finding permanency for our most vulnerable youth:
DESCRIPTION
Why APPLA Isn’t Good Enough. Christopher Church & Patricia Buonodono Georgia’s Court Improvement Program Anthony Reeves, Edward Washington & Crystal Williams Georgia empowerMEnt 34 th National Child Welfare, Juvenile & Family Law Conference National Association of Counsel for Children - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Christopher Church & Patricia BuonodonoGeorgia’s Court Improvement Program
Anthony Reeves, Edward Washington & Crystal Williams Georgia empowerMEnt
34th National Child Welfare, Juvenile & Family Law ConferenceNational Association of Counsel for ChildrenAugust 30, 2011 – San Diego, CA
1
Timeline of Events Identifying & Recognizing the Problem
Aunt Betty
Truck Drivin’ Grannie
APPLA “Child does not want to be adopted.”
Child’s Mental & Emotional Well Being Care or Control?
Questions & Answers
2
3
The Committee on Justice
for Children
Timeline of Events Identifying & Recognizing the Problem
Aunt Betty
Truck Drivin’ Grannie
APPLA “Child does not want to be adopted.”
Child’s Mental & Emotional Well Being Care or Control?
Questions & Answers
4
Scientific Definition: Children most likely to negatively impact state
conformity with CFSR Permanency Composite 3
Practical Definition: Children most likely to “age-out” without
permanency.
5
6
Permanency Composite 3: Achieving permanency for children in foster care for long periods of time Measure C3 - 1: Exits to permanency prior to 18th birthday for children in care for 24 + months: Of all children in foster care for 24 months or longer on the first day of the year shown, what percent was discharged to a permanent home prior to their 18th birthday and by the end of the fiscal year? A permanent home is defined as having a discharge reason of adoption, guardianship, or reunification (including living with relative).
Measure C3 - 2: Exits to permanency for children with TPR: Of all children who were discharged from foster care in the year shown, and who were legally free for adoption at the time of discharge (i.e., there was a parental rights termination date reported to AFCARS for both mother and father), what percent was discharged to a permanent home prior to their 18th birthday? A permanent home is defined as having a discharge reason of adoption, guardianship, or reunification (including living with relative)
Measure C3 - 3: Children Emancipated Who Were in Foster Care for 3 Years or More: What percent of children were in care for 3 years or longer who either: 1) exited foster care in the year shown with a discharge reason of emancipation or 2) reached their 18th birthday while in foster care but had not discharged?
Recipe Cold Cases
Ingredients 66 data elements from
AFCARS Foster Care file
Final Product Tastes about 90% good!
7
Aunt Bettie Truck Drivin’ Grannie
8
Timeline of Events Identifying & Recognizing the Problem
Aunt Betty
Truck Drivin’ Grannie
APPLA “Child does not want to be adopted.”
Child’s Mental & Emotional Well Being Care or Control?
Questions & Answers
9
APPLA is one of the permissible permanency goals under the Adoption & Safe Families Act of 1997.
A child may have a permanency goal of APPLA, but only when the State agency has documented to the court a compelling reason for determining that it would not be in the best interest of the child to follow one of the other four specified options. ▪ 45 CFR § 1355.20(v)
State must consider all other options permanency options first, and even then, must document a compelling reason for any alternate plan:▪ 45 CFR § 1355.21(h)(3)
10
Examples of a compelling reason may include:
The case of an older teen who specifically requests that emancipation be established as his/her permanency plan;
The case of a parent & child who have a significant bond, but parent is unable to care for the child b/c of an emotional or physical disability and the child’s foster parents have committed to raising him/her to the age of majority and to facilitate visitation with the disabled parent
▪ 45 CFR § 1355.21(h)(3)(i)-(ii)
11
“Child does not want to be adopted.”
12
SSM § 1006.8: Two Options for APPLA
Long-Term Foster CareSigned, Informal Agreement by SubstituteCaregiver and Child
EmancipationBasically Same as Above, but Nobody to Sign Long-Term Foster Care Agreement
Policy recognizes neither option is really permanency, and cautions against adopting as permanency plan for any child.
13
DHS Practice Bulletin: Permanency For Children: APPLA. January 2009
Generally Appropriate for some older youth, age 16 or older.
Insists compelling reasons “be convincingand forceful. [They] must be supported with very strong, case-specific facts and evidence which includes justification for the decisions and reasons why all other permanent options for a child are not reasonable, appropriate, or possible.”
14
Policy Title: Establishing the Goal of APPLAD.C. CFSA, June 25, 2009
Child at least 16, with concurrent plan to identify adults who will commit to youthafter time in foster care ends
Youth must reconsider permanency options 6 weeks before every permanency hearing.
APPLA goal shall be constantly examined and revisited at all relevant team meetings and reviews – never considered fixed or immutable.
15
VA DSS, Volume VII, § 3B - 7.6 thru 7.7
The selection of APPLA is appropriate only if the child has a severe chronic emotional, physical, or neurological disabling condition for which the child requires long-term residential treatment ofsix months or longer.”
But allows APPLA for older youth preparing to transition to ILP when all other goals are have been considered and ruled out.
16
17
18
Long-StaysFFY2009
149.1142.8142.7
139.1138
136.2135.4134.2
132.1131.5131.5130.2130129.9129.7
126.7124.5124.1123.6
121120.2119.8118.6118.3
115.7114.6114.2113.2113.1112110.7110.3109.6
107.6107.6106.5105.9105.5
101.997.7
95.395.295.294.794.593.5
91.283.9
74.4
50 70 90 110 130 150
NebraskaTennessee
WyomingIdaho
New JerseyPennsylvania
IndianaNew Mexico
ArizonaNevada
West VirginiaKansas
MississippiNorth DakotaRhode Island
ArkansasWashington
IowaFlorida
North CarolinaColorado
GeorgiaDelaware
HawaiiWisconsinNew York
New HampshireUtah
MassachusettsCalifornia
OregonMichiganMissouri
KentuckyOhio
OklahomaAlaska
VirginiaVermont
IllinoisMinnesota
ConnecticutAlabama
TexasDistrict of Columbia
MontanaPuerto Rico
MaineMarylandLouisiana
South CarolinaSouth Dakota
Composite 3 Scores
Notice the Range:
- South Dakota = 74
- Nebraska = 150
FFY2009: 42/52 meet standard, 101.5 is the 19th percentile, 75th percentile is 131.5, 50th percentile is 118.5
19
Legal Orphans Exiting to Non-PermanencyFFY2009
0.0%0.0%0.0%
0.8%1.1%1.4%1.4%1.9%2.1%2.4%2.6%2.9%3.0%3.0%3.1%3.1%3.4%3.7%3.8%4.0%4.3%4.3%4.5%4.7%4.8%5.2%5.4%5.5%5.6%6.1%6.3%
7.5%7.8%7.9%7.9%8.0%8.1%8.5%8.5%
9.3%9.7%
10.4%10.6%10.8%11.0%11.0%11.6%
13.2%13.7%
15.8%17.3%17.5%
0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% 20%
Long-StaysFFY2009
149.1142.8142.7
139.1138
136.2135.4134.2
132.1131.5131.5130.2130129.9129.7
126.7124.5124.1123.6
121120.2119.8118.6118.3
115.7114.6114.2113.2113.1112110.7110.3109.6
107.6107.6106.5105.9105.5
101.997.7
95.395.295.294.794.593.5
91.283.9
74.4
50 70 90 110 130 150
Emancipating After 3 YearsFFY2009
15.0%17.7%20.1%
25.3%26.6%29.0%30.3%30.4%30.8%30.8%31.8%33.7%34.4%35.0%35.9%35.9%36.8%36.9%
40.5%41.9%42.0%43.3%43.6%43.9%44.4%45.0%45.3%45.9%46.0%46.4%46.6%46.6%47.0%47.2%48.8%
53.2%53.7%54.1%
57.4%57.7%58.0%58.3%59.3%60.2%61.2%63.4%63.8%64.6%64.7%67.1%67.1%
70.1%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
Timeline of Events Identifying & Recognizing the Problem
Aunt Betty
Truck Drivin’ Grannie
APPLA “Child does not want to be adopted.”
Child’s Mental & Emotional Well Being Care or Control?
Questions & Answers
20
Care or Control?
21
State Representative Oliver introduced House Bill 23 in January to provide transparency and oversight in the administration of psychotropic meds by DFCS.
Finalizing partnership between Casey Family Programs, Barton Center at Emory University, DFCS, GA CIP for independent oversight by local child psychiatrist.
Karen Worthington researched and published paper on the issue. PDF available here:w2.georgiacourts.org/cj4c/files/Psych_meds_paper%20(2).pdf
22
Online Videos:
Pat O’Brien, You Gotta Believe!www.law.emory.edu/centers-clinics/barton-child-law-policy-center/presentations.html
Karen Worthington, Psychotropic Meds for Georgia Youth in Foster Carew2.georgiacourts.org/cj4c/files/Psych_meds_paper%20(2).pdf
Executive Report, Cold Case Project w2.georgiacourts.org/cj4c/files/The%20Georgia%20Cold% 20Case%20Project_2010(1).pdf
23