for and structures 31 january dtic · ad-a253 336 final technical report theater level...
TRANSCRIPT
AD-A253 336
FINAL TECHNICAL REPORT
THEATER LEVEL EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS FORADVANCED MATERIALS AND STRUCTURES
31 January 1992
DTICSELECTE
Sponsored by JUL 2 81992Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DoD) U
Defense Small Business Innovative Research ProgramARPA Order No. 5916 A
Issued by U.S. Army Missile Command UnderContract # DAAH01-91-C-R201
I Name of Contractor: STR Corporation Principal Investigator: W. Leon GoodsonBusiness Address: 10700 Parkridge Blvd Phone Number:. 703-758-1100
Reston, VA 22091-5429 Short Title of Work:Effective Date of Contract: 21 Aug 91 Theater Level Effectiveness AnalysisContract Expiration Date: 31 Jan 92Reporting Period: 21 Aug 91 - 31 Jan 92
-- This document has been approved
for public release and sale; itsdistribution is unlimited.
DISCLADEfRI "The views and conglusions contained in this document are those of the authors andshould not be interpreted as representing the official policies, either express or implied, ofthe Defense Advanced Research Project Agency or the U.S. Government."
* 9 727 162 92-202-46
ABSTRACT
This is our final technical report, the purpose of which is to demonstrate our abilityto estimate and compare the contributions of advanced materials and structures toeffectiveness, at the theater level.
A Middle East scenario in the 2000-2010 timeframe was chosen for thisdemonstration. A notional advanced fighter was used for the example. Two advancedmaterials were selected for comparison - a conventional polymer-based composite for theaircraft skin which provides weight savings, and a high temperature ceramic for the enginehot section which allows increases in engine turbine inlet temperature. We also providedresults for increased tank survivability, to demonstrate the flexibility of the model inassessing a range of weapons system.
By varying these characteristics against the base case, a set of parametric curves weredeveloped which plot change in effectiveness vs. change in characteristic. By using thesecurves, the change in campaign effectiveness produced by each of the three materials wasdetermined. A break even cost vs. change in material curve was then produced to enableestimates to be made of when a development program of stated risk should be undertakencompared to simply buying more aircraft of the stated characteristics.
In addition to this report, we are delivering the parametric curves developed for thisdemonstration on magnetic media. These will permit users at DARPA to see how easy it isto have effectiveness information available to them for the purpose of comparing the impactof various advanced materials and structures on campaign effectiveness.
Accesion For
NTIS CRAM~D DrIC TABU .uao ced ELi
IIBy ..... ..... ......................
Dist. ibution! "
Ava'iaility ,t s
Dist Specialo
ILOF
IL
I* I-0
j
Mlewjqxliv ii j
Z Fft~I CE j UJIqxmJO
III
al CO)
o
: E "0 rI-1;C
.0 tR_ .°- 0_. 0 C.D_ ., .. a - LE . - - 'Ca n)
0, ®n, 0 -- ,->ci50 C I
-= 0E 'g - 8. C-o :., ,,.,.go .- 0 ca ...C"L:
I-C Co 0 )
Z -0 00)c
0)
0 0r- m _. .E . > .o _ E
cm cc
C a = - a 0 t 0
D E- o) a . Z -- II=0 CD
4)...-C *. t cs0 (D 04-
*1) .~0)>0 0 CO 0 E 0I0V Cn ( Cc~ (>C :3 0=,u -
I
oC 4)CD
~ 0 7E> W ~ C(0
E) 4) 2<C 0,04).U
- .50 0.- L- -o m 3-:2 cu C 0 "1 ofC -0)- (D -
rtI~ 00 CD 0Mr_ 0.0M = V;I
--x k 4) .L ts=.aI
one 0
0C
- mw
0000.5 0
0 *a
0L 0
0 oW
00c. U) -
80 a CL:
C 0 10 & c c
000 C cc0_
no-
W 'U 'U 00 0 C c~
ccU C -0u 0 C0~0
00
0 0E
S 0 U 0
a.. c a.',c 0~~ * 0
II
JD
DO)~I
Do I
_ o a_)- '
0)C.I
~~0 , ..
B~ C ~C 0
as ca 0" - (D 0)Io o _.c
ca 0"
-- Z - = ,, -0
o 0)
.. Cu L-. . I
CO~~ asc
x~o
W- 000)-V 0> a) EE
. .- ) IC
t-CE-~ 0
ca .* - a 4-' 3ou *j-~a --
.CO (D 0 ) a(D M.I> * "
U cc- d g V=ICC = >% (
13
C'a
CO E
0 CD
(()DO U~OIAQUA DJ
III
m4co
, (1)
- .CUr-) Ia) ) 1°>IE~ a
SIo o
o I
0 I
II
Ca
c'
jS
ooc2w ami
IU
I
0 .-
F --. l -cc e, >m
C u C0 c
E 0 0 C0 0EI
x!
0.D 3 .0 Cc &-jc 0
.i-a >6~ 4)0C -
0 E- a EOCO -0
4 0 cacc 00
_M 40 ca
c6 &3FL W CO00
a) o20 0 c~
- mC > g) E-
0 = 0 0 0 -=
( ME0 C00
r. LL0
0 QIAsI
c 000
*00
*.bm E
* 0 cc a
-L
~In Cca
~C 0C
0-0 0E c~ ,
0c 0
0
I
_ ) II
UCD
IE '
o E
o c (0 ID0.j
E E O'
L) w.cc:
c -- =o US ca)cu 0
cu
aCEu0)00 as
oo cUC I(Dsot P 0 0,0
o) t
A
'0.
0 b.
Ec SE
00I () -
'U 0c
I Lslu
Cl5 low.00 EE
I 'U -cc
'U o E0
a EI 0 000 S00
IX
0) I1 ba
0) CI C 0)0
o) C r 4)C )
0t .0)>Q 0F-U0 * 6 to(D0) a)0 > O
~E C?)~ CO C Uc ) 0 0 . 3-0 ) 8 0 w W ) 0)C 0 )
0) 0 r- Cc*- .. UE~0 0 E*l.c - m 75- *CO0&0
cOO m0 tE) ~ 0 CD13 v0. E)
E>Z 0- o~C 0~U4 00.0) >% Lc >,Cr I C
C (
r~-0 4-' C
LU m E (aI
00a 0 .0-C mr_ 20'75 a) D) U co A?~C
a) !CU -- )-W 0ts 0- 0 0 - 0
CI~ Im0 0C5U *UCU# CU%%U
t5 C(D C 2 0T 0U0 V * m mCIS ~s I
Im EcI
UL
0U&
u cIUIu
(31FLcc coIL=
I0
II
CAI
0
0
C,
0D0
0Naa
.0 EE0
FE 3CCO
IL0Iw
LULI ~ii
w-3~ Lu
I L3 olzS2
C0.
I Lu ~ss(jS L IIl
IUoiIc (I C
I-I
III
E
04. ) 0 . I> ) 0
> EU0
cc$~
CD
._.203
a 0 4
M CDu. 00
S~E s-.= c q. EM 0 0
' ) E E. .
_ *0 II 00
C ~ Cu .~ E~*~!Cu ~ COC
00
04.
- -
so
(I) 0
0 E0
U) 0
goom 0=10 g0 w> I MI NF v
IIII
oo . co 0
m Ia0f CoC) !
- I
= I
~r
a.): as.. )LL Mm
IcIcc
a. CCOCL*Cal) cc~(j
0 (D ) CC
E!
(D!a) 0. 0)2 C
IEI
LUU
LU-0
LU11.1.2
2E0 0. ccc L
2~E cm 0omt 0 c c4% u
III
aCA0 II
C. 0 0 •
CD C0
- 4.' 3- Q
0 .- '
-. 1m o
cct Cg .. 2
. .o -2 c.c .
C.U r- o * :U .. _.
. .% CD 0
0)c ..9o ~E)LC
C0 00a0
C C L
4- z , %- 4) Co' CL.
0a 0 0 0Vio ~ ~~~~ an2~UC -
(D ) C CC 0)V.24
0 Je B. CD) C. 2 0'0 al a =.C aU~ a.C4-' 0) Cc CcWU ~
C 0) CIa)C a) 0 C
0 ~ ~ *OL cc E ccaj~ ~0
0~ >vO~J-~
E a 0 I4.0 1
cc r 'r
CC
ICc
6C a
Es 0 .0 801
-9 M0 CC
cc W2.m E T0 *a. 0 C
0 C- 0)0 05I- ~~ .- E 6 6 .5ia =m~
LU Cm 'iw CJ C 0 2eelown 0 6 .z I
Va *u a-~ 0U
S 01
= 0 v
00
C.-L
0 UC C FOc 0_
o *.acU c I-
.2 0 0) 0rI Ccc
e 0.)
E-C
0= 0.c G (1)Cf=
0 a S0on
00) CO
Cl) ( c r -r 0* LIw ( c d@ 4
0:5 - m )4"as CDM 12 -T 8-F I% W;a 0 o),) 2 o U
LUL
ILo
I I
III
Ur) a cS
U) as'- L = 3cc C -0 E~0
0 DU_C,) CD0~
.E= S E '0 c 0 4 0CCL (D I->. C O QD O w -.
o" z o .cn. V 0Is Itu LM 0
o 0.2 0 0 CX> .c0
EIas .( 00mw--0*r
E:* cr4 LI) r .€:'-C' 0 .,. 8 )= 7 o cc0 Cc CU 0 3 1
cis o 0 E-0:)
.Av - 0 ) o3.= 05=lo-1( 0 0~0 'aL 3
o--,00)-.,.. ... .C I:
0~ cc2 oSo
0 wIOa 0 Cc 0.0 a)~o 0
l. -o i--0..0 3. ccis m *C CI):3 > (DI(D " r -0 W
m c.2*. cs ts:m oco U
Iz
I z
Ic0 U)
z
III
~I
CL cx C0 . .0
~~>
a) ca
o. CD
0 CO I
de 0
L 0 Ch
c o 5ca C/)
CO 5AO *~co
.0 C0u 0 V
0 Cu 0 0 2
o!0) C!
* '0C (
'C _
-0 =Cc 0
0o 0
0 0 c
* Roec 0
IC
III
0 U)
-~ 0
0~d 0
0-- .0 0C _
I-. CU .U"0,
U)0) A3t
CL' 0 Q. cc
mo ct ct-- c-0.' "> -_ a >mL-cco 72 coa Cu
0-:o 0 E o . -o=U ocm 0 con-o0)C0 4 ) )
o ,.. .. >a -- 3 ,160 o- a >%E o-wc *2E U.Sc r4)0 CD "2
0) Ch- .: 0 S
_. . 0r : c--
o c C> 0 % 04
cc 0' E r- Ema ccc) >
C 00 0 E* .5)CGa 4 -0 C ZCD.5 > Eoe0) cL- E 0- 02
(0 0mm
III
I
0 U3 U-R 0
I SI
'0 C
0
0
I0 cc0 08
I cc a
cc 0
III
0 UCuCCu Ix
IU)o I2
-oI I
00)o 1cuC0U)o U
I~ .0
0"0 IC U)
0 I- Cu
U)0 IU) I
mmq) I-
mm~
~bmm'heUrn I
mm
~ I
UU
0 ) 0
00du c 0 1
0 C 0ui I
C 0m
0 .0C a) 2
-0 cr
0
Cc C
* 0 Co
- 0)
0 .6
0)4 c 00I
II
I
cc 0
0: C° 0)
>i,,
" ® vo
mo
OM€:
00
0'r "0 ='3-,0Oo 0
.c I
_ro. 02.
VI
Loo 5OR c
CO C . a.
CD0
C 0 SD
cDc ZCDC
0 Cd
go 0cc
In 0 El
Ccm UC 0 mcm C-
0)3
0 0 C0000
CD 0
0 cc
Lu C 0go
@j Lu cc
U) 00 0 0
0 .o La z -
alOs Lu
z N uz
.0-
£OL0>
0) CM 0 M C
a j C) CIS0 *c *- >
ao CD) >%- 0 0a
o8 0
.0. W.C
0) E
0coVs 0 CD20
~n0 coC 0C
L.. 0 L0o)
Q0
0 ~ E.C0 2a Q000
(1) o ~ cts0)" ,.aCO) cs = ) CIa) E 2 Oc 0.-IV) L- M c0 4) ) co -.c
cc o 0 0in 0 0C 0 to o cl c C#I CF
Cc E TMTMTMto 4
c ON rLI LL U!
cI w
co 0
I I-
.0
0 cccoL o
E)00
LL E0I
0~(
) as0~0
o N
CD
0)CS
oo r(0O
co C
0L
4) C 4 ) cm (
0 z.
0.0
75 00 = E 0 0
E CD 0 c
Mm -0E0U
o E 04- 0
E ) L4)0
cc a))'D
4) CD)
w E 00
00o CCc
Z3 *c :c- 0%* cc a C Cl) E 4
GE E p i.m.E -
oL w
0~ :cjKE C D *,)n~..so c C;-0 ICLI
..I.. j ............. .. *
*: :.U.:~I VaC.LL. ... '....... ..
I 114
IIJ
III
o0 x o C ,
E > 0) ) QUO) CL
a) C ACUro-
~ cE
u <.c 2I"- C DV . - .- x u rC
0 C , 0 m
I
"d -Q-- CDe::00
-c 3: -EL I
a 0 -- es == -
,, )o 8 , .:-,c o 'oo ooo cc
c0 *_* -@zO 3I] ):
(D!
I
0 m : C c
EI>,r E(,DI
Uu
L 2lILlIz
LuIIj
4:1
IT LOU o
IC _
W 000X ) (1) c
-0
o 0 0 -o.! 0 >
cmU 0-Cl) >0E
E 0fl8 0 UUacr.P4 c 0~ o*0
Co ) (
0.9 P0 -- -00a9
o 4) Co M c UX
CL .C - 0 0 .cc E ts *0 CD C0> a)4E
E ~ -0 w *USco ) 0 L0 Coooo >- ) co L-.V
w E _Do .cmC 0 CD cc0 0 .~ C.S
0 *C 00 ) ~0C E 0
0)CO
CU CoL~ E0 > 0-05 $~ 0
0 ~~ 0.UC 0C2j wS u cusci -~~ S o
0 0 - "0 MoMq)~ 0-CC- Cc,.0
ao (Do S?, cE -0 0IC4 m 0I
%% A
-~ -Ir~. 9 if;
Ii:I000
Iie
00
I 0 00 so o 01mm *so l 0~ 0 S 0
1 00 * * 00 00' 0
1 0 0 0 ..40 00 00
0 0 0 0.. SUA 0000 %I
I 0 -r 00 I0
I000 0041I0 00 .0'o 00'%
I
ImI0I
cisLUU2I
*0
01)
mr IQ
C I
.3Mmj__
Lu -I
.mm . J...I..... .....
I~Ll
jj
0 v
0 >.0C 0D M_ :
LLV 75
.C0o E c 004 - c C 1 -4 0 -10 2
E.- 00 t c
(a0Cl 000 0,
>~0 m0 0 0 caco2 NL2C'
Cd U- 0 - cx
00
CD q) 0 =,. =c
g? > 0~c' cm 0On 0 >%I.s
CD0 000 00
0 *-~c c CDEC
-0 ~ ~ -CCCE0 c 0 EM 0WO 0
>.o~ ca 0A> *-wo %*o no~ C.
CO > 00 OV _00) AIC6 Cf 0 C
-"4--
5u
N~b5 S0. -iCO
~ a a
~,Io N
al Le _w
II
6- I
S~ CAEOU4~
7@ ?:' COLC
E Do .co> : 03
.. o "o' 0 cca: E m:. v >
= *- 75
& o a E 0.- 2 Wm't =04 co "_Z
V~-zTs W Ui0 o ) ac cI- C 0.: 0 .01 .
Cc~ 3rE
7a E o ,-.1 m _
0o 0~~. 0oa- OC C- ::3 i:EE0
00 C -
- E m .
cc 0. E - 0 0 -- S ?
I
wcm=
0 0E ccc0 CoO
,,0 2 cc 0.)
s w 0CD D 0I
._ '-, o , .0 .8aICL 4"I
cc 0 CL E C
uj ftCfa
00 CL 0l%
060
I
U) c
E) 0*0 > a,
r- E as24)-01 C I
.O.
) E) ) "0
S.0 0 C: w 0 .r
e CDcc E I
j5 ) E :3 -a
(1) 3Z t :: 02: _
a) as.:=.:
E C 0E0fCUDO CD ~ 3
0 r . , , C 'l)m " W
> CL C Ia.-40 -->CD EC
A 4.0 3
0 c- c o 0-* . lC
CD0
> ' - m._,J t. C ""I
_>,.o- m® v .'
z
S I
(I) Ih1j I iii
4 U I~IL~ I
~mE) 0
II
L mm - mmii
-
0IL IiI ImmmlLua.mu -~ 4
ifI4
III
C I
U)I
CuI
L.. I- I
Ic
C4)
III
co) IEoCo
=. 0:c O I
cZc
.0
E c _ I
F-' = in
CrCD
CJ) I
C) 0)oa.! Io on 7@
(D = 0) C)
E C
L C Ch r-w rI
TIFE (0) c
III __________________________________
II
(3
I aII** 0
e~q~I O, -c
-
* I
/I ZQ:I I/I I
ujiII __________________________________
I 1~ ~
s~e~qOt~ p jeqwn~
III
o.
0C 10 o~l- I20 0
0n Io(D() _
E~ E 3'Ma..~ c C~
0S f. 0 -r-
CL 00
a09
(D 0)LO E. 5
m E C D 40
C0
= u) CoCoa"0
) 1
IIC
co~Lo
Ie4iol 0m n
I
ca''I
.0 0-
II
I I I I I I I I
E IZ 0o
VI
ILL-
.* 7
9JBuLAj pold 10 j~qmnN
II
I0
CL=u
~I
Co ca
E
0 I.0.
00C Cl)
) 0
I
EE >=(D E
C) 0 Co> dC E
0 .9) 0 Etf CD 0
ccVcU) 5
CDo.- 0M to0. c"
CD~O e% .rU-O 0
0.0
IleVI
C)
*IT
sepJoS tKoddnS puni~
I
0, 0
I
c) 0 E cI
.> ." E - ,.. ..
w .,=w €: .
-- ) c .0 "=0 ..W , a., c, =
MC-o 3 '
.a.. _ .Ow ._ .
0 - ,.
= 0) U)o 0- C#)m -- - 0 1
oEI-I
E, 0vE
a,) ~O lia~caw 4-Eo
0 M0
0 iU.r a)
CL 0. aC 0 COM40
0CL I 4~~~.1 c ma,a -0 cc~ Ia
CD ~~~ ~ / 0 )>-- :c.>U b- 2CS 'aIc
o C"--- >
CIO (I*-- < -0) C
a U* Ua U
* UCD
* U
a U* CD
Ia Ia I
a I
a N
am
0* I
04,3 a s"N~LAj
I
o S II
-~________________________
(n~i) peou~py eouu~a
EE
0
C V
c C
> 08
C0) C) mvCU- 0)" 0)
> *Ca
C Ioo 0
.~.
C -zCUCu g _ 0 .
a: CO
4 0SP
ccI
ca)
S I
(m IIu.pvwm~
II
I'5 3
I
E28C DU
E) >0
cCu 0o 3
CL
(ID
>
o 0 I
0
Cl)s0
C/)>u
oE0 w
en
Z0
Ib ctS 4 5io1 4iUinoL
sesr e-u~wn
EI
CL
E
00
CD
ol Co S?
0 O)
0
75 CEf
III a~3~
I B* S* 6I S I* SI S I* S* S I* S* S II SI S
I S g '~\ '* S I* S* S II S gCD* S __* S I* S II S* S I* SI * S I
* SS S I* S
S S I
0 I S* S I* So S SI S I* So 5 5 I
* So~3u5~ * S
SS
* I IS-S* I 0S * -~*Ii \\ 1~* *H
a-~:* S0 S S S
.*~ * S I* S SI
SI0 I j'I I I-
'5'
'II S
S SS S
I S
0I9O9SO~ e~~jnwn~
III
CL
0
Eo 0
E IC ) 4
C',
0l) M)
L
E
1 0
co0Ig u
0-h L
Iesr m~wr
CLIEI
0)
EcaC L
0 0
0)
S 0
0)1co
> .
CIOE C
- .- - - - - '-~w 7 ~- ~ -~
.2 %2 2
SS
S SS S 9'5 0
9'S SS S 9'5 5S S 9'S S9' 9'
S SS S 9'' SS S 9'S S9' S 9'
S S5 5 9'S SS SS S55 94 Co
S SS SS SS S
\S
'S 9'55 ~('3
LLJ S SS Sw.. S S'5 9'''9' t~5
oCu SS~ 9'
b '' 9'V*~-. '' 9'\S~ 9'"9'''9' a
55 5 SI S
5555 9'Cu ;SS 9'" 9'
E'S 9'55
cm) S.' i'5 9'~S9' I-
SS
9' SS9' SS
S
0
9Q99O~ e~nwn~
II
000l 0) ILCUC
it E 0) I
0 L .92 0.1 .-1.
0- -m -- "- (1)* 7
W 0C 0 _ Cod 0cc.1
eD 2 ,,- 0 0
0_) U)a )(cc 0 E E " EL-.~ co 0 -
-.3-c-O-_- _ .oi 2.. -,- o .~ 0) I0 0 cc. U
o .- 3,_ c _0o
_ 0V- * c o '
=~ >I t o. o o0 0
Cl -~E C, ) .. '
,4 0 0 *-0 00
CiC
00
- 0%...0CCfLO C
>a0 . , Mo
mEa M Icait 0 0 o. -
ow
E|
q0
01
CD VL
9e.€o3 p~oddns punloJ9 fe
• mml11
II
I
I0 C6
oc0
COCL 0
C LD
0Co
Z 2..C_
(,, _E
o a-c
. . I
0 16
.2c
.0
CO)
7E t.U2
z
C
w
ssBOnfS jo AP.;~qqOJd Aweu3
II
E 2I
c E=
COV;
Co'.60 ( C:
> o=E I
) a . I
-- / Ia cca
c E o Ia),A
aas
0 0)C 0
E~~ a,4- a ,," 2
0 0 Iao_ IIo = o_
II
LU .
.. ....-. ...
Iz.......
..........K 7 ...... .... .. .... ..lX,......
.......
LU -
0j A! 1x4......iA ........... ijJX
...i ............. ... ... ..L ..... ... .... ....
x
.0.... ..
......... .. ...... .J
.~~ . ........ ......
4. .............. l -.. U
UJ CL lo~w E* m!
III
"t4'a I,.) a ,) , I)coo
0 aC
ui. 'a)ca: -0'o .- 3ccI
>O a
OS- 00 _o0o
@-0 E ° (a) CD
"" " .- : .F . C,
a) X IM
E V a cao
I
W I~
E!
MU-(D CO "a2cE C L- I
gcm IF c2COa o (c E5
LUI2 v I0---20.0cc &
uju
cc 0
IL U
3R.
1LL 0 lI La12
II
CD10
-to
r- Ca:, -.
U €) I
CU~
L0 4) I-C_ I
o o
uco
CL (>1
=E= Ico10
cc Z%
9 0.
00.
.r %I.-
I'I
I)LL
100
Ap W-0
cil
Cu
IL cI
m) 00I
< L
6 0 C
0) Io o _
mm U S
IN
33I1
.. .... ... .. ... . ... .. . -- --
4-a
*A S
< wC
A.%% 101
Av(J)ljS I-o-t
i
C Ic
2 C
Cl I- I
O.E
~I
OiLi
4-' IL .. !1I
00
'0
C
l0a) 4-'.l
l
co
00
Q5"
CAS
>S
_ .
S........................................................... .......
4.L481~ .rV-01-.nV q11o::3
II
"RI
4) 1"o
°,- a> I
4 .(D C
- 3o( 1 I
CIOE 6= > CL.' CD
CI- I0 .-W ") .c: (D.
CfC2 - o I)
0 .C- I-
Ii I
• .
II
1),
C,
II IqAlJnS I -OM-Jr l e
/ .l~ .S Y . o
cnh
00)
CC
00.
0) 1,C))T
a)0) 16 EI
LuU ... j.. .. ............ ... ...
..w .....
LU >
LL.
4 .......
'm m ... .....
UII
E II
oI-
° IC,, I
0) a 2I
CA C 0
(D0) I
Cc~ c M .- |
(D i-I.r UC)0)
W COM) :0I
C
CC
0 'Cc cis000
.U0 0cc) S
2l 0 .
.00000
mL C C
~~0 E."
:N ~ CL a
pilEnO cc
co jo E0.
C~) nC 0 0 MOWC
ho 4) EC 218 I..
- '0 C0L
9C 0
006 a ~
III
a)-owfl4..d cUU)
E E CD
• -.- 0 :3 0 CMJ
U/) . -) E.
0_
i) c,.o I,~~~ o5 a) =,, --
.5 IV ) w.- l
,cU,, O. OC
.a) . as -a) 0 " '
0 r v
SA- - O- '(D CD o E E
-E p " 0 = u) CD -
S. a) _ r r- O n
jE=-=°°-o-S I
_ ,- (a CM =- -
,2 ct - - --- c - -(s ) v
E ( CI
II
.4b.
'mmmlS~o~o~Cc
3EZ
EI.U c
0 cE
0 1.
U Eo 0.2'
CC _
Co C EIA.a a
0 -
com
q)::)
mU
0I
• • , ., I;2..- r-.
0 E
C C
E VI
F- E_)CD O
00
0 0;a:
0n
6o
lz~a c;
WR" .)
0;
Co
Lfl
PGBS 1461M Adw3
U) cU
IoI
- ;
-0 0 .
._ • N --CO
CC .0 1 0: )
E ) a E 1)E 0- C
B 2coQE OT
CD CfOcG
C D(D c c" c$
0 ) 0ID!= - ,
m o '
co * rmm w
I
E c cd '5
a00
CD~
CDD
00
0 0
0 ~ C u -
"00
cmr- 4- 0 Cu E
0 0 00 t.0 CL j
UJEE EC5 EIL, u 4) CD
C
(D Cu..-' 0
0 0
CDW* 0
0IEI0I
-2'O-E
a) 0 0-a)U
E
I- a)Co IEE I
CDC 3: a CI
CDE'tato m IC 4..'04(D
-t
F E
1~1-0 (VrLLX~ i %)-ML e
Ea S
.~.il
C ,. ...........................
.1,__ S _
i 'a
2 .'
Cu'-ra, 1i
aI
( sruujxxgflo %) sn'Ujyl. jea
E ) Ea)
a)aE
0)C)
CC
EI~~r (D2
OC
*C6 .0. -(
>. 'm .0 U(i)
0 (a
(f4-) ICoI
CDjEE
* -£
CD
(1461M #4dwa jo c/) genj iqea
Ii
U)
U) U)
a o Iz O'C
> I
E ) i0 J
mEo cEc E
Cu cu I
o . "c 0
U) I
~ ~Eo
a) OC6j
mo E
IE S0I= I
... ... .. .. ..
u
o ..........- .. ...
..
.ml . .........
.. .... .. .. ....0. ....
... ... .... .. ... .... ... ... ...
.. ..... ....
zU
z0I
LL
zI0U
H/z/I
I
0 co'.- 0 a ) cam i , Coo a) _ E
., . CC CC- ,
M-- a) wo) CC' Q- 0 --
I
• " ",a) -.- = ;o .0 . >
?mi a a) aC
>%5O E .6c >ca
-0 MS .. -O.
o 0c
0 -- 2 D ,- C 1 Sal).
cc . r- (L
Il
~~a) -0 c
CD CU(D CD 5'd
CD=-
0~C C D0..
CD 0 o C D CR Coo
0 US E 3:oa)L
ts 0 to~a
S."U CO- c7
I) cem @ C *_c
EI =M1c
I. -uw oa
.0
Cu;
LIC I
CO~LO LoIcpai Ioe kw
ib
Q-.J
co..... . .................... .. ... ... . ....... ...
EI
' w
oii
Apl.el Jjy-o-J.V elea
I
I
) I
........................ ... .............
q) * w
/ ,30!
tz
_LU S IS - ------ -~- e- --- -- ---- A
15 .9I
I I
I
• II
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
a) I
;* .l I 0 K "
co '-- - - -- --- -- -- -- -- -- --
2~
2
z
se uoddnS PunOJ N
-77TM77U
coI
I - - -- - - - -
....... r** ............51c0 1
AM U
ssonS p0 AvtlqoJw AWuJ~u5
sa)0)
0 U
Cl)O
co N 0.0'
oil.
c)
.00)
ssGOnfS AwOu3 0O Al4tqKqod
77
tLILUU
zI0IzI
L I
0
I.-
CD)C/)I
Cc
-- Q LU" . 0)_ :
o~ ~ C >' ' ){aO.,:o Cc mc
L.) >- P*- w" "CL -0 E c0 wco)m' •3
E- 0) , -a) to 2 0 '0 Uc EE 0CcL~ 2E jo
> -- >,OuLZ
R2 C
00
,.V € 0 ( c u.> _.. -C. u- 0 ca 7Z 0Z
n Cc0 ~ co
.-. E. a:-._ u .co 0 ==
E - C0) 0 0"a
E :~0O'~cc
0 0--c.(a -0
E (D 0
III
Ep I
....... a.................. ... .................... a............... P T:L.= , IC. ' Ic a. I I
FaE" LI .o, i
-C"-
-2- 1 5 0l
(isju. xen jo o/) isruq.I. qea
I I
aQ) I
I S ICu II I" /I
~i
HU !
;it LC
I S
I
0 .0S1!rS
Arre~pq jiv-om-JNrv uiea
II
a I* I
Co~
~I
22~I
CMu
I
o I.
SA II IIi
Ii I = i I l l li lllml i f l ll l dI
CD -- -- ---
0) M
00 1
b b
Sk/g
(Ie-kIu:jl )le.I (
* I•
I
I
.* I
I
UI
IC0
SI 4
I 0
,0
E
E E
III ,
II.2aI S A
Ii~S S
UL
II :0
9I
o0 S0
_ .
1411qeAvin i.-l ir.
II
I
I I;
g I
Olt 0
,±----------, - ----------
z i
Isepos lioddns PUflojE ION I
IL
CD~
trio.Isn 10AIqmdAU
UUUIII
-
I
'Ii II
"I I(I)~ I
III
~II
Iz
I zI0
L
I-I z
II
E 0
CO
0 Cc 0J)8
Y. M 0
40 >
E CC
CD ) CL _2 _
CL *E CL a
(D 00 : 0o w =w
Co 00 0C ww10 wcURE*t 0) C
CL 3.C Mo C U
Oha.
MeUIw%~ s~uBj eniq pO J~qnN
0
el
sco go
sIa
so
Sc
S I1~- 0
S M 0 .W)w
0.C
a)a
cm
-0*0
OW *"I
( a -)
0050): U c
Wa)
-I
I~CL
M."T
. .. ....
......... .
!::j: - x
........ . .
LA..
UJU
0(o r
LL. I
-o .0 tun) I)"a c )0) o o(
Q ) I.) _a o
> 005
-o .0 E as>-) :) -6 I
a) ct 00 '
> >,2u - . ._,
00o ooE L.SEo
- 0- Iz 7E - Z I *'"
a) O> Cc. 0
(D E 4
>
- .O a . 30 C
a~ 0,(U co C >
C Wu
iU
I
U-
LE0
C
SsOOnS AWSU3 P AftqBqW d
0>
*cu> ID
.)
>0
CU)as c
*~'0
Cl C
E E
CD
Z 0)Ea) C
> =WwSm
>IU)I
> 0I
0)
to ca
0
ON)
In
NLQVl) V1, U Ipeouu~p ePqejeV GIRuAYAnb3
C
CL0
0 cCD/
C L00
> CL)
E
Q1) 0
0
I C4 6NU.
(a)0 uwoGG 83WJ
II+ I
I a "a
s-c_
4 D
cc0
> W._ II
c . r0)
.. E. I
c!
II
C.3 C(D.S
> a= 0 1
a)
u 2! 0)
rl. I-0v )U
IL
I3I1
IC
I _ B'
Lb 6 thpjojV PWMW ICM!-AV ln2
I
0.0
(D - 0
0i. oVL
cis 0 ) *t c t
,.., 0 0 C
a 0 a .0
w E= (A E II
0 0
.a _ 4.,.. 1- ,0
o .R> .0 IE 0 ,, 0 m 0c
CL 0 a ' O 0. .0 o&
00 I, .a.0 o. _ (a E- ,oo_E 0 0,... ? 0%le
0 (0 ci (00
C 1 -' ---)kn' 0 O0(3_*o AT m .C ._
.,,,.= = 0 - o -I0 E 0 ' C 00
o CL Ecl$ 0)2
0L 0 ti~ + ca 0 0IM CO 0 4) _ - C - c010CD 0 CD~
C D 0 D 6' & .4 C 0. C4-&-0 ~ ~CD (D 0 -. 00o
00
CL 78 E I I !
_-L OCu0 co< 00. 2?-0) rL )0
M ~ '' z~ 0 ccC
Vs0~. 0o* 2! 1
= 0~S 2 Q 0 11! 0 -9 E
3-
IL
II
I** II.(as) o vi~udoea u3 w0
2Co CDI)7.0-0 G ) -o - 0) cc EI
r - -0 > x ccu10) CL E 0 0 0 ccD
T) EE..) UJ 0 0 al
= . 0 u-.0. cn 0>
~~AiM CfLfC, 0)
.2tE cc 0. 0a0 0 Cll
q.j-d0 ch 0)Ccn U.
(D- a) >,(L -
E co0 % OAU -u oCD M
CD Co .0-0' 0ca
~ co 0 ) E Cco o' 0 c.0~ wW o- .~~
I- r, " >%- 0)
,0~ 00a)
00D 0 (DI0- E r 0I
IjCcI
ImL- am
0 c ccCo 0
02 0
0 E0
LU 0.U 0 wCc = Oha
m~ 00.0c
woo~ Ccau .
cc -0 c
a a 0- ~~C 0 40
E 0~
s . C -J 0C
C 0
.200 0 accS 0 1;
=~ ~ %.0= C 0L *
00 0 0 Xc
-o 0L 0
FE U
-. .- •-.*. - , ,
aO CDto_ = o
iom a ,_..C& ."--- :uJ :: c u .A- C)/) (
ua~ ". 0) wigu "i
0_~ m - o 0 CIS ej Cc='<
0 ~EE~c 0
CDr_ -0M_ 'r_ C ;E' r - g- -- 0 0 (D---
.V5- to x-Wzi oo>
C CU
0_ 3 "6- E 0 0 CD 0" E-"10 .- z ?® w f==.I
: 0 -a <-
-E m j.(D 0.0 a).~
> 0'.,C,_CD_ d o O-
78~~e E= % CLEcc
a)- - 0.o . .Cl 00 Z5 ClQ *u.C
0 ~t0 0.w E0
Cu CO ,) _ -r_ U >. 0 . LEl 0 E n u C0 co CU 0
0 g E0) 0m~~ Cc) E
0. ~ 0 D , C q)CLto -
(D 0 c0 Em
I
m wI II
00
_c 0
Cu ca
iRc-- 0u
c .E 0 4
E 5&0 a Lsm9 0 0-0 C 0E-
0 cc a E
v CLC, Ia am-Ia
c CL
0 'jjE -1oOa XOw 'e*
260 c
La left~
C 2
- 0"9 I
.0 0 C
._ ..:= > "0 ;aI&.o'-0-0 ,U "amo C
cr 0
Ca._.- *O., a.,- .,. " ,
E- I
ca)
~0 0
S 0 o 5 T.
.=mca:.o Cc CD
CC
..CoC .o0 0-3
2) CD a)L
CLC
om~ ~~ 0 0 C CC. 2 - c . % >.0 (A OaU -0) (1 U
0.0 con~ Cot2' r 3:
-0 C -0 CD~
EI
... I>,C 0- l. 0 V c
0 0
-5 0 CE 0 CU
lI *a
0
c 0o 6=*x 0
E aS °
8e
E c
0 ..aI 0. 0
b0 a
= ~ itoL 02
00 *me .6
CL 0O M 0
I--z
-J
C/)I
U)
CL
c
-C0
0 C
C 0or0
0-
C.)
CZ
0 U
CuL
*Ic_ 0JC 0CC
0 0 e 0
E cc
*a
0 q
c 0.90 o0 0 2CLU E -
cc E' -- ca)LU 0~ aY' 0Cr a) r- )O
00 0 -W
000 CL 0 C >%IM =) C. a ..-
a)cI E w eow4
0)00~~~ 0 'EL 2C~. E 2 C CE8~~I 8i 8'0 CL a
0 S 05 E 0 0c CV 00 04
0
0oE0 E- o
000
0 E CL0
cc 06
tA c *00 c s~0 ~ 0E-~0 4
3~ I.. 4(is0L 0
c cc [E00~ cc 0.cc
o00* E Cm O
0 -a
U 0 a C-
0 '~0 0~
(I~~: 000 6.0.C L 0 C c J wh
to c * C c 0
0 0. 0L
C E
LL1LUUiI
z
w
zI
0nI-
IIII II
1 (1)III (3UIIIIIUI
LUU
4)
CLal
(L) -iC ,)I
a0
4 -) I)0
I~~C C; 0000 CS 00
*0
(I 00 CL . O R 0100m
0 0 an0 '"aa 00a
I 000o 000
as C. c 2 C
C,, tcr &o a 0
'aaa 00 -. 0 a-~I0 Lo o.
IJ u LMo 0MDRaRcm C* l el 1R v "Vn ISI; 0c ;C
TNI
E~~ 0 0) e
*0
CO
0 ID
U 0
x 04
M O).Ca.I
>00
(D0) )
mmo
ZZI. < (Ica 0 V
lkI
ccI
Lu
Lu LU
CD C
4) 4) . IL
c~ c
0.,0yC4) cc
6h 0
cd co 4)
.CL
N- U Im V coIS.m
Im to
MI
. 0 It) so C4
I~c C5 Nc)iC;) *i
O 0>0 -:8~ ~
100
ILO
0 o
Ij U) . a
o o Ic0
_ IP
0) ciC D0)c a:*
< I.a 0
I.- 4 - ,
cc
0) ccU5,
U) mo nCx) (T IE
LL C C
cooo'
Zl U)co
Q ~ 00 0 ccMO
LUU
Cl) in-'
14 LLN mN N m
OF