7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

1/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GGD1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDG

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& : () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

2/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GGU1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDD

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& ; () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

3/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GGP1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDU

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& < () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

4/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GGV1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDP

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& = () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

5/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GGW1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDV

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& > () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

6/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GGF1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDW

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& ? () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

7/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GGX1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDF

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& @ () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

8/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GGO1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDX

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& A () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

9/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDE1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGDO

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& B () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

10/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDG1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUE

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :C () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

11/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDD1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUG

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :: () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

12/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDU1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUD

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :; () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

13/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDP1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUU

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :< () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

14/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDV1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUP

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& := () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

15/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDW1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUV

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :> () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

16/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDF1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUW

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :? () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

17/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDX1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUF

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :@ () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

18/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GDO1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUX

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :A () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

19/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GUE1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGUO

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& :B () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

20/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GUG1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGPE

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& ;C () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

21/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GUD1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGPG

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& ;: () ;;

7/22/2019 Free Will and Determinism (Theodore Sider)

22/22

!"#$$% '()*+ ,-.$)% /0$".")$1 2-..*$3 "4 '5-36$#7$ 8 9 :;-.$. /";) "4 3-731

!()>% ?!% @,98 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$33% DEEF1 = GUU1

066=8HH3-6$1$I)()>17"JH*-IH0K;*-I)()>HL"7M-.NGEGOPDGGQ==RNGPD

!"=>)-R06 S DEEF1 A54"). @#-B$)3-6> C)$331 9** )-R063 )$3$)B$.1

#"6 I$ )$=)".;7$. -# (#> 4")J T-60";6 =$)J-33-"# 4)"J 60$ =;I*-30$)% $57$=6 4(-) ;3$3 =$)J-66$.

;#.$) @1,1 ") (==*-7(I*$ 7"=>)-R06 *(T1

#$%& () *+"&,%-.% / 0 12"#%# 3(24 () 5%,6789&".& ;; () ;;