final report-tobacco compliance 2014 - final - eng[6] copy

8/21/2019 Final Report-Tobacco Compliance 2014 - FINAL - EnG[6] Copy

1/59

"#$%&$'()* )+ ,-'$(%-./0 1-2$#()&. 3)4$.5/ 6-.'$(*

7)&'2 899-//:'):3);$99) ,-/'.(9'()*/


2/59

"X8YZ83CMH M< ,"38CY",F0 1"P8XCMZ, 3M[8,LF 6",38CH 7MZ3P 866"FF:3M:3M1866M ,"F3,C63CMHF

\$G- A

"#$%& '( )'*+&*+,

-. /0&12+34& 5266#78 ................................................................................ 9

AT? 1$9VG.)&*5 TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT K

ATK \.-+$9- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT B

ATJ ,-/-$.92 M;]-9'(#-/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT SATB N-E -'2)5)%)GE TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT Q

ATSTA F9)=- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AA

ATST? F$W=%- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AA

ATSTK F$W=%- [-(G2'(*G TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AK

ATO Z*5-./'$*5(*G '2(/ ,-=).' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AB

:. ;&+#3%&< =3*, .................................................................................. -?

?TA H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AS

?TATA H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E 8G- )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AU

?TAT? H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E 8G- )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?@

?TATK H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E F-^ )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?A

?TATJ H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E F-^ )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ??

?TATB H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E \.)^(W('E ') F92))%/ $*5_). >$%%/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?K

?TATS H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E 3(W- )+ X(/(' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?K

?TATO H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E \.-/-*9- )+ 85&%'/ (* M&'%-' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?B

?TATU H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E 6%$// )+ 3.$5- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?S

?T? ,-/&%'/ ;E 6('E_\.)#(*9-_,-G()* TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?O

?T?TA ,-G()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E 8G- )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT K?

?T?T? ,-G()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E 8G- )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT KJ

?T?TK ,-G()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E F-^ )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT KS

?T?TJ ,-G()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E F-^ )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT KU

?T?TB ,-G()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E \.)^(W('E ') F92))%/ $*5_). >$%%/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT J@?T?TS ,-G()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E 3(W- )+ X(/(' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT J?

?T?TO ,-G()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E \.-/-*9- ). H)' )+ 85&%'/ (* M&'%-' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT JJ

?T?TU ,-G()*$% ,-/&%'/ ;E 6%$// )+ 3.$5- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT JS

?TK 3);$99) \.)5&9'/ L(/=%$E 6)W=%($*9- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT JU

?TJ M;/-.#$'()*/ )* ":9(G$.-''-/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT B@

?TJTA H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ +). ":9(G$.-''- F$%-/:'):>(*)./ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT B@

?TJT? H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ +). ":9(G$.-''-/ ;E 8G- )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BA

?TJTK H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ +). ":9(G$.-''-/ ;E 8G- )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT B?

?TJTJ H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ +). ":9(G$.-''-/ ;E F-^ )+ >(*). $*5 )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BK

?TJTB H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ +). ":9(G$.-''-/ ;E 3(W- )+ X(/(' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BJ

?TJTS H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ +). ":9(G$.-''-/ ;E \.)^(W('E ') F92))%/ $*5_). >$%%/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BB?TJTO H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ +). ":9(G$.-''-/ ;E \.-/-*9- )+ 85&%'/ (* M&'%-' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BB

?TJTU H$'()*$% ,-/&%'/ +). ":9(G$.-''-/ ;E 6%$// )+ 3.$5- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BS

?TJTQ ":9(G$.-''- L(/=%$E/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BS

9. )'*1%2,3'*, ........................................................................................... @A


3/59


\$G- ?

B*(*)./ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AS

62$.' ?R H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ') >(*)./ #/T 8/V-5 +). CL TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AO

3$;%- AR F$%-/ $*5 CL 6)W=%($*9- ;E 7-$. TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AU

62$.' KR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ') $ >(*).R 1E 8G- )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AQ

3$;%- ?R F$%-/ $*5 CL 6)W=%($*9- ;E 8G- )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT AQ

62$.' JR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ') $ >(*).R 1E 8G- )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?@

3$;%- KR F$%-/ $*5 CL 6)W=%($*9- ;E 8G- )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?@

62$.' BR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ') $ >(*).R 1E F-^ )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?A

3$;%- JR F$%-/ $*5 CL 6)W=%($*9- ;E F-^ )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ??

3$;%- BR F$%-/ $*5 CL 6)W=%($*9- ;E F-^ )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ??

3$;%- SR F$%-/ $*5 CL 6)W=%($*9- ;E \.)^(W('E ') F92))%/ $*5_). >$%%/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?K

62$.' SR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ') $ >(*).R 1E 3(W- )+ X(/(' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?J

62$.' OR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ') $ >(*).R 1E \.-/-*9- )+ 85&%'/ (*

F').- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?B

62$.' UR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ') $ >(*).R 1E 6%$// )+ 3.$5- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?S

3$;%- OR P(G2 6)W=%($*9- ,-G()*/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ?Q

3$;%- UR F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E ,-G()* `AQQQ:?@AJa TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT K@

3$;%- QR F$%-/ $*5 CL 6)W=%($*9- ;E ,-G()* TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT KA

3$;%- A@R F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E 8G- )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT KK

3$;%- AAR F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E 8G- )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT KB

3$;%- A?R F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E F-^ )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT KO

3$;%- AKR F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E F-^ )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT KQ

3$;%- AJR F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E \.)^(W('E ') F92))%/ $*5_). >$%%/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT JA

3$;%- ABR F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E 3(W- )+ X(/(' TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT JK

3$;%- ASR F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E \.-/-*9- )+ M'2-. 85&%'/ (* F').- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT JB

3$;%- AOR F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- ;E 6%$// )+ 3.$5- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT JO

3$;%- AUR F$%-/ 6)W=%($*9- 1$/-5 )* 6)W=%($*9- 4('2 \.)5&9' L(/=%$E ,&%-/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT JQ

62$.' QR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ":9(G$.-''-/ ') $ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT B@

62$.' A@R H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ":9(G$.-''-/R 1E 8G- )+ >(*). TTTTTTTTTTTTT BA

62$.' AAR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ":9(G$.-''-/R 1E 8G- )+ 6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTT B?

62$.' A?R H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ":9(G$.-''-/R 1E F-^ )+ >(*). $*5 )+

6%-.V TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BK

62$.' AKR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ":9(G$.-''-/R 1E 3(W- )+ X(/(' TTTTTTTTTTTTTT BJ

62$.' AJR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ":9(G$.-''-/R 1E \.-/-*9- )+ 85&%'/ (*

F').- TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BB

62$.' ABR H$'()*$% 6)W=%($*9- ,-/&%'/R ,-'$(%-./ ,-+&/(*G ') F-%% ":9(G$.-''-/R 1E 6%$// )+ 3.$5- TTTTTTTTTTT BS

3$;%- AQR \.)=).'()* M;/-.#(*G ":9(G$.-''-/ (* F').-/ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BO


4/59


\$G- K

-.

/0&12+34& 5266#78

-.: D#1E>7'2*<

32(/ .-=).' /&WW$.(b-/ .-/&%'/ +.)W '2- %$'-/' (*5-=-*5-*' (*#-/'(G$'()* (*') .-'$(%-. ;-2$#()&. 4('2

.-/=-9' ') V-E $/=-9'/ )+ 6$*$5($* ');$99) %-G(/%$'()*I (* =$.'(9&%$. '2$' =$.' )+ '2- %$4/ .-G$.5(*G E)&'2

$99-// ') ');$99)T 32- %$4/ .-G&%$'(*G ');$99) /$%-/ (* 6$*$5$ $.- -W;)5(-5 (* '2- +-5-.$%

G)#-.*W-*'0/ !"#$%%" '%( $*5 (* 9)..-/=)*5(*G =.)#(*9($% %-G(/%$'()*T

M* 8=.(% BI ?@@AI '2- +-5-.$% G)#-.*W-*' $**)&*9-5 '2- %$&*92(*G )+ '2- (*)./ $''-W='-5 ') ;&E $ ;.$*5:*$W- =$9V )+ 9(G$.-''-/ ;&' .-+&/-5 '2- '.$*/$9'()* (+

.-'$(%-./ $==-$.-5 4(%%(*G ') /-%%T C+ $/V-5 '2-(. $G-I '--*/ 4-.- (*/'.&9'-5 ') ;- &*'.&'2+&%T P)4-#-.I'2-E 9$..(-5 *) (5-*'(+(9$'()* $*5 W$5- *) -++).' ') 5(/G&(/- '2-(. $==-$.$*9-T 85&%' );/-.#-./ 4-.-

.-/=)*/(;%- +). '2- /&=-.#(/()* $*5 '.$*/=).'$'()* )+ W(*)./I $/ 4-%% $/ +). '2- 9)%%-9'()* )+ 5$'$ .-%$'(*G

') '2- 5(/=%$E )+ -:9(G$.-''-/T 32- $5&%' $%/) $//(/'-5 4('2 '2- -/'(W$'- )+ '2- $G- )+ '2- 9%-.V $*5 %))V-5

+). /92))%/ $*5 W$%%/ 4('2(* 9%)/- =.)^(W('E ') '2- .-'$(%-.T 3-$W W-W;-./ )=-.$'-5 (*5-=-*5-*'%E )+

)*- $*)'2-.T

>(*)./ 4-.- (*/'.&9'-5 ') $/V +). $ /=-9(+(9 ;.$*5 )+ 9(G$.-''-/I L& >$&.(-. N(*G F(b- (* $%% =.)#(*9-/


5/59


\$G- J

-^9-=' d&-;-9I 42-.- '2-E $/V-5 +). "^=).' e8fT C+ '2- /').- 5(5 *)' 2$#- '2- ;.$*5I '2-E 4-.-

(*/'.&9'-5 ') $/V +). \%$E-.0/ N(*G F(b-T ,-G$.5%-// )+ '2- ;.$*5/ /')9V-5 ). $#$(%$;%-I '2- W(*). 4$/

(*/'.&9'-5 ') 92))/- $ ;.$*5 $*5 $/V ') =&.92$/- ('T

32(/ E-$.I E)&'2 4-.- $/V-5 ') .-=).' (+ .-'$(%-./ 4-.- /&GG-/'(*G )'2-. ;.$*5/ ). 'E=-/ )+ ');$99)

5&.(*G $* $''-W='-5 =&.92$/-I $/ 4-%% $/ 42-'2-. '2-E 4-.- )++-.-5 $* -:9(G$.-''- (*/'-$5 )+ $ =$9V )+

9(G$.-''-/T 32- +(*5(*G/ /2)4 '2$' %-// '2$* Ac )+ .-'$(%-./ `@TSca /&GG-/'-5 $*)'2-. ;.$*5 !" 'E=- )+

');$99) ). $* -:9(G$.-''- `@TKcaT

,-'$(%-./ (* +)&. 9%$//-/ )+ '.$5- 4-.- /$W=%-5R 92$(* 9)*#-*(-*9-I G$/ /'$'()*/ 4('2 9)*#-*(-*9- /').-/

`.-+-..-5 ') $/ eG$/ 9)*#-*(-*9-f '2.)&G2)&' '2- .-=).'aI G.)9-.E /').-/I $*5 (*5-=-*5-*' `(T-TI *)*:

92$(*a 9)*#-*(-*9- /').-/T 32(/ E-$.I 4- 5)9&W-*'-5 42-'2-. $ G.)9-.E /').- /)%5 9(G$.-''-/ +.)W

(*/(5- '2- /').- $' $ 9)&.'-/E 9)&*'-.I ). +.)W $ /-=$.$'- -*'.$*9-I /&92 $/ $ /W)V- /2)= $''$92-5 ')

'2- /').-T 32(/ (/ )+'-* '2- 9$/- 42-* G.)9-.E /').-/ 2$#- (*:2)&/- =2$.W$9(-/I /(*9- (* $%% =.)#(*9-/

4('2 '2- -^9-='()* )+ 1.('(/2 6)%&W;($I =2$.W$9(-/ $.- ;$**-5 +.)W /-%%(*G 9(G$.-''-/T C+ $ G.)9-.E /').-

2$5 $ G$/ /'$'()* )* '2- =.-W(/-/ $*5 /)%5 9(G$.-''-/ +.)W '2-.-I (' 4$/ 9%$//(+(-5 $/ $ G$/ 9)*#-*(-*9-

%)9$'()*T

C* ?@AJI +(-%5 .-/-$.92 ') 5-'-.W(*- '2- e&*(#-./-f =)=&%$'()* )+ .-'$(%-./ (* -$92 9%$// )+ '.$5- 4$/

9)*5&9'-5 (* -$92 )+ '2- K@ 9('(-/ /'&5(-5 2-.-(*T 32- &*(#-./- =)=&%$'()* 4$/ 5-+(*-5 $/ ;-(*G

');$99):/-%%(*G .-'$(%-./ (* $*E )+ '2- +)&. 9%$//-/ )+ '.$5- $*5 )=-.$'(*G 4('2(* '2- G-)G.$=2(9

;)&*5$.(-/ )+ '2- 9('E0/ 6-*/&/ >-'.)=)%('$* 8.-$ `6>8a ). 6-*/&/ 8.-$ `68aT 32- .-/&%'/ )+ '2-

.-/-$.92 4-.- &/-5 ') .-5-/(G* '2- /$W=%(*G =%$* $*5 .-5(/'.(;&'- '2- /$W=%- ;E 9('E $*5 ;E 9%$// )+

'.$5- ') -*/&.- '2$' (' 4$/ .-=.-/-*'$'(#- )+ 9&..-*' W$.V-' 9)*5('()*/T

8 ')'$% )+ BIBKQ /').-/ 4-.- #(/('-5 4('2(* K@ 9('(-/ $9.)// 6$*$5$I $/ =$.' )+ '2(/ /'&5ET 32- /$W- 9('(-/

2$#- ;--* 9)*/(/'-*'%E /'&5(-5 /(*9- ?@@?T

F(G* 9)W=%($*9- 4$/ );/-.#-5 (* =.-#()&/ E-$./I ;&' *)' (* ?@AJT 8 5-9(/()* 4$/ W$5- *)' ')

9)%%-9' '2(/ (*+).W$'()* )* W$*5$').E $G-:$5#(/).E $*5_). ');$99) 2-$%'2:4$.*(*G /(G*/ (* .-'$(%

-/'$;%(/2W-*'/ 42-.- ');$99) =.)5&9'/ $.- /)%5T 8/ '2-.- (/ W&92 #$.($'()* +.)W =.)#(*9- ') =.)#(*9-

4('2 .-/=-9' ') W$*5$').E 5(/=%$E )+ $G-:$5#(/).E /(G*/ +). '2- =&.92$/- )+ ');$99) $*5 '2- %)9$'()* )+

'2-/- /(G*/I '2(/ (*+).W$'()* 4$/ )+ %(W('-5 &/-T

8* -:9(G$.-''- 9)W=)*-*' 4$/ $55-5 ') '2- /'&5EI (*9%&5(*G );/-.#$'()* )+ -:9(G$.-''- 5(/=%$E/ (*

.-'$(%-. /').-/ /-%%(*G ');$99) =.)5&9'/ $*5 W-$/&.(*G .-'$(%-./0 4(%%(*G*-// ') /-%% -:9(G$.-''-/ ') E)&'2

&*5-. '2- %-G$% $G- )+ =&.92$/(*G 9(G$.-''-/ 42) 4)&%5 )'2-.4(/- ;- ')) E)&*G ') ;- %-G$%%E +&.*(/2-5

4('2 9(G$.-''-/T

1$*/ )* ');$99) 5(/=%$E/ 2$#- ;--* =&' (*') -++-9' (* $%% =.)#(*9-/I (*9%&5(*G H-4+)&*5%$*5 $*5

Y$;.$5).I 42(92 9$W- (*') -++-9' (* ?@A@T 8/ /&92I )&. .-/-$.92 +(*5(*G/ )* '2- =.-/-*9- )+ =)(*':)+:/$%-

`\MFa $5#-.'(/(*G 4-.- .-W)#-5 +.)W '2(/ /'&5ET P)4-#-.I )&. +(*5(*G/ .-%$'-5 ') ');$99) 5(/=%$E

9)W=%($*9- $.- =.-/-*'-5 $G$(* (* '2(/ E-$.0/ /'&5ET

>(*)./ 4-.- $/V-5 ') );/-.#- (+ )'2-. ');$99) =.)5&9'/I /&92 $/ 92-4(*G ');$99)I /*&++I (*5(#(5&$%

9(G$./I 9(G$.(%%)/I +%$#)&.-5 9(G$.-''-/ 4-.- 5(/=%$E-5 +). /$%-T 8%% )'2-. W-$/&.-W-*'/ +). '2(/ E-$.0/


6/59


\$G- B

/&.#-E 4-.- 9)%%-9'-5 $*5 .-9).5-5 (* '2- /$W- 4$E $/ =.-#()&/ E-$./T

M;/-.#$'()*/ 4-.- W$5- .-%$'(*G ') -:9(G$.-''- 5(/=%$E/I $*5 42-'2-. '2- W(*)./ 4-.- )++-.-5 ')

=&.92$/- $* -:9(G$.-''- (*/'-$5 )+ $ =$9V )+ 9(G$.-''-/T 8 /&;/$W=%- )+ '2- W(*)./I (+ .-+&/-5 '2- /$%- )+

$ =$9V )+ 9(G$.-''-/I $''-W='-5 ') =&.92$/- $* -:9(G$.-''- (*/'-$5 (+ '2- )==).'&*('E =.-/-*'-5 ('/-%+

`42(92 (' 5(5 $W)*G AQTJc )+ '2)/- 5-*(-5 '2- /$%- )+ 9(G$.-''-/aT M* '2-/- )99$/()*/I .-'$(%-./ 4-.-

4(%%(*G ') /-%% -:9(G$.-''-/ ') W(*)./ QTUc )+ '2- '(W-T

-.9

F7&(#1&

32(/ (/ '2- %$'-/' (* $ /-.(-/ )+ /'&5(-/ 5-/(G*-5 ') -#$%&$'- '2- ;-2$#()&. )+ .-'$(%-./ ')4$.5/ E)&'2

$99-//:'):');$99) .-/'.(9'()*/T 32- /'&5E '))V =%$9- $**&$%%E +.)W AQQB ') ?@@@I ?@@? ') ?@@QI $*5

$G$(* (* ?@AJT P-$%'2 6$*$5$ 2$/ ;--* &/(*G (*5-=-*5-*' .-/-$.92-./ /(*9- AQQB ') -#$%&$'- .-'$(%-.

;-2$#()&. ')4$.5/ E)&'2 $99-// .-/'.(9'()*/ )+ '2- +-5-.$% $*5 =.)#(*9($% ');$99) %$4/T

32- +-5-.$% !"#$%%" '%( /-'/ '2- W(*(W&W +-5-.$% /'$*5$.5/ (* 6$*$5$I =.)2(;('(*G '2- +&.*(/2(*G )+

');$99) =.)5&9'/ ') W(*)./T 8W)*G V-E =.)#(/()*/I '2- %-G(/%$'()* W$V-/ (' (%%-G$% +). .-'$(%-./ ') +&.*(/2

');$99) =.)5&9'/ ') $*E)*- &*5-. '2- $G- )+ AU $*5 =.)#(5-/ +). 5-+-*9- )+ 5&- 5(%(G-*9- +). .-'$(%-./

42) .-g&(.- =2)') (5-*'(+(9$'()* ') 9)*+(.W $ 9&/')W-.0/ $G-T 32- '%( $%/) .-/'.(9'/ '2- 5(/'.(;&'()* )+

$5#-.'(/(*G $*5 /-'/ W(*(W&W W$*5$').E /(G* .-g&(.-W-*'/ $' =)(*' )+ /$%-T

C*5(#(5&$% =.)#(*9-/ 2$#- (* =%$9- '2-(. )4* .-G&%$'()*/ =.)2(;('(*G '2- /$%- )+ ');$99) =.)5&9'/ ')

W(*)./T 32-/- W$E /'(=&%$'- /'.(9'-. .&%-/ +). '2- 5(/=%$E )+ ');$99) =.)5&9'/ ;-E)*5 '2- +-5-.$%

W(*(W&WI '2-E W$E .-g&(.- 5(++-.-*' /(G*:=)/'(*G .-g&(.-W-*'/ +.)W '2- +-5-.$% =.)#(/()*I $*5 W$E

.-/'.(9' '2- /$%- )+ ');$99) =.)5&9'/ ') E)&'2/ )%5-. '2$* AUT C*5--5I -^9-=' +). d&-;-9I >$*(');$I

8%;-.'$ $*5 F$/V$'92-4$*I .-'$(%-./ (* $%% )'2-. =.)#(*9-/ $.- .-/'.(9'-5 ;E %)9$% %$4 +.)W /-%%(*G ');$99)

=.)5&9'/ ') $*E)*- %-// '2$* AQ E-$./ )+ $G-T

8/ (* =.-#()&/ E-$./I 8%;-.'$I >$*(');$I d&-;-9 $*5 F$/V$'92-4$* 4-.- '2- %$/' .-W$(*(*G =.)#(*9-/42-.- ');$99) .-'$(%-./ $.- W)*(').-5 $G$(*/' '2- ;$/(9 +-5-.$% G&(5-%(*-/I -#-* '2)&G2 d&-;-9 =&' ('/

)4* ');$99) %-G(/%$'()* (* =%$9- /-#-.$% E-$./ $G) '2- W(*(W&W $G- ') =&.92$/- ');$99) (/ /'(%% AUT

M;/-.#-./ (* '2-/- +)&. =.)#(*9-/ 4-.- (*/'.&9'-5 ') W)*('). .-'$(%-. 9)W=%($*9- 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2 '2-

W(*(W&W $G- )+ =&.92$/- /'(=&%$'-5 (* '2- +-5-.$% !"#$%%" '%( T

C* >$.92 ?@@?I F$/V$'92-4$*0/ !"#$%%" )"*(+", '%( '))V -++-9' $*5 .-W)#-5 .-'$(% 5(/=%$E/ +.)W /').-/T

F(*9- '2-*I $%% =.)#(*9-/I (*9%&5(*G H-4+)&*5%$*5 (* ?@A@I 2$#- +)%%)4-5 /&(' 4('2 '2-(. )4* =.)#(*9($%

%-G(/%$'()* ;$**(*G '2- 5(/=%$E )+ ');$99) =.)5&9'/ (* -/'$;%(/2W-*'/ 42-.- W(*)./ 2$#- $99-// ') '2-

=.-W(/-/T 32- %$4 .-g&(.-/ #-*5)./ ') &/- 9&.'$(*/ $*5 9$;(*-'/ ') 2(5- 9(G$.-''-/I 9(G$./ $*5 92-4(*G

');$99) ;-2(*5 '2- 9)&*'-.I ). ;$* W(*)./ +.)W '2-(. /').-/T

32- ;$*/ )* $5#-.'(/(*G $*5 =.)W)'()* )+ ');$99) =.)5&9'/I $/ 4-%% $/ '2- ;$* )* '2- 5(/=%$E )+ ');$99)

=.)5&9'/ (* $%% =.)#(*9-/I 2$#- .-/&%'-5 (* '2- .-W)#$% )+ =)(*':)+:/$%- `\MFa $5#-.'(/(*G =.-#()&/%E

=-.W(''-5 &*5-. '2- !"#$%%" '%( T 8/ /&92I '2- 5-9(/()* 4$/ W$5- +). '2- ?@@Q /'&5E ') 5(/9)*'(*&- '2-

\MF =).'()* )+ '2(/ /'&5E $*5 ') .-=%$9- (' 4('2 );/-.#-5 9)W=%($*9- .-%$'-5 ') '2- 5(/=%$E )+ ');$99)

=.)5&9'/T

32(/ /'&5E 4$/ 5-/(G*-5 ') =-.W(' 5(.-9' 9)W=$.(/)*/ 4('2 '2- .-/&%'/ )+ ?@@Q $*5I $/ W&92 $/ =)//(;%-I

http://www.qp.gov.sk.ca/documents/english/Statutes/Statutes/t14-1.pdfhttp://www.qp.gov.sk.ca/documents/english/Statutes/Statutes/t14-1.pdfhttp://www.qp.gov.sk.ca/documents/english/Statutes/Statutes/t14-1.pdfhttp://www.qp.gov.sk.ca/documents/english/Statutes/Statutes/t14-1.pdf


7/59


\$G- S

4('2 /(W(%$. 5$'$ 9)%%-9'-5 (* E-$./ =.().T 8/ /&92I '2- 9&..-*' 5$'$ 9$* ;- 9)W=$.-5 4('2 /'$'(/'(9$%

#$%(5('E 4('2 =$/' .-/&%'/T [2-.- $5]&/'W-*'/ ') '2- /$W=%- 4-.- W$5- ). 42-.- %-G(/%$'(#- 92$*G-/

*-9-//('$'-5 $5]&/'W-*'/ ') 4).V .-g&(.-W-*'/I '2-/- 5(++-.-*9-/ $++-9'(*G '2- 2(/').(9$% '.-*5 $.-

*)'-5 $' '2- $==.)=.($'- =%$9-/ (* '2(/ 5)9&W-*'T

-.G

H&,GC I$J&1+34&,

P-$%'2 6$*$5$0/ +&*5$W-*'$% );]-9'(#- (* 9)WW(//()*(*G '2(/ .-/-$.92 (/ ') W$(*'$(* $*5 -*2$*9- '2-

2-$%'2 $*5 /$+-'E )+ E)&*G 6$*$5($*/T 32- 5$'$ 4- 2$#- 9)%%-9'-5 (/ /'.(9'%E +). (*+).W$'()* $*5

-#$%&$'()* =&.=)/-/I $*5 2$/ *)' ;--* 9)WW(//()*-5 +). =&.=)/-/ )+ -*+).9-W-*'T

32- +(*5(*G/ +.)W '2- 9&..-*' /'&5E ;&(%5 )* '2- .-/&%'/ )+ $**&$% .-'$(%-. ;-2$#()&. W-$/&.-W-*'/

+.)W AQQB ') ?@@QI $' '2- /$W- '(W- -/'$;%(/2(*G *-4 ;-*92W$.V/ $G$(*/' 42(92 +&'&.- =.)G.-// 9$* ;-

W-$/&.-5 $*5 9)W=$.-5T

32(/ E-$.0/ /'&5E 2$5 '2.-- /=-9(+(9 W-$/&.-W-*' );]-9'(#-/ (* W(*5R

AT 3) W)*('). 42-'2-. .-'$(%-./ 9)W=%(-5 4('2 '2- /$%-/:'):W(*)./ =.)#(/()*/ )+ '2- !"#$%%" '%(

$*5 .-%$'-5 =.)#(*9($% %-G(/%$'()*I /=-9(+(9$%%E W-$/&.(*G '2- =-.9-*'$G- 42) .-+&/-5 ') /-%% ')

'2- W(*)./ $''-W='(*G ') ;&E $*5 '2- =-.9-*'$G- 42) 92-9V-5 +). (5-*'(+(9$'()* $/ .-g&(.-5h

?T 3) W)*('). 42-'2-. ). *)' ');$99) =.)5&9'/ 4-.- )&' )+ #(-4 $/ .-g&(.-5 ;E =.)#(*9($% %$4/h

$*5

KT 3) 92-9V 42-'2-. -:9(G$.-''-/ 4-.- #(/(;%- $' '2- \MF $*5 42-'2-. '2-E 4-.- )++-.-5 ). W$5-

$#$(%$;%- $/ $* $%'-.*$'(#- ') W(*)./ $''-W='(*G ') =&.92$/- .-G&%$. 9(G$.-''-/T


8/59


\$G- O

-.@

K&8 =3*,

32- +)%%)4(*G $.- '2- V-E +(*5(*G/ +)%%)4(*G +.)W '2- ?@AJ .-/-$.92T

)'6L%3#*1& M3+C "'$#11' 5#%&,N+'NO3*'7, P&>3,%#+3'*

H$'()*$%%EI UJTUc )+ .-'$(%-./ .-+&/-5 ') /-%% 9(G$.-''-/ ') &*5-.$G- 6$*$5($*/ $''-W='(*G ') ;&E '2-WT

32(/ %-#-% )+ 9)W=%($*9- 4('2 %$4/ .-%$'-5 ') '2- /$%- )+ 9(G$.-''-/ (/ /'$'(/'(9$%%E &*92$*G-5 /(*9- '2-

%$/' /)&*5(*G (* ?@@Q `42-* UJTKc .-+&/-5 ') /-%%aT

8W)*G '2- KK .-G()*/ (*9%&5-5 (* '2- /'&5EI /&;/'$*'($% `(T-TI 5)&;%-:5(G('a (W=.)#-W-*'/ 4-.- +)&*5 (*

'2- +)%%)4(*G 9('(-/R

F2-.;.))V- KATK

62(9)&'(W(_i)*g&(-.- AQT?

>)*9')* AOTK

3).)*') AAT?

32- .-G()*/ $*5 9('(-/ 4('2 W)5-/' `(T-TI /(*G%-:5(G('a (W=.)#-W-*'/ (* 9)W=%($*9- /(*9- ?@@Q (*9%&5-5R

F$/V$'))* QTQ

[(**(=-G QTA

d&-;-9 6('E UTA

6$%G$.E OTU

,-G(*$ OTK

6('(-/ 42-.- /&;/'$*'($% 5-9%(*-/ (* 9)W=%($*9- 4-.- +)&*5 (*9%&5-5R

1$'2&./' :BOTB

>-5(9(*- P$' :K@TA

,-5 L--. :?OTO

>)*'.-$% :A?TU

X$*9)-. J :A?TB

X$*9)-. ? :AATQ

"5W)*')* :AATO

32- =-.9-*'$G- )+ .-'$(%-./ $/V(*G +). CL 4$/ U?TOcI /'$'(/'(9$%%E &*92$*G-5 +.)W '2- UKT?c W-$/&.-5 (*

?@@QT

8W)*G '2- .-'$(%-./ 42) 5(5 *)' 92-9V CLI +)&. (* +(#- Ù@TAca 4-.- 4(%%(*G ') /-%% 9(G$.-''-/ ') '2- W(*).

$''-W='(*G ') ;&E '2-WT 32(/ .-/&%' (/ /'$'(/'(9$%%E &*92$*G-5 +.)W ?@@Q 42-* UATSc )+ .-'$(%-./ 42) 5(5

*)' 92-9V $* CL 4-.- 4(%%(*G ') /-%%T 32(/ /2)4/ '2$' '2- +$(%&.- ') 92-9V $* CL .-W$(*/ /'.)*G%E$//)9($'-5 4('2 $ 4(%%(*G*-// ') /-%% ') W(*)./ $*5 (/ *)' ;-9$&/- .-'$(%-./ $.- W).- %(V-%E ') .-+&/- $ /$%-

4('2)&' 92-9V(*G CL )* '2- ;$/(/ )+ /)W-)*- 42) $==-$./ ')) E)&*GT

C* V--=(*G 4('2 '2- .-/&%'/ )+ =.-#()&/ E-$./ `?@@U -^9%&5-5aI '2- %(V-%(2))5 )+ .-+&/(*G ') /-%% 9(G$.-''-/

') W(*)./ (*9.-$/-/ $/ $G- 5-9.-$/-/T C* ?@AJI AB E-$. )%5/ `QJTKca 4-.- W&92 W).- %(V-%E ') ;- .-+&/-5

'2$* $.- -('2-. AS ). AO E-$. )%5/T P)4-#-.I 9)W=%($*9- %-#-%/ 42-* /-.#(*G AS E-$. )%5/ 4$/ $9'&$%%E

%)4-. ÒQTJca '2$* +). AO E-$. )%5/ Ù?TQcaT [2(%- '2(/ 5(++-.-*9- (/ /'$'(/'(9$%%E /(G*(+(9$*'I '2-


9/59


\$G- U

=-.9-*'$G- =)(*' 5(++-.-*9- (/ )*%E KTBcT C* ?@@QI 9)W=%($*9- 4$/ 2(G2-. $W)*G AS E-$. )%5/ '2$*

$W)*G AO E-$. )%5/T 32- 5(++-.-*9- (* .$'-/ )+ .-'$(%-. 9)W=%($*9- +). AB E-$. )%5/ 9)W=$.-5 ') AS $*5

AO E-$. )%5/ /&GG-/'/ '2$' '2-.- W$E ;- $ 5(++-.-*9- (* 2)4 .-'$(%-./ =-.9-(#- AB E-$. )%5/I #-./&/ AS

$*5 AO E-$. )%5/T

6)*/(/'-*' 4('2 '2- ?@@Q .-/&%'/I 9%-.V/ 42) $==-$.-5 ') ;- e)%5-. '2$* ?B ;&' *)' $ /-*(). 9('(b-*f

4-.- '2- W)/' %(V-%E ') .-+&/- ') /-%% ') $ W(*).T P)4-#-.I '2- $G- )+ '2- 9%-.V 2$5 %(''%- (W=$9' )* '2-

%(V-%(2))5 ') .-+&/-I 4('2 $ .$*G- )+ BTB =-.9-*'$G-:=)(*'/ ;-'4--* '2- %-$/' %(V-%E ') .-+&/- `/-*().

9('(b-*/I U@TKca $*5 '2- W)/' %(V-%E ') .-+&/- `)%5-. '2$* ?B ;&' *)' $ /-*(). 9('(b-*I UBTUcaT

8%/) 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2 ?@@QI .-'$(%-./ (* ?@AJ 4-.- /(G*(+(9$*'%E W).- %(V-%E ') .-+&/- '2- /$%- )+ ');$99) ')

+-W$%- W(*)./ ÙSTOca '2$* W$%- W(*)./ ÙKT@caT 8W)*G 9%-.V/I +-W$%-/ ÙBTQca 4-.- /(G*(+(9$*'%E W).-

%(V-%E '2$* W$%- ÙKTUca 9%-.V/ ') 9)W=%ET

32- 9)W=%($*9- .$'- ;-'4--* .-'$(%-./ %)9$'-5 *-$. $ /92))% $*5_). W$%% ÙBT?ca $*5 '2)/- %)9$'-5

-%/-42-.- ÙJTBca 4$/ /(W(%$.T 32(/ (/ $ 92$*G- +.)W ?@@QI 42-* .-'$(%-./ *-$. $ /92))% ). W$%% 4-.-

%-// 4(%%(*G ') /-%% ');$99) ') W(*)./ '2$* .-'$(%-./ -%/-42-.- ÙOT?c *-$. $ /92))% $*5_). W$%% #-./&/

UKTAc -%/-42-.-aT

6)W=%($*9- ;$/-5 )* '2- '(W- )+ #(/(' 4$/ /(G*(+(9$*'%E 2(G2-. 42-* W(*)./ $''-W='-5 ') ;&E ;-+).-

*))* ÙOTOca '2$* 42-* '2-E $''-W='-5 %$'-. (* '2- 5$EI 4('2 '2- %)4-/' 9)W=%($*9- %-#-%/ W-$/&.-5

5&.(*G $''-W='/ '2$' )99&..-5 $+'-. SR@@ =TWT ÒQTUcaT 32(/ .-%$'()*/2(= (/ /(W(%$. ') ?@@QI 42-* '2-

%)4-/' %-#-% )+ 9)W=%($*9- $%/) 2$==-*-5 $+'-. SR@@ =TWT ÒUTKc 9)W=$.-5 ') '2- *$'()*$% 9)W=%($*9-

.$'- )+ UJTKc '2$' E-$.aT

8/ (* ?@@QI 9)W=%($*9- .$'-/ 4-.- 2(G2-. 42-* $*)'2-. $5&%'I )'2-. '2$* '2- 9%-.VI 4$/ $%/) =.-/-*' (*

'2- /').-T 32(/ E-$.I 9)W=%($*9- 42-* $*)'2-. $5&%' 4$/ =.-/-*' 4$/ UOTJc *$'()*$%%E 9)W=$.-5 ')

U@TKc 42-* *) )'2-. $5&%' 4$/ =.-/-*'T C* ?@@QI '2- 5(++-.-*9- 4$/ /(W(%$. ÙBTUc 42-* )'2-. $5&%'/

4-.- =.-/-*' 9)W=$.-5 ') UATOc 42-* *) )'2-. $5&%'/ 4-.- =.-/-*'aT

8W)*G '2- +)&. 9%$//-/ )+ '.$5-I 9)W=%($*9- 4$/ 2(G2-/' $W)*G 92$(* 9)*#-*(-*9- /').-/ ÙQT@caI

+)%%)4-5 9%)/-%E ;E G.)9-.E /').-/ ÙUT@ca $*5 G$/ 9)*#-*(-*9- /').-/ ÙSTOcaT 8/ (* ?@@QI (*5-=-*5-*'

9)*#-*(-*9- /').-/ ÙAT@ca 4-.- %-$/' 9)W=%($*'T 32(/ E-$.I G.)9-.E /').-/ 42-.- ');$99) =.)5&9'/ $.-

/)%5 (* '2- /').- `+). -^$W=%-I $' '2- 9)&.'-/E 9)&*'-.a 4-.- 9)W=$.-5 ') G.)9-.E /').-/ 42-.- ');$99)

=.)5&9'/ $.- /)%5 (* $ /-=$.$'- -*9%)/-5 $.-$ '2$' 9$**)' ;- $99-//-5 +.)W 4('2(* '2- G.)9-.E /').-T H)

5(++-.-*9- ;-'4--* '2- '4) 4$/ );/-.#-5 `4('2 G.)9-.E /').-/ /-%%(*G (*/(5- '2- /').- $' UUT?c

9)W=%($*9-I 9)W=$.-5 ') UUT@c $W)*G G.)9-.E /').-/ 42-.- '2- =.)5&9'/ 4-.- /)%5 (* $ /-=$.$'-

%)9$'()* +.)W '2- /').- ('/-%+aT

"'$#11' ;3,L%#8 )'6L%3#*1&

32- 5-9(/()* 4$/ W$5- *)' ') 9)%%-9' (*+).W$'()* )* W$*5$').E $G-:$5#(/).E $*5_). ');$99) 2-$%'2:

4$.*(*G /(G*/ (* .-'$(% -/'$;%(/2W-*'/ 42-.- ');$99) =.)5&9'/ $.- /)%5T 32-.- (/ W&92 #$.($'()* +.)W

=.)#(*9- ') =.)#(*9- 4('2 .-/=-9' ') W$*5$').E 5(/=%$E )+ $G-:$5#(/).E /(G*/ +). '2- =&.92$/- )+

');$99) =.)5&9'/ $*5 '2- /=-9(+(-5 %)9$'()* )+ '2-/- /(G*/ '2$' '2- (*+).W$'()* 4$/ )+ %(W('-5 &/-T 1$*/

)* '2- 5(/=%$E )+ ');$99) =.)5&9'/ 2$#- *)4 ;--* =&' (*') -++-9' (* $%% =.)#(*9-/ $*5 /'$'- '2$' ');$99)


10/59


\$G- Q

=.)5&9'/ W&/' ;- V-=' )&' )+ #(-4T 32- +(*5(*G/ /2)4 '2$' 9)W=%($*9- 4('2 ');$99) 5(/=%$E %$4/ (/ 2(G2

*$'()*$%%EI 4('2 QBTSc .-=).'(*G '2$' ');$99) =.)5&9'/ 4-.- )&' )+ #(-4T 32(/ (/ 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2 '2- ?@@Q

.-/&%' `QJTUcaT

32- %)4-/' %-#-% )+ 9)W=%($*9- 4$/ +)&*5 (* H)#$ F9)'($I $' UBT@cI $/ $ .-/&%' )+ P$%(+$^ ÙATScaI 42-.-

'2- %)4-/' %-#-% )+ 9)W=%($*9- 4$/ );/-.#-5 $W)*G $%% K@ 9('(-/T 32- .-/&%'/ /2)4 '2$' 9)W=%($*9- .$'-/

$.- 2(G2-. 42-* '2- ');$99) =.)5&9'/ $.- 2(55-* ÙBTAca '2$* 42-* '2-E $.- *)' ÒUT@caT

I$,&74#+3'*, '* /N13>#7&++&,

32(/ E-$.I +). '2- +(./' '(W-I );/-.#$'()*/ $;)&' -:9(G$.-''-/ 4-.- .-9).5-5T 32- .-/&%'/ /2)4 '2$'

$W)*G '2- UJTUc 42) 4-.- .-+&/-5 '2- /$%- )+ 9(G$.-''-/I %-// '2$* Ac `@T@Kca 4-.- )++-.-5

-:9(G$.-''-/ $/ $* $%'-.*$'(#- ;E '2- 9%-.VT 8W)*G '2- AQTJc 42) .-g&-/'-5 ') =&.92$/- $* -:9(G$.-''-

42-* '2- /$%- )+ 9(G$.-''-/ 4$/ .-+&/-5I '2-E 4-.- $%/) .-+&/-5 '2- -:9(G$.-''- =&.92$/- Q@T?c )+ '2-

'(W-T

32- .$'- )+ .-+&/$% ') /-%% -:9(G$.-''-/ ') W(*)./ $+'-. '2- /$%- )+ 9(G$.-''-/ 2$5 ;--* .-+&/-5 4$/ 2(G2-/'

$W)*G AB E-$./ )%5/ `QBTSca +)%%)4-5 ;E AO E-$./ )%5/ ÙOTOca $*5 %$/'%EI AS E-$. )%5/ ÙBTScaT

32- .-+&/$% .$'- ') /-%% -:9(G$.-''-/ ') $ W(*). 4$/ %)4-/' $W)*G 9%-.V/ 42) 4-.- $;)&' '2- $G- )+ '2-

W(*). ÒBTAca $*5 /-*()./ ÙBTKcaT 6%-.V/ 42) 4-.- )%5-. '2$* '2- W(*). ;&' E)&*G-. '2$* ?B 4-.-

W)/' %(V-%E ') .-+&/- ') /-%% $* -:9(G$.-''- ') $ W(*). $+'-. .-+&/(*G ') /-%% 9(G$.-''-/ `QATScaI +)%%)4-5 ;E

9%-.V/ )%5-. '2$* ?B ;&' *)' 9)*/(5-.-5 /-*()./ `Q@TScaT

L&.(*G '2-(. #(/('I W(*)./ 4-.- $/V-5 ') %))V +). 5(/=%$E/ )+ -:9(G$.-''-/ $/ 4-%% $/ '.$5('()*$% ');$99)

=.)5&9'/T [2(%- '2-.- $.- %$4/ G&(5(*G '2- 5(/=%$E )+ '.$5('()*$% ');$99) =.)5&9'/I *) /&92 %$4/ E-' -^(/'

(* 6$*$5$ ') $55.-// '2- 5(/=%$E )+ -:9(G$.-''-/I 42(92 4-.- );/-.#-5 $;)&' $ '2(.5 )+ '2- '(W- `KKTJcaT

8W)*G '2)/- 42) );/-.#-5 -:9(G$.-''-/I '2-E 4-.- /$(5 ') ;- 4('2(* .-$92 )+ '2- W(*). $;)&' $ '2(.5 )+

'2- '(W- `KATScaT ,-G()*$%%EI '2- 9('(-/ 4('2 '2- 2(G2-/' =-.9-*'$G- )+ /').-/ 4('2 -:9(G$.-''- 5(/=%$E/4-.- (* 8'%$*'(9 6$*$5$I =$.'(9&%$.%E H-4 1.&*/4(9V `JBTSca $*5 H)#$ F9)'($ `JSTJcaT

-.?

O&+C'8

3-$W/ W$5- &= )+ '4) -#$%&$')./I )*- $ W(*). ÀBI AS ). AO E-$./ )+ $G-a $*5 '2- )'2-. $* $5&%' AQ

E-$./ )+ $G- ). )%5-.I 4-.- /-*' (*') $ .$*5)W%E /-%-9'-5I /'.$'(+(-5 /$W=%- )+ BIBKQ .-'$(%

-/'$;%(/2W-*'/ (* K@ 9('(-/ $*5 ')4*/ $9.)// 6$*$5$T \.-=$.$'()* +). '2(/ .-=).'0/ .-/-$.92 ;-G$* (*

i&*- ?@AJ 4('2 $ e&*(#-./-f /'&5E )+ '2- =)=&%$'()* )+ .-'$(%-./ '2$' g&$%(+(-5 $/ ');$99):/-%%(*G

-/'$;%(/2W-*'/ 4('2(* -$92 9('ET 32(/ .-/-$.92 /'-= (/ *-9-//$.E ') -*2$*9- '2- /$W=%(*G =%$*I ;.(*G(*G ('

(*') $%(G*W-*' 4('2 '2- 9&..-*' W$.V-' 9)*5('()*/T 32(/ (/ $* (W=).'$*' +$9'). ') 5-'-.W(*- '2-

4-(G2'(*G )+ '2- 5$'$T

F').-/ 4-.- #(/('-5 )#-. AO 4--V/I +.)W 8&G&/' AI ?@AJ ') L-9-W;-. KI ?@AJT 32- .-/&%'/ $W)*G

*jBIBKQ .-'$(%-./ =.)#(5- $ '2-).-'(9$% W$.G(* )+ -..). )+ ATK =-.9-*'$G- =)(*'/ `9$%9&%$'-5 $' $ QBc

9)*+(5-*9- (*'-.#$%aT 32(/ /$W=%- /(b- (/ 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2 ?@@Q `*jBIB@?aT 1$/-5 )* '2-/- /$W=%- /(b-/I

'2- '2.-/2)%5 +). /'$'(/'(9$% /(G*(+(9$*9- (/ k_: ? =)(*'/T

3-$W W-W;-./ -*'-.-5 /').-/ $' 5(++-.-*' '(W-/T 32-E G$#- *) (*5(9$'()* )+ ;-(*G ')G-'2-.T "$92


11/59


\$G- A@

9$..(-5 )&' /=-9(+(9$%%E $//(G*-5 '$/V/R

32- .-/=)*/(;(%('E )+ '2- '--* .-/-$.92-. 4$/ ') G$&G- '2- 4(%%(*G*-// )+ .-'$(%-./ ') /-%% 2(W_2-.

');$99) ;E $9'&$%%E $''-W='(*G ') ;&E $ ?@ ). ?B /(b- =$9V )+ ;.$*5:*$W- 9(G$.-''-/T 32-

'--*$G-./ 5(5 *)' 9$..E (5-*'(+(9$'()*T L&.(*G '2- $''-W='-5 '.$*/$9'()*I W(*)./ W$5- *)

W(/%-$5(*G /'$'-W-*'/ )'2-. '2$* (+ $/V-5 '2-(. $G-T C+ $/V-5 '2-(. $G-I '2-E 4-.- *)' '.&'2+&%I

;&' .$'2-. 9%$(W-5 ') ;- AU ). AQ E-$./ )%5I 5-=-*5(*G )* '2- W(*(W&W $G- .-g&(.-W-*'/ )+

'2$' =.)#(*9-T Z*5-. *) 9(.9&W/'$*9-/ 5(5 '2-E W$V- $ =&.92$/-T 32-E 4-.- G(#-* 9%-$.

(*/'.&9'()*/ $;)&' 2)4 ') 9$/&$%%E ;$9V )&' )+ $*E $''-W='-5 /$%-h

C* $ /W$%% /$W=%- )+ .$*5)W%E /-%-9'-5 .-'$(%-./I '--*/ $''-W='-5 ') =&.92$/- $* -:9(G$.-''- (+

'2-E 4-.- .-+&/-5 '2- /$%- )+ $ .-G&%$. =$9V )+ 9(G$.-''-/h

32- /-*(). W-W;-. )+ '2- .-/-$.92 '-$W 4$/ .-/=)*/(;%- +). '2- /$+- '.$*/=).'$'()* $*5

/&=-.#(/()* )+ '2- '--*I $*5 +). 9$..E(*G )&' $ #(/&$% (*/=-9'()* )+ '2- .-'$(%-.0/ =%$9- )+ ;&/(*-//

+). '2- =&.=)/- )+ );/-.#(*G '2- =.-/-*9- )+ -:9(G$.-''-/ $*5 '2- =.)=-. 9)*9-$%(*G )+ ');$99)

=.)5&9'/ ;-2(*5 9&.'$(*/ ). 9$;(*-'/I $99).5(*G ') -$92 =.)#(*9-0/ /=-9(+(9 ');$99) %$4T 32-

$5&%' $%/) 2-%=-5 4('2 '2- -/'(W$'- )+ '2- $G- )+ '2- 9%-.V $*5 %))V-5 +). /92))%/ $*5 W$%%/4('2(* 9%)/- =.)^(W('E ') '2- .-'$(%-.T

C* ).5-. ') W-$/&.- '2- (*+%&-*9- )+ $G- $*5 /-^ )+ '2- W(*). )* .-'$(%-./0 =.)=-*/('E ') 9)W=%E 4('2

/$%-/:'):W(*)./ %-G(/%$'()*I #(/('/ 4-.- ).G$*(b-5 /) $/ ') -*/&.- '2- +)%%)4(*G W(*(W&W *$'()*$%

.-g&(.-W-*'/R

'2$' /').- #(/('/ 4-.- 9)*5&9'-5 ;E $ W(^ )+ ;)'2 W$%- $*5 +-W$%- '--*/ (* .)&G2%E -g&$%

=.)=).'()*/h $*5

'2$' $==.)^(W$'-%E 2$%+ )+ $%% /').- #(/('/ 4-.- 9)W=%-'-5 ;E $ W(*). AO E-$./ )+ $G-I 4('2 '2-

.-/' )+ '2- /$W=%- ;-(*G 5(#(5-5 $;)&' -g&$%%E ;-'4--* AB $*5 AS E-$. )%5/T

32-/- 5(/'.(;&'()* '$.G-'/ $.- '2- /$W- $/ '2)/- -/'$;%(/2-5 +). /'&5(-/ 9)*5&9'-5 /(*9- AQQUT

32- '$;%- ;-%)4 5(/=%$E/ '2- *$'()*$% 9)W=%-'()* .$'-/ ;E $G- $*5 /-^ )+ '--* .-/-$.92-./ +). '2-

9&..-*' /'&5E $*5 =.-9-5(*G )*-/ /'$.'(*G 4('2 ?@@?T

"#$%& 3Q R#+3'*#% 5#6L%& ;3,L&7,3'* $8 S>& #*< 5&0 '( "&&* H&,GC&7

8/ W&92 $/ =)//(;%-I 4- '.(-5 ') .-/=-9' '2-/- '$.G-'/ 4('2(* (*5(#(5&$% 9('(-/ $*5 $9.)// .-'$(% 9%$//-/ )+

'.$5-T P)4-#-.I $/ (* =$/' E-$./I '2-.- 4-.- 9('(-/ $*5 /').- 'E=-/ '2(/ E-$. 42-.- '2- *&W;-. )+

/$W=%- /').-/ 4$/ ')) /W$%% ') $99)WW)5$'- $ +&%% W(^ )+ W$%-/ $*5 +-W$%-/ $9.)// -$92 $G- G.)&=T C*

'2-/- 9$/-/I '2- /$W=%- 4$/ $//(G*-5 ') )*- ). W).- '--*/ )+ =.-:5-'-.W(*-5 $G- $*5 /-^T C* ?@AJ

?@@? ?@@K ?@@J ?@@B ?@@S ?@@O ?@@U ?@@Q ?@AJ

F$W=%- F(b-

`l F').- X(/('/a BIBB@ BIJB? BIBAS BIBSA BIS@B BIBUU BIBQU BIB@? BIBKQ

>$%- JQTJc JQTSc JQTOc B@TAc B@T@c B@TKc B@TAc JQTQc B?TKc


12/59


\$G- AA

9)W=$.-5 ') ?@@Q '2- /'&5E =$.'(9(=$*'/ 4-.- /(G*(+(9$*'%E W).- %(V-%E ') ;- AO E-$./ )+ $G-I $*5 ') ;-

+-W$%- `$%'2)&G2 (* ;)'2 9$/-/ '2- 5(++-.-*9- (/ )*%E /%(G2'%E G.-$'-. '2$* '2- k_:? =-.9-*'$G- =)(*'

'2.-/2)%5aT

-.?.-

51'L&

,-'$(% /').-/ (* K@ &.;$* W$.V-'/ 4-.- #(/('-5T 32- %(/' )+ $%% 9('(-/ (*9%&5-/ $' %-$/' )*- 9('E +.)W -$92

=.)#(*9- (* 6$*$5$T

-.?.:

5#6L%&

8 '$.G-'-5 *$'()*$% /$W=%- )+ .-'$(%-./ 4$/ /-%-9'-5 +.)W ;-/':$#$(%$;%- &*(#-./- -/'(W$'-/ $9.)// -$92

)+ '2- 92)/-* 9('(-/T 8 9)W=%-'-%E *-4 /$W=%- 4$/ .$*5)W%E 92)/-* +). '2- %$'-/' /'&5E ;$/-5 )* *-4

5$'$ 9)%%-9'-5 (* '2- -*./0+10 2(345 9)W=%-'-5 (* i&*- $*5 i&%E ?@AJT

32- e&*(#-./-f (*9%&5-5 $%% '2- .-'$(% )&'%-'/ '2$' /-%% ');$99) =.)5&9'/ $*4 $%%)4 W(*)./ $99-// ') '2-

=.-W(/-/T 32- =&.=)/- )+ '2- -*./0+10 2(345 4$/ ') /&GG-/' 4$E/ )+ $..(#(*G $' $ *-4 +.$W- '2$'

9)*/(5-./ 9&..-*' %-G(/%$'()* $*5 9&..-*' =)=&%$'()* 5(/'.(;&'()* ;E 9%$// )+ '.$5-T

32- =)=&%$'()* ). e/$W=%(*G +.$W-f +.)W 42(92 '2- /$W=%- 4$/ 5.$4* 9)*/(/'-5 )+ '2- +)%%)4(*G

9%$//-/ )+ '.$5-I 42(92 $.- 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2 =.-#()&/ E-$./0 /$W=%(*G +.$W-R

62$(* 9)*#-*(-*9-

D$/ 9)*#-*(-*9- /').-/

D.)9-.E `(*/(5- $*5 '2)/- 4('2 /-=$.$'- -*'.$*9-/a

C*5-=-*5-*' 9)*#-*(-*9-

8/ W).- G.)9-.E /').-/ ;-9)W- /&=-.:/(b- ). ;(G:;)^ .-'$(%-./I '2-E $.- (*9%&5(*G =2$.W$9(-/ 4('2(*

'2-(. /').-/T 8/ %-G(/%$'()* 5(9'$'-/ (* $%% =.)#(*9-/ -^9-=' 1.('(/2 6)%&W;($I =2$.W$9(-/ $.- =.)2(;('-5

+.)W /-%%(*G ');$99) =.)5&9'/I '2&/I .-5&9(*G '2- =)=&%$'()* )+ G.)9-.E /').-/ (* '2- e&*(#-./-fT 3)

9)W=%E 4('2 '2(/ %$4I /)W- G.)9-.E /').-/ 4('2 =2$.W$9(-/ 2$#- 9.-$'-5 $* $%'-.*$'(#- /=$9- 4('2 $

/-=$.$'- -*'.$*9- +). /-%%(*G ');$99) =.)5&9'/T C* '2(/ E-$.0/ /'&5EI -#$%&$')./ 5)9&W-*'-5 42-'2-. $

G.)9-.E /').- /)%5 ');$99) (*/(5- '2- /').- `$' '2- 9)&.'-/E 9)&*'-.a ). +.)W $*)'2-. /=$9- 4('2 $

/-=$.$'- -*'.$*9-T D.)9-.E /').-/ '2$' (*9%&5-5 $ G$/ /'$'()* $*5 /)%5 9(G$.-''-/ '2-.- 4-.- 9%$//(+(-5 $/

G$/ 9)*#-*(-*9-T

6)W=$.-5 ') '2- =.-#()&/ /$W=%(*G +.$W-I '2- 5(/'.(;&'()* )+ =)'-*'($% .-'$(%-./ ') #(/(' /2(+'-5 /%(G2'%E

+.)W )*- 9%$// )+ '.$5- ') $*)'2-.T L-9.-$/-/ )99&..-5 (* 92$(* 9)*#-*(-*9-I G$/ 9)*#-*(-*9- $*5

G.)9-.EI $*5 $* (*9.-$/- )99&..-5 (* (*5-=-*5-*' 9)*#-*(-*9-T

)%#,, '( "7#


13/59


\$G- A?

;$**-.I 42-.- $==.)=.($'-I $*5 G-)G.$=2(9$%%E 5(/'.(;&'-5 $9.)// -$92 9('E ;$/-5 )* =)/'$% 9)5-/T 32-

+.$W- 4$/ '2-* 5(#(5-5 (*') /&;:/'.$'$ .-g&(.(*G $ W(*(W&W /$W=%- )+ )*-I $*5 $ /').- 4$/ .$*5)W%E

/-%-9'-5 +.)W -$92 /&;:/'.$'&WT

C* $%% 9('(-/ +). ?@AJI )&. /$W=%(*G );]-9'(#- 4$/ ') W$'92 /$W=%- 5(/'.(;&'()*/ ;E 9('E $/ 9%)/-%E $/

=)//(;%- ') '2)/- -/'$;%(/2-5 (* =.-#()&/ E-$./T F$W=%-/ 4-.- 5.$4* ') -*/&.- .-=.-/-*'$'()* )+ '2-

9-*/&/ W-'.)=)%('$* $.-$ `6>8a )+ '2- %$.G-/' 9('(-/T 3'* - H&>3'* : H&>3'* 9 H&>3'* G

X$*9)-. 1&.*$;E L-%'$ H).'2 X$*9)-.

,(92W)*5 6)g&('%$W F&..-E [-/' X$*9)-.

\).' >))5E Y$*G%-E\).' 6)g&('%$W H).'2 L-%'$

>$=%- ,(5G- [2('- ,)9V

[2)**)9V

\('' >-$5)4/

H-4 [-/'W(*/'-.

M*9- +(-%54).V ;-G$*I /)W- /-%-9'-5 /$W=%- /').-/ 4-.- +)&*5 ') 2$#- 9%)/-5 ). ') *) %)*G-. ;- /-%%(*G

');$99) =.)5&9'/T C* '2-/- 9$/-/I '2- /').-/ 4-.- .-=%$9-5 4('2 )'2-. .-'$(% -/'$;%(/2W-*'/ )+ '2- /$W-

'E=- %)9$'-5 (* 9%)/- =.)^(W('E ') '2- ).(G(*$% /').-`/aT [2-* $55('()*$% /').-/ )+ '2- /$W- 'E=- '2$' /)%5');$99) 9)&%5 *)' ;- +)&*5I '2- ).(G(*$% /$W=%- /').- 4$/ .-=%$9-5 ;E $ /').- +.)W $*)'2-. 9%$// )+

'.$5- (* '2- /$W- $.-$T

C* '2- -*5I 4- 9)W=%-'-5 #(/('/ ') BIBKQ /').-/I G-)G.$=2(9$%%E 5(/=-./-5 (* $ W$**-. 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2

)&. =.-:-/'$;%(/2-5 '$.G-'/T !$#,0 .. ;-%)4I /2)4/ '2- $9'&$% *&W;-. )+ 9)W=%-'-/ $9.)// '2- *$'()*T


14/59


\$G- AK

-.?.9

5#6L%& V&3>C+3*>

L&- ') '2- /'.$'(+(-5 .$*5)W /$W=%-I +)&. 9%$// '.$5-/ =-. .-G()*I .$4 %-#-% 5$'$ +.)W )&. /$W=%-

)&'%-'/ 2$#- ;--* 4-(G2'-5 /'$'(/'(9$%%E ') .-+%-9' '2- 5(/'.(;&'()* )+ ')'$% )&'%-'/I (* '2- &*(#-./- 4('2(*

'2- K@ 9)WW&*('(-/ $*5I /&;/-g&-*'%EI '2- =.)#(*9-/ $*5 $9.)// '2- 9)&*'.ET [-(G2'-5 5$'$ (/ $*

-/'(W$'- )+ 9)*5('()*/ 4- %(V-%E 4)&%5 2$#- +)&*5 2$5 4- #(/('-5 -#-.E .-'$(% )&'%-' (* '2- K@ 9('(-/(*/'-$5 )+ ]&/' '2- )&'%-'/ (* )&. /$W=%-T C* *) (*/'$*9- 2$/ $* $''-W=' ;--* W$5- ') =.)]-9' .-/&%'/

;-E)*5 '2- .-'$(% &*(#-./- (* '2- &.;$* $.-$/ /$W=%-5T

Z*%-// )'2-.4(/- W-*'()*-5I $%% '2- =-.9-*'$G-/ g&)'-5 (* '2(/ .-=).' $.- .-/&%'/ $+'-. 4-(G2'(*G/ 2$#-

;--* $==%(-5T

HM3"R ,-$5-./ $''-W='(*G ') .-=%(9$'- 4-(G2'-5 =-.9-*'$G- +(G&.-/ &/(*G .$4 /$W=%- /(b-/ 4(%% E(-%5

5(++-.-*' .-/&%'/T


15/59


\$G- AJ

"#$%& 33Q 5#6L%& ;3,L&7,3'* $8 )%#,, '( "7#3'* S%% 5+'7& )%#,,&, )C#3*

)'*4&*3&*1&

W#,

)'*4&*3&*1& W7'1&78

B*


16/59


\$G- AB

-.X

Y*


17/59


\$G- AS

:.

;&+#3%&< =3*,

:.- R#+3'*#% H&,2%+,

C* ?@AJI '2- =-.9-*'$G- )+ $%% )&'%-'/ #(/('-5 '2$' .-+&/-5 ') /-%% 9(G$.-''-/ ') W(*)./ `'2- 4-(G2'-5

.-'$(%-. *$'()*$% 9)W=%($*9-a 4$/ UJTUcI 9)W=$.-5 ') UJTKc (* ?@@QT

M#-.$%%I '2- '.-*5 +). .-'$(%-./ .-+&/(*G ') /-%% ') W(*)./ 2$/ /2)4* $ /'-$5E (*9.-$/- /(*9- AQQU 4('2

)*%E $ /(G*(+(9$*' 5.)= (* ?@@K ;E KTBc +.)W '2- =.-#()&/ E-$.T 32- '.-*5 ;-'4--* 4-(G2'-5 $*5

&*4-(G2'-5 .-/&%'/ (/ /(W(%$.I 42(92 (/ (*5(9$'(#- )+ $ 4-%%:/-%-9'-5 $*5 5(/=-./-5 /$W=%(*G )+ '2-

=-.9-(#-5 =)=&%$'()* )+ ');$99) .-'$(%-./T

)C#7+ -Q R#+3'*#% )'6L%3#*1& H&,2%+,Q H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' O3*'7,

H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' O3*'7,

Z:-. B* 8'27 'L3*3'*[ $#,&< '* +C& #1+3'*, #*C+&


18/59


\$G- AO

32- =-.9-*'$G- )+ .-'$(%-./ .-g&-/'(*G =.))+ )+ $G- `U?TOca 5(++-./ %(''%- +.)W '2- =-.9-*'$G- .-+&/(*G ')

/-%% ') W(*)./ `UJTUcaT 32- 4-(G2'-5 $#-.$G- )+ .-'$(%-./ $/V(*G +). CL 4$/ *)' /'$'(/'(9$%%E /(G*(+(9$*'%E

5(++-.-*'h +.)W UJTKc (* ?@@Q ') U?TOc (* ?@AJT

)C#7+ :Q R#+3'*#% )'6L%3#*1& H&,2%+,Q H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' O3*'7, 4,. S,E&< ('7 B;

H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' O3*'7, 4,. S,E&< ('7 B;

GX.Ua

?T.@a

?X.9a

?-.Ta

?U.Xa ?U.Aa

X-.:a

?X.Xa

A:.9aAT.Aa

A-.Xa

[email protected]

[email protected]

AG.Aa

GG.Xa

?T.-a

?U.?a

?G.Aa

XG.AaXX.-a

?U.Ua

??.Ua

AT.-aX?.Ga

XU.Ua

A9.:a

AG.-aA9.:a

A:.Xa

-UU@ -UU? -UUX -UUA -UUU :TTT :TT: :TT9 :TTG :TT@ :TT? :TTX :TTA :TTU :T-G

GTa

G@a

@Ta

@@a

?Ta

?@a

XTa

X@a

ATa

A@a

UTa

)'6L%3#*1&

S,E&< ('7 B;

Z:-. B* 8'27 'L3*3'*[ $#,&< '* +C& #1+3'*, #*


19/59


\$G- AU

[2-* %))V(*G W).- 9%)/-%E $' '2- .-%$'()*/2(= ;-'4--* .-+&/(*G ') /-%% ') W(*)./ $*5 $/V(*G +). =.))+ )+

$G-I '2- .-/&%'/ $.- 9)W=$.$;%- ') ?@@QT

8W)*G '2- .-'$(%-./ 42) 5(5 *)' 92-9V CLI +)&. (* +(#- Ù@TAca 4-.- 4(%%(*G ') /-%% 9(G$.-''-/ ') '2- W(*).

$''-W='(*G ') ;&E '2-WT 32(/ .-/&%' (/ /'$'(/'(9$%%E &*92$*G-5 +.)W ?@@Q 42-* UATSc )+ .-'$(%-./ 42) 5(5

*)' 92-9V $* CL 4-.- 4(%%(*G ') /-%%T 32(/ /2)4/ '2$' '2- +$(%&.- ') 92-9V $* CL .-W$(*/ /'.)*G%E

$//)9($'-5 4('2 $ 4(%%(*G*-// ') /-%% ') W(*)./ $*5 (/ *)' ;-9$&/- .-'$(%-./ $.- W).- %(V-%E ') .-+&/- $ /$%-

4('2)&' 92-9V(*G CL )* '2- ;$/(/ )+ /)W-)*- 42) $==-$./ ')) E)&*GT

"#$%& -Q 5#%&, #*< B; )'6L%3#*1& $8 b

:.-.-

R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 S>& '( O3*'7

,-+&/$% ') /-%% 9(G$.-''-/ 4$/ 2(G2-. $W)*G AB E-$. )%5/ `QJTKca '2$* $W)*G -('2-. AS ). AO E-$. )%5/T

P)4-#-.I .-+&/$% ') /-%% 4$/ /(G*(+(9$*'%E 2(G2-. $W)*G AO E-$. )%5/ Ù?TQca '2$* $W)*G AS E-$. )%5/

ÒQTJcaT

32- .-+&/$% .$'- +). AB E-$. )%5/ .-W$(*-5 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2 '2- ?@@Q .-/&%' `QJTKc (* ?@AJ 9)W=$.-5 ')

QBTAc (* ?@@QaT P)4-#-.I '2- .-+&/$% .$'- +). AS E-$. )%5/ 5-9.-$/-5 /(G*(+(9$*'%E ;E KTS =-.9-*'$G-

=)(*'/ ÒQTJc (* ?@AJ 9)W=$.-5 ') UKc (* ?@@Qa $*5 '2- .$'- +). AO E-$. )%5/ (*9.-$/-5 /(G*(+(9$*'%E ;E

KTJ =-.9-*'$G- =)(*'/ Ù?TQc (* ?@AJ 9)W=$.-5 ') OQTBc (* ?@@QaT

:TT: :TT9 :TTG :TT@ :TT? :TTX :TTA :TTU :T-G

c ,-'$( %-./ 8/V(*G +). CL SQTQc SSTQc U@TAc OSTJc OQTQc UKT?c UJTAc UKT?c U?TOc

c ,-'$ (%-./ H)' 8/ V(*G +). CL K@TAc KKTAc AQTQc ?KTSc ?@TAc ASTUc ABTQc ASTUc AJTKc

,-'$(%-./ [2) ,-+&/-5 ') F-%%

$/ c )+ 32)/- 8/V(*G +). CL

QST@c QOTAc QSTQc QOTQc QOT?c QOTQc QUT@c QOTOc QOTBc

,-'$(%-./ [2) [-.- [(%%(*G ') F-%%

$/ c )+ 32)/- 8/V(*G +). CL JT@c ?TQc KTAc ?TAc ?TUc ?TAc ?T@c ?TKc ATSc

,-'$(%-./ [(%%(*G ') F-%% $/ c )+

32)/- H)' 8/V(*G +). CL USTJc QATBc OSTBc OJTUc OQTUc OKTOc OUTAc UATSc U@TAc

,-'$(%-./ [2) ,-+&/-5 ') F-%% $/ c )+

32)/- H)' 8/V(*G +). CL AKTSc UTBc ?KTBc ?BT?c ?@T?c ?STKc ?ATQc AUTJc AQTQc


20/59


\$G- AQ

)C#7+ 9Q R#+3'*#% )'6L%3#*1& H&,2%+,Q H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' O3*'7Q D8 S>& '( O3*'7

32- /$W- '.-*5 2)%5/ '.&- 42-* (' 9)W-/ ') .-'$(%-./ $/V(*G +). $ =.))+ )+ $G-T C* ?@AJI $ G.-$'-.

=-.9-*'$G- )+ .-'$(%-./ $/V-5 +). CL 42-* '2- '--* 4$/ AB E-$./ )%5 9)W=$.-5 ') AS ). AO E-$./ )%5T

P)4-#-.I AO E-$. )%5/ 4-.- /(G*(+(9$*'%E W).- %(V-%E ') ;- $/V-5 +). CL `UATSca 9)W=$.-5 ') AS E-$. )%5/

`OOT@caT

[2-* W(*)./ 4-.- $/V-5 +). CL $*5 CL 4$/ *)' =.)#(5-5I %-// '2$* ?c )+ .-'$(%-./ 4-.- /'(%% 4(%%(*G ')

/-%% ');$99) =.)5&9'/ `(T-TI AB E-$. )%5/ o ATBcI AS E-$. )%5/ o ?T@cI $*5 AO E-$. )%5/ o ATBcaT

"#$%& :Q 5#%&, #*< B; )'6L%3#*1& $8 S>& '( O3*'7

H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' # O3*'7Q D8 S>& '( O3*'7

U-.Xa

AX.Xa

XA.Ua

A-.Xa

U9.:a

[email protected]

A-.Ua

[email protected]@.@a

A9.Ga

[email protected]

[email protected]

A9.Ta

XU.@a

AG.9a

UG.9a

XU.Ga

A:.Ua

AG.Aa

?Ta

?@a

XTa

X@a

ATa

A@a

UTa

U@a

-TTa

-@ 8 '%#7&++&, C#< 8'2 C#< +C& 1'77&1+ 1C#*>&]

D#,&Q S%% H&,L'*& '( O3*'7 -@ b I%


21/59


\$G- ?@

:.-.:

R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 S>& '( )%&7E

6)*/(/'-*' 4('2 '2- ?@@Q .-/&%'/I 9%-.V/ (* '2- e)%5-. '2$* ?B ;&' *)' $ /-*(). 9('(b-*f 9$'-G).E 4-.- '2-

W)/' %(V-%E ') .-+&/- ') /-%% ') $ W(*).T P)4-#-.I '2- $G- )+ '2- 9%-.V 2$5 %(''%- (W=$9' )* %(V-%(2))5 ')

.-+&/- 4('2 $ .$*G- )+ BTB =-.9-*'$G- =)(*'/ ;-'4--* '2- %-$/' %(V-%E ') .-+&/- `/-*(). 9('(b-*/I U@TKca

$*5 '2- W)/' %(V-%E ') .-+&/- `)%5-. '2$* ?B ;&' *)' $ /-*(). 9('(b-*I UBTUcaT 32-.- 4-.- *) /(G*(+(9$*'

5(++-.-*9-/ ;-'4--* ?@@Q $*5 ?@AJ (* 9)W=%($*9- .$'-/ )* '2- ;$/(/ )+ '2- $G- )+ '2- 9%-.VT

)C#7+ GQ R#+3'*#% )'6L%3#*1& H&,2%+,Q H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' # O3*'7Q D8 S>& '( )%&7E

"#$%& 9Q 5#%&, #*< B; )'6L%3#*1& $8 S>& '( )%&7E

X-.Ga

A-.Aa A9.?a

X:.-a?U.Ta

A@.@a AX.GaA9.9a

?A.Ua

AG.-a

AA.Ta

AG.@aA:.-a

AG.:[email protected]

XU.Ga

A9.@a A9.Ua

[email protected]

AT.9a

Ta

-Ta

:Ta

9Ta

GTa

@Ta

?Ta

XTa

ATa

UTa

-TTa

S$'2+ #>& '( 63*'7 I%& '( )%&7E

Z:-. B* 8'27 'L3*3'*[ $#,&< '* +C& #1+3'*, #*& '(

O3*'7 I%


22/59


\$G- ?A

:.-.9

R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 5&0 '( O3*'7

C* ?@AJI .-'$(%-./ 4-.- /(G*(+(9$*'%E W).- %(V-%E ') .-+&/- '2- /$%- )+ ');$99) ') +-W$%- W(*)./ ÙSTOca

'2$* ') W$%- W(*)./ ÙKT@caT

,-'$(%-./0 9)W=%($*9- %-#-%/ +). .-+&/(*G ') /-%% ');$99) .-W$(* 9)*/(/'-*' +). W$%- '--*/ $*5 /2)4 $*

(*9.-$/- +). +-W$%- '--*/T 32- .$*G- ;-'4--* '2- .-+&/$% .$'-/ +). +-W$%-/ $*5 W$%-/ (*9.-$/-5 +.)W

ATK =-.9-*'$G- =)(*'/ (* ?@@Q ') KTO =-.9-*'$G- =)(*'/ (* ?@AJT

32- $#-.$G- )+ '2-/- '4) 9)W=%($*9- %-#-%/ `W$%- $*5 +-W$%-a -g&$%/ '2- *$'()*$% W-$*I (*5(9$'(*G $

*-&'.$% 4-(G2'(*G -++-9' )* '2- )#-.$%% .-/&%'T 32(/ (/ %(V-%E 5&- ') '2- $==.)^(W$'-%E -g&$% *&W;-. )+

+-W$%- $*5 W$%- W(*)./ &/-5 $*5 '2- =.)=).'()*$'- 5(/'.(;&'()* )+ '2-W $9.)// '2- .-G()*/T

)C#7+ @Q R#+3'*#% )'6L%3#*1& H&,2%+,Q H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' # O3*'7Q D8 5&0 '( O3*'7

>$%- $*5 +-W$%- W(*)./ 4-.- .-+&/-5 ');$99) (* $%W)/' -#-.E (*/'$*9- 42-* '2-E 4-.- $/V-5 +). CL ;E

'2- .-'$(%-. `W$%- QUTBcI +-W$%- QUT?caT ,-'$(%-./ 42) 5(5 *)' $/V +). CL 4-.- W&92 W).- %(V-%E ') /-%% ')

'2- W$%-/ ÙQTKca '2$* ') '2- +-W$%-/ `SQTOcaT

[email protected]

A-.Aa

A@.@a

AX.@a

A9.Xa A9.Ta

X?.9a

A-.Xa

A?.:a

AG.9a [email protected]?.Xa

@Ta

@@a

?Ta

?@a

XTa

X@a

ATa

A@a

UTa

U@a

-TTa

:TT@ :TT? :TTX :TTA :TTU :T-G

O#%&

=&6#%&

H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' # O3*'7Q D8 5&0 '( O3*'7

Z:-. B* 8'27 'L3*3'*[ $#,&< '* +C& #1+3'*, #*


23/59


\$G- ??

"#$%& GQ 5#%&, #*< B; )'6L%3#*1& $8 5&0 '( O3*'7

:.-.G

R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 5&0 '( )%&7E

32(/ E-$.I 9)W=%($*9- .$'-/ 4-.- /(G*(+(9$*'%E 2(G2-. $W)*G +-W$%- `UBTQca '2$* $W)*G W$%- `UKTUca

9%-.V/T 32- 9)W=%($*9- .$'- +). ;)'2 +-W$%- $*5 W$%- 9%-.V/ (* ?@AJ 4$/ /'$'(/'(9$%%E &*92$*G-5 +.)W

?@@QT C* ?@AJI W$%- $*5 +-W$%- 9%-.V/ 4-.- -g&$%%E %(V-%E ') $/V +). CL $*5 9)W=$.-5 ') ?@@Q '2-.- 4$/

*) /'$'(/'(9$% 5(++-.-*9- +). -('2-. /-^ 4('2 .-/=-9' ') .-g&-/'(*G CL +.)W '2- W(*).T

"#$%& @Q 5#%&, #*< B; )'6L%3#*1& $8 5&0 '( )%&7E

5&0 '( O3*'7 O#%& =&6#%&

c ,-'$ ( %-./ ,-+&/ (*G ') F-% % UKT@c USTOc

c ,-'$ ( %-./ 8/V(*G +). CL U?TAc UKTKcc ,-'$ ( %-./ H)' 8/V(*G +). CL AOTOc ASTQc

c )+ ,-'$ ( %-./ [2) 8/V-5 +). CL $*5 [2) ,-+&/-5 ') F-% % QUTBc QUT?c

c )+ ,-'$ ( %-./ [2) L(5 H)' 8/V +). CL $*5 ,-+&/-5 ') F-% % A@TOc K@TKc

c )+ ,-'$ (% -./ [2) L( 5 H)' 8/ V +). CL $ *5 [-.- [( %% (*G ') F- %% UQTKc SQTOc

b O#%& =&6#%& O#%& =&6#%& O#%& =&6#%&

?@AJ UKTUc UBTQc U?TAc UKTKc QUT?c QUTSc

?@@Q UJTBc UJT?c UKTBc U?TUc QOTUc QOTBc

?@@U UKTUc UUT?c UATSc USTOc QOTQc QUTAc

?@@O UBTOc UST@c U?TSc UKTUc QOTOc QUTAc

?@@S U@TKc UKTKc OQT@c U@TOc QSTUc QOTUc

?@@B OOTBc UKTUc O?TJc U@TAc QOTKc QUTJc

?@@J U@TBc UKTUc OQT@c UATAc QST?c QOTBc

?@@K SBTOc SQTJc SJT?c SQT@c QOTOc QSTOc

?@@? SUTSc OKT?c SOTOc OATOc QJT?c QOTKc

a H&(2,&< +' 5&%% a VC' S,E&< ('7 B; a '( "C',& S,E3*> ('7 B;

VC' ;3< R'+ 5&%%


24/59


\$G- ?K

:.-.@

R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 F7'0363+8 +' 51C''%, #*


25/59


\$G- ?J

)C#7+ ?Q R#+3'*#% )'6L%3#*1& H&,2%+,Q H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' # O3*'7Q D8 "36& '( e3,3+

AX.Xa

A9.?a

AT.9a

XU.Aa

Ta :Ta GTa ?Ta ATa -TTa

D&('7& R''*

R''* +' 9 L.6.

9 +' ? L.6.

S(+&7 ? L.6.

H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% +' # O3*'7Q D8 "36& '( e3,3+

Z:-. B* 8'27 'L3*3'*[ $#,&< '* +C& #1+3'*, #*


26/59


\$G- ?B

:.-.X

R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 F7&,&*1& '( S +' 5&%% +' # O3*'7Q D8 F7&,&*1& '( S


27/59


\$G- ?S

:.-.A

R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 )%#,, '( "7#


28/59


\$G- ?O

:.:

H&,2%+, $8 )3+8\F7'43*1&\H&>3'*

32- W(*(W&W *$'()*$% /'$*5$.5 G)#-.*(*G '2- /$%- )+ ');$99) =.)5&9'/ ') E)&*G 6$*$5($*/ (/ -W;)5(-5

(* '2- +-5-.$% G)#-.*W-*'0/ !"#$%%" '%( T Z*5-. '2- '%( I (' (/ (%%-G$% +). 6$*$5($* .-'$(%-./ ') /-%% ');$99)

') W(*)./ &*5-. '2- $G- )+ AUT "(G2'--* (/ '2- W(*(W&W $G- )+ E)&*G 6$*$5($*/ ') 42)W .-'$(%-./ 9$*

/-%% ');$99) (* d&-;-9I >$*(');$I F$/V$'92-4$*I $*5 8%;-.'$T C* $%% )'2-. =.)#(*9-/I '2- %-G$% $G- (/ AQT

32- ?@AJ *$'()*$% 9)W=%($*9- %-#-% `4-(G2'-5 $#-.$G- $9.)// K@ 9('(-/a 4$/ UJTUcI *)' /(G*(+(9$*'%E

5(++-.-*' '2$* '2- UJTKc 9)W=%($*9- .$'- .-=).'-5 (* ?@@QT

C* d&-;-9I '2- %$.G-/' 9('EI >)*'.-$%I /2)4-5 $ /(G*(+(9$*' 5-9.-$/- +.)W ?@@QI 4('2 $ A?TU =-.9-*'$G-

=)(*' 5.)= `+.)W UQTUc (* ?@@Q ') OOT@c (* ?@AJaT

3).)*')I '2- %$.G-/' 9('E (* M*'$.()I /2)4-5 $* AAT? =-.9-*'$G- =)(*' (*9.-$/- '2(/ E-$. `+.)W OKTKc (*

?@@Q ') UJTBc (* ?@AJaT

,-G()*/_9('(-/ $9.)// 6$*$5$ (* ?@AJ 4('2 /&;/'$*'($% (*9.-$/-/ `5)&;%- 5(G('a (* 9)W=%($*9- /(*9- ?@@Q

(*9%&5-R

F2-.;.))V- KATK

62(9)&'(W(_i)*g&(-.- AQT?

>)*9')* AOTK

3).)*') AAT?

8*5 .-G()*/_9('(-/ 4('2 W$.G(*$% (*9.-$/-/ `G.-$'-. '2$* Bca /(*9- ?@@Q (*9%&5-5R

F$/V$'))* QTQ

[(**(=-G QTA

d&-;-9 6('E UTA

6$%G$.E OTU

,-G(*$ OTK

F(^'--* )+ '2- KK .-G()*/ /2)4-5 $ =-.9-*'$G- =)(*' (*9.-$/- `*)' $%% 4-.- /'$'(/'(9$%%E /(G*(+(9$*'a )#-.

?@@QI )+ 42(92 +)&. $.- 9)*/(5-.-5 %$.G-. .-G()*/I 2$#(*G $ G.-$'-. 4-(G2' )* '2- )#-.$%% /9).-R 3).)*')

ÀAT?aI [(**(=-G `QTAaI d&-;-9 6('E ÙTAa $*5 6$%G$.E ÒTUaT

,-G()*/ 4('2 /&;/'$*'($% 5-9.-$/-/ `5)&;%- 5(G('/a /(*9- ?@@Q (*9%&5-5R

1$'2&./' :BOTB

>-5(9(*- P$' :K@TA

,-5 L--. :?OTO

>)*'.-$% :A?TU

X$*9)-. J :A?TB

X$*9)-. ? :AATQ

"5W)*')* :AATO


29/59


\$G- ?U

,-G()*/_9('(-/ 4('2 W$.G(*$% 5-9.-$/-/ `G.-$'-. '2$* Bca /(*9- ?@@QR

X$*9)-. 6>8 :UTO

X$*9)-. A :OTK

32&*5-. 1$E :STB

62$.%)''-')4* `\"Ca :BTU

M+ '2- /-#-* .-G()*/_9('(-/ '2$' /2)4-5 5)&;%-:5(G(' 5-9.-$/-/I 1$'2&./'I >-5(9(*- P$'I ,-5 L--.

/2)4-5 '2- G.-$'-/' 5-9%(*-/ 9)W=$.-5 ') ?@@QT

32- )#-.$%% *$'()*$% =-.+).W$*9- (* ?@AJ .-W$(*-5 /'$'(/'(9$%%E &*92$*G-5 +.)W ?@@Q `$* (*9.-$/- )+

]&/' @TB =-.9-*'$G- =)(*'/aT

32- ')= '-* 9('(-/ (* ?@AJ $#-.$G-5 $ 9)W=%($*9- %-#-% )+ QOTUcI /'$'(/'(9$%%E &*92$*G-5 +.)W '2- QUT?c

.-=).'-5 (* ?@@QAT P)4-#-.I ?@ 9('(-/ /9).-5 ;-''-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% $#-.$G- '2(/ E-$.h '4) W).- '2$*

(* ?@@Q `AU 9('(-/aT M*9- $G$(*I W).- '2$* 2$%+ )+ '2- 9('(-/ /9).-5 $;)#- '2- 4-(G2'-5 *$'()*$% $#-.$G-T

32(/ (/ ;-9$&/- '2- .-%$'(#- /9).(*G )+ '2- (*5(#(5&$% .-G()*/ 2$/ %-// )+ $* -++-9' )* '2- *$'()*$% /9).-

'2$* 5)-/ '2- 4-(G2'-5 -++-9' )+ %$.G-. .-G()*/T

1 Final Report of Findings 2009: The Corporate Research Group Ltd.


30/59


\$G- ?Q

32- +)%%)4(*G %(/'/ '2- 9('(-/ '2$' /9).-5 UJTUc ). ;-''-. `G.-$'-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% $#-.$G-a (* ?@AJ $*5

$%/) %(/'/ '2-(. /9).-/ (* ?@@QR

"#$%& XQ f3>C )'6L%3#*1& H&>3'*, g :TTU 4,. :T-G

)3+8 :TTU :T-G

F3T iMPHmF ̀HYa QOTBc A@@T@c

F7LH"7 QSTKc A@@T@c

M338[8 QSTSc A@@T@c

[CHLFM, QUTOc QQT?c

>MH63MH U@TUc QUTAc

F3T 683P8,CH"F QQTSc QOTOc

1,8HLMH QBTAc QOTKc

FZL1Z,7 QJTBc QSTUc

68>\1"YY ,CX",_ 6MZ,3"H87 QUTSc QSTAc

6P8,YM33"3M[H ̀\"Ca QUTUc QKT@c

N"YM[H8 QJTAc QATQc

NCHDF3MH QKTJc Q@TSc

F8FN83MMH U@TJc Q@TKc

FP",1,MMN" BUTUc Q@TAc

X8H6MZX", A QOTJc Q@TAc

68YD8,7 UATSc UQTJc

,"DCH8 UATKc UUTSc

dZ"1"6 6C37 OQTBc UOTSc

X8H6MZX", J A@@T@c UOTBc

8 QJT@c UBTKc

H83CMH8Y UJTKc UJTUc


31/59


\$G- K@

F-#-* 9('(-/ /9).-5 '2- /$W- ). G.-$'-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% %-#-% '2(/ E-$. ;&' 4-.- *)' )* '2- %(/' (*

?@@Q?T 32-E $.-R >)*9')*I [(**(=-GI d&-;-9 6('EI F2-.;.))V-I 6$%G$.EI ,-G(*$I $*5 F$/V$'))*T 32-

%$.G-/' 9('E (* 6$*$5$ `3).)*')a (/ *)' $W)*G '2- ')= =-.+).W-./ `(T-TI $;)#- '2- *$'()*$% $#-.$G-aT

"#$%& AQ 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 H&>3'* ^-UUUN:T-G`

2 Final Report of Findings 2009.

H&>3'* -UUU :TTT :TT: :TT9 :TTG :TT@ :TT? :TTX :TTA :TTU :T-G

H83CMH8Y SQTOc SQTUc OAT?c SOTOc U?TKc U@TUc UATOc UBTQc UBTQc UJTKc UJTUc

F3T iMPHmF ̀ HYa B?TJc UOTUc QUT?c SOT?c O@TKc QUTJc UUTKc A@@T@c QOTJc QOTBc A@@T@c

6P8,YM33":3M[H ̀ \"Ca UST@c UST@c OBTSc OJTUc QATQc Q@TAc QJT@c QOTAc UJTBc QUTUc QKT@c

H"[ 1,ZHF[C6N J?TAc O?TOc UATSc OUTOc O?TSc UJTAc UJTSc USTUc U?TJc UBTJc UKTOc

183PZ,F3 S@TKc QBTJc BQTAc OUTOc QOT?c UJT?c OOTJc QATAc QATBc A@@T@c J?TBc

MH63MH H_8 H_8 QUTBc U?TUc USTUc SATAc SQTSc QUTAc SSTBc U@TUc QUTAc

F8CH3 iMPH JBTQc SOTAc OKTAc O@T?c JUTJc QQT@c QJTBc SBTKc Q@TQc U?TAc UKTUc

HMX8 F6M3C8 OKTKc O@TQc SKTUc UQTOc OQTKc UJTBc UKTOc UUTQc OBTOc U@TKc U@TOc

P8YC8HC3M18 UKTOc OUTQc SBT?c Q@TBc SJTBc O?T@c UQTOc OJTOc OBT@c OUTJc USTSc

1,8HLMH Q?TSc UJTBc UJTQc OKTQc SSTOc OOT?c USTAc UUTQc UATUc QBTAc QOTKc

[CHHC\"D UKTSc OUTUc SKTSc QATUc SJT?c OATSc Q@T@c OKTKc OJTKc OSTBc UBTSc

F8FN836P"[8H OUTQc UATJc QKTJc UATOc OSTBc QST@c UUTKc UQTJc QJTUc U@TUc UQTSc

,"DCH8 O@TOc U@TAc QBT?c OKT@c QKT@c Q?TQc UJTBc Q@TUc Q@TQc UATKc UUTScF8FN83MMH UBTQc U?TSc QATQc UQT@c SJTJc QQT@c QATBc UUT?c QUTAc U@TJc Q@TKc

8Y1",38 OKTSc SOTKc UOT@c UKT?c QATUc UJTOc Q@T?c UOTAc USTQc UKTKc OUT?c

68YD8,7 SKT?c SKT@c QBT@c U?TJc QATOc Q@TKc QSTQc UKTKc UBTQc UATSc UQTJc

"L>MH3MH UBTJc OATOc OQTSc UAT@c UQTSc OUTJc UKTQc UQTSc USTQc U@TJc SUTOc

>"LC6CH" P83 STSc QBTSc UQTQc QBTJc QUTJc UUTUc Q@TBc QSTQc QJT@c A@@T@c SQTQc

,"L L"", H_8 H_8 UATKc A@@T@c A@@T@c OUTKc UATAc Q?TOc UQTQc QJTSc SSTQc

1,C3CFP 6MYZ>1C8 BQTKc OBTKc SQTKc UJT?c QATBc QATUc UKTSc U?TJc Q?TBc QJTKc USTJc

N"YM[H8 QUT?c SKTUc A@@T@c QKTKc QBTOc QJTAc QSTJc OUTKc Q?TAc QJTAc QATQc

68>\1"YY ,C X",_6MZ,3"H87 QUT?c UBTAc QOTSc UQTUc UJTBc OUTBc QKTAc QKTBc QBTUc QUTSc QSTAc

X8H6MZX", 6>8 BUT?c OBTJc SBTBc UKT?c QATUc Q?TUc UATQc U?TAc Q?TKc QJT@c UBTKc

X8H6MZX", A H_8 H_8 S?T?c UATJc QKTKc UOTAc SQTKc OST@c Q@TAc QOTJc Q@TAc

X8H6MZX", ? H_8 H_8 SKTUc UQTKc QKTBc QST?c QST?c UJTJc QKTKc Q?TQc UAT@c

X8H6MZX", K H_8 H_8 OATKc UATAc QUTSc QJTKc UOTAc USTSc QJTUc UJTOc U?TKc

X8H6MZX", J H_8 H_8 O?TKc UATJc O@T?c QUT?c A@@T@c QSTQc QJTKc A@@T@c UOTBc

X$*9)-. AR X$*9)-.I ,(92W)*5

X$*9)-. ?R 1&.*$;EI 6)g&('%$WI \).' >))5EI \).' 6)g&('%$ WI >$=%- ,(5G-I [2)**)9VI \('' >-$5)4/I H- 4 [-/'W(*/ '-.

X$*9)-. KR L-%'$I F&..-EI Y$*G%-EI H).'2 L- %'$I [2( '- ,)9V

X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$*9)-.I [-/' X$*9)-.

pH)'-R 32- / '&5E E-$./ AQQB:?@@@ 4-.- 9)W=.(/-5 )+ ?B 9).- 9('(- / $ *5 ?@@?:?@@Q 4-.- 9)W=.(/-5 )+ K@ 9).- 9('(-/T 32- 9('(-/ $55-5 4-.- >)*9')*I H1I N(*G/')*I

MHI F'T 6$'2$.(*-/I MHI 32&*5-. 1$EI MHI ,-5 L--.I 81T 32-/- 92$*G-/ ( W=$9' '2- .-/&%'/ +). '2- =.)#(*9-/ )+ 8%; -.'$I M*'$.() $ *5 H-4 1.&*/4(9VT

H_8 j H)' 8==%(9$;%- I (T-TI .-G()* 4$/ *)' /&.#-E-5 +). ');$99) /$%-/ 9)W=%($ *9- 5&.(*G '2$' E-$.T


32/59


\$G- KA

"#$%& UQ 5#%&, #*< B; )'6L%3#*1& $8 H&>3'*

H&>3'*\)3+8 a Y*M3%%3*> +'

5&%% ^)'6L%3#*+`

a V3%%3*> +' 5&%%

^R'*N1'6L%3#*+` a VC' S,E&< ('7 B;

a VC' ;3\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc KTQc QBTBc @T@c

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc AJTOc UBT@c UUTKc

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc QTQc Q@T?c Q@T@c

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c AQT@c U?TSc Q?TQc

X8H6MZX", K U?TKc AOTOc U?TSc A@@T@c

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc A?TBc UAT@c SKT?c

X$*9)-. AR X$*9)-.I ,(92W)*5

X$*9)-. ?R 1&.*$;EI 6)g&('%$WI \).' >))5EI \).' 6)g&('%$WI >$=%- ,(5G-I [2)**)9VI \('' >-$5)4/I H-4 [-/'W(*/'-.

X$*9)-. KR L-% '$I F&..-EI Y$*G%- EI H).'2 L-%'$I [2( '- ,)9V

X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$ *9)-.I [-/' X$ *9)-.

H_8 (*5( 9$'-/ '2$' $%% /&.#-E-5 $/ V-5 +). CLT


33/59


\$G- K?

:.:.-

H&>3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 S>& '( O3*'7

32- .-/-$.92 5-/(G* .-g&(.-5 .-'$(% )&'%-' #(/('/ ') ;- 9)W=%-'-5 ;E '--*/ ABI AS $*5 AO E-$./ )%5T

H$'()*$%%EI $==.)^(W$'-%E 2$%+ `JST?ca )+ '2- /$W=%- 4$/ #(/('-5 ;E AO E-$. )%5/I $*5 '2- ;$%$*9- 4$/

#(/('-5 ;E AB $*5 AS E-$. )%5/ (* .)&G2%E -g&$% =.)=).'()*/ `?BT@c $*5 ?UT?cI .-/=-9'(#-%EaT

32- 6)W=%($*9- %-#-% 4$/ 2(G2-. +). '2- G.)&= )+ E)&*G-/' '--*/I QJTJc $W)*G '2)/- AB E-$./ )%5I '2$*

$W)*G -('2-. AS ). AO E-$. )%5 W(*)./T P)4-#-.I '2- 9)W=%($*9- %-#-% +). AS E-$. )%5/ ÒQTBca 4$/

/(G*(+(9$*'%E %)4-. '2$* +). AO E-$. )%5/ Ù?TQcaT C* ?@@QI $ /(W(%$. .-%$'()*/2(= -^(/'-5 ;-'4--* '2- $G-

G.)&=/h '2-.- 4$/ $%/) $ /&;/'$*'($% 5(++-.-*9- ;-'4--* '2- 9)W=%($*9- .$'- +). AB E-$. )%5/ `QBTAca

$*5 '2- )%5-. '--*$G-. G.)&=/T C* 9)*'.$/'I '2- 9)W=%($*9- %-#-% +). AS E-$. )%5/ ÙKT@ca 4$/

/(G*(+(9$*'%E 2(G2-. '2$* +). AO E-$. )%5/ ÒQTBca (* ?@@QT

1-%)4 $.- .-G()*$% 2(G2%(G2'/ )+ '2- +(*5(*G/ ;$/-5 )* '2- $G- )+ '2- W(*). $''-W='(*G ') ;&E 9(G$.-''-/T

AB E-$. )%5/R $W)*G '2- .-G()*/ 42-.- )&'%-'/ 4-.- #(/('-5 ;E AB E-$. )%5/I 9)W=%($*9- 4$/

/&;/'$*'($%%E %)4-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% $#-.$G- +). '2(/ $G- G.)&= (* F2-.;.))V- ÙOTQcaI 32&*5-.

1$E ÙJTAca $*5 "5W)*')* ÒQTOcaT

AS E-$. )%5/R $W)*G '2- .-G()*/ 42-.- )&'%-'/ 4-.- #(/('-5 ;E AS E-$. )%5/I 1$'2&./' `J?TBca

$*5 >)*'.-$% `BJT?ca 4-.- '2- %-$/' 9)W=%($*' .-%$'(#- ') '2- OQTBc 9)W=%($*9- .$'- $W)*G

#(/('/ ;E AS E-$. )%5 W(*)./ *$'()*4(5-T P$%(+$^ `SOT?ca $*5 >-5(9(*- P$' Ò@T@ca 4$/ $%/)

/(G*(+(9$*'%E %)4-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% $#-.$G- +). '2(/ $G- G.)&=T

AO E-$. )%5/R $W)*G '2- .-G()*/ 42-.- #(/('/ 4-.- W$5- ;E AO E-$. )%5/I '2- .-/&%'/ 4-.-

/(G*(+(9$*'%E %)4-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% $#-.$G- +). '2(/ $G- G.)&= (* 62(9)&'(W(_i)*g&(-.- `SOTScaI

3).)*') ÒOTScaI [(**(=-G `SQTScaI "5W)*')* `B?TScaI >-5(9(*- P$' `SSTOcaI ,-5 L--.

`SSTQcaI X$*9)-. ? ÒQTAca $*5 X$*9)-. K ÒBT?caT

[2(%- -++).'/ 4-.- W$5- ') -*/&.- $ .-G()*$%%E ;$%$*9-5 W(^ )+ W(*)./ ;E $G-I *)' $%% 9('(-/ (* '2-

.-/-$.92 (*9%&5-5 W(*)./ 4('2(* -$92 $G- G.)&=T C*/'$*9-/ 42-.- *) W(*)./ )+ $ =$.'(9&%$. $G- #(/('-5%)9$'()*/ (* $ G(#-* 9('E $.- (*5(9$'-5 (* '2- '$;%- ;-%)4 ;E eH_8Tf


34/59


\$G- KK

"#$%& -TQ 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 S>& '( O3*'7

H&(2,&< +' 5&%% N

S%% S>&,

H&(2,&< +' 5&%% +'

-@ 8.'.

H&(2,&< +' ,&%% +'

-? 8.'.

H&(2,&< +' ,&%% +'

-X 8.'.

RS"BIRSP UJTUc QJTJc OQTBc U?TQc

F3T iMPHmF ̀HYa A@@T@c A@@T@c H_8 A@@T@c

6P8,YM33"3M[H ̀\"Ca QKT@c A@@T@c H_8 UBTOc

R/V DHYR5VB)K UKTSc QSTJc O@TUc Q@TQc

183PZ,F3 J?TBc H_8 J?TBc H_8

MH63MH QUTAc QSTJc H_8 A@@T@c

F8CH3 iMPH UKTUc H_8 U@T@c UUT@c

RIeS 5)I"BS U@TOc A@@T@c SOT?c OOT@c

P8YC\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc H_8 H_8 QSTAc

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc A@@T@c Q@TKc U?TQc

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc H_8 UQTOc UQTQc

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c A@@T@c H_8 OQTAc

X8H6MZX", K U?TKc H_8 A@@T@c OBT?c

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc H_8 OUT@c QKT?c

H&>3'*\)3+8

)'6L%3#*1& $8 S>& '( O3*'7

X$*9)-. AR X$*9)-.I ,(92W)*5

X$*9)-. ?R 1&.*$;EI 6)g&('%$ WI \).' >))5EI \).' 6)g&('%$ WI >$=%- ,(5G-I [2)**)9VI \('' >-$5)4/I H-4

[-/'W(*/'-.

X$*9)-. KR L-%'$I F&..-EI Y$*G%-EI H).'2 L-%'$I [2('- ,)9V

X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$*9)-.I [-/' X$*9)-.

H_8 j >(*)./ )+ '2$' $G- 4-.- *)' &/-5 (* '2$ ' 9('E ). .-G()*T


35/59


\$G- KJ

:.:.:

H&>3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 S>& '( )%&7E

32- +)%%)4(*G $.- 2(G2%(G2'/ +). .-'$(%-. 9)W=%($*9- ;E .-G()*I ;$/-5 )* '2- $==.)^(W$'- $G- )+ '2- 9%-.V

;-2(*5 '2- ');$99) 9)&*'-.R

F(W(%$. $G- ') W(*).R 32- 9)W=%($*9- .$'- 42-* '2- 9%-.V 4$/ $==.)^(W$'-%E '2- /$W- $G-

$/ '2- W(*). '.E(*G ') ;&E $ =$9V$G- )+ 9(G$.-''-/ 4$/ U?TQcI 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2 ?@@Q

Ù?TAcaT32- .-/&%'/ 4-.- %)4-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% $#-.$G- +). '2(/ G.)&= (* +(#- .-G()*/T

6)W=%($*9- 42-* '2- 9%-.V 4$/ $;)&' '2- /$W- $G- $/ '2- W(*). 4$/ %)4-/' (*

62(9)&'(W(_i)*g&(-.- `J@T@caI 3).)*') Ò@T@caI -5(9(*- P$' `BOTAca $*5 "5W)*')*

`BUT?caT

M%5-. '2$* ?B ;&' *)' $ /-*().R $/ (* ?@@QI '2(/ $G- G.)&= .$*V-5 2(G2-/' (* 9)W=%($*9- $'UBTUc ÙBTJc (* ?@@QaT 32- .-/&%'/ 4-.- %)4-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% $#-.$G- +). '2(/ G.)&= (*

A@ .-G()*/T 32- %)4-/' .-/&%'/ $W)*G '2(/ 9)2).' 4-.- +)&*5 (* 1$'2&./' `BKTUcaI P$%(+$^

`SBT?caI >)*'.-$% ÒOT?caI "5W)*')* ÒJTBca $*5 >-5(9(*- P$' Ò@caT

F-*()./R 2$5 '2- %)4-/' )#-.$%% *$'()*$% 9)W=%($*9- $' U@T?cI 9)W=$.-5 ') OQTJc (* ?@@QT

32- .-/&%'/ 4-.- %)4-. '2$* '2- *$'()*$% +). '2(/ G.)&= $#-.$G- (* *(*- .-G()*/T 32- %)4-/'

.-/&%'/ $W)*G 9%-.V/ 42) 4-.- /-*()./ 4$/ +)&*5 (* P$%(+$^ `B@caI F2-.;.))V- `SSTOcaI

[(**(=-G `B@caI $*5 X$*9)-. ? `BOTAcaT


36/59


\$G- KB

"#$%& --Q 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 S>& '( )%&7E

H&>3'*\)3+8 )'6L%3#*+ N "'+#% )'6L%3#*+ N )%&7E

#$'2+ 63*'7h, #>&

)'6L%3#*+ N )%&7E

'%\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc A@@T@c Q@TQc QSTSc A@@T@c

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc B@T@c UBTBc UST?c OOTKc

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc H_8 UOT@c QAT@c U@T@c

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c A@@T@c U@TSc U?T@c BOTAc

X8H6MZX", K U?TKc H_8 QATBc OQTSc OBT@c

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc H_8 OUTKc UUTQc A@@T@c

X$*9)-. AR X$*9)-.I ,(92W)*5

X$*9)-. ?R 1&.*$;EI 6)g&('%$WI \).' >))5EI \).' 6)g&('%$WI >$=%- ,(5G-I [2)**)9VI \('' >-$5)4/I H-4 [-/'W(*/'-.


X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$*9)-.I [-/ ' X$*9)-.

H_8 j 32- '--* -#$%&$')./ 4-.- *)' /-.#-5 ;E 9%-.V/ )+ '2$' $G- G.)&=T


37/59


\$G- KS

:.:.9

H&>3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 5&0 '( O3*'7

>$%- $*5 +-W$%- W(*)./ -$92 4-*' (*') .-'$(% )&'%-'/ (* ?A )+ '2- K@ 9('(-/ #(/('-5T 8==.)^(W$'-%E $*

-g&$% *&W;-. )+ W$%-/ $*5 +-W$%-/ 4-.- &/-5 (* '2- /'&5ET H$'()*$%%EI 9)W=%($*9- 4$/ 2(G2-. 42-* '2-

W(*). $''-W='(*G ') ;&E 9(G$.-''-/ 4$/ +-W$%- ÙSTOca '2$* W$%- ÙKT@caT 32(/ .-=.-/-*'/ $ /'$'(/'(9$%%E

/(G*(+(9$*' 5(++-.-*9- $*5 (' (/ /(W(%$. ') '2- .-/&%'/ (* ?@@Q `42-* 9)W=%($*9- $W)*G +-W$%-/ 4$/ UBT@c9)W=$.-5 ') UKTOc $W)*G W$%-/aT

[2(%- '2- *$'()*$% .-/&%' (/ 9)*/(/'-*' 4('2 ?@@QI '2-.- 4$/ /(G*(+(9$*' #$.($'()* ;E .-G()*T )*'.-$% ÀOTKca

$*5 X$*9)-. 6>8 À?TAca 42-.- 9)W=%($*9- 4$/ 2(G2-. $W)*G +-W$%-/ '2$* W$%-/T


38/59


\$G- KO

"#$%& -:Q 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 5&0 '( O3*'7

)'6L%3#*1& N "'+#% )'6L%3#*1& $8

O#%& O3*'7

)'6L%3#*1& $8

=&6#%& O3*'7

RS"BIRSP UJTUc UKT@c USTOc

F3T iMPHmF ̀HYa A@@T@c A@@T@c A@@T@c

6P8,YM33"3M[H ̀\"Ca QKT@c A@@T@c UBTOc

R/V DHYR5VB)K UKTSc Q?TAc OUT?c

183PZ,F3 J?TBc H_8 J@TQc

MH63MH QUTAc A@@T@c QSTJc

F8CH3 iMPH UKTUc UOTBc U@TUc

RIeS 5)I"BS U@TOc OUTKc UKTOc

P8YC\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc QOTOc H_8

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc OUTAc Q@T?c

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc UQT@c Q@TQc

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c OKTAc QJTOcX8H6MZX", K U?TKc OATJc UBTOc

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc OUT@c QKT?c

H&>3'*\)3+8

)'6L%3#*1& $8 5&0 '( O3*'7

H_8 j >(*)./ )+ '2$' G-*5- . 4-.- *)' &/-5 ( * '2$' 9('E ). .-G( )*T

X$*9)-. AR X$*9)-.I ,(92W)*5

X$*9)-. ?R 1&.*$;EI 6)g&('%$ WI \).' >))5EI \).' 6)g&('%$ WI >$=%- ,(5G- I [2)**)9VI \('' >-$ 5)4/I

H-4 [-/'W(*/'-.

X$*9)-. KR L-% '$I F&..-EI Y$*G%- EI H).'2 L-%'$I [2( '- ,)9V

X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$*9)-.I [-/ ' X$*9)-.


39/59


\$G- KU

:.:.G

H&>3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 5&0 '( )%&7E


40/59


\$G- KQ

"#$%& -9Q 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 5&0 '( )%&7E

)'6L%3#*1& N "'+#% )'6L%3#*1& $8

O#%& )%&7E

)'6L%3#*1& $8

=&6#%& )%&7E

RS"BIRSP UJTUc UKTUc UBTQc

F3T iMPHmF ̀HYa A@@T@c A@@T@c A@@T@c

6P8,YM33"3M[H ̀\"Ca QKT@c QKTUc QSTJc

R/V DHYR5VB)K UKTSc OUTSc UUTKc

183PZ,F3 J?TBc JJTJc KUTBc

MH63MH QUTAc QBTUc A@@T@c

F8CH3 iMPH UKTUc U@T@c UJT@c

RIeS 5)I"BS U@TOc OQTUc U@TQc

P8YC\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc A@@T@c QKTUc

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc UKTOc UOT?c

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc UQTUc UQTOc

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c OUTKc UKTKc

X8H6MZX", K U?TKc OOTSc UBTQc

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc UJTSc QATOc

H&>3'*\)3+8

)'6L%3#*1& $8 5&0 '( )%&7E

X$*9)-. AR X$*9)-.I ,(92W)*5

X$*9)-. ?R 1&.*$;EI 6)g&('%$WI \).' >))5EI \).' 6)g&('%$WI >$=%- ,(5G-I [2)**)9VI \('' >-$5)4/I

H-4 [-/'W(*/'-.


X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$*9)-.I [-/' X$*9)-.


41/59


\$G- J@

:.:.@

H&>3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 F7'0363+8 +' 51C''%, #*


42/59


\$G- JA

"#$%& -GQ 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 F7'0363+8 +' 51C''%, #*C_iMHdZC"," U@TSc USTJc SQTSc

>MH3,"8Y OOT@c O@TOc U@TKc

dZ"1"6 6C37 UOTSc UUT?c UOT@c

FP",1,MMN" Q@TAc UOTUc QST@c

IR"SHBI UUTSc Q@TAc UOTQc

NCHDF3MH Q@TSc UUTQc Q@T@c

M338[8 A@@T@c A@@T@c A@@T@c

F3T 683P8,CH"F QOTOc QSTKc QUT@c

FZL1Z,7 QSTUc A@@T@c QJTAc

3PZHL", 187 UJTAc SSTOc UUTBc

3M,MH3M UJTBc UOTOc UKTAc

[CHLFM, QQT?c QOTQc A@@T@c

OSRB"IDS USTSc QKTUc UJT?c

1,8HLMH QOTKc A@@T@c A@@T@c

[CHHC\"D UBTSc QBTSc U?TSc

5S5KS")f/VSR UQTSc QSTKc USTUc

,"DCH8 UUTSc Q?TSc UJTKc

F8FN83MMH Q@TKc A@@T@c USTAc

SPD/H"S OUT?c U?TSc OJTUc

68YD8,7 UQTJc USTKc Q?TUc

"L>MH3MH SUTOc OQTKc SKTJc

>"LC6CH" P83 SQTQc SQT?c SSTOc

,"L L"", SSTQc S?TBc SUT@c

DHB"B5f )IPYODBS USTJc QKT?c U?TJc

N"YM[H8 QATQc Q@TQc A@@T@c

68>\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc A@@T@c QBTAc

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc QKTJc U@TQc

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc Q?TSc UQTAc

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c QBTBc OATScX8H6MZX", K U?TKc Q@TSc OUTAc

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc A@@T@c U?TSc

H&>3'*\)3+8

)'6L%3#*1& $8 F7'0363 +8 +' 51C''%, '7 O#%%,

X$*9)-. AR X$* 9)-.I ,(92W)* 5

X$*9)-. ?R 1&.*$;EI 6)g&('%$WI \).' >))5EI \).' 6)g&('%$WI >$=%- ,(5G-I [2)**)9VI \('' >-$5)4/I H-4

[-/'W(*/'-.

X$*9)-. KR L-%'$I F&..-EI Y$*G% -EI H).'2 L- %'$I [2( '- ,)9V

X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$* 9)-.I [-/' X$*9)-.


43/59


\$G- J?

:.:.?

H&>3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 "36& '( e3,3+

6)W=%($*9- ;$/-5 )* '2- '(W- )+ #(/(' 4$/ /(G*(+(9$*'%E 2(G2-. 42-* W(*)./ $''-W='-5 ') ;&E ;-+).-

*))* `Q@TBca '2$* 42-* '2-E $''-W='-5 %$'-. (* '2- 5$EI 4('2 '2- %)4-/' 9)W=%($*9- %-#-%/ W-$/&.-5

5&.(*G $''-W='/ '2$' )99&..-5 $+'-. SR@@ =TWT `UATQcaT 32(/ .-%$'()*/2(= (/ /(W(%$. ') ?@@QI 42-* '2-

%)4-/' %-#-% )+ 9)W=%($*9- $%/) 2$==-*-5 $+'-. SR@@ =TWT `OUTKc 9)W=$.-5 ') '2- $#-.$G- *$'()*$%

9)W=%($*9- .$'- )+ UJTKc '2$' E-$.aT 32- %)4-/' %-#-%/ )+ 9)W=%($*9- $+'-. SR@@ =TWT 4-.- +)&*5 (*

1$'2&./' `B@caI P$%(+$^ `SKTScaI "5W)*')* `SScaI >-5(9(*- P$' `B@caI ,-5 L--. `BKTUca $*5 X$*9)-.

6>8 `SQTJcaT


44/59


\$G- JK

"#$%& -@Q 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 "36& '( e3,3+

)'6L%3#*1& N

"'+#%

)'6L%3#*1& N

D&('7& R''*

)'6L%3#*1& N

D&+M&&* -:N9L6

)'6L%3#*1& N

D&+M&&* 9N?L6

)'6L%3#*1& N

S(+&7 ?L6

RS"BIRSP UJTUc Q@TBc USTOc U?TBc UATQc

F3T iMPHmF ̀HYa A@@T@c A@@T@c A@@T@c A@@T@c A@@T@c

6P8,YM33"3M[H ̀\"Ca QKT@c A@@T@c A@@T@c UQTBc A@@T@c

R/V DHYR5VB)K UKTSc O?TOc UKT@c UKTSc UJTBc

183PZ,F3 J?TBc S@T@c KOTBc J?TQc B@T@c

MH63MH QUTAc A@@T@c QOT@c A@@T@c A@@T@c

F8CH3 iMPH UKTUc A@@T@c OBT@c U?TJc UQTBc

RIeS 5)I"BS U@TOc A@@T@c QKTJc SJTSc SKTSc

P8YC\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc A@@T@c QSTKc H_8 H_8

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc UOTQc UQT?c UOT@c SQTJc

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc QATQc QBTKc UOTQc SJTOc

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c QJTOc UJTUc U?TSc SKTKcX8H6MZX", K U?TKc BJTBc U?TSc UOTSc OKTKc

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc H_8 USTUc Q@TSc UOTBc

H&>3'*\)3+8

)'6L%3#*1& $8 "36& '( e3,3+

X$*9)-. AR X$*9)-.I ,(92W)*5

X$*9)-. ?R 1&.*$;EI 6)g&('% $WI \).' >))5EI \).' 6)g&('% $WI >$=%- ,(5G-I [2)**) 9VI \('' >-$5)4/ I H-4 [-/ 'W(*/'-.

X$*9)-. KR L-%'$I F&..-EI Y$*G% -EI H).'2 L-% '$I [2('- ,)9V

X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$*9)-.I [-/' X$*9)-.

H_8 j F').-/ (* '2$' 9('E ). .-G()* 4-.- *)' #(/('-5 5&.(*G '2$' '(W- )+ 5$ET


45/59


\$G- JJ

:.:.X

H&>3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 F7&,&*1& '7 R'+ '( S


46/59


\$G- JB

"#$%& -?Q 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 F7&,&*1& '( I+C&7 SC_iMHdZC"," U@TSc OSTAc Q@TBc

>MH3,"8Y OOT@c U@T?c O?TKc

dZ"1"6 6C37 UOTSc UOTBc UOTOc

FP",1,MMN" Q@TAc Q@TOc UJTSc

IR"SHBI UUTSc QAT?c UJTBc

NCHDF3MH Q@TSc USTOc A@@T@c

M338[8 A@@T@c A@@T@c A@@T@c

F3T 683P8,CH"F QOTOc QOTOc QOTAc

FZL1Z,7 QSTUc QSTUc Q?TKc

3PZHL", 187 UJTAc U?TSc USTOc

3M,MH3M UJTBc UUTSc OUTQc

[CHLFM, QQT?c QUTUc A@@T@c

OSRB"IDS USTSc Q@TUc OQTOc

1,8HLMH QOTKc A@@T@c @T@c

[CHHC\"D UBTSc UQTJc U@TUc

5S5KS")f/VSR UQTSc QAT@c USTQc

,"DCH8 UUTSc Q@T?c UOTBcF8FN83MMH Q@TKc QATUc UUTSc

SPD/H"S OUT?c OUTOc OOT?c

68YD8,7 UQTJc UQTOc UQT?c

"L>MH3MH SUTOc SQT?c SOTQc

>"LC6CH" P83 SQTQc OKTOc SJTKc

,"L L"", SSTQc SBT?c O@T@c

DHB"B5f )IPYODBS USTJc QAT@c OSTJc

N"YM[H8 QATQc QKTKc USTOc

68>\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc QBTUc QBT?c

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc Q@TBc OKTSc

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc QJTJc UKTUc

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c UOT@c O@TBc

X8H6MZX", K U?TKc QAT@c BBTKc

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc UUT?c UBTOc

H&>3'*\)3+8

)'6L%3#*1& $#,&< '* F7&,&*1& '( I+C&7 S


47/59


\$G- JS

:.:.A

H&>3'*#% H&,2%+, $8 )%#,, '( "7#


48/59


\$G- JO

"#$%& -XQ 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& $8 )%#,, '( "7#\1"YY ,CX",_6MZ,3"H87 QSTAc A@@T@c Q@TBc A@@T@c A@@T@c

X8H6MZX", 6>8 UBTKc QATKc UJTUc UUTJc U@TBc

X8H6MZX", A Q@TAc A@@T@c Q@TOc QATBc UBTOc

X8H6MZX", ? UAT@c USTOc SQTUc UUTQc U?TAc

X8H6MZX", K U?TKc A@@T@c Q?TBc UOTAc SKTUc

X8H6MZX", J UOTBc U@T@c Q?TQc UKTUc Q?T@c

H&>3'*\)3+8

)'6L%3#*1& $8 )%#,, '( "7#))5EI \).' 6)g&('%$WI >$=% - ,( 5G-I [2)**)9VI \('' >-$5)4/I H-4 [-/'W(*/ '-.

X$*9)-. KR L-% '$I F&..-EI Y$*G%- EI H).'2 L-% '$I [2('- ,) 9V

X$*9)-. JR H).'2 X$*9)-.I [-/' X$*9)-.

H_8 j H) /').-/ 4-.- +)& *5 ( * '2$' 9('E +). '2$' 9%$ // )+ '.$5-T


49/59


\$G- JU

:.9

"'$#11' F7'


50/59


\$G- JQ

"#$%& -AQ 5#%&, )'6L%3#*1& D#,&< '* )'6L%3#*1& M3+C F7'


51/59


\$G- B@

:.G I$,&74#+3'*, '* /N13>#7&++&,

:.G.-

R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, ('7 /N13>#7&++& 5#%&,N+'NO3*'7,

C* ?@AJI $ *-4 9)W=)*-*' 4$/ $55-5 ') '2- /'&5E ') -#$%&$'- '2- 4(%%(*G*-// )+ 9%-.V/ ') /-%%

-:9(G$.-''-/ ') '2- W(*). $+'-. .-+&/(*G '2- /$%- )+ '2- =$9V$G- )+ 9(G$.-''-/T C* $55('()* ') '2- /W$%%-.

/$W=%- )+ .-/-$.92 =$.'(9(=$*'/ 42) 4-.- $/V-5 ') $''-W=' ') ;&E -:9(G$.-''-/I $%% )'2-./ 4-.- $%/)

$/V-5 ') *)'-I (* 9$/-/ 42-* '2-E 4-.- .-+&/-5 '2- /$%- )+ 9(G$.-''-/I 42-'2-. '2- 9%-.V )++-.-5 '2-W

-:9(G$.-''-/ $/ $* $%'-.*$'(#-T \%-$/- *)'- '2$' -#-* '2)&G2 '2- W(*). 5(5 *)' 9)W=%-'- '2- '.$*/$9'()*

+). '2- -:9(G$.-''- =&.92$/-I $' '2- '(W- )+ '2(/ /'&5E '2-.- 4$/ *) %$4 '2$' =.)2(;('/ '2- /$%- )+

-:9(G$.-''-/ ') W(*)./T

8W)*G '2- UJTUc 42) 4-.- .-+&/-5 '2- /$%- )+ 9(G$.-''-/I %-// '2$* Ac `@T@Kca 4$/ )++-.-5 -:9(G$.-''-/

$/ $* $%'-.*$'(#-T 8W)*G '2- AQTJc 42) .-g&-/'-5 ') =&.92$/- $* -:9(G$.-''- 42-* '2- /$%- )+

9(G$.-''-/ 4$/ .-+&/-5I '2- -:9(G$.-''- /$%- 4$/ $%/) .-+&/-5 Q@T?c )+ '2- '(W-T

)C#7+ UQ R#+3'*#% )'6L%3#*1& H&,2%+,Q H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% /N13>#7&++&, +' # O3*'7

QTUc

Q@T?c

7-/

H)

Z:G. V#, +C& 7&+#3%&7 M3%%3*> +' ,&%% +C& &N13>#7&++& +' 8'2]

D#,&Q f#4& 7&i2&,+&< +' L271C#,& #* &N13>#7&++& ̂ *_-[--?`

H&+#3%&7, V3%%3*>*&,, +' 5&%% /N13>#7&++&, +' 63*'7,


52/59


\$G- BA

:.G.: R#+3'*#% H&,2%+, ('7 /N13>#7&++&, $8 S>& '( O3*'7

32- .$'- )+ .-+&/$% ') /-%% -:9(G$.-''-/ ') W(*)./ $+'-. '2- /$%- )+ 9(G$.-''-/ 2$5 ;--* .-+&/-5 4$/ 2(G2-/'

$W)*G AB E-$./ )%5/ `QBTSca +)%%)4-5 ;E AO E-$./ )%5/ `UOTOca $*5I %$/'%EI AS E-$. )%5/ `UBTScaT

)C#7+ -TQ R#+3'*#% )'6L%3#*1& H&,2%+,Q H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% /N13>#7&++&, +' # O3*'7Q D8 S>& '(

O3*'7

H&+#3%&7, H&(2,3*> +' 5&%% &N)3>#7&++&, +' # O3*'7Q D8 S>& '( O3*'7

U@.?a

A@.?a

AX.Xa

UT.:a

?Ta

?@a

XTa

X@a

ATa

A@a

UTa

U@a

-TTa

-@ 8 '% +' ,&%% +C& &N13>#7&++& +' 8'2]

D#,&Q f#4& 7&i2&,+&< +' L271C#,& #* &N13>#7&++& ̂ *_-[--?`

8/21/2019 Final Report-Tobacco Compliance 2014 - FINAL - EnG[6] Cop

final report-tobacco compliance 2014 - final - eng[6] copy

Documents