exit strategies mitch ratcliffe internet/media strategies inc. & innovationworld llc

12
Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Post on 21-Dec-2015

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Exit Strategies

Mitch RatcliffeInternet/Media Strategies Inc. &

InnovationWORLD LLC

Page 2: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Goals

» Understand the concept of an “exit strategy”

» The options» The realities» Case Study: Google

Page 3: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Plan for success and “failure”

» 17 percent of companies that close are a “success”

» 33 percent of companies failed after four years, 60.5 percent after six years

» Whether you are staying in the company or leaving, how you do it matters

Closed & Successful17%

Surviving50%

Closed & Unsuccessful33%

Business success of new firms after four years, 1992-1996Source:Small Business Administration; U.S. Census Bureau (excluding C corps.) and Congressional Budget Office

Page 4: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Exit vs. Liquidity» A fund's intended method for liquidating its holdings while

achieving the maximum possible return. These strategies depend on the exit climates including market conditions and industry trends. Exit strategies can include selling or distributing the portfolio company’s shares after an initial public offering (IPO), a sale of the Portfolio Company or a recapitalization. www.ventureglobe.com/glossy.html

» Potential scenarios for liquidating an investment while achieving the maximum possible return. For venture capital-backed companies, typical exit strategies include Initial Public Offerings (IPOs) and mergers with larger companies. www.championventures.com/glossary.htm

» The business owner's intended method of retiring or transferring ownership of the company. www.oaktreeresources.com/Deal_Central/Glossary%20of%20M&A%20terms.htm

Page 5: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Transactions

» Mergers and Acquisition (“M&A”): » 36 Net deals in Washington in 2001, compared to

322 in California» Nationally, 71 VC-backed companies saw

transactions in Q4-03, worth $2.3B at an average valuation of $67MM

» Initial Public Offering: 13 VC-backed companies in Q1-04,» Six in biotech ($433MM)» Four healthcare/medical ($272MM)» Two semiconductor/electronics ($1.9B)

Page 6: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Transaction of last resort

» Liquidation» Preferred investors (that’s the VCs,

angels and anyone you ever want to talk to again) come after the banks that loaned you money

» Always remember: It takes money to shut down

Page 7: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

“Google is not a conventional company.”

Page 8: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

A personal appeal to benevolent despotism

» “Sergey and I intend to write you a letter like this one every year in our annual report.”

» “As a private company, we have concentrated on the long term…. As a public company, we will do the same. In our opinion, outside pressures too often tempt companies to sacrifice long-term opportunities to meet quarterly market expectations.”

Page 9: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Not by Wall Street’s rules

» Management declines to offer guidance.» Two classes of shares with 10:1 voting

rights to make it “harder for outside parties to take over or influence Google.”

» “We are creating a corporate structure that is designed for stability over long time horizons. By investing in Google, you are placing an unusual long-term bet on the team, especially Sergey and me, and on our innovative approach.”

Page 10: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Forced to go public

» With 500 investors, they have to report some financial information

» Need to provide investors liquidity» Need to provide employees

liquidity» Expected to generate $1.2 billion in

free cash this year

Page 11: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

“We would like you to invest for the long term….”

» Management is selling shares, taking its payday at the IPO

» Dutch auction, while “democratic,” amplifies the potential for irrational pricing

» With $2.7 billion more in cash, what will Google do?

Page 12: Exit Strategies Mitch Ratcliffe Internet/Media Strategies Inc. & InnovationWORLD LLC

Google Realities

» Management is taking care of itself» Allocating only 10 percent of free cash

this year to investors would provide a 10x return on investment

» Investors can be paid out with a “fair” profit while preserving private company advantages

» It may not be “evil” to Google, but what about the rest of us individual investors?