fiscal policy topics 1 sources of federal revenue and expenditures expansionary and contractionary...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Fiscal policy topics Sources of Federal revenue and expenditures Expansionary and contractionary fiscal policy Spending multiplier Tax multiplier Automatic stabilizers Budget deficits and the national debt Long-term issues
2
Federal revenue
3
Federal revenue Three largest sources:
Individual income tax Social security tax Corporate income tax
Top three combined account for 89% of federal revenue
4
Income tax Individual income tax is a progressive tax:
Individuals with larger incomes pay a larger percent of income in tax
Individuals with smaller incomes pay a smaller percent of income in tax
Some individuals pay no tax, some have a negative tax rate
5
Income tax Income tax due is based on taxable
income. To arrive at taxable income, start with
your income and subtract deductions and exemptions.
One exemption is allowed for each person
6
Income tax Example: Sheila is a single person with
an income of $50,000
Gross Income
$50,000
Standard deduction
-$6,200
Exemption -$3,900
Taxable income
$42,900
7
Income tax How much federal income tax does
Sheila pay?
8
Income tax brackets
Income Thresholds
Taxable
income
Marginal tax rate
Tax
Up to $9,075 $9,075 10% $907$9,076-$36,900
$27,825 15% $4,174
$36,901-$89,000 $6,000 25% $1,500
$42,900
$6,581
Sheila pays $6,581 in federal income tax
9
Income tax Sheila’s average tax rate : $6,581 / $50,000 =
13.2% Sheila’s marginal tax rate is 25%
She would pay 25% tax on any additional income
10
Federal expenditures
11
Federal expenditures Four largest sources:
Medicare and Medicaid Social security National defense Income security
Top four account for 83% of federal expenditures. Medicare and Medicaid is the fastest growing component.
12
Expansionary and contractionary fiscal policy What is the correct fiscal policy for
A recession? An inflationary period?
Recession: Increase government spending, and/or Cut taxes
Inflation: Cut government spending, and/or Increase taxes
13
Recessionary gap
Real GDP
Price level
SRAS0
Y*
LRAS0
AD1
Y1
P1 A
Recessionary Gap
14
Expansionary fiscal policy
Real GDP
Price level
SRAS0
Y*
LRAS0
AD1
Y1
P1 A
AD2
BP2
Increased government spending can pump up aggregate demand
15
Expansionary fiscal policy
Suppose the output gap is $200 billion. How much would government spending need to increase to close the gap?
Use the spending multiplier:
∆Y = * ∆G
Assume MPC = 0.7
16
Expansionary fiscal policy
$200 billion = * ∆G
$200 billion = * ∆G
∆G = $200 billion / 3.3 = $60.6 billion
17
Expansionary fiscal policy
Government spending would need to rise by $60.6 billion to cause output to increase by $200 billion.
Consumption spending accounts for most of the increase in output.
18
Linkages – expansionary fiscal policy
Increased government spending or lower taxes
Aggregate demand increases
Output rises
Unemployment rate falls
Spending multiplier
19
Expansionary fiscal policy
What if the government cut taxes instead of increasing government spending?
How much would tax revenue need to be reduced?
We must use the tax multiplier to find out.
20
Tax multiplier
∆Y = * ∆T
T = tax revenue
21
Tax multiplierExample: We want output to rise by $200 billion. How much would tax revenue need to decline?
$200 billion = * ∆T
22
Tax multiplierExample: We want output to rise by $200 billion. How much would tax revenue need to decline?
$200 billion = -2.33 * ∆T
∆T = $200 billion / -2.33 = -$85.8 billion
Taxes would need to be cut by $85.5 billion.
23
Government spending and tax revenue
We have found that to increase output by $200 billion we could
Increase government spending by $60.6 billion, or
Cut taxes by $85.5 billion.
Why aren’t these figures the same?
24
Government spending and tax revenue
Y = C + I + G + NX
If government spending rises by $1, how much does output rise immediately?
25
Government spending and tax revenue
Y = C + I + G + NX
If government spending rises by $1, output rises by $1. Government spending is a direct component of aggregate demand.
26
Government spending and tax revenue
Y = C + I + G + NXC = a + b(Yd)
If taxes are cut by $1, how much does output rise?
27
Government spending and tax revenueY = C + I + G + NXC = a + b(Yd)
If taxes are cut by $1, output rises by $1*MPC. Taxes affect aggregate demand indirectly.
28
Contractionary fiscal policySuppose the economy is suffering from high inflation. Output is higher than potential output and unemployment is very low.
Assume the inflationary gap equals $80 billion in output.
The government can reduce the output gap by cutting government spending (or increasing taxes).
29
Inflationary gap
Real GDP
Price level
SRAS0
Y*
LRAS0
AD1
Y1
P1 A
Inflationary Gap
30
Contractionary monetary policy
Real GDP
Price level
SRAS0
Y*
LRAS0
AD1
Y1
P1 A
Inflationary Gap
AD2
P2 B
Cuts in government spending can reduce aggregate demand
31
Expansionary monetary policy
The inflationary gap is $80 billion. How much would investment spending need to decrease to close the gap?
∆Y = * ∆G
Assume MPC = 0.7
32
Contractionary fiscal policy
$80 billion = * ∆G
$80 billion = * ∆G
∆G = $80 billion / 3.3 = $24.2 billion
Government spending would need to be cut by $24.2 billion to cause output to decline by $80 billion.
33
Contractionary fiscal policyQuestion: how much of a tax increase would be needed to reduce output by $80 billion? Assume the MPC = 0.7
34
Contractionary fiscal policyQuestion: how much of a tax increase would be needed to reduce output by $80 billion? Assume the MPC = 0.7
Answer:
-$80 billion = * ∆T
∆T = -$80 billion / -2.33 = $34.3 billion
Taxes would need to increase by $34.3 billion
35
Linkages – contractionary fiscal policy Cuts in
government spending or
increased taxes
Aggregate demand
decreasesOutput
decreasesPrice level declines
Spending multiplier
36
Balanced budget multiplierSuppose increased government spending is balanced by an equal increase in tax revenue. What is the effect on output?
37
Balanced budget multiplier
∆Y = * ∆G = 3.3 * $10 billion = +$33 billion
∆Y = * ∆T = -2.3 * $10 billion = -$23 billion
38
Balanced budget multiplier
∆Y = * ∆G = 3.3 * $10 billion = +$33 billion
∆Y = * ∆T = -2.3 * $10 billion = -$23 billion
+$33 billion -$23 billion = +$10 billion net gain
The balanced budget multiplier equals one.
39
Question 56Suppose I pay $15,000 income tax on a taxable income of $100,000. Therefore, my marginal tax rate is 15%.A) TrueB) False
40
Question 57To increase output by $50 billion, how much would taxes have to be cut? Assume the MPC = 0.8Cut in taxes: $____ billion (leave out the negative sign)
41
Question 58To increase output by $50 billion, how much would government spending need to increase? Assume the MPC = 0.8Increase in government spending: $____ billion
42
Fiscal policy issues
Conclusion: in the short-run, fiscal policy can shift aggregate demand in the desired direction.
Three problems arise that cause complications.
43
Fiscal policy issues
1) Crowding out
2) Timing and policy lag
3) Negative supply shocks
44
Fiscal policy issues
Crowding out - occurs when increased government spending results in less private spending
Two cases: how is the government spending paid for?
1) Higher taxes or2) More borrowing?
45
A) Government spending funded by taxes
If government spends $100 million on new highways and increases taxes by $100 million, does net spending increase?
It depends – would the private sector have spent the $100 million?
46
A) Government spending funded by taxes
If the private sector would have spent most (90%) of the $100 million, then the impact of $100 million in government spending would be very small.
47
A) Government spending funded by taxes
But what if confidence is low, and the private sector would NOT have spent most of the $100 million.
In this case, the impact of $100 million in government spending would be much larger.
Expansionary fiscal policy is effective when the private sector is afraid to spend money.
48
B) Government spending funded by borrowing
If government spends $100 million on new highways paid for by borrowing, does net spending increase?
The public purchases more ($100 million) government bonds and fewer private bonds.
49
B) Government spending funded by borrowing
If the private bonds would have funded new factories, then investment spending falls.
Also, interest rates rise when the government sells bonds, causing additional decline in investment spending.
50
B) Government spending funded by borrowing
What if the private sector would not have invested the money in new plant and equipment? That is, they see no reason to expand.
This occurs during a recession.
Thus, government borrowing is unlikely to crowd out private spending when the economy is in a recession.
51
Automatic stabilizers
Fiscal policy: Increase G and reduce T in a recession Cut G and raise T when inflation is the problem
Some of this occurs automatically, without additional action by Congress or the executive branch
52
Automatic stabilizers
In a recession, people lose jobs. Payments for unemployment insurance rise More households become eligible for low-income
assistance (Medicaid, TANF, food stamps, other programs). Some begin social security payments.
Fewer taxes are collected
Point: government spending rises and taxes decline during a recession
53
Automatic stabilizers
During an inflationary gap caused by high aggregate demand, unemployment is very low Payments for unemployment insurance drop Fewer households become eligible for low-income
assistance (Medicaid, TANF, food stamps, other programs). Workers delay social security payments.
More taxes are collected
Point: government spending declines and taxes rise when output > potential output
54
Automatic stabilizers
The rise of government spending during a recession and decline in an inflationary gap are examples of automatic stabilizers.
The recession/inflation would be more severe without the automatic stabilizer.
55
Budget deficits
When government spending > tax revenue, the government has a budget deficit.
When government spending < tax revenue, the government has a budget surplus.
When government spending = tax revenue, the government budget is balanced.
56
Budget deficits
When the government budget is in deficit, the government borrows.
When the government budget is in surplus, the government pays off some debt.
57
Budget deficits
Ideally, budget deficits should occur during recessions budget surpluses should occur during inflationary
gaps
Result: the government budget balances in the long-run (but not every year)
58
Budget deficits as percent of GDP
59
Federal spending as percent of GDP
60
Federal revenue as percent of GDP
61
Federal spending and revenue as percent of GDP
Year Spending
Revenue Deficit
2009 24.4% 14.6% -9.82014 20.2% 17.4% -2.8
62
Budget deficits and debt
But policymakers tend to spend more (or cut taxes) in most years, both during recessions and expansions.
Result: climbing national debt
National debt is the sum of past budget deficits and surpluses
63
Budget deficits and debt
Example:
Federal debt 2013: $12,300 billion
Deficit end of 2013: $ 700 billion
64
Budget deficits and debt
Example:
Federal debt 2013: $12,300 billion
Deficit end of 2013: $ 700 billion
Federal debt 2014: $13,000 billion
65
Budget deficits and debt
How much debt is too much?
66
Budget deficits and debt
How much debt is too much?
Measures:
Debt as percent of income
Interest payments as percent of income
67
Federal debt as percent of GDP
101% in 2014
68
Interest payments as percent of GDP
1.3% in 2014
69
Budget deficits and debt
How much debt is too much?
Do you have difficulty borrowing?
Does the U.S. government have difficulty borrowing?
70
Budget deficits and debt
How is the debt paid back?
The government must run budget surpluses.
71
Long-term forecast by Congressional Budget Office
Billions of dollars
2014-2023
Revenues 40,336
Outlays
Discretionary 12,790
Mandatory 28,670
Net interest 5,216
TOTAL 46,676
DEFICIT (6,340)
Source: CBO
72
Long-term budget issues
Mandatory spending – occurs without any action by Congress (Medicare, social security, Medicaid, income maintenance programs)
Discretionary spending – Congress decides funding each year (defense, transportation, education, foreign aid, others)
73
Long-term budget issues
Goal: reduce the 2023 projected deficit of $6.3 trillion to zero
How can we accomplish this goal?
74
Long-term budget issues
Goal: reduce the 2023 projected deficit of $6.3 trillion to zero
How can we accomplish this goal?
Cut spending?
Increase taxes?
A mix of the two?