finding the poor in urban areas: the philippines’...

24
11 November 2015 Jacel J. Paguio, Assistant Regional Director Department of Social Welfare and Development, Philippines Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experience Nuts and Bolts of SPL systems in Urban Areas: from Strategy to Delivery

Upload: truongtu

Post on 26-Jun-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

Jacel J. Paguio, Assistant Regional Director Department of Social Welfare and Development, Philippines

Finding the poor in urban areas:

The Philippines’ experienceNuts and Bolts of SPL systems in Urban Areas:

from Strategy to Delivery

Page 2: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

Urban

Situation

in the

Philippines

3 Major Urban

Cities:

-Metro Manila

-Metro Cebu

-Metro Davao

11 November 2015

• 1 in 2 Filipinos live the urban

life (UNICEFs State of the World Children’s

2012 report)

• 21.7 million population from

12 Metro Cities (23% of the 92

million total Philippines

population)by NSCB in 2009

• By 2030, 77% of Filipinos is

projected to be living in urban

areas.

Page 3: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

Poverty Incidence Among

Families (2012)

(Estimates %)

Philippines 19.7

Major Cities

Metro Manila 2.4

Metro Cebu 18.9

Metro Davao 26.7

11 November 2015

Page 4: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

To establish an objective and transparent targeting system for social protection programs.

GENERAL

OBJECTIVE

National

Household

Targeting

System for

Poverty

Reduction

(NHTSPR)

Page 5: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

• Formulate a uniform set of criteria for identifyingpoor families through scientific means.

• To expand promotion and sharing of high qualitydatabase to public and private social protectionstakeholders.

• Reduce leakage or inclusion of non-poor and undercoverage or exclusion of poor from the necessarysocial protection programs and services.

Specific Objectives

Page 6: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

Geographical Targeting

1. IDENTIFICATION OF AREAS FOR ASSESSMENT

LISTAHANAN is implemented nationwide in17 regions,80 provinces, 1,491 municipalities 143 cities and 42,028 barangays.

2. IDENTIFICATION OF DATA COLLECTION STRATEGY

a. Rural barangays - SATURATION (all families will be assessed)

b. Urban barangays – SATURATION inpockets of poverty

Finding the Poor in Urban Areas

Step 1.

Page 7: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

HouseholdAssessment

1. Assess all families in all poor areas and thosepockets of poverty through house to houseinterviews using a 4-page questionnaire with46 variables Family Assessment Form (FAFs).

2. Encode all FAFs, run the duplicity checker,and apply the Proxy Means Test Model todetermine income per capita of thehouseholds.

3. Rank the PMT results according to provincialpoverty thresholds.

Step 2.

Finding the Poor in Urban Areas

Page 8: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

Enumerators in areas with reliable internet signal use android tablets for data collection.

Paper and Pencil Approach and Tablet

Page 9: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

Page 10: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

PerformanceAssessed

10,909,456 Households in 2009 from:

- 17 regions

- 80 provinces

- 1,491 municipalities/

143 cities

- 42,028 barangays

Page 11: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

5,255,118 (48.17%) POOR HHs identified in the

Philippines as per PMT result on

July 1, 2011.

Page 12: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

4.3 million

poor familiesIdentified in the LISTAHANAN were accessed to

major social protection programs.

These are:

-Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program

(The Philippine Conditional Cast Transfer –CCT)

-Sustainable Livelihood Program

-Health Insurance under PHIC

Page 13: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

Selling the Targeting System

Mechanisms

Given the amount of government resources

invested in the Listahanan, there is also a

much need to inform the public on the good

news about it to optimize the use of the

database to aid in the poverty alleviation in

the country.

11 November 2015

Page 14: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

Selling the Targeting System

Mechanisms

National and Regional Social Marketing Plan were formulated

leading to behavioral change of the target audience groups:

- National Legislators -Local Government Units

- National Government Agencies -Media Practitioners

- Non-Government Agencies -Development Organizations

- Targeted Families -DSWD staff

11 November 2015

Page 15: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

Selling the Targeting System

Mechanisms

In urban setting, marketing the LISTAHANAN is more challenging given the other existing database systems of highly urban cities (HUCs).

The approach instead is highlighting the complementation of all available local database on poor families as basis for planning and targeting.

Additional potential target users of the database are the Business and Corporate sector which also implements support programs on poverty alleviation under the company’s Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR).

11 November 2015

Page 16: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

HOMELESS STREET FAMILIES, ITINERANT

FAMILIES AND INDIGENOUS PEOPLES (IPs)

WERE EXCLUDED IN THE DATABASE AND WERE

LEFT BEHIND!

Page 17: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

- Families residing in streets in

urban & urbanizable areas whose

income or combined household

income cannot afford for housing

facilities.

WHO ARE THE HOMELESS STREET

FAMILIES (HSF) IN URBAN AREAS???

-Families routinely living on the

streets either in the open air

(doorways, sidewalks, pavements,

parks or in makeshift dwelling units

or push carts (“kariton family”).

-Families without

any form of house

structure adhered

to the soil.

Page 18: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program

MODIFIED

CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFER

FOR HOMELESS STREET FAMILIES

(MCCT-HSF)

• Target areas are highly urbanized cities andother areas where there is a growing number ofHSF.

• The strategy is CCT but with modifications in terms of processes in targeting, conditionalities, package of benefits, interventions and modes of implementation.

Page 19: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

• REACH OUT OPERATIONS

- Daily and Massive Inter-Agency

Reach out to Individuals/Families at Risk

•TWITTER ACCOUNT: @savestreetkids

•DEPLOYMENT OF STREET FACILITATORS &

OTHER FIELD STAFF

•STRONGER COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION

HOW the Homeless Street Families (HSF)

can be INCLUDED???

Page 20: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

• Reach out to HSF

• Household Enumeration using pre-screening tool.

• Name-matching in the NHTS & CCT Database and Housing Alpha List

• Assessment of Eligibility

• Validation of Potential Beneficiaries thru Community Assembly/FGD

MCCT Beneficiary Targeting & Registration

Page 21: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

Family Registration to MCCT

- Use of Registration Form and Oath of Commitment

-Issuance of MCCT Identification cards with the Household ID Number given by the DSWD.

Page 22: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

THE RESULTS

218,401 families are now benefiting from the MCCT-HSF program which is 4.87% of the total Pantawid Pamilyabeneficiaries nationwide.

Page 23: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family

11 November 2015

ENSURING NO ONE IS LEFT BEHIND!!!

Page 24: Finding the poor in urban areas: The Philippines’ experiencepubdocs.worldbank.org/en/260571448383099784/Nov-10... · -Metro Manila-Metro Cebu -Metro Davao ... 46 variables Family