fourth section - eods · fourth section case of mchugh and others v. the united kingdom...

186
FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February 2015 This judgment is final but it may be subject to editorial revision.

Upload: others

Post on 22-Mar-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

FOURTH SECTION

CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM

(Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others -

see list appended)

JUDGMENT

STRASBOURG

10 February 2015

This judgment is final but it may be subject to editorial revision.

Page 2: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February
Page 3: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 1

In the case of McHugh and Others v. the United Kingdom,

The European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), sitting as a

Committee composed of:

Päivi Hirvelä, President,

Nona Tsotsoria,

Faris Vehabović, judges,

and Fatoş Aracı, Deputy Section Registrar,

Having deliberated in private on 20 January 2015,

Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date:

PROCEDURE

1. The case originated in 1,015 applications against the United Kingdom

of Great Britain and Northern Ireland lodged with the Court under

Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and

Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”). A full list of the applicants and

their legal representatives, if applicable, is set out in the appendix.

2. The United Kingdom Government (“the Government”) were

represented by their Agent, Ms A. Sornarajah, of the Foreign and

Commonwealth Office.

3. On 22 September 2014 the applications were communicated to the

respondent Government.

4. Written observations were received from the Government and just

satisfaction claims were received from a number of the applicants.

THE FACTS

I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE

5. The applicants were all incarcerated at the relevant time following

criminal convictions for a variety of offences. They were automatically

prevented from voting, pursuant to primary legislation, in one or more of

the following elections: elections to the European Parliament on 4 June

2009; the parliamentary election on 6 May 2010; and elections to the

Scottish Parliament, the Welsh Assembly or the Northern Irish Assembly on

5 May 2011 (for further details see the appended table).

Page 4: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

2 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE

6. The relevant domestic law and practice is set out in Hirst v. the United

Kingdom (no. 2) [GC], no. 74025/01, ECHR 2005-IX; Greens and M.T.

v. the United Kingdom, nos. 60041/08 and 60054/08, ECHR 2010

(extracts); McLean and Cole v. the United Kingdom (dec.), nos. 12626/13

and 2522/12, 11 June 2013; and Firth and Others v. the United Kingdom,

nos. 47784/09, 47806/09, 47812/09, 47818/09, 47829/09, 49001/09,

49007/09, 49018/09, 49033/09 and 49036/09, 12 August 2014.

THE LAW

I. JOINDER

7. Given their similar factual and legal background, the Court decides

that the applications should be joined pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules

of Court.

II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 3 OF PROTOCOL No. 1 TO

THE CONVENTION

8. The applicants complained that they were prevented from voting in

elections (see paragraph 5 above). They relied on Article 3 of

Protocol No. 1 to the Convention, which reads as follows:

“The High Contracting Parties undertake to hold free elections at reasonable

intervals by secret ballot, under conditions which will ensure the free expression of

the opinion of the people in the choice of the legislature.”

A. Admissibility

9. The Court notes that the applications are not manifestly ill-founded

within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) of the Convention. It further notes

that they are not inadmissible on any other grounds. They must therefore be

declared admissible.

B. Merits

10. The Court has found that the statutory ban on prisoners voting in

elections was, by reason of its blanket character, incompatible with Article 3

of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention (see Hirst (No. 2), cited above, § 82;

and Greens and M.T., cited above, §§ 78-79). In Greens and M.T. it

indicated that some legislative amendment would be required in order to

Page 5: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 3

render the electoral law compatible with the requirements of the Convention

(see § 112 of the Court’s judgment). The Government subsequently

published a draft bill which underwent parliamentary scrutiny by a joint

committee of both Houses of Parliament. The committee’s report, published

in December 2013, made recommendations as to suitable legislative

amendments to be enacted and the appropriate timetable for enactment (see

Firth and Others, cited above, § 14).

11. Given that the impugned legislation remains unamended, the Court

cannot but conclude that, as in Hirst (no. 2), Greens and M.T. and Firth and

Others, and for the same reasons, there has been a violation of Article 3 of

Protocol No. 1 in the applicants’ case.

III. APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION

12. Article 41 of the Convention provides:

“If the Court finds that there has been a violation of the Convention or the Protocols

thereto, and if the internal law of the High Contracting Party concerned allows only

partial reparation to be made, the Court shall, if necessary, afford just satisfaction to

the injured party.”

13. Some of the applicants claimed non-pecuniary damage and costs and

expenses. As regards legal costs, they argued, variously, that since their

cases were lodged before the Court’s judgment in Greens and M.T., it was

unfair to refuse legal costs; that costs incurred in domestic proceedings

should be awarded; that postage costs should be awarded; and that legal

assistance was required to lodge the cases and consider the appropriate

response to the communication of the cases, and in particular the

implications of Firth and Others.

14. The Court does not consider that applicants who lodged their

applications before its judgment in Greens and M.T. should be entitled to

legal costs. It has already explained in its judgment in Firth and Others

(cited above, § 21) why it does not agree that legal assistance was required

to lodge an application. Further, in its Greens and M.T. judgment, the Court

explained that the award made in respect of costs in that case was limited to

the proceedings before it and reflected the fact that extensive written

submissions had been lodged in the context of the written proceedings in the

case. By contrast, the present cases were processed by the Court under a

simplified procedure and, following the Firth and Others judgment, the

Court’s approach to such follow-up cases was clear. In particular, the Court

does not accept that there was any need for legal assistance to consider the

implications of the Firth and Others judgment, since that judgment was

both concise and unambiguous.

15. In so far as some applicants claimed the costs of domestic court

proceedings, adequate vouching has not been provided showing that court

Page 6: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

4 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

fees or legal costs were charged or paid. The claims are accordingly

unsubstantiated.

16. Finally, while the Court accepts that some minor costs must have

been incurred in purchasing envelopes and postage stamps, it does not

consider it “necessary”, within the meaning of Article 41, to make any

award in respect of these costs in the present applications.

17. In conclusion, as in Firth and Others (cited above, § 18) and for the

same reasons, in the present case the Court concludes that the finding of a

violation constitutes sufficient just satisfaction for any non-pecuniary

damage sustained by the applicants. Further, for the reasons set out in

paragraphs 14-16 above and in Firth and Others (cited above, § 20-22), the

Court declines to make any award in respect of costs and expenses.

FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT, UNANIMOUSLY,

1. Decides to join the applications;

2. Declares the applications admissible;

3. Holds that there has been a violation of Article 3 of Protocol No. 1 to the

Convention;

4. Holds that the finding of a violation constitutes in itself sufficient just

satisfaction for any non-pecuniary damage sustained by the applicants;

5. Dismisses the remainder of the applicants’ claim for just satisfaction.

Done in English, and notified in writing on 10 February 2015, pursuant

to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court.

Fatoş Aracı Päivi Hirvelä

Deputy Registrar President

Page 7: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 5

APPENDIX

LIST OF APPLICANTS

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

1. 51987/08

07/06/2010

James Stevens MC

HUGH

16/01/1926

Hull

British

A1238AC

HMP Hull

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Hull

2. 49043/09

28/08/2009

James DOW

16/06/1984

Tullibody

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Glenochil

3. 49065/09

28/08/2009

James BROWN

05/03/1974

Tullibody

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Glenochil

4. 49077/09

19/08/2009

Michael QUINN

24/09/1971

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead.

5. 49083/09

28/08/2009

Kevin GIBSON

09/01/1980

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts.

Page 8: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

6 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

6. 58077/09

20/10/2009

Alan MAIR

27/11/1958

Tullibody

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Glenochil

7. 58452/09

20/10/2009

James

CUNNINGHAM

28/12/1976

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009

Detained at the relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

8. 58485/09

20/10/2009

Joseph

BLEAKLEY

05/06/1960

Forfar

British

HMP Noranside

TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time in HMP

Noranside

9. 58492/09

22/10/2009

John

DONALDSON

27/01/1948

Tullibody

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

10. 60710/09

09/11/2009

Christopher

LEARY

23/07/1980

Addiewell

British

HMP Addiewell

TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Addiewell

Page 9: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 7

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

11. 60716/09

09/11/2009

Brian

DOCHERTY

30/01/1968

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

12. 62146/09

17/11/2009

William MOUNT

09/11/1944

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

13. 67026/09

26/11/2009

Sean MC KAY

20/08/1967

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

14. 67036/09

26/11/2009

Jon MAC

INTOSH

17/11/1967

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

15. 67045/09

26/11/2009

Kevin HENDRY

23/05/1975

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

16. 67052/09

26/11/2009

Daniel

HAMILTON

27/07/1982

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

Page 10: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

8 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

17. 154/10

10/05/2010

Howard WOODIN

25/04/1959

Devizes

British

(A9946AF/KJ4609/A4224AA)

HMP Erlestoke

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

18. 22599/10

21/04/2010

Leon Martin

PUNCHARD

21/03/1991

Norwich

British

A5057AK

HMP Norwich

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Norwich

19. 29309/10

14/05/2010

Lee FLAHERTY

23/11/1956

Stockton on Tees

British

A8780AD

HMP Holme House

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

20. 29316/10

06/05/2010

Mark Anthony

HOOK

01/09/1976

Gloucester

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

21. 31679/10

24/05/2010

Kenneth REGAN

Evesham

British

A4838AE

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

22. 31888/10

25/05/2010

Paul BLACK

11/04/1959

Preston

British

A0321AG

HMP Wymott

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 11: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 9

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

23. 31914/10

19/05/2010

Peter William

LONGSTAFF

30/12/1974

Middlesbrough

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

24. 31950/10

03/06/2010

John DOUGHTY

28/06/1973

Norwich

British

A5575AM

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

25. 32163/10

07/06/2010

Kevin BUNBY

13/05/1957

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

26. 33293/10

01/06/2010

Jamie CHESHER

09/11/1976

Eastchurch

British

A9310AM

HMP Swaleside

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

27. 33416/10

14/09/2010

Richard MUSKER

Ashbourne

British

A8314AF

HMP Sudbury

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

28. 33417/10

24/08/2010

Stuart PEARSON

26/08/1978

Everthorpe

British

HMP Wolds

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Sudbury

Page 12: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

10 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

29. 33521/10

09/06/2010

John SMITH

22/02/1984

Whatton

British

A5875AA

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight

30. 33599/10

10/06/2010

George Robert

GALLOWAY

24/01/1964

Stockton on Tees

British

A3923AE

HMP Holme House

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

31. 33876/10

15/06/2010

Gareth

WHEATLEY

29/10/1979

Hull

British

VT5872

HMP Wolds

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wolds

32. 33888/10

14/06/2010

John Stanley

CAUGHEY

11/09/1953

Tullibody

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dumfries

33. 33906/10

14/06/2010

Lee James

POTTER

15/12/1983

Woking

British

A7663AL

HMP Coldingley

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Coldingley

Page 13: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 11

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

34. 33912/10

14/06/2010

John BRADY

10/05/1948

Wakefield

British

A9977AA

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

35. 33919/10

12/06/2010

Philip MC HUGH

14/09/1955

Bedford

British

General election 6 May 2010

Released on 23/07/2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

North Sea Camp

36. 34032/10

11/06/2010

Mohammad

IBRAHIM

27/12/1978

Nottingham

British

A7081AN

HMP Whatton

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shepton Mallet

37. 34212/10

08/06/2010

Keri ROMANS

22/05/1969

Goudhurst

British

A8597AN

HMP Blantyre House

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shepton Mallet

38. 34376/10

16/06/2010

Patrick John

CHAMBERS-

CLARKE

30/07/1960

Durham

British

A3931AE

HMP Frankland

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

Page 14: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

12 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

39. 34385/10

15/06/2010

Simon Onemena

KOGORO

05/07/1969

London

British

A9794AD General election 6 May 2010

Not known

40. 34433/10

10/06/2010

Raymond Eric

Gaylord COATES

23/06/1954

Hull

British

A0920AC

HMP Hull

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

41. 34457/10

08/06/2010

Raymond Stuart

MINNS

23/11/1978

Norwich

British

A5375AA

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight

42. 34561/10

09/06/2010

James MC

KERRELL

29/01/1943

Edinburgh

British

TAYLOR & KELLY General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

43. 34576/10

09/06/2010

Stephen MC

GOVANEY

30/05/1958

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

TAYLOR & KELLY General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

Page 15: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 13

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

44. 34672/10

16/06/2010

Brian KELSO

14/07/1969

Paignton

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

45. 34674/10

13/06/2010

Kevin Andrew

DOWNING

18/06/1963

Boston

British

A2797AN

HMP North Sea Camp

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dartmoor

46. 34899/10

18/06/2010

Jermaine

TAYLOR

16/01/1980

Beckenham

British

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Coldingley

47. 34933/10

21/06/2010

Gordon ALEE

20/06/1951

Lowdham

British

GT9030

HMP Lowdham Grange

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Lowdham Grange

48. 34939/10

21/06/2010

Andrew Sean FOX

29/06/1967

Nuneaton

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Hewell

49. 34953/10

17/06/2010

Wayne SHAW

17/12/1980

Woking

British

A2670AK

HMP Coldingley

BINDMANS LLP General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Coldingley

Page 16: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

14 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

50. 34957/10

14/06/2010

Gary Peter

PUTLAND

15/10/1978

Arundel

British

A3728AD

HMP Ford

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Coldingley

51. 37002/10

23/06/2010

Michael Elias

SAMUELS

05/10/1969

Hemel Hempstead

British

A2411AM

HMP The Mount

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Swaleside

52. 37099/10

25/06/2010

Brendon

OXENDALE

16/11/1983

Bristol

British

A8565AG

HMP Ashfield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

53. 37113/10

23/06/2010

Winston TAYLOR

03/01/1961

Bristol

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Leyhill

54. 37197/10

21/06/2010

Geoffrey Alfred

ALEXANDER

27/08/1962

Bridgend

British

AD6469

HMP Parc

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Parc

Page 17: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 15

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

55. 37522/10

28/06/2010

Mark WILSHIRE

22/01/1965

Monmouthshire

British

A6132AM

HMP Usk

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

56. 37525/10

28/06/2010

Lee Anthony

OSBORNE

24/12/1978

Whatton

British

A6372AM

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

57. 37541/10

28/06/2010

Paul Thomas

GOLDSMITH

15/07/1967

Maidstone

British

A1504AA

HMP Maidstone

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

58. 37655/10

28/06/2010

David Charles

Richard FROOMS

22/04/1947

Norwich

British

A5838AM

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

59. 37682/10

28/06/2010

Paul

WOODWARD

25/07/1960

Badersfield

British

A1989AMD

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 18: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

16 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

60. 37698/10

28/06/2010

Anthony John

CHANDLER

21/11/1957

Boston

British

A1522AA

HMP North Sea Camp

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

61. 37796/10

24/06/2010

James Marvin

JONES

20/06/1971

Denbigh

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wymott

62. 37828/10

18/06/2010

Christopher James

ANDREWS

22/04/1972

Willoughby

British

A9082AH

HMP Onley

General election 6 May 2010

10/01/2008 to unknown date; Detained

at relevant time at HMP Onley

63. 37918/10

24/06/2010

Brian Wayne

RICHARDS

23/05/1972

Pontypool

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Parc;

Released on 30/11/2011

64. 37961/10

23/06/2010

Keith PORTCH

10/12/1962

Minster

British

A6289AM General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Prisoner no. A6289AM

Page 19: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 17

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

65. 38089/10

28/06/2010

John LAMBE

16/08/1943

Nottingham

British

A5697AM

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

66. 38093/10

28/06/2010

Paul BURES

24/03/1954

Whotton

British

A5883AM

HMP Whotton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

67. 38148/10

27/06/2010

Steve COPELAND

02/04/1961

Retford

British

AJ2045AJ

HMP Ranby

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

68. 38160/10

25/06/2010

Simon Peter

CRAWFORD

10/04/1950

Scottow

British

A1435AA

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight, Albany Site

69. 38189/10

28/06/2010

Alan Michael

SWINDON-

ADAIR

19/07/1966

Durham

British

A7674AG

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 20: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

18 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

70. 38305/10

22/06/2010

Ben REDFERN-

EDWARDS

25/08/1984

York

British

HMP Full Sutton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

71. 38313/10

22/06/2010

Wayne Michael

GLANCY

21/02/1977

Newmarket

British

A4724AD

HMP Highpoint

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

72. 38331/10

25/06/2010

Mark MILLEN

14/06/1980

London

British

A2214AC

HMP Pentonville

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Coldingley

73. 38424/10

02/07/2010

Liam Matthew

CUNLIFFE

31/10/1975

Cheshire

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Sudbury

74. 38441/10

04/11/2010

Darren

WOODFORD

31/05/1987

Bisley

British

A5813AF

HMP Coldingley

BINDMANS LLP General election 6 May 2010

13/11/2009 to 14/03/2012; Detained at

relevant time at HMP Coldingley

Page 21: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 19

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

75. 38496/10

28/06/2010

Lou

NAPOLITANO

22/04/1966

Doncaster

Italian,British

A2376AJ

HMP Moorland

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

76. 38538/10

06/07/2010

Gary

RICHARDSON

Brasside

British

Anthony SHAW

Brasside

A4553AE

HMP Frankland

A4691AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

77. 38657/10

18/10/2010

Ian KENDRA

11/09/1969

Featherstone

British

A6016AF

HMP Oakwood

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

78. 38680/10

05/07/2010

Adam Terence

BELTON

01/04/1967

Newport

British

A2680AA

HMP Parkhurst

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

79. 38732/10

01/07/2010

Barrie Sean

William

HEWLETT

09/05/1966

Somerset

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 22: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

20 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

80. 38764/10

28/06/2010

Michael TULLY

28/10/1949

Bristol

British

A6111AM

HMP Ashfield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

81. 38772/10

15/06/2010

Stephen CASEY

09/01/1968

Leyland

British

A7731AF

HMP Wymott

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wymott

82. 38774/10

05/07/2010

David CANNON

02/03/1972

Brasside

British

A5548AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

83. 38782/10

22/06/2010

Anthony HAYES

07/05/1964

Bridgend

British

A5596CM)

HMP Parc

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Parc

84. 38822/10

06/07/2010

David NEWTON

27/09/1953

Wakefield

British

A9472AA

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

85. 38823/10

07/07/2010

Richard Robert

ANGEL

16/05/1965

Bournemouth

British

General election 6 May 2010

From 08/07/2009 to unknown date;

detained at relevant time at HMP

Dorchester

Page 23: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 21

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

86. 38832/10

05/07/2010

Obiagwu

IKEDIONU

02/09/1970

Newport

British

A3871AA

HMP Isle of Wight

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

87. 38833/10

30/06/2010

Adam George

WILLMOTT

24/04/1965

March

British

A5610AL

HMP Whitemoor

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Whitemoor

88. 38843/10

05/07/2010

Andrew MORRIS

01/08/1977

London

British

A2457AP

HMP Wormwood Scrubs

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Erlestoke

89. 38880/10

07/07/2010

Derek Royd

GATES

04/05/1975

Hull

British

A9879DA

HMP Hull

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

90. 38887/10

07/07/2010

Darren GLEAVES

10/11/1974

Ashbourne

British

A3320AK

HMP Sudbury

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Sudbury

Page 24: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

22 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

91. 38916/10

05/07/2010

William Matthew

Clifford WRIGHT

11/06/1969

Retford

British

A2060AJ

HMP Ranby

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

92. 38978/10

05/07/2010

Neville FOSTER

11/03/1966

Bovingdon

British

A2931AL

HMP The Mount

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

93. 39048/10

12/07/2010

Michael DOYLE

30/03/1983

Hatfield

Woodhouse -

Doncaster

British

A2481AJ

HMP Lindholme

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

94. 39072/10

07/07/2010

Casper SMITH

24/08/1983

London

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Coldingley

95. 39087/10

22/06/2010

Jarod YUSUF

03/11/1974

Wolverhampton

British

A0974AJ

HMP Featherstone

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010; EU

election 4 June 2009

From 11/03/2008 to unknown date

Page 25: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 23

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

96. 39090/10

22/06/2010

Christopher

Raymond

TRAVERSE

19/01/1942

Rugby

British

A8869AP

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010; EU

election 4 June 2009

From March 2010 to unknown date

97. 39096/10

22/06/2010

Warren ELLIS

25/03/1970

Rugby

British

A0796AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010;

From 20/11/2009 to unknown date

98. 39106/10

22/06/2010

Simon Paul

SWAIN

10/12/1975

Rugby

British

A8514AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

From 29/10/2008 to unknown date

99. 39109/10

22/06/2010

Andrew NELSON

07/10/1981

Rugby

British

A9763AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

From 18/05/2009 to unknown date

100. 39150/10

22/06/2010

Steven Barry

HOLMES

27/03/1981

Rugby

British

A8743AC

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

From 27/04/2009 to unknown date

Page 26: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

24 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

101. 39152/10

22/06/2010

Lee Andrew

GIDDINGS

04/03/1979

Rugby

British

A9655AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

From 05/08/2009 to unknown date

102. 39153/10

22/06/2010

Lewis NOCITO

28/03/1988

Rugby

British

A9796AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

11/09/2009 to unknown date

103. 39156/10

22/06/2010

Ryan BURNS

14/05/1985

Rugby

British

A0415AQ

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

From 07/05/2009 to unknown date

104. 39160/10

22/06/2010

Benjamin BENN

22/08/1987

Rugby

British

A7791AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

From 02/06/2009 to unknown date

105. 39162/10

22/06/2010

Daniel BRICE

20/07/1987

Rugby

British

A8787AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

From 12/08/2009 to unknown date

106. 39165/10

22/06/2010

Michael John

DOMICAN

30/10/1979

Rugby

British

A8730AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

From 23/11/2006 to unknown date

Page 27: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 25

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

107. 39171/10

22/06/2010

Peter James

CROFTS

09/05/1978

Rugby

British

PD6695/A7730AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

13/07/2005 to unknown date

108. 39175/10

18/06/2010

Sean James

REILLY

05/05/1982

Rugby

British

A8147AH

HMP Onley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

16/12/2006 to unknown date

109. 39251/10

30/06/2010

John James Dean

FERN

26/03/1968

Newport

British

A8147AH

HMP Isle of Wight

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

110. 39272/10

29/10/2010

James CURTIN

12/01/1982

Maidstone

British

A1491AA

HMP Maidstone

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

04/01/2004 to unknown date

111. 39319/10

08/07/2010

Peter O’BRIEN

03/07/1963

Worsley

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wymott

Page 28: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

26 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

112. 39354/10

28/06/2010

Sheraz Ateeque

BHATTI

21/01/1981

Burnley

British

A6298AF General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wymott

prisoner no. A6298AF

113. 39385/10

01/07/2010

Garry MEE

17/10/1955

South Littleton

British

A8519AG

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

114. 39738/10

12/07/2010

Mark Anthony

MORRIS

20/08/1963

Leyland

British

A2276AF

HMP Garth

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Garth

115. 39781/10

09/07/2010

Derek John

KENNY

28/02/1965

Haverrig

British

A4869AF

HMP Haverigg

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Released on 29/03/2011

116. 39792/10

15/07/2010

Michael

DINSDALE

26/07/1972

Wealstun

British

A2607AC

HMP Wealstun

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

20/12/2007 to unknown date

Page 29: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 27

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

117. 40254/10

08/07/2010

Alan LORD

30/05/1961

Currington

British

A8521AE

HMP Risley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

118. 40301/10

15/07/2010

Shaun MC

PHERSON

08/01/1985

Wakefield

British

A5543AE

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

119. 40305/10

15/07/2010

Anthony Joseph

GLEESON

12/07/1954

Birmingham

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Whatton

120. 40390/10

14/07/2010

Guy Peter

TASKER

14/10/1977

South Littleton

British

(A8589AF)

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

121. 40415/10

14/07/2010

Michael DIXON

10/07/1961

London

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 30: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

28 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

122. 40578/10

01/07/2010

Richard

MATTHEWS

12/11/1987

Inverness

British

HMP Portefield TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

123. 40596/10

30/06/2010

Raymond William

JUDE

15/04/1967

Dunbar

British

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

124. 40885/10

16/07/2010

Nangyal

GAUHAR

14/07/1983

Bovingdon

British

A5602AL

HMP The Mount

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

125. 40889/10

15/07/2010

James William

SIBLEY

06/11/1965

Woolavington

British

General election 6 May 2010

30/08/2008 to unknown date; Detained

at relevant time at HMP Dartmoor

126. 40935/10

13/07/2010

Roderic Barrie

CHAFFIN-LAIRD

20/11/1944

Monks Gate

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 31: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 29

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

127. 40943/10

13/07/2010

Gary Stuart

WARD

06/12/1973

Warrington

British

A0710AK

HMP Risley

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

128. 41145/10

13/07/2010

Karl

HOLDSTOCK

13/04/1974

Hull

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

129. 41247/10

14/07/2010

James BRENNAN

17/02/1982

Normanton

British

General election 6 May 2010

03/11/2008 to 19/11/2010

130. 41272/10

14/07/2010

Leslie Richard

BERRY

14/08/1932

PERRY

British

A2696AL

HMP Littlehey

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Littlehey

131. 41290/10

23/06/2010

Mark

LEICESTER

17/01/1962

Brasside

British

A5451AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

Page 32: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

30 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

132. 41295/10

23/06/2010

Andrew Nicholas

MALKINSON

23/01/1966

Brasside

British

A5519AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

133. 41528/10

20/07/2010

William HORNEY

05/05/1952

South Littleton

British

A9357AS

HMP Long Lartin

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Parc

134. 41544/10

20/07/2010

Desmond BAZIL

31/07/1958

Scottow

British

A6674AP

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

135. 41579/10

19/07/2010

Ian GEORGE

18/09/1969

Princetown

British

A4196AN

HMP Dartmoor

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

136. 41592/10

29/10/2010

Michelle

SAUNDERS

29/07/1967

Maidstone

British

A5737AM

HMP Maidstone

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

137. 41663/10

27/06/2010

Shaun Paul

WALLACE

09/06/1953

Kersly

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 33: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 31

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

138. 41861/10

20/07/2010

Terence John

LOCKHART

16/09/1963

Oakham

British

A1752AK

HMP Ashwell

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

139. 42172/10

26/07/2010

Marcus

WINGFIELD

28/01/1975

Griston

British

A2362AE

HMP Wayland

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

140. 42189/10

27/07/2010

Shane

RATCLIFFE

14/03/1961

Princetown

British

A3576AN

HMP Dartmoor

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dartmour

141. 42202/10

22/07/2010

Moussin

BOUJJETTIF

13/06/1979

Gartree

British

A1411AK

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 13 December 2003 pursuant to

life sentence

142. 42225/10

22/07/2010

Stuart Alistair

MORRIS

01/04/1959

Rugby

British

A7972AG

HMP Rye Hill

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

Page 34: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

32 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

143. 42420/10

15/07/2010

David Samuel

BROWN

17/03/1970

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

144. 42648/10

28/07/2010

Sarah Jane

BAKER

26/07/1969

Kettering

British

A1801AF (formerly Alan

BAKER)

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Grendon

Prisoner no. A1801AF

145. 42650/10

23/07/2010

Tony Paul

WILKINSON

26/08/1980

South Littleton

British

A6034AD

HMP Long Lartin

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

146. 42654/10

23/07/2010

Nadeem KHAN

06/05/1978

Coventry

British

A7720AG General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

Prisoner no. A7720AG

147. 42768/10

26/07/2010

Jaswant KAJLA

19/01/1980

Featherstone

British

A1644AH

HMP Featherstone

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 35: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 33

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

148. 42791/10

26/07/2010

Jason Anthony

COX

08/03/1976

Griston

British

A8824AP

HMP Wayland

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

149. 43003/10

29/07/2010

Michael Peter

JALLAND

15/10/1953

Bournemouth

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Usk

150. 43012/10

12/07/2010

Anthony

WOODBINE

19/08/1966

Wakefield

British

A9520AA

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

151. 43030/10

23/07/2010

Michael Edward

HANN

26/11/1981

Bisley

British

A5686AK

HMP Coldingley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

152. 43046/10

05/07/2010

Gary Stephen

NASH

30/09/1970

Exeter

British

A7190AQ

HMP Exeter

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dartmoor

Page 36: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

34 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

153. 43323/10

12/07/2010

Gareth GARSIDE

07/06/1986

Huddersfield

British

General election 6 May 2010

09/03/2010 to unknown date

154. 43332/10

07/07/2010

Colin Edward

MANGAN

09/07/1974

Manchester

British

A3807AK

HMP Manchester

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Manchester

155. 43374/10

27/07/2010

Russell Mark

HEPWORTH

16/12/1978

Hull

British

A2984AP

HMP Hull

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Hull

156. 43418/10

27/07/2010

Gary HINDS

20/03/1964

Whatton

British

A8253AK

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

157. 43425/10

27/07/2010

Michael John

SMITH

11/01/1939

Shepton Mallet

British

General election 6 May 2010

06/11/2009 to 16/09/2010

158. 43453/10

02/08/2010

Ross RYAN

05/10/1988

Brasside

British

A0137AF

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 19 February 2008 pursuant to

nineteen year sentence

Page 37: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 35

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

159. 43455/10

29/07/2010

Norman FISHER

06/03/1969

Risley

British

A9953AH

HMP Risley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

160. 43462/10

27/07/2010

Keith Brian

TAYLOR

05/10/1964

Risley

British

A0092AF

HMP Risley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Risley

161. 43469/10

27/07/2010

Nigel STORY

26/09/1969

Huntington

British

A3593AL

HMP Littlehey

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Littlehey

162. 45238/10

02/08/2010

Stuart MOIR

12/11/1966

Portland

British

A7606AN

HMP The Verne

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

163. 45241/10

03/08/2010

Bernard

HOPKINS

29/04/1947

South Wales

British

A5494AH

HMP-YOI Parc

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

164. 45246/10

02/08/2010

Robert

WILLGOSS

14/04/1989

Griston

British

A6061AK

HMP Wayland

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 38: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

36 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

165. 45299/10

02/08/2010

Paul

STEVENSON

29/09/1986

Thetford

British

A5004AK

HMP Wayland

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

166. 45302/10

05/08/2010

James Daniel

GILLIGAN

07/07/1977

Featherstone

British

A9369AG

HMP Oakwood

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

167. 45305/10

02/08/2010

Alan WILLIAMS

22/03/1961

London

British

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

168. 45311/10

28/07/2010

David IRWIN

21/01/1974

Durham

British

A3452AP

HMP Durham

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

169. 45317/10

24/10/2010

Alan Joseph

CURRY

23/09/1965

Liverpool

British

A6796AF

HMP Kennet

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 39: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 37

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

170. 45321/10

04/08/2010

Robert

Christopher

HODGEON

08/05/1953

Leyland

British

A0378AG

HMP Wymott

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wymott

171. 45324/10

29/07/2010

James John MC

DAID

06/12/1965

Bedford

British

A3411AL

HMP Bedford

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

172. 45410/10

30/07/2010

Colin David

EVANS

30/08/1981

Devizes

British

A3733AH

HMP Erlestoke

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at the relevant time at HMP

Garth

173. 45423/10

04/07/2010

Shahram

AGHAJANPOOR

21/01/1975

MANCHESTER

British

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at the relevant time

174. 45428/10

02/07/2010

Daniel

STEPHENSON

22/12/1987

HULL

British

A8647AD

HMP Hull

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at the relevant time at HMP

Hull

Page 40: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

38 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

175. 45562/10

03/08/2010

Robert Neil

SYMES

26/09/1959

LIVERPOOL

British

A7474AH

HMP Liverpool

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at the relevant time at HMP

Liverpool

176. 45770/10

05/08/2010

Leon SETCHELL

11/11/1986

Griston

British

A0213AM

HMP Wayland

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

177. 45778/10

06/08/2010

Neil Andrew

HOWARD

19/04/1973

Griston

British

A4279AK

HMP Wayland

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

178. 45780/10

10/10/2010

Andrew John

RYAN

20/01/1979

BICESTER

British

A5139AA

HMP Bullingdon

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

179. 45795/10

06/08/2010

Gordon FRASER

05/10/1961

NEWPORT

British

A1123AQ

HMP Parkhurst

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

180. 45811/10

29/10/2010

Derek BAINES

Leyland

British

A4090AF

HMP Wymott

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 41: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 39

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

181. 45819/10

04/08/2010

Nicholas FOGO

27/05/1979

Rutland

British

HMP Ashwell

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 15 February 2001 pursuant to life

sentence

182. 45821/10

18/10/2010

David Alan

BURGIN

07/05/1961

Nottingham

British

A9004AN

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

183. 45846/10

18/10/2010

David Anthony

ENGLAND

26/08/1966

Bovingdon

British

A1701CD

HMP The Mount

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Lowdham Grange

184. 45847/10

09/08/2010

Robert Alan

JACKSON

03/11/1959

Wakefield

British

A7892AE

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

185. 45852/10

06/08/2010

Darren JENKINS

15/01/1977

Devizes

British

A0202AP

HMP Erlestoke

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shepton Mallet

186. 46493/10

10/08/2010

Derek HUNTER

27/06/1965

PORTSMOUTH

British

A7687AC

HMP Kingston

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 42: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

40 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

187. 46530/10

10/08/2010

Shaun Gary

O’ROURKE

04/11/1968

Milton Keynes

British

A7544AL

HMP Woodhill

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

188. 46608/10

09/08/2010

Silroy BENNETT

01/06/1976

Newport

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Erlestoke

189. 46614/10

09/08/2010

Shaun Russell

PARKINSON

24/08/1983

Wootton-Under-

Edge

British

A7233AF

HMP Leyhill

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wymott

190. 46642/10

18/06/2010

Peter

DOCHERTY

14/09/1969

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

191. 46656/10

02/07/2010

David

BLACKMORE

23/11/1982

Ifeld

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 43: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 41

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

192. 46657/10

09/08/2010

Geoffrey

SHEPHERD

10/01/1942

Nottingham

British

A5434AM

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

193. 46662/10

02/08/2010

Ian Neil VICKERS

22/03/1954

Lewes

British

A5665AM

HMP Lewes

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

194. 46697/10

20/07/2010

Winston WHITE

03/09/1963

Nottingham

British

A5915AA

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

195. 46740/10

09/08/2010

Peter GRAHAM

28/11/1965

LIVERPOOL

British

BN8687

HMP Altcourse

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

196. 46757/10

11/08/2010

Timothy James

TUCKER

11/07/1948

Melksham

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

197. 46805/10

18/06/2010

Neil

ROBERTSON

05/10/1965

Tullibody

British

78510

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

Page 44: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

42 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

198. 46866/10

14/06/2010

Joseph

MILLBANK

19/07/1960

Edinburgh

British

70191

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Not known

199. 47337/10

11/08/2010

Richard NELSON

24/04/1964

Newton Abbot

British

A3319AN

HMP Channings Wood

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

200. 47362/10

09/08/2010

David Edward

TYSON

23/03/1982

LIVERPOOL

British

X11593

HMP Altcourse

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

201. 47365/10

11/08/2010

Benjamin

Laurence GAULE

24/09/1939

Newport

Irish,British

A8477AG

HMP Isle of Wight

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

202. 47370/10

11/08/2010

Alex SHARMAN

23/08/1989

AYLESBURY

British

A0730AD

HMYOI Aylesbury

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 45: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 43

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

203. 47374/10

11/08/2010

Shane MC

KENZIE

15/11/1983

LONDON

British

A8503AQ

HMP Belmarsh

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

204. 47543/10

10/08/2010

Steve BERGER

03/04/1964

Woodford Green

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

205. 47564/10

13/08/2010

Glen James

Douglas WILSON

12/12/1968

Wealstun

British

A7415AA

HMP Wealstun

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

206. 47580/10

11/08/2010

Carl

TEMPLETON

29/04/1986

Banbury

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

207. 47719/10

12/08/2010

Damien WASON

04/07/1985

Longforgan

British

HMP Castle Huntly

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 46: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

44 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

208. 47749/10

16/08/2010

Jimmy Anthony

TEMPLE

07/02/1958

Norwich

British

A7112AN

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shepton Mallet

209. 47763/10

08/08/2010

Maurice Patrick

CROSSLEY

28/09/1975

Tullibody

British

18162

HMP Glenochil

General election 6 May 2010; Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

210. 47786/10

16/08/2010

William

DICKENS

22/06/1986

Croydon

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Coldingley

211. 47837/10

13/08/2010

Derek Thomas

WAY

20/02/1943

Worcestershire

British

A8513AG

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

212. 47842/10

16/10/2010

John SADIQ

02/06/1971

County Durham

British

A0352AK

HMP Durham

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 47: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 45

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

213. 47892/10

16/08/2010

David WILES

27/05/1975

Herts

British

A3478AQ

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Bedford; Released on 14/03/2011

214. 47902/10

09/08/2010

Garry CLIFTON

19/07/1964

Wolverhampton

British

A1870AJ

HMP Oakwood

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Nottingham

215. 47983/10

16/08/2010

Frances INGLIS

27/02/1952

Ashford

British

VM8688

HMP Bronzefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

20/01/2010 to unknown date

216. 48131/10

17/08/2010

Aarran

HENDERSON

30/06/1977

Ashford

British

A1272AQ General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Prisoner no. A1272AQ

217. 48137/10

16/08/2010

William G.R.

LITTLE

18/09/1967

Arundel

British

A5684AD

HMP Ford

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

218. 48249/10

13/08/2010

Dave VANN

13/04/1961

MOOR LANE

British

A5121AC

HMP Fullsutton

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Full

Sutton; Released on 17/11/2010

Page 48: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

46 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

219. 48277/10

11/08/2010

Peter James

Andrew

MUSGROVE

31/05/1972

Rugby

British

A9257AG

HMP Rye Hill

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

220. 48681/10

16/08/2010

John James MC

FADYEN

23/09/1979

HULL

British

A5167AF

HMP Hedon Road

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

221. 48719/10

18/08/2010

Trevor

PILLINGER

24/01/1962

Onley

British

A9461AG

HMP Rye Hill

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

222. 48730/10

17/08/2010

Wayne

Christopher

RHODEN

10/12/1970

Newmarket

British

A5442AK

HMP Highpoint

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

223. 48736/10

04/11/2010

Gene Anthony

MORRISON

05/09/1958

Risley

Jamaican

A7188AE

HMP Risley

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 49: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 47

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

224. 48743/10

16/08/2010

Ivan THOMPSON

04/07/1970

DURHAM

British

AO889AN

HMP Durham

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

225. 48813/10

12/08/2010

Christopher John

WRAY

18/04/1964

Durham

British

A5138AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

226. 48861/10

20/08/2010

Guy

LONGHURST

21/10/1963

Walton Highway -

Norfolk

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Littlehey

227. 48875/10

17/08/2010

Dale Anthony

DAY

22/12/1987

Nottingham

British

A0817AC

HMP Nottingham

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

228. 49333/10

29/10/2010

Andrew

BARLOW

12/05/1956

Hull

British

A6067AL

HMP Hull

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 50: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

48 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

229. 49343/10

05/08/2010

Mark BURNS

15/10/1984

Market Drayton

British

A9846AE

HMP Stokeheath

General election 6 May 2010

19/03/2010 to 24/03/2011; Detained at

relevant time at HMP Liverpool

230. 49678/10

24/08/2010

Martin Lewis

CALVER

12/10/1959

Ipswich

British

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Burke

231. 49679/10

24/08/2010

Keith Andrew

GODDEN

27/09/1970

Cambridgeshire

British

A1751AL

HMP-YOI Littlehey

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Littlehey

232. 49688/10

23/08/2010

Mohammed

HANIF

01/09/1967

Derbyshire

British

A2139AH

HMP Sudbury

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

233. 50061/10

22/08/2010

Darren SCOTT

28/05/1966

Wakefield

British

A5231AE

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

234. 50106/10

27/08/2010

Jay SAVAGE

19/04/1966

Croydon

British

(formerly J. COOKE) General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 51: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 49

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

235. 50113/10

27/08/2010

Peter Alan

Thomas

BLACKWELL

03/03/1968

Oxfordshire

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

236. 50157/10

28/07/2010

Martin

RUSHTON

07/01/1971

Uttoxeter

British

A5562CA

HMP Dovegate

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

237. 50937/10

15/08/2010

Andrew IVISON

08/07/1973

Bicester

British

A4003AD

HMP Bullingdon

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Bullingdon

238. 50943/10

31/08/2010

Peter Dennis

WHITE

01/01/1932

Full Sutton

British

A5092AC

HMP Full Sutton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

239. 50958/10

31/08/2010

Chris QUADDY

10/11/1972

Evesham

British

A7779AG

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

Page 52: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

50 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

240. 50968/10

31/08/2010

Mark James

CROOKSHANK

05/08/1964

Brighton

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

241. 50978/10

31/08/2010

Owen DAVIES

06/07/1969

Isle of Wight

British

A7787AA

HMP Parkhurst

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Hull

242. 51167/10

31/08/2010

Gordon

MCLACHLAN

25/03/1972

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

243. 51174/10

01/09/2010

Graham

SNEDDON

07/03/1981

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

244. 51196/10

31/08/2010

Peter Kevin

NUTTALL

13/04/1966

Risley

British

A1306AF

HMP Risley

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Risley

Page 53: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 51

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

245. 51410/10

01/09/2010

Darren JAMES

27/08/1973

Durham

British

A4147AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

246. 51412/10

02/09/2010

Richard TIPPETT

22/01/1977

Huntingdon

British

A2698AL

HMP Littlehey

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Littlehey

247. 51417/10

27/08/2010

Michael Paul

CONNOR

02/08/1966

Leicester

British

HMP Gartree

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

248. 52097/10

29/08/2010

Jaslyn Ricardo

SMITH

19/08/1965

South Littleton

British

A4250AE

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

249. 52188/10

06/09/2010

Graham PARKIN

25/09/1979

Stockton on Tees

British

A6122AF

HMP Holme House

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Holme House

250. 52208/10

09/09/2010

Kevin John

BAKER

25/07/1973

Evesham

British

A7752AG

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

Page 54: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

52 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

251. 52213/10

06/09/2010

Paul HULL

20/08/1953

Cambridgeshire

British

A3660AL

HMP-YOI Littlehey

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

252. 52580/10

08/09/2010

Gavin Damon

AMBLER

07/08/1978

Retford

British

A3923AL

HMP Ranby

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

253. 52583/10

08/09/2010

Paul Victor

BOWERS

28/11/1967

Kent

British

A7937AQ

HMP Elmey

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Elmley

254. 52976/10

08/09/2010

Jason

SUNDERLAND

05/06/1972

Maghull

British

A6155AN

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

255. 52978/10

07/09/2010

James COLEMAN

Liverpool

British

A3707AF

HMP Kennet

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

256. 53255/10

11/09/2010

Fred BENNETT

24/10/1949

Featherstone

British

A4739AP

HMP Oakwood

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 55: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 53

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

257. 53262/10

14/09/2010

Andrew ARNOLD

06/02/1981

Wolverhampton

British

A1034AH

HMP Featherstone

General election 6 May 2010

12/12/2006 to unknown date

258. 53263/10

16/09/2010

Christopher

ALLEN

16/11/1970

Shaftesbury

British

A7140AN

HMP Guys Marsh

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

259. 53748/10

09/09/2010

George Albert

MIDDLEMAST

30/12/1950

Pinner

British

General election 6 May 2010

Released on 12/12/2011

260. 54641/10

27/08/2010

Richard

MACKENZIE

19/05/1949

Kingston upon Hull

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

261. 55166/10

22/09/2010

Steve BROWNE

08/07/1956

Newport

British

A5372AA

HMP Isle of Wight

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 56: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

54 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

262. 55197/10

30/07/2010

E.M.

NEWBERRY

04/08/1951

Newport

British

A1521AA E

HMP Albany

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

263. 55212/10

22/09/2010

Elroy MC

ARTHUR

15/10/1977

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

264. 55218/10

22/09/2010

Paul IGOE

13/05/1974

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

265. 55690/10

21/09/2010

Kim Stuart

SWANSON

10/11/1965

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

266. 55703/10

22/09/2010

Kevin Paul

CLEMENT

18/07/1960

Newport

British

A8138AC

HMP Albany

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 57: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 55

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

267. 55704/10

22/09/2010

Patrick LOYDEN

06/10/1968

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

268. 55761/10

17/09/2010

Paul Adrian

FLINDERS

21/09/1952

EVESHAM

British

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

269. 55762/10

21/09/2010

Graham MEIKLE

01/06/1966

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

270. 55767/10

17/09/2010

Colin WHYTE

25/03/1967

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

271. 55769/10

17/09/2010

Christopher

Francis

BOUHADI

04/12/1984

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 58: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

56 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

272. 55771/10

16/09/2010

Michael

HODGSON

10/07/1961

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

273. 55776/10

16/09/2010

Andrew SHEK

07/09/1973

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

274. 55781/10

16/09/2010

Paul DOWDS

03/08/1974

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

275. 55783/10

16/09/2010

John COYLE

03/01/1973

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

276. 55786/10

16/09/2010

David MC

INERNEY

29/03/1967

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

277. 55799/10

21/09/2010

Scott DUNCAN

19/05/1981

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 59: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 57

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

278. 55966/10

23/09/2010

Albert MASSIE

16/01/1961

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

279. 55970/10

23/09/2010

Euan

KIRKWOOD

16/04/1985

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

280. 55973/10

24/09/2010

Jason ALDER

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

281. 55977/10

24/09/2010

David PENMAN

15/01/1975

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

282. 56035/10

27/09/2010

Lucy BAKER

22/06/1977

Maidstone

British

HMP East Sutton Park

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

283. 56041/10

27/09/2010

Zoe Maureen

KENEALY

22/06/1963

MAIDSTONE

British

A0283AD

HMP East Sutton Park

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 60: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

58 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

284. 56046/10

27/09/2010

Philip ROBINSON

15/05/1966

HUNTINGDON

British

A3480AL

HMP Littlehey

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Littlehey

285. 56167/10

23/09/2010

James

CRAWFORD

30/03/1980

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

286. 56168/10

23/09/2010

John MILLER

31/07/1963

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

287. 56174/10

23/09/2010

Garry GRAHAM

07/09/1971

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

288. 56176/10

23/09/2010

Robert KIDD

16/06/1984

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time in HMP

Shotts

289. 56179/10

23/09/2010

Thomas

CAMPLING

30/01/1971

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

shotts

Page 61: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 59

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

290. 56183/10

23/09/2010

Robert

TAGGART

29/11/1953

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time in HMP

Shotts

291. 56184/10

23/09/2010

Graham LYNN

20/11/1986

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

292. 56187/10

23/09/2010

William LYNAS

04/09/1966

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

293. 56192/10

23/09/2010

Kenneth MOORE

25/06/1973

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained atr relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

294. 56193/10

23/09/2010

Michael

GORMAN

28/03/1965

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

295. 56201/10

23/09/2010

Colin Stuart

SCOTT

21/02/1969

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

Page 62: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

60 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

296. 56203/10

23/09/2010

James BLACK

17/06/1976

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

297. 56209/10

23/09/2010

John MC

GEECHAN

17/05/1960

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

298. 56214/10

23/09/2010

James

CULLINANE

11/09/1964

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

299. 56215/10

23/09/2010

Gary WILSON

19/05/1969

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

300. 56284/10

16/09/2010

Robert

SANDERSON

09/12/1970

Greenock

British

HMP Gateside

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 63: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 61

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

301. 56289/10

16/09/2010

John Lawrie

LAWSON

04/06/1960

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

302. 56291/10

16/09/2010

Alexander REID

22/07/1974

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

303. 56292/10

16/09/2010

Graeme BEWS

16/01/1984

Glasgow

British

HMP Barlinnie

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

304. 56293/10

16/09/2010

Matthew MC

LACHLAN

13/05/1976

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Bowhouse

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

305. 56297/10

16/09/2010

John Paul SMITH

10/02/1971

Glasgow

British

HMP Barlinnie

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

306. 56790/10

28/09/2010

John FORBES

13/01/1988

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Saughton

Page 64: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

62 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

307. 56831/10

28/09/2010

Duncan

MCDONALD

04/04/1980

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Detaoned at relevant time at HMP

Saughton

308. 56843/10

28/09/2010

Bryan BOYLE

21/06/1988

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Saughton

309. 56884/10

30/09/2010

Michael CAINE

08/12/1976

Liverpool

British

A7055AQ

HMP Kennet

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained since October 2009 at HMP

Kennet

310. 57035/10

29/09/2010

Gary SCOTT

24/05/1981

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

311. 57039/10

28/09/2010

Thomas MC

INTYRE

04/10/1974

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

312. 57043/10

29/09/2010

Barry RYCE

25/05/1966

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

Page 65: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 63

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

313. 57045/10

28/09/2010

William

MCDONALD

18/02/1960

Dumfries

British

HMP Dumfries

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dumfries

314. 57053/10

28/09/2010

Mitchell Gray

DOLPHIN

06/07/1958

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

315. 57064/10

28/09/2010

William

SINCLAIR

24/12/1966

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

316. 57071/10

28/09/2010

James RENNIE

12/01/1971

Tullibody

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

317. 57089/10

28/09/2010

Patrick COYLE

15/09/1963

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

318. 57097/10

29/09/2010

James GIRVAN

05/07/1970

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

Page 66: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

64 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

319. 57103/10

29/09/2010

Colin MURPHY

01/06/1969

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

320. 57108/10

29/09/2010

Bryan

GALLOWAY

01/07/1984

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

321. 57115/10

29/09/2010

William Hugh

LAUCHLAN

01/07/1976

Tullibody

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

322. 57122/10

29/09/2010

Donald MAIN

21/08/1988

Tullibody

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

323. 57128/10

29/09/2010

Ronald

CLYDESDALE

29/12/1943

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

324. 57135/10

29/09/2010

Colin SLAVEN

08/06/1985

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

Page 67: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 65

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

325. 57140/10

28/09/2010

Alexander MC

BRIDE

06/08/1954

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

326. 57244/10

28/09/2010

Colin HENDRY

13/08/1964

Dumfries

British

HMP Dumfries

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dumfries

327. 57264/10

28/09/2010

Edward

KENNEDY

22/04/1970

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

328. 57266/10

28/09/2010

Richard

FARQUHAR

06/05/1957

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

329. 57273/10

31/08/2010

Jamaine

THEOPHANE

05/11/1977

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

Page 68: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

66 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

330. 57388/10

29/09/2010

James MILLER

11/08/1957

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

331. 57391/10

29/09/2010

William MC

HUGH

13/02/1972

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

332. 57396/10

29/09/2010

Alexander MC

LEOD

20/07/1952

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

333. 57401/10

28/09/2010

Dean MAC LEAY

07/08/1986

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

334. 57411/10

28/09/2010

Albert JONES

26/11/1953

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

335. 57419/10

28/09/2010

Stephen GORDON

02/02/1969

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

Page 69: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 67

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

336. 57427/10

28/09/2010

Andrew GIBSON

29/08/1986

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

337. 57436/10

29/09/2010

Iain JOHNSON

26/05/1988

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

338. 57499/10

30/09/2010

Stuart Andrew

PATTERSON

12/07/1968

Freiston, Boston -

Lincolnshire

British

HMP North Sea Camp

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Usk

339. 57510/10

21/09/2010

Leroy FRANCIS

12/02/1962

Stafford

British

HMP Stafford

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

340. 57667/10

16/09/2010

Michael

MULLANEY

16/10/1984

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

Page 70: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

68 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

341. 57731/10

30/09/2010

Larry

WILLOUGHBY

03/07/1953

Durham

British

A5234AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

342. 57801/10

06/10/2010

Stuart Brett

HEATH

07/05/1979

Rutland

British

A7710AG

HMP Stocken

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

343. 57826/10

01/10/2010

Philip John

BARTON

04/11/1987

Blandford Forum

British

A8728AN General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Guy’s March

Prisoner no. A8728AN

344. 57869/10

06/10/2010

Naveed

MAHMOOD

09/06/1984

Evesham

British

A7944AG

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

345. 57901/10

04/10/2010

Steven DAYKIN

23/10/1987

Lincoln

British

A9354AH

HMP Lincoln

General election 6 May 2010

09/10/2008 to unknown date

Page 71: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 69

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

346. 58376/10

29/09/2010

Paul

PRENDERGAST

20/04/1965

Sheerness

British

A3084AM

HMP Swaleside

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Elmley

347. 58402/10

17/09/2010

Gary MC

GOWAN

09/04/1968

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

348. 58412/10

17/09/2010

Ian MCDONALD

30/06/1982

Tullibody,

British

HMP Glenochil

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Glenochil

349. 58419/10

17/09/2010

Grant

DUNSMORE

19/12/1986

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

350. 58430/10

23/09/2010

Robert Lesarian

HOWARD

20/04/1944

Durham

British

A4949AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

Page 72: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

70 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

351. 58446/10

05/10/2010

Mark John

DAVIES

22/01/1976

Wotton-under-Edge

British

A4492AN

HMP Leyhill

General election 6 May 2010

28/10/2004 to 08/09/2011

352. 58471/10

30/09/2010

Brian HURST

Addiewell

British

HMP Addiewell ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

353. 58482/10

05/10/2010

Daniel Anthony

DUNSFORD

25/10/1980

Durham

British

A2625AA

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

24/03/2004 to unknown date

354. 58533/10

04/10/2010

James MEEK

12/09/1963

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

355. 58537/10

04/10/2010

James LEITH

28/05/1970

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

356. 58569/10

03/10/2010

Keith WILLIAMS

12/08/1964

Durham

British

A5603AE

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 73: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 71

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

357. 58780/10

30/09/2010

Colin MCLEAN

30/05/1979

Greenock

British

HMP Greenock

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

358. 58799/10

01/10/2010

Ian Edward

KENNEDY

18/02/1954

Wakefield

British

A9530AA

HMP Wakefield

5 Love Lane

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

359. 58850/10

04/10/2010

James

MCDONALD

24/02/1952

Peterhead

British

HMP Peterhead

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

360. 58852/10

04/10/2010

Alexander POTTS

24/05/1955

Dumfries

British

HMP Dumfries

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dumfries

361. 58855/10

04/10/2010

Gary RODGERS

21/08/1970

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

362. 58858/10

04/10/2010

Frank MC

GLONE

13/04/1970

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

Page 74: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

72 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

363. 58863/10

04/10/2010

Henry

WILLIAMSON

30/08/1973

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

364. 58873/10

04/10/2010

Hugh STEEL

27/01/1981

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

365. 58881/10

04/10/2010

Adam DALLAS

17/05/1953

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

366. 58884/10

05/10/2010

Gary MC COLM

01/01/1981

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

367. 58903/10

05/10/2010

Norman

SAUNDERS

12/09/1966

Norwich

British

A3869AA

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

368. 58916/10

05/10/2010

Martin Gregory

HALLIWELL

31/01/1961

Denbury

British

HMP Channings Wood

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 75: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 73

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

369. 58928/10

04/10/2010

David

CAMPBELL

24/02/1968

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

370. 58972/10

04/10/2010

Kenny

WILLIAMSON

20/12/1974

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

371. 58982/10

04/10/2010

Joseph REILLY

10/02/1986

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

372. 58991/10

04/10/2010

Matthew YOUNG

05/07/1959

Lanarkshire

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

373. 58998/10

04/10/2010

David

JOHNSTON

19/12/1967

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

374. 59004/10

04/10/2010

David BAIN

01/05/1964

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

Page 76: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

74 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

375. 59026/10

05/10/2010

Martin COOPER

18/09/1958

Denbury

British

HMP Channings Wood

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

376. 59206/10

03/10/2010

Marie DEAN

25/06/1966

Huntingdon

British

A0346AG

HMP Littlehey

(formerly Dean MARIE)

General election 6 May 2010

From 22/05/2009 to unknown date

377. 59311/10

14/09/2010

Harry MUSSON

02/12/1953

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

378. 59316/10

14/09/2010

Glyn KENYON

21/08/1960

Wakefield

British

A9386AA

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

379. 59524/10

05/10/2010

Aaron

NICHOLLS

05/02/1981

York

British

A4655AE

HMP Full Sutton

General election 6 May 2010

From 10/02/1999 pursuant to life

sentence, twelve years of tariff

380. 59576/10

05/10/2010

Kevin STUART

11/12/1960

Wolverhampton

British

A1156AK

HMP Featherstone

General election May 2010

From 24 July 2010 pursuant to a life

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

Page 77: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 75

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

381. 59788/10

12/10/2010

Fajr ELLIS

22/01/1976

Durham

British

A9911AA

HMP Frankland

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

382. 60642/10

07/10/2010

Peter Robert

SEATON

10/03/1985

Worcestershire

British

A8561AA

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

383. 60684/10

12/10/2010

Geoff John

NORKETT

06/10/1976

Preston

British

A2681AA

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 14/06/2005 to unknown date

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

384. 60965/10

11/10/2010

Kirk Ronald

MARCHBANK

23/04/1972

Uttoxeter

British

A0193AQ

HMP Dovegate

General election 6 May 2010

05/08/2005 to unknown date

385. 60976/10

07/10/2010

Andrew Stephen

ROBINSON

11/11/1961

Risley

British

A7069AE

HMP Risley

General election 6 May 2010

06/10/2006 to unknown date

Page 78: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

76 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

386. 60980/10

11/10/2010

Clive David HALL

18/12/1972

Usk

British

HMP Usk

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

19/06/2006 to unknown date

387. 61223/10

06/10/2010

Stephen KIDD

02/12/1971

Market Harborough

British

A9166AZ

HMP Gartree

General election 6 May 2010

22/01/2009 to unknown date

388. 61263/10

07/10/2010

Mark Andrew

NICHOLAS

11/08/1975

Wakefield

British

A8261AA

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

389. 61798/10

19/10/2010

John SMITH

Norwich

British

A2007AL

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

390. 61806/10

20/10/2010

Kevin Peter

DOUGLAS

19/03/1980

Paisley

British

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

391. 61810/10

20/10/2010

James Stephen

WHITSON

01/12/1977

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 79: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 77

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

392. 61822/10

11/10/2010

Matthew Anthony

SCAIFE

02/04/1983

Kirkham

British

HMP Kirkham

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

393. 62043/10

06/10/2010

Christopher David

REED

14/11/1959

Huntingdon

British

A6468AD

HMP Littlehey

General election 6 May 2010

10/07/2009 to unknown date

394. 62172/10

05/10/2010

Francis LOGAN

06/07/1968

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

395. 62182/10

06/10/2010

Andrew

HALLIDAY

17/03/1982

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Saughton

396. 62202/10

05/10/2010

James QUINN

10/01/1986

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Saughton

Page 80: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

78 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

397. 62215/10

31/08/2010

Russell Neale

CROFT

05/04/1961

Surrey

British

General election 6 May 2010

398. 62231/10

08/10/2010

Vincent Roy

GRUNCELL

29/04/1968

Wellingborough

British

General election 6 May 2010

From 10 March 2010 pursuant to eight

years and six months sentence

399. 62420/10

25/10/2010

Mohannad

MAHMOUD

07/08/1977

Preston

British

A6012AH

HMP Garth

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Hewell

400. 62446/10

20/10/2010

Richard Malcolm

MARTIN

18/04/1952

Wakefield

British

A9946AA

HMP Wakefield

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

401. 62553/10

04/10/2010

Donald

MCDONALD

28/07/1943

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 81: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 79

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

402. 62555/10

04/10/2010

Barry DON

06/05/1987

Perth

British

HMP Perth

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

403. 62574/10

04/10/2010

Edward THOMAS

05/09/1971

Nottingham

British

A5457AK

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

404. 62657/10

14/10/2010

John ALI

05/04/1962

Norwich

British

A8795AK

HMP Bure

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Bure

405. 62665/10

14/10/2010

Shahin RAHMAN

07/09/1975

Norwich

British

A8823AK

HMP Bure

General election 6 May 2010

From 27/03/2009 pursuant to four year

sentence

406. 63176/10

06/10/2010

James HALL

03/01/1986

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

407. 63843/10

29/10/2010

Aaron MONK

05/08/1988

Sherwood,

Nottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/02/2010 to unknown date

Page 82: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

80 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

408. 63874/10

29/10/2010

Barrie STOKES

08/12/1978

Doncaster

British

HMP Lindholme

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

09/05/2008 to unknown date

409. 63901/10

26/10/2010

Christine

EGGLETON

03/03/1958

Solihull

British

General election 6 May 2010

22/01/2010 to unknown date

410. 63939/10

29/10/2010

John BUTLER

09/11/1982

Doncaster

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 3 February 2009 pursuant to

three years sentence

411. 63941/10

29/10/2010

Duane BUTLER

22/05/1968

Bottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

412. 63945/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

BUTTERS

20/10/1961

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

23/11/2009 to unknown date

413. 63948/10

29/10/2010

David

BREAKSPEAR

22/09/1969

Norwich

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

04/09/2008 to unknown date

Page 83: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 81

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

414. 63953/10

29/10/2010

Graham BRETT

30/10/1950

Highpoint

British

HMP Highpoint

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

415. 63956/10

25/10/2010

Robert BROWN

01/01/1966

Peterborough

British

A7367AP

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

416. 63957/10

29/10/2010

James BRIGGS

06/09/1975

Okehampton

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

30/05/2008 to unknown date

417. 63958/10

29/10/2010

Wayne BRISCOE

02/12/1966

Uttoxeter

British

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

418. 63960/10

29/10/2010

John BROOM

17/03/1961

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

14/02/1992 to unknown date

419. 63962/10

29/10/2010

Andrew

BROUGHTON

23/09/1981

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 26 October 2009 pursuant to six

years sentence

Page 84: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

82 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

420. 63965/10

29/10/2010

Owen BROWN

24/12/1981

Full Sutton

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

23/12/1997 to unknown date

421. 63966/10

29/10/2010

Matthew BROWN

27/08/1984

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

04/12/2009 to unknown date

422. 63969/10

29/10/2010

Adrian BROWN

24/03/1962

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

423. 63971/10

29/10/2010

Selena

BROWNING

20/05/1976

Ashford

British

HMP Bronzefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

15/10/2009 to unknown date

424. 63974/10

29/10/2010

Mark ACKROYD

01/09/1967

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

15/03/2010 to unknown date

425. 63976/10

29/10/2010

Leslie BRYAN

23/01/1960

Oakham

British

HMP Ashwell

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 85: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 83

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

426. 63980/10

29/10/2010

Raymond

BRYANT

04/06/1979

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

427. 63987/10

29/10/2010

Martin BUDBY

06/11/1961

Newport

British

A1379AC

HMP Isle of Wight

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

26/09/2007 to unknown date

428. 63990/10

29/10/2010

David BULLOCK

26/10/1983

Stretton

British

HMP Stocken

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

25/01/2010 to unknown date

429. 63995/10

29/10/2010

Simon BULLOCK

08/11/1968

Nottigham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 23 April 1986 pursuant to life

sentence

430. 63997/10

29/10/2010

Dean BURT

13/08/1988

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

431. 64009/10

29/10/2010

Daniel BUTLER

03/01/1987

Norwich

British

HMP Norwich

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

20/02/2009 to unknown date

Page 86: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

84 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

432. 64015/10

29/10/2010

Stephen BUTLER

09/06/1957

Full Sutton

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

433. 64025/10

29/10/2010

Nicholas ADAMS

06/07/1967

Eastchurch

British

HMP Sheppey Cluster

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

17/04/2009 to unknown date

434. 64051/10

29/10/2010

Mark BAIGENT

03/05/1980

gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

435. 64053/10

29/10/2010

Dijibril BAIN

26/02/1976

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

14/01/2010 to unknown date

436. 64055/10

29/10/2010

William BAIN

05/10/1973

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

08/11/2007 to unknown date

437. 64058/10

29/10/2010

John MOORE

12/08/1976

Thefort, Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

23/03/2009 to unknown date

Page 87: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 85

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

438. 64059/10

29/10/2010

Clinton

BALDWIN

08/01/1976

gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

06/03/2006 to unknown date

439. 64061/10

29/10/2010

Jon BANKS

24/05/1974

Wayland

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

440. 64063/10

01/11/2010

David MORAN

06/10/1984

Sherwood,

Nottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

05/01/2009 to unknown date

441. 64064/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

BANKS

19/07/1973

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

442. 64066/10

29/10/2010

David BARBER

18/01/1981

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

443. 64069/10

29/10/2010

John BARBER

07/08/1966

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

Page 88: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

86 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

444. 64073/10

29/10/2010

Gary BARLOW

16/09/1965

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

445. 64074/10

29/10/2010

Steven BUTTERS

25/08/1959

Uttoxeter

British

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

446. 64075/10

29/10/2010

David MORGAN

18/08/1965

Durnham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From April 2004 pursuant to ten-year

sentence

447. 64076/10

29/10/2010

Adrian BARNES

20/08/1967

Dover

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 27 May 2009 pursuant to two

years and six months sentence

448. 64078/10

29/10/2010

Wayne BARNES

07/06/1981

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

29/10/2010 to unknown date

449. 64083/10

29/10/2010

Timothy

BARNETT

14/11/1967

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 89: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 87

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

450. 64084/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

BARRETT-

JOLLEY

17/02/1947

Leyhill

British

HMP Leyhill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

05/12/2002 to unknown date

451. 64085/10

16/07/2010

Ronan KORBY

03/12/1968

Bristol

British

A8614AE

HMP Ashfield

(formerly Lee

WATERSWORTH)

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Manchester

452. 64099/10

11/10/2010

Anthony Peter

SCAIFE

04/09/1956

Kirkham

British

A7232AA

HMP Kirkham

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Lowdham Grange

453. 64107/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

THOMAS

07/07/1966

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

28/10/2009 to unknown date

454. 64108/10

29/10/2010

Jamil AHMED

02/07/1985

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From April 2006 pursuant to

indeterminate sentence

Page 90: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

88 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

455. 64110/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

AHMED

18/09/1969

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From November 2002 pursuant to life

sentence

456. 64112/10

29/10/2010

Saleem AKHTAR

20/09/1968

Derbyshire

British

HMP Sudbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 23 February 2010 pursuant to

two years sentence

457. 64113/10

29/10/2010

Brett ALDUS

04/01/1987

Wayland

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

08/07/2009 to unknown date

458. 64114/10

29/10/2010

Mohammed ALI

13/01/1982

March

British

HMP Whitemoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

11/01/2007 to unknown date

459. 64115/10

29/10/2010

Marcel ALLAN

27/11/1966

gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/11/2009 to unknown date

460. 64116/10

29/10/2010

Lee THOMPSON

16/10/1981

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

29/10/2010 to unknown date

Page 91: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 89

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

461. 64120/10

29/10/2010

Neal ALLANSON

02/10/1966

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

462. 64121/10

29/10/2010

John ALLEN

04/11/1951

Portsmouth

British

HMP Kingston

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

463. 64122/10

29/10/2010

Mohanid AL-

OBAYDI

06/05/1967

Huntington

British

HMP Littlehey

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

09/12/2005 to unknown date

464. 64124/10

29/10/2010

Robert

THORNTON

22/11/1981

Brough

British

HMP Wolds

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 29/10/2009 to unknown date

465. 64125/10

29/10/2010

David AMBLER

12/08/1977

Wayland

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

466. 64126/10

29/10/2010

Michael

ANDERSON

11/12/1960

Usk

British

A2709AR

HMP Usk

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 14/12/1998 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 92: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

90 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

467. 64127/10

29/10/2010

David

ANDERSON

30/04/1984

Millom

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Haverigg

468. 64128/10

29/10/2010

Paul THORPE

05/04/1963

Hull

British

HMP Hull

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 11/12/2009 pursuant to eight

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP Hull

469. 64130/10

29/10/2010

David ANGEL

29/12/1963

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

470. 64131/10

29/10/2010

Matthew ANSELL

28/07/1966

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From February 2007 pursuant to

fifteen years sentence

471. 64134/10

29/10/2010

Arthur TIFFANY

18/04/1958

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 15/05/2009 pursuant to fifteen

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

472. 64137/10

29/10/2010

Michael ARCHER

22/04/1961

Oakham

British

HMP Ashwell

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ashwell

Page 93: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 91

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

473. 64138/10

29/10/2010

Andrew

ARMSTRONG

03/11/1966

nottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

474. 64140/10

29/10/2010

Mudassar

ARSHAD

16/05/1984

Sudbury

British

HMP Sudbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 18/06/2009 pursuant to three

year sentence;

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Sudbury

475. 64141/10

29/10/2010

Brenton TOBIN

04/11/1983

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

05/03/2009 to unknown date

476. 64142/10

29/10/2010

Ricky ASHLEY

30/05/1963

Isle of Wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

08/01/2009 to unknown date

477. 64145/10

29/10/2010

Junior MORGAN

28/02/1979

Thetford, Norfolk

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

478. 64147/10

29/10/2010

Adam ASTON

20/05/1978

Woodhill

British

HMP Woodhill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/10/2009 to unknown date

Page 94: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

92 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

479. 64148/10

29/10/2010

Azeem AYUB

19/11/1985

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

05/02/2010 to unknown date

480. 64149/10

29/10/2010

Mark MORGAN

19/10/1964

Uttoxeter,

Staffordshire

British

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 13/02/1985 pursuant to life

sentence

481. 64157/10

29/10/2010

Anthony TOVEY

20/05/1953

Shrewbury

British

HMP Shrewbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

01/02/2010 to unknown date

482. 64164/10

29/10/2010

Tammy TOWNER

06/05/1977

Middleesex

British

HMP Bronzefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

483. 64169/10

29/10/2010

Joshua MORGAN

26/03/1982

Newport - Isle of

Wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 10 June 2006 pursuant to eight

years and six months sentence

484. 64173/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

MORGANS

14/08/1947

Newport

British

A2181AE

HMP Albany

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 4 August 2009 pursuant to

fourteen year sentence

Page 95: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 93

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

485. 64175/10

29/10/2010

Paul CALDER

15/01/1989

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 6 August 2007 pursuant to four

year sentence

486. 64176/10

29/10/2010

Ian TRAFFORD

28/07/1961

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 3 December 2007 pursuant to life

sentence

487. 64180/10

29/10/2010

Leonard

TREACHER

25/03/1956

Preston

British

HMP Preston

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 8 July 2006 pursuant to eight

year sentence

488. 64185/10

29/10/2010

Mark TUGWELL

07/07/1966

Maidstone

British

HMP Maidstone

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 15 November 2001 pursuant to

life sentence

489. 64198/10

01/11/2010

Marc CALEY

16/02/1984

Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 29 January 2007 pursuant to

three year and six months sentence

490. 64201/10

29/10/2010

Shaun

TETHINGTON

11/02/1969

Devon

British

HMP Dartmoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 22 December 2009 pursuant to

four year sentence

Page 96: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

94 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

491. 64206/10

18/10/2010

Dennis

UNDERWOOD

12/02/1960

Redditch

British

A5881AH

HMP Hewell

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

492. 64213/10

29/10/2010

Wayne MORLEY

11/08/1979

Dover

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 04/08/2009 to unknown date

493. 64214/10

29/10/2010

Marc STOMBOLI

01/05/1980

Huntingdon

British

HMP Littlehey

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 15/10/2009 to unknown date

494. 64218/10

29/10/2010

Steven MOFFAT

26/01/1966

Redford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

495. 64219/10

29/10/2010

David

STRINGFELLOW

07/07/1959

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 13 July 2006 pursuant to sixteen

year sentence

496. 64224/10

29/10/2010

Robert

MITCHELL

11/09/1968

Marchington

British

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 30 May 2006 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 97: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 95

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

497. 64225/10

29/10/2010

Chris

CAMBRIDGE

22/05/1983

Doncaster

British

HMP Lindholme

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

27/05/2004 to unknown date

498. 64226/10

29/10/2010

Louis SULLIVAN

20/03/1989

Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

22/03/2010 to unknown date

499. 64229/10

29/10/2010

Lee MITCHELL

21/01/1982

Millon, Cumbria

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

500. 64230/10

29/10/2010

Owen

CAMPBELL

19/08/1958

Rutland

British

HMP Ashwell

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/05/2007 to unknown date

501. 64231/10

29/10/2010

Rayne

MITCHELL

16/08/1970

Huntingdon,

Cambridgeshire

British

HMP Littlehey

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Littlehey

Page 98: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

96 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

502. 64234/10

29/10/2010

Adrian SYKES

08/10/1941

West Yorkshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 05/12/2005 pursuant to ten year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

503. 64236/10

29/10/2010

Brian MINSHALL

27/08/1976

Wakefield, West

Yorkshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

504. 64239/10

29/10/2010

Leroy

CAMPBELL

27/04/1961

Wakefield

British

MP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

505. 64240/10

29/10/2010

Leon CHUNG

23/04/1963

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

506. 64241/10

29/10/2010

Colin MILNES

07/05/1960

Lowdham,

Nottingham

British

HMP Lowdham Grange

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 99: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 97

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

507. 64243/10

29/10/2010

John MILNER

07/11/1944

Wakefield, West

Yorkshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/05/2004 to unknown date

508. 64246/10

29/10/2010

Malcolm

CARTER

26/03/1964

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

509. 64247/10

29/10/2010

Marc

MIDDLEBROOK

04/08/1981

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

16/10/2008 to unknown date

510. 64249/10

29/10/2010

Stephen

SZANDROWSKI

14/09/1969

Nottinghamshire

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

511. 64251/10

29/10/2010

Tommy CHURCH

30/11/1984

Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

Page 100: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

98 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

512. 64254/10

29/10/2010

Koyeas MIAH

10/04/1986

Newport - Isle of

Wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Parkhurst

513. 64255/10

29/10/2010

Karl

CHURCHILL

12/12/1962

London

British

HMP Wandsworth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Ford

514. 64256/10

29/10/2010

David CARTER

02/06/1968

Whatton

British

HMP WHATTON

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 30/06/2006 to unknown date

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Whatton

515. 64258/10

29/10/2010

Greg CHARLES

21/08/1968

Arundel

British

HMP FORD

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Ford

516. 64265/10

29/10/2010

Adrian TAITT

18/09/1984

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/10/2008 to unknown date

517. 64272/10

29/10/2010

Simon CLANCY

03/09/1975

Warrington

British

HMP Risley

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

05/03/2010 to unknown date

Page 101: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 99

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

518. 64278/10

29/10/2010

James CLARK

06/11/1980

Nottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

16/04/20101 to unknown date

519. 64280/10

29/10/2010

Frederick

TAYLOR

19/05/1946

Warrington

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

19/06/2009 to unknown date

520. 64282/10

29/10/2010

Craig CLARKE

20/06/1975

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

521. 64284/10

28/10/2010

George CLARKE

05/12/1951

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Scottish election 5 May 2011

From 14/10/2005 pursuant to fifteen

year sentence.

522. 64286/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

CLARKE

05/10/1980

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

30/05/2008 to unknown date

523. 64287/10

29/10/2010

Kevin CLAY

11/07/1959

Eastchurch

Sheerness

British

HMP Stanford Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

04/05/2010 to unknown date

Page 102: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

100 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

524. 64289/10

29/10/2010

Daniel TAYLOR

21/04/1989

Straffordshire

British

HMP Swinfen Hall

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

525. 64293/10

29/10/2010

Robert COATES

20/05/1960

London

British

HMP Belmarsh

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

30/06/2009 to unknown date

526. 64295/10

29/10/2010

Brian TAYLOR

15/07/1979

Preston

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

13/10/2008 to unknown date

527. 64316/10

29/10/2010

David TURNER

12/05/1956

Norwich, Norfolk

British

HMP Norwich

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

528. 64319/10

29/10/2010

Levi UPTON

26/12/1974

Nr. Rugby,

Warwickshire

British

HMP Rye Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

529. 64321/10

29/10/2010

Alan VERNON

01/06/1965

Thetford, Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

17/09/2009 to unknown date

Page 103: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 101

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

530. 64322/10

29/10/2010

Roger VINCENT

06/06/1972

March,

Cambridgeshire

British

HMP Whitemoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

23/08/2005 to unknown date

531. 64323/10

29/10/2010

Gareth

WAGHORN

02/11/1985

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

17/06/2005 to unknown date

532. 64325/10

29/10/2010

Neil WALGATE

07/08/1966

Wakefield, West

Yorshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

533. 64328/10

29/10/2010

James

COCHRANE

13/07/1966

York

Maltese

A5243AC

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Full

Sutton

534. 64329/10

29/10/2010

Robert COLE

30/07/1975

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

Page 104: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

102 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

535. 64330/10

29/10/2010

Thomas COLLEY

01/08/1985

SHAFTSBURY

British

HMP Guys Marsh

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Guys

Marsh

536. 64331/10

29/10/2010

Darren COOPER

13/05/1970

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

537. 64332/10

29/10/2010

Carl CORBIN

28/09/1978

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

538. 64333/10

29/10/2010

Kevin CORKE

02/11/1975

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

539. 64334/10

29/10/2010

Antony

COUGHTREY

27/01/1973

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 5 April 1992 pursuant to life

sentence

540. 64335/10

29/10/2010

Graham

COUGILL

21/01/1980

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

Page 105: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 103

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

541. 64336/10

29/10/2010

Alex COURT

21/10/1977

Ipswich

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

542. 64337/10

29/10/2010

Wayne COURTIS

22/08/1974

Shaftsbury

British

HMP Guys Marsh

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

543. 64338/10

29/10/2010

Adrian COX

11/05/1964

Hull

British

HMP Hull

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 22/07/2009 pursuant to fifteen

year sentence

Detaiend at relevant time at HMP Hull

544. 64342/10

29/10/2010

Kramer CRAFT

06/06/1980

Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

27/05/2010 to unknown date

545. 64345/10

29/10/2010

Robert

CRAMPSIE

13/07/1956

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

19/06/2009 to unknown date

546. 64347/10

29/10/2010

Stephen

CRAWFORD

11/01/1979

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/06/2008 to unknown date

Page 106: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

104 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

547. 64349/10

29/10/2010

Liam CROMIE

28/10/1987

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

21/10/2008 to unknown date

548. 64351/10

11/10/2010

Thomas FADIAN

04/11/1973

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

549. 64352/10

29/10/2010

Peter

CROMPTON

06/09/1969

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/07/2009 to unknown date

550. 64355/10

29/10/2010

Lee CROWDEN

26/04/1974

SHERWOOD

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

551. 64356/10

12/10/2010

George

SWEENEY

22/09/1974

Ayrshire

British

HMP Kilmarnock

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

552. 64413/10

29/10/2010

Lee WALKER

13/07/1988

Thetford, Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 26/02/2010 pursuant to four year

sentence

Page 107: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 105

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

553. 64417/10

25/07/2010

Marcia WALKER

21/12/1973

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

554. 64422/10

29/10/2010

Phillip WALKER

26/11/1974

Oakham, Rutland

British

HMP Stocken

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

555. 64423/10

29/10/2010

Vaughan

GANNON

20/09/1988

Lichfield

British

HMP Swinfen Hall

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

556. 64426/10

29/10/2010

Carl WALL

29/07/1976

Millom

British

HMP Harverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

15/10/2009 to unknown date

557. 64427/10

11/10/2010

John HENZELL

27/11/1965

Durham

British

A9973AL

HMP Durham

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

558. 64429/10

29/10/2010

Gary WALTON

16/01/1974

Wakefield, West

Yorkshire

British

A9550AA

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

02/09/2004 to unknown date

Page 108: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

106 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

559. 64430/10

29/10/2010

Jason WARD

29/03/1981

Wakefield, West

Yorkshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/12/2003 to unknown date

560. 64431/10

29/10/2010

Stuart WARREN

11/01/1958

Millom, Cumbria

British

HMP Harverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 04/12/1997 pursuant to a life

sentence

561. 64437/10

29/10/2010

Brian GARRITY

15/07/1956

Millom

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

02/12/2001 to unknown date

562. 64444/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

GASKELL

07/07/1979

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

14/04/2003 to unknown date

563. 64449/10

29/10/2010

Alex GEORG

25/05/1947

Whatton

British

HMP Whatton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

564. 64450/10

29/10/2010

Shazad

GHAFOOR

18/01/1974

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 109: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 107

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

565. 64455/10

29/10/2010

Claire WATSON

20/01/1968

Birmingham

British

HMP Birmingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

27/07/2008 to unknown date

566. 64458/10

29/10/2010

Peter WAYNE

19/10/1955

London

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

13/12/2009 to unknown date

567. 64463/10

29/10/2010

Timothy

WEBBER

11/02/1981

Bromley

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

17/12/2009 to unknown date

568. 64467/10

29/10/2010

Sandra WEIR

02/12/1961

Ashford, Middlesex

British

HMP Bronzefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Scottish election 5 May 2011

From 17/03/2010 pursuant to eleven

year sentence.

569. 64475/10

29/10/2010

Paul WEST

06/06/1957

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

08/08/2007 to unknown date

570. 64476/10

29/10/2010

Roy GIBSON

15/08/1956

Full Sutton

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

22/09/2005 to unknown date

Page 110: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

108 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

571. 64480/10

29/10/2010

James WEST

23/01/1986

Nr Rugby,

Warwickshire

British

HMP Rye Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

03/03/2009 to unknown date

572. 64488/10

29/10/2010

Ian GIBSON

03/11/1981

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

573. 64499/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

WESTON

26/08/1987

Thetford, Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

574. 64500/10

29/10/2010

William

WHARTON

18/02/1944

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

575. 64503/10

29/10/2010

Stephen

WHATLING

27/06/1959

Bridgend

British

HMP Parc

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2011

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 29/05/2009 pursuant to a

fourteen year sentence

Page 111: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 109

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

576. 64506/10

29/10/2010

Robert GORMAN

10/10/1977

Whatton

British

HMP Whatton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

577. 64511/10

29/10/2010

Ronald

WHITBREAD

15/05/1955

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

12/03/2010 to unknown date

578. 64512/10

29/10/2010

Stephen

GRAHAM

17/02/1954

Shaftsbury

British

HMP Guys Marsh

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

01/02/1985 to unknown date

579. 64514/10

29/10/2010

Jason WHITE

09/11/1975

Dorchester

British

HMP Dorchester

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

11/11/2007 to unknown date

580. 64517/10

29/10/2010

Peter WILLIAMS

11/03/1970

Yelverston

British

HMP Dartmoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

22/07/2008 to unknown date

581. 64518/10

29/10/2010

Ashley GRANT

25/09/1983

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

19/03/2010 to unknown date

Page 112: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

110 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

582. 64519/10

29/10/2010

Carl WILLIAMS

28/07/1981

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

18/09/2007 to unknown date

583. 64521/10

29/10/2010

Michael GRANT

26/03/1984

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

18/07/2006 to unknown date

584. 64523/10

29/10/2010

John WILLIAMS

25/08/1965

Eastchurch

British

HMP Standford Hill LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

11/12/2008 to unknown date

585. 64524/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

WILLIAMS

28/12/1977

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

586. 64525/10

29/10/2010

Jason GRANT

09/10/1985

Doncaster

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

587. 64529/10

29/10/2010

Michael

GREGORY

23/12/1981

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

21/03/2005 to unknown date

Page 113: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 111

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

588. 64546/10

29/10/2010

Dennis

WILLIAMS

06/08/1955

Sheerness, Kent

British

HMP Standford Hill LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

13/10/2009 to unknown date

589. 64561/10

29/10/2010

Randle

WILLIAMS

17/09/1959

Millom, Cumbria

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

08/07/2003 to unknown date

590. 64566/10

29/10/2010

Dion WILLIAMS

28/05/1984

March,

Cambridgeshire

British

HMP Whitemoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

591. 64571/10

29/10/2010

Fabian WILSON

28/08/1982

Sherwood,

Nottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

04/03/2009 to unknown date

592. 64575/10

29/10/2010

Paul GRIFFIN

10/01/1959

Sheerness

British

HMP Sheppey Cluster LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Sheppey Cluster (Standford Hill)

Page 114: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

112 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

593. 64576/10

29/10/2010

Andrew DAVIS

07/11/1964

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

594. 64577/10

29/10/2010

Paul WISHART

16/05/1957

Millom, Cumbria

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Haverigg

595. 64579/10

29/10/2010

John WOOD

07/12/1965

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

596. 64580/10

29/10/2010

Jason DANIELS

29/12/1982

warrington

British

HMP Risely

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Risley

597. 64581/10

29/10/2010

Glyn WOODS

10/01/1944

Usk

British

HMP Usk

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 26/06/2009 pursuant to 6 year

sentence

598. 64584/10

29/10/2010

Robert

GRIFFITHS

25/11/1949

Stoke-on-Trent

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

12/11/2009 to unknown date

Page 115: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 113

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

599. 64585/10

29/10/2010

Jez DEAFFERN

17/03/1965

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

19/12/2004 to unknown date

600. 64586/10

29/10/2010

Mark WOOLLEY

20/06/1965

Sheerness

British

A6391AK

HMP Elmley

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

601. 64588/10

29/10/2010

Lee WORGAN

12/11/1979

Market harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 20 December 2003 pursuant to

twenty year sentence

602. 64590/10

29/10/2010

Michael DEAN

19/06/1949

Garth

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 21/12/2001 to unknown date

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Garth

603. 64593/10

29/10/2010

Terry

GRIFFITHS

23/08/1985

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 25/10/2007 pursuant to seven

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

604. 64594/10

29/10/2010

Barry WRIGHT

12/05/1971

Allenton, Derby

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 14/04/2010 pursuant to sixteen

week sentence

Page 116: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

114 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

605. 64596/10

29/10/2010

Brian DEAN

29/11/1966

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

606. 64600/10

29/10/2010

Barry WRIGHT

31/03/1959

Sherwood

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 12 April 2010 pursuant to one

year sentence

607. 64601/10

29/10/2010

Dean DICKSON

29/09/1971

Norwich

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained from 01/05/2009 pursuant to

eight year sentence.

608. 64607/10

29/10/2010

Michael WRIGHT

11/05/1984

Nr Rugby,

Warwickshire

British

HMP Rye Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 12 May 2009 pursuant to twelve

year sentence

609. 64608/10

29/10/2010

Robert DIXON

01/12/1971

hull

British

HMP Hull

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 21 May 2007 pursuant to eight

year sentence

610. 64610/10

29/10/2010

Linda

GRIFFITHS

27/05/1959

Surrey

British

HMP Send

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 20/11/2009 to unknown date

Page 117: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 115

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

611. 64612/10

29/10/2010

Nicholas DOLAN

13/12/1980

Wayland

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

612. 64613/10

29/10/2010

Terence WYATT

23/01/1971

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight,

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

613. 64616/10

29/10/2010

Stephen WYNNE

24/10/1977

Brasside, Durnham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

27/01/2006 to unknown date

614. 64618/10

29/10/2010

Mark DONE

12/05/1961

Usk

British

HMP Usk

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

05/03/2010 to unknown date

615. 64621/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

DORE

22/12/1960

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

07/02/1994 to unknown date

616. 64623/10

29/10/2010

Mark DORLING

05/04/1968

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

21/04/2006 to unknown date

Page 118: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

116 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

617. 64624/10

29/10/2010

Seumas

DOUGLAS-REID

23/02/1958

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained from 18/03/1992 pursuant to

a life sentence.

618. 64625/10

29/10/2010

Carl DOWEN

20/04/1973

Leichestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

619. 64627/10

29/10/2010

James DOWSETT

13/03/1946

Suffolk

British

HMP Highpoint

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

23/03/1989 to unknown date

620. 64629/10

29/10/2010

Edward DOYLE

28/02/1972

Isle of Wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight,

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

18/04/2007 to unknown date

621. 64632/10

29/10/2010

Lee DOYLE

30/04/1982

dartmoor

British

HMP Dartmoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 18/01/2009 pursuant to four year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dartmoor

622. 64635/10

29/10/2010

Parnell

DUBERRY

13/10/1966

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

Page 119: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 117

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

623. 64637/10

29/10/2010

Hamed DUFFUS

02/01/1976

Ashwell

British

HMP Ashwell

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ashwell

624. 64640/10

29/10/2010

Graeme DUNCAN

25/08/1985

Franklan

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

625. 64643/10

29/10/2010

Keiran

DUNKLEY

14/10/1976

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

626. 64644/10

29/10/2010

Ian DUNSTANE

13/02/1967

isle of wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Parkhurst (Isle of Wight)

627. 64645/10

29/10/2010

Paul DUTTON

02/07/1961

isle of wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

06/02/2009 to unknown date

628. 64646/10

29/10/2010

Peter

EASTWOOD

13/01/1969

gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

23/03/2000 to unknown date

Page 120: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

118 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

629. 64648/10

29/10/2010

Jason EDGE

22/01/1977

Lindholme

British

HMP Lindholme

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

30/04/2010 to unknown date

630. 64649/10

29/10/2010

John GILBERT

11/08/1960

Preston

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

13/11/2009 to unknown date

631. 64651/10

29/10/2010

David EDWARDS

28/12/1959

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

11/11/2008 to unknown date

632. 64652/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

ENTWISTLE

14/11/1949

full sutton

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

633. 64655/10

29/10/2010

Jason EUGENE

04/04/1971

Willoughby

British

HMP Rye Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

25/04/2005 to unknown date

634. 64657/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

HILLS

29/06/1987

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

Page 121: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 119

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

635. 64659/10

29/10/2010

Nigel EVANS

04/07/1961

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

636. 64669/10

29/10/2010

Stephen GILLETT

26/03/1958

Norfolk

British

HMP Waylang. LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

637. 64672/10

29/10/2010

Simeon GITTENS

05/03/1974

Birmingham

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

638. 64678/10

29/10/2010

Paul GOBELL

26/09/1962

Newport

British

A4243AA

HMP Isle of Wight

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Parkhurst (Isle of Wight)

639. 64683/10

29/10/2010

Gilbert

GODDARD

13/11/1958

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

640. 64687/10

29/10/2010

Julian GODFREY

02/08/1977

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight (Parkhurst)

Page 122: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

120 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

641. 64694/10

29/10/2010

Scott GOLD

29/09/1976

Hatfield

Woodhouse

British

HMP Lindholme

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Lindholme

642. 64714/10

29/10/2010

Simon

GOLDSMITH

03/06/1963

York

British

HMP Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Full

Sutton

643. 64717/10

29/10/2010

Daniel

GOLDSMITH

05/09/1976

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

644. 64718/10

29/10/2010

Ian GOOCH

01/04/1954

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

645. 64721/10

29/10/2010

Gordon HOPPIE

31/03/1963

Oakham

British

HMP Ashwell

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ashwell

646. 64726/10

29/10/2010

John LEES

14/04/1957

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

Page 123: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 121

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

647. 64729/10

29/10/2010

Hugh LEISHMAN

16/05/1945

Yelverton

British

HMP Dartmoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 19/11/2005 pursuant to five year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dartmoor

648. 64738/10

29/10/2010

Michael LEWIS

01/08/1966

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

649. 64741/10

29/10/2010

Shaun LEWIS

04/05/1969

Market Harborough

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 03/07/2008 pursuant to 12 year

sentence

650. 64842/10

29/10/2010

Philip GRINTER

30/08/1976

Parc

British

HMP Parc

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 06/06/2008 pursuant to thirteen

years four months sentence

651. 64850/10

29/10/2010

Leon GUNNING

09/07/1974

Full Sutton

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Full

Sutton

652. 64854/10

29/10/2010

Shaun HALL

12/10/1982

Randby

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

Page 124: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

122 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

653. 64864/10

29/10/2010

David HALL

08/01/1967

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

09/10/2009 to unknown date

654. 64869/10

29/10/2010

Dennis

HAMILTON

30/01/1980

Highpoint

British

HMP Highpoint

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

655. 64872/10

29/10/2010

Steven

HAMILTON

15/07/1959

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

29/10/2010 to unknown date

656. 64878/10

29/10/2010

Karl

HAMMERSLEY-

BAKER

29/01/1969

Evesham

British

HMP Long Lartin

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

657. 64884/10

29/10/2010

Victor

HANCHARD

12/03/1960

Isle of wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 125: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 123

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

658. 64891/10

29/10/2010

John

HANRAHAN

03/12/1984

Durham

British

A9534AA

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

659. 64894/10

29/10/2010

Michael

HARDACRE

27/09/1976

Full Sutton

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Full

Sutton

660. 64897/10

29/10/2010

Nicholas

HARDING

30/03/1966

Grendon

British

HMP Grendon

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

661. 64902/10

29/10/2010

Victor

HARFIELD

01/05/1952

Dorchetser

British

HMP Dorchester

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

16/11/2009 to unknown date

662. 64904/10

29/10/2010

Ryan HOLMES

24/10/1980

Dagenham

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

19/03/2010 to unknown date

Page 126: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

124 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

663. 64908/10

29/10/2010

Gerard HARPER

04/04/1970

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 25 February 2009 pursuant to

fourteen year sentence

664. 64911/10

29/10/2010

Chris HARRHY

04/05/1961

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 04/03/2005 pursuant to a life

sentence (tariff of 8 years)

665. 64916/10

29/10/2010

David HARRIS

22/03/1952

Maidstone

British

HMP Maidstone

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From August 2008 pursuant to seven

month sentence

666. 64963/10

29/10/2010

Stuart HARRIS-

HANCOCK

23/03/1971

Maidstone

British

HMP Maidstone

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 17 February 2009 pursuant to

five year sentence

667. 64965/10

29/10/2010

Christopher JEAL

05/03/1980

Princetown

British

HMP Dartmoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 4 August 2008 pursuant to five

year sentence

668. 64966/10

29/10/2010

Lee HARRISON

19/09/1981

Hollesley

British

HMP Hollesley Bay

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 19 May 2009 pursuant to five

year sentence

Page 127: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 125

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

669. 64968/10

29/10/2010

Colin JEERY

07/01/1967

Preston

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 16 April 2009 pursuant to ten

year sentence

670. 64970/10

29/10/2010

Melvyn

HARRISON

01/12/1949

Shaftesbury

British

HMP Guys Marsh

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From April 1972 pursuant to life

sentence

671. 64971/10

29/10/2010

Sean JOHNSON

12/03/1970

Shaftsbury

British

HMP Guys Marsh

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 4 February 2009 pursuant to two

year and six months sentence

672. 64974/10

29/10/2010

James HARVEY

03/06/1983

Wayland

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 19 February 2010 pursuant to

eighteen month sentence

673. 64981/10

29/10/2010

Peter HASTINGS

22/02/1968

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 5 June 1998 pursuant to life

sentence

674. 64984/10

29/10/2010

Matthew

JOHNSON

01/07/1986

Stretton, Nr.

Oakham

British

HMP Stocken

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 23 January 2010 pursuant to five

year sentence

Page 128: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

126 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

675. 64986/10

29/10/2010

Ryan HAWKINS

17/06/1985

isle of wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 3 April 2006 pursuant to

indeterminate imprisonment sentence

676. 64989/10

29/10/2010

Jon JOLLY

16/02/1987

Chelmsford

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 17 February 2010 pursuant to

four years and 6 months sentence

677. 64990/10

29/10/2010

Peter HAYES

18/06/1969

wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From April 2006 pursuant to

indeterminate imprisonment sentence

678. 64992/10

29/10/2010

Paul JONES

20/11/1963

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 12 August 2003 pursuant to life

sentence

679. 64997/10

29/10/2010

Mark

HAMILTON

27/10/1963

Newport

British

HMP Isle Of Wight

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 11 November 2005 pursuant to

indeterminate imprisonment sentence

680. 64998/10

29/10/2010

Carl JONES

29/11/1967

Stradishall /

Newmarket

British

HMP Highpoint

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From March 1988 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 129: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 127

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

681. 65002/10

29/10/2010

Kevin John

HAZELWOOD

16/02/1966

Newport

British

HMP Albany

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From November 2005 pursuant to life

sentence

682. 65014/10

29/10/2010

Lee

HEATHCOCK

03/02/1977

Ranby

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 9 December 2008 pursuant to

four year sentence

683. 65018/10

29/10/2010

Carl HEMMINGS

04/06/1964

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

684. 65019/10

29/10/2010

Calvin HENRY

20/09/1965

Lincoln

British

DN228EO

HMP Lincoln

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Lincoln

685. 65021/10

29/10/2010

Michael HERD

29/10/1956

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

686. 65023/10

29/10/2010

William MOORE

17/07/1982

Manchester

British

HMP Forest Bank

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Forest Bank

Page 130: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

128 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

687. 65024/10

29/10/2010

Shane HESKEY

12/09/1972

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

688. 65027/10

29/10/2010

Marc HEWITT

13/05/1953

Scottow

British

HMP Bure

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Bure

689. 65028/10

29/10/2010

Stuart HICKMAN

08/06/1978

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

690. 65031/10

29/10/2010

Andrew

SNELGROVE

27/02/1963

Isle of Wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 1 June 2009 pursuant to sixteen

year sentence

691. 65032/10

29/10/2010

Adrian

HICKMAN

10/09/1975

Maidstone

British

HMP Maidstone

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Maidstone

692. 65036/10

29/10/2010

Jonathan WALSH

17/02/1988

Salford

British

HMP Forest Bank

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 22 November 2005 pursuant to

six year and six months sentence

Page 131: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 129

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

693. 65039/10

29/10/2010

Christopher HILL

16/10/1967

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From October 2007 pursuant to

nineteen year sentence

694. 65043/10

29/10/2010

Bradley JAYES

15/03/1976

Eastchurch

British

HMP Standford Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 13 February 2009 pursuant to

five year and twelve months sentence

695. 65045/10

29/10/2010

Lee HILL

22/04/1975

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 29 November 2008 pursuant to

nine year sentence

696. 65047/10

29/10/2010

Andrew HILL

30/08/1960

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 24 January 2009 pursuant to life

sentence

697. 65050/10

29/10/2010

Rory HILLIAM

23/07/1964

Isle of wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/11/2008 to unknown date

698. 65063/10

29/10/2010

Stephen

JAMNITZKY

30/05/1984

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/02/2010 to unknown date

Page 132: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

130 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

699. 65069/10

29/10/2010

Shaun HILTON

22/12/1966

gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/02/2006 to unknown date

700. 65071/10

29/10/2010

Anjum FAROOQ

12/12/1981

Rochdale

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/07/2008 to unknown date

701. 65073/10

29/10/2010

Barrington

HINDHAUGH

22/09/1940

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

28/03/2008 to unknown date

702. 65076/10

29/10/2010

Paul HOLCROFT

25/03/1984

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

21/10/2008 to unknown date

703. 65080/10

29/10/2010

Thomas

HOLLYOAKE

01/09/1961

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

14/11/2008 to unknown date

704. 65081/10

29/10/2010

Carl HOLMES

01/01/1986

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

19/10/2007 to unknown date

Page 133: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 131

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

705. 65082/10

29/10/2010

Gerald JAMES

DAVIS

16/07/1955

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

02/08/2006 to unknown date

706. 65083/10

29/10/2010

John HOLMES

17/06/1964

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

707. 65085/10

29/10/2010

Victor FARRANT

18/11/1949

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 1997 pursuant to life sentence

708. 65088/10

29/10/2010

Derek JACKSON

02/11/1972

Millom

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 24/11/2009 pursuant to four year

sentence

709. 65092/10

29/10/2010

Lee FAULKNER

02/04/1972

Liverpool

British

HMP Liverpool

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 1999 pursuant to life sentence

710. 65098/10

29/10/2010

Nicholas LEWIS

10/10/1962

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 13/11/2002 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 134: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

132 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

711. 65101/10

29/10/2010

Dawn FIELDS

15/07/1980

Sutton

British

HMP Downview

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 20/02/2006 pursuant to fifteen

year sentence

712. 65102/10

29/10/2010

Richard LEWIS

05/10/1970

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

16/03/1992 to unknown date

713. 65105/10

29/10/2010

James KING

06/04/1981

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/02/2005 to unknown date

714. 65107/10

29/10/2010

Thomas KIRBY

21/02/1983

Millom

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

20/01/2003 to unknown date

715. 65112/10

29/10/2010

Shaka KIRNON-

HENRY

22/11/1980

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/06/2008 to unknown date

716. 65113/10

29/10/2010

Paul FILL

08/08/1976

Eastchurch

British

HMP Standford Hill LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

13/03/2009 to unknown date

Page 135: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 133

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

717. 65114/10

29/10/2010

John KNOWLES

06/10/1981

Newport

British

HMP Isle Of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

718. 65115/10

29/10/2010

Mohan KULAR

05/09/1951

Newmarket

British

HMP Highpoint

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

03/11/1997 to unknown date

719. 65116/10

29/10/2010

James LAMONT

04/10/1980

Huntingdon

British

HMP Littlehey

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Detained at HMP Littlehey

720. 65117/10

29/10/2010

Michael LATHAM

14/10/1978

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

721. 65121/10

29/10/2010

Shaun LATIMER-

KAYSER

09/06/1981

Isle of Sheppey

British

HMP Swaleside LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

722. 65123/10

29/10/2010

Charlie LAWSON

06/03/1969

March

British

HMP Whitemoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

14/12/2001 to unknown date

Page 136: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

134 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

723. 65124/10

29/10/2010

Kenneth

KENNEDY

10/04/1972

Durham

British

HMP Durham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/10/2006 to unknown date

724. 65125/10

28/10/2010

Martyn

FITZSIMMONS

02/09/1980

Millom

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained from 27/10/2008 pursuant to

12 year sentence.

725. 65133/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

FLANAGAN

15/02/1941

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

726. 65156/10

29/10/2010

Simon FORD

27/09/1969

Willoughby

British

HMP Rye Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

13/02/2009 to unknown date

727. 65180/10

29/10/2010

Mark FOSTER

24/07/1962

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

Page 137: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 135

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

728. 65183/10

29/10/2010

Benjamin

FOSTER

08/02/1984

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

729. 65193/10

29/10/2010

Mark FOWLER

09/11/1967

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

730. 65211/10

29/10/2010

Leslie KENNEDY

12/12/1954

Wakefield, West

Yorkshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

731. 65215/10

29/10/2010

Robert KERR

09/06/1953

Usk,

Monmouthshire

British

HMP Usk

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 09/08/2004 pursuant to fifteen

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP Usk

732. 65219/10

29/10/2010

David KERSHAW

18/07/1968

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

Page 138: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

136 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

733. 65223/10

29/10/2010

Andrew KEY

12/06/1984

Long Eaton,

Nottingham

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

734. 65224/10

29/10/2010

Abdul

KHALISADAR

12/07/1981

Newport - Isle of

Wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight (Albany site)

735. 65228/10

29/10/2010

Suleman KHAN

01/08/1984

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

736. 65229/10

29/10/2010

Mohammed

KHAN

11/08/1987

Retford,

Nottinghamshire

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

737. 65235/10

29/10/2010

Zulqifal KHAN

19/04/1987

Thetford, Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

Page 139: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 137

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

738. 65242/10

29/10/2010

Kevin KIERNAN

24/08/1950

Eastchurch, Kent

Irish

HMP Standford Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 18/12/2006 pursuant to four year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Stanford Hill

739. 65247/10

29/10/2010

Anthony KEMP

18/11/1961

Shepton Mallet

British

HMP Shepton Mallet

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 03/05/1985 to unknown date

Detained at relevant time at HMP Guys

Marsh

740. 65251/10

29/10/2010

Sidney KEEGAN

16/05/1961

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

741. 65254/10

29/10/2010

Sean

KAVANAGH

26/04/1974

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

742. 65258/10

29/10/2010

Barry KARIM

21/06/1964

London

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 10/2004 pursuant to ten year

sentence

743. 65261/10

29/10/2010

Dominic KAMAL

05/06/1982

Derbyshire

British

HMP Sudbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 26/01/2010 pursuant to four year

and six month sentence

Page 140: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

138 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

744. 65263/10

29/10/2010

Mark JONES

24/07/1978

Pontypool

British

HMP Prescoed

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

21/08/2006 to unknown date; detained

at relevant time at HMP Parc

745. 65267/10

29/10/2010

Dominic JORDAN

09/11/1985

Birkenhead, Wirral

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 03/2009 pursuant to three year

and four month sentence

746. 65269/10

29/10/2010

Paul

JORGENSEN

07/12/1961

Millom, Cumbria

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

747. 65272/10

29/10/2010

Desmond JOSEPH

07/07/1962

Eastchurch,

Sheerness - Kent

British

HMP Standford Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 14/09/2009 pursuant to fourty-

three month sentence

748. 65277/10

29/10/2010

Timothy JOSH

19/02/1962

Thetford, Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 29/03/2010 pursuant to four year

sentence

749. 65279/10

29/10/2010

Michael JUKES

02/03/1981

Folkestone, Kent

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 30/04/2010 pursuant to eighteen

month sentence

Page 141: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 139

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

750. 65313/10

29/10/2010

Noel FRANCIS

15/05/1977

Eastchurch

British

HMP Standford Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 09/10/2003 pursuant to twelve

year sentence

751. 65319/10

29/10/2010

Jamie FRANKLIN

22/04/1970

Market Harborough

British

HMP GARTREE

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

752. 65327/10

29/10/2010

Aaron

FREESTONE

17/09/1982

Ashbourne

British

HMP Sudbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

13/11/2009 to unknown date

753. 65334/10

29/10/2010

Khalid

MAHMOOD

04/09/1978

Sudbury

British

HMP Sudbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 23/12/2009 pursuant to two year

and eight month sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Sudbury

754. 65342/10

29/10/2010

Wayne MADDOX

29/08/1972

Haverigg

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Haverigg

755. 65345/10

29/10/2010

John LOTE

27/08/1948

Staffordshire

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 13/11/2009 pursuant to three

year sentence

Page 142: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

140 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

756. 65348/10

29/10/2010

Solomon LOPEZ

19/01/1989

Birmingham

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 29/09/2007 pursuant to four year

sentence

757. 65350/10

29/10/2010

James LONG

03/06/1977

Buckinghamshire

British

HMP Woodhill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 10/03/2006 pursuant to life

imprisonment, seventeen year tariff

758. 65351/10

29/10/2010

Michael LOMAS

14/06/1963

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

759. 65353/10

01/11/2010

Martyn FROST

10/02/1971

Newport

British

HMP ISLE OF WIGHT

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 10/2005 pursuant to life

sentence, eight year tariff

760. 65358/10

29/10/2010

Stephen LOFTUS

02/06/1979

Nottingham

British

HMP Lowdham Grange

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 08/2002 pursuant to fifteen year

sentence

761. 65362/10

29/10/2010

Stephen

FULLERTON

07/09/1976

Staffordshire

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 02/2006 pursuant to life

sentence, sixteen year tariff

Page 143: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 141

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

762. 65377/10

29/10/2010

Kevin LLOYD

21/07/1974

Rugby

British

HMP Rye Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 28/10/2007 pursuant to fourteen

year sentence

763. 65382/10

29/10/2010

Andrew LLOYD

16/09/1983

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 15/12/2006 pursuant to life

sentence, twenty-four year tariff

764. 65386/10

29/10/2010

Brian LLOYD

13/04/1942

Gartree

British

HM Prison Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

765. 65390/10

29/10/2010

Raymond

LIDDLE

17/03/1961

Hull

British

HMP Hull

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

766. 65392/10

29/10/2010

John INNES

16/11/1966

Lindholme

British

HMP Lindholme

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

07/11/2008 to unknown date

767. 65408/10

29/10/2010

Ian SHUTT

21/06/1962

Newport - Isle of

Wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

23/09/2002 to unknown date

Page 144: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

142 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

768. 65409/10

29/10/2010

Lionel SIME

06/03/1956

Faversham, Kent

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

769. 65411/10

29/10/2010

Howard

SIMMERSON

01/07/1962

Market Harborough,

Kent

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

09/11/2005 to unknown date

770. 65413/10

29/10/2010

Gavin SIMMS

25/09/1980

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO

771. 65418/10

29/10/2010

Mahmood

HUSSAIN

02/11/1959

Sudbury

British

HMP Sudbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

772. 65419/10

29/10/2010

Dilwar HUSSAIN

24/09/1983

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 145: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 143

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

773. 65420/10

29/10/2010

Nazim HUSSAIN

14/05/1983

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 16/01/2009 pursuant to thirteen

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

774. 65423/10

29/10/2010

Noweed HUSSAIN

10/02/1982

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

775. 65425/10

29/10/2010

Amir SINGH

07/04/1968

Retford,

Nottinghamshire

British

HMP Randy

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

776. 65426/10

29/10/2010

Neil HUNTER

19/07/1980

Full Sutton

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Full

Sutton

777. 65428/10

29/10/2010

Orlando SIR

03/06/1969

Leyland, Preston

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Garth

778. 65433/10

29/10/2010

Sean HUNT

30/12/1973

Wolverhampton

British

A1808AJ

HMP Featherstone

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

05/12/2005 to unknown date

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

Page 146: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

144 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

779. 65435/10

29/10/2010

Harry HUGHES

25/12/1986

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From August 2008 pursuant to five

year sentence

780. 65436/10

29/10/2010

Adam SKEATS

03/09/1986

Shaftesbury, Dorset

British

HMP Guys Marsh

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 23 January 2009 pursuant to four

year sentence

781. 65440/10

29/10/2010

Stephen HUGHES

06/07/1951

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 19 September 1997 pursuant to

life sentence

782. 65451/10

29/10/2010

Adrian MUDIE

03/09/1954

Huntington

British

HMP Littlehey

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 6 April 2005 pursuant to ten year

sentence

783. 65455/10

29/10/2010

David MULCAHY

23/05/1959

York

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

03/02/2001 to unknown date

784. 65471/10

29/10/2010

Darren MULLINS

06/08/1967

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 08/09/2009 pursuant to three

year sentence

Page 147: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 145

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

785. 65477/10

29/10/2010

Peter MUNDEN

17/09/1961

Devon

British

HMP Dartmoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 23/05/2008 pursuant to three

year and three month sentence

786. 65551/10

29/10/2010

Michael

SKUDDER

01/10/1957

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 01/01/2009 pursuant to eleven

year sentence

787. 65552/10

29/10/2010

Dennis SLADE

16/09/1975

Brasside, Durnham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 04/03/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

788. 65555/10

29/10/2010

Steven SMALE

18/11/1974

Leyland, Preston

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Garth

789. 65558/10

29/10/2010

Simon SMITH

07/07/1982

Hatfield

Woodhouse,

Doncaster

British

HMP Lindholme

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 18/11/2009 pursuant to two years

and nine months sentence

Page 148: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

146 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

790. 65585/10

29/10/2010

David SMITH

15/02/1966

Sherwood,

Nottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 27/10/2009 pursuant to fourty-

five month sentence

791. 65623/10

29/10/2010

Michael

MUOTTO

29/11/1989

London

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From September 2009 pursuant to

eighteen month sentence

792. 65628/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

MURPHY

10/05/1990

Lichfield

British

A2258AD

HMYOI Swinfen Hall

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 04/02/2009 pursuant to seven

years and two months sentence

793. 65638/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

MURPHY

19/12/1964

Eastchurch

British

HMP Standford Hill LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Standford Hill (Sheppey Cluster)

794. 65643/10

29/10/2010

George MURRAY

03/12/1971

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

Page 149: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 147

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

795. 65648/10

29/10/2010

Neil

MUSGREAVES

02/11/1969

Doncaster

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

796. 65675/10

29/10/2010

Brian

NALBOROUGH

08/06/1944

Eastchurch

British

HMP Standford Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 15/12/2009 pursuant to four year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Standford Hill

797. 65685/10

29/10/2010

Scott NAPIER

21/04/1966

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 03/03/2006 to unknown date

798. 65692/10

29/10/2010

Royden NASH

09/09/1955

Bridgend

British

HMP Parc

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

01/2007 to unknown date

799. 65730/10

04/10/2010

Julian

MAKANJUOLA

30/01/1983

Nottingham

British

A1744AL

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 13/03/2006 pursuant to six year

and six month sentence

800. 65837/10

29/10/2010

Ronnie HUDSON

08/09/1982

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

Page 150: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

148 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

801. 65841/10

29/10/2010

Victor NAUNTON

10/12/1946

Newmarket

British

HMP Highpoint

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 27/06/2000 pursuant to fourteen

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Highpoint

802. 65857/10

29/10/2010

Amir NAWAZ

04/12/1954

Nottingham

Pakistani

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 16/02/1998 to unknown date

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Sudbury

803. 65863/10

29/10/2010

Michael HORA

10/04/1966

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight (Parkhurst site)

804. 65868/10

29/10/2010

Michael

JACKSON

17/05/1967

Evesham

British

HMP Long Lartin

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

805. 65872/10

29/10/2010

David JACKSON

09/03/1978

Eastchurch

British

HMP Swaleside

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

806. 65884/10

29/10/2010

Ian NAYLOR

02/01/1984

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

Page 151: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 149

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

807. 65891/10

29/10/2010

Peter MARRITT

03/01/1978

Hull

British

HMP Hull

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 05/05/2010 pursuant to eighteen

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP Hull

808. 65894/10

29/10/2010

Gerard NELSON

30/10/1954

Preston

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Garth

809. 65896/10

29/10/2010

Wade MARGRIM

30/06/1988

Brasside

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

810. 65900/10

29/10/2010

Dean MANTON

18/10/1978

Clacton

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

811. 65908/10

29/10/2010

Sadakat

MALOOK

15/08/1980

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

812. 65910/10

29/10/2010

Mark MALONE

19/05/1978

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 12/12/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 152: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

150 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

813. 65914/10

29/10/2010

Amjad MALIK

05/08/1968

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 31/01/2008 pursuant to thirteen

year sentence

814. 65915/10

29/10/2010

Steven NERNEY

06/12/1974

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 17/11/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

815. 65935/10

29/10/2010

Samantha

NEWBURY

11/09/1975

Ashford

British

HMP Bronzefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 12/2008 pursuant to four year

and six month sentence

816. 65942/10

29/10/2010

Stephen

NEWTON

06/09/1971

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 10/2009 pursuant to life sentence

817. 65950/10

29/10/2010

Philip NICHOL

07/03/1989

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 17/12/2009 pursuant to life

sentence

818. 65952/10

29/10/2010

Anthony MAHON

27/09/1965

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 13/11/2009 pursuant to fourteen

year sentence

Page 153: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 151

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

819. 65954/10

29/10/2010

Sabul MIAH

25/01/1975

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 08/2003 pursuant to life sentence

820. 65955/10

29/10/2010

Michael

METCALFE

20/08/1960

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 06/07/2006 pursuant to life

sentence

821. 65957/10

29/10/2010

Paul MELLING

18/04/1954

Leyland

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Garth

822. 65960/10

29/10/2010

Michael MC NEE

12/04/1985

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

823. 65961/10

29/10/2010

Kevin MCLEAN

11/09/1979

Huntingdon

British

HMP Littlehey

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Littlehey

824. 65962/10

29/10/2010

Geoffrey

MCKENZIE

02/12/1978

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 12/01/2009 pursuant to four year

and six month sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

Page 154: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

152 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

825. 65963/10

29/10/2010

Ernie MC KENNA

10/10/1961

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

27/02/2009 to unknown date

826. 65965/10

29/10/2010

Simeon MC

KELLAR

06/10/1988

Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Detained at relevant tiem at HMP

Wayland

827. 65967/10

29/10/2010

William

MCINNES

12/09/1957

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

Scottish elections 5 May 2011

From 26/01/2004 pursuant to fourteen

year sentence

828. 65971/10

29/10/2010

Paul MCINNES

09/03/1977

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 07/06/2002 pursuant to life

sentence

829. 65983/10

29/10/2010

Martin MC

GUINNESS

25/02/1984

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 22/12/2006 pursuant to life

sentence

830. 65986/10

29/10/2010

Lee MC GRATH

31/01/1972

Theddlethorpe

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From May 2004 pursuant to nine year

sentence

Page 155: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 153

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

831. 65988/10

29/10/2010

Greg MC

GETRICK

04/11/1966

Maidstone

British

HMP Maidstone

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 18/09/2009 pursuant to seven

year sentence

832. 65989/10

29/10/2010

Philip MC DAID

31/08/1972

Millom

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 02/12/1999 pursuant to life

sentence

833. 65995/10

29/10/2010

Peter MC

CLUSKIE

26/02/1963

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 11/04/2003 pursuant to eight

year and two month sentence

834. 66007/10

29/10/2010

Richard

MCCLEARY

25/10/1988

Newmarket

British

A5355AK

HMP Highpoint

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 21/07/2008 pursuant to five year

sentence

835. 66010/10

29/10/2010

Jamie

MCCLEARY

15/09/1987

Wayland

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 14/01/2010 pursuant to four

years and six months sentence

Page 156: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

154 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

836. 66013/10

29/10/2010

Keith MAWSON

16/02/1961

Doncaster

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 02/02/2009 pursuant to three

year sentence

837. 66019/10

29/10/2010

Rhys

MATHESON

28/01/1982

Bridgend

British

HMP Parc

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh Assembly elections 5 May 2011

From 20/07/2005 pursuant to twelve

year sentence

838. 66021/10

29/10/2010

Neil MASIH

14/03/1973

Derbyshire

British

HMP Sudbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 18/06/2009 pursuant to six year

sentence

839. 66025/10

29/10/2010

John MARSHALL

09/04/1975

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 22 May 2004 pursuant to seven

year and six months sentence

840. 66029/10

29/10/2010

Ashley

MARSHALL

21/08/1987

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From January 2006 pursuant to thirteen

year sentence

841. 66037/10

29/10/2010

John MARSHALL

06/11/1961

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 24 December 2003 pursuant to

life sentence

Page 157: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 155

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

842. 66701/10

29/10/2010

Peter SMITH

05/07/1971

Wakefield, West

Yorkshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From April 2006 pursuant to life

sentence

843. 66702/10

29/10/2010

Peter SMITH

08/02/1964

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From December 2007 pursuant to life

sentence

844. 66705/10

29/10/2010

Leroy SMITH

05/11/1968

Brasside, Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 24 April 1994 pursuant to

twenty-five year sentence

845. 66707/10

29/10/2010

Gordon SMITH

07/05/1965

Wakefield, West

Yorkshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From March 2000 pursuant to life

sentence

846. 66709/10

29/10/2010

Elias SMITH

22/12/1978

Millom, Cumbria

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 28/02/2007 pursuant to twelve

year sentence

Page 158: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

156 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

847. 66711/10

29/10/2010

Stephen SOANS-

WADE

07/07/1967

Brasside, Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

848. 66712/10

29/10/2010

Leon SOBERS

05/03/1978

Isle of Sheppey,

Kent

British

HMP Swaleside LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From January 2001 pursuant to life

sentence

849. 66714/10

29/10/2010

James

SOUTHWELL

27/09/1961

Wakefield, West

Yorkshire

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From June 2004 pursuant to life

sentence

850. 66718/10

29/10/2010

David SPEDDING

11/10/1960

Lowdham,

Nottingham

British

HMP Lowdham Grange

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From July 2004 pursuant to twelve

year sentence

851. 66722/10

29/10/2010

Terry SPENCER

07/04/1989

Doncaster

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 159: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 157

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

852. 66724/10

29/10/2010

Colin STACEY

21/04/1969

Shaftesbury, Dorset

British

HMP Guys Marsh

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Guys

Marsh

853. 66725/10

29/10/2010

Corey BARTEN-

BACH

09/12/1973

Rutland

British

HMP Ashwell

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ashwell

854. 66726/10

29/10/2010

Andrew

STAFFORD

06/03/1983

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

855. 66727/10

29/10/2010

Alan STEAD

27/04/1966

Market Harborough,

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

856. 66730/10

29/10/2010

Matthew

BARTLETT

29/01/1986

Camborne

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 11/06/2009 pursuant to three

year and three month sentence

Page 160: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

158 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

857. 66731/10

29/10/2010

John

STEPHENSON

04/02/1965

Retford,

Nottinghamshire

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 07/08/2009 pursuant to five

years and four months sentence

858. 66734/10

29/10/2010

Alan STEVENS

06/08/1941

Uttoxeter,

Stafforshire

British

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From April 1992 pursuant to life

sentence

859. 66735/10

29/10/2010

Richard BATES

07/05/1952

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From September 2002 pursuant to

eighteen year sentence

860. 66737/10

29/10/2010

Timothy

STEWARD

09/07/1972

Thetford, Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 4 May 2009 pursuant to three

years and six months sentence

861. 66738/10

29/10/2010

Albert BELL

18/11/1975

Leicestershire

British

HMP Stocken

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Since 19 October 1996 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 161: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 159

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

862. 66739/10

29/10/2010

Jack STOCKS

10/08/1954

Preston

British

HMP Kirkham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Since June 2002 pursuant to life

sentence

863. 66743/10

29/10/2010

Ricardo BELL

02/06/1988

Preston

British

HMP Grath

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 03/08/2007 pursuant to three

years and four months sentence

864. 66744/10

29/10/2010

Jamie BENNETT

14/08/1987

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 26/12/2006 pursuant to life

sentence

865. 66747/10

29/10/2010

Paul BEVAN

07/02/1952

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 23/02/2006 pursuant to eighteen

year sentence

866. 66750/10

29/10/2010

Lee BEVAN

02/12/1973

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 17/11/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

867. 66755/10

29/10/2010

Justin

BILLINGHAM

30/07/1972

Leicestershire

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

22/03/2007 to unknown date

Page 162: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

160 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

868. 66758/10

29/10/2010

Mark

BILLINGHAM

25/03/1981

Lowdham

British

HMP Lowdham Grange

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 07/07/2006 pursuant to life

sentence

869. 66760/10

29/10/2010

Ian BIRD

14/06/1958

York

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From June 2007 pursuant to life

sentence

870. 66768/10

29/10/2010

Stewart BIRKS

07/05/1977

Nottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 21/01/2010 pursuant to twenty

month sentence

871. 66772/10

29/10/2010

Christopher

BIRKS

25/07/1978

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 26/02/2009 pursuant to life

sentence

872. 66775/10

29/10/2010

Roger BISHOP

24/04/1957

Norwich

British

HMP Bure

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 21/08/2007 pursuant to three

year sentence

873. 66777/10

29/10/2010

James BLACKIE

26/12/1958

Retford

British

HMP Randy

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 30/09/2005 pursuant to three

year sentence

Page 163: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 161

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

874. 66781/10

29/10/2010

Wayne BLACK

14/01/1971

Rutland

British

HMP Ashwell

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

15/02/2008 to unknown date

875. 66783/10

29/10/2010

Mark BONNER

30/03/1982

Nottinghamshire

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

24/06/2008 to unknown date

876. 66785/10

29/10/2010

Antony BOOTH-

ISHERWOOD

25/09/1979

Nottingham

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/01/2005 to unknown date

877. 66787/10

29/10/2010

Peter BOSTOCK

19/08/1967

Docaster

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

17/09/2009 to unknown date

878. 66793/10

29/10/2010

Adrian Robert

BOWDEN

09/04/1966

Uttoxeter

British

(HG 9367

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

879. 66794/10

29/10/2010

James PALMER

30/08/1946

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 07/1995 pursuant to a life

sentence (six-year tariff)

Page 164: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

162 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

880. 66796/10

29/10/2010

Stephen BOWER

13/06/1985

Pendlebury

British

HMP Forest Bank

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

881. 66800/10

29/10/2010

John BRADFORD

01/06/1969

Sherwood

British

HMP Nottingham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

27/03/2009 to unknown date

882. 66801/10

29/10/2010

Mentor BRAHIMI

11/01/1982

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

10/11/2008 to unknown date

883. 66804/10

29/10/2010

Mark BRAY

18/09/1979

Leicestershire

British

A1813AK

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 27/04/2009 pursuant to life

sentence

884. 66807/10

29/10/2010

Allan PALMER

11/03/1965

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 26/11/2009 pursuant to life

sentence

885. 66808/10

29/10/2010

Colin BRAY

26/06/1954

Wakefield

British

CN0987

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 26/10/1993 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 165: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 163

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

886. 66814/10

29/10/2010

Gerald O’LEARY

12/05/1954

Millom

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

19/11/2007 to unknown date

887. 66820/10

29/10/2010

Mark ORDISH

12/08/1967

Preston

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 25/03/2002 pursuant to life

sentence

888. 66826/10

29/10/2010

Frank

ORMESHER

29/04/1971

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

889. 66832/10

29/10/2010

Graham OSMENT

08/07/1980

Milton Kaynes

British

HMP Woodhill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

890. 66837/10

29/10/2010

Peter O’TOOLE

20/03/1977

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 26/05/2005 pursuant to life

sentence

891. 66845/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

O’TOOLE

01/09/1964

Millom

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

23/07/2003 to unknown date

Page 166: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

164 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

892. 66849/10

29/10/2010

Zak OWEN

13/12/1970

Sheerness

British

HMP Sheppy Cluster LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

28/03/2008 to unknown date

893. 66853/10

29/10/2010

Gary OXLEY

18/01/1961

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 12/10/2009 pursuant to life

sentence

894. 66854/10

29/10/2010

Darren NICKLEN

27/04/1970

Sheerness

British

HMP Standfor Hill LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

895. 66856/10

29/10/2010

Herpal NIJJER

11/03/1969

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

896. 66888/10

29/10/2010

Darren ROBERTS

12/09/1980

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

897. 66894/10

29/10/2010

Peter ROE

26/02/1948

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 167: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 165

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

898. 66896/10

29/10/2010

Wayne ROGERS

22/01/1970

Uttoxeter

British

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dovegate

899. 66899/10

29/10/2010

David ROOKES

11/03/1962

Kellington

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Full

Sutton

900. 66900/10

29/10/2010

Andrew

ROWLANDS

20/10/1982

Uttoxeter

British

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

901. 66903/10

29/10/2010

Stuart ROYLE

20/07/1958

Durham

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

902. 66909/10

29/10/2010

Leslie SALTER

10/03/1965

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

903. 66912/10

29/10/2010

Stephen

SANDISON

08/01/1980

Preston

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Garth

Page 168: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

166 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

904. 66913/10

29/10/2010

Manjinder

SANGHA

08/04/1973

Birmingham

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

905. 66915/10

29/10/2010

Gideon SARIG

31/08/1951

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 08/02/2010 pursuant to nine year

sentence

906. 66920/10

29/10/2010

Peter SAVILLE

26/01/1978

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 29/10/2010 pursuant to two year

and six month sentence

907. 66922/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

SCANTLEBURY

25/01/1976

Dorchester

British

HMP Dorchester

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 10/01/2008 pursuant to three

year and three month sentence

908. 66925/10

29/10/2010

David SCOTT

02/08/1988

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

18/12/2008 to unknown date

909. 66928/10

29/10/2010

Thomas SCOTT

01/10/1983

Nottingham

British

HMP Nottignham

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 22/03/2010 pursuant to twenty

one month sentence

Page 169: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 167

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

910. 66929/10

29/10/2010

William

SCOUARNEC

04/11/1977

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 04/11/2009 pursuant to life

sentence

911. 66931/10

29/10/2010

Richard SEAMAN

08/01/1977

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 22/12/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

912. 66934/10

29/10/2010

Kevin SEAMAN

31/01/1962

Hull

British

HMP Hull

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 23/08/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

913. 66937/10

29/10/2010

Nigel SENIOR

23/09/1951

Wakefield

British

A9601AA

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

914. 66939/10

29/10/2010

Haroon SHARIF

12/11/1977

Retford

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

915. 66943/10

29/10/2010

Charles SHAW

30/05/1959

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 02/02/2010 pursuant to ten year

sentence

Page 170: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

168 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

916. 66945/10

29/10/2010

Malcolm SHEATH

20/05/1954

Thetford

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 22/02/2010 pursuant to fifty four

month sentence

917. 66950/10

29/10/2010

Simon

SHINGFIELD

04/08/1975

Ipswich

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 09/12/2008 pursuant to four year

sentence

918. 66998/10

29/10/2010

Andrew NORRIS

14/04/1963

Shrewsbury

British

HMP Shrewsbury

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 21/03/2010 pursuant to two year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shrewsbury

919. 67003/10

29/10/2010

Raymond

NORRIS

13/01/1965

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight (Parkhurst Site)

920. 67009/10

29/10/2010

Gary O’BRIEN

06/03/1963

Leyland

British

HMP Garth

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Garth

921. 67028/10

29/10/2010

Jason O’DELL

12/08/1969

Norwich

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

Page 171: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 169

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

922. 67039/10

29/10/2010

Barry

O’DONNELL

18/04/1963

Manchester

British

HMP Manchester

(Has provided a home address

in Londonderry, Northern

Ireland).

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Northern Irish Assembly election 5

May 2011

From 15/05/2006 pursuant to life

sentence

923. 67046/10

29/10/2010

Michael

O’GORMAN

19/06/1979

Norfolk

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

924. 67056/10

29/10/2010

Ogbogu OKAFOR

10/08/1981

Newport

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 12/06/2009 pursuant to eight

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight (Parkhurst site)

925. 67059/10

29/10/2010

Victor PARKER

06/06/1961

Isle of Wight

British

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle

of Wight (Parkhurst site)

926. 67063/10

29/10/2010

Antony PARSONS

08/01/1979

Willoughby

British

HMP Rye Hill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Rye

Hill

927. 67097/10

29/10/2010

Adrain

PATCHETT

20/05/1980

Yorkshire

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

Page 172: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

170 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

928. 67119/10

29/10/2010

Jason PATERSON

29/07/1977

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

929. 67124/10

29/10/2010

Gerard PAUL

10/06/1962

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

930. 67143/10

29/10/2010

Andrew PEEBLES

10/10/1973

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

931. 67148/10

29/10/2010

Khalid PENDER

16/08/1986

Wayland

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 27/11/2009 pursuant to five year

and three month sentence

932. 67151/10

29/10/2010

Anthony

PERKINS

11/10/1982

Norwich

British

HMP Norwich

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 27/03/2009 pursuant to five year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Hollesley Bay (Hoxton Wing)

933. 67156/10

29/10/2010

Victor PERRIN

04/09/1945

Lewes

British

HMP Lewes

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 29/04/2008 pursuant to ten year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Lewes

Page 173: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 171

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

934. 67162/10

29/10/2010

Robert PHILLIPS

25/05/1966

Norwich

British

A0358AV

HMP Norwich

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

13/02/2009 to unknown date

935. 67290/10

29/10/2010

Stephen PILE

11/02/1961

Portland

British

HMP The Verne

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Guys

Marsh

936. 67310/10

29/10/2010

Ross PLANT

19/04/1989

Doncaster

British

HMP Lindholme

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 03/03/2010 pursuant to three

year and six month sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Nottingham

937. 67311/10

29/10/2010

Graham POPE

18/06/1939

Leyhill

British

HMP Leyhill

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Leyhill

938. 67315/10

29/10/2010

Jamie POTTER

01/07/1972

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

939. 67319/10

29/10/2010

Delroy POWELL

13/09/1979

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Frankland

Page 174: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

172 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

940. 67326/10

29/10/2010

Derek PRATT

07/03/1942

Camborne

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Exeter

941. 67328/10

29/10/2010

Mark PRICE

18/01/1967

Market Harborough

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Gartree

942. 67333/10

29/10/2010

Francis

PRITCHARD

01/02/1977

Preston

British

HMP Kirkham

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 04/07/2001 pursuant to life

sentence

943. 67340/10

29/10/2010

Eric PURKISS

27/05/1956

Wakefield

British

HMP Wakefield

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 09/05/1985 pursuant to life

sentence

944. 67348/10

29/10/2010

Michael PURTILL

04/10/1955

Sheerness

British

HMP Sheppey Cluster LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

16/06/2009 to unknown date

945. 67349/10

29/10/2010

Leslie PURVIS

10/04/1964

frankland

British

A482OAE

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 06/03/2003 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 175: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 173

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

946. 67354/10

29/10/2010

Mark RAFTERY

03/12/1973

Wayland

British

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

20/01/2010 to unknown date

947. 67363/10

29/10/2010

Ramoon RAHIMI

24/10/1985

March

British

AS36SAC

HMP Whitemoor

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 17/07/2007 pursuant to eight

year sentence

948. 67369/10

29/10/2010

James RAVEN

10/12/1959

York

British

HMP Full Sutton

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 19/06/2003 pursuant to life

sentence

949. 67380/10

29/10/2010

Matthew

RECORD

22/09/1982

Haverigg

British

HMP Haverigg

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 12/08/2009 pursuant to two years

and eight months sentence

950. 67382/10

29/10/2010

Craig REILING

06/04/1977

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 10/09/2007 pursuant to three

years and 181 days sentence

951. 67408/10

29/10/2010

Mark REVILL

16/03/1971

Dovegate

British

HMP Dovegate

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From January 2004 pursuant to ten

year sentence

Page 176: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

174 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

952. 67409/10

29/10/2010

Errol Junior

REYNOLDS

15/11/1986

Frankland

British

HMP Frankland

LEIGH DAY & CO General elections 6 May 2010

From 28/10/2005 pursuant to twenty-

one year sentence

953. 67410/10

29/10/2010

Mark RHODES

01/10/1975

Freiston

British

HMP North Sea Camp

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 17/09/2009 pursuant to three

year sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

North Sea Camp

954. 67414/10

29/10/2010

Stephen RICE

24/06/1963

Griston

British

A3846AD

HMP Wayland

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 22/12/2006 pursuant to six year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

955. 67415/10

29/10/2010

James RICE

29/10/1984

Folstone

British

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 16/08/2006 pursuant to two year

and six month sentence with one year

licence.

956. 67416/10

29/10/2010

Oliver

RICHARDS

23/04/1986

Ranby

British

HMP Ranby

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

From 19/03/2010 pursuant to two year

and three month sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Ranby

957. 67418/10

29/10/2010

Dafydd

RISEBOROUGH

12/08/1985

Usk

British

HMP Usk

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010;

Welsh election 5 May 2011

From 24/07/2008 pursuant to four year

sentence.

Page 177: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 175

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

958. 60820/11

05/11/2010

Owen

ANDERSON

09/06/1972

West Lothian

British

HMP Addiewell

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

959. 62244/11

20/10/2010

Floyd BAILEY

16/07/1962

Evesham

British

A7947AE

HMP Long Lartin

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

960. 62282/11

31/10/2011

William BAIRD

12/07/1966

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

961. 62916/11

15/10/2010

Mario Leo

BONCELLI

08/08/1954

March

British

A8289AA

HMP Whitemoor

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Whitemoor

962. 62948/11

01/11/2010

Brian BOYLE

01/06/1984

Morpeth

British

HMP Acklington

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

From 15/09/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Acklington

963. 63170/11

01/11/2010

Terence BRYANT

21/11/1956

London

British

HMP Wormwood Scrubs

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

From 15/06/2007 pursuant to five year

sentence

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wormwood Scrubs

Page 178: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

176 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

964. 63519/11

03/11/2010

Michael BULLA

14/02/1976

Aberdeen

British

HMP Peterhead

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

965. 63881/11

19/10/2010

Alan CAMERON

17/05/1954

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

966. 64200/11

29/10/2010

Barry

CHEETHAM

31/10/1957

Gartree

British

HMP Gartree

LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

967. 64209/11

04/04/2011

Peter CHESTER

04/10/1954

York

British

A9675AA

HMP Full Sutton

EU elections 4 June 2009

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wakefield

968. 64824/11

03/11/2010

Ian CRAIG

03/05/1970

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Bowhouse

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

969. 64837/11

01/11/2010

Eric CUMMINGS

19/08/1981

Featherstone

British

HMP Featherstone

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

Page 179: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 177

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

970. 65171/11

01/11/2010

Jack DOCHERTY

07/05/1961

London

British

HMP Wormwood Scrubs

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

971. 65178/11

29/10/2010

Michael Darren

DOCHERTY

16/08/1974

Stafford

British

A3227AH

HMP Stafford

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Stafford

972. 65615/11

03/11/2010

Thomas FINAN

05/10/1980

Coatbridge

British

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

973. 65867/11

19/10/2010

Scott

GALLAGHER

15/07/1967

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

974. 66855/11

28/10/2010

Christopher

HATTON

23/04/1978

Goudhurst

British

A5952AL

HMP Blantyre House

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

975. 66944/11

19/10/2010

Gary HICKS

20/08/1979

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

Page 180: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

178 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

976. 66948/11

01/11/2010

Daniel HIGH

20/11/1980

Griston

British

HMP Wayland

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

977. 67121/11

01/11/2010

Christopher HILL

17/06/1964

Whatton

British

A8793AV

HMP Whatton

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

978. 67223/11

03/11/2010

Robert

HOUGHTON

07/09/1964

Nottingham

British

A8557AH

HMP Whatton

General election 6 May 2010

09/01/2006 to unknown date

979. 67467/11

19/10/2010

Richard HUNTER

17/10/1944

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time in HMP

Edinburgh

980. 67800/11

30/10/2010

Abdul Hamid

KAYANI

31/07/1953

London

British

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

981. 68904/11

02/11/2010

John MALLIN

04/01/1956

South Littleton

British

A7824AF

HMP Long Lartin

BROUDIE

JACKSON CANTER

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Long

Lartin

Page 181: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 179

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

982. 70456/11

19/10/2010

Scott MC INNES

27/09/1974

Lanarkshire

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

983. 71054/11

01/11/2010

Gregor MC

MURTRIE

10/04/1976

London

British

A9736AQ

HMP Wandsworth

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wandsworth

984. 71363/11

01/11/2010

David John

MILLS

01/02/1985

Hull

British

HMP Hull

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Hull

985. 71392/11

19/10/2010

Thomas

MITCHELL

11/04/1968

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock

TAYLOR & KELLY General elections of 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Kilmarnock

986. 71655/11

01/11/2010

Paul Andrew

MORRELL

25/07/1968

Griston

British

A4562AH

HMP Wayland

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wayland

Page 182: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

180 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

987. 71959/11

01/11/2010

Mark NUTTALL

05/02/1980

Liverpool

British

HMP Altcourse

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Altcourse

988. 71974/11

03/11/2010

William

O’DONNELL

26/11/1955

Aberdeen

British

HMP Peterhead

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Peterhead

989. 72799/11

01/11/2010

Darren PILCHER

20/04/1972

Chelmsford

British

HMP Chelmsford

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Chelmsford

990. 73069/11

04/11/2010

Ashley POWELL

09/02/1988

London

British

BINDMANS LLP General election 6 May 2010

16/02/2010 to unknown date; Detained

at relevant time at HMP Wormwood

Scrubs

991. 73330/11

25/10/2010

Abdul RASHID

08/10/1961

Wotton-under-Edge

British

A8228AH

HMP Leyhill

T

General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP Bure

992. 73335/11

19/10/2010

Malcolm RAY

29/10/1972

Edinburgh

British

HMP Edinburgh

TAYLOR & KELLY General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at the relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

Page 183: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 181

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

993. 73396/11

01/11/2010

Duncan REED

10/01/1967

Willoughby

British

HMP Rye Hill

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

From 12/05/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

994. 73406/11

01/11/2010

James REID

23/11/1937

Dumfries

British

HMP Dumfries

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Not known

995. 73640/11

19/10/2010

Michael ROSS

28/08/1968

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts

TAYLOR & KELLY General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

996. 73661/11

01/11/2010

Marsha RUSSELL

24/03/1976

Bronzefield

British

HMP Bronzefield

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

From 09/11/2007 to unknown date

997. 73671/11

01/11/2010

Glenn RYCROFT

02/04/1976

South Littleton

British

HMP Long Lartin

General election 6 May 2010

From 03/07/2009 pursuant to life

sentence

998. 73685/11

12/05/2011

Peter SCHRODER

17/12/1967

Edinburgh

British

HMP Saughton

ROBERTSON &

ROSS

Scottish election 5 May 2011

Not known

Page 184: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

182 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

999. 74197/11

04/11/2010

Nicholas SMITH

25/02/1950

London

British

A5506AQ

HMP Wormwood Scrubs

BINDMANS LLP General election 6 May 2010

From 11/01/2009 to unknown date;

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Wormwood Scrubs

1000. 74218/11

01/11/2010

Terence

STANDAGE

22/01/1959

London

British

HMP Belmarsh

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

12/04/2010 to unknown date; Detained

at relevant time at HMP Belmarsh

1001. 74247/11

03/11/2010

Paul STIRLING

02/07/1982

Addiewell

British

HMP Addiewell ROBERTSON &

ROSS

General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Addiewell

1002. 75136/11

19/10/2010

John SWEENEY

19/01/1948

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts TAYLOR & KELLY General elections 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

1003. 75141/11

01/11/2010

Ian SWINBURNE

18/05/1963

Stocken

British

HMP Stocken FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

24/11/2009 to unknown date

1004. 75151/11

01/11/2010

Stephen TANNER

27/02/1964

London

British

A7427AP

HMP Wandsworth

FISHER MEREDITH

SOLICITORS

General election 6 May 2010

From 12/03/2008 pursuant to life

sentence

Page 185: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT 183

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

1005. 8836/12

31/10/2011

Mohammed

AKRAM

04/02/1960

Lanarkshire

British

HMP Shotts TAYLOR & KELLY Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

1006. 8883/12

28/10/2011

James Kerr

COWAN

22/09/1976

Kilmarnock

British

HMP Kilmarnock TAYLOR & KELLY Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh

1007. 9158/12

31/10/2011

Sid RATTRAY

10/12/1979

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts TAYLOR & KELLY Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Glenochil

1008. 9177/12

28/10/2011

Sean MOYNIHAN

12/09/1984

Scotland

British

HMP Shotts TAYLOR & KELLY Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Edinburgh or Dumfries.

1009. 9409/12

31/10/2011

George MACKAY

27/07/1954

Scotland

British

HMP Low Moss TAYLOR & KELLY Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Dumfries

1010. 9439/12

31/10/2011

Steven QUILL

30/07/1986

Scotland

British

HMP Shotts TAYLOR & KELLY Scottish election 5 May 2011

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

Page 186: FOURTH SECTION - EODS · FOURTH SECTION CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 10 February

184 MCHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT

No. Application

no. and date

of

introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Prisoner no. where known &

Name of Prison

Represented by Election missed Detention details where known

1011. 9600/12

31/10/2011

Alexander MC

CLURE

30/01/1975

Dumfries

British

74071

HMP Dumfries

Scottish election 5 May 2011

From 14/11/2002 pursuant to life

sentence

1012. 31715/12

28/10/2011

Jim SPENCE

23/04/1987

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts TAYLOR & KELLY Scottish election 5 May 2011

From 28/04/2008 pursuant to life

sentence; Detained at relevant time at

HMP Kilmarnock

1013. 21191/13

29/10/2010

Kevin COLE

01/03/1974

Isle of Wight

Jamaican

HMP Isle of Wight LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010

Not known

1014. 13262/14

19/10/2010

James BERRY

13/02/1978

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts

1015. 13287/14

19/10/2010

Keiron

RICHARDS

04/03/1985

Shotts

British

HMP Shotts TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010

Detained at relevant time at HMP

Shotts