable asphalt was installed in spring of 2010 on the west side of the library off Research Park Dr. To date the City of Fitchburg hasn’t done much maintenance except for sweeping aggregate that has been coming off. City staff report that the permeable asphalt is still performing, but not holding up well. During the winter months maintenance staff clear snow off with a broom as it does not hold up to the snow plow.

SMALL ACTIONS MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE

Pre-cast permeable concrete sidewalk - Southwest Madison The City of Madison installed a 75 foot section of pre-cast permeable concrete sidewalk with underdrain in an area on southwest the corner of Pilgrim and Homestead Rd. that was prone to flooding. Pre-cast (RePlenish by Spancrete) was chosen in an effort to eliminate the variability of traditional concrete installation. The pre-cast was installed in fall 2016 as a trial in only a few hours and city staff report that there hasn’t been flooding issues at this location since.

Stricker Park Basketball Courts- 7605 Voss Parkway, Middleton Permeable asphalt was initially installed on the right basketball court only at Stricker Park to try and reduce cracking that was common at this site with traditional asphalt. Permeable was installed around 2010 directly over the old courts. City staff report that the permeable held up so well that they eventually decided to replace the left basketball court with permeable several years later (2014). This is the only site on the tour where permeable was not selected specifically for its infiltration properties.