garcia, norman (ofc) sent: october 31, 2019 2:05 pm to ... · 1 dey, asit (sd) from: garcia, norman...

22
1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa (OFC); Escarlan, Mary Lynn (OFC) Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) - File 3285.10 Good afternoon Jennifer, Thank you for the opportunity to review this file and provide comments. The OFC recommends that the proponent to: - Comply with the Manitoba Fire Code, - Submit Fire Safety Plan (as per NFC Section 2.8) to local fire department, and - Obtain required permits from the Authority Having Jurisdiction. Regards, Norman A. Garcia, P.Eng., LEED AP BD+C Building and Fire Safety Engineer Office of the Fire Commissioner 508-401 York Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3C 0P8 P: 204-794-3840 [email protected] www.firecomm.gov.mb.ca www.manitoba.ca From: Escarlan, Mary Lynn (OFC) <[email protected]> Sent: October 31, 2019 12:26 PM To: Garcia, Norman (OFC) <[email protected]> Cc: Morhun, Lisa (OFC) <[email protected]> Subject: FW: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) File 3285.10 ***Please note this email is being tracked. Please carbon copy or blind copy or reply to me when completed. Thank you!***

Upload: others

Post on 13-Aug-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: Garcia, Norman (OFC)Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Cc: Morhun, Lisa (OFC); Escarlan, Mary Lynn (OFC)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

Good afternoon Jennifer, Thank you for the opportunity to review this file and provide comments. The OFC recommends that the proponent to: - Comply with the Manitoba Fire Code, - Submit Fire Safety Plan (as per NFC Section 2.8) to local fire department, and - Obtain required permits from the Authority Having Jurisdiction. Regards, Norman A. Garcia, P.Eng., LEED AP BD+C Building and Fire Safety Engineer Office of the Fire Commissioner 508-401 York Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3C 0P8 P: 204-794-3840 [email protected] www.firecomm.gov.mb.ca www.manitoba.ca

  

From: Escarlan, Mary Lynn (OFC) <[email protected]>  Sent: October 31, 2019 12:26 PM To: Garcia, Norman (OFC) <[email protected]> Cc: Morhun, Lisa (OFC) <[email protected]> Subject: FW: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  

***Please note this email is being tracked.

Please carbon copy or blind copy or reply to me when completed. Thank you!***

Page 2: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October‐31‐19 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) <[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Good morning,  Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:  https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html  Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.  Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.  **No hard copies will be provided**  Thank you,   Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 Fax: 204‐945‐5229 

  

Page 3: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: Kelly, Jason (SD)Sent: October 31, 2019 2:27 PMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

Parks has reviewed the proposal and has no comments to offer.   

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October‐31‐19 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) <[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Good morning,  Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:  https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html  Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.  Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.  **No hard copies will be provided**  Thank you,   Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 

Page 4: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

Fax: 204‐945‐5229 

  

Page 5: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: Miller, Glenn (SD)Sent: October 31, 2019 2:08 PMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

No concerns from Eastern Region IRMT.  Thanks   Glenn Miller (204) 345‐1435 Eastern Region A/Eastern Region Wildfire Superintendent  

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October 31, 2019 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) <[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Good morning,  Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:  https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html  Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.  Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.  **No hard copies will be provided**  Thank you,   

Page 6: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 Fax: 204‐945‐5229 

  

Page 7: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: Vitt, Cory (SD)Sent: November 1, 2019 9:28 AMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

No concerns. Office of Drinking Water (ODW)  

Cory Vitt, CMMA M.Eng. P.Eng. 

(My name is Cory. Please refrain from any prefixes like "Mr. Vitt”) Approvals Engineer Office of Drinking Water Department of Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, Manitoba  R3H 0W4 Phone: 204‐806‐1363 Fax: 204‐945‐1365 Email: [email protected] 

 

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October 31, 2019 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) <[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Good morning,  Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:  https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html  Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.  Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.  **No hard copies will be provided** 

Page 8: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

 Thank you,   Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 Fax: 204‐945‐5229 

  

Page 9: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: Toop, David (SD)Sent: November 1, 2019 2:18 PMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Cc: Phipps, Graham (SD)Subject: EA Lactalis 3285.10

Hi Jennifer  I reviewed the proposal with respect to groundwater resources. I don’t have any concerns.   David Toop    Hydrogeologist Groundwater Management 200 Saulteaux Crescent Winnipeg 2049450162 

Page 10: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: Kiss, Brian (SD)Sent: November 5, 2019 2:05 PMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

No wildlife related concerns.  ‐Brian Kiss  

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October 31, 2019 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) <[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Good morning,  Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:  https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html  Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.  Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.  **No hard copies will be provided**  Thank you,   Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street 

Page 11: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 Fax: 204‐945‐5229 

  

Page 12: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: +WPG574 - HRB Archaeology (SCH)Sent: November 12, 2019 10:59 AMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

Good morning,  The Historic Resources Branch has reviewed the Environment Act Proposal (3285.10) in the RM of Hanover (Grunthal) for Lactalis Canada in conjunction with Branch records. The potential to impact significant heritage resources has been considered low in the area at this time, therefore, the Historic Resources Branch has no immediate concerns with the proposed EAP.  If at any time, however, heritage resources are encountered in association with these lands during future development, the Historic Resources Branch must be contacted and may require that an acceptable heritage resource management strategy be implemented by the developer to mitigate the effects of development on the heritage resources.  Thanks!  Hani Khalidi Impact Assessment Archaeologist Sport, Culture and Heritage Government of Manitoba  Historic Resources 204‐945‐3130 [email protected] 

  

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October‐31‐19 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) 

Page 13: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

<[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Good morning,  Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:  https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html  Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.  Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.  **No hard copies will be provided**  Thank you,   Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 Fax: 204‐945‐5229 

  

Page 14: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: +WPG1195 - Mines BR (GET)Sent: November 21, 2019 1:13 PMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

Hi Jennifer,  Mines Branch has no concerns with this proposal  Tim Davis GIS Specialist, Tenure and Regulatory Geoscience Data Management Section Resource Development Division

360-1395 Ellice Ave, Winnipeg, MB (204)945-6525 [email protected]    

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October‐31‐19 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) <[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Good morning,  Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:  https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html  Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.  Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.  

Page 15: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

**No hard copies will be provided**  Thank you,   Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 Fax: 204‐945‐5229 

  

Page 16: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Memorandum DATE: November 25, 2019 TO: Jennifer Winsor

Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4

FROM: Rayson Wong Community Planner Community Planning Branch 240-323 Main St. Steinbach, MB R5G 1Z2

PHONE: 204-346-6244 FAX: 204-346-7305 EMAIL: [email protected] SUBJECT: Environment Act Proposal File 3285.10 – Lactalis Canada – RM of Hanover Community Planning- Steinbach Region has reviewed The Environmental Act proposal from a land use planning perspective. Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) has filed a proposal to install and operate a reverse osmosis system to process whey at the existing dairy plant in Grunthal. The subject properties consist of Titles 2280856 and 2280859, which combined together encompasses a total area of 4.7 acres. However, it is noted that Section 1.1 of the Environment Act Proposal states that the Grunthal facility is situated on 89 acres of land. The expansion is considered an expansion of the existing dairy plant, which is categorized as “processing plant” under the RM of Hanover’s Zoning By-Law. As the primary use will not change due to the expansion, the continued use of the processing plant continues to comply with the RM of Hanover Development Plan and Zoning By-Law. However, as the footprint of the building will be altered, the expanded portion must meet yard requirements specified in the Zoning By-Law. The Environment Act Proposal does not specify the front yard measurement (ie. The distance from the wall fronting the road to the road). If this distance is shorter than the minimum front yard requirement of 50 ft., a variance order would be required. Community Planning notes that the subject 4.7 acre property is zoned “C” Commercial Zone at the southern portion closest to the intersection of Elm Ave. and Main St., and “I” Industrial Zone on the majority of the title, including where the processing plant is located. S. 3.1 of the Environment Act Proposal should be revised to reflect this. The proposed development is in keeping with the intent and policies identified in the RM of Hanover Development Plan. Our office has no concerns with respect to the Environment Act proposal subject to ensuring that the new building footprint meets front yard site requirements.

Page 17: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

Thank you for the opportunity to review. I trust that this submission will assist in the review of the proposed project. Please contact me at the above number if you have any questions or require further information. Yours truly, originally sent by email

Rayson Wong Community Planner

Page 18: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: Epp, Jane (SD)Sent: November 25, 2019 2:16 PMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

No concerns.  Jane Epp  

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October 31, 2019 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) <[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Good morning,  Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:  https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html  Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.  Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.  **No hard copies will be provided**  Thank you,   Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street 

Page 19: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 Fax: 204‐945‐5229 

  

Page 20: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

1

Dey, Asit (SD)

From: Lerner, Jordyn (HSAL)Sent: November 28, 2019 12:36 PMTo: Winsor, Jennifer (SD)Cc: Isaac, Michael (HSAL); Roussin, Brent (HSAL); Roberecki, Susan (HSAL)Subject: RE: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review - Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) -

File 3285.10

Hi Jennifer,  Health has reviewed the proposal and has no concerns.   

From: Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>  Sent: November 19, 2019 2:53 PM To: Lerner, Jordyn (HSAL) <[email protected]> Subject: FW: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10  Here is the other one.  Thanks  Susan  Susan Roberecki, MD, FRCPC, MSc. Medical Officer of Health - Environmental Health Health, Seniors and Active Living Government of Manitoba 300 Carlton Street, Winnipeg, R3B 3M9 204-788-6699 [email protected] www.manitoba.ca

Confidentiality Notice: This message and any attachment to it are intended for the addressee only and may contain legally privileged or confidential information. Any unauthorized use, disclosure, distribution, or copying is strictly prohibited. Please notify the sender if you have received this E-mail by mistake, and please delete it and the attachments (and all copies) in a secure manner. Thank you.

Message de confidentialité : Ce message et tout document dans cette transmission est destiné à la personne ou aux personnes à qui il est adressé. Il peut contenir des informations privilégiées ou confidentielles. Toute utilisation, divulgation, distribution ou copie non autorisée est strictement défendue. Si vous n'êtes pas le destinataire de ce courriel, veuillez en informer l'expéditeur et effacer l'original (et toutes les pièces jointes) de manière sécuritaire. Merci. 

Page 21: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

2

      

From: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) <[email protected]>  Sent: October‐31‐19 11:46 AM To: Kohler, Shannon (SD) <[email protected]>; Crocker, Peter (SD) <[email protected]>; Markwart, Larry (SD) <[email protected]>; Cunningham, Neil (SD) <[email protected]>; Molod, Rommel (SD) <[email protected]>; Kiss, Brian (SD) <[email protected]>; Janusz, Laureen R (SD) <[email protected]>; Kelly, Jason (SD) <[email protected]>; Epp, Jane (SD) <[email protected]>; Conrod, Matt (SD) <[email protected]>; Frias, Winifred (SD) <[email protected]>; Miller, Glenn (SD) <[email protected]>; Page, Elaine (SD) <[email protected]>; Phipps, Graham (SD) <[email protected]>; Vitt, Cory (SD) <[email protected]>; Stonehouse, Perry (SD) <[email protected]>; +WPG574 ‐ HRB Archaeology (SCH) <[email protected]>; +WPG1195 ‐ Mines BR (GET) <[email protected]>; Mraz, Peter (GET) <[email protected]>; +WPG112 ‐ FireComm (OFC) <[email protected]>; Beruar, Omkar (GET) <[email protected]>; Roberecki, Susan (HSAL) <[email protected]>; Roberts, Tracy (HSAL) <[email protected]>; +BEA208 ‐ Beausejour CRP (MR) <[email protected]>; +WPG969 ‐ MIT Environmental Services Section (MI) <[email protected]> Subject: Environment Act Proposal for TAC Review ‐ Lactalis Canada (formerly Parmalat) ‐ File 3285.10   Good morning,   Your review and comment is requested for the following Environment Act Proposal submitted pursuant to The Environment Act:   https://www.gov.mb.ca/sd/eal/registries/3285.10parmalat_grunthal/index.html   Please let me know if you are unable to review the Proposal.  A non‐reply will be considered as indicating your department has reviewed the Proposal and has no concerns.   Any comments you have on the Proposal should be emailed to me on or before by November 29th, 2019.   **No hard copies will be provided**   Thank you,     Jennifer Winsor, P.Eng. Environmental Engineer Environmental Approvals Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street Winnipeg, MB R3H 0W4 Ph: 204‐945‐7012 Fax: 204‐945‐5229     

Page 22: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To ... · 1 Dey, Asit (SD) From: Garcia, Norman (OFC) Sent: October 31, 2019 2:05 PM To: Winsor, Jennifer (SD) Cc: Morhun, Lisa

DATE: 29 November 2019

TO: Jennifer Winsor Environmental Approvals Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street, Winnipeg

FROM: Muntaseer Ibn Azkar Air Quality Section Environmental Compliance and Enforcement Branch Manitoba Conservation and Climate 1007 Century Street, Winnipeg

SUBJECT: Lactalis Canada Inc (Formerly Parmalat Canada Inc.) � Dairy Plant

(File: 3285.10). Air Quality Section has reviewed the above proposal and provides the following comments: Based on the provided information, it is expected that there will be no significant impact on

air quality due to this proposal.

Air Quality Section suggests that the EA Clause regarding noise and odor nuisance be included.