geothermal&hydrogen energy
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
1/19
2011
Salma Ikbarieh
05/10/11
[Hydrogen and Geothermal
Energy]
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
2/19
Page 2
Table of Contents
Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 3
Geothermal Energy ............................................................................................................. 4
Geothermal resources...................................................................................................... 5
Hydrothermal (natural steam reservoirs) .................................................................... 5
Geopressured reservoirs .............................................................................................. 6
Geothermal gradients .................................................................................................. 6
Molten magma ............................................................................................................ 7
Environmental impact ..................................................................................................... 7
Depletion of resources ................................................................................................ 7
Damage to natural geothermal features ...................................................................... 7
Subsidence .................................................................................................................. 7
Polluting waterways .................................................................................................... 8
Air emissions .............................................................................................................. 8
Advantages and Disadvantages ....................................................................................... 8
Advantages:................................................................................................................. 8
Disadvantages (challenges): ........................................................................................ 9
Uses ............................................................................................................................... 10
Hydrogen Energy .............................................................................................................. 12
Resources and Uses....................................................................................................... 12
Hydrogen Fuel Cells ..................................................................................................... 13
Advantages and Disadvantages ..................................................................................... 14
Advantages ................................................................................................................ 14
Disadvantages ........................................................................................................... 14
Environmental Impacts of Hydrogen power ................................................................. 15
Applications .................................................................................................................. 16
Hydrogen Power- UAE ................................................................................................. 16
Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 17
Works Cited ...................................................................................................................... 18
Table of Figures ................................................................................................................ 19
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
3/19
Page 3
Introduction
Our population and technology development are increasing, and as long as they
both increase our demand on energy increases. This vast demand that is increasing
rapidly caused a lot of problem to our universe. Steps towards better technology are
faced by steps backwards because of the global warming. Do we need to make
choice or there is a way out? The answer is no. Then what is the solution for that?
Will scientists and researchers gathered there effort trying to find a solution. Part of
the solution was in finding an alternative methods and sources to generate energy.
Two of those sources are the geothermal energy and the hydrogen energy. This
report is going to discuss each one in depth.
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
4/19
Page 4
Geothermal Energy
Geothermal energy is defined as heat from the Earth (GEA), and the term geothermal
came from a combination of two Greek words: geo, meaning earth and thermal,
meaning heat (Gevorkian, 2010). Geothermal energy is force that: (1) moves
continents, (2) builds mountains, and (3) produce volcanic eruptions. (Nemzer).
At the earth core about 4000 miles deep temperatures might reach more than 5000o C this
tremendous heat flows outward melting huge mass of rocks, the molten rock is called
magma which moves through the cracks carrying the heat. Sometimes this heat appears
above the earth surface as lava. However most of the earth heat remains below the curst
heating up the rocks and the trapped water in the permeable and porous rocks under a
layer of impermeable rock, forming a geothermal reservoir. Moreover sometimes this
trapped water might manifest itself on the surface as geysers, hot springs, etc (GEA;
Gevorkian, 2010; Nemzer)
Figure 1 : Earth core (life in universe)
Electricity from geothermal energy had a modest start in 1904 at Larderello, Italy, with
an experimental 10 kW-generator. Nowadays, it has grown to 8771 MW in 25 countries
producing an estimated 54793 GWh annually. This electricity production serves about
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
5/19
Page 5
1.0% of our planets population. The development of worldwide geothermal power
production can be seen in Figure 2. The sharp drop in the production was caused by the
destruction of the Italian field at the end of World War II. Since WWII, geothermal
power has grown at a rate of 7.0% /yr (Lund, 2008 ) .
Figure 2 : Geothermal power grow rate (Lund, 2008 )
We can generate geothermal energy by drilling deep holes into the earths crust pumping
cold water through one end and then by the time it rises back to the surface the water can
be hundreds of degrees Celsius which we then use as steam to drive a turbine whichdrives a generator creating power. Geothermal energy is one of the best natural energies
available. (Advantages Of Geothermal Energy)
Geothermal resources
Hydrothermal (natural steam reservoirs)
Hydrothermal reservoirs consist of a heat source covered by a permeable formation
through which water circulates. Steam is produced when hot water boils underground and
some of the steam escapes to the surface under pressure. At the surface, once the
impurities and tiny rock particles are removed, the steam is piped directly to the electrical
generating station. These systems are the simplest and cheapest form of geothermal
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
6/19
Page 6
energy. The Geysers, ninety miles north of San Francisco, California, are the most
famous example of this type. The Geysers Geothermal fields are the world's largest
source of geothermal power, according to the Energy Information Administration.
Under some rare geological conditions the pressures in hydrothermal reservoirs are so
low that the water has boiled to steam, as at The Geysers power development. While this
reservoir form is the rarest, it is the easiest and most economical to tap, largely because
there is little corrosion problem and little needs to deal with the large amounts of brine
that must be drawn from and reinjected into a hot water reservoir. It is a very inexpensive
source of electricity, yet its rarity is not likely ever to contribute more than a few
gigawatts of generating capacity to this country.
Geopressured reservoirs
They are deep reservoirs of high pressured hot water which contain a dissolved natural
gas. To have a geopressured reservoir that is economically able to produce energy the
following features have to be included:
(1)A hot geothermal fluid, more than 230oC.(2)Significant methane dissolved in the geothermal fluid, if it contains a natural gas
only the reservoir might be uneconomical.
(3)Significantly thick, permeable, and faulty-bounded high-pressured sand.(4)The energy can be produces without subsidence. (DiPippo, 2008; GEOFAR,
2009)
Geothermal gradients
The internal temperature of the earth increase we go down. An average geothermal
gradient on the surface of the earth is about 25oC, but sometimes the temperature is
higher because of some natural factors as active tectonic forces. However, generally the
geothermal gradient increases 30oC every 1 km depth. Thats why if we drilled shafts
with 6 km deep in hot, dry rocks we will be able to produce a potential commercial
energy. (CliffsNotes; Gevorkian, 2010)
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
7/19
Page 7
Molten magma
This geothermal resource goes directly to the source. The idea is to drill a well into
magma body that is relatively close to the surface of the earth. Then insert an injection
pipe and pump cold water down the well under high pressure. Now the magma supposes
to solidify on a form of glassy material that will eventually crack under the huge thermal
stress that its imposed to. If there is away for the water to return and manifest on the
earth surface then this hot water will be ready to generate energy. Although it seems
simple to explain, using the molten magma as a source of geothermal energy is still a
topic that is under study especially if we are talking about from the economical
investment perspective (DiPippo, 2008).
Environmental impact
Depletion of resources
The extraction of the geothermal fluids, eventually remove the heat from the natural
reservoirs. However we could overcome this imbalance by making the geothermal fluid
run on a closed loop (Stewart, 2009).
Damage to natural geothermal features
Wherever there is geothermal development damage or deterioration on the geothermal
features, such as hot springs and geysers, can easily happen, causing ground sage in some
places, and decline of these geothermal features as the supply of steaming water from
below was depleted (Stewart, 2009).
Subsidence
The Extraction of geothermal fluids can decrease the pressure in underground reservoirs
causing land sinking. This may also put a strain on bores and pipelines, causing damage
in the buildings, roads, and surface patterns. The largest subsidence on record is at
Wairkei; in 2005 the centre of the subsidence bowl sank 14 meters lower than it was
before geothermal power plant was built (Stewart, 2009).
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
8/19
Page 8
Polluting waterways
Geothermal fluids may contain hazardous gases or materials because of the underground
contact between hot fluids and rocks. If waste is released into rivers or lakes damage in
the aquatic life and water will occur making these waterways unsafe for drinking or
irrigation. However we can overcome this problem by injecting the geothermal fluids
back to the geothermal system (Stewart, 2009).
Air emissions
Emissions of greenhouse gases, like CO2 and H2S, could be correlated with the extraction
of geothermal fluids. If these gases reach a certain level, they will jeopardize the health
and the life of people working in the geothermal fields, they can also be a problem in
urban areas. Though, geothermal power plants release far fewer greenhouse gases than
fossil fuels power plants. Moreover; Binary, air-cooled power plants have effectively
zero emissions (Stewart, 2009; GEA).
Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
Little land usageAccording to the U.S. Department of energy geothermal energy use less land space than
fossil fuel and renewable energy sources. Moreover if we compare the land space needed
to produce 1 GWh a coal facility will need an area of 3632m2 while a geothermal facility
will need an area of 404 m2
only. (GEA)
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
9/19
Page 9
Figure 3 : Land use comparison (GEA)
Renewable, Continues reliable energy
This is because the earth heat is a constant source, and the rainwater and snowmelt will
essentially continue feeding the underground thermal aquifers. Furthermore, the
geothermal energy doesnt need geological times for regeneration as fossil fuel reserves
do. (GEA; Gevorkian, 2010)
Benefits local economics
There are many economical benefits from using the geothermal energy such as:
(1)Reducing the healthcare related costs, since the use of geothermal energy willcounterbalance the emissions of NO2 and SO4 from the fossil fuel power plants.
(2)Providing a stable source of employment.(3)Reducing the local energy imports.(4)Producing a cost-competitive power. (GEA)
Low production cost
The power plant generates the energy that it needs to start production by itself. So that, no
fuel will be needed to run the production. Hence costs of purchasing, transporting, and
cleaning up the fuel will be eliminated. (GLA; Advantages Of Geothermal Energy)
Disadvantages (challenges):
Cost of plant insulation
The installation of geothermal plant requires significant expenses such as:
0
500
1000
15002000
2500
3000
3500
4000
coal* Solar
Thermal
wind** geothermal
m2/G
wh
30 YEAR LAND USE COMPARSION
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
10/19
Page 10
(1)Geological and environmental study cost.(2)Heavy and expensive mechanical components costs (example: circulating pumps,
heat exchangers).
(3)Maintenance expenses. (GEA)Engineering and environmental challenges
The geothermal energy technologies insulation, specially the deep penetration-type,
needs significant engineering design and a through environmental study. (Gevorkian,
2010)Hazardous gases
An important disadvantage of geothermal energy is the chances of hazardous gases like
H2S or hazardous materials like NH3 to be released causing environmental pollution,
which is not easy to get rid of. (Kanade) Lifespan and location
The biggest disadvantage of geothermal energy is the big uncertainty over the lifespan of
the project. This uncertainty is because the locations of the easy access to the geothermal
recourses are usually located in areas of volcanoes, and earthquakes. Such location will
eventual jeopardize any geothermal power plants that could be built there, making the
investment on such energy undesirable for investors. (Kanade)
Uses
Geothermal electricity
Geothermal energy generally produces electricity by drilling the wells into a geothermal
reservoir. These wells will carry the geothermal fluid to the earth surface and passing it to
an electrical generator. This conversion process is done at geothermal power plants
(GEA). There are four types of geothermal power plans, which are:- Flashed Steam Plants- Dry Steam Plants- Binary Power Plants- Hybrid Power Plants. (Evans, 2007)
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
11/19
Page 11
Heat uses
Back in the history, geothermal water was used by the Romans for eye and skin treatment
and buildings heating. In addition the medieval wares included fight over lands with hot
springs. Furthermore, for hundreds of years Tuscany, Italy, used natural steam to produce
vegetables in the winter. Geothermal heat is really amassing its free and it can be used
directly in many applications such as:- Air conditioning (heating and cooling)- Food preparation- Balneology (ex. Spas)- Agriculture and greenhouses- Aquaculture- Industrial processes. (Lund, 2008 )
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
12/19
Page 12
Hydrogen Energy
Hydrogen is a colorless gas that is the most available gas in the universe. The hydrogen
atom is made from one atom and one electron only, which makes H2a very light gas. Its
even lighter than the air. However the hydrogen contains an energy that is three times
larger than the energy of the gasoline. (U.S. EIA)
Resources and Uses
Hydrogen is an energy carrier just like the electricity, and just like the electricity
hydrogen can be produced from variety of sources that can be renewable like: solarthermal and biomass, or non-renewable sources like: natural gas and coal. At the same
time hydrogen can be used in transportation, industrial applications, buildings, and the
list can get longer (European Commission, 2003).
There are several ways in which we can produce hydrogen. Two common procedures are
electrolyses and steam reforming. In the electrolyses procedure the water is separated into
oxygen and hydrogen. The procedure is considered to be an expensive procedure, yet its
the best because there are no emissions produced by this procedure. On the other hand
there is the steam reforming procedure which is the least expensive but produces
greenhouse gases. This is because the steam reforming procedure is done by separating
the hydrogen from the methane, CH4 (European Commission, 2003) .
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
13/19
Page 13
Figure 4 : Hydrogen: primary energy sources, energy converters and applications (European Commission,
2003).
Hydrogen Fuel Cells
Hydrogen fuel cells are devices that convert the hydrogen into electricity, water and heat.
Fuel cells operate like the casual batteries, yet it doesnt need electrical recharge. The
question now is: How do these fuel cells work? Will a typical fuel cell is like a sandwich
of five layers. The electrolyte is the middle layer sandwiched between two electrodes
which are sandwiched between two bipolar plates. The hydrogen enters from bipolar
plate that is near the anode. This hydrogen goes through the channels to the anode to be
separated by the catalyst membrane into electrons stream that take an external path as
electricity, and protons that go through until it reach the cathode where it meet back the
electrons. Then the electrons, the protons and the oxygen coming out of the air collide
together forming heat and water as an output of the fuel cell (European Commission,
2003; CHFCA).
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
14/19
Page 14
Figure 5 : Hydrogen fuel cell illustration (European Commission, 2003)
Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages
There are several advantages of hydrogen power. First of all, if we produced the
hydrogen power from a renewable energy source, then we will be able to get a clean
power source. Second, since we are able to produce the hydrogen power from vast variety
of resources, and then hydrogen power can be produced in any country. Third, the
hydrogen power can be produced on site, meaning that it doesnt need to be generated on
somewhere and then to be transferred to somewhere else. An obvious example of that are
the fuel cells. Forth, the hydrogen is safer than gasoline, diesel, and natural gas; yet it can
compete them effectively on the economical side. Last but not the least; hydrogen can
help in maintaining the fossil fuel reserves (AFVTech).
Disadvantages
On the other side of the equation there are some disadvantages of hydrogen power. The
first one is the difficulty in storing and distributing hydrogen. Another one is that
extracting hydrogen might necessitate the bourn of fusel fuels which eventually will emit
greenhouse gases. Moreover the hydrogen power is considered to be the most expensive
power source. Statistics of the U.S. Department of energy show that the cost of hydrogen
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
15/19
Page 15
fuel cell manufacturing in 2002 reached $275/kW and dropped to $51/kW in 2010. This
shows that we are able to overcome the high expense of hydrogen power generation by
the technology development (Hydrogen power; U.S.DOE).
Figure 6 : Cost reduction in hydrogen fuel cell manufacturing (U.S.DOE)
Also there are some disadvantages related to the hydrogen fuel cells. One of them is its
size. The hydrogen fuel cell is big and bulky. Its three times larger than the casual gas
tank. Furthermore, there is a big safety issue related to the hydrogen fuel cell, which is
the probability of it to explode. This explosion might happen because of the ability of the
hydrogen liquid to freeze which eventually will plug up the valve causing a high pressure
and the only release for this pressure is the explosion (Agarwal).
Environmental Impacts of Hydrogen power
Since the hydrogen power generation tends to be from a fossil fuel source, our hydrogen
power generation is contributing in emitting greenhouse gases like CO2 which contribute
in the global warming. Furthermore the hydrogen system if was not designed probably
can release the hydrogen in side it very fast. This released hydrogen can help in
increasing the reaction rate of methane and ozone, making the global warming issue
enlarges ( European Commission DG Environment News Alert Service, 2006).
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
16/19
Page 16
Applications
NASA is considered to be the largest hydrogen power consumer. NASA uses the
hydrogen power in several applications like a fuel to lift the space shuttles, and a source
of drinking water for the space shuttle crew. Hydrogen powered vehicles is another
application, where the hydrogen is used to generate electricity that is going to run the
vehicle motor (U.S. EIA).
Hydrogen Power- UAE
With initial cost of 7 billion dirham Emirati, Masdar and British Petroleum signed acontract to build hydrogen manufacturing power plant that is going to cover 5% of Abu
Dhabi power generation capacity. The project is going to provide from 3000 to 4000
construction jobs during the construction phase and about 100 permanent jobs when the
power plant starts operating. The hydrogen generation will be produced by burning the
natural gas. The generated CO2 which estimated to reach 1.7 million tons is going to be
injected back into the oil field to help in maintain the pressure of the oil field. This
project is going to increase the oil reserved of Abu Dhabi and its expected to finish in
2014, however some recent news says that the project will be delayed (Hydrogen Power
Abu Dhabi (HPAD)).
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
17/19
Page 17
Conclusion
The geothermal energy is a very good power source that needs an excessive research
and technological development to be able to gather its benefits safely. On the other
hand the hydrogen power is a potential power source that would be very efficient ifwe are able to generate it from renewable and clean resources. At the end we can see
that we need a development in the renewable and alternative energy filed that
equals the vast, rapid change in the development of the technology to be able to
adopt those technological development without jeopardizing our environmental
balance.
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
18/19
Page 18
Works Cited
(n.d.). Retrieved from life in universe: www.lifeinuniverse.org
European Commission DG Environment News Alert Service. (2006, October 19).
Environmental Impacts of Hydrogen-based Energy Systems. Science for Environment
policy , p. 1.
Advantages Of Geothermal Energy. (n.d.). Retrieved April 22, 2011, from
http://www.clean-energy-ideas.com
AFVTech. (n.d.).Advantages of Hydrogen. Retrieved May 10, 2011, from Alternative
Fuel Vehicle Technology : http://www.afvtech.com/
Agarwal, A. (n.d.). 3 Great Disadvantages Of Hydrogen Fuel Cells. Retrieved April 25,
2011, from EzineArticles: http://ezinearticles.com
CHFCA. (n.d.). Canadian Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Association. Retrieved May 10, 2011,
from http://www.chfca.ca
CliffsNotes. (n.d.). Geothermal Gradients. Retrieved April 23, 2011, from
http://www.cliffsnotes.comDiPippo, R. (2008). Geothermal Power Plants. Butterworth-Heinemann.
European Commission. (2003). RTD info.Hydrogen Energy and Fuel Cells - A vision of
our future , pp. 10 - 11.
Evans, S. (2007, October 22). The Uses of Geothermal Energy. Retrieved May 10, 2011,
from Green Living Ideas: http://greenlivingideas.com
GEA. (n.d.). Geothermal Energy Association. Retrieved April 16, 2011, from http://geo-
energy.org
GEOFAR. (2009, October 12). GEOPRESSURIZED SYSTEM. Retrieved April 23, 2011,
from energia: http://www.energia.gr/geofar/articlefiles/geothermalinnovative-
geopressurized.pdf
Gevorkian, P. (2010).Alternative Energy Systems in Bulding Design. McGraw-Hill.
GLA. (n.d.).Advantages and Disadvantages of Geothermal Energy. Retrieved April 22,
2011, from http://www.greenlivinganswers.com
Hydrogen power. (n.d.). Retrieved May 10, 2011, from Energy: http://www.odec.ca/
Hydrogen Power Abu Dhabi (HPAD). (n.d.). Retrieved April 25, 2011, from Hydrogen
Power Abu Dhabi: http://www.hydrogenenergy.com
Kanade, S. (n.d.). Geothermal Energy Disadvantages. Retrieved April 22, 2011, from
www.buzzle.com
Lund, J. W. (2008 , January 1). 100 Years of Geothermal Power Production. Geo-HeatCenter Quarterly Bulletin , pp. 12-19.
Nemzer, M. (Director). What is geothermal energy? [Motion Picture]. Tiburo.
Stewart, C. (2009, March 2). Geothermal energy - Effects on the environment. Retrieved
April 22, 2011, from http://www.teara.govt.nz
U.S. EIA. (n.d.).Energy Kids. Retrieved May 8, 2011, from http://www.eia.doe.gov/
-
8/4/2019 Geothermal&Hydrogen Energy
19/19
U.S.DOE. (n.d.).Accomplishments and Progress. Retrieved April 27, 2011, from U.S.
Department of Energy: http://www1.eere.energy.gov
Table of Figures
FIGURE 1:EARTH CORE (LIFE IN UNIVERSE) ........................................................................ 4
FIGURE 2:GEOTHERMAL POWER GROW RATE (LUND,2008) .............................................. 5
FIGURE 3:LAND USE COMPARISON (GEA) .......................................................................... 9
FIGURE 4:HYDROGEN: PRIMARY ENERGY SOURCES, ENERGY CONVERTERS AND
APPLICATIONS (EUROPEAN COMMISSION,2003). ....................................................... 13
FIGURE 5:HYDROGEN FUEL CELL ILLUSTRATION (EUROPEAN COMMISSION,2003) ......... 14FIGURE 6:COST REDUCTION IN HYDROGEN FUEL CELL MANUFACTURING (U.S.DOE) ...... 15