framework: recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/simi-kamal... ·...

47
Pakistan’s Water Policy Framework: Recommendations September 25, 2017

Upload: others

Post on 21-Jun-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Pakistan’s Water Policy

Framework:

Recommendations

September 25, 2017

Page 2: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Pakistan Vision 2025 states that

“Pakistan‟s ultimate aspiration is to see

Pakistan among the ten largest economies

of the world by 2047, the centennial year of

our independence”

National Water Vision

Page 3: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

We must therefore, develop Pakistan‟s water

economy and provide clean, safe and accessible

water for all citizens as a right, balanced with

affordable and efficient water supply for

economic and social development with benefits

for all areas of Pakistan, and for both women

and men

Page 4: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

This is a call to action to federal and provincial

governments and will continue until Pakistan has a

feasible and actionable national water policy and

provincial water policies in place

Page 5: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Land and water belong to the women and men of

Pakistan and form their endowment and entitlement

Pakistan has the largest contiguous irrigation system

in the world

Of the 104 MAF of surface water diverted into

irrigation system on average each year, two-thirds is

lost in transmission

Preamble

Page 6: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Gomal River

Kurram River

Kabul River

Tarbela

Reservoir

ChashmaReservoir

Indus River

Jhelum River

Chenab River

Ra

vi R

ive

r

Su

tlej R

ive

rArabian Sea

Nee

lam

R

ive

r

Kala Bagh Reservoir(proposed)

ManglaReservoir

Sehwan Reservoir(Proposed)

ThalC

anal

Thalreservoir

(proposed)

JinnahBarrage

RasulBarrge

L.C

.C.

West

(Jhang)

L.C

.C.

East

(Gugera

)

U.C

henab

Inte

rnal

BR

BD

Inte

rnal

C.B

.D.C

U. D

epalp

ur

L. D

epalp

ur

L.B

.D.C

U.

Pakpatta

n

Ford

wah

Easte

rnS

adiq

ia

Dera

Ghazi K

han

Muzaffa

rgarh

KotriBarrage

SukkurBarrage

GudduBarrage

TaunsaBarrage

TrimmuBarrage

SidhnaiBarrage

BallokiBarrag

e

MaralaBarrage

KhankiBarrag

eQadirab

adBarrage

SulemankiBarrage

IslamBarrag

e

Ch

en

ab

Jh

elu

m

WarsakDam

Rangpur

Canal

C.R

.B.C

Indus Basin Irrigation System

Source: Hasan 2005, quoted in Pakistan’s Water Economy: Running Dry, Report, The World Bank, November 8, 2005, pg 4

Page 7: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Pakistan‟s economy is a „water economy‟

60 percent of the population directly engaged in

agriculture and livestock

80 percent of Pakistan‟s exports based on these

sectors

95 percent of surface water and almost all sweet

groundwater is used in agriculture

Water resources have competitive advantage for

building Pakistan

Page 8: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal
Page 9: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Annual agriculture GDP for 55 million acres of

irrigated land is under US$500 million for every

million acre feet of water

This makes total agriculture GDP of around US$50

billion per year

There is a potential to raise this substantially and

build upon and expand the water „value chain‟

Situational Analysis of Water and Unused

Potential

Page 10: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

The cost of replacement of the Indus basin system is

approximately US$ 300 billion.

The Indus basin system is our asset and we must

leverage it to generate local investment from within

Pakistan for repair and maintenance of this

infrastructure

We should also build new infrastructure where

needed, through cooperative, institutional and

innovative financing models

Page 11: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

a. Australia

Replace-

ment

Interest

Efficient

O & M

Financial

Requirements Who pays

Taxpayers

Users

Excess

man-

power

O & M

Replace-

ment

Interest Taxpayers

Taxpayers

Taxpayers

Users

Users

No one

b. Pakistan

Financial

RequirementsWho pays

Source: Pakistan’s Water Economy:Running Dry, Report, The World Bank, November 8, 2005, pg 59

The Financing of Water Services in

Pakistan

Page 12: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Five Focus Areas

Page 13: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Improving access to water for the poor and landless,

and maximizing water use efficiency

Financing the urban and rural water economies and

the water value chain

Safeguarding the Indus Basin, its aquifers and its

infrastructure

Improving water institutions, governance and

management

Building a base for science, technology and social

aspects of water

Page 14: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

National Water Goals over

Next 10 Years

Page 15: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Goal 1:

Extend the irrigation system to the arid districts of

Eastern Sindh, Southern KPK, Eastern Baluchistan

and Southern Punjab, bringing at least 5 million

new acres under cultivation for distribution to

poor and landless farmers

Page 16: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Goal 2:

Mobilize 5 MAF of additional surface water each

year to reach farm gate by third year of this policy

(40 MAF instead of current 35 MAF)

Mobilize10 MAF each year by the seventh year of

the policy (45 MAF instead of current 35 MAF)

Including savings in current system (lining canals in

areas, changes in cropping patterns and water

saving measures)

Include new/enhanced storages of different sizes

at different levels, as appropriate in different areas

Page 17: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Goal 3:

Improve water efficiency from the current level of 33

percent to approximately 43 percent (i.e. 45 MAF

instead of 35 MAF of irrigation water available at the

farm gate)

Goal 4:

Achieve 1 billion dollar output for every Million Acre

Feet (MAF) of water used in agriculture

Goal 5:

Preserve, maintain, repair and add to the existing

water infrastructure assets

Page 18: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Goal 6:

Revise abiyana to reflect the real value of water,

make it pro rata and geographically specific

Goal 7:

Control withdrawals in fresh groundwater areas and

line watercourses in saline groundwater areas

Goal 8:

Generate additional 10,000 MW indigenous

hydropower and reduce reliance on thermal power

Page 19: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Goal 9:

Institute coordination among water, agriculture and

industry for maximum benefits

Goal 10:

Make investment in water infrastructure and

hydropower a core part of China Pakistan Economic

Corridor (CPEC) but be cautious to protect our

water resources from overexploitation

Page 20: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Required Actions for

Achieving Goals in Each

Focus Area

Page 21: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Fix entitlements of provinces, areas and districts

based on all available sources of water (groundwater,

surface water and precipitation), rather than only

surface water

If one district has large supplies of groundwater, its

share from surface water shall be reduced

Water for Poor and Landless and Water

Efficiency

Page 22: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal
Page 23: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Eastern Sindh districts: Kashmore, Ghotki, Sukkur,

Khairpur, Sanghar, Umerkot, Mirpurkhas, Tharparkar,

Thatta and Badin

Southern Punjab the districts: Pakpattan,

Bahawalnagar, Bahawalpur, Muzzafargarh, Lodhran,

Rajanpur, DG khan, Layyah and Bhakkar

Districts that Require More Water

Page 24: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Eastern Baluchistan the disrtricts: Barkhan, Kohlu,

Dera Bugti, Naseerabad, Jafarabad, Jhal Magsi, and

Khuzdar

Southern KP the districts: DI Khan, Tank,

Lakki Marwat and Karak.

Page 25: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Zone land according to water productivity and

water/irrigation efficiency potential

Recognize the role of men and women farmers (not

absentee land owners) as fundamental in the

irrigation and agricultural production process

Protect the livelihoods of small and tenant farmers,

inland and coastal fishermen

Page 26: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Every person moving to an urban area must bring his

or her domestic water „entitlement‟ with them as a

right, and the water supply to the city adjusted

accordingly .

Allocate water for barani, hard rock and desert areas

of Pakistan

Financing the Urban and Rural Water

Value Chain

Page 27: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal
Page 28: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Raise „water bonds‟ and other financial instruments

to fund the proposed rehabilitation, maintenance and

repair of existing systems and new development

Make Pakistani public and private sector banks, as

well as investment houses, integral part of funding

water infrastructure and water value chain

Page 29: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Fix water rates will be evaluated in line with

economic and social realities to bring them close to

the “true” value of water

Separate access and right to water for agricultural or

other activities from ownership of land

Put into place a comprehensive set of water laws

that define water rights, uses, value, conservation and

principles of pricing, subsidies, licenses and polluter

penalties

Page 30: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal
Page 31: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Safeguarding the Indus Basin, its Aquifers

and its Infrastructure

Ensure Physical Sustainability and Integrity of Rivers,

Water Bodies, Catchment Areas, Groundwater and

Coastlines

Institute groundwater regulations across Pakistan

that are environmentally sound, socially acceptable,

economically viable and legally enforceable

Control mining of aquifers and introduce strict

regulation for groundwater exploitation

Page 32: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal
Page 33: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Introduce appropriate conservation methods (which

may be different for different areas) will achieve salt

balance in the Indus Basin

Screen all water initiatives for their resilience to

climate change

Ensure a regular, controlled minimum flow each year

to the sea, to safeguard delta areas and the coastline

Page 34: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Preserve traditional water harvesting systems such

as tonka system, Rod Kohi agriculture and Karez

systems

Implement water conservation through appropriate

incentives and penalties

The greatest water savings will be targeted where

there is greatest use – in agriculture

Fix downstream distribution system to minimize

losses.

Page 35: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

All the water sources available to a province

must be taken into account.

The existing surface water sharing formula will be

applied in a spirit of goodwill each season, and

monitored by an independent body until such time

that the provinces can sit down together to work

out all water available (surface water, groundwater

and precipitation) for all uses in each province and

territory and determine shares accordingly

Water Institutions, Governance and

Management

Page 36: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

This will be further broken down for establishing

water allocations and rights at the district level

Create a coalition of stakeholders to promote

citizens social responsibility on water issues

Share information and data with the public at large

to build consensus, reduce polarization and increase

awareness of citizens‟ responsibility in protecting

water resources

Page 37: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Building a Base for Science, Technology

and the Social Aspects of Water

Pakistani universities will become the strongest link in

developing the person power and skill base for

propelling the vision of this policy framework,

developing new courses and degrees to prepare

thousands of men and women to serve in the water

sectors

Page 38: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Develop knowledge base and skilled person power

envisaging Pakistan‟s needs for the next 100 years

Develop interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary water

studies in consonance with Pakistan‟s requirements

Linkages among academia, practice, industries,

agriculture and technology across the water value

chain

Incentivize greater use of technology to bring

efficiency and innovation to overcome water

challenges

Page 39: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Strengthening National Security through

Trans-boundary Cooperation on Shared

Water Resources

This policy calls for a concerted effort to shift the

paradigm of thinking about trans-boundary water

resources management from competing for scarce

resources to one of cooperation and benefit sharing

Working on Indus Basin Treaty with India

Page 40: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Exploring the potential of developing a treaty with

Afghanistan to share the Kabul River

Exploring cooperation with China on Indus waters

Page 41: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Demonstrating Leadership

Page 42: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Government needs to get serious, provide clear

leadership and put up a well-resourced permanent

water commission (that could be an empowered

existing water institution or a new one) led by

people of integrity and knowledge that can deliver

the intent of rational use of water in Pakistan

Page 43: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Responsibilities for Action at Federal Level

Ensuring physical sustainability and integrity of rivers,

water bodies, catchment areas, groundwater and

coastlines

Protecting the integrity of the Indus basin

Implementing water sharing (based on all sources of

water) among provinces and regions

Building infrastructure

Page 44: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Implementing regulations

Designing investment and financing mechanisms

Developing national conservation plans and

campaigns

Page 45: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Responsibilities for Action at Provincial

Level

Developing provincial water policy

Managing and maintaining infrastructure

Running irrigation and drainage systems in sustainable

and equitable manner

Allocating water for each district and getting water to

each district as per this allocation

Making the provincial Irrigation and Drainage

Departments financially autonomous

Page 46: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Responsibilities for Action at City Level

Managing municipal water in sustainable and

equitable manner

Developing novel and pervasive systems for

harvesting and storing water

Ensuring water supply for household, industrial,

municipal and recreational purposes

Page 47: Framework: Recommendationswaterconference.hisaar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Simi-Kamal... · Kala Bagh Reservoir (proposed) Mangla Reservoir Sehwan Reservoir (Proposed) l l Thal

Responsibilities for Action at Local Level

Managing local water for all its uses, in sustainable

and equitable manner

It is essential that a well-resourced, autonomous,

empowered and functioning local government is in

place to deliver the intent of this policy