green procurement index health (gpih) phase 1 - 2015 project report

32
2012 © UNICEF/Olivier Asselin GREEN PROCUREMENT INDEX HEALTH (GPIH) PHASE 1 | 2015 PROJECT REPORT

DESCRIPTION

The document explains the challenge of measuring green health procurement and describes what the UNDP, with the generous support from the Government of Denmark and UNDP Innovation Facility, has done to improve the transparency of procurement in the health sector with regard to its environmental impact, and encourage UN agencies and their suppliers / manufacturers to produce, procure and supply in a more environmentally friendly manner in 2015.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

2012

© U

NIC

EF/O

livie

r Ass

elin

GREEN PROCUREMENT INDEX HEALTH (GPIH)

PHASE 1 | 2015 PROJECT REPORT

Page 2: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

2016 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 | 2015 Project R eportAll rights reserved ©2016 UNDPMarch 2016 UNDP Istanbul Regional HubChristoph Hamelmann, SPHS CoordinatorMirjana Milić, SPHS Associate CoordinatorIgnacio Sanchez Diaz, Greening Health Systems SpecialistAlessandra Blasi, Communications Specialist

The content, analysis, opinions and policy recommendations contained in this publication do not necessarily reflect the viewsof the United Nations Development Programme.

saving lives sustainably

Page 3: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

3Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

2011 ©UNICEF/UNI122548/Brian Sokol

This project has been developed and implemented with the generous support from the Government ofDenmark.

Following the development of the GPIH Roadmap in 2014 (project phase 0), this report outlines key achievements in 2015 to implement components from phase 1 of the GPIH Roadmap.

Page 4: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

co-designing through a multi-stakeholder approach dissemination and

utilisation of knowledge

end-users involvement

innovative cross-cutting natureaddressing sustainability across various fields including public health, environment and procurement

collaboration to share and learn

Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) | UNDP

use open innovationopening the door to innovation, behavioural change and engagement, knowledge building, innovation drive, risk management

design for scale

Page 5: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

1. Challenge of Measuring Green Health Procurement

2. GPIH Roadmap as a Framework Solution

3. Focus Areas of Work 4. 2015 I GPIH Roadmap Phase 1: Implementation of Key Components

4.1 Supplier and Manufacturer Engagement Strategy on Green Health Procurement 4.2 Strengthening Communication 4.2.1 Creation of a Visual Identity 4.2.2 Importance of Social Media Channels 4.2.3 Building an Online Engagement Platform on Green Health Procurement

4.3 Key Venues of Engagement 4.4 Capacity Building on Greening Supply Chains with Suppliers and Manufacturers 4.4.1 Renewable Energy Supply Chains and Energy Efficiency 4.4.2 Wastewater Treatments: Focus on Hazardous Substances 4.4.3 Green Site Visit to Herlev Hospital 4.4.4 Wastewater as a Resource

4.5 Towards a Green Procurement Index Health: Cutting Edge Technical Innovations 4.5.1 Standardization and Harmonization of Environmental Questionnaires for Suppliers and Manufacturers 4.5.2 Monitoring Health Procurement Compliance with International Environmental Conventions

5. Lessons Learnt

6. Next Steps - Further Innovations and Scale Up

end-users involvement

5

CONTENT

7

8

10

12

121213 1416

182021212224

26

26

28

30

31

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 6: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

6

Page 7: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

The healthcare sector is providing an indispensable service to the general public, and therefore plays a crucial role in human development. Sustainable health procurement can play a major role in lowering the environmental burden caused by the health sector, contributing to inclusive green economies with the aim to improve human health and well-being in the context of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).

The range of environmental risk caused by medical products is numerous. By following the maxim of medical ethics primum non nocere (first do no harm) the introduction of green procurement criteria and the monitoring of green procurement practices are important instruments to leverage the purchasing power for the greening of the health sector.

However, more work is required to specify and harmonize green procurement criteria and to develop monitoring tools that enable continuous improvement and benchmarking of green procurement practices. The Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) project is aiming to address these challenges. The project is one of UNDP’s contributions to the informal Interagency Task Team on Sustainable Procurement in the Health Sector (SPHS). The members of the SPHS are UNDP, UNEP, UNFPA, UNHCR, UNICEF, UNOPS, WHO, Gavi, The Global Fund and UNITAID. Their combined annual health procurement volume is approximately US $ 5 billion per year.

72012 © GAVI/Sala Lewis

1. CHALLENGE OF MEASURING GREEN HEALTH PROCUREMENT

“Only through measuring and monitoring our own green procurement practice will we demonstrate that commitment is followed by action.”

Christoph HamelmannUNDP, SPHS Coordinator

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 8: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

8 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

2. GPIH ROADMAP AS A FRAMEWORK SOLUTION

Phase 0 | Development of the GPIH RoadmapUNDP developed a GPIH Roadmap in collaboration with members of the SPHS and the SPHS network of global leaders and experts (see graphic on p. 9). The Roadmap outlines key processes, stakeholders and deliverables for a successful measuring, monitoring, and fostering of green health procurement practices. Three key objectives were introduced:

• Suggest a set of green procurement criteria to SPHS members

• Encourage interested SPHS members and their suppliers and manufacturers to strive towards more environmentally friendly products, production and procurement practices in the health sector

• Develop and implement a tool that measures and monitors status and progress of green procurement practices.

Due to the complexity of the project, the Roadmap is designed in a pragmatic way following a “launch-and-adjust” innovation process. This design allows for the expedited implementation of green procurement practices to meet the objectives of the project. Considering the milestones set, a largely parallel multi-tasking process was suggested that also allows for continuous feedback loops and therefore engagement of all stakeholders.

Phase 1 | Engagement with key health stakeholders and Implementation of Green Health ProcurementIn collaboration with other SPHS members, UNDP has focused on the following key components of the Roadmap during Phase 1 in 2015:

• Development of a Supplier and Manufacturer Engagement Strategy on Green Health Procurement (see p. 12)

• Development of an Online Engagement Platform on Green Health Procurement (www.savinglivesustainably.org - see p. 16)

• Engagement with key stakeholders from the global health aid market (particularly with suppliers and manufacturers) on green health procurement, through various national, regional and international events (see p. 18)

• Organisation of Environmental Capacity Development Sessions on Greening Supply Chains (see p. 20)

• Standardization and harmonization of environmental questionnaire for suppliers and manufacturers (see p. 26)

• Development of a pilot guide on Monitoring Health Procurement Compliance with International Environmental Conventions on Chemicals (see p. 28).

Page 9: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

9

Supported by: The UN informal Interagency Task Team on Sustainable Procurement in the Health Sector (SPHS) was established in 2012, with the aim to facilitate and coordinate the introduction of sustainable procurement practices in the global health aid market.

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

THE GREEN PROCUREMENT INDEX HEALTH ROADMAP

Page 10: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

3. FOCUS AREAS OF WORK towards green procurement

10 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

Page 11: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

With the overall mandate of promoting sustainable procurement in the global health aid market, members of the SPHS have put a particular focus on the environmental footprint of large-volume purchasing in 2015.

Efforts on the introduction of sustainable procurement policies and practices to strengthen health systems are particularly targeting nine focus areas of intervention, as listed below.

ensure safe management of hazardous chemicals and promote safer alternatives

support energy efficiency, and generation of renewable and alternative energy

incorporate sustainable principles into the production/management of medical products

ensure safe and environmentally-friendly packaging and eco-innovative solutions

promote sustainable procurement practicesin purchasing health products and services

foster saving and recycling habitsto improve efficiency of resources

promote low-carbon transportation systems and technologies, reduce carbon emissions

enhance environmentally sound practices in the treatment of healthcare waste

minimize water consumption and support greener wastewater treatment

Why do these key focus areas deserve our attention and how does the SPHS act on them?

11Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 12: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

4.1 SUPPLIER AND MANUFACTURER ENGAGEMENT STRATEGY ON GREEN PROCUREMENT

In collaboration with members of the SPHS, UNDP is developing an Engagement Strategy with Suppliers and Manufacturers on Green Procurement, addressing:• Product focus

Identification and prioritization of different products and product categories

• Key environmental dimensions Focus on greenhouse gas emissions (GHG); resource depletion: water, energy and material consumption; chemical pollution

• Benefits of greening the supply chainDevelopment of a B2B business case for suppliers and manufacturers and outline of benefits for engaging in a process of greening the supply chain

• Fair-playEnforcement of key principles for a transparent and inclusive approach, which acknowledges suppliers’ and manufacturers’ different starting points in introducing environmental safeguarding practices

• Sound communication Identification of best approaches to engage with suppliers and manufacturers including addressing any concerns, mainly through the development of an online engagement platform

• Implementation of the strategyPriority-setting for the implementation of the Engagement Strategy, including the key milestones.

12 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

4.2 STRENGTHENING COMMUNICATIONS

In line with the GPIH Roadmap, a well-defined communications approach was developed.

UNDP has:

• Broadened the global awareness on sustainable procurement in the health sector

• Engaged with key audiences (donors, suppliers and manufacturers, media, SPHS stakeholders)

• Created brand recognition and knowledge products.

By taking this communication approach, UNDP has achieved the following key milestones envisaged in the GPIH Roadmap:

4. 2015 | GPIH ROADMAP PHASE 1: IMPLEMENTATION OF KEY COMPONENTS

Initial development of an interactive online engagement platform that serves as a knowledge-hub of best practices to facilitate dialogue and information sharing (read more on page 16).

Raised visibility of UNDP’s and interested SPHS members’ work on green procurement, through the creation of a new visual identity that provides recognizability, including a set of guidelines, layouts, and advocacy/visibility products (see the examples of first of a series of postcards on p. 13).

Page 13: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

13

We hope you will enjoy our renewed site!

The United Nations informal Interagency Task Team on Sustainable Procurement in the Health Sector (iIATT-SPHS) facilitates and coordinates the introduction of inclusive and sustainable procurement policies and practices, to promote sustainability of the global health aid market.

ABOUTTHE

SPHS

savinglivesustainably.org

The SPHS website now has afresh new look and user-friendly browsing experience, updated with the latest information about the linkages between health and environment, and news about our work on sustainable procurement in the health sector.

Share your knowledge and best practices at:If you have any questions, comments orsuggestions please send them our way

saving livessustainably

4.2.1. Creation of a visual identity

2011

©U

NIC

EF/U

NI1

2254

8/Br

ian

Soko

l

savinglivesustainably.org

SM

A

NGOsTT

MHFI

PM

UN

The United Nations informal Interagency Task Team on Sustainable Procurement in the Health Sector (iIATT-SPHS) facilitates and coordinates the introduction of green and inclusive procurement policies and practices, to promote sustainability of the global health aid market.

WATER

MEDICAL PRODUCTS

TRANSPORTATION

PROCUREMENT

CHEMICALS

WASTE MANAGEMENT

RESOURCE EFFICIENCY

UN agencies

policymakers

PACKAGING

ENERGY

suppliers and manufacturers

think tanks

publicaudience

multilateral health �nancing institutions

PA

academia

savinglivesustainably.org

saving livessustainably

If you have any questions, comments orsuggestions please send them our way

2013

© G

AVI/R

oman

a M

anpr

eet

savinglivesustainably.org

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 14: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

14 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

@GreenProcIndex has built a community interested in the topic by tweeting about recent developments on sustainable healthcare procurement and environmental issues.

Among the @GreenProcIndex followers are members of the SPHS, healthcare procurement professionals, intergovernmental and nongovernmental organizations, pharmaceutical corporations, think tanks, global leaders and technical experts. UNDP Administrator Helen Clark is a follower of the @GreenProcIndex, and shows her interest by regularly retweeting and liking the content. The leadership of other UNDP bureaus (BPPS, BERA, BMS and RBEC) are also actively engaged through the Twitter account. Cihan Sultanoğlu, UN Assistant Secretary-General and UNDP Director of the Regional Bureau for Europe and the CIS regularly interacts with the @GreenProcIndex, as well as Kristian Jensen, Minister for Foreign Affairs of Denmark.

OUR FOLLOWERS:

From January 2015 to December 2015, the GPIH Twitter account @GreenProcIndex

has increased its followers by 1170%.

From January to December 2015, monthly tweet impressions increased from 283 to 58.9K

4.2.2 imPortanCe of soCial media Channels

Page 15: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

15

@GreenProcIndex

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 16: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

Interested in getting engaged? See where/how Through an interactive world map, we are bringing to you ours

and our partners’ key projects and events around the world.

Learning and working together have never been easier. Explore

what you can do page and act to change the global health

sector with us.

Networking has never been easierWe provide you with a list of worldwide events, throughout the

year. With an easy overview of key events related to greening

the global health sector, you can now meet, network and start

exciting projects, with experts from diverse fields. Find out more

on our event calendar page.

Global leaders’ perspectives are just one click awayWould you like to read front-runners’ views on sustainability,

health and environment? We’ve created news & stories page.

Navigating between stories and interviews is easy and finding

more content that appeals to you is just a click, swipe or tap

away.

Contact us to learn more Get in touch with us and explore different opportunities on how

we can collaborate to foster the introduction of eco-innovative

products and processes in the global health sector. The future

starts now and you should be a part of it.

16 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

4.2.3 Building an online engagement Platform on green health ProCurement

UNDP’s ability to introduce green health procurement is linked to engaging with the key stakeholders from the global health aid market. Through a multi-stakeholder approach and in line with the GPIH Roadmap, UNDP has initiated the development of an online engagement platform, engaging the SPHS members, global leaders and top experts.

SPHS - a must-know abbreviation in the global health aid marketIf you are eager to learn more, share your knowledge and engage

on greening the global health sector - you have already heard

of us. You can now easily find key facts about us, our mission,

objectives, and partners we bring together on who we are page.

Saving Lives Sustainably. Wondering how? UN agencies and multilateral health financing institutions are

working together to lower the environmental burden of their

procurement practices. We share best knowledge and practice-

examples, implement projects, organize trainings, and much

more. All of these are now waiting for you at what we do page.

Best practice examples on greening the health sector - in one placeLet your interests be your guide. On our knowledge & practice

page you will find key focus areas, and many examples of best

knowledge and practice which are shared by us, by our suppliers

and manufacturers, and by our global network of experts. Share

your story today.

Page 17: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

17

Welcome to savinglivesustainably.org

to our NewsFlash! Get unlimited access to stories on how we work to change the global health aid market.Join us today at http://eepurl.com/bq8Lez

SUBSCRIBE

We’ve designed our web experience with you in mind.

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 18: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

28th-30th October 2015 G7 Alliance on Resource Efficiency, International G7 Workshop on Industrial SymbiosisBirmingham, UK

9th November 2015SPHS Brown Bag LunchOne UN Plaza, New York, USAhttp://bit.ly/1NFEz0P

26th November 2015 UN Global Supplier Meeting UN City, Copenhagen, Denmark1. “The SPHS Capacity Building Sessions”: http://bit.ly/1lLnzLN2. “Energy Session” : http://bit.ly/1OfvcBj3. “Water and Pharmaceuticals”: http://bit.ly/1M0xoe5

10th -11th December 2015 The IPC (The Interagency Pharmaceutical Coordination group) Meeting Geneva, Switzerland http://bit.ly/1NDjILI

4.3 KEY VENUES OF ENGAGEMENT

In 2015, the GPIH was presented in meetings, workshops, and events worldwide. The Government of Denmark and the UNDP Innovation Facility were highlighted as funding partners of the initiative. The major events are listed below:

15th April 2015 Environmental Safeguarding of Global Health InitiativesThe Global Fund Geneva, Switzerland http://bit.ly/1O0hkec

20th - 21st July 2015 SAICM International Conference on Chemicals Management (ICCM) preparation meeting on Pharmaceuticals in the Environment Geneva, Switzerland

28th September 2015 UNEP Webinar: Presenting the United Nations Initiative on Sustainable Procurement in the Health Sector 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZERWULED7A2. http://bit.ly/1YERGDh

30th September - 2nd October 2015 FIP World Congress of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences Düsseldorf, Germany http://bit.ly/1MTI6qU

18 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

27 EVENTS

12 COUNTRIES

3,469 CONTACTS

Page 19: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

19

VENUES OF ENGAGEMENT

ANTWERP, BELGIUMBANGKOK, THAILANDBIRMINGHAM, UK

COPENHAGEN, DENMARKDÜSSELDORF, GERMANY GENEVA, SWITZERLAND

GOA, INDIAISPRA, ITALYNEW YORK, USA

PARIS, FRANCEWASHINGTON, USAWINDHOEK, NAMIBIA

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 20: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

20 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

4.4. CAPACITY BUILDING ON GREENING SUPPLY CHAINS WITH SUPPLIERS AND MANUFACTURERS

WHO, UNICEF and UNFPA traditionally organize annual meetings with suppliers and manufacturers of medical products, known as the UN Global Supplier Meeting. In collaboration with UNEP, UNFPA and the SPHS Secretariat, UNDP organized two capacity building sessions on water and energy at the 2015 annual meeting which gathered over 400 companies from around the world.

Suppliers and manufacturers shared their opinion about what are the key challenges and opportunities related to greening their supply chains. Putting the focus on energy and water, they discussed with keynote speakers and organizers, which are the benefits of green production and green products, and concrete steps of implementation.

2015 © UNDP/Wilfred Gachau

KEY BENEFITS through the lenses of UN suppliers:

• Reduction in the level of environmental pollution• Reduction in cost of production• Compliance with environmental requirements• Increased productivity• More competitive positioning on the market• Better place to live in, with the improvement of

environmental health

KEY PARTNERSHIPS with:

B2B BUSINESS CASE for eco-innovation:

• The SPHS Task Team on eco-innovative business cases• Suppliers’ base and potential customers • Other businesses to collectively invest in greener

supply chains

Based on the initial interest and positive feedback from the UN suppliers and manufacturers and technical experts, UNDP in collaboration with the SPHS Secretariat will develop business to business (B2B) service offerings for product and process innovation, leading to greening health procurement of UN entities and businesses.

Page 21: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

21

4.4.2 WasteWater treatments: foCus on hazardous suBstanCes

Given the importance of wastewater treatment, including the potential savings from an efficient use of water, experts on hazardous substances in the environment shared experiences about dealing with wastewater management in the health sector. Presenting practical cases, participants were shown how to measure and verify removal of hazardous substances from their production process and the available technology. Estimates of data and calculations on treatment costs were discussed, offering participants practical guidance on how to treat wastewater and additionally save resources through an efficient treatment and use of water.

Nicolai Schaaf, Programme Officer at SIWI, delivered a presentation on re-vectoring and recovering high value water at the water-energy-chemicals nexus, and explained SIWI’s approach to wastewater and pharmaceuticals in the water (further information is available on p. 24).

4.4.1 reneWaBle energy suPPly Chains and energy effiCienCy

The capacity building session on renewable energy and energy efficiency focused on the benefits resulting from switching to renewable energy supply chains. The key note speeches and panel discussion concentrated on how to reduce the dependency on fossil fuels, by increasing renewable energy sources and improving energy efficiency in the production process.

Many cases and best practices were presented, such as UNEP’s business case for eco-innovation. Success stories on energy efficiency were delivered by representatives of Energimidt, the Danish multi-utility energy company, and Kenergy, the Danish energy efficiency consulting and engineering company (see link to the presentations on p.18).

A high number of participants engaged with the panel, proposing potential ideas for implementation at country level, as well discussing barriers and opportunities of switching to renewable energy sources.

photos: 2015 © UNDP/Wilfred Gachau

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 22: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

4.4.3. green site visit to herlev hosPital

Under the inclusive engagement process of the global supplier and manufacturer community as outlined in the GPIH Roadmap, UNDP and UNFPA, with the support of the SPHS Secretariat, organized a green visit to Herlev Hospital in the Capital Region of Denmark.

As part of a public-private innovation partnership, Herlev Hospital has commissioned an entirely new purification plant that uses advanced technology to eliminate medicinal products and bacteria from wastewater.

Participating suppliers and manufacturers expressed great interest and positive feedback on the visit, as the practice can be applied to their own facilities, offering them many benefits by not only purifying the water and returning it clean to the nature, but also reusing it in their facilities for different purposes.

2015 © UNDP/Wilfred Gachau

22 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

https://www.flickr.com/photos/un_sphs

SEE MORE PHOTOS AT:

www.savinglivesustainably.org

SEE OTHER BEST PRACTICES AT:

Page 23: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

23Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 24: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

2010

© -

UN

AM

ID/A

lber

t Gon

zale

z Fa

rran

24

4.4.4 WasteWater as a resourCe

Interview with Nicolai Schaaf, Programme OfficerStockholm International Water Institute (SIWI)UN Supplier Meeting, 26 November 2015UN City, Copenhagen, Denmark

What is SIWI’s key message in working on greener wastewater treatment?To see it as a resource rather than waste. We tend to forget that wastewater contains significant amounts of resources that we failed to utilize. In an industrial process, wastewater containing chemicals and heat can be recovered, in turn helping reducing the need to source these resources from outside the system.

What are the investments needed and the return of such investments for introducing sustainable measures to reduce water consumption and improve wastewater quality?They vary significantly. It would only be safe to say that in several places there could be practices that cost almost nothing and hence have very high returns of investments. This is what is called low hanging fruits. But as you move closer to having harvested all low hanging fruits, the efforts and investments increase to get similar or even lower returns.

IMPORTANCE OF WATER IN GREEN PROCUREMENTthrough the lenses of the United Nations

Globally, clean water is a critical but limited resource essential to sustaining human health and the environment in general. United Nations agencies are committed to work towards minimizing water consumption and water pollution to maximize access to clean water in all regions. Through green procurement criteria which take into account water consumption procurers in the health sector can make a difference by saving lives sustainably.

Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

Page 25: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

Are there enough incentives or support from governments?Governments provide incentive and support in many forms. One of the best incentives is strict execution of existing regulations; the more the non-compliant actors get penalized, the more compliant actors feel that they are on the right track. This might even inspire non-compliant actors to become compliant too.

What type of intervention did you put in place that has been the most helpful to reduce water pollution?It has been to identify the value of water, such as seeing not only the cost for procuring the water - say from groundwater or surface water sources - but from looking at it as a cost carrier, and how reducing water in processes decreases cost associated with several other resources like electricity, heat and process chemicals.

What would be the interests and benefits for SIWI of engaging with the United Nations on the promotion of sustainable procurement practices?Looking into the water related challenges of supply chains is an exciting opportunity to help the United Nations in their mission of “Greening the Blue”. Green public procurement is not only about reduced environmental impacts in the own field of activity. It gives a signal to the market with a normative authority that no private actor has. Developing tools and criteria is a service to the private sector who might be hesitant to go ahead under an unclear regulatory umbrella.

25

Pharmaceuticals are a good example for this. Rolling out our experience in industrial water management with voluntary suppliers to the United Nations would be a thrilling mutual learning experience with a potentially huge impact.

How does strengthening the cooperation among suppliers, international actors, policy makers and end-users, increase engagement on water issues and more sustainable processes in the supply systems?Cooperation and communication have been among our strongest pillars for achieving success. Once these fundamental principles are in place, they spur innovation at all levels. One very important lesson for us has been that in many cases, a single actor or a partnership between the “usual suspects” will not bring the solution. It takes a lot more engagement from distinct and sometimes uncomfortable actors that leads to possible change.

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

“Green public procurement is not only about reduced environmental impacts in one’s own field of activity. It gives a signal to the market with a normative authority that no private actor has.”

Nicolai Schaaf, Programme OfficerStockholm International Water Institute (SIWI)

Page 26: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

4.5 TOWARDS A GREEN PROCUREMENT INDEX HEALTH: CUTTING EDGE TECHNICAL INNOVATIONS

As outlined in the GPIH Roadmap, UNDP has initiated the development of green procurement criteria and data collection on suppliers’ environmental performance. These activities have been undertaken with the support of technical experts as envisioned in the Roadmap (see the GPIH Roadmap on p. 9) through the working groups A (development of GPIH green procurement criteria) and B (data collection, processing, publication and implementation). As a result, UNDP developed an environmental questionnaire for the evaluation of suppliers and manufacturers and a pilot guide on monitoring healthcare procurement compliance with International environmental Conventions (see more on p. 28).

26 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

4.5.1 standardization and harmonization of the environmental Questionnaire for suPPliers and manufaCturers

A good number of environmental standards and assessment tools are currently available for a broad range of products. During 2015, UNDP has developed a standardized questionnaire on green procurement to assess the environmental performance of its suppliers and manufacturers. On a broader level, this questionnaire can be used by any of the SPHS members or public procurers in the health sector.

It is based on international standards, Global Compact principles, Global Reporting indicators and existing and well-accepted environmental scorecards and questionnaires from other national and international organizations.

The questionnaire has been developed with the support of technical experts putting an emphasis on key SPHS focus areas (e.g. chemicals, energy, packaging, water). This process has ensured the acceptance and recognition of the questionnaire as a key data collection tool by the SPHS partners and stakeholders.

The information collected through the questionnaire will be used for the development of environmental profiles of suppliers and of green procurement criteria. Consequently, these data will also be used for the further development of the GPIH.

Page 27: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

• Environmental sustainability best practices • GHG emissions and other hazardous emissions • Water and wastewater management • Energy management

• Product details• Resources Consumption

• Chemicals and hazardous substances management • Hazardous and non-hazardous waste management• Packaging

27

Environmental sustainability best practices

GHG emissions

Water and wastewater

Energy

Waste

Chemicals andhazardous substances

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Environmental Profile of Supplier A

2. PRODUCTION LEVEL*

Packaging

10 - 7

6 - 4

3 - 0

Scores:

* In this section, answers must cover

supplier and subcontractor performance

3. PRODUCT LEVEL

4. FINAL COMMENTS

QUESTIONNAIRE OVERVIEW

1. CONTACT DETAILS

• Packaging• Chemicals and hazardous substances management

Page 28: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

4.5.2 monitoring healthCare ProCurement ComPlianCe With international environmental Conventions

As UN and multilateral global health financing agencies, all members of the SPHS have a particular responsibility to ensure that their procurements in the health sector are compliant with international conventions and principles. This can also be regarded as a critical component for the GPIH.

In 2015, UNDP has developed a pilot guide for monitoring and evaluating the compliance of health procurement with International environmental Conventions on chemicals. This novel and unique tool has the following components:

• brief introductions to all Conventions listed above and highlights key aspects to be considered from a procurement perspective

• a practical checklist, indicators and guidance

Indicators proposed as part of this guide are intended to serve as a building block of the GPIH and the compliance with International environmental Conventions might be considered as one of the pillars for the development of the Index.

In the pilot, the tool has been proven to be easy to use for procurers, to serve as benchmarking of important components of green procurement practices and to trigger targeted action for further improvements.

28 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

• Minamata Convention on Mercury

• Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer and the Montreal Protocol on Substances That Deplete the Ozone Layer M 3.1 The product is free of any substances that deplete the ozone layer included in the Annexes of the Vienna Convention

• Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal

• Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade M 5.1 The product is free of any banned or severely restricted chemicals or severely hazardous pesticides formulations included in the Annex III of the Rotterdam Convention

• Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs)

M 1.1 The product is free or does not generate any Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) included in any of the Annexes (A, B or C) of the Stockholm Convention

M 2.1 The product is free of mercury

M 4.1 The supplier has proven that disposal and treatment of hazardous waste is done by an approved site or facility

Page 29: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

29

The statistics provided on this dashboard are a sample model, and do not represent UNDP’s compliance with International Conventions.

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

63%5%

11%

21%

%ofprocurements

Yes

AnnexA

AnnexB

AnnexC72%

9%

7%12%

%ofprocurementvolume

Yes

AnnexA

AnnexB

AnnexC

87%

13%

%ofprocurements

Yes

No

79%

21%

%ofprocurementvolume

Yes

No

80%

20%

%ofprocurements

Yes

No 55%45%

%ofprocurementvolume

Yes

No

61%

39%

%ofprocurements

Yes

No70%

30%

%ofprocurementvolume

Yes

No

91%

9%%ofprocurements

Yes

No

95%

5%

%ofprocurementvolume

Yes

No

M 4.1 The supplier has proven that disposal and treatment of hazardous waste is done by an approved site or facility

AUTOMATED REPORT DASHBOARD

Page 30: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

30 Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH)

• The engagement of end-users (procurement practitioners, suppliers and manufacturers) raises awareness and encourages these users to improve their environmental performance.

• The co-design process with technical experts and suppliers and manufacturers ensures harmonization and standardization of tools, as well as enhances commitment of these stakeholders towards introducing sustainable procurement practices.

• A clear concept and agreement on what will constitute the key components and indicators of the Green Procurement Index Health is a process that requires broad engagement of technical experts and and the development of partnerships.

• Data availability is crucial for successful development and use of indicators.

• Indicators must be well-defined, and questions precise, to avoid the collection of unnecessary information, raise of operations costs and time invested in data processing.

• The Supplier Environmental Questionnaire and the monitoring tool for the healthcare procurement compliance with international environmental conventions are critical components for green procurement practices and the further development of the Green Procurement Index Health.

5. LESSONS LEARNT

Page 31: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

How to scale up

• Intensification of engagement with suppliers and manufacturers on green procurement, through various national, regional and international events

• Strengthening of institutional relationships with key stakeholders from the global health aid market and leading international media channels to ensure further scale-up of GPIH project activities, as well as regular communications on key work-streams under the GPIH project

• Introduction of the Healthcare Procurement Compliance with International Environmental Conventions in the regular procurement processes within the UN-system and beyond in other public procurement organizations

• Strengthening of the national health systems capacities by introducing environmental safeguarding policies and practices

• Strengthening capacities of local suppliers and manufacturers of health commodities, through collaboration with national governments and offering assistance in the process of developing tailored to their needs and interests, environmental safeguarding policies.

31

6. NEXT STEPS - FURTHER INNOVATIONS AND SCALE UPInnovations in our pipeline

• Development of a B2B business case for eco-innovation in the health sector: Building on our focus areas, UNDP and other SPHS members will develop services offerings for product and prosess innovations which bring together our global network of technical experts as service providers for suppliers and manufacturers leading to greening health procurements and heath systems and contributing to inclusive green economies.

• Development of an online environmental assessment tool to process data collected through the supplier environmental questionnaire, and evaluate and monitor environmental performance of suppliers and manufacturers. This tool will offer feedback to suppliers and manufacturers on their score, and detailed and visual insight to the UN procurement practitioners that can be used in the procurement processes

• Further improvement of the online engagement platform (www.savinglivesustainably.org) to share knowledge among the SPHS members and key stakeholders from the global health aid market, to ensure the acceptance and successful introduction of sustainable procurement practices

• Development of guidelines and technical tools, and implementation of pilots, to support the further development of components of the GPIH.

Phase 1 | 2015 Project Report

Page 32: Green Procurement Index Health (GPIH) Phase 1 - 2015 Project Report

for further information, please contact:

Dr. Christoph HamelmannSPHS [email protected]

Mirjana MilićSPHS Associate [email protected]

www.savinglivesustainably.org