final solar power consumer protection report solar power...allows a comparison of impacts on the...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
SOLARPOWERONTHEROOFANDINTHENEIGHBORHOOD:
RECOMMENDATIONSFORCONSUMERPROTECTIONPOLICIES
BarbaraR.AlexanderConsumerAffairsConsultant
WiththeAssistanceof
JaneeBriesemeister
Consultant
March2016
![Page 2: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
BarbaraR.AlexanderopenedherownconsultingpracticeinMarch1996.From1986-96shewastheDirector,ConsumerAssistanceDivision,attheMainePublicUtilitiesCommission.Ms.AlexanderreceivedherJ.D.fromtheUniversityofMaineSchoolofLawin1976.Herclientsincludenationalandlocalconsumerorganizations,statepublicutilitycommissions,andstateutilitypublicadvocates.Herareasofexpertiseincludeconsumerprotectionstoaccompanytheimplementationofretailelectric,naturalgas,andlocaltelephonecompetition,servicequalityperformancestandardsforelectric,naturalgas,andtelecommunicationsproviders,lowincomeprogramdesignandimplementation,consumerprotectionsassociatedwithpilotandsystem-wideinstallationofadvancedmeteringanddynamicpricingprograms,analysisofutilitycustomerserviceprograms,andresidentialratedesignpolicies.
JaneeBriesemeisterhasmorethan25yearsofexperienceinconsumeradvocacy,policydevelopmentandadvocacyissuecampaignsonthestateandnationallevels,andisnationallyrecognizedasaleadingconsumeradvocateonresidentialutilityissues.From2006-2014Ms.BriesemeisterwasSeniorLegislativeRepresentativeintheDepartmentofStateAdvocacyandStrategyatAARP.AtAARPshewasresponsibleforsupportingtheorganization’sstateofficesonconsumer-orientedlegislativeandregulatoryadvocacyforaffordableutilityservice,includinghomeenergy,telecommunications,waterandwastewater.Ms.Briesemeisterreceivedthe2011AARPLynBodifordAwardforExcellenceinAdvocacy,recognitionfromhercolleaguesnationwideforleadershipoftheorganization’sadvocacyforaffordablehomeutilityservice.AARPisthenation’sleadingadvocacyorganizationforpeopleage50andover.
TheauthorsgratefullyappreciatetheassistanceandsupportforthisReportfromthefollowing:
• RichardBerkley,PublicUtilityLawProjectofNewYork• PaulaCarmody,MarylandOfficeofPeople’sCounsel• LindaConti,ConsumerProtectionDivision,OfficeofMaineAttorneyGeneral• TanyaMcCloskey,PennsylvaniaOfficeofConsumerAdvocate• MarkToneyandMarcelHawiger,TheUtilityReformNetwork(TURN),California
Inaddition,theauthorsthankCarolBiedrzyckiofTexasRatepayersOrganizationtoSaveEnergy(ROSE)inTexasforherassistance.
However,theauthorsremainsolelyresponsibleforthecontentandrecommendationsofthisReport.
![Page 3: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
TABLEOFCONTENTSINTRODUCTIONANDEXECUTIVESUMMARY 4
CHAPTERI:THEMARKETFORRESIDENTIALSOLARISGROWING,FUELEDBYNEWFINANCINGOPTIONS........................................................................................................................................................................................7
CHAPTERII:ITISDIFFICULTTOSHOPANDCOMPARECOSTSFORROOFTOPSOLARANDTHEPROJECTEDIMPACTSONARESIDENTIALCUSTOMERELECTRICBILL.......................................................12A. SOLARCOMPANYWEBSITESOFTENMAKEGENERICSTATEMENTSANDDONOTEXPLAINMANYDETAILSOFTHEPROPOSEDTRANSACTION..........................................................................................12B. ITISDIFFICULTFORCUSTOMERSTODETERMINETHEIROVERALLSAVINGSFROMINVESTINGINSOLARPRIORTOENTERINGINTOAPURCHASE,LOAN,LEASEORPPA....................15C. FEDERALANDSTATEINCENTIVESIMPACTCUSTOMERPAYMENTSANDSAVINGSFORSOLAR.....................................................................................................................................................................................17
CHAPTERIII:THECASEFORADOPTINGCONSUMERPROTECTIONSFORSOLARPOWERTRANSACTIONS.......................................................................................................................................................................19A. CUSTOMERCOMPLAINTSANDREVIEWS.....................................................................................................19B. STATEATTORNEYGENERALENFORCEMENTACTIONSANDCIVILSUITS...................................20C. LEGISLATIVEINITIATIVES...................................................................................................................................21D. STATEANDFEDERALGUIDANCEONENVIRONMENTALCLAIMS.....................................................23E. PROPOSALSFORINDUSTRYSELF-REGULATIONAREINSUFFICIENTFORCONSUMERPROTECTION.......................................................................................................................................................................24
CHAPTERIV:RECOMMENDATIONSFORCONSUMERPROTECTIONPOLICIESANDMANDATESFORRESIDENTIALSOLARTRANSACTIONS.........................................................................................................................26A. REGISTRATIONANDLICENSING.......................................................................................................................26B. DISCLOSURES.............................................................................................................................................................28C. CONTRACTTERMS...................................................................................................................................................31D. SALESANDMARKETINGCONDUCT.................................................................................................................35E. ENFORCEMENTANDPENALTIES;CUSTOMERCOMPLAINTS..............................................................36
CHAPTERV:COMMUNITYSOLARPROJECTS:ADDITIONALCONSUMERPROTECTIONS..................37
APPENDIXA:SUMMARYOFSTATEPROPOSEDLEGISLATION(2014-2015)............................................43
APPENDIXB:CRITIQUEOFTHESEIABUSINESSCODEFORSOLARTRANSACTIONSASASUBSTITUTEFORSTATEREGULATORYOVERSIGHTANDSTANDARDS.....................................................46
APPENDIXC:CONSUMEREDUCATIONALMATERIALS.......................................................................................51
ENDNOTES.................................................................................................................................................................................52
![Page 4: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
INTRODUCTIONANDEXECUTIVESUMMARY
ThepurposeofthisReportistoaddresstheneedforessentialconsumerprotectionpoliciestogoverntheburgeoningmarketsforresidentialrooftopsolarsystemsandcommunitysolarprojects.
TheU.S.residentialsolarmarkethasexperiencedexplosivegrowthinthelastfive
years,fueledbylowercosts,stateandfederalincentives,andnewfinancingoptions,includingleasesandpurchasedpoweragreements,alsoknownasthird-partyownership.Communitysolar,whereaconsumersubscribestosharesinasolarsystemthatislocatedinaneighborhoodorcommunity,isarelativelynewandgrowingoption.
Consumersmaybeinterestedinsolarpowertohelptheenvironment,orsimplytosavemoneyontheirelectricbills.Whateverthemotivation,itisnoteasytocomparisonshopforsolarpower.Consumerswillbefacedwithcomparingthecostsofoutrightpurchase,apurchasepoweragreement,alease,oraloan.Whetherpurchasedorleased,theconsumerismakingalong-termfinancialcommitmentwiththeexpectationthatsavingsonutilitybillswilloffsetthemonthlycostofthesystem.Achievingthesesavingsinrealityisdependentonavarietyoffactors—includingcontractterms,federal,state,andlocalsubsidies,theestimatedincreaseinthecustomer’scostofelectricity,andtheperformanceofthesolarpanelsthemselves.Itwouldbeeasyforaconsumertobemisledintoapurchasebasedonexaggeratedassumptionsaboutfuturesavings.Indeed,consumercomplaintshavepromptedstatestotakeactioninthecourts,andproposeconsumerprotectionstoaddressactualandpotentialabusesandmisconceptions.
ThisReportdescribesthemarketing,salespractices,disclosures,andcontractualtermsconcerningthecostsandbenefitsofinstallingrooftopsolarsystemsorparticipatingincommunitysolarsystems.Whileseveralexistinglawsandregulationsmaybeapplicabletoresidentialrooftopsolarinstallations,thosepoliciesarenotspecificallytargetedtosolarinstallationsandtheassociatedfinancialtransactions.ThisReportrecommendsthatsolarenergyprovidersthatengageinsales,leasesandpurchasepoweragreements,aswellasthoseofferingcommunitysolarprojects,shouldbesubjecttooversightbyastateagencyandberequiredtoprovideconsumerskeydisclosures,faircontractterms,andbesubjecttopenaltiesforviolatingstatelawsandregulations.
Thepreferredapproachfor
oversightofsolarenergyprovidersofferingresidentialrooftoporcommunitysolarprojectsshouldbeuniformandcomprehensivejurisdictionbythestateutilitycommission,orotherequivalentstateagency.Solarenergybusinessesaremarketingtoresidentialelectricutilitycustomersforaproductthatisinexorablylinkednotonlytothe
ThisReportwillnotaddressissuesgovernedbyhomeconstructioncodesandoversight,northedisclosuresandoversightassociatedwithloansdirectlyprovidedbyfinancialinstitutions.ThisReportshouldbeviewedascomplementarytotheoversightbystateAttorneysGeneralunderastate’sUnfairTradePracticelaws,theFederalTradeCommissionunderthecomparableFederalUnfairTradePracticelaw,andanystateandfederalregulationsthatspecificallyaddressDoortoDoorSalesandTelemarketingSalesactivities.Theseexistingconsumerprotectionpolicies,whilevaluable,arenotcomprehensiveanddonotaddressthespecifictypesoftransactionsandassociateduniquefeaturesforrooftopsolarsystemsorcommunitysolarsystems.
![Page 5: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
customer’smonthlyelectricbill(andthepurchaseofwhichmightevenappearontheutility’selectricbillundersomeproposals),butisalsolocatedintheutility’sdistributiongrid.Tosomeextent,utilitycommissionsalreadyregulatesolarpowerwiththeirdetailedpricingdecisionsonnetmeteringandvalueofsolartariffsthatarecrucialtothemarketingclaimsrelatedtoloweringahouseholdelectricbill.Oftenstatepolicyrequiresthestatepublicutilitycommissiontopromotesolarpowerspecificallyaspartoftheefforttoachieverenewableenergyandcarbonemissionreductiongoals.Commissionsthentypicallyrequireutilitiestomakeinvestmentstoaccommodatetheintegrationofdistributedgenerationandsolarenergyfacilities,whetherthroughindividualcustomerrooftopinstallationorlocalcommunitysolarprograms.Thus,itfollowsthatstateutilitycommissionsarethemostlogicalfocustooverseeretailsolarsales,andsuggestionstolimitthejurisdictionofutilityregulatorstoonlyafewtypesofsolartransactionswouldresultinlikelyconfusionbyconsumersastotheirrightsandremedieswhenshoppingforsolarsystems.However,statesmaydecidethatadifferentstateagencyshouldexercisethisoversightandjurisdictionandourrecommendationswouldaccommodateanalternativeapproach.
ThisReportproposesconsumerprotectionsspecifictosolarleaseandsaletransactions,withdisclosuresandcontractualprovisionsthatflowfromthelongstandingconsumerprotectionpoliciesthathavegovernedretailsalesofproductsandservicestoresidentialcustomers.
ThekeyrecommendationssetforthinChapterIVincludethefollowingpolicies:
RegistrationorLicensing;StateAgencyAuthority:Consumersprotectionsarenoteffectiveunlessagovernmentalagencyhastheauthoritytoinvestigatecomplaintsandtakeactionagainstbadactors,andsuchenforcementcannotoccurwithoutregistrationorlicensing.Regulatorsshouldknowhowtocontactauthorizedrepresentatives,investigatethebackgroundofabusiness,andtakeactionagainstaproviderforviolationsofstatelawsandregulations.
Disclosures:ACustomerTemplate:ThisModelwouldnotregulatethefinancialcontentsofthesolarprovider’soffer,butwouldrequireallsolarprovidersmarketingtoresidentialcustomerstousethesametermsanddefinitionsandmaketheiroffersinamannerthatallowsacomparisonofimpactsonthecustomer’selectricitybillsandobligationsundertheapplicablefinancialarrangement.
ContractProvisions:Standardizingcontracttermsanddisclosuresdoesnotinanywayregulateorlimitthepricechargedforasolarlease,purchasepoweragreementorsale.However,certaincontracttermsshouldbespecificallyaddressedand,insomecases,mandatedorprohibitedtopreventunfairdealingandone-sidedbargainsaboutfineprinttermsandconditions.
SalesandMarketingConduct:Consumerprotectionregulationapplicabletoretailsolarprovidersshouldexplicitlyprohibitmisleadinganddeceptivesalesandmarketing
![Page 6: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
statementsandreferencethestate’sspecificunfairtradepracticeorgeneralconsumerprotectionlaw.Asellercannotmisrepresentthenatureoftheformalagreementorusestatementsthataredirectlycontradictedbytheformalagreementorcontract.
TermsattheSaleofaproperty:Therehavebeencomplaintsaboutthirdpartyfinancingarrangementsincludingaprovisiongivingthesolarprovider(theownerofthesolarpanelsinseveraltypesoffinancialarrangements)therighttoapproveanewhomeownerbeforetheleasecouldbetransferredtothenewowner.Severalstateshaveaddressedthissituationintheirproposedlegislation,andtherightsandobligationsatthetimeofthesaleofpropertyareakeydisclosureintherecentlyenactedArizonalaw.
EnforcementandPenalties;CustomerComplaints:Theproposedconsumerprotectionscannotbeeffectiveunlessthoseregulationscanbeenforcedandviolatorspenalized.Enforcementrequiresthatanagencyhavetheauthorityandnecessaryresourcestoinvestigatecomplaints,accessthesolarprovider’srecordsdemonstratingcompliancewiththeunderlyingconsumerprotectionandcontractrequirements,takeactionstorevokelicensesorregistration,andassessfinesorpenaltiestoensurecustomersareprotected.
![Page 7: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
CHAPTERI:THEMARKETFORRESIDENTIALSOLARISGROWING,FUELEDBYNEWFINANCINGOPTIONS
TheU.S.residentialsolarmarkethasexperiencedexplosivegrowthinthelastfiveyears.Thisgrowthhasbenefitedfromseveralfactors.First,thecostofsolarpowerpanelshasdroppedsignificantlyinrecentyears.1Second,federalandstatesubsidiesandincentiveshavefurtherloweredthenetcosttoconsumers.Finally,thesolarindustryhasdevelopednewfinancingmethods,includingloans,leasesandpurchasedpoweragreements,thatlowertheinitialcosttoresidentialcustomers.Theresultisthatfinancialinvestorshavesupportedthedevelopmentofsolarpowercompanies,theirmarketingandsalesactivitieshaveexpandedtomanystates,andnewindustryentrantshaveproliferated.
Whenacustomerinstallssolarpanelsontheirroof,theyhaveinstalledatiny
generatingplantforelectricity.Theallureofsolartomanycustomersisnotitsinitialcost,whichissignificant,butthepotentialforthecustomertogenerateelectricityandreducetheamountofelectricitypurchasedfromthelocalutilityandcontributetothe“greener”generationofelectricity.But,thatisonlypartofthecustomerbenefits.Thecustomermaygeneratemoreelectricityundercertaintimesofthedayorundercertainweatherconditionsthanthecustomerneedsandsothis“excess”electricityisflowedbackintotheutility’sdistributionsystemandthecustomerispaidforgeneratingthisexcesselectricity.Fromthesolarcustomer’sperspective,theissueiswhetherthereducedusageandthepaymentsforexcessgeneration(theresultingmonthlyelectricbill)offsettheupfrontandmonthlycostsofthesolarinstallation,whetherpurchasedoutright,throughaloan,orleasedfromthesolarcompany.
Themethodormannerinwhichthecustomerispaidforgeneratingexcess
electricitybytheutilityisreferredtoas“netmetering”orthe“valueofsolar.”Themethodologyforcalculatingthevalueandthepaymentstothecustomerforthisexcesselectricityishighlycontroversialmainlybecausetheutilityisallowedtorecoverthecostsofthebillimpactsassociatedwithsolar(i.e.,reducedusageandpaymentsforexcessgeneration)fromothercustomers.Utilityratesareregulatedbythestatepublicutilitycommissionandautilityisallowedtosetratesthatrecoveritsapprovedrevenuerequirement.Asaresult,thereisagrowingconcernabouttheshiftincoststosupporttheelectricitysystemfromsolarcustomerstonon-solarcustomers.2ThisReportdoesnotaddressthisissue,butratherfocusesontheneedforconsumerprotectionpoliciesandprogramsthataddressthemarketing,sales,andcontracttermsassociatedwithresidentialsolarprojects—whetherinstalledonthecustomer’srooforaspartofacommunitysolarprojectfinancedbyagroupofcustomers.Indeed,severalstatesarereconsideringtheirnetmeteringpolices,andsignificantchangeshaverecentlybeenadoptedbyNevadaandHawaii.Appropriatedisclosuresandaccuratesavingscalculationsareallthemoreimportantforconsumersinthischangingmarketplace.
Thesolarindustryconsistsofthreedistinctmarkets:individualcustomerrooftopsolar;utility-ownedsolarpowergeneratingfacilities;andcommunitysolar.Rooftopsolaris,asthenameimplies,typicallyinstalledonanindividualcustomer’sroof.Utility-owned
![Page 8: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
solarpowerfacilitiesarelargerarraysofsolarpanelsthatareinstalledonthegroundandformpartoftheutility’sgenerationmixforallitscustomersandtheprudentcostsforthesefacilitiesareincludedinratespaidbyallcustomers.Communitysolarisusuallyinstalledonthegroundandfinancedbyaprivateorpubliclyownedorganizationtoserveagroupofcustomersinaneighborhoodordefinedgeographicarea.Solarpowerisaformof“distributedgeneration”becauseitisaformofgenerationofelectricitythatcanbelocatedthroughoutthedistributionsystemofanelectricutility,verydifferentfromthemoretraditionallargepowerplantsthathavehistoricallybeenusedtoproduceelectricity.ThisReportdoesnotusetheterm“distributedgeneration”becausethatisagenerictermthatcanincludegenerationresourcesotherthansolar.ForeaseofreferencethisReportusestheterm“solarpower”or“solarenergyfacilitiesorsystems.”
Throughtheendof2014,morethan600,000homesandbusinesseshadinstalledon-sitesolar,typicallyontheroof.Theresidentialmarketgrewbymorethan50%annuallyin2012,2013,and2014—atrendthatsomeexpertspredictwillcontinuefor2015and2016.Thesesystemsgenerateapproximatelyone-thirdofthetotalU.S.solarelectricityproduction.Themarketforresidentialsolarisexpandingrapidlyacrossthecountry.Twenty-onestateshavenowaddedmorethan100MWofsolarPV.Yetthetopfivestatesstillaccountfornearlythree-fourthsofcumulativeU.S.PVinstallations,withapproximatelyhalfofallresidentialsolarinstallationsinCalifornia.3Preliminary2015dataconfirmsthesignificantgrowthinresidentialsolarinstallationsby66%comparedto2014andconstitutes29%oftheentireU.S.solarmarket.Actualactivityremainsconcentratedintenstates.4
Homeownerscancontractwithasolarenergycompanytohaveasolarsystem
installedontheirrooftop(orelsewhereontheirproperty).Thehomeownermaybeofferedaloanorthirdpartyownershiparrangementtolowertheinitialinvestmentcostsofthesystem.Althoughrarejustafewyearsago,72percentofresidentialsolarsystemsinstalledin2014werefinancedthroughathird-partyownershipmodel(i.e.,solarleasingorathird-partypowerpurchaseagreement(PPA))5.Whilethird-partyownershiphasbeenontheriseintheresidentialmarket,someanalystspredictitsgrowthwillslowdownandthatfinancingtrendsmayshiftbacktoloanproducts.6
Dependingonthethirdpartyownershipagreement,thesolarcompanywilloftenbe
responsibleforfinancing,permitting,designing,installing,andmaintainingthesolarsystem.Underthetypicalthirdpartyownershipagreement,thehomeowneralsoassignsanytaxincentives,rebatesorotherincentivestothesolarprovider(thethird-partyowner).Theassumptionisthatthesebenefitshavebeenfactoredintothecontractterms.
Thefollowingfinancialarrangementscanbeofferedtoacustomerinterestedin
rooftopsolar,7butnotallsolarcompaniesofferalltheseoptionsandseveraloftheseoptionsarenotavailableinallStatesduetostatelawsthatmayimpacttheabilityofsolarproviderstooffersomeofthesefinancialoptions,particularleasesandPPAs.
![Page 9: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
CustomerOwnershipoftheRooftopSolarSystem:CustomerPurchase:Thehomeownerobtainstheirownfinancing(oftenintheformofahomeequityloan)topurchasethesystemandthereisnoongoingrelationshipbetweenthehomeownerandthesolarcompanyaftertheinstallationofthesystemotherthanpotentialrepairandmaintenanceorwarrantyissues.LoanAgreement:Thehomeownerentersintoaloanagreementwiththesolarcompanytofinancethepurchasepriceofthesystem,thuseliminatingthehomeowner’sobligationtoobtaintheirownloan.Solarcompaniesthatofferthismodelhaveenteredintoagreementswithfinancialinstitutionstosupporttheirloanoffersandthesetermsmaydifferfromwhatthehomeownermightbeabletoobtainindividually.
Third-PartyOwnershipoftheRooftopSolarSystem:
PurchasePowerAgreement(PPA):Thesolarcompanyretainsownershipofthesolarsystemandthehomeownerbuysalloftheelectricityproducedbythesolarsystematanagreed-uponpriceperkWh.Thispricetypicallyrisesoverthetermofthecontract.Thehomeownertypicallyisnotrequiredtoinvestanysignificantcapitalcosts.PPAsareusuallylonger-termcontractswithtermsofupto20years.Lease:Thehomeownerentersintoaleaseagreementandmakespre-establishedmonthlypaymentstothesolarcompany,whoretainsownershipofthesystemforthecontractterm.Ineffect,thehomeownerisrentingthesolarsystemandhastherighttouseallthepowerproducedbyit.Theleasepaymentstypicallyriseyearlyoverthecontracttermandarenottiedtotheoutputofthesystem.Unlessthecontractincludesaperformanceguarantee,thehomeownercouldexperiencehigherorlowerelectricbillsdependingontheelectricaloutputassumedatthetimeofthetransaction.Thefollowingchartsummarizesthedifferentattributesassociatedwithaloan,a
lease,andaPPA:
![Page 10: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
PurchasewithLoan Lease PPATypesofLoansincludesecuredandunsecuredsolarloans,homeequityloans,homeequitylineofcreditandPACEloans
Typesofleasesinclude$0downoracustomdownpayment,withmonthlypaymentsthattypicallyescalateeachyear.Optiontopre-pay(functionslikeacashpurchase,withtheleasingcompanyretainingalltaxcreditsandrebates).
Sameaslease
Meetqualifications,suchasminimumcreditscore.
Typicallyaminimumcreditscoreisrequired,butnotalways
Sameaslease
Termsof5-20years;3.5-7.5%interestrates.Somestatesoffersubsidizedloans.Interestonaloanmaybetaxdeductible.
Contractfor20-25yearperiod Sameaslease
Purchaserretainsanyincentivesandtaxcredit.
Leasingcompanyretainsanyincentivesandtaxcredits.
Sameaslease
Homeownerownsthesystemandisresponsibleformaintenance.
Leasingcompanyownsandmaintainssystem.However,consumermayhavesomemaintenanceresponsibilities,suchastreetrimming.
Sameaslease.
Consumermakesloanpayments.Hastherighttouseallofthepowerproducedbythesystem.
Consumerpaysamonthlyleasepaymentinexchangefortherighttouseallofthepowerproducedbythesystem.Ifthesystemproduceslesspowerthanpredicted,thecostwillbehigher.
ConsumeragreestobuythepowergeneratedbythesystematasetpriceperkWh.
Attheendoftheloanperiodtheconsumerownsthesystem.
Attheendoftheleasetheconsumercanbuythesystematthefairmarketvalueorpricespecifiedinthelease;havethecompanyremovethesystemorrenewthelease.Howisfairmarketvaluedetermined?
Sameaslease
Systemtransfersatsaleofhome.
Buyermayhavetoqualifytotakeoverleasepaymentsorsellermayberequiredtopurchasesystembeforesale.
Sameaslease.
![Page 11: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Whetherloan,leaseorPPA,thesearesignificantfinancialoutlaysforaconsumer,potentiallywithtermsthatmaynotbefullyunderstoodby,ornecessarilyfavorableto,thepurchaser.Whilecertainpoliciesrelatingtoresidentialsolar,suchasnetmetering,remaincontroversial,thereisagrowingawarenessoftheneedfordevelopingandimplementingbasicconsumerprotectionpolicesrelatingtothesaleandleasingofsolarsystems.
![Page 12: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
CHAPTERII:ITISDIFFICULTTOSHOPANDCOMPARECOSTSFORROOFTOPSOLARANDTHEPROJECTEDIMPACTSONARESIDENTIALCUSTOMERELECTRICBILL
Whenshoppingforarooftopsolarsystem,customersarepresentedwithawidevarietyofoptionsthatincludeoutrightpurchase,apurchasepoweragreement,alease,oraloan.Customersmayhearaboutsolarpoweroptionsdirectlyfrommarketersintheformoftelemarketingsalescalls,door-to-doormarketing,web-basedadvertisements,andrecommendationsfromneighborsandfriends.Whiletheideaofsolarpowerisfairlysimpletoexplain—installsolarpanelsonthehomeowner’sroof--itisnoteasytocomparisonshopforaresidentialrooftopsolarsystem.Whetherpurchasedorleased,theconsumerismakingalong-termfinancialcommitmentwiththeexpectationthatsavingsonutilitybillswilloffsetthemonthlycostofthesystem.Achievingthesesavingsinrealityisdependentonavarietyoffactors—includingcontractterms,federal,state,andlocalsubsidies,theestimatedincreaseinthecustomer’scostofelectricity,andtheperformanceofthesolarpanelsthemselves.Whilesomeorevenallprospectivecustomersmayalsobemotivatedbytheenvironmentalattributesofsolarsystemsandtheirpotentialtodisplacethegreenhousegasorcarbonemissionsassociatedwithmoretraditionalpowerplants,mostconsumersalsoexpectbenefitsintheformofareducedmonthlyelectricbill.Thesavingspotentialforrooftopsolarsystemsisparticularlyimportanttocustomerswhocannotaffordtofinancethepurchaseofthesolarsystemthemselves.
A. SOLARCOMPANYWEBSITESOFTENMAKEGENERICSTATEMENTSANDDONOTEXPLAINMANYDETAILSOFTHEPROPOSEDTRANSACTIONAreviewofsomeofthetopsolarcompanywebsites8revealsthepotentialforconfusionandconfirmsthedifficultyofshoppingandcomparingthevariousoptionsordeterminingtheprojectedsavingsinthecustomer’smonthlyelectricbill.Inalmosteverycase,thesolarcompany’swebsitemakesgenericstatementsaboutelectricbillsavings,butasksthecustomertocalloremail(andthenreceiveasalescall)forapricequote.
• ThesolarcompanyBrite’swebsitepromotesaresidentialcustomerlease
(http://www.britelease.com/).Whiletherearenosampleleasedocumentsavailableonthiswebsite,theCompanyoffersanodownpayment15-yearleasewithaperformanceguaranteeandclaimthatconsumers“startsavingimmediately.”Thesitestatesthatelectricityratesriseanaverageof5to6%annually.Infineprint,thecustomerisinformedthatthereisa2.5%annualescalationinleasepayments.Thewebsitedoesnotincludeanylinkstobrochures,references,oreducationalmaterials.
• SunEdison(www.sunedison.com)onlyofferspurchasepoweragreementsforresidentialsolarinsixstates.Whilethewebsitepromotes“potentialsavings,”therearenoexplicitpromisesorestimatesofsavingsandthe“frequentlyaskedquestions”portionofthewebsitegenerallyidentifiesthecustomerspecificinformationneededtocalculatebenefitsandcosts.Thecompany’ssolarsystemispromotedasalongterminvestmenttoreducetheelectricbill,addvaluetothesaleofthehome,andasanactiontoreducecarbonemissions:
![Page 13: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
Idon’tplanonbeinginmyhomefor20years,whywouldIaddsolar?Regardlessofhowlongyou’llbeinyourhomeitalwaysmakessensetogosolarformanyreasons.Financially,youwillbesavingmoneythefirstmonthyougosolarandeverymonthyouareinthehome.You’llalsobeabletosellyourhomeformoreasaresultbecauseitisamoreenergyefficienthome.Lastlyyou’llbereducingyourcarbonfootprintbynotusingthedirtyenergythattheutilitycompaniescurrentlyprovide.Aneffectthatwillnotonlybefeltbyyoubutbyyourchildrenandgrandchildren.Willmysystemincreasethevalueofmyhome?Yes!Theamountdependsonthemarketconditionsatthetimeyousellyourhome,theareaofthecountryyouliveinandtheamountofmoneyyouaresaving.However,mosthomeswillappraiseanywherefrom$5,000-$15,000more.
SunEdison’swebsiteexplainsthattheCompanywillnotchargethecustomeranyupfrontcostsfortheinstallationofthenewsolarsystemandthecustomerwillpayfortheenergythatthesolarsystemgenerates,“ataratetypicallythatislowerthanyouarecurrentlyproviding”(sic).Specifically,“Afterallofthefreeequipment,maintenance,andmonitoring,theonlythingyouhavetopayforwithourPPAisthepoweryoursolarpanelsproduce.Welockinaratethatisusuallylessthanyourlocalutilitycompany’smarketrate—whichmeansyou’refreefromthevolatilityoffuturerateincreases.Plus,ifyouproducemorepowerthanyouuse,weputitbackonthegridandyougetacreditfromyourutilitycompany.Ifyouproducelesspowerthanyouneedyoucanstilluseenergyfromyourenergyprovideratyouragreeduponprice.”
• Sungevity(www.sungevity.com)promotesa“savingsgraph,”thatreliesonaprojected
electricityrateincreasederivedfromnationalaverageelectricityrateincreasedatafrom1993-2013:“Thesooneryougosolar,thesooneryoucansave.”Thiscompanyoffersloans,leases,andaPPA,butdoesnotincludeanyofthesampledocumentsonitswebsite.Whilethereisafineprintdisclaimeraboutthe“estimates”forelectricitypricesandsavings,thepromotionalmaterialpresentsasavingsgraphwithastraightlinethatimpliesthepriceforsolarwillremainconstantfor20years.Yetthereisafineprintdisclaimerthatincludesawiderangeofcustomerleasepaymentsandthefactthatthereisanescalationclauseforthe“fixed”leasepayments:
Systemsize,cost,andavailabilityvaryaccordingtolocation,electricityusage,andutilitycompany.A5kilowattsystemleasestartsat$40-$140permonthfor20yearsonapprovedcredit.Paymenttermsvaryandmayincludefixedpaymentsorescalatingpaymentsatarateof1.5-2.9%annuallyfor20years.Zerodueatleasesigning.Nosecuritydepositrequired.ContactSungevitySalesforafreecopyofourwrittenperformanceguarantee.
• Sunrun’swebsite(www.sunrun.com)prominentlystatesthatitscustomersare“typically
saving20%”andthat“electricityratesareskyrocketing”aswellasthefollowingstatements:“Noneedtobuy.AsolarleaseorPPAcanbeaslittleas$0down.”“AsaSunruncustomeryou’llsave20%ormoredependingonhowhighyourelectricratesare,howmuchsunshineyouget,andfinancialincentives.”“TheaverageU.S.homeownercouldsave$84amonthbygoingsolar.
![Page 14: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Insomestates,it’smorelike$150amonth.”“Over20years,savingscanreach$20,000ormore.”Thewebpagewiththelargeprintreferenceto20%savings,includesanasterisktothefollowingstatement:
*SavingsclaimbasedonaverageSunruncontractsignedbeforeSeptember15,2014,paymentbyautomaticdebit,andanassumedannualutilityrateincreaseof3.5%.Actualsavingswillvary.Savingsdependsonseveralfactors,includingproducttype,systemproduction,geography,weather,shade,electricityusage,andutilitystructuresandrateincreases.Seesunrun.com/save20fordetails.
Sunrunoffersloans,outrightpurchase,leases,PPAs,andaprepaidoption.Thereisno
presentationofthecontractdocumentsonthewebsite.Withregardtochoosingamongthevariousoptions,Sunrunpresentsaseriesofquestionsthatpromotethe“payasyougo”and“norecurringbill”options.WithrespecttothechoicebetweenaleaseorPPA,thereisadisclosurethatthisoptionisdependentonthestatelawatthecustomer’sresidence.Whileseveralstatementsaremadewithregardto“flatmonthlypayments,”thereisnomentionofanypriceescalationincontract.
• SolarCityisthelargestresidentialsolarcompany.Onitswebsite(www.solarcity.com)the
CompanyidentifiestheStatesinwhichitoperatesandofferspurchase,loans,leaseandPPAswithexplanationsofeach.Unlikeothersolarcompanywebsites,SolarCityincludesactualPPAandleasedocumentsavailableforreviewbycustomers.SolarCitypromotessolarprimarilyasameansofreducingcarbonemissions.While“savings”aregenerallypromotedtoprospectivecustomers,theonlyspecificexampleisamentionofasavingsofupto40%ontheentirehomeenergybillwithasolarloan,butingeneralthewebsiteoptionsstatethatpaymentswillbelessthanthemonthlyelectricitybill.Whiletheactualleaseorcontractdocumentsreferenceapaymentescalationrate,thereisnoreferencetothisfeatureonthewebsiteorinpromotionalstatements
• Vivint(www.vivintsolar.com)emphasizespayinglessforelectricityandincludesabargraph
comparingmonthlyelectricbillsversussolarpoweredelectricbillsinHawaii,astatewithhighelectricityratesthatisnottypicalofotherjurisdictions.TheCompanyemphasizesacontractwithazerodownpayment,withafineprintreferenceto“forqualifiedcustomers.”Whilethechartpresentsapurported20yearsavingsestimate,thefineprintsaysthechartisnotbasedonactualsavings.Thewebsitedoesnotincludesamplecontractsoranyexplanationofhowcustomerpaymentsescalateovertime.TheonlypurchaseoptionexplainedonthewebsiteisaPPA(“OurPowerPurchaseAgreement(PPA)isthereasonwecanofferyouanaffordablesolarsolution.Youagreetopayforthepowerourarrayproduces,andweagreetodesign,install,finance,andserviceasolarenergysystemforyourhome.”).TheCompanyalsopromotescustomerquotationsandsavingsexperiencesonitswebsite.
Evenacasualreviewofthesewebsitesconfirmsthatthereareamyriadoffactorsto
considerandweighinacustomer’schoicetoinstallsolarpower.Thereisthepotentialforconsumerstobeconvincedtobuyorleasesystemsunderunfavorableloanorleasetermsthatdonotactuallyproducesavingsatthelevelpromotedinsalesandmarketingmaterials.Asdescribedinoneconsumereducationpiece:“[W]ithsomanysolarfinancingoptionsnowavailable,themarketplacefortheseproductshasbecomeincreasinglycomplex.Itcanbehardtochooseamongthedifferentpackagesandvendors.Thedifferencebetweenthemmaynotbereadilyapparent.Somecontractsarefilledwith
![Page 15: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
confusingtechnicaljargon,andkeytermscanbeburiedinthefineprintofacustomercontact.”9B. ITISDIFFICULTFORCUSTOMERSTODETERMINETHEIROVERALLSAVINGSFROMINVESTINGINSOLARPRIORTOENTERINGINTOAPURCHASE,LOAN,LEASEORPPA
Thesalespitchissimpleenough—thecostofinvestinginsolarwillresultinsavingsonthemonthlyelectricbillthatoffset,ormorethanoffset,themonthlypaymentforthesolarsystem.Solarpowersystemsarealsomarketedtoresidentialcustomersasameansofloweringpollutionfromtraditionalpowerplantsandcontributingtothecallforreducingcarbonemissionsandhelpavoidglobalwarming.
Theimpactofarooftopsolarsystemonacustomer’sfutureelectricbillisnotsimple.
EstimatingfutureenergypricesandtheoutputofasolarPVsystemisnecessarilydependentonassumptionsandpredictions,aswellastheveracityandqualificationsofthesolarmarketersandinstallers.Inadditiontotheactuallease,PPAorloanterms,aconsumer’sactualmonthlysavingsinenergybillswilldependsignificantlyontheincreaseinelectricityratesoverthecontractterm,anynetmeteringorvalueofsolartariffprograms,aswellasneworincreasedfixedchargesorothernonbypassablefeesandsurcharges.Anyavailabletaxcredits,rebatesorotherincentivesapplicabletothecustomer’sinstallationwilllowertheoverallcostofthesystem.Propersiting,sizing,installation,andperformanceofthesystemisalsoessentialfortheconsumertoachievethemaximumsavingsattheleastcost.
Toillustratethepointofhowprojectedsavingsvarygivenassumptionsaboutfutureutilityrates,considerthefindingsinanarticleontheMotleyFoolwebsite.InAprilof2014theMotleyFoolobtainedquotesonsolarleasesfromSolarCityforhomesinConnecticutandCalifornia.10TheSolarCityquotesassumedelectricityratesinbothjurisdictionswouldriseatarateof4.8%eachyear.TheMotleyFoolfound:“Ifweusethehistoricalcompound20-yeargrowthrateofelectricity,theConnecticutquotestillresultsinsignificantsavingsovertwodecades,butfarlessthanthe$23,942quotedbySolarCity.TheCaliforniaquotewouldactuallyresultinahighercostofelectricityfromsolarusingthehistoricalaveragegrowthrate.”
AnexamplefromconsumereducationalmaterialsdevelopedbytheAgCenteratLouisianaStateUniversitygivesahypotheticalexampleoftwodifferentfinancingoptions.Comparingthetwooptions,theexampleshowsonescenariowheremonthlypaymentsforsolarwouldbe$16higherthantheinitialmonthlyelectricbill,andanothernettingsavingsof$30permonth.Again,thesavingstoconsumersarehighlydependentontheriseinthepriceofelectricity:“Maintenanceexpensesmaybeincurred,andproductionvarieswithweatherandshadechanges.Electricityratescouldrisemorethanexpected,whichwouldincreasetheannualsavingsfromthesolarpowerproducedandshortenthepaybackperiod.Conversely,ifutilityelectricratesfallorexpensesrise,thereversehappens(savingswouldbelessandthepaybackperiodlengthened).”11
![Page 16: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Gettinganestimateiscrucial,butcomparisonshoppingamongthevariouspurchase
andloanoptionsisdifficult.Itisunderstandablydifficulttogiveconsumersquotesovertheinternet,givenallthefactorsthatmustbeconsideredinsizingandpricingasolarsystem.Manysolarinstallersareeagertogiveconsumersquotesbasedonanactualevaluationofthecustomer’sproperty,butacustomerwouldhavetoobtainsuchinformationfromseveralsolarcompaniesandavarietyofsolarpurchase,loan,orleaseoptionstocomparetheimpactontheirmonthlyelectricbill.Astheexamplesaboveshow,solarprovidersusedifferingestimatesofthefuturepriceincreasesforelectricity—thehighertheestimatedpriceincreases,themorecosteffectivesolarbecomes.Consumersmaynotunderstandthatevenaftergettingavarietyofcostestimatestheymaynotbeabletocomparethemonan“applestoapples”basis,giventhevaryingassumptionsmadebyeachprovider.
Thereareafew“savingscalculators”availabletoconsumersthatarenotdirectlyassociatedwithanysolarcompany.TheCaliforniaEnergyCommissionhaslaunchedtheSolarAdvantageValueEstimator,orSAVE.Thetool“estimatesthepresentvalueofasolarphotovoltaic(PV)system;providingamethodtocalculatetheenergysavingsvalueofasolarsystemincludingtheestimatedvalueinannualenergysavings.TheCaliforniaEnergyCommissiondevelopedSAVEinresponsetoexpressedinterestfromrealestateprofessionals,andotherstakeholders.”12ThecalculatorworksforCaliforniaaddressesonly.Itusesa2%annualescalationinenergyprices.TheNationalRenewableEnergyLabsNRELPVwattscalculator13offersdefaultsettings(unlikeCASAVE)andalsoincludesinformationonallavailablefederalandstateincentives.
Amorecustomer-friendlyoptionthatallowsconsumerstocomparequotesonan
“applestoapples”basisisEnergySage.14ThiswebsitehasthesupportandbackingoftheU.S.DepartmentofEnergy,NewYorkStateEnergyResearch&DevelopmentAuthority,ConnecticutGreenBank,andMassachusettsCleanEnergyCenter.Accordingtothewebsite,“EnergySagegetsyouquotesfrommultiplequalifiedinstallers,calculatestheimportantfinancialmetricsandmakesiteasytocompareyourquotessoyougetagreatdeal!Allatnocost!”EnergySagestatesthatitprescreensinstallersbasedon“reputation,experienceandqualityofservices.”Thewebsitesaysitsstaffwillanswerquestionsand“helpguideyourdecision.”
Yet,eventhebestsavingscalculatorcannotprovideanaccurateestimateofsavings,
becausetherearesimplytoomanyvariables.Theseincludethelocationandconditionofthehome,shade,conditionoftheroof,localrestrictions,sizeofthesystem,escalationofpayments,insurance,taxes,repairs,maintenance,andmore.Additionalconsiderationsincludethecertificationandreputationoftheinstaller,responsibilityformakingrepairs,homeownerassociationrestrictions,andresponsibilityforroofdamage,tonameafew.
![Page 17: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
C. FEDERALANDSTATEINCENTIVESIMPACTCUSTOMERPAYMENTSANDSAVINGSFORSOLAR Thistransactionismadeevenmorecomplicatedbytheexistenceoffederal,state,andlocalsubsidiesassociatedwiththeinstallationofrooftopsolarsystems,someofwhicharetemporaryinnatureandcanexpireorbechanged.
Federalsubsidies:Certainresidentialdistributedgenerationinvestments15receiveaninvestmenttaxcredit(ITC)of30%ofeligiblecosts,withnoupperlimit(exceptforfuelcells).Rentalpropertydoesnotqualifyforthetaxcredit.Ataxcreditreducestheamountoftaxesowedbyataxpayeronaone-timebasis.Forexample,ifthevalueoftheITCwere$6,500andthefederaltaxowedwere$6,500,thetaxpayerwouldpaynotaxfortheyear.SinceitwasfirstenactedintheEnergyPolicyActof2005theITChasbeenextendedandexpanded.TheCongressionalResearchServiceestimatesthattherevenuecosttothefederalgovernmentoftheITCwas$500millioninFY2013and$600millioninFY2014.
ThemarketvalueofsolarcompaniesisheavilydependentonthefederalITCbenefit.As
reportedbySEIA,BloombergNewEnergyFinanceestimatedthatiftheITCexpiredinstalledsolarcapacitywoulddecreasebynearly8gigawattsin2017,comparedto2016levels.16Therefore,theCongressionalactionthatadoptedafive-yearextensionoftheITCinlate2015omnibusbudgetlegislationwasasignificantfactorintheclaimsofsolarlobbyrepresentativesthatitwouldallowfora$133billioninnew,privatesectorinvestmentsintheU.S.economyby2020.17ItistypicalunderleaseandPPAagreementsforthethird-partyownertoclaimthevalueofthistaxcredit.Thus,theresidentialcustomerdoesnotdirectlyclaimthetaxcredit,butmustrelyonthesolarprovidertorealizethevalueofthetaxcreditinthetermsofthetransaction.181920
Stateandlocalsubsidiesandincentives:Stateandlocalgovernmentsprovideavarietyoffinancialandpolicyincentivestobothresidentialandcommercialcustomersforsolarinstallations.Financialincentivesaretypicallydefinedasdirectpayments(suchasrebates),taxcredits,andsubsidizedloans.Policyorregulatoryincentivesincludetheapprovednetmeteringpolicyorvalueofsolartariff.Solarinstallationsmayalsobesubjecttolocallicensingandpermittingstandardsandfeesthatcouldimpactthecostofthesystem.
Stateandlocalfinancialincentivescansignificantlyreducecoststoconsumersinstallingsolarsystemsorotherdistributedgeneration.Asearchofanationaldatabaseofrenewableenergyandsolarenergyincentivesandstateregulatorypoliciesforresidentialincentivesrelatedtosolaridentified612stateandlocalprogramsacrossthecountry.21
Accordingtothe50StatesofSolarreport:“Atthestatelevel,thegeneraltrendsarethatsolarrebateincentivesaredecreasing,solartaxincentivesareexpiring,renewableportfoliostandardsarenearingtheir
![Page 18: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
targets,netmeteringcapsarebeingreached,andnetmeteringandratedesignareundergoingregulatoryandlegislativereview.”22
Changesinstateandlocalsubsidiesandincentivesforsolarinstallationswillalterthefinancialtermsofthesolarprovider’scontractandleaseoptions,includinginsomeinstancesforexistingcontracts.Sincethevalueofsolartothecustomerisprimarilylinkedtosavingsinenergyexpenditures,theinteractionsamongtheapplicablesubsidiesandincentivepaymentsisnotknowntomostcustomersandgenerallynottransparentinthepaymenttermsofthesolarprovider’scontractdocuments.
![Page 19: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
CHAPTERIII:THECASEFORADOPTINGCONSUMERPROTECTIONSFORSOLARPOWERTRANSACTIONS
RecentStateAttorneyGeneralenforcementactivities,Statelegislativereforms,andnationalpublicityhaveheightenedaninterestinunderstandingandconfrontingtheneedforspecificconsumerprotectionpoliciesforresidentialsolartransactions.23
Thereareseveralstateandfederallysponsoredpublicationsandweb-based
resourcesthatattempttoprovideunbiasedconsumereducationalmaterialsaimedathelpingresidentialcustomersunderstandthevarioussolarsystemtransactionsandcomparethevariousfinancialmodels.24Whilevaluable,consumereducationcannotsubstituteforstateoversightincludingspecificdisclosureandcontracttermregulationsgoverningthesecomplexdocuments.ArecentarticlebyanationalmediawebsitedevotedtorenewableandsolarenergydevelopmentssummarizestheseconcernsandinitiativesandhighlightedrecentlegislationadoptedinArizonaandthecallsfromsomeU.S.Congressmentoseekgreateroversight.25
ThisChapterdocumentsthenatureofthecustomerconcerns,StateAttorneyGeneralenforcementactivities,andasummaryoftheCaliforniaandArizonastatutorypoliciestogoverncertainaspectsofresidentialsolartransactions.AppendixAprovidesasummaryofotherproposedstatelegislationtoadoptconsumerprotectionsforcertainsolartransactionsconsideredin2015,butthatwerenotadopted.A. CUSTOMERCOMPLAINTSANDREVIEWS Inlightofthecomplexityofsolarenergycontractterms,thesignificantcoststoconsumers,andthesite-specificnatureofanyanalysisofcostsandbenefitsorimpactsonacustomer’selectricbill,itwouldnotbesurprisingforsomecustomerstofilecomplaints,buttheymaynotknowwheretoturn.CustomersmightfindtheirwaytotheStateAttorneyGeneral’sconsumeroffice,typicallythesectionoftheAttorneyGeneral’sofficethatdealswithunfairtradepracticeissues.OthercustomersmightfileacomplaintwiththelocalBetterBusinessBureau.Severalweb-basedcomplaintorcustomersatisfaction-ratingservicesreportoncustomercomplaintsaboutsolarinstallationandcontractterms. InDecember2013,GreenTechMediapublishedareviewofthetopfivesolarinstallersbasedoncustomercommentsandreviewsmaintainedbyYELP,apopularcustomerreviewwebsite.26ThereviewfocusedoncustomerratingsofSolarCity,VerengoSolar,VivintSolar,RECSolarandSungevityinCalifornia.Asaresultofthereviewofnegativecommentsaboutanyofthesesolarcompanies,theauthorconcluded,“Clearly,upsetcustomersweremostannoyedwithpushysalestacticsandhiddenfeesincontracts.Themostpositivereviewscamefrompeoplewhofeltliketheentireprocesswastransparent.”
Notingthatupto10%ofthetotalcostofthesolarsystemisestimatedtobecustomeracquisitioncosts,theauthornoted,“Reducingthosecostsmeanscrafting
![Page 20: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
bettermanagementsoftwareandmoreattractivefinancingoptions,aswellasfindingnewretailoutletsviawhichtoreachconsumers.Butgettingcustomerstoactuallysignacontractrequirestraditionalsalestacticslikedoor-to-doorvisits,phonecallsandadvertising.”Also,theauthor,relyingonhisanecdotalexperience,statedthathehadheardfarmorepositivereviewsabouttheinstallationprocessthannegative,butthat“hardsalestacticsaretheuncomfortablerealityofcustomeracquisition."
AnotherwebsitethatpublishescustomerreviewsandexperienceswithsolarinstallersandsolarcompaniesisConsumerAffairs.27Thiswebsiteinformsviewersthatitacceptscommercialadvertisementsforitswebsite,butstatesthatitdoesnotreflecttheirreviewsorcustomercomments.Whilethereisnointenttosuggestthatthenegativecommentsorcomplaintsreflectedonthisoranyotherwebsiterepresentsastatisticallyvalidindicatororthattherearewidespreadnegativeexperiences,thefactthatnegativecommentsandcomplaintsexistcanprovidearedflagtosuggesttheneedforreforms.ThenegativecommentsaboutsolarinstallersreflectawiderrangeofissuescomparedtothosenotedaboveinthereviewofYELPdatafrom2013dueinparttoitsinclusionofmorerecentsolarmarketingactivitiesinmultiplestates.Inadditiontocommentsaboutpushysalestacticsandlackofclearexplanationofcontracttermsandfees,thesereviewersdescribedclaimsofsavingsontheelectricbillthatdidnotoccur(“IwastoldIwouldbeoffthegrid.”);disputesaboutdamagestotherooforinoperablesystemsthatwerenotrepairedinatimelymanner;delaysininstallation;andmisrepresentationofthetransaction.FromaMassachusettscustomer:
“Backin2013[]notifiedmeandtoldmeIqualifyforsolarpanelsbecauseIwasalowincomefamily.Theyputthesolarpanelson.Ireceivedabillforquitealot.Icalledthem.TheytoldmeIamina20yearcontractonlease.Nobodynevermentionedanyofthistome.TheytoldmeIsignedthepaper.Itwasfineprint.IfeelthatIwastrickedandcoercedintodoingthis.Iwanteveryoneouttheretobeawareofthesepeople.Theyarenothingbutaripoff.SonowIsitherestuckwitha20yearcontractwithanextrabilleachmonth.IfIknewanyofthisupfrontofcourseIwouldn'thavedoneanyofthis.Theyarenothingbutaripoff.Ifyouseethemcomingruntheotherway.”
B. STATEATTORNEYGENERALENFORCEMENTACTIONSANDCIVILSUITS
TheAttorneysGeneralinseveralstateshavetakenactionagainstsolarcompaniesandsolarinstallersusingtheirauthorityunderexistingstatelawsonfraudanddeceptivetradepractices:
• TheAttorneyGeneralofArizonahassettledacriminalcomplaintagainstasolarretailerthatmarketedsolarpanelinstallationspromisingrebatesfromthelocalutilitythatwerenotdeliveredeventhoughtheutilitypaidtheretailertherequiredrebate.Over$1millioninrestitutionwasmadeavailabletocustomers,butthelocalutility’ssolarrebateprogramisnowdefunct.28
• TheAttorneyGeneralofArizonahasalsosettledaconsumerfraudcasefiledagainstasolar
energyinstallerthatmadethousandsoftelemarketingcalls,conductedhighpressuresalespresentations,andsoldproductsthatdidnotresultinthepromisedreductioninenergy
![Page 21: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
bills.ManyofthecustomerswhocalledtheAttorneyGeneraltocomplainaboutthissolarproviderhadactuallyexperienceincreasedelectricbillsaftertheinstallationofsolarpanelsduetoequipmentcosts.29
• TheAttorneyGeneralofMassachusettsannouncedasettlementwithSoltasEnergy
Corporationoverallegationsthatitviolatedthestate’sConsumerProtectionandFalseClaimsactsbyfailingtohonoragreementstosellnetmeteringcredits.
• In2014theLouisianaAttorneyGeneralinvestigatedSaderPowerEnterprisesforalleged
violationsoftheLouisianaUnfairTradePracticesActrelatingtoallegationsthatSadermisledconsumersabouttheamountofcostsavingsfromtheuseofsolarequipmentandthecostsofleasingtheequipment.
• A2013classactionlawsuitispendingagainstSunruninaLosAngeles,CASuperiorCourt
thatallegesthatthissolarprovider,oneoftheleadingprovidersofsolarleasesandpowerpurchaseagreements,ismakingfalseclaimsabouttheprojectedriseinelectricityprices.30
Somedisgruntledcustomershavefiledtheirowncivilactionsagainstsolarcompanies.InLouisianaaclassactionwasfiledagainstSaderPower,allegingunfairtradepracticesbypromisingclaimsofsubstantialsavingsoncustomerelectricbills,butsomecustomersendeduppayingmorefortheirmonthlyelectricbillaftergettingsolarpanels.ThislawsuitisstillpendinginU.S.DistrictCourtforEasternDistrictofLouisiana.31 C. LEGISLATIVEINITIATIVES Inmoststates,theAttorneyGeneralhasauthorityoversolarmarketingandsalesactivitiesbycommercialentities,includingsolarproviders,aspartoftheirUnfairTradePracticestatutes.Thesestatutestypicallyapplytoconsumertransactionsgenerallyandprohibitunfairanddeceptivetradepractices.Asindicatedabove,severalAttorneysGeneralhavemadeuseofthisauthoritytoinitiateinvestigationsandbringformalenforcementactionsagainstseveralsolarproviders.However,thesegenericconsumerprotectionstatutesdonottypicallyreflectspecificdisclosureandcontracttermsthatarespecifictosolarsystemmarketingandsalesactivities.Asaresult,severalstateshaveconsidered,butfewhaveadopted,morecomprehensiveregulatoryprogramsthatlinkthetraditionalunfairtradepracticepolicieswithspecificenergyand/orregulatedutilityoversight. Californiaadoptedspecificdisclosureobligationsforsolarprovidersin2008.Thesedisclosures,whileminimal,providesomekeyprotectionsforconsumers:
Anindependentsolarenergyproducercontractingfortheuseorsaleofelectricityortheleaseofasolarenergysystem,toanentityorperson,foruseinaresidenceshallincludeadisclosuretothebuyerorlesseethat,ataminimum,includesallofthefollowing:
• Agoodfaithestimateofthekilowatthourstobedeliveredbythesolarenergysystem.• Aplainlanguageexplanationofthetermsunderwhichthepricingwillbecalculated
overthelifeofthecontractandagoodfaithestimateofthepriceperkilowatthour.
![Page 22: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
• Aplainlanguageexplanationofoperationandmaintenanceresponsibilitiesofthecontractparties.
• Aplainlanguageexplanationofthecontractprovisionsregulatingthedispositionortransferofthecontractintheeventofatransferofownershipoftheresidence,aswellasthecostsorpotentialcostsassociatedwiththedispositionortransferofthecontract.
• Aplainlanguageexplanationofthedispositionofthesolarenergysystemattheendofthetermofthecontract.
Further,thisstatuteauthorizesthePublicUtilityCommissiontorequiresolar
energyproviderstoprovideadditionaldisclosurestoabuyerorlesseeasaconditionofreceivingratepayer-fundedincentives.
Thelawalsorequiressolarenergycompaniestorecordanoticewhensolarelectricityproducingequipmentisinstalledonresidentialproperty.Thecodeisquitespecificthatsuchnoticeshallberecorded“againstthetitle”totherealproperty.Thecodealsosaysthatthisnotice“doesnotconstituteatitledefect,lien,orencumbranceagainsttherealproperty”.
Arizonamostrecentlyadoptedlegislationin2015,withthestatutetotakeeffectonJanuary1,2016.32Whiletherearenospecificprovisionsregardingcomplaintsandenforcement,thenewrequirementsamendTitle44(Chapter11,RegulationofParticularBusinesses),asectionofArizona’slawthatisundertheenforcementpowersoftheAttorneyGeneral.
Thenewstatutoryrequirementsincludespecificdisclosuresandcertaincontracttermsforthesale,lease,orfinancingofasolarenergydevicethatisintendedtobeusedprimarilyforon-siteconsumption.Anysuchagreementmust:
a.Besignedanddatedbythepersonbuying,financingorleasingthesystem;b.Beinatleast10-pointtype;c.Includeaprovisiongrantingthebuyerorlesseetherighttorescindtheagreementwithinthreebusinessdaysaftertheagreementissignedandbeforethesystemisinstalled;d.Provideadescription,includingthemakeandmodeloraguaranteeconcerningenergyproductionoutputthatthesystemwouldprovide;e.Separatelysetforththetotalpurchasepriceorcostforthelifeoftheagreement,anyinterestorfeestobepaid,andthetotalnumberofpayments,paymentfrequency,theamountofpaymentandthepaymentduedate,ifthesystemisfinanced;f.Identifypotentialtaxobligations;g.Discloseandseparatelyidentifytaxincentivesandrebatesthebuyermaybeeligibleforandanyconditionsorrequirementstoobtainthesetaxincentives,rebatesorotherincentives;h.Disclosewhetherthewarrantyormaintenanceobligationsmaybesoldortransferredtoathirdparty;i.Discloseandseparatelyacknowledgetheabilitytomodifyortransferownershipofasystemortherealpropertytowhichthesystemisaffixed,includingwhetheranymodificationortransferissubjecttorevieworapprovalbyathirdpartyandincludethecontactinformationoftheentityresponsibleforapprovingormodifyingthetransfer;
![Page 23: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
j.Provideasummaryofthetotalcostsofoperating,maintaining,financingandconstructingthesystem;k.Provideanestimateoftheutilitychargesimpactedbypotentialutilityratechangesfromwithinplusorminus5%rangeofanannualincreaseordecreasefromcurrentutilitycostsiftheagreementcontainsanestimateofutilitychargeswiththeinstallationofasystem;andl.Includeadisclosurestatingutilityrates,structuresandprojectedsavingsaresubjecttochangeandtaxincentivesmaychangeorbeterminatedbyexecutive,legislativeorregulatoryaction.Thenewlawexemptsanindividualorcompany,actingthroughitsofficers,
employeesoragents,thatmarkets,sells,solicits,negotiatesorentersintoanagreementforthesale,financingorleaseofasystemaspartofatransactioninvolvingthesaleortransferofrealpropertytowhichthesystemisorwillbeaffixed.Finally,thestatutespecifiesthatanyagreementcontainingblankspaceswhensignedbythebuyerorlesseeisvoidableuntilthesystemisinstalled.
InadditiontothelegislationadoptedinArizonaandCalifornia,consumerprotectionlegislationrelatingtoresidentialsolarsystemswasintroduced,butnotadopted,inseveralstatesduringlegislativesessionsendingin2015includingIndiana33,Washington34,Louisiana35,andNevada.36Theselegislativeproposalsvariedindetailandspecificprovisions,butallincludeddisclosures,authorityforalicense,orregistrationwithagencyoversightandenforcement.AsummaryoftheselegislativeproposalsisincludedinAppendixAtothisReport.
D. STATEANDFEDERALGUIDANCEONENVIRONMENTALCLAIMS
Mostsolarprovidersmarkettheirproductsas“green”or“renewable”andmostconsumersbelievesolarisenvironmentallyfriendly,yetinactuality,theseclaimsmaynotbecompletelyaccurate.Questionsrelatingtohowsolarprovidersmarkettheirsolarsystemsbyclaimingrenewableor“green”energyattributeshasbeenaddressedbytheFederalTradeCommissionandinabulletinrecentlyissuedbytheVermontAttorneyGeneralentitled“GuidanceforThird-PartySolarProjects.”37Solarprovidersshouldnotclaimthattheirproductwillgivethecustomer“renewable”or“green”electricitysimplybecausethesolarpowergeneratedbythesystemhasvalueasaRenewableEnergyCertificate(REC).ARECisacertificatethatprovesthattheholderhasgeneratedorhaspurchasedelectricitywithcertainrenewableattributes.RECscanbeboughtandsoldinprivateandpublicmarketsandRECsareimportantattributestoensurecompliancewithstaterenewableenergymandatesandrequirements.However,unlesstheRECisspecificallyassociatedwithsolarenergy(which,insomestatesisregisteredasa“SolarREC”),theuseofaRECthatmayhaveattributesforrenewableenergyotherthansolarenergyshouldbecarefullydescribed.
TheVermontguidanceclearlystatesthatsolarproviders,includingcommunitysolarproviders,cannotpromoteprojectsasclean,renewableenergyifthesolarproviders
![Page 24: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
retainandthenselltherenewableenergycredits.Thatpracticeisknownas“doublecounting”theRECs,anditisdeceptive,accordingtothisGuidance.
E. PROPOSALSFORINDUSTRYSELF-REGULATIONAREINSUFFICIENTFORCONSUMERPROTECTION Tradeassociationsforcompaniesintheresidentialsolarelectricindustrytypicallyopposetheadoptionoflegislationorregulationsthatwouldimposespecificconsumerprotectionrequirements.Ratherthansubmittogovernmentregulation,tradeassociationsoftenpromoteindustryself-regulationasasubstitute.
Forexample,inapendingproceedingbeforetheNewYorkPublicServiceCommissiontoadoptcertainregistrationandconsumerprotectionrequirementsonsomeDistributedEnergyResource(DER)providers,theSolarEnergyIndustriesAssociation(SEIA)submittedcommentsinopposition:
Asthenationaltradeassociationforsolarenergythathasbeenworkingacrosstheleadershipoftheindustrytobuildaself-regulatoryframework,theSolarEnergyIndustriesAssociation(SEIA)stronglyencouragesthatNewYorkallowSEIAandthesolarindustrytoself-regulate,ratherthansubjecttheNewYorksolarindustrytowell-intentionedbutpotentiallycostlyregulations.Asawhole,theSEIASolarBusinessCode(Code)adoptedbySEIA’sBoardofDirectorsandpublishedSeptember14,2015,providesahigherlevelofconsumerprotectionthantherulesproposedbyPSCStaff(Staff)inthisMatter.38
SEIAhasadoptedaCodeofEthics,aswellasModelLeaseandPurchaseAgreementsdevelopedbytheNationalRenewableEnergyLaboratory.Mostrecently,SEIAhaspublishedaSEIASolarBusinessCodethatconsistsofTheCodeconsistsoffivesections:GuidingPrinciples;Unfair,Deceptive,orAbusiveActsorPractices(UDAAP);Advertising;SalesandMarketingInteractions;andContracts.39
SEIAanditsmembersadoptedtheCodewithoutpublicinputorparticipationand,asa
privateorganization,couldnotpossiblydosoinanycase.Thesefactssupportthepropositionthatany“regulations”or“codeofconduct”applicabletoretailsolarprovidersshouldbeundertakenbyagovernmentalagencywithnoticeandopportunityforallpartiesandinterestedpersonstoparticipateandhaveinput.SEIA’sCodedoesnotreflecttheinputforconsumerrepresentativesandgovernmentalagencieswiththenecessaryexpertise.
Theself-regulationofthisemergingconsumermarketisnotanadequatesubstitutefor
meaningfulandenforceablelawsandregulations.Theattemptatself-regulationbySEIAisatestamentthatthereisaneedforoversightofstandardsandenforcement.TheSEIAcode,whilerecognizingtheneedforsomeuniformityinstandardsanddisclosures,isneithersufficientnorcomprehensive.WhilemanyoftheprovisionsoftheCodewouldbebeneficialtoconsumers,theCodeisnotasufficientsubstitutebecauseitisvoluntaryandunenforceableinanypublicprocessthatwouldincludefinesorordersforrestitution.Finally,aprivatemembershiporganizationisunabletorequirenon-memberstocomplywithitsproposed
![Page 25: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
policiesandanymemberthatobjectedtoanyprovisionoftheCodeoranyattemptto“enforce”theCodecouldandlikelywouldseveritstiestotheorganization.
AppendixBisamoredetailedcritiqueoftheSEIACode.
![Page 26: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
CHAPTERIV:RECOMMENDATIONSFORCONSUMERPROTECTIONPOLICIESANDMANDATESFORRESIDENTIALSOLARTRANSACTIONS
ThisChapterrecommendsstatelawand/orregulationstogoverntheretailsalesofsolarpowertoresidentialcustomersforinstallationonacustomer’sresidence,typicallyonthecustomer’sroof.ChapterVaddressescertainuniquefeaturesassociatedwithcommunitysolarprograms,butitisintendedthatthedisclosureandoversightpoliciesrecommendedinthisChaptershouldalsobeconsideredforcommunitysolarprograms.Nosellerofgoodsandservicesshouldcommitunfairtradepractices,makedeceptivedisclosures,ormisrepresenttheproductorserviceinmarketingandsalesactivities.Theseproposalsarespecifictosolarleaseandsaletransactions,withspecificdisclosuresandcontractualprovisionsthatflowfromthelongstandingconsumerprotectionpoliciesthathavegovernedretailsalesofproductsandservicestoresidentialcustomers.Inaddition,theserecommendationsareintendedtocomplementexistingstateandfederalconsumerprotectionlawsandregulationsthatapplytotelemarketingsalescallsanddoor-to-doormarketingtoresidentialcustomers,aswellasfederalfinancialtransactionlawsanddisclosuresthatapplytoloansissuedbyregulatedfinancialinstitutions.Theserecommendationsalsodonottakeprecedenceoverexistingstateorlocalhomeconstructionandrepairregulationsthatmaybeapplicabletotheinstallationforsolaronacustomer’shome.
TheproposedpoliciesinthisReportareorganizedinthefollowingtopics:
A. RegistrationorLicensing;StateAgencyAuthority
B. Disclosures:ACustomerTemplate
C. ContractProvisions
E. SalesandMarketingConduct
E. EnforcementandPenalties;CustomerComplaints
A. REGISTRATIONANDLICENSING
Apersonshallnotsell,leaseorinstallarooftopsolarsystemoracommunitysolarsystemorsellelectricitygeneratedbysuchsystemsunlessthepersonhasregisteredwiththeCommissionbysubmittingaformasprescribedbytheCommission.
1.TheCommissionshalladoptregulations:
(a)RequiringaregistrationformsubmittedtotheCommissiontoinclude:
(1)thename,streetaddress,mailingaddress,electronicmailaddressandtelephonenumberoftheregistrant;
![Page 27: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
(2)thenameandcontactinformationofanyregisteredagentoranypersondesignatedbytheregistranttoreceivenoticesandothercommunicationsfromtheCommission;
(3)thename,address,andtitleofeachofficerordirector;
(4)ifthecompanyispubliclytraded,thecompany'smostrecentannualreportfiledwiththeUnitedStatessecuritiesandexchangecommission;
(5)ifthecompanyisnotpubliclytraded,thecompany'scurrentbalancesheet;
(6)thecompany'slatestannualreport,ifany;
(7)astatementdescribingeachactivitydescribedinthischapter/sectioninwhichtheregistrantintendstoengage;
(8)astatementdescribingeachjurisdictionwheretheregistrantoritsaffiliateoperates;
(9)astatementdescribingthemanagerialandtechnicalqualificationsoftheregistrant;and
(10)anyotherinformationrequiredbytheCommission;
(b)RequiringaregistranttosubmittotheCommission:
(1)Anexampleofeachconsumercontractandagreementforthesale,loan,lease,orpurchaseagreementinwhichtheregistranthasindicatedheorsheintendstoengage;and
(2)Anupdatedexampleoftheagreementifapreviouslysubmittedexampleisnolongerreasonablyaccurateoriftheregistrantintendstoengageinanactivitydescribedinthischapter/sectionforwhichtheregistranthasnotyetsubmittedanexampleofanagreement;
(c)RequiringaregistranttosubmittotheCommissionanamendedregistrationformifanyinformationprovidedtotheCommissiononaregistrationformorapreviouslysubmittedamendedregistrationformisnolongercorrect;and
(d)Providingthetimeperiodwithinwhichanupdatedexampledescribedaboveoranamendedregistrationformmustbesubmitted.
2.Thecommissionmayrejectanapplicationthatdoesnotcontainallinformationrequiredbythissectionorbycommissionrule.
3.Thecommissionmusttakeactiontoapproveordenyanyapplicationforregistrationwithin_______daysafterreceivingtheapplication.Thecommissionmayapprovesuchapplicationwithorwithoutahearing.Thecommissionmaydenysuchapplicationaftera
![Page 28: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
hearingwhenitfindsthatthecompanyoritsregisteredagenthasviolatedthischapterortherulesofthecommission,orthecompanyoritsregisteredagenthasbeenfoundbyacourtorgovernmentalagencytohaveviolatedthelawsofastateortheUnitedStates.
4.Thecommissionmaychargeaone-timeapplicationfeetorecoverthecostofprocessingapplicationsforregistrationunderthissection.
5.Thecommissionshalladoptrulestoestablishthecompanies'responsibilitiesforrespondingtocustomercomplaintsanddisputes.
6.Thecommissionshalladoptannualreportingrequirements.
7.Thesolarpowercompanymustkeepitscustomerrecords,includingcustomercontractsandagreements,availableforinspectionbythecommissionforfiveyears;
8.Thesolarpowercompanymustcooperatewithcommissioninvestigationsofcustomercomplaints;
7.Thecommissionmayconductinvestigationsandmaysuspendorrevokearegistration,and/orimposefeeorpenaltiesuponcomplaintbyanyinterestedparty,includingthestateutilityconsumeradvocate,oruponthecommission'sownmotionafternoticeandopportunityforhearing,whenitfindsthattheregisteredcompanyoritsagenthasviolatedthischapter,therulesofthecommission,orthecompanyoritsregisteredagenthasbeenfoundbyacourtorgovernmentalagencytohaveviolatedthelawsofastateortheUnited
States.
B. DISCLOSURES
Asolarprovidershallaccuratelyandcompletelydescribetheproposedtransactioninitsmarketingmaterialsandtermsofserviceandshallnotincludeanypromisesorsuggestionsofbenefitsthatarenototherwiseincludedinthecontractualtermsandconditions.Asolarprovidershallbeheldtocomplywithitsdisclosuresifthereisanyconflictwiththeunderlyingcontractualtermsandconditions.
ThecommissionshalldevelopamodelConsumerDisclosureTemplatethatisprovidedinaseparatedocumentofatleast12pointtypeandthatmustbeusedbylicensed(or
DISCUSSION:Consumerprotectionsarenoteffectiveunlessagovernmentalagencyhastheauthoritytoinvestigatecomplaintsandtakeactionagainstbadactors,andsuchenforcementcannotoccurwithoutregistrationorlicensing.Regulatorsshouldknowhowtocontactauthorizedrepresentatives,investigatethebackgroundofabusiness,andtakeactionagainstaproviderforviolationsofstatelawsandregulations.ThisReportrecommendsthepublicutilitycommissionasthemostlikelyfocusforoversightandenforcement,butrecognizesthatanalternativeagencyorarrangementcouldbeappropriatelyidentified.
![Page 29: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
registered,whereapplicable)solarprovidersthatwillinclude,ataminimum,thefollowinginformation,andseparatelysignedanddatedbythepersonbuying,financing,orleasingthesolarenergysystem:
1. Theexpectedamountofelectricitythatwillbeproducedbythesolarenergysystem.Thebuyerorlesseeshallbeprovidedwithagoodfaithestimateofthenumberofkilowatthoursthatwillbedeliveredbythesolarelectricsystemonamonthlyandannualbasis,togetherwithadescriptionofthewarrantiesandlimitations,ifany,affectingtheestimate.
2. Totheextentthatthesolarproviderhaspromotedthesale,lease,orfinancingforacustomer’ssolarsystemasameanstosaveorlowerthecustomer’selectricitybill,theprovidershallincludethemethodologyandestimatedresultoftheproposedtransactiononthecustomer’selectricitybill,usingamethodologyforestimatingthefuturepriceofelectricitythatisapprovedbythecommission.Suchanestimateshallbeprovidedforthelengthofthefinancialtransaction.
3. Allofthecostsassociatedwithinstallingthesolarenergysystemincludingbutnotlimitedtoanytaxesthebuyerorlesseewillberequiredtopayaspartofanypurchaseorleaseagreement.
4. Agoodfaithestimateoftheimpactoftheinstallationofthesolarenergysystemonthevalueofthehomeaswellasagoodfaithestimateofanyapplicablepropertytaxes,suchestimatestobebasedonadisclosedmethodologyordata.
5. Thevalueofallfederal,state,andlocaltaxcredits,electricutilityratecredits,RenewableEnergyCredits,incentives,orrebatesthatthebuyerorlesseemayreceiveorsignover,ifapplicable.
6. Agoodfaithestimateofeachfinancialbenefitthebuyerorlesseewillreceiveorwaiveuponsigninganagreement,includingtaxcredits,electricutilityratecredits,incentives,subsidies,orrebatesandinformationregardingtheallocationofresponsibilityforpaymentsifandwheneachofthesefinancialbenefitsexpiresorismodified.
7. Theexpectedrateofcompensationforanyelectricityproducedbythesolarpowersystemandsoldtothecustomer’selectricutility,includingthecurrentreimbursementrateoftheelectricutilityatthetimeofsigningacontract,withadisclaimerthatthecurrentreimbursementrateissubjecttochange.
8. Ifretailnetmeteringorasimilartariffisinplaceatthetimeofthesaleorlease,anoticeinformingthebuyerorlesseethatadditionalchargesfordistribution,transmission,orstand-bygenerationmaybeimposedinthefutureifapprovedbythecommission,orbychangestostatelaw.
9. Thefullextentofpaymentsandinterestratesortheescalationofpaymentsoverthelifeofthesaleorleaseagreement.
10. Agoodfaithestimateoftheanticipatedvalueofanyassetsthatremainwithalesseeattheendoftheleaseagreementifapplicable.
11. Informationonthepotentialfireandotherhomesafetyrisksofasolarelectricsystem,andanexplanationofhowoperationsofthesolarelectricsystemcould
![Page 30: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
affecthomeappliancesandequipmentintheeventthatthesystemisoperatingwithoutbackuporsupportfromtheutilitygrid.
12. Informationonwhetherthesaleorleaseagreementinsuresthesolarpowersystemagainstdamageorlossandunderwhatcircumstancesthecompanydoesnotinsureorcoverdamagesorlossofthesystem.
13. Astatementthatthebuyerorlesseeshoulddeterminewhetherhomeownerinsurancerateswillbeaffectedbytheinstallationofthesolarpowersystem.
14. Astatementthatthebuyerorlesseeshoulddeterminewhetherahomeowner’sassociationhasanyrestrictionsontheinstallationofasolarpowersystem.
15. Adisclosureonwhethertheleaseagreementprotectsagainstanydamageorlosstothelessee’srealandpersonalpropertyandhowtheinstallationofthesolarpowersystemmayimpacthomeinsuranceagreementsandratesandotherwarranties.
16. Astatementthattherearecostsfortheremovalortemporaryremovalofasolarelectricsystemincaseofroofrepairorreplacementduetoweather,wearandtear,orotherevents.Thebuyerorlesseeshallbegiveninformationonthecoststhecompanywillcoverandwillnotcoverintheeventtheroofneedsmaintenanceand,inthecaseofaleaseagreement,whetherthelesseeisrequiredtomakeanyleaseagreementpaymentsduringthetimethesolarelectricsystemisinoperableduetoroofmaintenance.
17. Informationexplainingthetermsoftheleaseagreementincasesofinoperabilityduetoproductmalfunctionsordefects.
18. Thecoststothebuyerorlesseeofanyadditionalmeteringequipmentorequipmentusedtoconnectthesolarpowersystemtothehomeorgrid,includinginstallation,removal,ormaintenanceandcleaningareaafterconstruction,installation,andremoval.
19. Astatementofthecompany’spolicyontheuseofcustomerdataasitrelatestoelectricityusage,production,andpersonalinformationandwhethersuchinformationisorcouldbesharedwithanyadditionalparties,withtheconditionsandmethodsofsuchsharingidentified.
20. Informationregardingthechangeintermsofleaseagreementintheeventofthesaleofthehomeorintheeventofthedeathofthelessee,andwhetherandunder
whatcircumstancestheleaseistransfer-able.
DISCUSSION:Thelegislation(orregulation)shouldnotmerelylisttheitemsthatmustbedisclosedtothecustomerbecausesuchadirectivemayresultinincludingthedisclosurerequirementsinamulti-pagecontract,typicallywritteninfineprintandwithtechnicaltermsandjargon.SimilartotheproposalforaConsumerTemplateinonelegislativeproposal,theregulatorycommissionshoulddevelopamodelCustomerDisclosureTemplateandrequiresolarenergyproviderstousethemodelthatisprovidedtoallprospectivecustomersandwouldbeavailableforeachfinancialmodelorproductofferedbythesolarenergyproviderasadvertisedontheprovider’swebsite.ThisModelwouldnotregulatethefinancialcontentsofthesolarprovider’soffer,butwouldrequireallsolarprovidersmarketingtoresidentialcustomerstousethesametermsanddefinitionsandmaketheiroffersinamannerthatallowsacomparisonofimpactsonthecustomer’selectricitybillsandobligationsundertheapplicablefinancialarrangement.WhereactualcustomerspecificinformationisrequiredtocompletetheTemplate,thecustomershouldreceiveadocumentthatreflectstheirspecificanalysisandinformation.Wherethisinformationisnotavailable,theprovidershouldberequiredtouseactualaveragecustomerusageandinstallationspecificationsfromtheutility’sserviceterritoryforpublicdisseminationwiththe
![Page 31: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
C. CONTRACTTERMS
Anagreementgoverningthefinancing,saleorleaseofasolarenergysystemtoanypersonofthisstatemust:
1. Besignedbythepersonbuying,financingorleasingthesolarenergysystemandmustbedated.AnyDisclosureStatementorcontractualagreementthatcontainsblankspacesaffectingthetiming,valueorobligationsoftheagreementinamaterialmannerwhensignedbythebuyerorlesseeisvoidableattheoptionofthebuyerorlesseeuntilthesolarenergysystemisinstalled.
2. Beinatleast12pointtype.3. Includeaprovisiongrantingthebuyerorlesseetherighttorescindthefinancing,
saleorleaseagreementforaperiodofnotlessthanthreebusinessdaysafterthebuyerorlesseesignstheagreementandbeforethesolarenergysystemisinstalled.
4. Provideadescription,includingthemakeandmodelofthesolarenergysystem’smajorcomponentsoraguaranteeconcerningenergyproductionoutputthatthesolarenergysystembeingsoldorleasedwillprovideoverthelifeoftheagreement.
5. Separatelysetforththefollowingterms,ifapplicable:a. Thetotalpurchasepriceortotalcosttothebuyerorlesseeunderthe
agreementforthesolarenergysystemoverthelifeoftheagreement;b. Anyinterest,installationfee,documentpreparationfees,servicefeeorother
coststobepaidbythebuyerorlesseeofthesolarpowersystem;c. Ifthesolarpowersystemisbeingfinancedorleased,thetotalnumberof
payments,thepaymentfrequency,theamountofthepaymentexpressedindollars,andthepaymentduedate.
6. Provideadisclosureinthesaleandfinancingagreements,totheextenttheyareusedbythesellerormarketerindeterminingthepurchasepriceoftheagreement,identifyingallcurrenttaxincentivesandrebatesorotherstateorfederalincentivesforwhichthebuyermaybeeligibleandanyconditionsorrequirementspursuanttotheagreementtoobtainthesetaxincentives,rebatesorotherincentives.
7. Identifythetaxobligationsthatthebuyerorlesseemayberequiredtopayasaresultofbuying,financing,orleasingthesolarpowersystem,including:
a. Theassessedvalueandpropertytaxassessmentsassociatedwiththesolarpowersystemcalculatedintheyeartheagreementissigned;
b. Anyobligationofthebuyerorlesseetotransfertaxcreditsortaxincentivesofthesolarpowersystemtoanyotherperson.
8. Disclosethetermsofanywarrantyandwhetherthewarrantyofmaintenanceobligationsrelatedtothesolarpowersystemmaybesoldortransferredtoathirdparty.
9. Includeadisclosure,thereceiptofwhichshallbeseparatelyacknowledgedbythebuyerorlessee,ifatransferofthesale,leaseorfinancingagreementcontainsanyrestrictionspursuanttotheagreementonthelessee’sorbuyer’sabilitytomodifyor
![Page 32: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
transferownershipofasolarpowersystem,includingwhetheranymodificationortransferissubjecttorevieworapprovalbyathirdparty.Ifthemodificationortransferofthesolarpowersystemissubjecttorevieworapprovalbyathirdparty,theagreementmustidentifythename,addressandtelephonenumberof,andprovideforupdatinganychangein,theentityresponsibleforapprovingthemodificationortransfer.
10. Includeadisclosure,thereceiptofwhichshallbeseparatelyacknowledgedbythebuyerorlessee,ifamodificationortransferofownershipoftherealpropertytowhichthesolarpowersystemisorwillbeaffixedcontainsanyrestrictionspursuanttotheagreementonthelessee’sorbuyer’sabilitytomodifyortransferownershipoftherealpropertytowhichthesolarpowersystemisinstalledoraffixed,includingwhetheranymodificationortransferissubjecttorevieworapprovalbyathirdparty.Ifthemodificationortransferoftherealpropertytowhichthesolarpowersystemisaffixedorinstalledissubjecttorevieworapprovalbyathirdparty,theagreementmustidentifythename,addressandtelephonenumber,andprovideforupdatinganychangein,theentityresponsibleforapprovethemodificationortransfer.
11. Provideafullandaccuratesummaryofthetotalcostsundertheagreementformaintainingandoperatingthesolarpowersystemoverthelifeofthesolarpowersystem,includingfinancing,maintenanceandconstructioncostsrelatedtothesolarpowersystem.
12. Iftheagreementcontainsanestimateofthebuyer’sorlessee’sfutureutilitychargesbasedonprojectedutilityratesaftertheinstallationofasolargenerationsystem,provideanestimateofthebuyer’sorlessee’sestimatedutilitychargesduringthesameperiodasimpactedbypotentialutilityratechangesrangingfromatleastafivepercentannualdecreasestoatleastafivepercentannualincreasefromcurrentutilitycosts.Thecomparativeestimatesmustbecalculatedbasedonthesameutilityrates.
13. Includeadisclosure,inatleast12pointtype,thereceiptofwhichshallbeseparatelyacknowledgedbythebuyerorlessee,thatstates:Utilityratesandotherfederal,state,orlocaltaxsubsidiesaresubjecttochange.Thesechangescannotbeaccuratelypredicted.Projectedsavingsfromyoursolarpowersystemarethereforesubjecttochange.Taxincentivesaresubjecttochangeorterminationbyexecutive,legislativeorregulatoryaction.
14. Ifapplicable,includeadisclosureregardingtheratethebuyerorlesseecanexpecttobecompensatedforanyelectricityproducedbytheirsolarpowersystemandsoldtotheelectricutility.Thedisclosure,inatleast12pointtype,thereceiptofwhichshallbeseparatelyacknowledgedbythebuyerorlessee,shallprovideinformationtothebuyerorlesseeaboutthecurrentreimbursementrateofthebuyerorlessee’selectricutilityatthetimeofsigningtheagreement.Thedisclosureshallalsocontainadisclaimerthatthecurrentreimbursementrateissubjecttochange.Ifretailnetmeteringisinplaceatthetimeofthe
![Page 33: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
purchase,thesolarcompanyshallinformthesolaruserthatadditionalchargesfordistribution,transmission,orstand-bygenerationmaybeimposedattherequestoftheutility,byruleofthecommission,orbychangestostatelaw.
15. Anagreementforthefinancing,saleorleaseofasolarpowersystemthatdoesnotcomplywiththerequirementsofsubsection1orthatisnotaccompaniedbythestatementrequiredbysubsection2isvoidableattheoptionofthepersonbuyingorleasingthesystemuntiltheinstallationofthesystembegins.
16. Ifapplicable,adisclosuresimilartothefollowing:Thisagreementlimitsyourrighttobringacourtcaseorfileaclassactiontoenforcethisagreementorseekdamages.Instead,youagreetosubmitanyclaimstoanarbitratorwhowillhavetheauthoritytointerpretthisagreementanddecideanyclaimsyoumayhave.40
TermsofSolarContractRelatedtoSaleofaHome
1. Intheeventthatrealpropertysubjecttoasolarpowersystemconsumercontractissold,theremainderoftheconsumercontractmustbeassumedbythebuyerifamemorandumhasbeenrecordedreflectingtheessentialtermsoftheconsumercontract,unlessthesellerand
buyeragreeotherwise.Ifthebuyerofsuchpropertyassumesaconsumercontractthebuyercontinuestoqualifyforallapplicableincentives.
2. Thirtydayspriortoclosing,thesellerofthepropertyshallnotifyanyutilityandsolarpowercompanyaffectedbytheconsumercontractthatthebuyerisassumingthecontract,orthatthebuyerandsellerhaveagreedotherwise.
3. Withinsevendaysoftheseller'snotice,theutilityandsolarpowercompanyshallprovidethedocumentationoftheproceduresnecessaryforassumptionoftheconsumer
DISCUSSION:Standardizingcontracttermsanddisclosuresdonotinanywayregulateorlimitthepricechargedforasolarlease,PPAorsale.AsshownbytheAttorneyGeneralenforcementactions,andstatelegislation,thereisarecognizedneedtoprovideconsumerswithclear,understandabledisclosuresthatallowthemtomakemeaningfulcomparisonsamongoffersandtofullyunderstandthetermsofthefinancialtransaction.Solarprovidersshouldnotmakeclaimsofsavingsonwebsitesoranysuchclaimsof“average”savingsshouldbeconspicuouslyidentifiedwiththebasisfortheclaimandallowcustomerstoaccessorreviewthedatathatsupportssuchclaims.Claimsofcustomersavingsontheelectricbillshouldreflectautilityspecificprofilebecausesavingsaresocloselyrelatedtoaspecificutility’sratesandapplicablenetmeteringorsolartariffpolicy.Consumersshouldbeabletoaccessthisinformationbyinputtingtheirzipcodeontheprovider’swebsite.
Inaddition,consumersshouldbeinformedinaconspicuousmannerthattheirfutureandpredictedsavingsorcostforelectricityissubjecttochangebytheutilitycommissionorstatelegislature.
Withregardtothedisclosureconcerningtheobligationtosubmitclaimstoanarbitrationprocess,alineofU.S.courtcaseshaveheldthatthe1926FederalArbitrationActpreemptsstatelegislationthatmayattempttoprohibitsuchcontractualprovisions.
![Page 34: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
contractbythebuyer,or,intheeventthatthebuyerisnotassumingthecontract,forterminationoftheconsumercontractandremovaloftherenewableenergysystem.
4. Attheendoftheconsumercontracttermorintheeventofanyearlierterminationoftheconsumercontract,theownerofthesolarpowersystem,whetheritisautilityorasolarpowercompany,isresponsiblefortheremovalofthesolarpowersystemfromthepropertyandmayrecoverthecostthereofonlyasspecifiedintheconsumercontractandnotedintherecordedmemorandum.Theowneroftherenewableenergysystemmayonlyobtaindamagesfortheprematureterminationofaconsumercontracttotheextentthattheamountofthedamagesisspecifiedasliquidateddamagesintheconsumercontract.
5. Renewableenergysystemconsumercontractsmaynotgrantutilitiesorsolarpowercompaniesanyauthoritytoapproveordisapproveofthetransferofrealpropertyassociatedwithsuchaconsumercontract.
6. Theownerofasolarpowersystemshallguaranteesufficientfundstoproperlydisposeofthesystemattheendoftheconsumercontract.
7. Theownerofasolarpowersystemmustremovetherenewableenergysystemfromthepropertywithintwenty-onedaysofawrittenrequestofthepropertyowner.Theownerofasolarpowersystemisresponsibleforidentifyinghazardousandcommerciallyvaluablematerialscontainedinthesolarpowersystemandhowthosematerialswillbeproperlydisposedoforreclaimed.Theownermustprovidethisinformationtothe
commissionuponrequest.
PrivacyofCustomerInformation
1. Solarprovidersshallkeepconfidentialcustomerspecificorprivateinformationrelatingtothecustomer’selectricityusage,financialsituation,credithistory,andotherresidence-specificinformationobtainedtoimplementtheproposedtransaction.Suchcustomerspecificinformationobtainedfromthecustomerorthecustomer’selectricutilityshallnotbeusedortransmittedtoanyentity,includingaffiliates,foranypurposeotherthantoimplementthecustomer’stransactionwithoutthecustomer’saffirmativeconsent.
DISCUSSION:TherehavebeencomplaintsaboutleaseandPPAcontractsincludingaprovisiongivingthesolarprovider(theownerofthesolarpanels)therighttoapproveanewhomeownerbeforetheleasecouldbetransferredtothenewowner.Severalstateshaveaddressedthissituationintheirproposedlegislation,andtherightsandobligationsatthetimeofthesaleofpropertyareakeydisclosureintheArizonalaw.
![Page 35: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
D. SALESANDMARKETINGCONDUCT
1. Solarpowercompaniesshallensurethatallsales,marketingandadvertising,whetheroral,writtenorelectronic,areaccurate,easilyunderstandableandbasedonfactsandincompliancewithstateandfederallawsandregulations.Solarpowercompaniesshall(1)accuratelydescribethecustomer’sfinancialobligationsundertheproposedtransactioninitssalespresentationsandmarketingmaterialsbasedonitsunderlyingformalcontractorleasingdocuments;and(2)ensurethatitsmarketingandsalesstatementsandpromisesconformtotheformalandwrittentermsandconditions.
2. Solarpowercompaniesareresponsiblefortheactionsoftheiremployees,agentsandanyotherthirdpartyrepresentativesandshallensuretheycomplywiththerequirementsofthissection.Solarpowercompaniesshalldocumenttheirinternaltrainingandmonitoringprogramsapplicabletotheirsalesagents,whetheremployeesorthirdpartyagents,andmakesuchrecordsavailabletothelicensingorregulatoryauthorityuponrequest.
3. Solarpowercompaniesshouldnotrefertosolarpoweras“free”inoralorwrittenmarketingorsalesdiscussionsunlesstheConsumerwillnotpayanythingforthesolarsystemortheenergyitgenerates.
4. Ifadvertisedpricesincludeinitialpricingreductionsorfutureincreases,allmaterialtermsofsuchinitialreductionsorfutureincreasesshallbedisclosedwhensuchpricesaremarketedorotherwisecommunicatedtoConsumers.
5. Publicstatements,includingthoseonwebsitesorinprintmaterial,thatdescribesolarenergyas“clean”or“renewable”aredeceptiveiftheRenewableEnergyCreditsaresoldandthereisnoadequatedisclosureaboutit.Disclosuresmustbeproximatetothepromotionofsolarenergy.
6. Whereapplicable,solarprovidersshallbesubjecttotheregistrationandapplicablerequirementsofthe[StateDoortoDoorand/orTelemarketingSalesActs].
41
DISCUSSION:Similartoregulationsontheretailsaleofelectricity,consumerprotectionregulationapplicabletoretailsolarprovidersshouldexplicitlyprohibitmisleadinganddeceptivesalesandmarketingstatementsandreferencethestate’sspecificunfairtradepracticeorgeneralconsumerprotectionlaw.Asellercannotmisrepresentthenatureoftheformalagreementorusestatementsthataredirectlycontradictedbytheformalagreementorcontract.Forexample,retailsellersofelectricgenerationsupplycannotadvertisethattheirgenerationsupplywillsavecustomersontheelectricitybillandthenbillthecustomerbasedonavariableormonthtomonthpricethatmightcomplywiththefineprinttermsofthecontract,butthatresultsinsignificantincreasesinthecustomer’smonthlyelectricbill.Asimilarexampleexistswithpromotingsolarenergytransactions.Solarprovidersshouldnotoffer“free”electricityoreven“freesunpower”becausethatisnotwhatisreflectedinthetransaction.
![Page 36: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
36
E. ENFORCEMENTANDPENALTIES;CUSTOMERCOMPLAINTS
1.ThecommissionshallinvestigateanycomplaintreceivedagainstasolarpowercompanyrelatedtoaviolationofthisChapter.If,afterinvestigatingsuchcomplaint,thecommissionfindstherehasbeenaviolationofthisChapter,thecommission,afternoticeandhearing,mayimposeanadministrativepenaltyagainstthesolarcompany.ThecommissionshallpromulgaterulesandregulationstodeterminetheappropriatepenaltiesforviolationsoftheprovisionsofthisChapter.
2.NothingintheChapterisintendedtoprecludetheauthorityoftheAttorneyGeneraltoinvestigateandenforcestateconsumerprotectionlawspursuanttothatoffice’sjurisdiction.
3. AsolarprovidershallmaintainrecordsofcompliancewiththerequirementsofthisAct,includingdisclosurestatements,contractterms,trainingandoversightofitsagents,customercomplaints,andcustomernoticesandcontractcommunicationsforaperiodofthreeyearsorthelengthofthecontractterm,whereapplicable.
4. Inordertoproperlyallowcustomerstocommunicatequestionsandcomplaints,thesolarprovidershallmaintainreasonableandadequatecustomerservicefacilities,atollfreetelephonenumber,andsufficientstaffingtohandleincomingcustomercommunications,ameanstoobtainadditionalstaffingintheeventofanemergency,andsufficientlytrainedpersonneltoensurethattheservicerepresentativecanprovideinformationaboutthecustomer’sspecifictransactionandassociatedissuesrelatingtotheimplementationofthattransaction,withaccesstomanagerialorsupervisoryassistanceas
needed.
DISCUSSION:Theproposedconsumerprotectionscannotbeeffectiveunlesstheregulationscanbeenforcedandviolatorspenalized.Enforcementrequiresthatanagencycaninvestigatecomplaints,thesolarprovidershouldberequiredtomaintainrecordsdemonstratingcompliancewiththeunderlyingconsumerprotectionandcontractrequirements,includingevidenceofaffirmativecustomerconsentandenrollment,receiptofdisclosuresbythecustomer,customercomplaints,complaintsnotresolved,andbusinessrecordsassociatedwiththeseactivitiesforaminimumtimeperiod,typicallythreeyearsfromthedateofthetransactionforenrollmentsanddisclosuresandarollingthreeyearperiodforcustomercomplaints.
![Page 37: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
37
CHAPTERV:COMMUNITYSOLARPROJECTS:ADDITIONALCONSUMERPROTECTIONS
Communitysolarprojects42aretypicallylessexpensiveperoutputofenergythan
individualsolarinstallations,dueinparttotheirinstallationontheground,andtheassociatedeconomiesofscaleincreatingalargersolararray.Acommunitysolarprojectalsoenablestheoptionofmakingsolarpoweravailabletoabroadergroupofresidentialcustomers,includinglowerincomehouseholds,rentersandthosewithhomesthatareinappropriateforasolarinstallation(duetolocation,typeofroof,shade,etc.).Acommunitysolarprojectisalargerversionoftheindividualrooftopsolarinthatitisessentiallyasmallelectricgeneratingplantlocatedinthedistributionsystem.
Communitysolarsystemscanbeowneddirectlyandentirelybytheutility,ownedby
theutilityinpartnershipwithathirdpartyservingaspecificrole(e.g.,projectdeveloper,customerinterface),orownedbyathirdparty.Thethirdpartycouldbeaprofit-makingsolarprovideroranon-profitlocalcommunityagencyororganization.Acommunitysolarsystemcouldbepromotedbythelocalutilitypursuanttotariffsorotherdirectivesofthestatepublicutilitycommissionorpromotedbyasolarproviderwhomayseekthenecessarylandunderaleasingarrangementandthensolicitindividualcustomerstoparticipateintheproject.
Acommunitysolarprojectiscomposedofthreedistinctactivities:First,agroupof
participantsvoluntarilypayforasubscription(ordirectownership)ofaportionofacommunitysolarsystemthatislocatedoff-site.Second,theelectricityproducedbythesystemflowsdirectlyintotheelectricgrid.Third,inexchangefortheirsubscription,theparticipantsreceiveanagreeduponcompensation(e.g.,acreditontheelectricbill)fortheelectricproductionoftheirportionofthecommunitysolarsystem.
AccordingtotheSolarElectricPowerAssociation(SEPA),13statesplustheDistrictof
Columbiahaveenactedcommunitysolarlegislation.Eachstatepolicyvaries,particularlyinscaleandreimbursementrate,butthefoundationforeachistheenablementofbillcreditsforcustomersparticipatingincommunitysolarprograms.43TheSEPAreportanalyzed68communitysolarprojectsinoperationacrossthecountry.About80percentoftheseprojectsareunder1megawatt(MW).About73percentoftheorganizationsrespondingtoSEPA’scommunitysolarsurveychargesubscribersanupfrontfeetobuyintoaproject;butassolarcostshavedropped,sohaveupfrontfees,from$5perWattin2011to$3perwattin2015.AccordingtoSEPA’sReport,“Initialmarketresearchshowsthatconsumersareinterestedincommunitysolar,butarelookingforprogramswithflexiblecommitments--suchasshort-termcontractsandtransferability.Somewouldalsoprefertheprojectsbelocatedatremotelocationswheretheydon’thavetoseethem.”
![Page 38: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
38
The
marketing,sales,contract,anddisclosurerequirementsrecommendedinChapterIVshouldalsobeadoptedforcommunitysolarprojects.Thereareseveralaspectstocommunitysolarprogramsthatraiseconsumerprotectionissuesandconcerns,someofwhichareuniquetocommunitysolarandothersofwhicharesimilar
totheoffersforrooftopsolarsystems.ThisChapterdescribestheuniquefeaturesforcommunitysolarandrecommendsadditionalconsumerprotectionpoliciesthatshouldbeadoptedfortheseprograms.
UtilityandCommissionOversight.Severalstatecommunitysolarprogramsthrust
thelocalutilityandthepublicutilitycommissiondirectlyintotheoversightandapprovaloftheseprograms.Insomecases,thesizeandscopeoftheprograms(intermsofthesizeoftheutilityarrayandnumberofparticipantsorsubscribers)arerestrictedorlimitedtopilotprograms.Inmostcases,theseprogramscomewithastatutorymandatetodevelopspecificconsumerprotectionorregulatoryoversightregulations.Ineithercase,therearegroundsfordirectoversightandregulationbytheregulatorycommission.
CommunitySolarMarketingActivities.Whetherornotthecommissionhasbeen
requiredtoconductcommunitysolarpilots,thepotentialformarketingabuseandtheneedforoversightofprivatemarketersisparticularlyimportant.Whenasolarproviderismarketingtoobtainsubscribers,itmayseektomarketitsprojectviatelemarketingordoor-to-doorsalesactivities,promotingasolaroptionatalowercostthanforindividualrooftopsolarsystems.Itwillbeveryimportanttoensurethatmarketingclaimsandlegalagreementsareproperlyandaccuratelydisclosedandthatconsumersareprotectedagainstmisleadinganddeceptiveclaimsabouttheimpactofsubscribershipontheirmonthlyelectricbill.Thisconcernisparticularlyimportantforprojectsthataredesignedtosolicitlowerincomeanddisadvantagedcustomerstoenrollinacommunitysolarprogram,thusintendingtomakesuchanoptionmoreaffordablecomparedtorooftopsolarsystems,manyofwhicharenotavailabletocustomerswithouta
AmongthecasestudiesevaluatedintheSEPAreportarethefollowing:XcelEnergyhascommunitysolarprojectstotalingalmost20MWinits
Coloradoserviceterritory.Xcel’sSolar*RewardsCommunityprojectsareconstructedandownedentirelybyprivatesolarcompanies.Theseprojectshaveenjoyedrapidgrowthandareusuallyfullysubscribedwithin6monthsofcomingonline.Xcelselectsitsfor-profitpartnersthroughacompetitivebiddingprocessandpaysthemsubsidiestiedtotheamountofelectricitygenerated.Earlyintheprogram,participantspaidanupfrontfeebasedontheirsubscriptionsize,howeverfinancingisnowavailabletomostsubscribers.
In2015,GrandValleyPower(GVP)partneredwithGRIDAlternatives
(GRID)tobuilda24kWCSG.Thesystemwasdedicatedspecificallytolow-incomecustomersinGVP’sserviceterritoryandisoperatedandmanagedbyGRID.GRID,anonprofit,promotesaCSmodelthatinvolvescombiningequipmentdonationsfromsolarmanufacturers,financialcontributionsfromvarioussources,andlaborfromjobtrainingprogramsandvolunteers.Subscriberstotheprogrampaynoup-frontfeeandreceiveanongoingcreditfortheproductionoftheirshareoftheCSG,thoughthereisa2centperkWhfeetohelpdefraymanagementcosts.Subscribersparticipateinfour-yearcycles.Aftereachcycle,theycanre-qualifyfortheprogram,oriftheynolongerqualify—forexample,iftheirincomehasrisenaboveprogramlimits—theirsharecanbeassignedtoanotherlow-incomeparticipant.
![Page 39: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
39
specificcreditscoreorcredithistory.Inaddition,communitysolarsystemsareoftentoutedasapotentialmeanstoenrollcustomerswhodonotowntheirhomesinsolarpowersystems.
TheSEPAReportidentifiedseveralkeyissuesforbothregulatorsandconsumersto
understandandconsiderwithregardtocommunitysolarprojects:CustomerOffer.Thisreferstothepaymentforparticipation--typicallyeitheran
upfrontpaymentofallcostsoranongoingpremiumpaymentappliedtotheelectricityproducedbythecustomer'sshareofthesystem.Financingmaybeofferedforupfrontpayments.OftheactivecommunitysolarprogramsstudiedbySEPA,73%haveanupfrontpaymentcustomeroffer,17%haveanongoingpayment,and10%allowcustomerchoiceamongthetwooptions.
ValuePropositiontoSubscribers.Thisreferstothefinancialvaluethesubscriber
receivesinreturnforparticipatinginthecommunitysolarproject,eitherabillcredit(71%ofthosereviewedintheSEPAReport),oraseparatelineitempaymentontheelectricbill(29%).Thebillcreditreducesthesubscribers’kWhconsumptionbythekWhproducedbytheirshareoftheproject.Aseparatelineitempaymentisarateuniquetothecommunitysolarprojectthatisbasedonavoidedcostsinavalueofsolartariff,netmetering,oranotheraccountingmethod,andwouldbeappliedtoallkWhproducedbythesubscriber’sshareoftheoutput.Theutility’sadministrativecosts,particularlybillingsystemcosts,areafactorindesigningbothoftheserates.
Sign-upFee:Theprojectmaychoosetochargeasign-upfeethatcanbeusedto
guaranteeasubscriber’ssharebeforetheprojectisactuallygeneratingelectricity.OftheprojectsstudiedbySEPAthatcurrentlyhavefees,thefeesrangefrom$50toseveralhundreddollars.Whenupfrontpaymentisrequested,ahighersignupfeemaybechargedtoreserveashare,andthencreditedtowardtheupfrontpayment.Forprojectswithongoingpayments,sign-upfeesmayprotectagainsttheriskofasubscriberleavingbeforetheminimumterm.
RenewableEnergyCreditTreatment:Renewableenergycredits(RECs)maybe
availableforthecommunitysolarproject.RECshavevalue,therefore,adecisionmustbemadeastowhowillownthecreditsandwhatwillbedonewiththem.SEPAdescribestwooptions:Inthefirstoption,theowneroftheenergycanmaintainownershipoftheREC.Inthiscase,itisthenuptotheownerwhethertheyretiretheRECtomeetacompliancerequirementoriftheysellitonthemarket.ThesecondoptionisthattheRECcanbetiedtotheenergyproductionandtransferredtothecustomer.44
ProposedConsumerProtectionPoliciesforCommunitySolarProjects.Severalstateshaveadopted,orareconsidering,consumerprotectionsthataredirectlyapplicabletocommunitysolarprojects.ThisReportrecommendsthattheproposedconsumerprotectionpoliciesreflectedintheMarylandandMinnesotapublicadvocateproposalsbeadopted:
Marylandadoptedalawin2015creatingapilotprogramforcommunitysolarprojects.TheMarylandlawrequiresthecommunitysolartobeinthesameelectricserviceterritoryasitssubscribers,butathirdpartymayfinance,build,own,oroperateacommunitysolarproject.Electricutilitiesmustbuythevirtualnetexcessgeneration,uptospecifiedlimits.TheMarylandlawcreatesathree-yearpilotprogramthatallowsfortheconstructionofcommunity
![Page 40: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
40
solarprojectsundertheauthorityoftheMarylandPublicServiceCommission.TheCommissionmustadoptregulationsimplementingthepilotprogramnolaterthanMay15,2016,andthethree-yearprogramwillstartfollowingruleadoption.KeyissuestoresolveinthePSCrulemakingareconsumerprotectionmeasures—atariffstructureunderwhichanelectriccompanyprovideskilowatt-hourorvaluecreditstothecommunitysolarsubscriber;virtualnetmeteringcalculation;protocolsforcommunicationamongthepertinentparties;andinterconnectionprotocols.Underthepilotprogram,individualsystemsizesarecappedat2megawattsand200kilowattsubscriptionscannotconstitutemorethan60percentofitssubscriptions.Thecumulativenameplatecapacityunderthepilotprogramcountstowardtheexistingstatutorylimitationof1,500megawattsforallnetmeteringprojectsinthestate.TheCommissionisrequiredtolimitthepilotprogramwithincertainparameterssothatitcanconducta“meaningful”(asrequired)analysisoftheprogramanditsresults.ThelawrequirestheCommissiontoinitiateastakeholderworkgroupthatexaminesandidentifiesthecostsandbenefitsoftheprogramandrecommendswhethertoestablishapermanentcommunitysolarprogram.TheCommissionwillthenreportitsfindingsandrecommendationstotheMarylandlegislaturebyJuly1,2019.45
TheMarylandOfficeofPeople’sCounselhasproposedspecificissuesthatshouldbe
reflectedintheforthcomingconsumerprotectionanddesignregulationsforthesepilotprograms.46Specifically,thisOfficehasrecommended:
SignUpandDepositLimits:Thesign-upcostsanddepositrequirementthatdevelopersimposeonsubscribersinterestedinparticipatingandreservingaportionofCSEGSmustbelimitedtoareasonableamount.SomeprotectionmustexisttopreventdevelopersfromcollectingdepositsfrominterestedcustomersandneverbuildingtheCSEGS.Onepotentialsolutiontothiswouldberequiringsubscriberdepositstoenteratypeof“escrow”accountwhichwouldtransferapercentageofthefundstothedeveloperonlyaftertheCSEGSbecomesoperational.Thisapproachcould;however,limitdevelopers’abilitytoeffectivelyfinancesystems,sosomebalancewouldhavetobestruck.
TheNeedforContractRegulation:Forsomeextremelyimportantconsumerprotectionissues,simplyrequiringdisclosuretothesubscribersisinsufficient.Iftheissuehasbeenidentifiedasakeyprotectionclause,itshouldbemandatedbytheCommissionaspartoftheprogram,ratherthanjustbeingarequireddisclosure.Thiswillpreventunscrupulousdevelopersfromtakingadvantageofunder-educatedsubscribers,poisoningthecommunitysolarprogram,andpotentiallydampeningtheentiresolarindustryandmarket.
Listofsuggestedprogrammaticrules:
• Noyearlypriceescalationpast2%embeddedintocontract.• Notransferfeesifcustomermoveswithinserviceterritory.• Projectionsofcostsavingsmustincludeascenarioof0%increaseinelectricrates.• Nofeeforadownsizingallocationwithinfirstsixmonthsupto20%ofsubscribed
blocks.• Nofeetodownsizebyatmost5%eachyearthereafter.
![Page 41: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
41
SubscriptionTransferability:Subscribersshouldbeabletotransfertheirsubscriptionbacktothesubscriberorganizationsonamonthlybasis,butmayincurapenaltytodoso.ShouldaCSEGSbeundersubscribed,theportionofthecapacitythatisnotsubscribedshouldbecreditedatthecommodityrateuntilnewsubscriberscanbefound.
Downsizing:Thereshouldbeprovisionsallowingsubscriberstodownsizetheirsubscriptionsize.Forexample,regulationscouldprovidesubscriberswitharighttodownsizetheirsubscriptionsizebyatmost20%withoutpenaltywithinthefirstsixmonthsofsigningup,5%thereafter,inaccordancewiththeminimumownershippercentages,shares,orcapacityestablishedbythesubscriberorganization.Thispreventsapotentialdisincentiveforsubscriberstoconserveenergyafterjoiningtheprogram,whileincentivizingsubscriberorganizationstoprovideexcellentcustomerserviceandmaintaincompetitivecostsasmorecommunitysolaroptionsbecomeavailabletoconsumers.
Minnesotahasimplementedacommunitysolarprogramcalled“solargardens”inwhichcertainconsumerprotectionissueshavebeenspecificallyconsidered.Inthisproceeding,XcelEnergysubmittedaproposedtarifftoimplementcommunitysolarprojects.TheOfficeofAttorneyGeneral—AntitrustandUtilitiesDivisionraisedsignificantissueswithregardtothelackofspecificinformationontheutility’sproposedtariffandmaderecommendationstoreformtheproposalpriortoanyCommissionapproval.47ThecommentssubmittedbytheMinnesotaAttorneyGeneralproposedthattheCommissionadoptconsumerprotectionsforsolargardensubscribers,relyingontheCommission’sobligationthatthesolargardenprogramisinthepublicinterestandtoensurethatconsumersareprovidedwithfullandfairdisclosuresoffuturecostsandbenefits.
AsdescribedbytheAttorneyGeneral’sComments,Xcel’sproposedtariffwaslackingin
keyinformation,includingwhatcustomersmightberequiredtopayforsolargardensubscriptions,whethercustomerswouldpayanyfeeinalumpsumorinsubscriptions,thedurationofcustomersubscriptions,thetransferabilityofanycustomersubscriptions,orthemethodsthatsolargardendeveloperswouldberequiredtousetoestimatetheoutputofthesystem.ReferringtoinformationfromXcel’scommunitysolardevelopersinColorado,“SolargardendevelopersinXcel’sColoradoserviceterritoryestimatethat,inexchangeforthe$3,700up-frontcost,subscriberswillreceivebillcreditsofapproximately$270peryearperkilowatt,concludingthatcustomerswouldnotrecovertheirinitialinvestmentformorethan13yearsaftertheprojectbecomesoperational.48AmongtherecommendationsbytheAttorneyGeneralarethefollowingconsumerprotectionpolicies:
• RequireregistrationorcertificationbeforetheCommunitySolarProjectqualifiesfor
incentives.Thisshouldincludebasicinformationabouttheownership,site,andthefinancialandtechnicalabilitytomanageaproject.
• Contractsbetweentheutilityandtheprojectdevelopermustbeapprovedbythecommission;
• Consumershouldreceivecomplete,credibleandaccuratedisclosures,includinginformationonthecosts(includingfinancingcosts)andbenefitsofaparticularprojectpriortosigningacontract;
• Consumersshouldbeabletorecoveranypaymentsmadeforsubscriptionsintheeventthattheirlifecircumstanceschange;
![Page 42: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
42
• TheCommissionshouldreviewmaterialsusedbycommunitysolarmarketerstopromotetheirprojecttocustomers;
• Consumersmustbeinformedofthetimeperioditwilltaketorecoveranyinitialpaymentspriortoobtaininganycustomersignature;
• Astandardcontractordisclosureformshouldberequiredforallcommunitysolarprojects;
• TheCommissionshouldestablishastandardizedmethodusedtodeterminehowtheprojectwillestimateprojectoutput;
• TheCommissionshouldestablishastandardizedmethodtoprojectfutureelectricitypricesorimpactsoncustomerbillsduringthelifetimeoftheprojectand/orthecustomer’ssubscriptionobligation.
IntheOrderapprovingtheSolarGardentariff,49theCommissionrejectedtheAttorney
General’swarrantyorperformancerecommendationonthegroundsthatitmightimpedethecreationandfinancingofsolargardensattheearlystageoftheirdevelopment.TheCommissionrejectedtheAttorneyGeneral’srecommendationsonreviewingsolargardencontractsandmarketingmaterials,anddevelopinguniformstandardsforsolargardenproductionestimates,againconcludingthatsuchrequirementswouldburdensolargardenoperatorsatthestartoftheprogram.Withregardtodisclosures,theCommissionrequiredXcel’scontractwiththesolargardenoperatortoprovidesubscriber-specificdisclosuresonfuturecostsandbenefits,proofofinsurance,andproofofalong-termmaintenanceplan.TheCommissiondidrequiresolargardenoperatorstoobtainopinionlettersonthelegalandtaxbenefitsofparticipationintheprogram.TheCommissionagreedthatcustomersubscriptionsshouldbetransferablebacktothesolargardenoperator.Finally,theCommissionadoptedtheAttorneyGeneral’ssuggestionsaboutdataprivacyandstrengthenedsubscriberprivacyprotections.
![Page 43: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
43
APPENDIXA:SUMMARYOFSTATEPROPOSEDLEGISLATION(2014-2015)
Thelegislativeproposalssummarizedherewerenotadopted.Indiana:HB1320wouldhaveallowedthirdpartyownershipandincluded
requirementsregardingsafetyandinterconnectionandamendedthestate’sdeceptivetradepracticesacttorequireconsumerdisclosuresrelatedtodistributedgenerationorsolarpowersystems.TheStateAttorneyGeneralwouldhavehadauthoritytoreceivecomplaintsandenforcethenewlaw.Requireddisclosuresincludedestimatesoftheenergyoutputofthesystem,allfinancialtermsincludingpriceescalations,disclosureofallstateandfederalsubsidiesandincentives,andcleardelineationofresponsibilityfortheequipmentatthetimeahomeissold. Washington:HB1912coveredvariousaspectsofdistributedgenerationincludingstatetaxcredits,incentives,solarmodulerecycling,andrequiringanindependentconsultanttoprepareatwo-phase"SmartPlanforaSmartGrid"study.Withregardtoconsumerprotectionprovisions,thebillwouldhavepermittedthirdpartyownershipandprovidedaregulatoryframeworkforthirdpartyownersofdistributedgeneration.ThelegislationproposedtoempowertheWashingtonUtilitiesandTransportationCommissionwithjurisdictionovernon-raterelatedconsumerprotections,whileretainingthecurrentjurisdictionpursuanttothestate’sunfairtradepracticestatuteimplementedbytheAttorneyGeneral.Third-partyvendorsandaffiliatesofanelectricutilitymustregisterwiththecommission,disclosetermsofservice,andcooperatewithcommissioninvestigationsofconsumercomplaints.Thisincludesrequirementstoprovide,onaseparatepageinconspicuousprint,certaintermsaddressingarbitrationorwaivingtherighttojoinaclassaction,andtofilewiththecommissionortheAttorneyGeneralcopiesofjudgmentsorarbitrationdecisionsinactionsallegingviolationofconsumerprotections.Thecommissionisgrantedregulatoryauthorityoverconsumerprotections.50Certainminimumdisclosuresareenumeratedinthelegislation.
OneofthemoreinnovativeprovisionsofthebillwasarequirementforthedevelopmentofaConsumerTemplatethatwouldthenberequiredtobeusedbythirdpartysolarcompanies.Thetemplatemustincludetermsdeemednecessaryforaconsumertounderstandthebusinessdeal,suchasperformanceguarantees,respectiverightsoftheparties,andthefinancialpaybackofthesystem.
(1)Anyinstallationcompany,competitiveelectricserviceprovider,orelectricutilityprovidingarenewableenergysystemeligibleforanincentivepaymentundersection5ofthisactmustprovidetheentityapplyingundersection5(1)ofthisactauniformstatementofessentialterms.TheuniformstatementmustbeinaformatestablishedbytheWashingtonStateUniversityextensionenergyprogram,whichmustconsultwiththeattorneygeneral,theutilitiesandtransportationcommission,andrepresentativesofutilitiesinestablishingtheuniformstatement.
![Page 44: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
44
(2)Theuniformstatementmustbeprovidedpriortoexecutionoftheconsumercontractandmustbesignedbythecustomer.
(3)Theuniformstatementmustincludeinformationregardingtherespectiverightsandresponsibilitiesofallpartiesinvolved,andincludesuchtermsasreasonablynecessaryforthecustomertounderstandandmakeaninformeddecisiontoentertheconsumercontract.Suchinformationmustincludethefollowing:
(a)Informationaboutthesystem'sperformance,suchasamonthlyorannualproductionperformanceguaranteeorrangeofperformanceandsystemsizeandcapacity;
(b)Customercosts,includingtheamountofanydownpaymentrequired,periodicpayments,orcostperkilowatt-hourofelectricityproduced,andanybuilt-inescalationratesorscheduleofpaymentamounts;
(c)Lengthofcontracttermandtotalexpenditureorrangeofexpenditures,ortheeffectiveannualinterestrateoverthetermoftheagreement;and
(d)Thecustomer'srightsandresponsibilitieswhensellingarenewableenergysystemaspartofasaleofrealproperty,includingresponsibilityforsystemremovalcosts,disposalofthesystem,andanyremainingperiodicpayments.
Most importantly, the proposed bill included specific languagewith regard to theoversight and enforcement powers of the commission, including its ability to resolvecustomer complaints and conduct enforcement actions and assess penalties. The thirdpartyentitiessubjecttothisjurisdictionwerealsorequiredtocooperateininvestigations,handling of customer complaints, and maintain records of their sales and financialactivities for five years. These entities were also required to ensure that its customercontractsmeetthedisclosurerequirementsofthecommission’srules.
Withregardtocontracttermsthatmaylimitthecustomer’srighttoobtainaremedybycourtorclassaction,theentity“mustprovidethesetermsonaseparatecontractpageinboldandconspicuousprintandrequirethecustomertoseparatelysignacknowledgmentoftheterms.”And,theseentities“maynotincludeinaconsumercontractaprovisionthatlimitsaconsumer'sabilitytoseekdamages.Aprovisionlimitingdamagesisvoidasagainstpublicpolicy.”
Louisianaalsoconsideredspecificlegislationgoverningsolarpowertransactions,butdidnotenactanyfinallanguage.ThisbillauthorizedthePublicServiceCommissiontopromulgaterulesandregulationstogoverntheregistrationofsolarcompanieswiththecommission,toconductinvestigations,imposefeesandpenalties,andtakeactionsnecessarytoassureproperimplementationoftheconsumerprotectionprovisionsofproposedlaw.Theproposalprovidesforcertaindisclosurestobemadebyasolarcompanytoasolaruser.Thesedisclosuresincluderegulatory,financial,safetyandinformationregardinguseofcustomerinformationandinsurancecoverage.ThebillrequiredtheCommissiontoinvestigateanycomplaintreceivedagainstasolarcompanyrelatedtoa
![Page 45: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
45
violationofproposedlaw,andif,afterinvestigatingsuchcomplaint,theCommissionfindstherehasbeenaviolation,thecommission,afternoticeandhearing,mayimposeanadministrativepenaltyagainstthesolarcompany.TheCommissionwasauthorizedtopromulgaterulesandregulationstodeterminetheappropriatepenaltiesforviolationsofproposedlaw,butsuchregulationswouldnotprecludetheconsumer’srighttofileacivilsuitfordamagesorcriminalchargesintheappropriatestateorfederalcourt.Thebillexplicitlyoutlawedthetypicalmandatoryarbitrationclauseforsolarpurchaseorleaseagreementsandstatedthattheinvocationofarbitrationshallbevoluntaryatthediscretionofthesolaruser.
Thelegislationproposeddisclosuresconsistentwiththoseproposedinotherstates,includingfinancialtermsandanyavailablestateorfederalincentives.TheLouisianaproposalalsorequiredsafetyandmaintenancedisclosures,suchasresponsibilityfordamagetotheequipmentortheroof;insurance;andastatementthatrooftopsolarpanelscouldlimitaccessbyafiredepartment.
Nevada:A.B.330proposedtorequiresolarproviderstoprovidewiththesaleorinstallationanexpress,writtenwarrantyforthesystemwhichmustprovidecoverageforbothpartsandlabor.Thesellerorinstalleralsomustprovidewiththesaleorinstallationadescriptionofthewarranty,adescriptionofanyresponsibilityassumedordisclaimedbythesellerorinstaller,andperformancedataforthesystem.Thebillproposedtherequirementsforanyagreementforthefinancing,saleorleaseofadistributedgenerationsystemorforthepurchaseofelectricitygeneratedbyadistributedgenerationsystem.Theagreement,whichmustbeinwriting,wouldhavetomakedisclosuresregarding:themanufacturer,sellerandinstallerofthesystem;thecostandfinancialdetailsofthepurchaseorleaseandthecostofoperatingandmaintainingthesystem;anytaxincentivesrelatingtothepurchaseorleaseofthesystemorthepurchaseofelectricity;andanyrestrictionsorobligationsimposedbytheagreement.Thesellerorlessorofasystemorthesellerofelectricityalsomustprovidewrittenstatementsregardingutilityratesandattestingtothetruthfulnessandcompletenessoftheagreement.Anysuchagreementisvoidableattheoptionofthepersonpurchasingorleasingthesystem,orpurchasingelectricitygeneratedbythesystem,untiltheinstallationofthesystem.Withregardtothecontentsoftheagreement,thebillrequiredthatitincludeanestimateofthecostofelectricityforthepurchaserorlesseeafterthesystemisinstalled.ThebillalsoincludedaregistrationrequirementthroughtheNevadaOfficeofEnergy.Violationsoftheprovisionsofthisbillwouldconstitutedeceptivetradepractices.
Ofnote,ifacontractreferencedthepriceofelectricityprovidedbyapublicutility,thelegislationrequiredaseparate,writtenstatementinatleast12-pointfont,stating:
Utilityratesandutilityratestructuresaresubjecttochange.Foradditionalinformationregardingutilityratesandutilityratestructures,youmaycontactyourlocalpublicutilityorthePublicUtilitiesCommissionofNevada.
![Page 46: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
46
APPENDIXB:CRITIQUEOFTHESEIABUSINESSCODEFORSOLARTRANSACTIONSASASUBSTITUTEFORSTATEREGULATORYOVERSIGHTANDSTANDARDS
ThefollowingsummarizesthekeyprovisionsoftheSEIACodeandprovidesCommentsthatidentifypotentialshortcomingsparticularlyascomparedtotheproposedconsumerprotectionstandardsrecommendedinChaptersIVandVofthisReport:
Unfair,Deceptive,orAbusiveActsorPractices(UDAAP).TheCoderequiresmembersto“regularlyexamineandconsiderthepossibilityofUDAAPviolationsinallaspectsofitsbusinessthattouchonConsumersortheirinterests,includingbutnotlimitedtomarketing,sales,origination,contractterms,contractoptions,installation,servicing,andlossmitigation.”Membersarerequiredto“regularlyremindandtrain“eachemployee”toavoidUDAAPviolations.
RESPONSE:WhilethissectionoftheCodeappearstoattempttorespondtoexistingstate
andfederalUnfairTradePracticeslaws,thereisnoidentificationofwhatconstitutesUDAAPoranyreferencetosuchdescriptionsorexamplesofwhatwouldconstituteUDAAP,althoughanumberofthesubsequentsectionsoftheCodeclearlybuildontraditionalUDAAPcriteria.Noristhereanyrequirementthatmembersdevelopandprovideevidenceoftrainingmaterialsandactualdocumentationoftrainingactivitiesforeitheremployeesorthemember’sthirdpartyagents.
Advertising.TheproposedCodeincludeshighlevelstandardsgoverningadvertising,
including:
“Claimsshouldbeaccurate,easilyunderstandableandbasedonfacts.”“Systemproductioncalculationsmusttakeintoaccountmaterialfactors.”“Projectionsoffutureutilitypricemustbebasedonacceptedsourcesandmethods.”“Endorsementsmustbegenuineandauthorizedbytheendorser.”
RESPONSE:ThereareanumberofvaluableandimportantspecificsincludedinthisSection
oftheCode,includingaprohibitiononreferencestosolarsystemsas“free”,anobligationtospecificallyidentifyanyincentivesandassociatedeligibilityrequirements,andobligationsfordisclosuresofaccurateprices,allpricingdetails,andrequiringfact-basedestimatesthatincludeall“materialfactors.”
CalculationofEstimatedFutureElectricityRates.Oneofthekeydisclosuresassociated
withanyconsumer’sdecisiontoinvestinoragreetoasolarinstallationcontractistherelationshipbetweenthecostofthesolarsystemandthemonthlyleasingorpurchasingcostscomparedtothecustomer’scurrentelectricbillandestimatesoffuturerateincreases.Withregardtoprojectionsoffutureutilityprices,theCoderequiresitsmemberstorelyonatleastoneofavarietyofsources,includingtheU.S.EnergyInformationAgencyapplicabletothestatewherethesystemwillbelocated,stateutilitycommissionorenergyofficepublications,utilityratecasefilings,“historicalutilitypricedataforthesystemlocation”(thesourceforwhichisnotidentified),“industryexpertsorotherqualifiedconsultant,”the“retailsourceorelectricity
![Page 47: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
47
generationsourceservicingthesystemlocation,”and“othersimilarreliablesourcesqualifiedbySEIA.”Further,theCodeallowsthemembertouseamethodforfutureutilitypriceprojectionsrelyingonan“averagegrowthrateusingnolessthanfiveyearsofdataendingwiththemostrecentyearforwhichdataispubliclyavailable,”anddatathatisbasedon“thirdpartysources”withsomelimitations.
RESPONSE:Theserequirementsarenotreasonablebecausetheywouldallowforawide
rangeofpotentialsourcesanddatatobeusedthatcarryahighdegreeofpotentialinaccurateormisleadingprojectedutilityprices.Consumerswouldnothavethenecessaryinformationtocompareoffersacrossprovidersbecauseeachprovidercoulduseadifferentdatasettoestimatefutureelectricityrates.Thisprovisionofthecodedoesnotservetopreventunfairanddeceptiveprojectionsofsavings.AsdiscussedfurtherinactualrecommendationsinSectionIV,anycalculationsoftheimpactofasolarsystemonaresidentialcustomer’selectricbillshouldrelyonthecurrentelectricpriceschargedbytheindividualconsumerandastate-specificandutility-specificapprovedmethodologytoprovidearangeofpotentialfutureutilitybillimpacts.Ofmostimportance,thesolarmarketerorprovidershouldberequiredtoaffirmativelydisclosetheriskthatanysuchprojectionswillbeincorrectandarenotsubjecttothecontrolofthesolarprovider.
SalesandMarketingInteractions.TheCodeincludesrequirementsonrespecting
consumerprivacy,treatingcustomersfairlyandcompliancewithDoNotCalllistsandTelemarketingSalesRules,theFTC’sCAN-SPAMAct,andrelatedstatutes,referencingstateorlocalanalogouslaws.Membersarerequiredtomaintaina“donotcontact”listandensurethattheiragentscomplywithsuchinformation.MembersandtheiragentsmustaccuratelyidentifytheCompanytheyrepresentandavoidstandarddeceptivestatementsandmisrepresentationsthatwouldbeapplicabletoanyretailsalesandmarketingactivitypursuanttomostStateUnfairTradePracticeActs.
RESPONSE:TheobligationsandprohibitionsincludedinthisSectionoftheCoderepeatthe
currentapplicablefederalandstatelawandregulations,almostnoneofwhicharespecifictothemarketingofsolarsalesandleasing.
Contracts.TheCodeincludesrequirementsforcontracts,suchasthatcontractterms
shouldreflectverbalrepresentations;contractsshouldbeclearandunderstandabletoConsumersandcontainallcontractterms;andthatcompaniesshouldallowConsumerstheabilitytorescindcontracts.Standardrequirementsthatthecontractbe“writteninlegiblefont,”andwrittentobe“easytounderstand”areincluded.Thespecific“materialterms”thatmustbeincludedincontracts(andare“recommended”beplacedabovetheCustomer’ssignature)areidentifiedas:
• Costs,• Ownershipterms,• Financingterms,• Warranties,• Consumeroptionsintheeventofahomesale,• Terminationandsystemremovaloptionsandcosts,and• Consumerrightsregardingdamagetopropertyfrominstallation.
![Page 48: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
48
TheCoderequiresthattheprovidermustprovideathree-dayrightofrescission(exceptforsolarsystemsinstalledonnewhomesaletransactions)withareasonablemeansofexercisingthatright.
WithregardtoRenewableEnergyCertificates(RECs),thememberisprohibitedfrom
doublecountingtheREC---byrelyingonitsvalueafterthesaleofitinthetransactionforanyotherpurpose.Further,thecompanyisrequiredtoeducatecustomersaboutRECsandreferthemtoaspecificpublication,“GuidelinesforRenewableEnergyClaims:GuidanceforConsumersandElectricityProviders,CenterforResourceSolutions(Feb.26,2015).IftheagreementassignstheRECtotheCompanyandnottheConsumer,theprovidershould“explain”totheConsumerthattheConsumerhasnorightstotheREC,but“maystatetotheConsumerthatsellsitsRECsthat,bypurchasing,leasingorhostingasolarsystem,theConsumerishelpingadvancesolarenergyintheU.S.,orsimilarbroadpolicyormarketstatements.”
RESPONSE:Theseprovisionsareappropriateinmostcases,buttheyfailtoadoptthe
levelofspecificitythatshouldbeincludedandasidentifiedinChapterIVofthisReport.Furthermore,someoftheobligationsto“explain”certainobligationsorissuestoaffectedcustomersisnotsufficientinthatthereisnorequiredmethodofexplanationorrecordofhoworwhenthisexplanationisgiven.WithregardtotherecommendedstatementsaboutRECs,thespecificadviceoftheVermontAttorneyGeneralasreflectedinChapterIVofthisReportismoreexplicitandaccurate.
Thecodeisvoluntaryandthusdoesnotprovideconsumerprotectionacrosstheindustry. TheSEIABusinessCodeincludesGuidingPrinciplesthatrequiremembersoftheSEIAto“expresslyagreetofollowingtheCode,cooperatewithSEIAandanydesignatedthirdpartyduringanyinvestigationsintoallegedviolationsoftheCode,andcomplywithanyauthorizedactionsbySEIAorthirdpartiestoenforcefindingsmadewithdueprocess.”Inaddition,theCoderequiresmembersto“takecommerciallyreasonablemeasures”torequirethemember’s“contractors,serviceprovidersoragentstoabidebytheCode. RESPONSE:Theseobjectivesarewelcome,buttheapplicabilityofthesepoliciesonlyto“members”andthelackofanymeanstoconductpublicproceedingstodetermineviolationsandassessappropriatepenaltiesaresignificantshortcomings.While“members”arerequiredtocomplywiththeCode,notallretailpromotersorsellersofsolarinstallationsaremembersofSEIAsinceSEIAisavoluntaryorganizationandmemberscancomeandgoastheyplease.SEIAidentifiesitsmembershiponitswebsite,claimingthatthislistincludesover1,000entities,manyofwhomarenotretailsolarproviders,butthosewhocontractwithsolarproviders,lobbyontheirbehalf,orprovidelegalandtechnicaladvice.51SEIAalsoidentifiesthenumberofmembersbyStateandbytypeofentityinvolvedinthesolarindustry.Asexpected,someoftheStateswiththehighestnumberofmembersarethosewithsignificantsolarsalesandleasingactivity,suchasCalifornia,Florida,NewJersey,andNewYork.But,strangely,severalstateswithveryhighsolarmarketingactivities,suchasArizonaandNevada,haveveryfewmembers,lessthan10accordingtothisinformation,andmanyofthoselistedforthesestatesarenotactualretailproviders,butfinancialorotherentitiesthatwouldprovideservicestosolarmarketersandtheiragents.Finally,mostofSEIA’smembersdonotactuallyconductretail
![Page 49: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
49
salesandleasingtoresidentialcustomers,butareassociatedwiththemanufacturing,legalandfinancialconsulting,andadvocatesforsolarpowerbusinesses.
MembershipinSEIAisvoluntary,thusadherencetothecodeisaswell.Further,itisnotclearwhetherSEIAactuallyrepresentsamajorityorevenalargenumberofsolarcontractors,installers,orotherretailmarketingentitiesofferingsalesorleasingofsolarsystemstoresidentialcustomers.
WithregardtoSEIA’sattempttoapplyitsCodetotheagentsofitsmembers,i.e.,thosethird
partyvendorsoragentsthatmayactuallysolicitsalesandleasesfromresidentialcustomersonbehalfofaSEIAmember,theCode’sobligationtouse“commerciallyreasonablemeasures”isaweaksubstituteforaclearobligationthatSEIAmembersareresponsiblefortheactionsandrepresentativesoftheiragentsandwillbeheldaccountablefortheactionsoftheiragents.ThereisnorequirementintheCodethatSEIAmembersprovideevidenceofhowtheircontractorsandagentsaretrainedorhowthemembersarerequiredtodocumenttheiroversightandsupervisionoftheiragentstoassurecompliancewiththeCode.TheCodeisnotenforceableinanymannerthatwouldserveasadeterrenttobadactorsorthatwouldcompensateaggrievedconsumers.
AccordingtoSEIA,itwilladoptmeaningfulenforcementtoolstoensuretheCode“has
teeth.”InSEIA’sviewinternalreviewandtoolssuchasletterstomembersregardingviolations,andsuspensionofmembershipareappropriateandsufficientenforcementactivities.
RESPONSE:SEIAisaprivatenon-profitorganizationwhosememberspayafeetosupporttheSEIAstaffandtheSEIAmission.Thisorganizationhasnogovernmentalorformalenforcementauthority.SEIAcannotprohibitanon-memberfromviolatingitsCodeandcannotrequirenon-memberstorecognizeorcomplywiththeCode.Withregardtoitsmembers,SEIAcannotimposeanypenaltiesonitsmembersforviolatingtheCode.ThesuggestionbySEIAthatitcanissue“letters”orsuspend“memberbenefits”tothosefoundnotincompliancewiththeCodeisaninsufficientenforcementmechanismandwithoutanypreventivevalueorrecompensetoconsumers.
SEIAdoesnotstatehowitwillconductdecisionsaboutcomplianceornon-compliance
withtheCode.CustomersarenotlegallyinformedoftheirrighttocomplaintotheSEIAanddoingsowouldchillthecustomer’slegalrighttofilecomplaintswithothergovernmentalauthorities,includingthestateAttorneyGeneralortheFederalTradeCommission.AllofitshandlingofcustomercomplaintsandallegationsofviolationoftheCodecanandlikelywillbeheldinconfidentialforumswithoutanyproceduraldueprocessrightsandremediesthatareaffordedconsumersbeforestateandfederalregulatoryagenciesandcourts.
Furthermore,thefederalandstateAnti-TrustActsprohibitSEIAandsimilar
organizationstoundertakeanypoliciesoractionasagroupthatmightbeallegedorfoundtobeanti-competitive,thatis,havingtheimpactofthwartingtheabilityofnon-SEIAmembersfromconductingbusinessandobtainingconsumerswhetherornottheycomplywiththeCode.Anymovetocreatea“shield”tothoseproviderswhoagreetobecomeanSEIAmemberandabidebytheCodeora“sword”tolabelcompetitorswhoarenotmembersoftheSEIAandhave
![Page 50: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
50
notagreedtocomplywiththeCodewilllikelyraiseseriousAnti-Trustclaims.Furthermore,theexistenceoftheAnti-TrustobligationspreventsSEIAandsimilartradeorganizationsfromimposingcertainrequireddisclosureterms,usingcertainplainlanguageterms,creatingbarrierstoentrywithregardtofinancialandtechnicalqualifications,orimposingcustomerserviceperformancecriteria.
SEIA’sSolarBusinessCode,whilecontainingsomeusefulrecommendationsand
provisions,isnotasubstituteformoreformallegislationand/orregulationsgoverningthesolarindustryinitsdealingwithresidentialcustomers.
Thereissomeprecedentfortheseconclusions.Theretailenergymarkethasbeenthe
subjectofdetailedlicensingandconsumerprotectionregulationsandpoliciessincetheonsetofretailcompetition.NoStatehasreliedon“self-enforcement”orindustrycodesofconducttoregulateretailenergyproviders.BoththeNationalEnergyMarketersAssociationandtheRetailEnergySuppliersAssociation(RESA)recognizethisrealityandhavearguedthatsuchprivateregulationshouldnotbesubstitutedforgovernmentalstandardsandregulations,particularlywhenthereisthepotentialfordisparatetreatmentamongsomecompaniesofferingsolarpowerservicesandotherentities,whomaywishtocombinesuchserviceswithothercompetitiveproductsthataresubjecttogovernmentregulation.RESA’srecentcommentstotheNewYorkPublicServiceCommissiononitssuggestionthatdistributedenergyresource(DER)providersmightbeabletorelyonaself-enforcementmechanismwithacodeofconductstated,“Staffshouldhoweverbemindfulthatnoorganizationhastheauthorityorresourcestomonitorandenforceanystandardsthatareadopted.FortheforeseeablefuturethatwillremaintheprovinceoftheCommission.”Evenmoreimportantly,asRESAdescribed,retailenergysupplierswhoarerequiredtobelicensedandregulatedintermsofdisclosureandconsumerprotectionandservicequalityattributesbystateutilitycommissionswillbeofferingDERproductsandservicestoresidentialcustomersthatmaybundleenergycommodityanddistributedgenerationproductsandservices.Asaresult,thereisthepotentialforunfairdiscriminationintermsofregulatoryoversightandconsumerprotectionenforcementthatislikelytohaveanti-competitiveimpactsifsolarprovidersareabletoavoidanydirectordetailedregulationbystatesthroughaprivatelyoperatedself-enforcementmechanism.52
![Page 51: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
51
APPENDIXC:CONSUMEREDUCATIONALMATERIALS
o SolarPowerForYourHomeAConsumersGuide,LSUAgCenterCommunication,2015(partiallyfundedbyEEI)http://www.lsuagcenter.com/en/communications/publications/Publications+Catalog/Home+Improvement/Energy/Solar-Power-for-Your-Home--A-Consumers-Guide.htm
o Energy.govsolarresourceandeducationmaterials:http://energy.gov/eere/sunshot/solar-energy-resource-center-0?Topic=Solar%20Basics_and_Educating%20Consumers
o U.S.DepartmentofEnergy,AConsumersGuide:GetYourPowerFromtheSun.http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy04osti/35297.pdf
o AHomeowner’sGuidetoSolarFinancing,Leases,Loans,andPPAs.ByNateHausman,ProjectManager,CleanEnergyStatesAlliance.February2015.http://www.cesa.org/assets/2015-Files/Homeowners-Guide-to-Solar-Financing.pdf
o AConnecticutConsumer’sGuidetoBuyingaSolarElectricSystembytheConnecticutCleanEnergyFundhttp://uhaweb.hartford.edu/solarinfo/WebPictures/Consumer_Solar_Guide.pdf
o EnergySagewebsite:https://www.energysage.com/solar
o BetterBusinessBureau,Don’tFallforaSolarEnergyScamThisSummerhttp://www.bbb.org/blog/2012/06/dont-fall-for-a-solar-paneling-scam-this-summer/
o SEIA,ResidentialConsumerGuidetoSolarhttp://www.seia.org/sites/default/files/resources/SEIA%20Residential%20Consumer%20Guide%20to%20Solar%20Power%20-%20June%202015.pdf
![Page 52: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
52
ENDNOTES1Inpartthisisduetothelowerproductioncostsassociatedwithsolarpanelsgenerallyandtheimpactof
competitionfrommanufacturersinChina.AccordingtoEnergySage,44%ofthesolarpanelsinuseintheU.S.
weremanufacturedinChinaandU.S.solarpanelscostonaverage10-30centsmoreperwattthanimported
panels.http://blog.energysage.com/where-solar-panels-are-manufactured/2Manystatesinitiallyadoptedgenerouspaymentsundertheirnetmeteringpoliciestostimulateanascent
industryandestablishedceilingsassociatedwithnetmeteringcosts.Asthoseceilingsarereachedandthe
costsassociatedwithnetmeteringaregrowing,manystatesarereviewingandreconsideringthispayment
andcostallocationsystem.3SEIASolarMarketresearchReport.http://www.seia.org/research-resources/us-solar-market-
insight/about4SEIA,U.S.SolarMarketSetsNewRecord,installing7.3GWofSolarPVin2015,PressRelease(February22,
2016),availableat:http://www.seia.org/news/us-solar-market-sets-new-record-installing-73-gw-solar-pv-
2015Itshouldbenotedthatutilityscalesolarstillrepresentsthebulkofsolarpower,representinghalfofall
solarinstalledin2015.5Themarketreached72%thirdpartyownershipin2014.SolarCity,oneofthelargestrooftopsolar
marketers,sellsone-thirdoftheU.S.residentialsolar.
https://www.greentechmedia.com/research/report/us-residential-solar-financing-2015-20206However,SolarCityannouncedinearly2016thatitwasterminatingitsMyPowerleasingproduct.Likea
solarlease,ittiedthecustomer'spaymenttoasolarsystem'senergyproduction,butunlikealease,the
homeownerownedthesystemoncetheloanwaspaidoff.See,
http://www.foxbusiness.com/markets/2016/02/27/solarcity-corp-backed-itself-into-corner-with-
mypower-loan.html7ThecommunitysolartransactionisaddressedspecificallyinChapterVofthisReport.8ThesewebsiteswerevisitedinDecember2015-January2016.9AHomeowner’sGuidetoSolarFinancing,CleanEnergyStatesAllianceandU.S.DepartmentofEnergy,p210WilltheSolarLeaseLiveForeverorFlameOut?
http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/04/30/will-the-solar-lease-live-forever-or-flameout.aspx11SolarPowerforYourHome:AConsumersGuide,LouisianaStateUniversityAgCenter,2015,
http://www.lsuagcenter.com/portals/communications/publications/publications_catalog/home%20improv
ement/energy/solar-power-for-your-home--a-consumers-guide12http://www.gosolarcalifornia.ca.gov/tools/calculators.php13http://pvwatts.nrel.gov14www.energysage.com15SolarWaterHeat,SolarPhotovoltaics,Wind(All)GeothermalHeatPumps,FuelCellsusingNon-Renewable
Fuels,Wind(Small)FuelCellsusingRenewableFuelsonexistinghomesandnewconstruction.
![Page 53: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
53
16http://www.seia.org/research-resources/solar-itc-impact-analysis(Accessed11/7/2015)17“SEIACelebratestheExtensionoftheITC,”http://www.seia.org/news/seia-celebrates-extension-itc
(Accessed12/24/2015)18DISCUSSIONPAPERSINECONOMICSWorkingPaperNo.13-05TaxEvasionandSubsidyPass-Through
undertheSolarInvestmentTaxCredit,MollyPodolefsky,UniversityofColoradoatBoulder,November2013
<http://www.colorado.edu/econ/papers/Wps-13/wp13-05/wp13-05.pdf>(Accessed11/7/2015)19SeeSolarCityForm10-QfortheperiodendingSeptember30,2015,filedonOctober30,2015,pp54-55.<
http://investors.solarcity.com/secfiling.cfm?filingID=1564590-15-8928#SCTY-
10Q_20150930_HTM_ITEM_1_A_RISK_FACTORS>(Accessed11/7/2015)20http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/09/us-usa-solar-investigation-
idUSBRE8980YL20121009#8LSvOOsxldo35JdC.97(Accessed11/7/15)21http://www.dsireusa.org/DSIRE,theDatabaseofIncentivesforRenewablesandEnergyEfficiency,isa
“comprehensivesourceofinformationonincentivesandpoliciesthatsupportrenewableenergyandenergy
efficiencyintheUnitedStates.”ThedatabaseisoperatedbytheN.C.CleanEnergyTechnologyCenteratN.C.
StateUniversityandisfundedbytheU.S.DepartmentofEnergy.Consumerscansearchbystateorzipcodeto
findcurrentincentivesandpolicies,withoptionstofilterbytechnologyand/orprogram.TheU.S.
DepartmentofEnergymaintainsasimilardatabase:http://energy.gov/savings/search22https://nccleantech.ncsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/50-States-of-Solar-Q3-FINAL_25.pdf23http://www.wsj.com/articles/solar-power-fight-hits-home-in-arizona-143833500024AppendixCliststhemostprominentconsumereducationmaterials.25“AreRooftopSolarCompaniesDoingEnoughtoProtectConsumers?”GreentechMedia.comSeptember24,
2015[visited10/28/2015]26https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/yelp-reviews-of-the-top-us-solar-installers27www.consumeraffairs.com/solar-energy/Thiswebsitewillallowtheconsumertosearchbyspecificsolar
companies.28AttorneyGeneralBrnovichSettlesLawsuitAgainstSolarCompany|ArizonaAttorneyGeneral29ArizonaConsumersEligibleforCriminalRestitutioninSolarRebateScam|ArizonaAttorneyGeneral30http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/sunrun-class-action-complaint.ThiscomplaintisCaseNo.
BC498001.31NewOrleansAdvocateon1/1/2015(http://www.theneworleansadvocate.com/news/11222295-
171/nearly-2m-lawsuit-accuses-sader)(Accessedon11/24/2015):32http://www.azleg.gov/DocumentsForBill.asp?Bill_Number=SB1465&Session_ID=11433HOUSEBILLNo.1320wasintroducedJanuary13,2015.Anamendedbillpassedtherelevantcommitteein
a9-4vote,butthebilldidnotreachthefloorforanyfinalvote.
https://iga.in.gov/legislative/2015/bills/house/1320#
![Page 54: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
54
34HB1912wasintroducedFebruary2,2015andreintroducedinthreesubsequentspecialsessions.Whilea
proposalpassedcommitteeonavoteof8-3,thebilldidnotreachthefloorforavote.
http://app.leg.wa.gov/billinfo/summary.aspx?bill=1912&year=201535SB214wasfiledApril3,2015anditwasconsideredincommitteeonApril29,2015,butleftpendingatthe
endofthesession.
https://legis.la.gov/legis/BillInfo.aspx?s=15RS&b=SB214&sbi=y36A.B.330wasintroducedMarch16,2015andwasvotedoutofCommitteewithamendments,butno
furtheractionoccurred.
https://www.leg.state.nv.us/Session/78th2015/Reports/history.cfm?DocumentType=1&BillNo=33037OfficeofAttorneyGeneral,StateofVermont,“GuidanceforThirdPartySolarProjects.”[Undated]38SEIAComments,NewYorkPublicServiceCommission,RE:Case15-M-0180–IntheMatterofRegulation
andOversightofDistributedEnergyResourceProvidersandProducts(September24,2015).39www.seia.org(September2015)[©SolarEnergyIndustriesAssociation]40See,Horton,David,“FederalArbitrationActPreemption:PurposivismandStatePublicPolicy,”Georgetown
LawJournal,Vol.7,2013.http://georgetownlawjournal.org/files/2013/07/Horton.pdf41See,e.g.,CommonwealthofPennsylvania,byAttorneyGeneralKathleenG.Kane,BureauofConsumer
ProtectionandTanyaJ.McCloskey,ActingConsumerAdvocatev.EnergyServicesProviders,Inc.d/b/a
PennsylvaniaGas&Electric,DocketNo.C-2014-2427656,OrderDenyingMotionInLimine(December1,
2014);PennsylvaniaPUC,Kibackv.IDTEnergy,Inc.,DocketNo.C-2014-2409676,OpinionandOrder(Aug.
20,2015);MarylandPSC,IntheMatteroftheInvestigationintotheMarketing,Advertising,andTrade
PracticesofAmericanPowerPartners,LLC;BluePilotEnergy,LLC;MajorEnergyElectricServices,LLCand
MajorEnergyServices,LLC;andXoomEnergyMaryland,LLC,CaseNos.9346and9346(b),ProposedOrder
(Oct.23,2015).42Communitysolarprojectsaresometimesreferredtoas“solarfarms”or“solargardens.”43SolarElectricPowerAssociation,“CommunitySolar:ProgramDesignModels,”(December2015).This
Reportisavailableathttp://www.solarelectricpower.org/about-sepa/sepa-news/press-releases/sepa-
report-provides-models-for-community-solar-success.aspx(AccessedDecember27,2015).44TheformeroptionispursuedinamajorityofCSPs.Someofthemainreasonsforthisarethatfew
communitysolarprojectsubscribershavesufficientunderstandingofRECstomonetizethemandthevalueof
asingleindividual’sRECSareoftenoutweighedbytransactionalcosts.Theprojectownercanbetterdraw
valuefromtheRECs,andinmanycasestheyareabletopassthisvalueontotheirsubscribers.Itshouldbe
notedthatmanyworkinggroupmemberspointedoutthatwhenaRECisnottransferredtothecustomeror
retiredonbehalfofthecustomer,thenthecustomerisnotactuallybuyingsolarpower.Inthesecases,
communitysolarprojectownersshouldbeawareoftheFederalTradeCommission’sguidancethat
“marketersshouldnotmakebroad,unqualifiedrenewableenergyclaims,directlyorbyimplication.”See
SEPACommunitySolarReportat11-12.
![Page 55: FINAL Solar Power Consumer Protection Report Solar Power...allows a comparison of impacts on the customer’s electricity bills and obligations under the applicable financial arrangement](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070811/5f09dfe77e708231d428ea0c/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
55
45MarylandHouseBill1087,availableat:http://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2015RS/bills/hb/hb1087F.pdf
(signedbyGovernorMay12,2015).46TheMarylandPublicServiceCommissionvotedtoissueproposedrulestoimplementthecommunitysolar
programandadoptedmany,butnotall,oftherecommendationsoftheOPC.See,RM56,RevisionstoCOMAR
20.62-CommunitySolarEnergyGenerationSystems,availableattheCommission’swebsiteat:
http://www.psc.state.md.us/search-
results/?keyword=RM56&x.x=20&x.y=10&search=all&search=rulemaking47OfficeoftheAttorneyGeneral—AntitrustandUtilitiesDivisions’SupplementalResponsetoExcelEnergy’s
PetitiontoApproveSolarGardenTariff,PublicUtilitiesCommissionofMinnesota,IntheMatterofthe
PetitionofNorthernStatesPowerCo.forApprovalofitsProposedCommunitySolarGardensProgram,
DocketNo.E002/M-13-867(December3,2013).48AttorneyGeneralCommentsat4,citingtoaDenverPostarticle,fn.16.49MinnesotaPublicUtilitiesCommission,IntheMatterofthePetitionofNorthernStatesPowerCo.,d/b/a
XcelEnergy,forApprovalofitsProposedCommunitySolarGardenProgram,DocketNo.E-002/M-13-867
(April7,2014).ThisproceedingsubsequentlyresultedinnumerousfilingsandordersfromtheCommission
duetothelargevolumeofsolargardeninterconnectionproposalsmadetoXcelEnergy,manyofwhomwere
proposalsfortheco-locationofseveral1MWgardenprojectsatonelocationbyoperatorsthatproposedto
servelargercommercialcustomers,givingrisetoconcernsabouttheincreasedcosttoratepayersforthe
subsidypaymentsorderedbytheCommissiontostimulatesolargardendevelopment.50Asincludedinthebill,“Thelegislaturerecognizestheimportanceofensuringpublicsafetyandconsumer
protectionwithanappropriatelevelofregulationthatstillallowsacompetitivemarketplacetodevelop,and
forthisreasonthelegislatureconfersauthoritytotheWashingtonUtilitiesandTransportationCommission
toregulateas"competitiveelectricalcompanies"privatethird-partyvendorswhoproviderenewableenergy
systemsdirectlytoconsumersthroughaconsumercontractandaffiliatesofinvestor-ownedutilitieswho
investcompanydollarstomakethesesystemsmorewidelyaccessible.”51https://www.seia.org/directory[Visited11/16/2015]52RetailEnergySupplyAssociation(RESA)Comments,NewYorkPublicServiceCommission,RE:Case15-M-
0180–IntheMatterofRegulationandOversightofDistributedEnergyResourceProvidersandProducts
(September24,2015).