general lake presentation
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
1/40
CLEAN-FLO
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
Restoring Lakes, Ponds, Rivers,Reservoirs and Wastewater
Lagoons Worldwide
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
2/40
2007 Lake Savers 2
Why Care About Restoring Water Bodies?
Which lake would you rather ownproperty on?
Swim in?
Invite your friends to?
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
3/40
2007 Lake Savers 3
Agenda
About CLEAN-FLO International
Understanding Restoration Dynamics
Limitations of Conventional TreatmentApproaches
The CLEAN-FLO System
Project Examples Newtown Creek Project
Questions and Discussion
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
4/40
2007 Lake Savers 4
About CLEAN-FLO
To dramatically improve the health
of water bodies.
Mission:
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
5/40
2007 Lake Savers 5
About CLEAN-FLO
The CLEAN-FLO processesbiodegrade bottom organic muck,
reduce weed and algal problems,eliminate odor, improve waterquality and provide healthy waterfor fish growth, health & increasednumbers.
Process:
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
6/40
2007 Lake Savers 6
About CLEAN-FLO
Recreational lake and ponds
Drinking water reservoirs
Municipal & industrial wastewater
Hog, dairy and chicken farmsAquaculture
Swimming beaches
Polluted rivers
Irrigation ponds
Dead end salt water canals
Used in:
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
7/40 2007 Lake Savers 7
Whats the Big Deal AboutPhosphorus?
Most times phosphorus is the limiting
nutrient that controls plant and algaegrowth.
Excess phosphorus means excess algae
and weeds. Excess weeds and algae overwhelm a water
bodys natural self-cleaning/renewal
process.
Water quality diminishes and the water bodybegins to literally die from overfeeding.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
8/40 2007 Lake Savers 8
The Reality
Fact:
Most inland water bodies in developed areas arereceiving more phosphorus than they can handle tostay in balance.
As a result, most water bodies are in a state ofaccelerated Eutrophication a fancy word for anover-fed, dying lake.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
9/40 2007 Lake Savers 9
Sources of Excess Phosphorus
1 Pound of Phosphorus can produce10,000 pounds of wet weeds and algae!
http://www.defiancecohealth.org/sewage.jpghttp://www.scsc.k12.ar.us/2005BlanchardSprings/images/Arnold%20Pictures/Mammoth%20Springs%2005/Canada%20Geese%201.JPG -
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
10/40 2007 Lake Savers 10
Impact: Accelerated Eutrophication
2. Dead algae and
weeds fall to thebottom
3. Decompositiondepletes lake of
oxygen
Decaying weeds and algae
Anaerobic sludge
Lake Bottom
4. Nutrients releasedback into the water
5. New algae bloomand weed growth
1. Nutrients Flow intoLake/Pond Leadingto ExcessiveWeed/Algae Growth
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
11/40 2007 Lake Savers 11
Traditional Management Approaches In Theory
Visible
Problems:
Excessive Weed Growth
Algae Blooms
Accumulation ofMuck/Loss of Depth
Odor
Root
Causes:
Externalnutrient loading
Internal nutrientloading
Oxygen Depletion
Treat thesymptomswithChemicals,
harvesting,drawdown,etc.
WatershedManagement
Dredging
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
12/40 2007 Lake Savers 12
Traditional Management Approaches In Practice
Watershed Management programs are extremelydifficult to implement and enforce withoutgovernment mandate/ordinances.
Dredging is typically too cost prohibitive anddifficult to obtain required permits.
Chemicals and harvesting become the de-factomanagement options to manage the symptoms ofthe problem.
These costs increase over time as root cause isnever adequately addressed.
Beaches are closed because coliform levelscannot be reduced.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
13/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
Lakes Need To Breathe To Be Healthy!!!13
CLEAN-FLO Management Approach
Restore/enhance the natural, self-cleaningmechanism of the water body with the
CLEAN-FLO Process.
Address Internal Loading
Reduce muck
Eliminate odor and gases
Limit external nutrient loading where
possible. Use chemicals/harvesting as a
supplemental tool if necessary.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
14/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
Lakes Need To Breathe To Be Healthy!!!14
The natural processes within a body ofwater begin to breakdown when they arelimited or eliminated by low oxygen levels.
High dissolved oxygen levels at the bottomprevent the release of Phosphorous fromthe sediment (internal loading).
Aerobic organisms are more efficient atdigesting organic material than anaerobicorganisms.
Aerobic organisms assimilate nutrients and
take them out of the system through thefood chain.
Dissolved Oxygen The Key toHealthy Water Bodies
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
15/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
Lakes Need To Breathe To Be Healthy!!!15
The Real Target for Lake Restoration
Rapid Accumulation ofOrganic Muck Caused by
Oxygen Depletion Toxic gases Hydrogen
sulfide, Ammonia, Methane. Disease causing bacteria
fecal coliform, E. coli
Other undesirable organisms swimmers itch parasite,leeches.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
16/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!16
The CLEAN-FLO Process
Improve the water bodys naturalSelf-Cleaning Capability:
Continuous Laminar Flow InversionProcess oxygenates the entire body ofwater significantly reducing nutrient
availability, odor and disease causingbacteria.
Application of naturally occurring
bacteria and enzymes accelerates theaerobic breakdown of organic material(decaying plants and muck).
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
17/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: Exercise Program for Lakes!17
The CLEAN-FLO Process
O2
Aerobic benthic bacteria
break down organics
Nutrients removed
through the food chain
Phosphorus stays
locked in sediment
NOxygenated surfacewater moves to thebottom.
CO2Toxic Gasesremoved
H2S
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
18/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!18
The CLEAN-FLO Process
The CLEAN-FLO approach is NOTa quick-fix.
A combination of strategies may berequired, but improving a water bodysability to breathe is THE KEYto improvingits health.
Every body of water is unique. The mainingredient to success is understandingthe conditions involved and designing the
system to achieve success.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
19/40 2007 Lake Savers 19
Collins LakeScotia, New York
About the Lake
60 acre lake with public beach.
Beach closed for two years due to fecal bacteria issue.
Milfoil and pondweed growth out of control.
Watershed management strategies and herbicide treatment werenot producing adequate results.
Management Program
One-time herbicide treatment formilfoil and pondweed (2006).
CLEAN-FLO System installed inApril of 2006.
CLEAN-FLO bacteria and enzymetreatment applied in July of 2006.
Results
Beach opened in August of 2006,remained open all of 2007.
No significant re-growth of milfoil orpondweed.
Dissolved oxygen maintainedthroughout water column all winterdespite shutting down the system for
3 months.
Noticeable reduction in dead plantmaterial and muck in 2007.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
20/40 2007 Lake Savers20
Collins Lake Before in May 2006
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
21/40 2007 Lake Savers 21
Collins Lake Before in May 2006
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
22/40 2007 Lake Savers 22
Collins Lake After in July 2008
Will L k
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
23/40 2007 Lake Savers 23
Willow LakeKalamazoo, Michigan
About the Lake
7 Acre lake/pond.
Completely over-run with milfoil, filamentous algae, lily pads, andcoontail
Management Program
CLEAN-FLO System installed inJune of 2007.
One-time herbicide treatment formilfoil.
Harvesting program for lilypads.
Bacteria and Enzyme treatmentapplied in July of 2007.
Results
Filamentous algae problemeliminated.
No significant re-growth of milfoil.
Coontail significantly reduced. Lily pads did grow back after
harvesting, however, we are startingto see tubers pop to the surface.
Clear signs of breakdown of organics
in the lake.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
24/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!24
Willow Lake Before Pictures June 18, 2007
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
25/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!25
Willow Lake Before Pictures June 18, 2007
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
26/40 2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!26
Willow Lake Before Pictures June 18, 2007
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
27/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!27
Willow Lake After Pictures June 23, 2007(5 days after installation of the Clean-Flo System)
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
28/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!28
Willow Lake After Pictures June 23, 2007(5 days after installation of the Clean-Flo System)
Willow Lake After Pictures July 6 2007
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
29/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!29
Willow Lake After Pictures July 6, 2007(Herbicide treatment applied on June 27th))
Willow Lake After Pictures July 14 2007
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
30/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!30
Willow Lake After Pictures July 14, 2007(Herbicide treatment applied on June 27th)
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
31/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!31
Willow Lake After Pictures July 14, 2007
Will L k B tt Pi t J l 15 2007
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
32/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!32
Willow Lake Bottom Pictures July 15, 2007(Bottom area not yet impacted by Clean-Flo System)
Willow Lake Bottom Pictures July 15 2007
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
33/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!33
Willow Lake Bottom Pictures July 15, 2007(Bottom area near Diffusers)
Willow Lake Secchi Disk Readings
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
34/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!34
Willow Lake Secchi Disk Readings(An indication of Water Clarity)
April 23, 2007 4+ feet Secchi disk hit bottom,still visible (did not knowlocation of deep hole)
May 15, 2007 3 feet Not clear to bottom maximum depth
June 18, 2007 < 2 feet Lake choked with weeds
and algae
July 6, 2007 6 feet Found the deep hole inthe lake.
July 15, 2007 7+ feet Secchi disk hit bottom,still visible
Date Depth Reading Comments
Cherry Creek Unimproved Area Across the Street from Willow Lake
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
35/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!35
Cherry Creek Unimproved Area Across the Street from Willow LakeJuly 15, 2007
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
36/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!36
Hammonton Lake Project Overview
Background On Hammonton Lake:
65 acre lake located in Hammonton, NJ.
Maximum depth of 12 feet; average depth of 6 feet
Swimming beach was closed for all but 13 days in 2006 dueto high coliform levels (>300/100 ml). Levels alwaysincreased significantly after rain events
CLEAN-FLO designed a program for the entire lake in 2005but was asked to address the beach area first
System installation completed on July 19, 2007
Coliform levels on the 19th were over 500
Daily water sampling was conducted by Hammontonpersonnel starting on July 23rd
Coliform levels were below acceptable limits for 25 of the
first 30 days of operation
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
37/40
2007 CLEAN-FLO
CLEAN-FLO: An Exercise Program for Lakes!37
Hammonton Lake Water Sampling
July 23 180 First test
July 31 1,621 1.5 rain on 7/30
Aug 2 356
Aug 3 185
Aug 4 96
Aug 8 56
Aug 15 60
Aug 19 58 2 rain event in pm
Aug 21 1,400Aug 24 200
Date Coliform Comments
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
38/40
2007 Lake Savers 38
Lake Powai, India
About the Lake
500+ acre lake in India.
Hydrilla and Water Hyacinth had taken over the lake. Lake heavily polluted from watershed
Management Program CLEAN-FLO System installed
with bacteria and enzymetreatment.
Harvesting program initiated toreduce Water Hyacinth.
Results Nutrient levels in the lake reduced
by 90% in the first year.
Hydrilla and Water Hyacinth
reduced to non-nuisance levels. Significant improvement in all
water quality indicators.
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
39/40
2007 Lake Savers 39
Lake Powai, India Results
Clean-Flo system Installed
-
8/3/2019 General Lake Presentation
40/40
CLEAN-FLO system Installed
Lake Powai, India Results