freestanding freestanding freestanding will never win any prizes for reliability. ... 8.30-6pm or...
TRANSCRIPT
Washer-dryers were once seen
as a poor substitute for separate
appliances, often criticised for being
expensive, unreliable, slow to dry, and
lacking capacity. This may be why only
15% of owners make regular use of
their appliance’s drying function.
But while these criticisms still hold
water for some appliances, many
manufacturers have made great
advances, producing models with
larger drums, greater water-efficiency
and faster drying speeds. So if space
is tight in your kitchen, a washer-dryer
may well be worth another look.
Save water with a BoschMost washer-dryers use water-cooled
condensers to turn damp extracted air
into water – using around 35 litres of
water per load in the process. But the
new Best Buy Bosch WVH28420GB
and the Siemens WD14H420GB work
like regular tumble dryers and use no
water in the drying cycle. Drying once a
week with either model will save enough
water over its lifetime to fill 137 baths.
MONEYSAVER
The Bosch and Siemens
washer-dryers are technically
the same machine, but you’ll
be able to pick up the Bosch (right) on
the high street for £150 less.
Miele’s Best Buys have fantastic
scores and come with prices to match
– up to £1,299 – but six of our featured
Best Buys cost less than £700.
WANt tO kNOW Which MOdEl hAS thE lOWESt RuNNiNg cOStS? Head online to
www.which.co.uk/washerdryer for reviews of more than 80 washer-dryers from all the
leading brands, including 13 Best Buys. Or call our member helpline on 01992 822800.
October 2010 | 33www.which.co.uk
How we test washer dryersWe test washing and drying power with loads
of cottons and synthetics. We record how well
the machines wash, spin and rinse, as well as
how quickly and evenly they dry.
Laundry gels and powdersBiological Best Buy Ariel Excel Gel with Actilift
scored 70% and is excellent on greasy and
fatty stains. Formil biological powder from
Lidl (74%) is great value at 8p per wash.
Tumble dryersWe’ll be featuring tumble dryers next month.
But if you need one now, there are 116 online
including 40 Best Buys starting from £199.
See www.which.co.uk/tumbledryers
AEG-ELECTROLUX L14840 £540WHICH? TEST SCORE 68%
PROS This Best Buy is equally good at
washing cotton and easycare items, and
drying is particularly impressive. Rinsing
is thorough and there’s a decent 1,400rpm
spin. Drying is quick and reasonably even,
and energy and water efficiency are good.
CONS It’s noisy when spinning and easycare
drying isn’t very water-efficient.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £540
AvAILABLE Online and at independents only
AEG-ELECTROLUX L14850 £589WHICH? TEST SCORE 65%
PROS This freestanding washer-dryer washes
well, dries quickly, and is one of the quietest
machines around. The 40°C cotton wash is
outstanding, the spin excellent and the 7kg
drum means you can get a large load
washed in one go. You can dry 5kg at a time.
CONS Water and energy use are only average.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £576
CHEAPEST HIGH STREET STORE John Lewis
ALSO AvAILABLE Online and at independents
ZANUSSI ZWD14581W1 £540WHICH? TEST SCORE 64%
PROS This Best Buy washes and dries well
and offers good energy and water-efficiency.
It can wash 7kg and dry 5kg. It’s better at
washing and drying cottons than synthetics
but water and energy use are both good.
CONS Easy-care rinsing and noisy spinning.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £420
CHEAPEST HIGH STREET STORE Comet
ALSO AvAILABLE AT Currys, online and
independents
JOHN LEWIS JLWD1609 £599WHICH? TEST SCORE 70%
PROS It washes a 7kg load of cottons in just
over two hours. For small loads, drying can
start straight after washing, and laundry is
evenly dried. Water and energy-efficiency are
good and it’s quiet even during the spin cycle.
CONS High energy use when drying easycare
laundry, and poor easycare rinsing.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £599
CHEAPEST HIGH STREET STORE John Lewis
ALSO AvAILABLE AT n/a
AEG-ELECTROLUX L16850 £629WHICH? TEST SCORE 74%
PROS This is one of the best washer-dryers
we’ve tested, combining excellent washing
results with impressive drying speed. You
can dry a large 5kg load quickly and evenly,
and energy and water use are low.
CONS Noisy spin and poor energy-efficiency
in easycare drying mode.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £549
CHEAPEST HIGH STREET STORE Currys
ALSO AvAILABLE Online and at independents
JOHN LEWIS JLBIWD1403 £699WHICH? TEST SCORE 68%
PROS This built-in Best Buy from John Lewis
is an excellent choice for a fitted kitchen.
It can wash 6kg and dry 4kg. It’s good at
washing and drying cottons and reasonable
at washing and drying easycare items.
CONS We found that loading and unloading can
be quite tricky as the door only opens to 90˚.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £699
CHEAPEST HIGH STREET STORE John Lewis
ALSO AvAILABLE AT n/a
FREESTANDING
FREESTANDING FREESTANDING BUILT-IN
FREESTANDING FREESTANDING
BEST BUyS UNDER £700
GREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUE
GREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUEGREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUEGREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUE
GREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUEGREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUE
next generationwasher-dryers
Best Buys for all budgets, including six under £700
BOSCH WVH28420GB67% £850
TESTLAB
GREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUEMORE
for you
pho
tog
raphY bY: pIo
tr grEg
orC
YK
www.which.co.uk 34 | October 2010
MIELE WT2780 £1,299WHICH? TEST SCORE 75%
PROS This Miele is the most expensive
Best Buy in our tests. It gets cottons really
clean, rinses well and the 1,600rpm spin
means clothes are left ready for the dryer.
It dries clothes evenly and relatively quickly.
Water and energy-efficiency are excellent
in both washer and dryer modes, so running
costs are low. Features include a 24-hour
delay timer and a handy choice of stain
removal settings.
CONS Relatively small drum and the easycare
wash isn’t as good as the cotton wash.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £1,150
CHEAPEST HIGH STREET STORE Comet,
Currys and John Lewis
ALSO AvAILABLE Online and at independents
MIELE WT2670 £1,049WHICH? TEST SCORE 76%
PROS A Best Buy since 2006, this Miele
washes as well as a Best Buy washing
machine. The 1,600rpm spin cycle is very
effective. It dries relatively quickly and evenly,
and energy and water consumption are both
good. You can choose a lower drying
temperature and features include an
end-of-program buzzer and options for
pre-wash, soak, short and water plus
(extra rinse) washing.
CONS Drum capacity is at the low end of the
range with 5kg washing and 2.5kg drying.
Rinsing is poor.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £1,049
CHEAPEST HIGH STREET STORE Comet
ALSO AvAILABLE Online and at independents
BOSCH WvH28420GB £850WHICH? TEST SCORE 67%
PROS The Bosch WVH28420GB is a Best
Buy for its impressive all-round washing and
drying performance. The stand-out feature
is that, unlike most washer-dryers, it doesn’t
use water during the drying phase. Its
cleaning power on cottons is good and
drying is reasonable for cottons and easy
care items. As well as low water use, the
Bosch keeps energy use to a minimum when
washing and drying. It’s £150 cheaper than
the near-identical Siemens WD14H420GB.
CONS Wash performance on easycare items
isn’t great and spinning is quite noisy.
WHICH.CO.Uk TARGET ONLINE PRICE £780
CHEAPEST HIGH STREET STORE Comet
ALSO AvAILABLE Online and at independents
TEST LAB WASHER-DRYERStHE top-ScoRERS fRom miElE, pluS An impRESSivE WAtER-SAving WASHER-DRYER fRom boScH
The average drying capacity for a new washer-dryer is now
4.5kg of laundry – that’s 54% more than models from just five
years ago. Washing capacities have also increased so
washer-dryers can now almost match washing machines but
they’re still smaller than new tumble dryers. The illustration
shows how capacities for washer-dryers and standalone
machines has increased since 2006.
Washer-dryer reliabilityWasher-dryers will never win any prizes for reliability. With two
machines in one, there’s more to go wrong and, in our annual
reliability survey, they bring up the rear. We only award Best Buys
to brands that either offer market-leading warranties or score
average or above for reliability. AEG-Electrolux, Bosch and Zanussi
all qualify with average reliability scores.
GREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUE
TWO MACHINES IN ONE?
TESTLAB
ILLUSTRATIO
N by: AC
UTE G
RAPHIC
S
October 2010 | 35www.which.co.uk
PerformanceThere’s little difference between a washer-
dryer and a washing machine when it comes
to cleaning power, but tumble dryers beat
washer-dryers in a drying race.
Save your energyUse less energy when you tumble
dry. Our video shows you how to
save energy and money every wash-day
www.which.co.uk/dryingtips
Need more buying advice?Call the Which? helpline for more information
about our Best Buy washer-dryers. Contact
the team on 01992 822800 Mon – Fri
8.30-6pm or Sat 9am-1pm.
score (%
)
bran
d relia
bility
overa
ll ease
of u
se
run
nin
g co
sts
tota
l water u
se
energy d
rying
energy w
ash
ing
easyca
re dryin
g
cotto
n d
rying
easy-ca
re wash
cotto
n w
ash
max d
rying
load
max w
ash
load
Price (£)
sPecification which? test Performance
freestanding
1 miele WT2670 1,049 5 2.5 HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHH n/a 76
2 miele WT2780 1,299 5.5 3 HHHH HHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHH n/a 75
3 aeg-electrolux L16850 629 7 5 HHHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHH 74
4 John lewis JLWD1609 599 7 3.5 HHHH HHH HHHHH HHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH n/a 70
5 aeg-electrolux L14840 540 7 5 HHHH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHH 68
6 bosch WVH28420GB 850 7 4 HHHH HH HHH HHH HHHHH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHH HHH 67
7 hotPoint AQM8F49I/V a
497 8 6 HHHH HHH HHHH HHHHH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHH H 67
8 siemens WD14H420GB 999 7 4 HHHH HH HHH HHH HHHHH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHH n/a 67
9 aeg-electrolux L14850 589 7 5 HHHH HHH HHHHH HHH HHHH HHH HHH HHH HHHH HHH 65
10 indesit PWDE8148S a
361 7 5 HHHH HH HHHH HHH HHHH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHH HH 64
11 Zanussi ZWD14581W1 540 7 5 HHHH HHH HHHHH HHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHH HHH 64
12 indesit IWDE7125S a
430 7 5 HHHH HHH H HHHH HHH HHHH HHHHH HHHH HHH HH 59
13 indesit IWDC6125 UK 301 6 5 HHHH HHH HHHH HHHHH HHH HHHH HHHHH HHHH HHH HH 59
14 samsung WD8704RJA 530 7 5 HHHH HHHH H H HHHH HHHH HHH HHH HHHH n/a 58
15 whirlPool AWZ510E 431 5 3 HHHHH HHHHH H HH HHH HH HHH HHH HHHH n/a 55
16 hoover VHW656D 429 6 5 HHH HH HH HHHH HHHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHH n/a 54
17 bosch WVD24460GB 550 5 2.5 HHHH HH H HHH HHHH HHH HHH HHH HHHH HHH 51
18 bosch WVD24520GB 516 5 2.5 HHHH HH H H HHHHH H HH HHH HHHH HHH 51
19 siemens WD12D523GB 549 5 2.5 HHHH H H HH HHHHH HHH HHH HHHH HHHH n/a 51
20 hotPoint WDL520P 324 7 5 HHHH HHH H HH HHHH HHH HH HHH HHHH H 47
21 hotPoint WDF740G 426 7 5 HHHH HHH H HH HHHH HHH HH HHH HHH H 45
built-in
1 John lewis JLBIWD1403 699 6 4 HHHH HHH HHHH HHH HHH HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH n/a 68
2 candy CDB75-4D 523 7 5 HHH HH HHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHHH HHHH HHHH HH n/a 60
3 hoover HDB854 589 8 5 H HH HHHH HHH HHHHH HHHH HHHH HHHHH HH n/a 47
a We only award Best Buy status to washer-dryer brands that have average or above average reliability, or those that come with market-leading warranties. Indesit has below average reliability and
Hotpoint reliability is poor, so washer-dryers from these brands can’t be Best Buys.
The more stars the better.SpecificationWash/drying load How much the machines can wash and dry.
Which? test performanceCotton wash Cleaning rating for a 40°C cotton wash.
Easy care wash Cleaning rating for a 40°C wash for synthetic clothes. Cotton/easy care drying How long it took to complete selected programs. Energy How much energy the machines used to wash and dry
cotton and synthetic loads.Water use How much water is used to wash and dry.Running costs How much each washer-dryers costs to runEase of use We rate how easy each machine is to set, load and unload.
Brand reliability Best Buys must have at least average reliability in our annual survey, or a market-leading warranty like Miele. N/a means there wasn’t enough data to judge reliability. For John Lewis, we use the data for the brand that makes its machines.
ScoreIgnores price and is based on:Washing 40%Drying 20%Ease of use/noise 20%Energy use 10%Water use 10%
Using the table
BEST BUyS OvER £700
GREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUEGREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUEGREATVALUE
DON’TBUY
EXCEPTIONAL
VALUE
Washer-dryersWash capacity (Kg)
Washer-dryersDry capacity (Kg)
Washing machinesCapacity (Kg)
Tumble dryersCapacity (Kg)
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
5.42 5.74 5.94 6.65 6.78
2.88 3.20 3.83 4.18 4.45
5.90 6.41 6.33 6.54 7.07
5.60 5.00 6.20 6.30 7.18
FREESTANDING FREESTANDING FREESTANDING