gene expression patterns in myelodyplasia underline the...
TRANSCRIPT
-
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3 137–149 137
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Correspondence: Merav Bar, M.D., Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, 1100 Fairview Ave. N, D1-100, Seattle WA. U.S.A. 98109. Tel: (206)667-4545; Email: [email protected]
Copyright in this article, its metadata, and any supplementary data is held by its author or authors. It is published under the Creative Commons Attribution By licence. For further information go to: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/.
Gene Expression Patterns in Myelodyplasia Underline the Role of Apoptosis and Differentiation in Disease Initiation and ProgressionMerav Bar1, Derek Stirewalt1, Era Pogosova-Agadjanyan1, Vitas Wagner1, Ted Gooley1, Nissa Abbasi1, Ravi Bhatia2, H. Joachim Deeg1 and Jerald Radich11Clinical Research Division, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, Washington. 2City of Hope National Medical Center, Duarte, California.
Abstract: The myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) are clonal stem cell disorders, characterized by ineffective and dysplastic hematopoiesis. The genetic and epigenetic pathways that determine disease stage and progression are largely unknown. In the current study we used gene expression microarray methodology to examine the gene expression differences between normal hematopoietic cells and hematopoietic cells from patients with MDS at different disease stages, using both unselected and CD34+ selected cells. Signifi cant differences between normal and MDS hematopoietic cells were observed for several genes and pathways. Several genes promoting or opposing apoptosis were dysregulated in MDS cases, most notably MCL1 and EPOR. Progression from RA to RAEB(T) was associated with increased expression of several histone genes. In addi-tion, the RAR-RXR pathway, critical for maintaining a balance between self-renewal and differentiation of hematopoietic stem cells, was found to be deregulated in hematopoietic cells from patients with advanced MDS compared to patients with refractory anemia. These fi ndings provide new insights into the understanding of the pathophysiology and progression of MDS, and may guide to new targets for therapy. Taken together with previous published data, the present results also underscore the considerable complexity of the regulation of gene expression in MDS.
Keywords: myelodysplasia, gene expression, apoptosis, differentiation
IntroductionThe myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) are a heterogeneous group of clonal disorders of the hemato-poietic stem cells [1, 2]. The natural history of MDS is that of progressive cytopenia with increasing transfusion needs, infectious and bleeding complications or alternatively, evolution to secondary AML [1, 2]. While relatively simple clinical and pathologic scoring systems with prognostic relevance have been developed, the molecular mechanisms involved in evolution of the disease are largely unknown [3, 4]. Identifying molecular markers of MDS may allow for a more accurate assessment of the prognosis and potentially identify new targets for therapy.
The genetic lesions so far identifi ed in MDS incompletely describe the biology and heterogeneity of the disease. Clonal karyotypic abnormalities are observed in approximately 40–50% of patients with primary MDS, and 90% of therapy-related MDS [2, 5]. Mutations important in denovo AML, for example mutations in RAS proto-oncogenes and FLT3 internal tandem duplications (ITD), have been described in 5%–20% of MDS patients and are variably associated with disease progression [3, 6–9]. Beside overt genetic lesions, epigenetic lesions may also play a roll in the development of MDS. Hyper-methylation has been described in many malignancies including MDS and may be associated with disease development, progression and prognosis [10–14]. For example, p15 promoter hypermethylation has been shown to be associated with MDS progression to AML in some studies [3, 15]. However, none of these alterations are specifi c for MDS and the underlying molecular causes of MDS have remained poorly understood.
The vast number of genetic and epigenetic disturbances in MDS makes investigations to identify potential common pathways that may involved in disease development and progression challenging. Oligonucleotide microarrays have been found to be an excellent tool to study biology and identify potential prognostic factors in many forms of malignancies, including MDS. This platform allows
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
-
138
Bar et al
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
examination of thousands of genes using a single sample. In the current study we used oligonucle-otide microarrays to determine how the genetic expression profi le differs between healthy hema-topoietic cells and hematopoietic cells from patients with MDS, and to identify genes and pathways that might be relevant for MDS evolution and progression.
Materials and Methods
PatientsMononuclear cells (N = 35) or purifi ed CD34+ cells (N = 8) from the marrow of 43 MDS patients were studied. Patients were sub-grouped according to the French-American-British (FAB) classifi ca-tion [16] into refractory anemia (RA, N = 18), refractory anemia with ringed sideroblasts (RARS, N = 11), refractory anemia with excess blasts (RAEB, N = 8), and refractory anemia with excess blasts in transformation (RAEB-t, N = 1). In addi-tion, we included one patient with unclassifi ed MDS, one patient with a mixed MDS/myelopro-liferative picture, and three patients with AML that had evolved from MDS. Three patients had 5q deletion, however not as an isolated lesion, but as part of complex cytogenetic abnormalities. Mono-nuclear (N = 10) or purifi ed CD34+ bone marrow cells (N = 14) from 24 healthy subjects were used as controls. Samples from fi ve normal bone mar-rows, four patients with low grade MDS (RARS or RA), and seven patents with high grade MDS (RAEB-1 or RAEB-2) not used in the microarray studies were used for PCR validation studies of MCL1 expression. Some of the patients had received treatment in the past, including chemo-therapy, erythropoietin or thalidomide, but no treatment was given within 4 weeks of sample acquisition. All patients and healthy donors had given informed consent according to the require-ments of the Institutional Review Board.
Sample preparationHeparinized bone marrow samples were obtained by aspiration from the posterior iliac crest. Mono-nuclear cells were separated by density gradient centrifugation through Ficoll-Hypaque. CD34+ cells were purifi ed by two rounds of high-gradient magnetic cell separation using autoMACS (Milt-enyi Biotec Inc, Auburn, CA) with superparamagnetic
microbead labeling of CD34+ cells. Total RNA was extracted using TRIzol (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA.) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. All RNA samples were analyzed on an HP 2100 bio-analizer (Aglient Technologyies, Palo Alto, CA USA) to ensure the integrity of total RNA prior to use in microarray assays [17].
Oligonucleotide microarray gene expressionRNA obtained from mononuclear cells was pre-pared according to the standard Affymetrix proto-col (GeneChip Expression Analyses Technical Manual (http; //www.affymetrix.com/support/tech-nical/manual/expression_manual.affx). For CD34+ cells, RNA was prepared using a single stranded linear amplifi cation protocol (SLAP) prior to RNA labeling and hybridization [17]. Fragmented, bio-tinylated cDNA was hybridized to an Affymetrix HG-U133 microarray according to the manufac-turer’s protocol.
Data analysisDAT fi les for individual samples were generated using Affymetrix MAS 5.0 software. Target signals for probe sets were scaled to 500 for analyses. The detection algorithm was based upon default set-tings per Affymetrix recommendations (https://www.affymetrix.com/support/downloads/manu-als/data_analysis_fundamentals_manual.pdf).
Signals were transformed into log2 intensity. Normalization was performed using the R 2.2.1 software [18]. The expression data was then ana-lyzed using SAM 2.2.1 (Signifi cance Analysis of Microarrays (SAM), Stanford, CA)[19] or Gene-Plus 1.2 (http://www.enodar.com/technology6.htm) for specifi c gene expression analysis and Gene Set Enrichment Analysis software (GSEA v1.0, Broad Institute, MIT, Cambridge, MA) for pathway analysis [20]. We selected a false discov-ery rate (FDR) of 5% to determine statistically signifi cant up or down regulated genes in SAM [21]. Hierarchical clustering was performed using the dChip software available at http://biosun1.harvard.edu/complab/dchip/.
For the analysis of MCL1 levels and transcript ratio in different MDS disease stages, a global p-value was derived using linear regression and tested in the null hypothesis that the mean tran-script ratios were the same across normal, RA, and
-
139
Gene expression profi les of CD34+ and unselected mononuclear cells in myelodysplasia
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
advanced phase MDS. The signifi cant test for trend used linear regression of the mean of the transcript across each group, where each group was assigned values 1, 2, and 3 for normal, low, and advanced MDS, respectively.
PCR validation of MCL1To validate the gene expression of MCL1 in normal and MDS hematopoesis, we developed quantitative RT-PCR assays. Samples from fi ve normal bone marrows, four patients with low grade MDS (RARS or RA), and seven patents with high grade MDS (RAEB-1 or RAEB-2) not used in the micro-array studies were analyzed. For MCL1, the two alternative splice variants were amplifi ed sepa-rately, producing a full-length transcript (T×1) associated with anti-apoptosis, and the alterna-tively spliced, smaller transcript (T×2) that is pro-apoptotic. Quantitative PCR validation for MCL1 splice variants was performed on an ABI 7900 HT Fast Real-Time PCR System. Thermocycler condi-tions were set at: 50 °C for 2 min, 95 °C for 10 min, and 40 cycles at 95 °C for 15 sec and 60 °C for 1 min. A common primer sequence was used for the forward MCL1 primer (E×1): 5 ’ -GAAGGCGCTGGAGACCTTAC-3’ ) . MCL1-T×1 (MCL1-T×1R) and MCL1-T×2 (MCL1-T×1R) reverse primer sequences were 5’-TTTCCGAAGCATGCCTTGG-3’ and 5’-ACTCCACAAACCCATCCTTGG-3’, respec-tively. All probes were FAM-TAMRA; the MCL-1 probe sequence was 5’-ATGGCGTGCAGCG-CAACCAC-3’. Controls genes were obtained from cloned 2.1 TOPO vector plasmids. The size of the MCL1-T×1 and MCL1-T×2 inserts was 517 bp, and 269 bp respectively.
ResultsTo explore the changes in gene expression that occur with the evolution of MDS from normal hematopoietic progenitor cells and during disease progression from RA to RAEB and transformation into secondary AML, we used two general strate-gies. First, we identifi ed expression changes com-mon to all MDS cases compared to normal bone marrow, and secondly, we examined gene expres-sion in MDS cases that correlated with disease subtypes. Since it is not clear to what extent the biology of MDS is determined only by the malig-nant “stem cell” and what the entire cellular envi-ronment contributes, separate analyses were
performed in unselected and CD34+ selected populations of both MDS and normal hematopoi-etic cells.
Gene expression in MDS compared to normal bone marrowWe fi rst compared unselected marrow mononuclear cells from 35 patients with MDS and 10 healthy donors. Unsupervised hierarchical clustering showed complete segregation between normal bone marrow and MDS marrow (Fig. 1A). How-ever, there was no segregation between the differ-ent morphologic subtypes of MDS (Fig. 1A), underscoring the diffi culty of describing MDS biology by morphology alone.
In comparing all MDS cases to normal bone marrow, 516 genes were up-regulated and 2107 were down-regulated in the MDS samples (Supple-mentary Table 1). The top up-regulated genes in MDS included: the HSPA1A (heat shock 70 kDa protein), CEACAM6 (carcinoembryonic antigen-related cell adhesion), DEFA1/4 (defensin alpha 1 and 4), GFI1 (growth factor independent 1) and TCN1 (transcobalamin 1). Among the top down-regulated genes were CREM (a cAMP responsive element modulator), SC5D (sterol-C5-desaturase (ERG3 delta-5-desaturase homolog, fungal)-like), PIK3R1 (phosphoinositide-3-kinase, regulatory subunit 1 (p85 alpha) and IRF4 (interferon regula-tory factor 4). GSEA analysis was then used to discover annotated biological pathways over-represented by genes that were up or down-regulated in MDS compared to normal bone marrow. The pathways most signifi cantly enriched in abnormally regulated genes in MDS were ves-icle transport, glycogen metabolism, chaperone modulated interferon signaling, and the pentose phosphate pathway.
We next compared gene expression in CD34+ selected cells from MDS and normal bone marrow to examine potential changes occurring primarily in the putative MDS “stem cell”. We identifi ed 704 genes that were up-regulated and 826 genes that were down-regulated in the CD34+ cells from MDS patients compared to CD34+ cells from healthy donors (Supplementary Table 2). In com-paring the genes that differed signifi cantly between unsorted samples and purifi ed CD34+ cells, we observed an overlap of 12 genes that were consis-tently up-regulated in both the unselected and CD34+ selected cells, and 95 genes that were
-
140
Bar et al
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
Tabl
e 1.
Top
gen
es d
iffer
entia
lly e
xpre
ssed
in M
DS
com
pare
d to
nor
mal
bon
e m
arro
w.
Gen
e sy
mbo
leD
escr
iptio
nC
D34
+ ce
lls:
Mon
onuc
lear
cel
ls:
SAM
sc
ore1
Fold
ch
ange
q-va
lue(
%)2
SAM
sc
ore
Fold
ch
ange
q-va
lue(
%)
Up
regu
late
d ge
nes:
MA
XM
AX
pro
tein
5.56
1.67
0.00
2.84
3.28
2.61
PM
Lpr
omye
locy
tic le
ukem
ia4.
652.
670.
213.
614.
391.
52P
NU
TL1
sept
in 5
3.57
4.22
1.63
3.94
3.35
0.75
SH
AP
Yca
lciu
m a
ctiv
ated
nuc
leot
idas
e3.
185.
591.
954.
463.
050.
21M
HC
2TA
MH
C c
lass
II tr
ansa
ctiv
ator
2.90
4.03
2.21
3.77
3.09
1.14
ALD
H3B
1al
dehy
de d
ehyd
roge
nase
3 fa
mily
, m
embe
r B1
2.67
2.15
3.03
4.63
1.85
0.21
CC
L18
chem
okin
e (C
-C m
otif)
liga
nd 1
8 (p
ulm
onar
y an
d ac
tivat
ion-
regu
late
d)2.
6212
.50
3.03
3.87
5.61
0.94
SPA
G8
sper
m a
ssoc
iate
d an
tigen
82.
532.
663.
374.
412.
000.
21Q
PR
Tqu
inol
inat
e ph
osph
orib
osyl
trans
fera
se
(nic
otin
ate-
nucl
eotid
e py
roph
osph
oryl
ase
(car
boxy
latin
g))
2.46
3.59
3.37
3.32
3.01
3.11
LAIR
1le
ukoc
yte-
asso
ciat
ed Ig
-like
rece
ptor
12.
211.
844.
764.
161.
630.
34D
own
regu
late
d ge
nes:
VIP
R1
vaso
activ
e in
test
inal
pep
tide
rece
ptor
1−4
.97
0.18
0.00
−2.6
60.
693.
11S
LC2A
14so
lute
car
rier f
amily
2 (f
acili
tate
d gl
ucos
e tra
nspo
rter)
, mem
ber 1
4−4
.12
0.27
0.00
−2.7
10.
653.
11
MC
L1m
yelo
id c
ell l
euke
mia
seq
uenc
e 1
(BC
L2-r
elat
ed)
−4.0
30.
210.
00−3
.32
0.61
1.14
TNFA
IP3
tum
or n
ecro
sis
fact
or, a
lpha
-indu
ced
prot
ein
3−3
.78
0.18
1.31
−4.5
00.
440.
32
DTN
Ady
stro
brev
in, a
lpha
−3.7
70.
241.
31−2
.47
0.78
4.63
NE
LL2
NE
L-lik
e 2
(chi
cken
) ///
NE
L-lik
e 2
(chi
cken
)−3
.72
0.33
1.31
−3.1
70.
631.
43
EP
OR
eryt
hrop
oiet
in re
cept
or−3
.71
0.35
1.31
−3.1
90.
671.
43K
RTH
B6
kera
tin, h
air,
basi
c, 6
(mon
ileth
rix)
−3.6
60.
371.
31−3
.40
0.79
0.94
CX
CR
4ch
emok
ine
(C-X
-C m
otif)
rece
ptor
4−3
.61
0.31
1.31
−3.8
00.
560.
56ZN
F297
Bzi
nc fi
nger
pro
tein
297
B−3
.56
0.31
1.31
−3.8
10.
500.
561 S
core
—Th
e T—
stat
istic
Val
ue.
2 q-v
alue
—Th
e lo
wes
t fal
se d
isco
very
rate
at w
hich
the
gene
is c
alle
d si
gnifi
cant
(Lik
e th
e “p
val
ue” a
dapt
ed to
ana
lysi
s of
a la
rge
num
ber o
f gen
es).
-
141
Gene expression profi les of CD34+ and unselected mononuclear cells in myelodysplasia
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
consistently down-regulated in both the unselected and CD34+ selected cells (Table 1, full list in Supplementary Table 3). These genes are likely to be highly relevant as markers of biological activity, as well as targets for diagnostic and therapeutic tools. The top overlap genes and their expression in all samples are shown in Figure 1B, 1C and Figure 2. The overlap genes fall into several rel-evant biological categories. Interestingly, many genes were deregulated in favor of increased apop-tosis: decreased expression in the anti-apoptotic regulator MCL1, the erythropoetin receptor EPOR, and TNF anti-apoptotic modulator TNFAIP3, and an increased expression in Ca+2 activated nucleo-tidase CANT1, and the inhibitory receptor LAIR1. There was no association of EPOR level and past use of erythropoetin. Dysregulated immune func-tion and cytokine expression have been implicated
in MDS, and in this analysis are highlighted by the increased expression of the CD4/CD8 cytokine CCL18, the decreased expression of the “master” control gene for class II MHC expression CIITA, and the decreased expression of CXCR4, the recep-tor for stroma derived factor 1.
Gene expression in RA compared to advanced MDSThe signals that lead to progression from RA to more advanced disease are poorly understood. We compared unselected mononuclear cells from 16 patients with RA to unselected mononuclear cells from 11 patients with advanced MDS, again using normal bone marrow as reference. Several genes were expressed differently in normal bone marrow, RA and advanced disease (Table 2, Supplementary
NB
M 1
NB
M 3
NB
M 7
NB
M 4
NB
M 9
NB
M 2
NB
M 5
NB
M 6
NB
M 8
NB
M 1
0R
AEB
2R
A 7
RA
11R
A 3
RA
4R
AEB
6R
AEB
7R
AEB
1R
AEB
TR
A 2
AM
L 2
RA
12R
A 10
RA
RS
3R
AR
S 4
RA
EB 5
MD
Sun
clas
sifie
dR
A 15
RA
1R
A 8
RA
5A
ML
3R
A 14
RA
RS
5R
A 13
RA
EB 4
RA
RS
2R
AR
S 6
RA
16R
AR
S 7
RA
6R
A 9
RA
EB 3
RA
RS
1A
ML
1
NBM MDS
d Genes
ea b c d f Genesg a b c ed Genes
A
CB
Figure 1. A. Hierarchical clustering of 1,000 differentially expressed genes in normal marrow and marrow from MDS patients. Each row represents a single probe set and each column a separated normal or MDS marrow sample. Blue coloring represents down-regulated genes in MDS compared to normal, while red represents up-regulated genes in MDS. Unsupervised hierarchical clustering showed complete segregation between normal bone marrow (n = 10) and MDS (n = 35), but no segregation between the different stages of MDS.B, C. Heat map of up- and down-regulated genes in unselected mononuclear and CD34+ selected cells from MDS marrow and normal marrow samples. B) Comparison of gene expression in unselected mononuclear cells in MDS and normal bone marrow: “a”—nor-mal bone marrow samples; “b”—RA samples; “c”—RARS; “d”—RAEB; “e”—RAEB-t; “f”—unclassifi ed MDS; and “g”—AML cases arising from antecedent MDS. C) Comparison of gene expression in CD34+ selected cells: “a”—normal marrow; “b”—RA; “c”—RARS; “d”—RAEB; and “e”—a case of MDS/MPS (a mixed MDS/myeloproliferative picture).
-
142
Bar et al
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
Table 4). Among these genes are MAX (MYC associated factor X), HIST2H2BE (histone 2, H2be), HIST2H2AA (histone 2, H2aa), HIST1H2BG (histone 1, H2bg) and TNFRSF1A (tumor necrosis factor receptor superfamily, mem-ber 1A) which were increasingly expressed with the evolution of RA from normal bone marrow and with progression from RA to more advanced stages of MDS (Fig. 3). ASGR2 (asialoglycoprotein receptor 2), TGFB1 (transforming growth factor, beta 1) IDH3B (isocitrate dehydrogenase 3 NAD+ beta) and EPB41L3 (erythrocyte membrane pro-tein band 4.1-like 3) were down regulated in RA compared to normal bone marrow, and were further down-regulated in advanced MDS (Fig. 3). We next searched for changes in biological pathways asso-ciated with MDS disease progression. Using the GSEA software we identifi ed statistically signifi -cant enrichment in genes involved in the Rac 1 cell
motility signaling pathway and the RAR-RXR pathway with advanced disease.
Validation studies of MCL1In validation studies (Fig. 4), the expression of both the longer anti-apoptotic transcript (T×1) and the shorter pro-apoptotic transcript (T×2) variants of MCL1 decreased signifi cantly from normal bone marrow to low grade, and high grade MDS (global signifi cance levels of T×1 and T×2 when compar-ing normal, low, and high grade MDS were p = 0.03 and p = 0.007, respectively). Moreover, there was a shift of the ratio of the anti-apoptotic/pro-apoptotic mRNA level in these three states, with a T×1/T×2 of 8.4 for normal bone marrow, 4.8 for low grade MDS, and 2.6 for high grade MDS (global signifi cance p = 0.0008, test of trend p = 0.0001). Thus, MDS and progression of MDS
Expr
essi
on –
Log
2
PML
NBM MDSNBM MDS
QPRT
NBM MDSNBM MDSMononuclear cells CD 34+ cells
Expr
essi
on –
Log
2
EPOR
NBM MDSNBM MDSMononuclear cells CD 34+ cells
Expr
essi
on –
Log
2
MCL1
NBM MDSNBM MDSMononuclear cells CD 34+ cells
Expr
essi
on –
Log
2
CD 34+ cellsMononuclear cells
Figure 2. Expression of genes that were up- or down-regulated in MDS compared to normal bone marrow.Log-2 expression level is shown on the Y axis; samples and cell type are indicated on the X axis. For each one of the four genes shown in this fi gure, the expression of the individual samples (for both unselected mononuclear cells and CD34+ selected cells) are shown. NBM: normal bone marrow.
-
143
Gene expression profi les of CD34+ and unselected mononuclear cells in myelodysplasia
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
were associated with not only a global decline in MCL1 level, but a shift in transcript towards a pro-apoptotic bias.
DiscussionMDS comprises a heterogeneous group of clonal disorders that are characterized by aberrant dif-ferentiation in multiple hematopoietic cell lineages and are thought to involve hematopoietic stem cells [1, 2]. However, there is mounting evidence that the disease process is not entirely stem cell-
autonomous and that signals derived from more differentiated cells, in particular monocytes and T lymphocytes, and from the marrow stroma affect the disease process [22–30]. We, therefore, per-formed an analysis of gene expression in both unselected mononuclear cells and in selected CD34+ cells from MDS marrow in comparison to the analogous cell populations from normal mar-row. Our results identifi ed 2623 genes with expres-sion differences between unselected marrow mononuclear cells from healthy donors and MDS patients and 1530 genes with expression differences
Table 2. Top genes differentially expressed in Advanced Disease (RAEB and RAEBT) compared to RA compared to normal bone marrow.
Gene symbole Gene description Linearslope1
P (linearslope)
Up regulated genes:HIST2H2BE histone 2, H2be 1.16 0.00MAX MAX protein 0.47 0.00HIST2H2AA histone 2, H2aa 1.52 0.00TNFRSF1A tumor necrosis factor receptor superfamily,
member 1A0.83 0.00
HIST1H2BG histone 1, H2bg 1.08 0.00ARHGEF2 rho/rac guanine nucleotide exchange factor
(GEF) 20.37 0.00
SNX19 sorting nexin 19 0.29 0.00C1RL complement component 1,
r subcomponent-like0.87 0.00
H2BFS H2B histone family, member S 1.37 0.01HIST1H2BF histone 1, H2bf 0.97 0.01Down regulated genes:ASGR2 asialoglycoprotein receptor 2 −1.75 0.00RNASE4 ribonuclease, RNase A family, 4 −1.11 0.00IDH3B isocitrate dehydrogenase 3 (NAD+) beta −0.36 0.00EPB41L3 erythrocyte membrane protein band
4.1-like 3−1.70 0.00
TGFBI transforming growth factor, beta-induced, 68 kDa
−1.80 0.00
CSPG2 Chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan 2 (versican)
−1.39 0.00
KIAA0399 (ZZEF1) zinc fi nger, ZZ-type with EF-hand domain 1 −1.17 0.00FLJ22222 hypothetical protein FLJ22222 −0.98 0.00IL15 interleukin 15 −0.67 0.01CLIC3 chloride intracellular channel 3 −1.86 0.011Linear Slope—Change of value in the dependent variable (gene expression change) per unit of independent variable (disease stage);The changes in gene expression in the different stages of MDS.
-
144
Bar et al
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
between CD34+ cells from healthy donors and MDS patients. Compared to normal marrow, MDS was associated with an aberrant expression of genes involved in apoptosis, including a decreased expression of MCL1 and EPOR1, and these changes were present both in non-selected and CD34+ selected cell populations. Moreover, the PML gene and genes of the RAR-RXR pathway were found to be associated with the diagnosis of MDS and with advanced disease, respectively, suggesting disruptions of the normal differentiation pathway.
Several genes associated with the promotion of a pro-apoptotic state were identifi ed, including anti-apoptotic regulator MCL1, the erythropoetin receptor EPOR, and TNF anti-apoptotic modulator TNFAIP3. Down regulation of MCL1 is consistent with the increased rate of apoptosis observed in MDS [26, 31–35]. The protein encoded by the MCL1 gene belongs to the Bcl-2 family, known to be regulator of programmed cell death. MCL1 has been shown to be essential in the survival of
hematopoetic stem cells, as inducible deletions of MCL1 in murine models results in a profound loss of bone marrow function, including a loss of hema-topoietic stem cells [36]. MCL1 activity appears to be required for neutrophil, but not for macro-phage survival, [37] suggesting the possibility of lineage specific or differentiation dependent activity. Alternative splicing of the MCL1 gene results in two transcript variants encoding distinct isoforms. The longer gene product (isoform 1; T×1) enhances cell survival by inhibiting apoptosis, while the alternatively spliced shorter gene product (isoform 2; T×2) promotes apoptosis and is death-inducing [38]. These fi ndings are reminiscent of those described for the long and short splice vari-ants of the death signal inhibitory protein FLIP in MDS, [39] suggesting that regulation of splice variants at the transcriptional level is involved in the determination of cell death in MDS. Our data show that not only was MCL1 expression decreased in MDS compared to normal hematopoetic cells, but ratio of long/short transcripts shifted in favor
MAX
NBM RA Advanced Disease
Expr
essi
on –
Log
2
HIST2H2BE
NBM RA Advanced Disease
Expr
essi
on –
Log
2
NBM RA Advanced Disease
CD36 Receptor
Expr
essi
on –
Log
2
TGFB1
NBM RA Advanced Disease
Expr
essi
on –
Log
2
Figure 3. Expression of genes that correlated with advanced disease.Log-2 gene expression of MAX, HIST2H2BE, CD36 Receptor and TGFB1 in normal bone marrow (NBM), RA, and advanced disease (RAEB, RAEB-t, AML).
-
145
Gene expression profi les of CD34+ and unselected mononuclear cells in myelodysplasia
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
of a more pro-apoptotic state. Would such a pattern be compatible with the general observation that apoptosis in marrow cells overall tends to decrease as MDS progressed to more advanced stages? [40] The results appear counterintuitive. However, we have previously shown that the rate of apoptosis differs between clonal and non-clonal hematopoi-etic cells, and the relative proportions of those cell populations change with progression of MDS [41]. Further we observed that expression of the short splice variant of FLIP, characterized anti-apoptotic protein, showed a positive correlation with the extent of apoptosis [39]. Taken together with the lineage specificity of MCL1 as described by Dzhagalove et al. [37] it is conceivable that a pro-apoptotic effect of MCL1 in advanced MDS is expressed only in subset of cells, but does not interfere with increasing proliferation of the mali-gnant clone. Such a model would also be consistent with the observed overall decline in expression of this gene as MDS progresses (see results).
The erythropoietin receptor (EPOR) is a member of the cytokine receptor family. Upon
erythropoietin binding, the erythropoietin receptor activates the Jak2 tyrosine kinase, which in turn activates various intracellular signaling pathways, including, Ras/MAP kinase, phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase and STAT transcription factors [42]. EPOR has an anti-apoptotic function via the Akt-pathway, and signaling via the erythropoietin receptor promotes erythroid cell survival, particu-larly in patients with MDS [43–45]. Thus, the down-regulation of both MCL1 and EPOR may play a role in the dysregulation of apoptosis in hematopoetic cells leading to ineffective hemato-poiesis in MDS. It is clear, however, that the pattern of expression of MCL1 and EPOR by themselves can not explain satisfactorily the extent of apopto-sis and proliferation dysregulations at different stages of MDS. Other factors are involved, and studies of purifi ed cell populations, simultaneously analyzing the impact of various signals will be necessary [46].
Of special biological interest are the MAX (MYC associated factor X) and PML (promyelo-cytic leukemia) genes, which were found to be up-regulated in both unselected mononuclear cells and CD34+ selected cells in MDS compared to normal bone marrow and which showed a correla-tion with progression to advanced disease. The protein encoded by the MAX gene is a transcription factor that interacts with the MYC oncoprotein to form homodimers and heterodimers. Rearrange-ment among these dimer forms provides a complex system of transcriptional regulation [47]. There-fore, alteration in transcription regulation resulted by up regulation of the MAX gene might play a role in the pathophysiology of MDS. In addition, the correlation with progression to advanced dis-ease and the fact that the MAX gene was found to be up regulated in both CD34+ selected cells and unselected marrow cells make this gene a candidate marker for disease progression. The protein encoded by the PML gene is a member of the tri-partite motif (TRIM) family. This phosphoprotein localizes to nuclear bodies where it functions not only as a transcription factor but also as a tumor suppressor. Its expression is cell-cycle related and regulates the p53 response to oncogenic signals [48]. The gene is also involved in the translocation of the retinoic acid receptor alpha gene associated with acute promyelocytic leukemia (APL) [49]. A Further suggestion of the importance of PML and the RARA pathway in MDS disease progression is the deregulation of the RAR-RXR pathway in
0
5
10
15
20
25
MCL1-tx2MCL1-tx1
NBM RA ADVANCED DISEASE
MCL1 Gene Expression
MCL1 tx1/tx2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
NBM RA ADVANCED DISEASE
MCL1 tx1/tx2
A
B
Figure 4. Quantitative RT-PCR assay of MCL1.A. Expression of MCL1 anti-apoptotic transcript (t×1) and pro-apoptotic transcript (t×2). Values on the y axis represent MCL1 expression relative to endogenous control (beta-2-microglobulin) in normal bone marrow (n = 5), RA patients (n = 4) and MDS patients with advanced disease (n = 7). Both normal and MDS marrows were obtained from individuals who were not used for the gene expression array.B. Relative expression of MCL1 anti-apoptotic transcript (t×1) versus pro-apoptotic transcript (t×2). Values on the y axis repre-sent the relative expression of MCL1 t×1 versus t×2 for each of the individuals shown in panel A.
-
146
Bar et al
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
the advanced MDS noted in our analysis. RXR and RAR are nuclear receptors that bind either all-trans retinoic, 9-cis retinoic acid, or other retinoid ligands [50]. Ligand binding induces a conforma-tional change in the receptors which results in dissociation of the co-repressors and binding of co-activators with histone acetylase activity [50]. The retinoic acid pathway is critical for maintain-ing a balance between self-renewal and differen-tiation of hematopoetic stem cells, [51, 52] and deregulation of the RAR-RXR pathway, as was shown in our study, may affect differentiation and self-renewal, and thereby allow RA to progress to acute leukemia.
Three histone genes (HIST2H2BE, HIST-2H2AA, HIST1H2BG) were found to be up-regulated in MDS compared to normal bone marrow, and moreover found to be correlated with advanced disease. The expression of specifi c his-tone classes dictate changes in chromatin structure and gene expression, and infl uences various path-ways, including cell cycle progression [53–55]. In addition, there is considerable evidence that histone H1 also functions as a non-specifi c repressor of transcription [56]. Moreover, post-translational modifi cations of histones by histone acetylation and deacetylation play a role in tumorgenesis. Histone deacetylases are promising targets in drug development for cancer therapy [57]. Given that our data suggest that aberrations in histone biology are involved in MDS progression, their may be a rationale for using these agents to stem progression of early MDS, especially in combination with agents that block apoptosis, as discussed above.
Several studies have examined gene expression in MDS, using either purifi ed CD34+ or unselected mononuclear cells [58–62]. There is little overlap between the genes identifi ed across those studies or our current results. Such discrepancies are not uncommon in gene expression studies, and likely result from differences in cell types studied (CD34+ versus mononuclear cells), analytic tech-niques to defi ne signifi cant genes, and composi-tion of the cohorts of patients studied. For example, the study by Pellagatti et al. [60] exam-ined CD34+ cells from 55 MDS patients obtained from multiple centers, and showed that MDS cells had gene signatures enriched in interferon response genes. Of the 55 patents, 20 had the 5q- chromosomal aberration. Patients with 5q- MDS are unusually sensitive to the drug lenalidomide, and have recently been shown to have a unique
gene expression signature using unselected mononuclear cells [63].
Since it is unknown which cell population, CD34+ selected or unselected mononuclear cells, best describes the pathology of MDS, and given that various studies have used both types of sam-ples, we performed both types of arrays, and focused on genes found to be dysregulated in both cell populations. Thus, we consider our gene selec-tion to be fairly robust. We are comforted by the fact that the most relevant genes identifi ed in the present analysis seem biologically relevant: alter-ations of differentiation and proliferation pathways (PML, RAR-RXR, MAX), involvement in apop-tosis (MCL1, EPOR) and regulation of hemato-poiesis (TNFAIP3, CXCR4, CCL18).
Since the patient population included in this study was relatively small, we were unable to study specific correlations between gene expression, cytogenetics, and clinical presentation. However there did not appear to be an association of previous treatment to the molecular signature, and specifi -cally there was no effect of erythropoietin treatment on EPOR gene expression. These fi ndings strengthen our interpretation that low EPOR levels might be related to the pathophysiology of MDS, and might explain the heterogeneity of response to treatment with erythropoietin among MDS patients.
In conclusion, this study provides new data on gene expression in the different phases of MDS. Although no single gene can likely explain the pathophysiology of the disease, some of the dif-ferences delineated in this study may prove relevant in our efforts to identify prognostic markers and therapeutic targets.
AcknowledgmentsWe thank all the patients and healthy donors who agreed to donate marrows for these investigations.
Author contributionsSupported by NHI/NCI grants: HL36444, HL082941, CA18021. Merav Bar: Conception and design, Collection and/or assembly of data, Data analysis and inter-pretation, Manuscript writing.Derek Stirewalt: Conception and design, Collec-tion and/or assembly of data, Data analysis and interpretation.Era Pogosova-Agadjanyan: Collection and/or assembly of data.
-
147
Gene expression profi les of CD34+ and unselected mononuclear cells in myelodysplasia
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
Vitas Wagner: Collection and/or assembly of data.Ted Gooley: Data analysis and interpretation.Nissa abbasi: Collection and/or assembly of data.Ravi Bhatia: Provision of study material or patients, Data analysis and interpretation.Joachim Deeg: Conception and design, Financial support, Data analysis and interpretation, Manuscript writing.Jeral Radich: Conception and design, Financial support, Data analysis and interpretation, Manuscript writing.
References[1] Aul, C., Bowen, D.T. and Yoshida, Y. 1998. Pathogenesis, etiology
and epidemiology of myelodysplastic syndromes. Haematologica, Jan;83(1):71–86.
[2] Heaney, M.L. and Golde, D.W. 1999. Myelodysplasia. N. Engl. J. Med., May 27;340(21):1649–60.
[3] Fenaux, P. 2001. Chromosome and molecular abnormalities in myelodysplastic syndromes. International journal of hematology, Jun;73(4):429–37.
[4] Steensma, D.P. and List, A.F. 2005. Genetic testing in the myelodys-plastic syndromes: molecular insights into hematologic diversity. Mayo. Clin. Proc., Jan;80(5):681–98.
[5] Olney, H.J. and Le Beau, M.M. 2001. The cytogenetics of myelodysplastic syndromes. Best Pract Res. Clin. Haematol., Sep;14(3):479–95.
[6] Fenaux, P., Morel, P. and Lai, J.L. 1996. Cytogenetics of myelodys-plastic syndromes. Semin. Hematol., Apr;33(2):127–38.
[7] Horiike, S., Misawa, S., Nakai, H., Kaneko, H., Yokota, S., Taniwaki, M. et al. 1994. N-ras mutation and karyotypic evolution are closely associated with leukemic transformation in myelodysplastic syn-drome. Leukemia, Aug;8(8):1331–6.
[8] Neubauer, A., Greenberg, P., Negrin, R., Ginzton, N. and Liu, E. 1994. Mutations in the ras proto-oncogenes in patients with myelo-dysplastic syndromes. Leukemia, Apr;8(4):638–41.
[9] Shih, L.Y., Lin, T.L., Wang, P.N., Wu, J.H., Dunn, P., Kuo, M.C. et al. 2004. Internal tandem duplication of fms-like tyrosine kinase 3 is associated with poor outcome in patients with myelodysplastic syn-drome. Cancer, Sep 1;101(5):989–98.
[10] Aggerholm, A., Holm, M.S., Guldberg, P., Olesen, L.H. and Hokland, P. 2006. Promoter hypermethylation of p15INK4B, HIC1, CDH1, and ER is frequent in myelodysplastic syndrome and predicts poor prognosis in early-stage patients. Eur. J. Haematol., Jan;76(1):23–32.
[11] Guan, X., Sagara, J., Yokoyama, T., Koganehira, Y., Oguchi, M., Saida, T. et al. 2003. ASC/TMS1, a caspase-1 activating adaptor, is downregulated by aberrant methylation in human melanoma. Int. J. Cancer, Nov 1;107(2):202–8.
[12] Herman, J.G. and Baylin, S.B. 2003. Gene silencing in cancer in association with promoter hypermethylation. N. Engl. J. Med., Nov 20;349(21):2042–54.
[13] Jones, P.A. and Baylin, S.B. 2002. The fundamental role of epigen-etic events in cancer. Nat. Rev. Genet., Jun;3(6):415–28.
[14] Machida, E.O., Brock, M.V., Hooker, C.M., Nakayama, J., Ishida, A., Amano, J. et al. 2006. Hypermethylation of ASC/TMS1 is a sputum marker for late-stage lung cancer. Cancer Res., Jun 15;66(12):6210–8.
[15] Quesnel, B., Guillerm, G., Vereecque, R., Wattel, E., Preudhomme, C., Bauters, F. et al. 1998. Methylation of the p15(INK4b) gene in myelodysplastic syndromes is frequent and acquired during disease progression. Blood, Apr 15;91(8):2985–90.
[16] Bennett, J.M., Catovsky, D., Daniel, M.T., Flandrin, G., Galton, D.A., Gralnick, H.R. et al. 1982. Proposals for the classifi cation of the myelodys-plastic syndromes. British journal of haematology, Jun;51(2):189–99.
[17] Stirewalt, D.L., Pogosova-Agadjanyan, E.L., Khalid, N., Hare, D.R., Ladne, P.A., Sala-Torra, O. et al. 2004. Single-stranded linear amplifi -cation protocol results in reproducible and reliable microarray data from nanogram amounts of starting RNA. Genomics, Feb;83(2):321–31.
[18] R Development Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria 2008.
[19] Tusher, V.G., Tibshirani, R. and Chu, G. 2001. Signifi cance analysis of microarrays applied to the ionizing radiation response. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., Apr 24;98(9):5116–21.
[20] Subramanian, A., Tamayo, P., Mootha, V.K., Mukherjee, S., Ebert, B.L., Gillette, M.A. et al. 2005. Gene set enrichment analysis: a knowledge-based approach for interpreting genome-wide expression profi les. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., Oct 25;102(43):15545–50.
[21] Storey, J.D. and Tibshirani, R. 2003. Statistical signifi cance for genomewide studies. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., Aug 5;100(16):9440–5.
[22] Aizawa, S., Nakano, M., Iwase, O., Yaguchi, M., Hiramoto, M., Hoshi, H. et al. 1999. Bone marrow stroma from refractory anemia of myelodysplastic syndrome is defective in its ability to support normal CD34-positive cell proliferation and differentiation in vitro. Leuk. Res., Mar;23(3):239–46.
[23] Copplestone, J.A., Mufti, G.J., Hamblin, T.J. and Oscier, D.G. 1986. Immunological abnormalities in myelodysplastic syndromes. II. Coexistent lymphoid or plasma cell neoplasms: a report of 20 cases unrelated to chemotherapy. British journal of haematology, May;63(1):149–59.
[24] Deeg, H.J., Beckham, C., Loken, M.R., Bryant, E., Lesnikova, M., Shulman, H.M. et al. 2000. Negative regulators of hemopoiesis and stroma function in patients with myelodysplastic syndrome. Leuk. Lymphoma, Apr;37(3–4):405–14.
[25] Flores-Figueroa, E., Arana-Trejo, R.M., Gutierrez-Espindola, G., Perez-Cabrera, A. and Mayani, H. 2005. Mesenchymal stem cells in myelodysplastic syndromes: phenotypic and cytogenetic characteriza-tion. Leuk. Res., Feb;29(2):215–24.
[26] Liesveld, J.L., Jordan, C.T. and Phillips, G.L. 2004. The hematopoi-etic stem cell in myelodysplasia. Stem Cells, 22(4):590–9.
[27] Micheva, I., Thanopoulou, E., Michalopoulou, S., Karakantza, M., Kouraklis-Symeonidis, A., Mouzaki, A. et al. 2004. Defective tumor necrosis factor alpha-induced maturation of monocyte-derived den-dritic cells in patients with myelodysplastic syndromes. Clin. Immu-nol., Dec;113(3):310–7.
[28] Miura, I., Kobayashi, Y., Takahashi, N., Saitoh, K. and Miura, A.B. 2000. Involvement of natural killer cells in patients with myelodys-plastic syndrome carrying monosomy 7 revealed by the application of fl uorescence in situ hybridization to cells collected by means of fl uorescence-activated cell sorting. British journal of haematology, Sep;110(4):876–9.
[29] Tauro, S., Hepburn, M.D., Bowen, D.T. and Pippard, M.J. 2001. Assessment of stromal function, and its potential contribution to deregulation of hematopoiesis in the myelodysplastic syndromes. Haematologica, Oct;86(10):1038–45.
[30] van Lom, K., Hagemeijer, A., Smit, E., Hahlen, K., Groeneveld, K. and Lowenberg, B. 1995. Cytogenetic clonality analysis in myelodysplastic syndrome: monosomy 7 can be demonstrated in the myeloid and in the lymphoid lineage. Leukemia , Nov;9(11):1818–21.
[31] Albitar, M., Manshouri, T., Shen, Y., Liu, D., Beran, M., Kantarjian, H.M. et al. 2002. Myelodysplastic syndrome is not merely “preleukemia”. Blood, Aug;100(3):791–8.
[32] Bouscary, D., Chen, Y.L., Guesnu, M., Picard, F., Viguier, F., Lacombe, C. et al. 2000. Activity of the caspase-3/CPP32 enzyme is increased in “early stage” myelodysplastic syndromes with excessive apoptosis, but caspase inhibition does not enhance colony formation in vitro. Exp. Hematol., Jul;28(7):784–91.
-
148
Bar et al
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
[33] Pecci, A., Travaglino, E., Klersy, C. and Invernizzi, R. 2003. Apoptosis in relation to CD34 antigen expression in normal and myelodysplastic bone marrow. Acta. Haematol., 109(1):29–34.
[34] Shimazaki, K., Ohshima, K., Suzumiya, J., Kawasaki, C. and Kikuchi, M. 2000. Evaluation of apoptosis as a prognostic factor in myelodysplastic syndromes. British journal of haematology, Sep;110(3):584–90.
[35] Washington, L.T., Jilani, I., Estey, E. and Albitar, M. 2002. Less apoptosis in patients with 5q-syndrome than in patients with refrac-tory anemia. Leuk. Res., Oct;26(10):899–902.
[36] Opferman, J.T., Iwasaki, H., Ong, C.C., Suh, H., Mizuno, S., Akashi, K. et al. 2005. Obligate role of anti-apoptotic MCL-1 in the survival of hematopoietic stem cells. Science, (New York, NY), Feb 18;307(5712):1101–4.
[37] Dzhagalov, I., St John, A. and He, Y.W. 2007. The antiapoptotic protein Mcl-1 is essential for the survival of neutrophils but not macrophages. Blood, Feb 15;109(4):1620–6.
[38] Michels, J., Johnson, P.W. and Packham, G. 2005. Mcl-1. Int. J. Biochem. Cell Biol., Feb;37(2):267–71.
[39] Benesch, M., Platzbecker, U., Ward, J., Deeg, H.J. and Leisenring, W. 2003. Expression of FLIP(Long) and FLIP(Short) in bone mar-row mononuclear and CD34+ cells in patients with myelodysplas-t ic syndrome: corre la t ion wi th apoptos is . Leukemia , Dec;17(12):2460–6.
[40] Gersuk, G.M., Beckham, C., Loken, M.R., Kiener, P., Anderson, J.E., Farrand, A. et al. 1998. A role for tumour necrosis factor-alpha, Fas and Fas-Ligand in marrow failure associated with myelodysplastic syndrome. British journal of haematology, Oct;103(1):176–88.
[41] Li, X., Bryant, C.E. and Deeg, H.J. 2004. Simultaneous demonstra-tion of clonal chromosome abnormalities and apoptosis in individual marrow cells in myelodysplastic syndrome. International journal of hematology, Aug;80(2):140–5.
[42] Cheung, J.Y. and Miller, B.A. 2001. Molecular mechanisms of erythropoietin signaling. Nephron, Mar;87(3):215–22.
[43] Hardee, M.E., Rabbani, Z.N., Arcasoy, M.O., Kirkpatrick, J.P., Vujaskovic, Z., Dewhirst, M.W. et al. 2006. Erythropoietin inhibits apoptosis in breast cancer cells via an Akt-dependent pathway with-out modulating in vivo chemosensitivity. Molecular cancer thera-peutics, Feb;5(2):356–61.
[44] Hellstrom-Lindberg, E. 2003. Approach to anemia associated with myelodysplastic syndromes. Curr. Hematol. Rep., Mar;2(2):122–9.
[45] Hellstrom-Lindberg, E., Gulbrandsen, N., Lindberg, G., Ahlgren, T., Dahl, I.M., Dybedal, I. et al. 2003. A validated decision model for treating the anaemia of myelodysplastic syndromes with erythropoi-etin + granulocyte colony-stimulating factor: signifi cant effects on quality of life. British journal of haematology, Mar;120(6):1037–46.
[46] Stirewalt, D.L., Mhyre, A.J., Marcondes, M., Pogosova-Agadjanyan, E., Abbasi, N., Radich, J.P. et al. 2008. Tumour necrosis factor-induced gene expression in human marrow stroma: clues to the pathophysiol-ogy of MDS. British journal of haematology, Feb;140(4):444–53.
[47] Lee, L.A. and Dang, C.V. 2006. Myc target transcriptomes. Curr. Top Microbiol. Immunol., 302:145–67.
[48] Zimber, A., Nguyen, Q.D. and Gespach, C. 2004. Nuclear bodies and compartments: functional roles and cellular signalling in health and disease. Cell Signal, Oct;16(10):1085–104.
[49] Melo, R.A., de Vasconcellos, J.F., Melo, F.C., Machado, C.G., Lacerda, T.M. and Souto, F.R. 2006. PML-RARalpha fusion gene transcripts and biological features in acute promyelocytic leukemia patients. Clin. Lab Haematol., Apr;28(2):126–9.
[50] Bastien, J. and Rochette-Egly, C. 2004. Nuclear retinoid receptors and the transcription of retinoid-target genes. Gene, Mar 17;328:1–16.
[51] Johnson, B.S., Mueller, L., Si, J. and Collins, S.J. 2002. The cytokines IL-3 and GM-CSF regulate the transcriptional activity of retinoic acid receptors in different in vitro models of myeloid differentiation. Blood, Feb 1;99(3):746–53.
[52] Purton, L.E., Dworkin, S., Olsen, G.H., Walkley, C.R., Fabb, S.A., Collins, S.J. et al. 2006. RARgamma is critical for maintaining a balance between hematopoietic stem cell self-renewal and differen-tiation. J. Exp. Med., May 15;203(5):1283–93.
[53] Gunjan, A. and Verreault, A. 2003. A Rad53 kinase-dependent surveil-lance mechanism that regulates histone protein levels in S. cerevisiae. Cell, Nov 26;115(5):537–49.
[54] Quina, A.S., Buschbeck, M. and Di Croce, L. 2006. Chromatin structure and epigenetics. Biochem. Pharmacol. Jul 10.
[55] Quivy, J.P. and Almouzni, G. 2003. Rad53: a controller ensuring the fi ne-tuning of histone levels. Cell, Nov 26;115(5):508–10.
[56] Brown, D.T., Alexander, B.T. and Sittman, D.B. 1996. Differential effect of H1 variant overexpression on cell cycle progression and gene expression. Nucleic Acids Res., Feb 1;24(3):486–93.
[57] Minucci, S. and Pelicci, P.G. 2006. Histone deacetylase inhibitors and the promise of epigenetic (and more) treatments for cancer. Nat. Rev. Cancer, Jan;6(1):38–51.
[58] Hofmann, W.K., de Vos, S., Komor, M., Hoelzer, D., Wachsman, W. and Koeffl er, H.P. 2002. Characterization of gene expression of CD34+ cells from normal and myelodysplastic bone marrow. Blood, Nov 15;100(10):3553–60.
[59] Lee, Y.T., Miller, L.D., Gubin, A.N., Makhlouf, F., Wojda, U., Barrett, A.J. et al. 2001. Transcription patterning of uncoupled proliferation and differentiation in myelodysplastic bone marrow with erythroid-focused arrays. Blood, Sep 15;98(6):1914–21.
[60] Pellagatti, A., Cazzola, M., Giagounidis, A.A., Malcovati, L., Della Porta, M.G., Killick, S. et al. 2006. Gene expression profi les of CD34+ cells in myelodysplastic syndromes: involvement of interferon stimulated genes and correlation to FAB. subtype and karyotype. Blood. Mar 9.
[61] Pellagatti, A., Esoof, N., Watkins, F., Langford, C.F., Vetrie, D., Campbell, L.J. et al. 2004. Gene expression profi ling in the myelo-dysplastic syndromes using cDNA microarray technology. British journal of haematology. Jun;125(5):576–83.
[62] Pellagatti, A., Fidler, C., Wainscoat, J.S. and Boultwood, J. 2005. Gene expression profi ling in the myelodysplastic syndromes. Hema-tology, Aug;10(4):281–7.
[63] Ebert, B.L., Galili, N., Tamayo, P., Bosco, J., Mak, R., Pretz, J. et al. 2008. An Erythroid Differentiation Signature Predicts Response to Lenalidomide in Myelodysplastic Syndrome. PLoS medicine, Feb 12;5(2):e35.
-
149
Gene expression profi les of CD34+ and unselected mononuclear cells in myelodysplasia
Translational Oncogenomics 2008:3
Gene Expression Patterns in Myelodyplasia Underline the Role of Apoptosis and Differentiation in Disease Initiation and ProgressionMerav Bar, Derek Stirewalt, Era Pogosova-Agadjanyan, Vitas Wagner, Ted Gooley, Nissa Abbasi, Ravi Bhatia, H. Joachim Deeg and Jerald Radich
Supplementary TablesTable S1. MDS (multiple groups) vs NBM mononuclear cells.
Table S2. MDS (multiple groups) vs NBM CD34+ cells.
Table S3. OVELAPPED GENES (up/down regulated) in MDS multiple groups vs NBM (Mononuclear cells and CD 34+ cells).
Table S4. Advanced Disease (RAEB and RAEBT) versus RA versus normal bone marrow.
Sheet1
MDS (multiple groups) vs NBM mononuclear cells:
Positive genes
Gene ID (Affymetrix probe #):Gene NameScore(d)Numerator(r)Denominator(s+s0)Fold Changeq-value(%)
214290_s_athttp://genome-www4.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/SMD/source/sourceResult?choice=Gene&option=Name&criteria=9.71934019432.55753067620.26313830216.56750663670
218280_x_athttp://genome-www4.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/SMD/source/sourceResult?choice=Gene&option=Name&criteria=8.83024728792.40993030990.27291764676.21667079490
200799_atHSPA1A8.00331393122.06638547620.2581912314.61933609890
213603_s_atRAC27.97699271460.68065246710.08532695111.624039690
205897_atNFATC47.46332510721.51507518940.20300270562.75347124440
214281_s_atZNF3637.02670409640.94955972910.1351358641.94129222810
211657_atCEACAM67.01955670544.46028849820.635408856335.24434952840
200800_s_atHSPA1A6.83579359962.39413114980.3502345586.44047921190
212749_s_atZNF3636.8056063961.01643368370.14935240512.00717006650
205033_s_atDEFA16.78563794635.22288872850.769697524447.83030966330
206589_atGFI16.76554840132.76478129510.40865590366.51991532070
205513_atTCN16.71355301343.73791844750.556772016220.53436889980
222315_athttp://genome-www4.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/SMD/source/sourceResult?choice=Gene&option=Name&criteria=6.66372056433.17325404050.476198545510.61217438990
205633_s_atALAS16.6306579372.0330481530.30661333654.95282700570
207269_atDEFA46.5627897335.31987987810.81061257473.35330837680
203757_s_atCEACAM66.37451557614.87243724740.764361964346.18743307970
208864_s_atTXN6.25692507360.8890495510.14209049021.90110391020
219281_atMSRA6.00312627641.13167464890.18851421692.3266603660
209893_s_atFUT45.90227890581.41833173080.24030239062.96071584160
218332_atBEX15.89617302752.72307896530.46183837439.6727083550
203897_atLOC571495.83964392050.55413143070.09489130471.48452696730
207384_atPGLYRP5.79786115856.36694154091.098153503136.90852266430
202708_s_atHIST2H2BE5.78757218471.60325294570.27701649233.55960698950
212408_atLAP1B5.77502977930.85304970570.14771347311.82404921940
203964_atNMI5.77144331260.71030424170.12307220281.66329019230
206207_atCLC5.74417028073.66629606090.638263819120.5782626710
218983_atC1RL5.71881136011.46028454060.25534756243.01031735160
222067_x_atHIST1H2BD5.71529633921.58664449260.27761368763.06144954360
208490_x_atHIST1H2BF5.70247731241.351762530.2370482962.5979267660
202252_atRAB135.65841965091.37991579970.24386946972.85652207160
206772_atPTHR25.6101208121.81181791510.32295524033.59726605350
220005_atGPR865.58506649693.12619834210.55974236729.27665444060
203986_atGENX-34145.56273086632.36162840760.424544795.56223776220
209332_s_atMAX5.56055666370.70472204840.12673588111.67437727210
208496_x_atHIST1H3G5.55935841312.25788357320.40614103386.20642324090
203021_atSLPI5.51490161012.87544067760.521394737610.68975575940
208546_x_atHIST1H2BH5.48791124951.73508284470.31616452343.14140069810
204430_s_atSLC2A55.4804769122.48806827310.45398754766.23959360730
204351_atS100P5.47440964823.56102307110.650485312617.69746118180
202442_atAP3S15.46182354450.90234681920.1652098081.96757102480
212062_atATP9A5.43845318772.18326598710.40144980785.43575724440
210244_atCAMP5.40199488875.0514528350.935108777248.44608084610
207802_atCRISP35.3896274765.76645817271.06991776385.48798256410
205480_s_atUGP25.36963779210.75084709680.13983198231.73026181330
209331_s_atMAX5.34950002230.63757546250.11918412191.55316320440
205041_s_atORM15.33382802124.80247380470.900380324563.47409139980
204804_atSSA15.30732089510.69140987010.13027474381.64561731130
213545_x_atSNX35.30396602270.65866374930.1241832521.61208938470
202875_s_atPBX25.28581835470.70593200510.13355207421.62676486410
200961_atSPS25.25633173530.71309978120.13566491181.68791270050
221523_s_atRRAGD5.24540846971.58548901150.30226225863.4993448940
204220_atGMFG5.21928228080.72611319770.13912127351.70814078920
204185_x_atPPID5.20660513790.63265979250.12151099911.59401402960
220811_atPRG35.1831175913.77464828790.728258277331.4096317280
203041_s_atLAMP25.16864794471.24050930710.24000653952.58736927070
214627_atEPX5.16729368392.71150604960.524743940510.30797400160
211275_s_atGYG5.14983327751.3764379670.26727816082.92201506250
209806_atHIST1H2BK5.14147069941.37807819550.26803190683.01264598680
220615_s_atFLJ104625.08931536552.19471093750.43123893495.9748930180
209357_atCITED25.07390737861.27793583020.25186424092.68961217010
202794_atINPP15.05982024140.79277497760.15668046291.80326587660
221864_atMGC130245.05333754690.88535044550.17520112941.95151469290
207643_s_atTNFRSF1A5.03990350961.0863232540.21554445482.26223113610
217794_atDKFZP564J1575.03836776920.68569699350.13609506591.63839027820
212268_atSERPINB15.0347567321.27983087740.25419914912.69374986010
212082_s_atMYL65.03052087520.55209132310.10974834151.47694320
200734_s_atARF35.0016784320.4199902470.08396986191.34967601170
211743_s_atPRG24.992967653.9768256120.796485355230.13265853020
201315_x_atIFITM24.99031035981.28204083550.25690603252.69391969960
220421_atFLJ214584.98086405592.83254008580.5686844813.15638788120
218643_s_atCRIPT4.94501803751.06957997220.21629445312.10792237810
202529_atPRPSAP14.93940176920.63055605050.12765838451.5865202510
214040_s_atGSN4.92402575932.45787046210.49915873367.13873956310
218870_atARHGAP154.92091416530.51730406230.10512356951.44004155560
219271_atGalNac-T104.919522292.29442635350.46639210446.07280392810
200067_x_atSNX34.91327099740.54918252870.11177533851.48235697460
202349_atDYT14.89850251560.59531527910.12153005481.5410601040
206640_x_atGAGE44.89003954581.0424301760.21317418121.7971110330
200942_s_atHSBP14.8557245050.53778106350.11075197181.45871188250
212203_x_atIFITM34.8501434691.00208992850.20661036832.12566666180
204436_atpp90994.85004013890.84401333150.17402192711.92288932020
208636_atACTN14.82764511461.41694058410.29350553953.08471239660
206157_atPTX34.82695225691.86544686770.38646474394.83780819690
212700_x_atKIAA03564.8249060760.96090874430.19915594821.99566254610
201318_s_atMRCL34.79546800760.60846585920.12688351971.55699437230
202030_atBCKDK4.78697789660.51081784060.10670988081.42444595870
214522_x_atHIST1H3D4.748321342.20817631430.46504357145.55172565790
200011_s_atARF34.73698504720.43716858010.09228835971.37128234840
208579_x_atH2BFS4.73180843651.61700807550.34173151713.74102153510
204636_atCOL17A14.7247852442.74192661630.58032830599.49831039720.212424178
203936_s_atMMP94.72145907213.33413336230.706165893117.59444780510.212424178
219191_s_atBIN24.72050388750.72880004020.15439030611.68311397120.212424178
213102_atACTR34.68222372920.67072219320.14324864251.63707754370.212424178
78047_s_atMMP244.67774499670.37574283180.08032563381.31177235480.212424178
221524_s_atRRAGD4.67412629741.32698919920.28390101482.81085376360.212424178
205040_atORM14.67293723034.86861042371.041873704680.24258583590.212424178
208583_x_atHIST1H2AJ4.65555984880.73093214720.15700198711.72727372120.212424178
217918_atDNCL2A4.64933651850.57781181370.12427833761.53087220180.212424178
206503_x_atPML4.64647828241.37419306010.29574937762.67079699250.212424178
208626_s_atVAT14.6459007840.91607388370.19717895972.03285217770.212424178
208527_x_atHIST1H2BE4.63786908980.94249924160.20321816412.08588464440.212424178
219014_atPLAC84.63518191390.9706082480.20940024922.06991955450.212424178
211004_s_atALDH3B14.63488685450.8416442550.18158895381.85006127060.212424178
212892_atZNF2824.62674219170.79869922250.1726266971.73913358450.212424178
200663_atCD634.61617580230.77309882180.16747603531.80828670390.212424178
214455_atHIST1H2BC4.61533687272.09373152460.4536465234.83857231570.212424178
200696_s_atGSN4.61383583091.46657387350.31786433833.30174288720.212424178
202811_atAMSH4.61270446150.51530961650.111715291.45045799260.212424178
206676_atCEACAM84.61061031074.12443583450.894553119128.62332472110.212424178
210648_x_atSNX34.60942290240.49450542080.1072814171.43653057310.212424178
212768_s_atGW1124.60366824824.70084002541.021107467336.93014597830.212424178
205147_x_atNCF44.60060225841.30221074440.28305223342.76117708350.212424178
205780_atBIK4.5701105182.20958368870.48348583266.75727513230.212424178
203282_atGBE14.55636532111.16479495740.25564125682.53013781830.212424178
200944_s_atHMGN14.53732033310.39400420340.08683632071.32281100530.212424178
206208_atCA44.53723336392.88064052370.634889213912.02071276270.212424178
202100_atRALB4.53518732720.7747510650.17083110561.81282164880.212424178
218145_atC20orf974.53231477950.83600108690.18445344761.91220443730.212424178
51192_atSSH-34.52168085440.79114286270.17496654191.72029263820.212424178
211509_s_atRTN44.52113644130.57795774770.12783461751.54836755280.212424178
207519_atSLC6A44.52067705870.94481611870.20899880851.72137473080.212424178
203765_atGCA4.49274180631.5203744310.33840681183.52053853420.212424178
213572_s_atSERPINB14.47664012831.03334271780.23082997252.2232985660.212424178
203274_atF8A4.47569926640.39708270040.08871970091.33730878210.212424178
215779_s_atHIST1H2BG4.47075465261.7005829930.38037940463.67967606460.212424178
209515_s_atRAB27A4.46927749891.11285325820.24900070732.42984850420.212424178
211883_x_atCEACAM14.4595311022.00785358930.45023872325.22951414070.212424178
221732_atSHAPY4.45859960981.50911193130.33847218043.04664254120.212424178
203042_atLAMP24.45836963281.03355716340.23182401832.17431923950.212424178
203802_x_atWBSCR20A4.45418713450.8326404450.18693432041.76477157240.212424178
205769_atSLC27A24.44956974891.15008444970.25847093422.41867129310.212424178
62212_atMGC9554.4480529450.3893122570.08752419581.31392902870.212424178
210484_s_atMGC319574.44634022162.05273151210.46166766594.05663775440.212424178
215102_atLOC892314.44076747762.34792372370.52872025746.25452634040.212424178
216210_x_atHRIHFB21224.44040353940.7149475240.16100958341.72101588510.212424178
209155_s_atNT5C24.43633579790.80152664110.18067312251.80157233470.212424178
200625_s_atCAP14.42200816460.72041874290.16291664691.74108195980.212424178
201487_atCTSC4.41340481350.76507141590.17335174281.64064591920.212424178
206816_s_atSPAG84.40596622981.16302292970.26396546622.00318581250.212424178
203960_s_atLOC516684.40342230830.62393889780.14169408571.49968000510.212424178
211535_s_atFGFR14.39898015541.18621391390.26965657312.28620752750.212424178
215884_s_athttp://genome-www4.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/SMD/source/sourceResult?choice=Gene&option=Name&criteria=4.39805143840.66647158020.1515379231.64083785960.212424178
221485_atB4GALT54.39645623841.40340837930.31921354453.11331411190.212424178
209911_x_atHIST1H2BD4.37814042721.07759647540.246131092.42147981140.212424178
215343_atKIAA15094.36591044370.99867849990.22874461422.02449245670.212424178
202990_atPYGL4.3656846131.52023650180.34822407863.53642241940.212424178
209089_atRAB5A4.36353150760.52812271570.12103103071.47814011020.212424178
210789_x_atCEACAM34.35899627850.94709200310.21727295522.0739596160.212424178
213773_x_atWBSCR20A4.33875897160.88445966360.20385084061.94777628560.3384027849
214138_atZNF794.33548931311.35706871450.31301396832.48903088390.3384027849
217837_s_atNEDF4.32808407480.61645096260.142430451.56826777610.3384027849
31845_atELF44.32186448880.59356484470.13733999441.54674858110.3384027849
201301_s_atANXA44.31583418590.75554435870.17506334261.74570688840.3384027849
204039_atCEBPA4.29068865281.09570372630.25536780112.41511935610.3384027849
217780_atPTD0084.28967123320.3053015110.07117130761.24727026070.3384027849
219933_atGLRX24.27192727020.57044513570.13353343811.52130613430.3384027849
211163_s_atTNFRSF10C4.26837883172.57732023090.60381712418.07072280360.3384027849
218773_s_atPILB4.26695027930.56416910060.13221834421.51788408070.3384027849
212230_atPPAP2B4.26588711641.1877898220.27843911232.58812704010.3384027849
205899_atCCNA14.25594105590.86054714930.20219902911.80564309810.3384027849
209215_atTETRAN4.25032407850.99744096010.23467409582.12679723990.3384027849
219295_s_atPCOLCE24.23802711492.30934455770.54491028376.2439988290.3384027849
209944_atAPA14.23706109430.49735742910.11738264281.44360343830.3384027849
209369_atANXA34.23473784652.94128122740.694560403512.76677409640.3384027849
209094_atDDAH14.2270290911.44675917410.34226383193.0412564020.3384027849
207008_atIL8RB4.22555240052.11347874430.50016626095.64121611580.3384027849
208637_x_atACTN14.21275287191.20508272880.28605587972.5859053670.3384027849
214606_atTSPAN-24.20992705941.89902174190.45108186324.77143664930.3384027849
204186_s_atPPID4.19344018410.50236089270.11979684241.43147211540.3384027849
216592_atMAGEC34.18477154161.34578211080.32159034193.1037514210.3384027849
215088_s_athttp://genome-www4.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/SMD/source/sourceResult?choice=Gene&option=Name&criteria=4.18420175350.3493134690.08348389721.28213771610.3384027849
210788_s_atretSDR44.17903784670.62426625640.14938037881.59200660530.3384027849
220945_x_atFLJ102984.16164524361.69646573070.40764304294.24839511750.3384027849
221766_s_atC6orf374.15881879871.17039455860.28142475432.50801863140.3384027849
221149_atGPR774.15721570251.75782166450.422836294.6760461760.3384027849
210644_s_atLAIR14.15682581350.66169813830.15918351361.63234680220.3384027849
209397_atME24.14615616730.66078273720.15937237061.65937157650.5589193537
212531_atLCN24.14565463143.64743184880.879820480323.02988890750.5589193537
206200_s_atANXA114.14036528580.71969473270.17382397041.73571119590.5589193537
218910_atFLJ103754.13640443061.32071799460.31929131132.77954088410.5589193537
202200_s_atSRPK14.13356158660.74883248420.18115914531.77409639560.5589193537
207677_s_atNCF44.13314005261.57967984960.38219848093.55301378750.5589193537
201605_x_atCNN24.13122236090.73306441580.17744491871.76172612810.5589193537
208749_x_atFLOT14.11758084140.66433848520.1613419411.66313003710.5589193537
65517_atAP1M24.1149612321.12001938010.27218224352.39720231410.5589193537
206851_atRNASE34.1073703412.88068598120.701345567112.63584503950.5589193537
211013_x_atPML4.10476750441.43454660750.34948303553.18221826630.5589193537
214554_atHIST1H2AL4.10207714811.21515831760.2962300012.31924033460.5589193537
205569_atLAMP34.09682261071.60744783440.39236451933.25746149760.5589193537
202286_s_atTACSTD24.09668870352.47946941410.60523744757.10696877180.5589193537
209892_atFUT44.07728206851.41476104540.34698630653.0695167190.5589193537
206039_atRAB33A4.06586580780.68488997930.16844874171.6543179550.5589193537
201023_atTAF74.05605109210.55670919990.13725399091.49288049990.6267294224
209355_s_atPPAP2B4.04626241161.78278971050.44060160444.17731277530.6267294224
205557_atBPI4.04562674573.27334363270.80910668216.99663382090.6267294224
216605_s_atR29124_14.03673422272.03450654330.50399814084.32243393340.6267294224
203725_atGADD45A4.02928203711.10289222380.27371929132.41472995510.6267294224
213589_s_atLOC2842084.02826035961.65600030270.4110956484.9193429310.6267294224
200618_atLASP14.01776868430.69086304080.17195192031.70944092210.6267294224
208052_x_atCEACAM34.01704430850.72869664280.18140119621.76624493830.6267294224
201180_s_atGNAI34.01331664410.33574183270.08365695071.27222178860.6267294224
215071_s_athttp://genome-www4.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/SMD/source/sourceResult?choice=Gene&option=Name&criteria=4.01059794951.50612982030.37553747333.74077144920.6267294224
204007_atFCGR3A4.00426993422.24713781370.56118539728.13253409830.6267294224
209710_atGATA24.0036510591.0511442910.26254642962.39276860970.6267294224
221408_x_atPCDHB123.99955344881.22206374620.30555004752.32218302380.6267294224
207980_s_atCITED23.98712928641.13238796710.28401084732.54697972870.6267294224
217986_s_atBAZ1A3.97094100110.68026540850.17131088281.66831887190.6267294224
207329_atMMP83.96553952753.58416242770.903827184922.81970021810.7458080126
201302_atANXA43.96134153510.76187771720.19232820761.7985947990.7458080126
201554_x_atGYG3.96067494651.4117430260.35644001213.34049983010.7458080126
205472_s_atDACH3.95738427781.94258446690.49087587424.08805098250.7458080126
209288_s_atCDC42EP33.95328179760.85198421920.21551315161.9372662830.7458080126
204725_s_atNCK13.95303619760.48764883420.1233605791.41092600430.7458080126
214575_s_atAZU13.94922715442.78721774560.705762833211.239053780.7458080126
35254_atFLN293.94884848320.54651601780.1383988321.50135671110.7458080126
217989_atRETSDR23.94858200910.59362480230.15033872941.53534890180.7458080126
209767_s_atPNUTL13.94102109761.78284210170.45238075553.34698147040.7458080126
213101_s_atACTR33.93825016020.4221809990.10720014771.35331811590.7458080126
221484_atB4GALT53.93784823741.07639720320.27334654322.34896024430.7458080126
208660_atCS3.93615936990.43625709290.11083318841.3719590070.7458080126
201176_s_atARCN13.93544167560.56934942630.1446723071.52715942610.7458080126
220416_atATP8B43.93257123531.55138161890.39449549063.62922780160.7458080126
203011_atIMPA13.91920848530.58172002920.14842793681.52898991210.7458080126
217852_s_atFLJ107023.91666202340.51409857480.13125936621.46972351950.7458080126
201061_s_atSTOM3.91308457521.08839640250.27814282612.39270792680.7458080126
201921_atGNG103.90586099730.81496727280.20865240041.83091839360.7458080126
207992_s_atAMPD33.90309857021.12861134870.28915778792.44466680110.7458080126
220291_atFLJ202073.89054159490.63134230810.16227620051.59475218660.7458080126
219146_atFLJ227293.88897443710.56852572860.14618911431.52663890370.7458080126
32837_atAGPAT23.88886757560.49981553170.12852469831.44934992470.7458080126
211773_s_atZNF3063.87700693810.5669455440.14623279071.47481014750.9433144823
201765_s_atHEXA3.869310250.4556337880.11775581651.38741932080.9433144823
209924_atCCL183.86839280641.98827225830.51397889455.61025241580.9433144823
219478_atWFDC13.86698287312.13846728580.55300666076.45672309170.9433144823
210189_atHSPA1L3.85726380541.05367564690.2731666022.00830742570.9433144823
202122_s_atTIP473.85523601210.46834358990.12148246921.41099950170.9433144823
214469_atHIST1H2AE3.84196938931.85641439610.48319343753.70918708770.9433144823
211889_x_atCEACAM13.83426178571.91675664430.49990239364.95656564280.9433144823
203823_atRGS33.83239235550.72709765230.18972422051.60220534180.9433144823
200832_s_atSCD3.8295655031.50361965550.39263453112.96671762640.9433144823
221687_s_atFLJ000013.82293589860.65579050220.17154106681.56998828090.9433144823
203054_s_atTCTA3.82157172350.39980408240.104617711.33628705740.9433144823
206576_s_atCEACAM13.81791210331.42818853430.37407580263.20326682790.9433144823
207949_s_atICA13.81227009030.80693799160.21166863121.65156401160.9433144823
216835_s_atDOK13.81074968950.48425148490.12707512281.41614554770.9433144823
203430_atHEBP23.80634963380.56463869230.14834125781.49523116150.9433144823
200951_s_atCCND23.79862774680.92615083060.2438119481.90602688620.9433144823
200996_atACTR33.79728756070.53471077610.14081387511.47416074710.9433144823
212461_atOAZIN3.79641411220.66359374390.17479487861.68544599320.9433144823
217976_s_atDNCLI13.79566910890.59876119570.1577485231.56714321530.9433144823
207890_s_atMMP253.79354876631.32519570460.34932876482.9087585820.9433144823
203559_s_atABP13.79189950311.43228086010.37772120783.37611667620.9433144823
201500_s_atPPP1R113.78356750770.35994544840.09513387771.30679731731.1415428764
218923_atSPATA13.78248078140.86190214030.22786689221.93601806921.1415428764
209435_s_atARHGEF23.77759462810.50338433080.13325525381.45388307611.1415428764
218963_s_atKRT233.77111354962.38792921820.63321594196.80478856921.1415428764
210925_atMHC2TA3.77001472621.43614749560.38093949223.09187987731.1415428764
221504_s_atATP6V1H3.7683080710.40276537330.1068822841.33870384221.1415428764
210981_s_atGPRK63.76812036320.58118488070.15423734511.54350426821.1415428764
209498_atCEACAM13.76757630222.39650159730.63608574997.21936496781.1415428764
213117_atKIAA13543.76660638391.00349739140.26641950051.95038979451.1415428764
204336_s_atRGS193.76554546980.7163695820.19024324311.7519174351.1415428764
209471_s_atFNTA3.76496364520.31167778270.0827837431.2468255821.1415428764
214151_s_atCPR83.75597983020.87209745970.23218906891.94799495551.1415428764
212358_atCLIPR-593.75491769420.49228434680.13110389811.43244042881.1415428764
203090_atSDF23.75463134860.36305592930.0966954931.29969665371.1415428764
218728_s_atHSPC1633.75117760580.77152564770.20567558481.81724688531.1415428764
218946_atHIRIP53.74607353980.38137388680.10180630011.32139343761.1415428764
58696_atRRP413.74136663220.5446454130.14557392171.4986453951.1415428764
215044_s_atSTAM23.73253887090.47141635570.12629911491.40029655381.1415428764
201553_s_atLAMP13.72660824750.33057561980.08870683421.27263561251.1415428764
201288_atARHGDIB3.7223208270.34147046980.0917359051.28121484081.1415428764
219044_atFLJ109163.72090216730.79947495770.21486051551.51927399681.1415428764
52975_atFLJ000013.71607598830.57271948420.15411942221.53465258261.1415428764
202119_s_atCPNE33.71579422861.43139219530.38521836983.51800392691.1415428764
221819_atRAB353.70806994690.47856156460.12905947611.42237041381.1415428764
208470_s_atHPR3.70616989282.96033312430.798758073711.92641487851.1415428764
211142_x_atHLA-DOA3.69999454110.65619648780.17735066381.59383306751.1415428764
209396_s_atCHI3L13.69935480632.77071829330.74897338559.23407922421.1415428764
219620_x_atFLJ202453.69828469820.55120469130.14904333671.42116731041.1415428764
202907_s_atNBS13.69669739070.53268416740.14409731471.50806683531.1415428764
218213_s_atC11orf103.69088723180.46900008650.12706974151.41188484461.1415428764
203490_atELF43.69040310071.11503387750.30214419591.87316510761.1415428764
218143_s_atSCAMP23.68929994160.38000404210.10300166651.30657662481.1415428764
213851_athttp://genome-www4.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/SMD/source/sourceResult?choice=Gene&option=Name&criteria=3.68750094540.60270651830.16344579361.48510735591.1415428764
206440_atLIN7A3.68705534541.88627236950.51159318014.21431675671.1415428764
207157_s_atGNG53.674477950.45189691190.12298261631.39727457341.4300662968
210044_s_atLYL13.66705010160.73050716530.19920839511.76996320211.4300662968
209551_atMGC110613.66533058170.66688747550.18194470071.61117711121.4300662968
219296_atHIP14L3.66085485080.71362238540.19493326411.75193176231.4300662968
216881_x_atPRB43.65655224030.74814263050.20460329331.66841969141.4300662968
211728_s_atHYAL33.6505187081.39453211130.38200930412.80366654281.4300662968
35265_atFXR23.64969633450.46968862830.12869252271.42248460211.4300662968
216092_s_atSLC7A83.64072918870.57049336840.15669755671.49564687151.4300662968
206222_atTNFRSF10C3.63315721631.46319649120.40273415223.51248138741.4300662968
218556_atORMDL23.62972026250.64543768840.1778202291.61927899611.4300662968
201968_s_atPGM13.62657271920.73083389170.20152191841.78947749011.4300662968
209238_atSTX3A3.62612368260.87188455250.2404453432.09523085071.4300662968
216460_athttp://genome-www4.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/SMD/source/sourceResult?choice=Gene&option=Name&criteria=3.61295279451.20590512490.3337727322.51818522681.4300662968
217836_s_atYAP3.61254722220.40105423790.1110170231.33156060881.4300662968
213279_atDHRS13.60890764320.40190073370.11136354081.3213332911.4300662968
216028_atDKFZP564C1523.60739983020.5532690380.15337058941.51881004031.4300662968
205715_atBST13.60081823871.16310898450.3230124122.60666146771.6385856601
204429_s_atSLC2A53.59979467761.04954352880.29155649772.38286714441.6385856601
221634_atRPL23AP73.59976187341.64276618480.45635412632.8513720411.6385856601
206209_s_atCA43.59436651531.22745035380.3414928192.83486432271.6385856601
219964_atST7L3.59066944521.19167065360.3318797992.46977329971.6385856601
209250_atDEGS3.58839601280.73418670780.20460024621.73903257651.6385856601
208308_s_atGPI3.58821735160.94764660930.2640995562.17820722721.6385856601
204340_atCXorf123.58373091951.51805149750.42359527872.41423669391.6385856601
203675_atNUCB23.57988724611.01564929270.28370985532.27866988711.6385856601
219356_s_atHSPC1773.57857109510.68006996570.19003952911.65309765731.6385856601
206734_atJRKL3.57193433661.02281645710.2863480571.98875041361.6385856601
209395_atCHI3L13.56524719033.35862033550.942044171514.45465329141.6385856601
207419_s_atRAC23.56363129860.71822846480.20154398831.76193234771.6385856601
215765_atMUF13.56212184050.69923631640.19629769781.53156614161.6385856601
220000_atSIGLEC53.55051756730.99731193520.28089198722.30368862461.6385856601
205847_atPRSS223.54930644640.44057700250.12413044891.3819370461.6385856601
208736_atARPC33.54666808310.4785308120.13492404721.42943655991.6385856601
218451_atCDCP13.53158343751.19883638350.33946143562.97394125571.6385856601
212519_atUBE2E13.52490902610.52256761390.14824995771.48706464341.6385856601
219913_s_atCRNKL13.52454783610.6338036090.17982550911.6552169331.6385856601
209001_s_atDKFZP566D1933.52362473670.26678874640.07571429031.21098973441.6385856601
210101_x_atSH3GLB13.52231720920.44279682770.12571179751.40004731311.6385856601
212971_atCARS3.52201724960.32565781630.09246343591.27233998391.6385856601
207153_s_atGLMN3.51912375340.65177821510.18521037081.52067027261.6385856601
213294_atFLJ383483.51384064860.72531790510.20641741551.8273656821.6385856601
222221_x_atEHD13.51328926950.67742932370.19281911391.70685758952.050953184
219049_atChGn3.51210954851.07514973610.30612648072.36107595992.050953184
201463_s_atTALDO13.50890461450.66720783020.19014704121.71188177292.050953184
209071_s_atRGS53.5078486561.10577192730.31522794622.63098236782.050953184
217007_s_atADAM153.50488620581.45923066850.41634181053.04662410522.050953184
214523_atCEBPE3.49367484251.69645071750.48557773524.36366721742.050953184
222014_x_atMTO13.49362359350.51469450330.14732397171.46538696262.050953184
201594_s_atPPP4R13.49330785260.48802079620.13970162861.4407494812.050953184
208734_x_atRAB23.492250010.40746096640.11667577211.3445814722.050953184
208966_x_atIFI163.49088027570.64861754180.18580343371.62838773642.050953184
212526_atSPG203.49031160590.86763143250.24858280021.97925238732.050953184
209287_s_atCDC42EP33.48848575040.71805332360.20583524631.65718846932.050953184
211961_s_atRAB73.48789632840.3657308990.10485715871.30642160562.050953184
209039_x_atEHD13.48482180940.63188247640.18132418561.66465867252.050953184
218812_s_atC7orf193.48432658530.77304682150.22186405391.82287688352.050953184
214540_atHIST1H2BO3.48331773621.2938109960.37143065723.53680938252.050953184
203013_atHSGT13.48087013260.38509062510.11063056381.28563570642.050953184
204011_atSPRY23.47953863941.6933091320.48664760123.19421441982.050953184
210140_atCST73.47919088271.23661779440.35543258082.76467246432.050953184
214472_atHIST1H3D3.46986510561.24363844090.35841117832.64861249632.050953184
218007_s_atRPS27L3.46529616780.50721159160.1463689011.48341381492.050953184
201319_atMRCL33.45979865120.39736629350.11485243321.31946537682.050953184
214778_atEGFL43.45506706791.45178531070.42019019664.04501347712.050953184
220489_s_atTDE23.45422556551.07380275190.31086642482.50239850242.050953184
213828_x_atH3F3A3.43989143490.38224312950.11112069571.33210067752.050953184
206697_s_atHP3.43854671291.76525165930.51337143474.60736045792.050953184
205479_s_atPLAU3.43833695870.82851149610.24096285681.90514279782.050953184
209628_atNXT23.43567025610.57757012090.16810988191.54775755492.050953184
217977_atSEPX13.43216805961.51733937560.44209355413.84287544172.050953184
202718_atIGFBP23.43123460991.88736987180.55005561742.99223907392.050953184
213214_x_atACTG13.43008007820.30349202510.08847957431.23691235162.050953184
202627_s_atSERPINE13.42974910981.32117347970.3852099492.62042999022.050953184
221856_s_atFLJ112803.42770409680.67222097510.19611406241.63499579772.050953184
200738_s_atPGK13.42700431650.29038678860.08473487681.2369360052.050953184
214381_atna3.42671062711.02994676910.30056426742.08507135022.050953184
209448_atHTATIP23.42084120890.81680241240.23877238451.81973845012.050953184
200654_atP4HB3.4194233420.62102018740.18161547291.61793475252.050953184
210951_x_atRAB27A3.41939439930.79448012390.23234527261.92949111542.050953184
205471_s_atDACH3.41900678421.06421212230.31126353052.41755720192.050953184
214080_x_atPRKCSH3.4187207930.31543262330.09226627221.25793663992.050953184
217835_x_atC20orf243.41785213140.48487077330.14186417511.45737626772.050953184
201602_s_atPPP1R12A3.41755050930.75491100610.22089242111.80288337152.050953184
204093_atCCNH3.41733860850.40222423170.11770101761.33937572572.050953184
221579_s_atNUDT33.41126521520.33581575730.09844316881.27004079162.5040850141
202814_s_atHIS13.41033320410.68809632590.20176806331.75670928682.5040850141
205726_atDIAPH23.41015429630.62145960940.18223797381.63205793582.5040850141
214378_atTFPI3.40610039370.96638730710.28372249651.75823636622.5040850141
219185_atSIRT53.40464848710.39225934770.11521287711.33666237992.5040850141
204121_atGADD45G3.40351651251.7368798860.51031921833.46349910252.5040850141
221505_atANP32E3.40350059410.50874311620.14947642941.45845115182.5040850141
211983_x_atACTG13.39724107120.3109242780.0915225831.24341209352.5040850141
201991_s_atKIF5B3.39703049460.37714099090.11102078461.31530266842.5040850141
219924_s_atZNF2583.39400630450.65715510880.19362224161.55549913072.5040850141
201352_atYME1L13.38680004680.25247612330.07454710051.19491077772.5040850141
204601_atN4BP13.38303145050.71724262820.21201181211.74169896072.5040850141
202266_atTTRAP3.38089747710.54897491480.1623754991.50513108652.5040850141
204949_atICAM33.38060459320.80154003610.23709961161.90876322442.5040850141
212870_atC14orf1383.37745451340.7456738360.22077983081.83653521392.5040850141
205857_atSLC18A23.3710180541.22671696370.36390103642.27417950732.5040850141
32069_atN4BP13.36995391360.71612151060.21250187061.78805008382.5040850141
219253_atFAM11B3.36898897410.67264166260.19965683111.70419469732.5040850141
201673_s_atGYS13.36036585360.72245317880.21499241761.79130583862.5040850141
214465_atORM13.35433349272.14107884080.63830231718.94477573242.5040850141
213526_s_atF259653.3521869230.52386946360.15627692481.44967348482.5040850141
213779_atEMU13.35149967090.60580612050.18075672981.55497888512.5040850141
203399_x_atPSG33.348576520.95990994090.28666208912.05631811492.5040850141
222294_s_atRAB27A3.3450119391.01281527310.30278375432.40734441122.5040850141
213002_atMARCKS3.34205076620.79125737590.23675803611.88026062812.5040850141
213410_atEDRF13.34077419550.57512676990.17215373931.51493319962.5040850141
209188_x_atDR13.33958466050.39647972930.11872126921.3442766242.5040850141
211075_s_atCD473.33198282150.32225112420.09671452151.26282899152.5040850141
202297_s_atRER13.32858062760.3691797380.11091206111.30580086862.5040850141
221554_atLYK53.32617943750.50266538040.15112395161.4134988313.1113177356
219242_atFLJ133863.32111464030.6960529990.2095841531.70045333513.1113177356
204044_atQPRT3.32088774761.30098029470.39175678123.00815508983.1113177356
202275_atG6PD3.31856011671.07002118130.32243537672.50910050123.1113177356
213513_x_atARPC23.31773738560.3318028740.10000878171.28021770933.1113177356
212505_s_atKIAA08923.31456985340.39604168750.11948509311.29583422293.1113177356
200653_s_atCALM13.31307750490.49911126790.15064883551.4713424833.1113177356
201550_x_atACTG13.31115253390.28918428640.08733644361.2249141233.1113177356
219998_atHSPC1593.30966678151.77221632870.53546669375.74853717713.1113177356
216981_x_atSPN3.30386295390.712880780.21577189791.7122471973.1113177356
219770_atFLJ117533.297511460.35615071810.10800590761.30195282423.1113177356
217746_s_atPDCD6IP3.29492588450.25163206040.07636956621.19855019453.1113177356
212988_x_atACTG13.29435290110.29084113670.08828475441.23137793663.1113177356
207094_atIL8RA3.28930665792.22007549550.674937221210.31876075733.1113177356
220911_s_atKIAA13053.28757300061.37236570330.41744037413.11192980763.1113177356
209019_s_atPINK13.28559763870.59097251870.17986758691.57310310183.1113177356
208168_s_atCHIT13.27941397712.01540097630.61456131816.68932038833.1113177356
212305_s_atFLJ392073.27899976550.36541600380.11144130221.28819303143.1113177356
201256_atCOX7A2L3.27591603230.50560075730.15433874141.48301486533.1113177356
218795_atACP63.27464520210.81451413210.24873355182.0102690213.1113177356
210242_x_atLOC2836873.27303012730.39374273650.12029914821.33695033193.1113177356
219079_atNCB5OR3.27210875390.49379301410.15090971951.45423061793.1113177356
202441_atKEO43.26775015050.70576287080.2159782231.73978515533.1113177356
53912_atSNX113.26537574420.59011734470.1807