fabian nehrbass. thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years australia...

32
Amphibious Homes: A Real Solution to Flooding? Fabian Nehrbass

Upload: cassandra-roads

Post on 28-Mar-2015

218 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Amphibious Homes: A Real Solution to Flooding?

Fabian Nehrbass

Page 2: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Sea level rise- floods

Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years

Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisiana’s

coastal parishes 634,000 homes New Orleans sea level rise:

8” by 2030 19” by 2050

Page 3: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Possible solutions:

Levees Restoration of wetlands Sediment use form Mississippi to

rebuild land Abandon land Adapt!

Page 4: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Amphibious homes

Allows the home to sit close to the ground, and in the event of a flood, rise up with the rising water

Page 5: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Why not just elevate homes?

Increased vulnerability of the structure to wind damage

Elevations are expensive $40,000-$60,000 to elevate vs. $25,000

to retrofit existing house with floating foundation

Difficult access to living areas Loss of character

Page 6: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas
Page 7: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Advantages of floating homes

No loss of character Cheaper than elevating No issues with soil subsidence Less vulnerable to hurricane damage

Page 8: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Problems with floating homes

FEMA does not believe they are a good strategy to protect against hurricane flooding

Storm surge can still push water into such a home

Still need to evacuate Only work in areas where water rises

slowly Size and weight limitations

Page 9: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Problems continued

**National Flood Insurance Program will not insure floating houses because they are not considered anchored to the ground**

Chance they aren’t allowed In Lakeview, house wasn’t allowed in

“special flood hazard zone”

More susceptible to wind damage?

Page 10: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

FEMA

Suggestions

Page 11: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

How it works – Buoyant Foundation Project

Shotgun retrofitting Buoyancy blocks and a vertical guidance

system interconnected by a light structural frame

Utility lines have either long, coiled “umbilical” lines or self-sealing “breakaway” connections that disconnect gas and sewer lines when the house begins to rise

Page 12: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Examples

Netherlands Maas River Prison Greenhouses

Maldives – designed by Watersudio Raccourci Old River, Louisiana 9th Ward Lakeview UK

Page 13: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

FLOAT House, 9th Ward

Page 14: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

FLOAT House, 9th Ward

Page 15: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

FLOAT House, 9th Ward

Page 16: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas
Page 17: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

“Noah’s Ark” –Lakeview

Page 18: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Raccourci Old River

Page 19: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas
Page 20: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas
Page 21: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas
Page 22: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Maas River

$310,000 each (about 25% greater) All survived major floods in 2011

Page 23: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Maas River

Page 24: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas
Page 25: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Maas River

Page 26: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas
Page 27: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Floating prison- Zaandem, Netherlands

Page 28: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Floating prison- Zaandem, Netherlands

Page 29: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Maldives

Page 30: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Maldives

Page 31: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas
Page 32: Fabian Nehrbass. Thailand $45 billion dollars damage due to floods in the past two years Australia $9.6 billion 1.4 million people live in Louisianas

Conclusion

No flood insurance, no success Frequency of storms? Wind protection? Float them down the river to Baton

Rouge!