faulkner rose for emily

3
Robert Thomas Mr. Pagel ENGL 1010 June 18, 2011 Faulkner's Unusual Narrative In his short story “A Rose for Emily”, William Faulkner utilizes a creative third person narrative which propagates two separate and very different protagonists; both of whom are in conflict with a common themed antagonist. On the first reading of the story, it is apparent the title character, Miss Emily Grierson is the main protagonist. The plot relates the main events of her life as told by an anonymous narrator who seems to be a resident of Miss Emily’s unnamed town. Beginning with her death, and then recounting past events, the narrator entices us to feel sympathy for Miss Emily despite the portrayal of her as eccentric, rude and anti-social. Faulkner accomplishes this by identifying several possible antagonist for Miss Emily as the narrator describes the conflicts she had with her dominant Father, her controlling Aunt, and even the town populace. However, after subsequent readings and a closer examination of the

Upload: joe-thomas

Post on 19-Aug-2015

19 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

essay

TRANSCRIPT

Robert ThomasMr. PagelENGL 1010June 18, 2011Faulkners !nusual Narrat"#e $n h"s short stor% &A Rose for Emily', ("ll"am Faulkner ut"l")es a *reat"#e th"r+ ,erson narrat"#e -h"*h ,ro,agates t-o se,arate an+ #er% +"..erent ,rotagon"sts/ both o. -hom are "n *on.l"*t -"th a *ommon theme+ antagon"st.0n the ."rst rea+"ng o. the stor%, "t "s a,,arent the t"tle *hara*ter, M"ss Em"l% Gr"erson "s the ma"n ,rotagon"st. The ,lot relates the ma"n e#ents o. her l".e as tol+ b% an anon%mous narrator -ho seems to be a res"+ent o. M"ss Em"l%1s unname+ to-n. 2eg"nn"ng -"th her +eath, an+ then re*ount"ng ,ast e#ents, the narrator ent"*es us to .eel s%m,ath% .or M"ss Em"l% +es,"te the ,ortra%al o. her as e**entr"*, ru+e an+ ant"3so*"al. Faulkner a**om,l"shes th"s b% "+ent".%"ng se#eral ,oss"ble antagon"st .or M"ss Em"l% as the narrator +es*r"bes the *on.l"*ts she ha+ -"th her +om"nant Father, her *ontroll"ng 4unt, an+ e#en the to-n ,o,ula*e.5o-e#er, a.ter subse6uent rea+"ngs an+ a *loser e7am"nat"on o. the narrat"#e, a se*on+ ,rotagon"st emerges8 the to-ns,eo,le. Th"s *on*lus"on *an be rea*he+ base+ on the "+ent"t% o. the narrator, -ho at one ,o"nt re.ers to themsel#es as &-e' "n ,lural. 4t another ,o"nt "n the stor% -hen M"ss Em"l% ,ur*hases 4rsen"* ,o"son .rom the +rug store, the narrator *omments &(hen she o,ene+ the ,a*kage at home there -as -r"tten ..'-h"*h "n+"*ates a more omn"s*"ent ,o"nt o. #"e-. $ bel"e#e that Faulkner "nten+e+ the &To-n'/ as a se,arate ent"t%, to be *ons"+ere+ as the narrator. Throughout the stor%, the narrator o.ten ,romotes a theme o. .org"#eness, un+erstan+"ng, an+ e#en ,"t% .or M"ss Em"l%, -h"*h also e#okes a sense o. k"nsh", -"th the to-ns,eo,le .rom the rea+er. The &To-n' ent-"nes the l".e o. M"ss Em"l% "nto that o. "ts ,eo,le, as ". the tell"ng o. Em"l%1s stor% "s a s%mbol"* statement an+ e7,lanat"on o. the tr"als an+ troubles the% ha#e en+ure+.The ne7t 6uest"on "s -hat then "s the true antagon"st .or both o. the stor%s ,rotagon"st, an+ -hat *ommon *on.l"*t +o the% share. The narrat"#e ,ers,e*t"#e on*e aga"n g"#es us a *lue. 4.ter relat"ng the sa+ h"stor% o. M"ss Em"l%s ,ast su"tors, the narrator states &9o -hen she got to be th"rt% an+ -as st"ll s"ngle, we -ere not ,lease+ e7a*tl%, but vindicate+...' -h"*h re.ers to the to-ns #"e- o. the Gr"erson .am"l% an+ the"r re,utat"on. The to-n1s ,eo,le -ere not aga"nst M"ss Em"l%, "n .a*t the% .elt sorr% .or her. $t -as her .am"l% name an+ the h"stor% o. arrogan*e, o,ulen*e, an+ ent"tlement -h"*h the% resente+an+ -ante+ to see brought +o-n an+ humble+/ un.ortunatel% Em"l% -as the onl% one le.t .rom -h"*h the% *oul+ e7tra*t th"s +em"se o. the Gr"erson name. 0. *ourse the same *on.l"*t e7"ste+ .or Em"l%, -ho struggle+ -"th her .am"l%s h"gh o,"n"on o. themsel#es her -hole l".e. $t +om"nate+ her an+ *ontrolle+ most o. her l".e +e."ne+ b% her Father, her 4unt an+ e#en her *ous"ns. :eterm"n"ng her "ntera*t"ons -"th the to-n an+ restr"*t"ng her so*"al l".e/ "t -as both her b"rthr"ght an+ her bur+en. $n the en+, "t -as these unreal"st"* e7,e*tat"ons .rom her .am"l% -h"*h ,rom,te+ M"ss Em"l% to mur+er her true lo#e be*ause he -as not seen as u, to her .am"l% stan+ar+s. Robert Thomas 0;