fatal scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › ip › foreign...

25
Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d)

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jun-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d)

Page 2: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d)

foreign patent application

Page 3: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d)

foreign patent granted

foreign patent application

Page 4: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d)

US patent application foreign patent

granted

foreign patent application

Page 5: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d)

more than one year

US patent application foreign patent

granted

foreign patent application

Page 6: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Nonfatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d)

US patent application foreign patent

granted

foreign patent application

more than one year

Page 7: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Nonfatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d)

less than one year

US patent application foreign patent

granted

foreign patent application

Page 8: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent
Page 9: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Kathawala (CAFC 1993)

Page 10: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Kathawala (CAFC 1993)

11/22/1982 Limited US application

Page 11: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Kathawala (CAFC 1993)

11/22/1982 Limited US application

11/21/1983 Expanded Greek & Spanish applications

Page 12: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Kathawala (CAFC 1993)

11/22/1982 Limited US application

11/21/1983 Expanded Greek & Spanish applications

10/2/1984 Spanish patent issued

Page 13: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Kathawala (CAFC 1993)

11/22/1982 Limited US application

11/21/1983 Expanded Greek & Spanish applications

10/2/1984 Spanish patent issued

1/21/1985 Greek patent issued

Page 14: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Kathawala (CAFC 1993)

11/22/1982 Limited US application

11/21/1983 Expanded Greek & Spanish applications

10/2/1984 Spanish patent issued

1/21/1985 Greek patent issued

4/11/1985 Expanded US application

Page 15: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Kathawala (CAFC 1993)

11/22/1982 Limited US application

11/21/1983 Expanded Greek & Spanish applications

10/2/1984 Spanish patent issued

1/21/1985 Greek patent issued

8/1/1985 Spanish Patent published

4/11/1985 Expanded US application

Page 16: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Kathawala (CAFC 1993)

11/22/1982 Limited US application

11/21/1983 Expanded Greek & Spanish applications

10/2/1984 Spanish patent issued

1/21/1985 Greek patent issued

8/1/1985 Spanish Patent published

4/11/1985 Expanded US application

Page 17: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Bayer problem (SDNY 1996)

Page 18: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Bayer problem (SDNY 1996)

Apply in Country X

Page 19: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Bayer problem (SDNY 1996)

Apply in Country X Apply in

Country Y

Page 20: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Bayer problem (SDNY 1996)

Apply in Country X Apply in

Country Y

Country X Patent issues

Page 21: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Bayer problem (SDNY 1996)

Apply in Country X Apply in

Country Y

Country X Patent issues

Apply in US

Page 22: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Bayer problem (SDNY 1996)

Apply in Country X Apply in

Country Y

Country X Patent issues

Apply in US

11 months

Page 23: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Bayer problem (SDNY 1996)

Apply in Country X Apply in

Country Y

Country X Patent issues

Apply in US

11 months 11 months

Page 24: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

Bayer problem (SDNY 1996)

Apply in Country X Apply in

Country Y

Country X Patent issues

Apply in US

11 months 11 months

22 months

Page 25: Fatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) › people › tfisher › IP › Foreign Patents.pdfFatal Scenario in re foreign patent applications -- 102(d) foreign patent

§119 (a) An application for patent for an invention filed in this country by

any person who has … previously regularly filed an application for a patent for the same invention in a foreign country which affords similar privileges in the case of applications filed in the United States … or in a WTO member country, shall have the same effect as the same application would have if filed in this country on the date on which the application for patent for the same invention was first filed in such foreign country, if the application in this country is filed within twelve months from the earliest date on which such foreign application was filed; but no patent shall be granted on any application for patent for an invention which had been patented or described in a printed publication in any country more than one year before the date of the actual filing of the application in this country, or which had been in public use or on sale in this country more than one year prior to such filing.