geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf ·...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Solar Energetic Particles (SEP), Solar Modulation and Space Radiation: New Opportunities in the AMS-02 Era
Honolulu, October 2015
Philip von [email protected]
Department of Physics & AstronomyUniversity of Hawai'i at Manoa
http://www.phys.hawaii.edu/~philipvdwww.antideuteron.com
Geomagnetic cutoff Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy simulations for low-energy
cosmic rayscosmic rays
![Page 2: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.2p.
Low-energy antiprotons and antideuterons
factor100
• Low-energy cosmic-ray antiprotons and antideuterons are very interesting probes for new physics → dark matter annihilations or decay
• Antideuterons are the most important unexplored indirect dark matter detection technique!
Giesen et al.arXiv:1504.04276
antiprotons antideuterons
![Page 3: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.3p.
Uncertaintiesmodulation
by solar wind
scattering in magnetic fields,interaction withinterstellar medium
deflection in magnetic field
zoom20GeV proton
proton > 10MeV redelectron > 10MeV green
positron > 10MeV blueneutron > 10MeV turquoise
muon > 10MeV magentaphoton > 10keV yellow
• Dark matter annihilation or decayDark matter annihilation or decay
• Dark matter clumpingDark matter clumping
• Antideuteron productionAntideuteron production
• Galactic propagationGalactic propagation
• Solar modulationSolar modulation
• Geomagnetic deflectionGeomagnetic deflection
• Atmospheric interactionsAtmospheric interactions
• Interactions in detectorInteractions in detector
interactions withatmosphere
![Page 4: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.4p.
Warning
This is work in progress. I highly welcome input.
![Page 5: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.5p.
PLANETOCOSMICSAtmospheric and geomagnetic simulations with PLANETOCOSMICS (Desorgher, Universitaet Bern) based on Geant4:http://cosray.unibe.ch/~laurent/planetocosmics/ [latest version on website from 2006]
● Atmospheric interactions:● updated to Geant 4.9.2 in 2010
→ plan to upgrade to Geant 4.10 soon (light nuclei physics!)● modified code validated with various data sets
→ works very reliably in predicting atmospheric backgrounds
● Cutoff calculations with backtracing● IGRF geomagnetic field (+simplified/earlier models)● added latest IGRF-12 coefficients● just added Tsyganenko 2004
● Backtracing method: Cooke et al., Il Nuovo Cimento 14C, 213, 1991● trajectories of cosmic rays with different rigidities, arriving at the same observing
position and from the same direction of incidence are computed backward in time using the Geant4 tracing of charged particles through magnetic fields
● all cutoff values shown are effective cutoff rigidities Rc
![Page 6: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.6p.
Geomagnetic cutoff
Cu
t-o
ff [
GV
]
vertical cutoff valuesIGRF field only
![Page 7: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.7p.
Cutoff and particle direction
Geomagnetic rigidity cutoff for antiprotons in Hawaii as function of direction
IGRF, TSY2004 140901
![Page 8: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.8p.
Magnetic field lines
IGRF geomagnetic fieldIGRF+Tsyganenko2004 magnetosphere
![Page 9: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.9p.
Tsyganenko 2004 magnetosphere● N. Tsyganenko, J. Geophys. Res. 110,
A03208 (2005)● dynamical data-based model of the inner
magnetosphere, representing its structure and temporal variation during geomagnetic storms
● Parameters: ● tilt angle of geomagnetic dipole● structure of the magnetosphere is influenced by disturbance storm
index (Dst) index and solar wind dynamic pressure Pdyn● By and Bz components of the interplanetary magnetic field
● 6 parameters describing: the total magnetic field composed of the tail field, the Chapman-Ferraro field, symmetrical ring current, the field of a partial ring current, Birkeland current systems, a penetrated component given by an ‘‘interconnection’’ term
● data base of all parameters as a function of time available
http://geo.phys.spbu.ru/~tsyganenko/modeling.html
![Page 10: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.10p.
Time dependence of cutoff: events
19-May-2011
5-December-2011
Red: 0.5GVBlue: 1.0GVMagenta: 1.5GVGreen: 2.0GVCyan: 2.5GV
Reverse computation of antiproton trajectories starting at the same location in the same direction for two different times
→ magnetic environment change changes the trajectories drastically and influences the cutoff values
![Page 11: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.11p.
Geomagnetic cutoff scanningSampling of geomagnetic cutoff behavior for AMS-02 operation
● study of protons and antiprotons● every 200days● as a function of location and direction● use of University of Hawaii HPC
cluster: so far about ~20years of CPU time
Scanning range for cutoffs:● latitude: -90-90° [bin width: 5°]● longitude: 0-360° [bin width: 10°]● zenith:0-90° [bin width: 5°]● azimuth 0-360° [bin width: 10°]
→ create database
Calculate cutoff for AMS-02:● take location from AMS-02 data
[1Hz sampling]● generate isotropic random direction● calculate cutoff for this location and
direction from database by interpolation● only use events cos(zenith) > 0.6
Position occupancy of AMS-02 on the ISS
SAA
![Page 12: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p.
Time dependence of cutoff: maps
proton antiproton
19-May-2011location of rigidity cutoffs of less than 2.5GV
→ differences for protons and antiprotons visible
![Page 13: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.13p.
Time dependence of cutoff: maps
proton antiproton
5-Dec-2011location of rigidity cutoffs of less than 2.5GV
![Page 14: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.14p.
Time dependence of cutoff: maps
proton antiproton
22-June-2012location of rigidity cutoffs of less than 2.5GV
![Page 15: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.15p.
Time dependence of cutoff: maps
proton antiproton
8-January-2013location of rigidity cutoffs of less than 2.5GV
![Page 16: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.16p.
Time dependence of cutoff: maps
proton antiproton
27-July-2013location of rigidity cutoffs of less than 2.5GV
![Page 17: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.17p.
Time dependence of cutoff: maps
proton antiproton
12-February-2014location of rigidity cutoffs of less than 2.5GV
![Page 18: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.18p.
Time dependence of cutoff: maps
proton antiproton
1-September-2014location of rigidity cutoffs of less than 2.5GV
![Page 19: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.19p.
Cutoff efficiency: p and p
19-May-2011
→ differences for protons and antiprotons visible
![Page 20: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.20p.
Cutoff efficiency: p and p
5-December-2011
→ differences for protons and antiprotons are not always in the same direction
![Page 21: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.21p.
Cutoff efficiency: p and p
22-June-2012
![Page 22: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.22p.
Cutoff efficiency: p and p
8-January-2013
![Page 23: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.23p.
Cutoff efficiency: p and p
27-July-2013
![Page 24: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.24p.
Cutoff efficiency: p and p
12-February-2014
![Page 25: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.25p.
Cutoff efficiency: p and p
1-September-2014
→ protons are back below antiprotons
![Page 26: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.26p.
Time dependence of cutoff: efficiencies
~30% TOF
RICH/NaF
RICH/Agl
mass reconstruction ranges for (anti)deuteron analysis
→ no systematic change of cutoff over AMS-02 measurement period
![Page 27: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.27p.
Solar flare event: 7-March-2012Extreme UV flash of X5-class solar flare March 7, 2012. (NASA SDO)
Significant decrease of geomagnetic cutoff
Pdyn
= 5.3nPa, Dipole tilt angle = -0.1633°, Dst = -98nT
interplanetary magnetic field: By = -10.65nT, B
z = -12.53nT
W1=3.65, W
2=4.65, W
3=1.19, W
4=6.45, W
5=3.46, W
6=9.51
![Page 28: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.28p.
Magnetic field changes
x [RE]
y [RE]
z [R
E]
y [RE]
z [R
E]
x [RE]
z [R
E]
z [R
E]
Bz [
nT]
Bz [
nT]
By [
nT]
By [
nT]
5-Dec-11
5-Dec-11
7-March-12
7-March-12
![Page 29: Geomagnetic cutoff simulations for low-energy cosmic raysphilipvd/1510_cutoff_pvd_solar.pdf · AMS-02 on the ISS SAA. P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.12p. Time dependence](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042805/5f648dfdb44e4d087441268d/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
P. von Doetinchem Geomagnetic cutoff Oct 15 – p.29p.
Conclusions
• large-scale simulations using PLANETOCOSMICS with Tsyganenko 2004 were carried out
• geomagnetic cutoff depends on charge sign• geomagnetic cutoff depends on the magnetospheric parameters• during solar flares (like March 7, 2012) a strong decrease of geomagnetic cutoff is
possible
→ study of low-rigidity cosmic rays (~<3GV) certainly requires to use a time dependent geomagnetic cutoff model