final review madeira / 28. march 2007

1AIDIMA / © ATHENA Consortium 2004

Final ReviewMadeira / 28. March 2007

ATHENA B6 Training


Outline

● Overview of Achievements● Major Achievements M32-M38● Courses and training material● Course execution● Outlook – Future executions


ATHENA B6 – Overview of achievements

Sustainability

Learning platforms: Moodle, Blackboard, SAP LSO, SAP Developer Network, EIC

Learning Partner commitment to execute classroom and virtual classroom training Many channels of dissemination and knowledge sharing

Delivery

Delivery methods (classroom, virtual classroom, Web Based Training) > 7.000 participations School of interoperability Positive learner feedback

Curriculum

Industrial and academic needs Training areas Course Catalogue Course Content

Target Groups Analysis Identification Validation

CourseDevelopment

Platform independence (SCORM, ARTICULATE) Content (animations, game based learning, interactivity, didactical structure,

glossaries, navigation facilities) Accompanying material Quality assurance (internal and external)


Major Achievements M32-M38

● DB 6.1, 6.2, 6.3 and 6.4 refinement● More than 7.000 course participations up to now, still growing● Development of 8 new courses (altogether 21 courses)● Continuous improvement of LMS (e.g. game based learning

for built in assessments)● Execution of virtual classrooms supplementing existing

delivery methods (web based training and classroom)● Sustainability of training delivery after the lifetime of the

project secured using various distribution channels● Attracted learners in line with initial target group findings


Courses and training material activities

● Development of contents● New 8 courses concluded at M36

● Development of training materials● Slides, Handouts, Booklet and Assessment.

● Improvement of the quality of the courses● based on delivery feedback and quality reviews.

● Development of flash-based courses with digital voice● eLearning and video

● Integration of courses in other e-Learning platforms● Moddle, Blackboard, SAP Developer Network.


Status of NEW M36 courses and training material

Course acronym and Title Type Length

Hours

Accomp

Material

BI1 – Introduction to business interoperability E-Learning 1.5 S, H, B,E

BI2 – Business Documents and Protocols E-Learning 4.5 S, H,B, E

CI2 - The ATHENA Interoperability Framework E-Learning 2 S, H, B, E

CI3 - Practices of Interoperability in SMEs E-Learning 1.5 S, H, B, E

ONT3 – The ATHENA Semantic Suite E-Learning 2 (*)

PDE1 - Introduction to Dynamic Requirements Definition Classroom 3 S, H, B, E

PDE2 - Standards to support Interoperability for Product Life cycle Management

Classroom 4 S, H, B, E

PDE3 - Frameworks for interoperability of product data in SME based environments

E-Learning 4 S, H, B, ES=Slides; H=Handouts; B=Booklet; E=Evaluation

(*) ONT3 course covers the use of tools


Status of M24 ALREADY FINISHED courses and training material


Hours

Accomp

Material

EM1- Enterprise Modelling as a way to achieve Interoperability E-Learning

4 S, H, B, E

EM2 - Active Knowledge Modelling of Enterprises Classroom 3.5 S, H, B, E

EM3 - Cross-Org. Business Processes - Interoperability Issues and Concepts

E-Learning

1.5 S, H, B, E

EM4 - Cross-Org. Business Processes – Enabling Technologies and Tools E-Learning

1.5 S, H, B, E

AP1 - Introduction to Service-Oriented Interoperability (SOI) Classroom 1 S, H, B, E

AP2 - Planning and Specification of Interoperable Service-Oriented Solutions


AP3 - Implem Interop Service-Ortd Solut. using WebService & Agent Technologies


AP4 - Introduction to Model-Driven Interoperability (MDI) Classroom 1 S, H, B, E

AP5 - Principles of Model-Driven Interoperability Classroom 4 S, H, B, E

AP6 - Model-Driven Dvlpmt of Interoperable WebServices, Agents & P2P Solutions


ONT1 - Introduction to Semantics E-Learning

4 S, H, B, E

ONT2 - Ontology based support to Enterprise Interoperability Classroom 2 S, H, B, E

CI1 - Fundamentals in Interoperability E-Learning

3 S, H, B, E

S=Slides; H=Handouts; B=Booklet; E=Evaluation


ATHENA training approach

The ATHENA training service supports three types of training:● Delivery that is bound by place and time, such as classroom

training and instructor-led training.● Delivery that is independent of time and location, such as

Web-based courseware that the learner can access anytime, anywhere.

● Delivery that is bound by time only, such as instructor-led, synchronous virtual classroom sessions, where a tutor guides the learner through a session over the Internet.


Web-based Training ● Web-based training is accessible and executable via the

ATHENA Learning Platform (SAP Learning Solution) and other Learning Management Systems.


Peer review and revision of course contents


Easy to use tools (e.g., for video production)● Articulate Presenter to create Flash based presentations

(SCORM compliant) from PowerPoint.● Text-to-Voice Synthesizer tools to rapidly transform

explicative text of courses into digital voice.


Learning Games● Learning Games (Choices, Word quiz and Sequence)


Web-based training courses


Hours

CI1 - Fundamentals in Interoperability E-Learning 3

EM1- Enterprise Modelling as a way to achieve Interoperability

E-Learning 4

ONT1 - Introduction to Semantics E-Learning 4

BI1 – Introduction to business interoperability E-Learning 1.5

BI2 – Business Documents and Protocols E-Learning 4.5

CI2 - The ATHENA Interoperability Framework E-Learning 2

CI3 - Practices of Interoperability in SMEs E-Learning 1.5

PDE3 – Frameworks for interoperability of product data in SME based environments

E-Learning 4


Training material compatibility● Integration of courses in other e-Learning platforms

● MOODLE, Faculty of Sciences and Technology, Portugal

● Bb (Blackboard), New University of Lisbon, Portugal● SAP Developer Network/Business Process Expert

Community● EIC community website● SAP Learning Solution


Virtual Classroom● Click-to-MeetTM was used for training in the European MSC

Programme to deliver synchronous virtual classroom sessions, where a tutor guides the learner through a session over the Internet.


Overall Training Execution

0

1000

2000

30004000

5000

6000

7000

8000

Q1 2006 Q3 2006 Q1 2007

Course Participations

external

internal


Participants in the delivered courses at M36

Internal

participants

External

participants

Total

participants

Comments

Classroom 472 1762 2234 50% are university students

Web-based 84 5143 5227 Delivery via 4 different elearning channels

Total 556 6905 7461


Number of times courses were delivered (M38)Course Acronym and Title Times

Delivered

EM1- Enterprise Modeling as a way to achieve Interoperability 8EM2 - Active Knowledge Modeling of Enterprises 9EM3 - Cross-Organizational Bus. Processes – Enabling Techn. & Tools 9EM4 - Cross-Organizational Bus. Processes – Interop.y Issues and Concepts 9AP1 - Introduction to Service-Oriented Interoperability (SOI) 8AP2 - Planning and Specification of Interoperable Service-Oriented Solutions 8AP3 - Implementing Interoperable Service-Oriented Solutions using Web Service and Agent Technologies

8

AP4 - Introduction to Model-Driven Interoperability (MDI) 5AP5 - Principles of Model-Driven Interoperability 6AP6 - Model-Driven Development of Interoperable Web Services, Agents and P2P Solutions

6

ONT1 - Introduction to Semantics 9ONT2 - Ontology based support to Enterprise Interoperability 3CI1 - Fundamentals in Interoperability 7


Number of times courses were delivered (M38)

Course Acronym and Title Times

Delivered

BI1 – Introduction to business interoperability 8 BI2 – Business Documents and Protocols 3 CI2 - The ATHENA Interoperability Framework 1 CI3 - Practices of Interoperability in SMEs 1 ONT3 – The ATHENA Semantic Suite 2 PDE1 - Introduction to Dynamic Requirements Definition 2 PDE2 – Standards to support Interoperability for Product Life cycle Management 2 PDE3 - Frameworks for interoperability of product data in SME based environments 3


Total figures achieved per Course – by M36

Date Producer Course Content Participants internal

Participants external

Participants total

2006- 3/2007 ESI

EM1 – Enterprise Modeling

(Course delivery to projects)

18 96 114

2005-3/2007

TrouxAKM

EM2 – Active Knowledge Modeling of Enterprises (adapted for industry)

24 140 164

2006

2007

SAPDFKI

EM3 – Cross Organizational Business Processes – Concepts and Issues

43 100 143

2006

2007

SAP

DFKI

EM4 – Cross Organizational Business Processes – Techniques and Tools

44 73 117

1/2006

2007 SINTEF

AP1 – Introduction to Service-.Oriented Interoperability

18 195 213

1/2006

2007 SINTEF

AP2 – Planning and specification of

Interoperable S-O Solutions

17 118 135

1/2006

2007 DFKI

AP3- Implementing ISOS using Web services and intelligent agents.

18 145 163




Participants total

1/2006

2007 SINTEF

AP4 - Introduction to Model-driven Interoperability (MDI)

21 148 169

1/2006

2007 SINTEF

AP5 – Principles of Model-driven Interoperability - MDI

21 148 169

1/2006

2007 SINTEF

AP6 – Model-driven Interoperable Web services, agents and P2P

solutions

22 148 170

1/2006

2007

SAP ONT1 – Introduction to semantic interoperability

43 216 259

5/2006

2007

SAP

LEX

ONT2 – Ontology based support to Enterprise Interoperability

8 30 38

9/2006

2007

SAP

LEX

ONT3 – Ontology methods

Will be blended with other courses

10 0 10

1-3/

2007 Aidima

PDE1 - Introduction to Dynamic Requirements Definition

6 28 34

1-3/

2007 EADS

PDE2 - Standards to

Support PLM Interoperability4 10 14





Participants total

1-3/

2007 ESI

PDE3 - Frameworks for interoperability of product data

6 22 28

9/2006

3/2007

INSEAD

St. Gallen

BI1 - Introduction to Business Interoperability

16 96 112

12/2006

2007

SAP BI2 - Business Documents and Protocols

5 11 16

2005

2007

UNINOVA CI1 - Fundamentals in Interoperability

25 90 115

1-3/

2007

SAP, IBM

SINTEF

CI2 –The ATHENA Interoperability

Framework

0 0 0

1-3/

2007

TXT

ESI, SINTEF

CI3 –Practices of interoperability in SMEs

0 0 0



Course Execution – eLearning

● 4 sucessfull eLearning channels addressing different target groups

● High demand for individual courses● EM3, ONT1 > 2000 participations

● Potential for ~18.000 overall participations in 2007

Figures counted 22nd of March 2007


Details of Web Based Training statistics


eLearning – attracted learners

● Majority with industry background● Substantial portion of Managers● ~ 90% experts with distinctive work

experience● IT and business know-how demands● Confirmation of initial target group

analysis findings

Distribution Academic/Industry

27%

57%

16%

Academic

Industry

Other

Trainee categories in industry

65%

29%

6%

Experts

Managers

Other

Trainee categories in general

9%

16%

6%

21%29%

3%

4% 12%Consultants

Managers

Students

Academic

Industry

Administration

Other

No JobTitle


Response to the last reviewers report● Recommendation D.B6.4a.1: Those partners of the project

that have been involved in the production of training materials and course content should come up with a document that clarifies the access rights and associated costs for a sustainable use of the training materials and course contents after the end of the project.

● Response: ● The recommended document was prepared, and delivered as

part of D.B6.4b – Annex B● Recommendation D.B6.4a.2: The not yet finalized materials

for Web-based and Classroom-based training need to be made available to the reviewers before the final project review.

● Response: .● All materials were finished


Sustainability of eLearning channels

● Long term ATHENA learning channels ● SAP Developer Network● EIC Community● New University Lisbon● ATHENA Learning Portal

confirmed to be availbable at least untill Q3 2007


Future execution Web Based Training

● Sustanibility of participation will be assured by the availability of new courses● Wave 1: EM3, ONT1, ONT3, BI1, BI2 available

now● Wave 2: CI1, CI2, CI3, PDE3, EM1 and EM4 to be

available end of April 2007● Wave 3: classroom trainings considered to be

converted● Potential of 18.000 participations during 2007


Planned classroom course deliveries after March 2007

Date Location Course Content Participants internal


Participants total

Spring

2007

By ESI

Spain



0 30 30

Autumn

2007

By ESI

Spain



0 30 30

Spring

2007

AKM seminar

Sweden

EM2 – Active Knowledge Modeling of Enterprises

(adapted for Automotive industry)

0 30 30

Autumn

2007

AKM seminars

EM2 – Active Knowledge Modeling of Enterprises,

seminar every month

0 30 30

Spring

2007

SAP Internal workshops

EM3 – Cross Organizational Business Processes –

Concepts and Issues

30 0 30

2007

CBN

St. Gallen

EM3 - Cross Organizational Business Processes –

Concepts and Issues

20 0 20

2007

SAP Internal workshops


30 0 30

2007

CBN

St. Gallen


20 0 20




Participants

total

Spring

2007

Univ. of Oslo

Norway

AP1 – Introduction to Service-.Oriented Interoperability

0 50 50

Autumn

2007

Norstella/DND

Norway

AP1 - Introduction to Service-.Oriented Interoperability

5 20 20

May 2007

Univ. of Oslo

Norway



0 50 50

May 2007

Norstella/DND

Norway



0 20 20

Autumn 2007

Univ. of Oslo

Norway

MDE course – Planning to combine AP1 and AP2 to deliver a new course.

0 50 50

Spring 2007

Univ. des Saarlandes

AP3- Implementing ISOS using Web services and intelligent agents.

0 40 40

Autumn

2007

DFKI AP3- Implementing ISOS using Web services and intelligent agents.

5 10 15

Spring

2007

Univ. of Oslo

Norway

AP4 - Introduction to Model-driven Interoperability (MDI)

0 50 50

Spring

2007

Univ. of Oslo

Norway

AP5 - Principles of Model-driven Interoperability - MDI

0 50 50

Autumn

2007

Univ. of Oslo

Norway

AP5 - Principles of Model-driven Interoperability - MDI

0 50 50





Participants total

Spring

2007

Univ. of Oslo

Norway

AP6 - Model-driven Interoperable Web services, agents and P2P solutions

0 50 50

Autumn

2007

Univ. of Oslo

Norway

AP6 - Model-driven Interoperable Web services, agents and P2P solutions

0 40 40

April 2007 European MSC Programme

SAP

ONT1- Introduction on semantics 0 20 20

Spring

2007

SAP Research, Karlsruhe

ONT2 – Ontology based support to Enterprise Interoperability

5 10 15

Autumn

2007

SAP XI ONT2 – Ontology based support to Enterprise Interoperability

5 10 15

Spring

2007


ONT3- ATHENA Semantic Suite 20 0 20

Summer

2007

SAP XI ONT3 - ATHENA Semantic Suite 15 0 15

Spring

2007

Aidima PDE1 - Introduction to Dynamic Requirements Definition

5 15 20





Participants total

Spring

2007

EADS PDE2 - Standards to

Support PLM Interoperability

15 10 25

Sept.

2007

ITC

Euromaster

PDE3 - Frameworks for interoperability of product data

0 15 15

Autumn

2007

UNINOVA PDE3 - Frameworks for interoperability, new course being developed

0 40 40

Spring

2007

SAP Research, St Gallen

BI1 - Introduction to Business Interoperability

15 0 15

Spring

2007

SAP Research, St Gallen

BI2 – Business Documents and Protocols

10 0 10

Summer

2007


BI2 – Business Documents and Protocols

20 0 20

Spring

2007

ITC

Euromaster

CI1- Fundamentals in

Interoperability

0 15 15

Autumn

2007

UNINOVA CI1- Fundamentals in Interoperability, new course being developed

0 40 40





Participants total

Spring

2007

SAP

SINTEF

CI2 – ATHENA Interoperability Framework

5 15 20

Autumn

2007

SAPEIC

CI2 – ATHENA InteroperabilityFramework

0 40 40

Spring 2007

ESI TXT

CI3 – Interoperability in SME’s 5 15 20

Spring 2007

ESI

EIC

CI3 – Interoperability in SME’s 0 40 40



Thank you…