experiences with tomari-3 construction (session_2... · plant construction experiences ... tomari-3...

28
GEN-HSW-9046- 0 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B CNRA/WGRNR Workshop “New Reactor Siting, Licensing and Construction Experience” Jinich Miyaguchi 16 September 2010 Nuclear Systems Engineering Department Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Ltd. MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction 0

Upload: duongtuyen

Post on 15-Mar-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 0 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

CNRA/WGRNR Workshop

“New Reactor Siting, Licensing and Construction

Experience”

Jinich Miyaguchi

16 September 2010

Nuclear Systems Engineering Department

Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Ltd.

MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Experiences with

Tomari-3 Construction

0

Page 2: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 1 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

CONTENTS

Background

Tomari-3 Construction

Outline / Construction Schedule

Plant Aspects

Proven Design

New Technology

Advanced Engineering

Construction Aspects

Site-work in winter season

Modularization in Construction

APWR progress report

Towards the future

1

Page 3: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 2 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Mitsubishi has constructed 24 PWR NPPs in Japan. Twin APWRs are under licensing.

TOKYO

YOKOHAMA

KOBE TAKASAGO

Tsuruga P/S

Mihama P/S Ohi P/S

Takahama P/S

Genkai P/S Sendai P/S

Ikata P/S

Tomari P/S

in operation

2 2

2 2

2 2

2 2 3

3 3 3 3

3 3

4 4 4 4

4 4

Number of Loops

under licensing (APWR)

Background

< Contributions for All PWR in Japan >

3 Tomari-3

2

Page 4: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 3 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

‘65 ‘70 ‘75 ‘80 ‘85 ‘90 ‘95 ‘00 ‘05

Background

< History of Mitsubishi PWR Plant Constructions >

2 loop PWR

4 loop PWR

Mihama-1

Mihama-2

Genkai-1

Ikata-1

Genkai-2

Ikata-2 Tomari-1

Tomari-2

Ohi-3

Ohi-4

Tsuruga-2

Genkai-3

Genkai-4

Ohi-1

Ohi-2

3 loop PWR

Takahama-1

Takahama-2

Mihama-3

Takahama-3

Takahama-4

Sendai-1

Sendai-2

Ikata-3 Tomari-3

3

Page 5: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 4 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Background

< Continuous Constructions Experiences >

1970s 1980s 1990s 2000s 2010s After 2020

9 units

▼ Tomari-3 (Dec.2009)

Tsuruga-3/4 (2016/2017)

▼▼

US-APWR

Developing

our own

technology

Safety & Reliability Enhancement

Plant Construction ExperiencesPlant Construction Experiences

Economy

Enhancement

Major Components Replacement Projects Major Components Replacement Projects (including Components Supply)(including Components Supply)

7 units 7 units

20 Steam Generator

14* Reactor Vessel Head

4 Core Internal

14* Turbine

6 Control Boards

*:including

2 foreign plants

▲ Sendai-3 (2019)

Japanese APWR

EU-APWR

4

Page 6: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 5 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Tomari-3 Construction

< Overview >

Tomari-3

Tomari-1/2 unit1;C/O 1989, 579MWe

unit2;C/O 1991, 579MWe

東京

Kobe

Tokyo

Tomari Heavy snow and

strong wind

in winter

Tomari-3

Utility Hokkaido Electric Power

Co., Inc

Manufacturer

/Constructor

Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, ltd.

Reactor PWR (3 Loop)

Electric power output 912 MWe

Fuel assembly 17 x 17 / 12ft

Number of fuel assemblies

157

Frequency 50Hz

5

Page 7: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 6 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Tomari-3 Construction

< Construction Schedule >

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

Rock Inspection

Loose Excavation

Base Concrete Inner Concrete of

Containment Vessel

Commercial

Operation

Construction of

Containment Vessel

Start-up

Test

Fuel Loading

MEF : Mechanical and

Electrical Facilities

Installation and Function test of MEF

Construction completed just on schedule

License

Approval

6

Page 8: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 7 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Plant Aspects Proven Design

3-loop conventional type PWR using highly reliable components

New Technology Fully digital I&C system

Advanced Engineering 3D-CAD engineering

Integrated Database System

Jobsite Construction Control System

Construction Aspects Site-work in Winter Season

Modularization in construction

Tomari-3 Construction

< Plant & Construction Aspects >

7

Page 9: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 8 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Proven Design

< Highly Reliable Components >

Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery

with high reliability fostered through long years

manufacturing and maintenance experiences.

8

Page 10: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 9 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

U.S.A

Turbine: 2units

Mexico

Turbine :2units

Taiwan

RV:3units,Turbine:

6units, RCP:8units,

CHP:24units

China

PBMR Turbine Generator /Core Barrel Assembly

South Africa

Turbine 1unit

Spain

RVCH:3units Sweden

Turbine Rotor 2sets

Slovenia

RV: 1unit

Finland

SG:10units

Belgium

SG:15units

France

RV:Reactor Vessel

RCP:Reactor Coolant Pump

CHP:Charging Pump

Prz:Pressurizer

RVCH:Reactor Vessel Closure Heads

SG:Steam Generator

RVCH : 16units

SG : 6units

Prz : 1unit

Brazil

RVCH:1unit

Proven Design

< World-wide Reliable Components Supply >

9

Page 11: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 10 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

New Technology

< Fully Digital Main Control Room >

Soft operation Soft operation

Large display panel Large display panel

Improved monitoring and Improved monitoring and operational performance

by integrating controls and

information display

Advanced Control Room Advanced Control Room

Compact operator consoleCompact operator console

10

Page 12: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 11 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

New Technology

< I&C System Verification Works >

Integrated Factory Acceptance Test.Integrated Factory Acceptance Test.

All the digital systems are connected at All the digital systems are connected at Mitsubishi factory via networks.Mitsubishi factory via networks.

Perform factory acceptance tests including Perform factory acceptance tests including communication check, system failure test communication check, system failure test and response time test.and response time test.

8 months of intensive test schedule.8 months of intensive test schedule.

Validation for total system performance Validation for total system performance before shipping.before shipping.

11

Page 13: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 12 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Advanced Engineering

< 3-D CAD Systems >

Layout・Piping Designing

Turbine

Main Component

Construction Planning

Improving design and construction

accuracy and efficiency.

Improving operation and maintenance

management.

Maintenance Demonstration

12

Page 14: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 13 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Advanced Engineering

< Integrated Database Systems >

Integrated Database

Inspection of welding

Inspection (on-site)

Material management

Manufacturing by CAM

Construction management

3D-CAD Management Integrated common database

from design, procurement,

inspection and construction

13

Page 15: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 14 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Drawing control

- Distribution by E-file. (in parallel with Hard copies)

- Multi-level security control

- Status control

Piping/Support construction progress follow-up

- Bar-code Multi-Tag for each weld point

- Progress monitoring

Advanced Engineering

< Construction Control System >

JCCS (Jobsite Construction Control System)

Final PT

Welding

Fit-up inspection

Joint fit-up 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

N F M S D M JNov Feb May Sep Dec Mar Jul 0

50

100

(%) ■R/B01(Plan)

◆R/B01(Result)

●R/B02(Plan)

▲R/B02(Result)

14

Page 16: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 15 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Site-work in Winter Season

< Winter Restriction at Tomari Site >

2.2. Heavy Duty Crane should be Heavy Duty Crane should be

used for construct used for construct

containment vessel before containment vessel before

winter seasonwinter season

1.1. Construction is difficult in winter season because Construction is difficult in winter season because

of heavy snow and strong windof heavy snow and strong wind

(end of Nov. (end of Nov. –– beginning of Mar.)beginning of Mar.)

15

Page 17: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 16 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Site-work in Winter Season

< Modified Setup Processes >

3. Early setup of outer shield is to enable inside work during

winter season.

16

Page 18: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 17 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Modularization in construction

< Shortening Construction schedule >

1. Piping modules

3. CV upper head

2. Packaging modules

17

Page 19: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 18 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Modularization in construction

< Modularization History >

18

Page 20: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 19 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Modularization in construction

< Piping Modules >

Multiple types of piping modules

19

Page 21: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 20 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Modularization in construction

< Packaging Modules >

20

Page 22: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 21 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Heavy duty crane

40m diameter

containment vessel

upper head

Advanced methods for shortening construction period.

Modularization in construction

< CV Upper Head Installation >

21

Page 23: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 22 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

High precision on-site welding for upper head assembly in parallel with CV body construction

Welding & assembling

of upper head

Construction of

CV body

Modularization in construction

< CV Construction in 8-Months >

22

Page 24: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 23 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Conclusion

< Tomari-3 Successful Construction >

Completed just on schedule

Proven Design 3-loop conventional type PWR using highly reliable components

New Technology Fully digital I&C system

Advanced Engineering 3D-CAD engineering

Integrated Database System

Jobsite Construction Control System

Modularization in construction

Launch Base for APWR worldwide

application

23

Page 25: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 24 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

APWR Progress Report

A new generation LWR “APWR” started as Japanese national project more than 20 years ago.

APWR has been standardized for worldwide market as US-APWR and EU-APWR.

Larger output and improved reliability based on best mix of proven technologies 1,700 MWe class power production

24 months fuel cycle with on-line maintenance

4 train safety system with advanced accumulator

Fully digital I&C and computerized MCR

24

Page 26: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 25 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

US-APWR

DC application under reviewing by USNRC, planned to be

certified in 2011

COL applications for two sites under reviewing

EU-APWR

Design modifications will be finished this year considering

European safety requirements.

(SA, APC, etc.)

Preparing for EUR assessment.

APWR Progress Report

25

Page 27: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 26 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Towards the Future

Earlier discussion with utility is important for mutual understanding and to achieve on schedule design, licensing and construction.

Pre-application discussion with licensing authority is quite effective to address important safety issues and to establish clear licensing procedure and schedule

Worldwide cooperation of industries and authorities is useful to establish international standards.

26

Page 28: Experiences with Tomari-3 Construction (session_2... · Plant Construction Experiences ... Tomari-3 Steam Generator was celebrated as MHI’s 100th delivery ... Integrated Factory

GEN-HSW-9046- 27 MITSUBISHI PROPRIETARY CLASS B

Thank you for your attention

27