The FSTP Test:

A Software System for Assessing an ET Cl's Practical and SPLQuality

www.fstp-expert-system.com

FSTP-IESIES - A Prototype of an eKnowledge Based Patent Expert System TELE.~H

FSTP Case Dis p la y Adm. Docs H elp Feedback l ogOUI

FSTP-TestDemov erS. ofOOR '399 patent AVI

Overview Case Document

Demovers . of DDR '399 p OilIE'DIAVI

pat en t Name

~.fETHODS OF EXPAr-.Ull'GCO~RCIAL OPPORTUNIT IESFOR INTERNETWEBSITESTHROUGH COORDP.-lATED OFFSITIMARKETING

Do c u m e nt s

TT.OMETHODS OFEXPANDING COM."lERClAL

Rl OPPORTtTh'TIES FORINTE RJffiTWE BSITESTHROUGH COORD~ATED

OFF SITE MARKE TING

laws

35 USC

EPC

PatG

Co u rt s

US Co u rts

USSC

CAFC

Distr ic t Courts

EU

European Court of Human Rights

Court of Jus t ice of t he EU

EPO's Enlarged Board of Appeal

DE

Feder al Cour t of Jusbce (BGH)

Federal Pat ent Court

PTO

Administrative Documen ts

~ 35 USC §112

lEI 35 USC §103

~ EPC Articl e 52- 56

E:l Pat G §14

Preceden ts

lEI Graham v, Deere

!EJ Phillips v , AWH Corp .

lEI damping Screw

Directive s

~ 35 USC §102

~ 35 USC § lO l

IE! EPC Article 69

~ PatG § § 1~ 4

lEI KSR v , Teleflex

lEIRetra c table Tech V, Bec t on

lEI Demonstr at ion Locke r

Basic requirements for an FSTP Test are e.g.:

- A TTO to be tested

- Which Patent Law System to apply

Reference Set of prior art (optional)

Precedents to refer to in argumentation (optional)

- Applicable PTO Directives (optional/depending on situation)

- Technical documentation to grasp general knowledge of TTOcontext (optional)

Upload Files for MUI 's of TTO into the System

FSTP-Test prompts:T..t I

3

_ 1lItF" ..-I... ,....... ... _..... ...·-..-er... t ' 8-'1':lO~.. lI'11J Ao-tR3lA'_ ..1AD..e-_ " Ior ., ft'SB.!nt I n ,,," !JRS! ' 'r-o,l '-,,~ _llstQ1l>_ ,...,~__........ _ f

'IU I 1,.

_ , ., w...,o I. _ 1''''WJ'_ ,..,.,. 4b.w.M.......... . _-qI.~I.-.pl"ll "- IIll).co(lloI;• •-~_ . "'~lrr""' BlIT..vl_" 1lll" -OIOt; ... II,,_.IOlOll"A'"'"'t

~_ ' '' A .~._. _I'!If,U1J>

_ ....., .,. ......""..... ,..... _1'!O.WJ'. ... · lfIWl.t --.m.....................t1..- ........._"' ............

.. ""'·..,'"'~,,~~._ l'~~.""' s.->.. I __ ""._.-.._~f)_... ..... ..,l'lI~,..m.· _ ._"" 1l11.W!"..... ·Gt_ T_ .__.._ ........ TlO_ IIS. __4~•• ....-.---.

......_ .M;fj·...III••• ,U l. l ·1" 1 _ _ ..~N(_., fS"'_.. ..,_.,... IoI_ t1__..,.«__....,., .,;1.. ... _ ...._ "._. ............~., .. ......- --II .-..,__..M_..... ~IIOIl__o-" ..._~-"

You . e on : . . ./US 7,n 8, l 99 1 1

Up lo ad Doc:um ent

r-... ct>oos.ilPOf "" to uplo oloCl .,u. "",,... METHODS OFEXPANDING CO

liP.It....' Appk.. _ ProMc ut>on.:~ DOll; ']99p,l 1..1

oc.c-t : TT.O

TELEa.H

Before testing starts some names have to be input andthe document(s) with the specification of the TTO is uploadedinto the sysrtem so you can refer to parts from it inside thesystem

Starting the FSTP Test by Input of CI Elements

FSTP-Test prompts:~5TP """ I 8 \

... 1loo~' I",I.. ,......._..... _ .--,..-cr.I."'....I'!lO,!lIf>~ .. "'" .~O_ '"~..... _11$.1~'"_ ..,. 1M _f1SOU1}>_ , ,- ..,. ' . _ , .... 'qI .NPl1.-.lK"l ..- Il1koCIlot. - 1IlOaOIlot..._ ,~IIJ-.lIt(rNl_ ly 1If0'.c. ... . .,1_ .. , _.-.

1E00...c.""A,e_ -~.WJ>

1E0'..ca "" • •1lu.-=*·em-::a......._ , ,..,,, ~ I .......

• 1loo· 1..r. .....m .. "" oIAbo . ...... ... _ .. ......,....

fI '~I~ ..~...c:oolt . ..__D-.._....I" .NPlI.-ofll"l _1\ m .ftIfI ...-.,._"fJ __1ooIoII .. 1J '21""",_m _ .-t.

_"'~IU1.UI'I>

• 1'Oo· Gt....,MIt'_-....._ .....""fII_RS._....--........,.-._....__N::Jl·"'RS ••S~,IJ.11J11 ._....•............... IIl _ oIn Tl'-. _oI .. ..I_oI_-..,.,__....,.·,L,),_.,.._"._ ---.-.,...__..,........................,,..,.••-.., ..M _ ... ""''''''''::.I__~..y_~.1J

y ou ..... ", : •• ./US 1.1 11,»9 I I

Elem ent

I~:.:.,=.:.::;..",:.::;;,,=:::;'~~~""'''I~

~

I Save I~ ""p...t..:l ...... Doo..on«lt rum. .. ,ttl "...... us1.81 8, )99 81

p.,. ..t. d ...... P.t''''t~.non l'roMalbQn .......

4 TELEa.H

For this presentation we will look at an FSTP Test for a TTO only;no Reference Set

Starting the Test (shown in the left hand window) by identifyingits CI "element s"

First Results

W a-,,'0000 :- OOJ

!; 0.... ;.....:.... ODR'J99_ A\·I Hyperbolic T..- fOf"c._: Oemo".re OOA '399 ~t.nt AY lli- n o n 1l It ' 'l'J DI TT.Q US1.81 8; J 99 8 l

~ X. O .l S ---;;;;;

X0 1S)__...... _ =-~ X0 1S,-__pn _

~/

5

I

) ,- --- -",TELEa.H

3 CI elements have been identified by the user - anotherpresentation of it

Reminder to User - Continue with "No"

FSTP-Test prompts:F~I"' llI\

... lMfITP.' ......,.. ... _....... _·--..-cr.l. tll ...., I'\IO~» ltt'f1T' ''o.I-flSI A1_ . 'f'W aCIooln O," W1_,.., IlM:J.aCOo.~ _ IUlll.1J1J>IOlI ::o(IIFl)..c,(D"II..... :~ .... --efll.

First MUI for First Element

- ?;l ,fE., M·ta'· E. lI'dBEEN====:.....--,~_______________ 0 1<

Imlll 1111 I W1 1111 111 IElI m i ll I--~--.-----.USOO7S183'HB I

"" nited Sta tes Paten tRo\ \ . J r. et at

(101 Patent ~o. : US7.818.399 HI( ~~ I I)a lr or Parent: Oct. 19, 2010

U I1"l70 " S 1_ \\ .. .__.__ 70S 14

UJ1.l14 " ' 1_ Ka-. _~.__~_._._ 70S 14

«'ntlll....'

Mark-up for the Second Element

- t"++ff " ft' P.5 ' ,_ 'Wi(D I< 0 >!PMjle JtI

x 0 2 Systemoomprt ..

X02A1.lhesamebme, I

63

8

!I'",Ie n...... "iii(.b .. ~r~'lCllml iiil l lllniia l'o~ ..rr ...IIOfI~ 11Jt''Jmft''~_1lIIr' C"Ih.ll .,..~ I IItlo:rlbo.'lf 1k't"'llh hnb. kPnlJll rn:oml "fl,lllllC:rommc:n:co Ipk'llll.nd rn",idn odlo:T bm·lk....ck,...'l1 ink". IWJtl;ofdl'I";tt;hrTt1ulll '''''' TIIuf l'' 'fIU·..... il. ht.-pa I" rcWl/CIh"l l~ hal .. lllc: "'l!!) M;al\'C' 11It.•• fl,I"'I" ~"""""''fI;C I} telll"" mdhnd ul ltlc:~'ll'''-.It\,"I: \ .. 11"..... S"",b ",,,'bo,lc 'Mn,,:" bo.)I.3lll.. 1M:1Ilbl.: IlIWllU,nn,.........-nt•• no.'" r.:o,..,Jlll'n" (~ n..1I·h1""'.. 111mo.T~h ..'fltlillC'

Some Parts of the Screen can be Detached for Better Readability

i :..-Upd.tltd Cone""t Comrnotnl WIth ..-.n', ....1. tIwIl SAO-C.)IS definlle

lJP

Starting with the BED Concepts

FSTP-Test prompts:F'ln>t_t l .. 1

10

_ TIoofSl"·r... ,...... ... _IIO ... _.--,.-a... •, a-'111I0"",1'1 "",,, ,,,,, ,, ,_ . 'I~ .. n ......._,-~........ _ ll I1ll.U'"

~1Il S::"fllfCkoCllUl I, _ , I/IrlHo(J/o_ . --WlHoOJU A_ ,, --.III.~""_"1_""'~.""""._...., -~_ •.,.S _ 1lIIIiIIIIIIIUU_ •.,., -.....- -1'_UIJI'

_ • ., ilI' U'-W IOfws"SS.. . (Iobool ·....,""""" _ ltSG.1J7I>_ . " .,. ~!I"""". _ 1'1O,t$1~_ , '" ......... .._... _ltSG.U/J>_ .,. __ ' . trtt ·InII"cl IJ4lllI~ A-Ilo..ow. ....-~_ I~ ..-.iltO';II4_.,. 1Il0'...ca ''''''' '_ A'_ ''~

ll(D'_ .. A'~·__I'lO,lJ1I>

_ ".,,.....,. IiRM't*'W I ....• n. ·...'_ _~110........~ _ _~ ... _ ... .....,

Q "·

Overview of Actual Progress

MUI's MUl's• indtcate-----+1 meat!!J

that ... that .. . _

X.D.l --- - - - - - + X.D.2 --- - - . X.D.] J[ BAD-~.O , ";-'------_· 8AO-~.O .2';-'----_· ·~BAO-~.o.Jl

[ BAD-C.'- - - - - - - --+J BAD-C.2- - - - - .., · · BAD- C., ]

[ c > BIO-C., -+ BID-C ." BID-C .l' BID- C."

F~TP1"test .1 II

. >

11

Another presentation which shows where in the Test the user iscurrently working

Overview of Actual Progress - Another Presentation

TT.O us 7,81 8, 399 81

)~." ..

0000,;.e Dn!l0\"U1 DDR '399 pe loen'AV! •

A TTors l .I1I)99 8 1

L BAD.C.2SVIUmCOJ:l

~ IBID·x0 2110011. and (,L !BID-e.S IOQk ud 1m

~ IBID-X 0 2 ~ CUllomn

L : 8ii:rC:6' C~';d

e I BiD···x ·O ·2 ~· '~d·~L fBID.C.7 IWlU d "-ct

e XOJ SyllMQ Com pt"l.llfl' ~c~ BAD .;x,O')1 S)". I.... «1m:

L 'BAD :c:3-sr;;~'~;;';;t I ~ID.XO ) . co-m.kttlL. ,BID -e.Sco-mas\e:q

.~.L j • •

12

ILJl

TELEa.H

After the BIDs have all been found we can present the itemsthis way.

Presentation of Analysis with MUI for BID-C.G

IIJl

H .O US 7,8 18 ,399 8 1

Hype rbolic Tr ees for C.se: nerne ve rs ODR '3 9 9 p.tent AVl

- ,'_. -' ,,- ---- "'-- _.._.__..._-~ ,.... ..., ..........~._ ... r- .. ......_ "',.. _N

FSTP-test2 Passed

FSTP-Test prompts:'§'TP t ....t,

_ 1'1...",..1"'..-..._..... _---..-0'.,. 'U"""ll!lO....... ""j..~ .. ,_ _'I'I/IOCOCOO ollnt.. ..,_,..,IoIOaQIo....... _II!lll,U /)'... .,.O

ANA Matrix - Without Reference Set

Anticipation Combin.tion

My SelKtxlns • CUstOl'l ZOOftl: 1~ •

"""Add 19 MIt' 51>!ectJom; F~ler It ems ; )(,0.1 . ,0.2 X,D,)Elemmt: III X 0 I SYltf'lll,comprll tnl lTO« and tft'\~ tupponLrl, e-eoeeeeree III X 0 .2 SYllmi eolnpllllUf 110ft 8ftd wn"fl II X 0 J Synt'm Com pfll lftJ IIOfeand """ " lUJl9Ol"IUlJ

QUIIoOUfCCpl' 0'I "1

Test Overview - with MUI's

,- XO.IS~.lIIID.pr"""_._Kn·" wpp

The End

17

Thank you for your attention

TELEa.H