fraunhofer institute for production systems and design ... · the fraunhofer institute for...
TRANSCRIPT
F r a u n h o F e r I n s t I t u t e F o r P r o d u c t I o n s y s t e m s a n d d e s I g n t e c h n o l o g y I P K
AutomAted VirtuAl reconstruction
Virtual reconstruction connects high technology with social-cultural relevance.
c o n t e n t s
3 Preface
4 Interview: Jigsaw for re-evaluation
6 The entire process
10 Preservation and restoration of cultural
assets
14 Strategic partners
15 Imprint
Dr.-Ing. Bertram Nickolay, head of the Security Technology department
2
P r e F a c e
For more than 30 years Fraunhofer IPK in Berlin has been
promoting excellence in production science. It delivers applied
research and development services for the entire range of
industrial tasks – from product development, the production
process and product recycling to design and management of
factory plants. The institute is divided into six business divi-
sions: Corporate Management, Virtual Product Creation, Pro-
duction Systems, Automation Technology, Joining and Coating
Technology, Medical Technology. The institute sets particular
value in applying production-related solutions beyond the
industrial setting, for example in the areas of medicine, traffic
and security.
Since the early 1980s the Security Technology department
within the Automation Technology division has been develop-
ing image-analysis systems for use in difficult environmental
conditions. Through systematic research its research engineers
have been able to develop techniques for complex pattern
recognition tasks. The department is an international pioneer
in implementing systems for detection of biometric features,
monitoring movement of people and vehicles, and document
interpretation.
The most distinguished advancement in image analysis is a
technology that will be a valuable contribution to the preser-
vation of cultural assets, historical research and reappraising,
as well as forensics: automated virtual reconstruction of rup-
tured, shredded or otherwise damaged documents. Fragments
of documents are digitized and re-assembled on the computer
monitor through complex automated image processing pro-
cedures. The system has been developed to make ruptured
G.D.R. secret service files readable again. But also experts in
other fields – such as Ancient Oriental Studies, Archivistics and
Criminalistics – are watching the development of the system
with great interest. The technology promises enormous gains
of information and advancement in these fields. Throughout
the ages, paper, papyrus and parchment have played a promi-
nent role as cultural mediums. Until now, when documents
made of these materials were intentionally or unintention-
ally damaged, the information recorded on them had to be
considered lost, because restoration – if possible at all – was
either too time-consuming or too expensive. Fraunhofer IPK’s
research and development will fundamentally change this
dilemma.
In this context it is important that the Security Technology de-
partment does more than develop and implement algorithms
for the virtual reconstruction of two-dimensional objects. The
team considers all related processes, exploring for example
concepts for time-efficient and high-resolution digitization
of the initial material, as well as long-term backup, analysis
and evaluation of reconstructed documents. Furthermore,
the department is concerned with scenarios where experts
are aiming for a physical reconstruction of the initial material,
whether that material is paper or a three-dimensional object
such as a fresco or sculpture. To support physical reconstruc-
tion, robotics solutions that hold, carefully fit together and
join fragments are considered, as well as systems for expert-
assisted virtual (pre-)reconstruction.
The Fraunhofer Inst i tute for Product ion Systems and Design Technology IPK is the global leader in auto-
mated v i r tual reconstruct ion of destroyed documents, thus restor ing damaged archival data or ev idence
for evaluat ion. Future projects inc lude technology for repl icat ion and restorat ion of damaged artworks,
such as frescos.
3
the world’s largest jigsaw puzzle
In fall of 1989, members of the G.D.R.’s
Department of State Security (MfS)
began destroying files on spying ac-
tivities. A large part of the material was
»pre-destroyed«, i.e. ruptured by hand,
when the file shredders overheated. The
fragments were to be destroyed for good
later on. But it didn’t get that far. Rumors
of the document destruction activities
leaked out and G.D.R. citizens stormed
the MfS offices on December 4th, 1989.
More than 15 000 sacks containing some
600 million fragments of paper were
salvaged. In 1995, the Federal Author-
ity for the Records of the State Security
Service of the former G.D.R. (BStU) began
the task of manually reconstructing the
documents. It soon became clear that the
ruptured files contained highly impor-
tant information. They bear witness, for
instance, to psychological subversion of
dissidents and document the cooperation
of so-called Unofficial Collaborators (IM)
with the Communist Party and the secret
service. The destruction of the files mostly
aimed at protecting collaborators from
exposure and prosecution. Therefore, re-
construction of the damaged documents
is a matter of urgency toward assessment
of the injustices of the G.D.R.
I n t e r v I e w
Conversation with Dr. Bertram Nickolay, head of the Security Technology department
4
JigsAw for re-eVAluAtion
Dr. Bertram Nickolay is head of the Secur i ty Technology department. Born in Saar land, with a doctorate in
engineer ing, he has been working at Fraunhofer IPK s ince 1977. He came up with the idea to develop a
system for automated v i r tual reconstruct ion of Stas i f i les , which resulted in the ePuzzler. The ePuzzler i s
a computer system based on complex a lgor i thms that wi l l make a fundamental contr ibut ion to coming to
terms with recent German history.
how did you get the idea for the ePuzzler?
In the mid-nineties I heard from media reports and conversa-
tions with Stasi victims that BStU employees in Zirndorf, Ba-
varia, were manually piecing back together the ruptured secret
service files. I asked, ›isn’t there an automated solution for this
problem?‹ It was estimated that reconstructing the files manu-
ally would take several hundreds of years. We were sure that
automated virtual reconstruction would drastically reduce the
time necessary for this task.
why do you think you in particular are fit to solve the
stasi puzzle?
My team has spent years acquiring competencies in automa-
tion of visual processes based on pattern recognition and
digital image processing. As a result we had the necessary
know-how to face this complex job. Also, I’ve got a personal
motivation: I have many friends that were civil rights activists
in the time of the former G.D.R. One of them was the writer
Jürgen Fuchs who died of cancer at the age of just 48. It is
possible that his illness was caused by clandestine radiation
during his Stasi imprisonment. It is assumed that dissidents
were secretly exposed to radiation in prisons. If this could be
proved by a reconstructed piece of paper, I’d be pleased.
how did the project materialize, and has there been any
opposition?
The project materialized through my initiative, but it wasn’t
immediately successful. Today it is experiencing huge interna-
tional media response, but it took constant work to get the
ministries with authority over BStU and representatives of vari-
ous German parliament committees to one table and convince
them of the feasibility and innovation of the project. When in
2002 the German parliament put the project internationally
out to tender, we won the tender: of all the candidates, we
were the only one that could prove that the problem could
be solved using fragments of original Stasi documents. But it
wasn’t until 2007 that the Procurement Agency of the Federal
Ministry of the Interior mandated us to develop a procedure
for virtual reconstruction in a pilot project. During this project,
400 sacks are being processed. The pilot stage is going well;
we want to finish it by the end of 2011.
how important are the ruptured stasi files?
These files are an important legacy of the Peaceful Revolution.
The BStU states that they are mainly from the last 20 years
of the G.D.R. and contain especially explosive and instructive
information. Moreover, if a political power goes to so much
trouble to destroy something, it must be important.
are there systems comparable to the ePuzzler? and is
this technology applicable in other areas?
Fraunhofer IPK’s reconstruction technology is probably unique.
Even though there is isolated development work going on
elsewhere – no one has gotten as far with it as we have. This
is astonishing, because the inquiries coming from all over
the world prove that there is an enormous demand for this
technology. At the beginning we thought the Stasi files were
an isolated case. But then other countries such as Poland and
the Czech Republic asked us for help reconstructing ruptured
and shredded files. We’ve also reconstructed documents and
even license plates for criminal investigation departments and
tax authorities. Also, we started applying the technology to re-
constructing objects, damaged frescos for instance. In order to
do so, we already cooperate with archaeologists and experts in
art restoration.
how important is this work for you personally?
Very important. I’m a scientist with heart and soul, the techni-
cal aspect of the project is an exciting challenge for me as an
engineer. But above all, my friendship with Jürgen Fuchs and
other victims of G.D.R. persecution is what keeps encouraging
me to carry the project through. I want to make a contribution
to clarification of the facts. In my team’s work, advanced tech-
nology and social relevance work together in a unique way.
5
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Preparation
digitization
ePuzzler
Processing & analysis
Digitization
Feature extraction Search space reduction Virtual jigsaw
Automated fileforming
Contentanalysis Long-term backup
With Fraunhofer IPK’s automated v i r tual reconstruct ion system, digita l repro-
duct ions of fragments of ruptured and damaged documents can be arranged
with the a id of the computer: for instance to make documents readable in
cases where manual reconstruct ion is e i ther imposs ib le or too t ime-consuming.
At present, the procedure is used mainly for restorat ion of two-dimensional
objects such as paper or paperboard.
Reconstruct ion is done in three steps: to process fragments v i r tual ly , f i rst they
must be digit ized. Then ePuzzler evaluates the digita l images of the paper
fragments and merges them gradual ly in an automated process to complete
pages. The third step goes beyond reconstruct ion of s ingle pages: i t comprises
mechanisms for automated formation of reconstructed pages to ent i re f i les as
wel l as techniques to interpret content. These tools are essent ia l especia l ly for
the evaluat ion of large amounts of source mater ia l , as in the case of the rup-
tured Stas i f i les .
the entire process
Before virtual reconstruction, digital images of the source ma-
terial have to be created, which means the fragments must be
scanned into a computer. This requires a series of preliminary
steps. The fragments must be isolated and cleaned, if neces-
sary; wrinkled and/or crushed material should be smoothed
out; paper clips and staples must be removed.
During digitization, metadata important for reconstruction is
collected. For instance, if paper snippets are clipped together,
this information is stored so the reconstructed pages will be
recognized as belonging together. Also, information on mate-
rial, rough content and temporal classification are fixed. This
»pre-knowledge« considerably increases the performance of
the matching process and renders possible to assemble multi-
page documents from single pages.
A high quality scanning process is required in order to be able
to evaluate and to arrange the digitized fragments precisely.
Both sides of fragments of any size – even very small ones –
must be scanned without reflections and shadows, true to
scale and color according to the original. Otherwise relation-
ships between the pieces, such as identical pigmentation or
neighbored edges, cannot be identified. Furthermore, the
fragments must be digitized on a background they can eas-
ily be separated from, similar to blue-screen-techniques. The
black and white backgrounds of common paper scanners are
not suitable for this. With large amounts of source material –
as with the ruptured Stasi documents – the goal is to process
several thousand pieces of paper per hour, while putting a
minimum of strain on the originals. At present, no tool exists
that lives up to all demands. Working with manufacturers,
scanning devices are being adapted specifically for the virtual
reconstruction process.
One of the biggest challenges is to limit deviations in color
and shape which can either result from aging of the scanner’s
lighting source, the scanning technique itself or the use of sev-
eral different scanners. Color differences can be balanced by
using color management systems, but inaccuracies concerning
the image shapes are much harder to overcome. Moreover,
different types of scanning techniques produce different
resolution errors. Line scanners capture the source material
line-by-line as it moves over a camera. A constant resolution
requires an extremely constant motion which is mechanically
hard to attain. By contrast, matrix scanners capture an entire
object at once. Resolution errors that occur by this scanning
technique can be compensated for through calculation to a
certain extent.
Scanning both sides of a piece of paper also requires thought-
out procedures. Alignment of both sides of the piece of paper
must be constant. This can be achieved by simultaneously
scanning both sides or using a special procedure by which the
fragments of paper stay fixed during turn over.
Furthermore, carrier materials are required to protect frag-
ments from friction and pressure, such as plastic film
envelopes. However, image defects can occur because of
these devices. Shadow preventing digitization requires very
thin film. Illumination is particularly difficult when extremely
fragile fragments have to be protected by solid glass panels
while they are being fed through the scanning device. Thus,
digitization is still a laborious field of research the institute is
actively involved in, in addition to development of reconstruc-
tion software.
digitizAtion
the entire process
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
7
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
The core of the automated virtual reconstruction system is
the so-called ePuzzler; here, the actual virtual restoration of
ruptured pages takes place. ePuzzler is a reconstruction soft-
ware developed by Fraunhofer IPK which uses complex image
processing and pattern recognition algorithms to construct
complete pages from digitized paper fragments. In addition, it
provides tools to examine and correct questionable or equivo-
cal puzzle results.
ePuzzler is structured into three main modules: feature extrac-
tion, search space reduction, and matching. Since there are
no two identical paper fragments, it is impossible to forecast
a straight calling sequence indicating how these modules
have to interact during a single reconstruction task. Thus, they
are embedded in a non-deterministic, adaptive workflow by
means of a complex software framework. The methodology of
virtual reconstruction is comparable to that of a human being
working on a jigsaw puzzle. On the basis of a number of de-
scribing features, he decides whether two pieces do match or
epuzzler
special mission: shredded documents
Reconstruction of shredded documents is a specific task
within virtual reconstruction of two-dimensional objects. In
this case, feature extraction and matching procedures have
to handle tremendous challenges: Shredded fragments
have a uniform shape, which means reconstruction must
rely only on content features and color gradients. More-
over, the fragments are just a few millimeters in width and
a few centimeters in length; therefore, content features
must be derived from a few sets of pixels. Hence, recon-
don’t. Similar to human procedure, ePuzzler initially calculates
different features of the paper fragments such as outlines,
paper color, writing, or ruling. These features are used to re-
duce the computational effort during puzzling – particularly
important with large amounts of data. Similar fragments are
clustered into subsets by means of intelligent search space re-
duction. The actual reconstruction, the matching, takes place
within these reduced quantities. Corresponding features are
investigated along the snippet contours. When two fragments
match, they are digitally glued and viewed as a larger frag-
ment during further reconstruction.
Ambiguities sometimes leave ePuzzler undecided about
whether two pieces really match. In this case partial recon-
structions available so far are collected and automatically
directed to so-called post-processing work stations. Here,
the system presents a range of most likely reconstruction
partners to a human editor so the results can be completed
interactively.
struction of shredded documents does not classify content
into obvious classes as »writing« or »ruling«. Instead all
elements on each shred – including paper color – are con-
sidered as geometric objects by whose allocation suitable
neighbors are being determined using rules of binary string
matching and probability. So the result is one that geo-
metrically suggests itself, rather than one that is correct in
respect of content. Therefore, reconstructed paper shreds
are currently always examined by a human supervisor.
t h e e n t I r e P r o c e s s
8
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosse
Merkmaleextrahieren
Suchraumreduktion Virtuelles Puzzeln
DigitalisierungVorbereitung
Automatisierte Aktenformierung
InhaltlicheErschließung
Langzeit-Archivierung
2. REKONSTRUKTION
1. DIGITALISIERUNG
3. AUFBEREITEN UND VERWENDEN
Genosseprocessing & AnAlysis
If a reconstruction process results in a correctly and completely
reassembled page, this is already a very valuable result. But
for content evaluation, single pages usually have little value.
Therefore, mechanisms are developed in cooperation with
partners that will in the future help form documents or even
entire files from reconstructed pages. They will be comple-
mented by tools that facilitate the development of large quan-
tities of virtual material.
»File formation« means combining single pages to reconstruct
complete documents and organizing several documents into
larger files. Presently, in archives this process is performed
manually without support of software tools. By using digital
image processing methods like those used in ePuzzler, file for-
mation can be automated to a certain degree.
First attempts in this direction are based on metadata that are
gathered in advance or calculated during the reconstruction
process: information on type of paper, paper color, typeface,
and type color or ruling. At Fraunhofer IPK, algorithms for ta-
ble and form identification have already been developed that
recognize known types of forms on reconstructed pages with
the help of patterns. It is intended to expand these procedures
so that they can autonomously derive other, unknown types
of forms from recurring patterns. Additionally the extraction
of layout features and handwriting comparison is advanced
in order to identify recurrent elements such as page numbers
or page headers, so that relationships between single pages
can be established. The goal is ultimately to be able to identify
pages written by the same hand or on the same typewriter.
This would considerably speed up the formation of files.
Digital image processing also holds great potential for formal
and content analysis of reconstructed documents. Intelligent
character recognition (ICR) could make it possible to search for
specific catch phrases and thereby assign documents to a cer-
tain context. This would not only facilitate file formation but
also specification of catalogue entries. However, these meth-
ods still require a lot of research. Current OCR/ICR software
is limited to a small number of typefaces – for example, the
technology cannot cope with handwriting or Gothic print.
Even before all the above-mentioned procedures become ap-
plicable in archive management, it will be necessary to consult
single reconstructed pages for research and examination, for
example in trials touching activities of the G.D.R. State Secu-
rity. In this context it is important to ensure the legal capacity
of the digitally reconstructed material. Hence the entire pro-
cess of virtual reconstruction from digitization to long-term
archiving must be designed to be clear–cut and transparent.
Furthermore, all processed data – and particularly the snippet
images – must be protected against manipulation by means of
common hash procedures so that the integrity and complete-
ness of the data can be verified.
Despite these measures the virtual material itself will not be
enough in every context. Sometimes it may be necessary to
present a reconstructed original. This case is also taken into
consideration in the reconstruction process. Already during
digitization every fragment is marked with a definite code that
refers to the storage place of the original. This makes it easy
to find the original fragments of a virtually reconstructed page
and, if necessary, to physically reassemble them.
9
assistance-based reconstruction in egyptology
Dr. Friederike Seyfried, director of the Egyptian Collection of the
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, is planning a unique pilot project
in cooperation with Fraunhofer IPK to put papyrus fragments
together with computer assistance.
what do you expect from this project?
Currently there is only one restorer taking care of the papyrus
collection within the Egyptian Collection. The number of papyrus
fragments she can put together during conservation work is
limited. Imagine the amount of information we would gain, if
she could be supported by virtual procedures! We also own parts
of documents whose fragments are dispersed over collections at
different locations. To put them together at least virtually, would
be a great help to research.
why does the system need the assistance of an expert?
Our restorer knows the highly sensitive material papyrus like no
one else. On the basis of fiber direction and style she can narrow
down place and date of origin. Such knowledge can hardly be
taught to a computer. Since the restorer’s expertise or a scientist’s
ability to decipher the characters is essential, it has to flow into
the necessary software development. But it cannot be substituted
by a computer.
why wouldn’t virtual reconstruction be sufficient?
We want to read what is written on the reconstructed papyrus,
but analysis of material is also an important part of the work. The
process for making papyrus is not known from contemporary
sources. We will only understand the procedure through study
of the material itself. Virtual images do not reflect every detail;
therefore, we have to assemble the originals – or at least the
parts we have. Hopefully virtual reconstruction will be a great
help with this process: It should be able to tell us, if we actually
have all the pieces of a document, or if there are important pieces
that have been lost or are perhaps in other collections.
P r e s e r v a t I o n a n d r e s t o r a t I o n o F
c u l t u r a l a s s e t s
Extremely damaged but
historically unique papyri
from the Egyptian Collec-
tion of Staatliche Museen
zu Berlin
Right: fragments of
destroyed documents from
the Cologne City Archive
high-tech meets expert knowledge
There are two approaches in assistance-based reconstruc-
tion. On one hand there is the concept of assistance-based
virtual reconstruction, which just like fully automated virtual
reconstruction aims at the virtual restoration of contents. After
digitization physical fragments are usually not required any-
more and can be archived conventionally. But in contrast to
fully automated restoration, assistance-based reconstruction
deals with fragments that for technical reasons cannot be re-
constructed in a fully automated manner – the reconstruction
process requires the active collaboration of a human supervi-
sor. Examples are the restoration of shredded documents and
restoration of damaged license plates to make them legible as
described on page 8.
The second approach follows the vision of an assistant system
to support physical reconstruction. Here, virtual reconstruction
will serve as a model for a subsequent manual reconstruction
or restoration. Such a system makes high demands on the
workflow before digitization and after virtual reconstruction.
Since the goal of this approach is the physical reconstruction
of the objects previously digitized, it requires the use of an ef-
ficient tracking system designed for the job. Also, depending
on the task at hand, many cases of physical reconstruction de-
mand the consideration of expert knowledge and evaluation.
Such knowledge may be the professional skills and insight of
the archivist or restorer – information on origin, age, or specif-
ic contemporary features – which can be applied to the virtual
reconstruction process via metadata. Other knowledge may be
gained during the process of virtual reconstruction itself – for
example when content features not visible on small fragments
though become visible to an expert when several pieces are
joined to make a larger piece. The computer will not be able
to depict expert knowledge that’s based on long-term experi-
ence, but it must be available for the process of restoration in
order to make it faster and more effective.
This approach is currently being tested. Fraunhofer IPK, in co-
operation with the Egyptian Collection of Stiftung Preußischer
Kulturbesitz Foundation – Staatliche Museen zu Berlin is plan-
ning a system to enable the physical reconstruction of a set of
extremely fragmented but historically unique papyri. Recon-
struction by hand would take an untold number of years be-
cause of the number of tiny fragments. This task can only be
solved through interaction of expert knowledge with a virtual
reconstruction solution.
The same applies to the Cologne City Archive building that
collapsed in 2009. Here too, Fraunhofer IPK’s systems and
methods can significantly support the reconstruction and res-
toration of the historically important archival records that sus-
tained considerable damage from the mechanical forces of the
collapse. The City of Cologne requested a test on 1000 pieces.
This test proved that the procedure can be applied to the
problem and it works.
Automated v i r tual reconstruct ion is a very versat i le tool . To use i t in an even more eff ic ient way in the
process of preserv ing and restor ing documents and other objects important to culture and society, sc ien-
t ists at Fraunhofer IPK are developing ass istance-based reconstruct ion systems that re ly on expert knowl-
edge for the reconstruct ion process and that wi l l ass ist phys ica l reconstruct ion of cultural assets.
11
P r e s e r v a t I o n a n d r e s t o r a t I o n o F
c u l t u r a l a s s e t s
Frescos broken into small
fragments can be re-
arranged with the aid of
virtual 3D reconstruction.
3d VirtuAl reconstruction
Archaeology and preservation of historical monuments has
for a long time made use of virtual 3D representation of de-
stroyed buildings and objects. But there hasn’t yet been an
automated procedure for assembling digitized components of
three-dimensional objects. So far, virtual reconstruction used
for presentation in a museum is a manual process which is
based on full knowledge of which part belongs where. But
automated reconstruction procedures are especially useful for
three-dimensional objects. When reconstructing these, restor-
ers struggle with multiple difficulties. First, the arrangement
of fragments in space presents various challenges. It is not
only difficult to practically do so, but often times additionally
complicated by the fact that the original form of the object to
be reconstructed is not known. Second, extensive excavations
or large-scale objects such as frescos render great numbers of
fragments. Virtual procedures can greatly assist and speed up
the process of classification and arrangement of such large
volumes of object fragments.
Fraunhofer IPK develops concepts for automated virtual re-
construction of three-dimensional objects using the example
of 100 000 marble slab fragments that are being excavated
in the ancient city of Ephesus in Turkey. The project is ideal
for first attempts in this field because no complex three-
dimensional registration of the fragments is required. Instead
a reconstruction by means of surface information is attempted
by evaluating contours and textures, similar to the process
described above for two-dimensional surfaces. In addition,
the thickness of the slabs at the breaking edges is taken into
consideration to help find fragment pairings – this is where
the procedure goes beyond that for reconstruction of two-
dimensional objects.
This method offers an intermediate step to »true« 3D recon-
struction: a 2D image of one side of the object is evaluated,
supplemented by information on depth. This procedure can be
considered a 2.5D reconstruction. In the next step entire 3D
objects can be constructed from several 2.5D images that por-
tray all areas of an object’s surface. One major challenge
in this context is to precisely distinguish between the object
and its break-up regions in order to generate respective views
of both.
High-quality 3D image acquisition devices designed for the
material to be reconstructed are a necessity for any kind of
spatial virtual reconstruction. State of the art are laser scanners
that capture a surface pointwise as well as devices using laser
cutting technology that gets depth information by layer cuts,
or topometric measuring systems that obtain depth informa-
tion via triangulation of patterns projected onto the object.
Additional procedures to gain 3D information, such as stereo-
photogrammetry, could also be taken into account.
Image acquisition is a major time factor in the processing of
three-dimensional objects. Therefore, Fraunhofer IPK first
develops concepts to execute this step as automated and ef-
ficiently as possible. Another field of work is the development
of algorithms for 3D reconstruction; here, successfully-tested
methods from 2D reconstruction are adapted and expanded.
Appl icat ion of automated v i r tual reconstruct ion is not l imited to two-dimensional objects such as paper
or papyrus. Three-dimensional reconstruct ion tasks can also great ly benef i t f rom the technology.
13
s t r a t e g I c P a r t n e r s
research and development partners
In the field of application-oriented basic research, Fraunhofer
IPK closely cooperates with the Institute for Computer Aided
Automation, CAA, of Vienna Technical University. Head of the
institute is Prof. Sablatnig, an internationally recognized figure
in the field of pattern recognition. His research team concen-
trates on the field of computer vision, image processing and
pattern recognition. They are international leaders in the use
of digital image processing for archaeology. Because their re-
search on methods of automated optical character recognition
has been so successful, they develop modules for character
extraction and classification for Fraunhofer IPK’s projects on
reconstruction.
Industry partners
Fraunhofer IPK’s important industry partners in the field of
reconstruction are arvato services and SAP Deutschland AG
& Co. KG (SAP Germany). arvato services is part of the global
Bertelsmann group and one of the largest suppliers of profes-
sional document management services in Germany. A success-
ful service enterprise for efficient solutions, arvato services has
longstanding experience in control and coordination of nation-
al and international services with complex business models.
The field of document management comprises a large spec-
trum of services; virtual reconstruction benefits from arvato
services’ elementary scan and logistics know-how. Having
provided similar services to other customers in the past, they
are experts on scanning, electronic storing, image processing
as well as transmission of electronically-processed image data.
arvato services has been Fraunhofer IPK’s strategic partner for
digitization within reconstruction projects since 2005. With
the start of the pilot phase of the BStU project, arvato services,
as a subcontractor of Fraunhofer IPK, is involved in digitizing
ruptured documents. Faced with masses of paper fragments,
the company manages a huge logistic challenge.
In terms of market capitalization, SAP is the world’s third-
largest independent software manufacturer for enterprises
and administrations. SAP has also been developing integrated
solutions, particularly in the public sector, since the beginning
of the 1990s (SAP Public Sector). With this, organizations are
able to successfully organize their business processes both in-
ternally and with customers, partners, and suppliers while sig-
nificantly improving the operational value. A leading software
manufacturer, SAP will in the future support Fraunhofer IPK in
product development and acquisition, performance and dis-
tribution for 2D digitization and reconstruction projects. SAP
also supports development of process-related graphical user
interfaces for automated virtual reconstruction and integration
of textual analysis procedures into document interpretation for
file forming and analysis.
clients as innovation partners
But not only partners from research, development, and indus-
try were in the past and still are relevant for bringing forward
reAching for higher goAls together
Virtual reconstruct ion is a technical ly and socia l ly re levant chal lenge for sc ience and research. Within
a global network of dist inguished partners in research and industry, Fraunhofer IPK has the goal of
thoroughly explor ing the potent ia l for reconstruct ion technology, thus highl ight ing Germany’s capabi l i -
t ies as a base for innovat ion in technology.
14
Kontakt
automated virtual reconstruction technologies. Fraunhofer
IPK’s client and a close partner in the Stasi documents frag-
ments project is »BStU«, the Office of the Federal Commis-
sioner Preserving the Records of the State Security Service of
the former G.D.R. More than 15 000 bags with ruptured Stasi
documents are in their archives, waiting for reconstruction
so that they can be used for archival development and for
tasks according to the Stasi Documents Law (StUG). The huge
amount of pre-destroyed archival materials and the manual
reconstruction of the Stasi documents that began in Zirndorf
near Nuremberg in February, 1995, is what inspired Fraun-
hofer IPK to its innovative technological developments. There
is a close cooperation between Fraunhofer IPK and BStU in
the interest of reviewing violent regimes. Together, they have
entered new territory in technology again and again. The chal-
lenges posed by the damaged Stasi files project have inspired
important advancements in the fields of computer-assisted for-
mation and analysis of the virtually reconstructed documents.
Issuer
Dr.-Ing. Bertram Nickolay
Fraunhofer Institute for Production Systems
and Design Technology IPK
Pascalstrasse 8-9, 10587 Berlin
www.ipk.fraunhofer.de
contact
Dr.-Ing. Bertram Nickolay, head of Security
Technology department
Phone: +49 30 39006-201
Fax: +49 30 391-7517
E-Mail: [email protected]
Dipl.-Ing. Jan Schneider, project manager
Phone: +49 30 39006-203
E-Mail: [email protected]
editorial staff: Nicole Kaiser, Jan Schneider,
Katharina Strohmeier
layout: Konstantin Heß
Photos: Fraunhofer IPK: Gerold Baumhauer (1,
2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, 15), Jan Schneider (12,13)
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Egyptian Museum
and Papyrus Collection: Myriam Krutzsch (10)
Imprint
© Fraunhofer IPK, 2010