exhibit 1 - cwrmbssettlement.com · r-483 483 9/25/2012 rakoff opinion - 2012 wl 4373327 (assured...
TRANSCRIPT
Exhibit 1
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/30/2013 INDEX NO. 651786/2011
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 848 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/30/2013FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/31/2013 INDEX NO. 651786/2011
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 853 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/31/2013
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-197 197 09/16/2010 SEC v. Mozilo, et. al., DecisionR-250 250 10/24/2012 U.S. v. Bank of America Corp, Complaint-in-Intervention of the United States of
America, Case. No. 12-Civ-1422 (JSR), USDC SDNYR-346 04/04/2012 Consent Judgment, U.S. v. Bank of America Corp., et. al., Case No. 12-cv-0361, D.
D. C. (Exhibits A and I only)R-426 426 10/31/2008 Exhibit 4, Doc. No. 2504, Spreadsheet titled: Countrywide Transition, Legal Entity
ListBACMBIA-C0000168643
R-427 6/25/2008 Exhibit 12, Doc. No. 2711, Email from Steve Brown, to David Belk, Subject: Final speech and slides for Countrywide (attachments: cfc June board 062408.doc, 8036_BOD_Countrywide_fin_v3.ppt; Countrywide Backup.xls)
BACMBIA-B0000018282-330
R-428 1/28/2008 Exhibit 18, Doc. No. 2716, Email from Mary Eyre, to Patty Van Tuyl, Subject: Re: 0125.2007 Exec Staff Meeting
BACMBIA-X0000018071-78
R-429 4/7/2008 Exhibit 21, Doc. No. 2718, Calendar invitation from countrywide to to various, Subject: BAC/Countrywide 4/8 Steering Committee - Presentation Materials
BACMBIA-B0000009907-924
R-430 7/2/2008 Exhibit 38, Doc. No. 2728, Purchase and Sale Agreement, between NB Holdings Corporation, and Countrywide homes loans, Inc.
BACMBIA-C0000161342-350
R-431 4/8/2009 Exhibit 63, Doc. No. 2748, Email from David M. King, to Arturo Perez, cc: various, Subject: Re: CHL retaining some loans?
BACMBIA-O0000029482-490
R-432 4/14/2009 Exhibit 64, Doc. No. 2749, Email from Ofcharsky to Pranger, Subject: RE: CHL Loans to Remain - Fire drill from last week - ?
BACMBIA-Z0000303303-304
R-433 5/11/2012 Exhibit 75, Doc. No. 2757, Transcript of Deposition of Kevin BartlettR-434 12/16/2010 Exhibit 112, Doc. No. 2769, Letter from Bank of America to Countrywide re 2/11/09
Agreed Final Judgment and Injunction against Countrywide and othersCWMBIA-G0000107681-680
R-435 8/4/2011 Exhibit 164, Doc. No. 2807, Transcript of Deposition of Irene Briones Transcript
R-436 1/15/2008 Exhibit 175, Doc. No. 2808, Email from Keith Davis to Lepley, Andersen, Brantley, McNairy, Mroz, and Lewis, Subject: RE: Countrywide Purchase - State Tax Losses
BACMBIA-C0000001729-734
R-437 11/12/2008 Exhibit 182, Doc. No. 2810, Email from Susan Welsh to Michael Sands and Debbie Minton, Subject: FW: Brucker Meeting Follow Up Items
BACMBIA-X0000271172-179
R-438 2/5/2008 Exhibit 183, Doc. No. 2811, Email from Sean Tobias to Brent Andersen, CC: Baalman, Lewis, Macan, Short, Subject: RE: Countrywide
BACMBIA-X0000102050-053
R-439 9/9/2008 Exhibit 185, Doc. No. 2813, Email from Kurzban to Ahareef Abdou, CC: Simantel, Rusli, Jewett, Milligan, Subject: Re: MBIA Status
CWMBIA-B0000005401-02
Excerpt Page 1 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-440 1/9/2008 Exhibit 186, Doc. No. 2814, Email from Randy Shearer to Neil Cotty, Subject: Project Red Oak Due Diligence
BACMBIA-X0000340164-167
R-441 10/10/2008 Exhibit 207, Doc. No. 2826, Email from Kent Sorey to Brucker, Bartlett, CC: various others, Subject: Internal Audit- Pul Backs and Claims Denial Report and attachment: Putbacks report 10 10 08
BACMBIA-Q0000025398-403
R-442 5/12/2009 Exhibit 210, Doc. No. 2827, Countrywide Transition End State Servicing Analysis, Execution Phase, End State Validation
BACMBIA-K0000002286-291
R-443 10/31/2008 Exhibit 212, Doc. No. 2829, Countrywide Transition, Legal Entity List BACMBIA-C0000118128-118128.0169
R-444 12/9/2008 Exhibit 216, Doc. No. 2833, Charter Collapse Update, Project Groundhog, Countrywide Transition Finance
BACMBIA-C0000036785-789
R-445 6/17/2008 Exhibit 251, Doc. No. 2866, Bank of America, Execution Kick-Off Script, participants: Jim Eckerle and Mary Kanaga
BACMBIA-C0000169260-265
R-446 1/9/2009 Exhibit 308, Doc. No. 2912, Email from Edward Ofcharsky to Mary Kanaga, Subject: RE: Legal entities
BACMBIA-P0000094840-841
R-447 9/15/2008 Exhibit 90, Doc. No. 2995, Draft Remarks for Barbara Desoer at the BAC Investor Conference - San Francisco, CA
BACMBIA-P0000015685-690
R-448 6/22/2012 Exhibit 25, Doc. No. 3101, redacted Expert Report of Professor John C. Coates IV
R-449 7/27/2012 Exhibit 28, Doc. No. 3103, redacted Expert Report of John C. Coffee, Jr.R-451 10/22/2008 Exhibit 84, Doc. No. 3109, redacted Bofa Corp. Audit Committee, 2008 Performance
ChecklistBACMBIA-Y0000035239-253
R-452 5/18/2012 Exhibit 56, Doc. No. 3118, Transcript of Deposition of Edward J. OfcharskyR-453 5/3/2012 Exhibit 68, Doc. No. 3119, Transcript of Deposition of Gregory Willis HobbyR-454 08/09/2012 Exhibit 72, Doc. No. 3121, Transcript of Deposition of Drew GissingerR-455 Exhibit 82, Doc. No. 3125, tables of separability analysis on Countrywide Financial
Corp. and Countrywide Home Loans, Inc.BACMBIA-I0000065612-13
R-456 12/31/2010 Exhibit 85, Doc. No. 3127, redacted Countrywide Home Loans Selected Financial Information (Unaudited)
BACMBIA-L0000003629-636
R-457 07/13/2012 Exhibit 180, Doc. No. 3144, BofA Corp.'s Second Supplemental Responses and Objections to Plaintiff's Interrogatories
R-458 08/29/2012 Exhibit 288, Doc. No. 3149, Transcript of Deposition of Michael W. Schloessmann
R-459 04/06/2012 Exhibit 322, Doc. No. 3158, Transcript of Deposition of James EckerleR-460 460 05/02/2012 Exhibit 96, Doc. No. 3340, Transcript of Deposition of Brian T. Moynihan
Excerpt Page 2 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-483 483 9/25/2012 Rakoff Opinion - 2012 WL 4373327 (Assured Guar. Mun. Corp. v. Flagstar Bank FSB)
R-524 524 12/20/2012 Summons and Notice, JP Morgan, et al. v. WMCR-568 568 09/06/2008 US SEC, Non-prosecution agreementR-571 10/24/2012 Complaint-in-Intervention of the United States of AmericaR-611 1/9/2013 MBIA presentation on the Parties' Motions for Summary Judgment on Successor
Liability Based on De Facto Merger (Motion Sequence Nos. 60-61), Doc. # 4209, Index No. 602825/2008
R-612 1/9/2013 BAC's oral Argument on BAC's and MBIA's motions for Summary Judgment on Successor liability
R-613 1/10/2013 MBIA presentation R-619 Dec-07 CFC Overview & outlook, Ex. 5 to Oblak Affirmation, Doc No. 2707, Index No.
602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012BacMBIA-B0000000688-174
R-620 620 6/25/2012 Email from Brown, to Belk, Subject: Final speech and slides for Countrywide, includes attachments, Ex. 12 to Oblak Affirmation, Doc No. 2711, Index No 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-B0000018282-330
R-621 621 6/11/2008 Email re BAC Strategic Announcement, Ex. 13 to Oblak Affirmation, Doc no 2712, index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-H000000122-141
R-622 622 6/24/2008 Email from Gordon to Descer, subject: Updated board presentation talking points, Ex. 16 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2714, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-O0000002036-2042
R-623 10/31/2008 Email attaching post purchase optimism, Ex. 17 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2715, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-A0000133311-313
R-624 624 1/28/2008 Email regarding 1/25/2007 staff meeting, Ex. 18 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2716, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-X0000018071-78
R-627 627 9/19/2008 Depo Transcript of Cynthia Simantel Vol. 1, MBIA v. Countrywide NY state supreme court, Ex. 47 Oblak
BACMBIA-W0000001964-1974
R-628 11/25/2008 Email regarding Profroma [sic] Investment in Sub Sale from CFC to BAC, Ex. 50 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2738, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012 (missing native doc)
BACMBIA-H00000007842-45
R-629 11/7/2008 Demand Note in amount of $3,464,227515 BACMBIA-C0000168502-07; BNYM_CW*497 Confidential
R-630 630 4/8/2009 Email from David King to Arturo Perez Subject: re: CHL retaining some loans?, Ex. 63 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2748, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-O0000029482-90
Excerpt Page 3 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-631 4/14/2009 Email from Ofcharsky to pranger, Ex. 64 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2749, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-X0000303303
R-632 10/14/2008 Written Consent of the Sole Shareholder of Countrywide home loans, inc., Ex. 74 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2756, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
CWMBIA-G0000196811-
R-633 Separability analysis, Ex. 82 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2756, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-I0000065612
R-634 634 12/31/2010 CHL selected financial info (unaudited) Ex. 85 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No , Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012 (fewer page numbers than Ex. 585)
BACMBIA-L0000003629-
R-635 635 11/17/2008 Email from Trouner to Jones, Subject: FW: Revised Management team discussion document (includes attachment), Ex. 97 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2759, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-R0000042401-13
R-636 6/30/2008 J. Price Talking Points, Ex. 108 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2765, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-X000121449
R-637 1/20/2010 Email from hobby to desoer re BAC earnings Q&A on reps and warrants, Ex. 122 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2772, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-G0000001274
R-638 638 1/15/2008 Email from e. Lepley re countrywide purchase - state tax losse, Ex. 175 to Oblak Affirmation Doc No 2808, Index no 602825/2008, filed 11/20/2012
BACMBIA-C000001729-34
R-639 12/28/2011 US v CFC, consent order, CV-11-10540, Ex. 178 Oblak BACMBIA-Y0000000834-
R-640 11/12/2008 Email re Brucker Meeting Follow up items, Ex. 182 Oblak BacMBIA-X0000271172
R-641 641 12/16/2008 Execution deliverable meeting agenda, Ex. 192 Oblak BACMBIA-0000037105
R-642 642 11/1/2008 Note Summary, Ex. 193 Oblak BACMBIA-V0000028884
R-643 10/14/2008 Countrywide Home loans, Inc., Action by Unanimous written consent of directors in Lieu of Meeting of Directors, Ex. 196 oblak (also produced at BNYM_cW-898-this version has more pages se ex. 644)
CWMBIA-G0000196813-
R-645 645 Pre-Charter-Collapse Transfers Project Task List, Ex. 205 Oblak BACMBIA-Y0000001039
R-646 646 5/12/2009 Countrywide Transition, end State Servicing analysis, Execution Phase, end state validation, May 12th, 2009, Ex. 210 Oblak
BACMBAI-K0000002286-
R-647 10/31/2008 Legal entity List, Ex. 212 Oblak BACMBIA-C0000118128
Excerpt Page 4 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-648 648 10/24/2008 CFC Government Lending IDs Transition presentation, Activities, Ex. 213 Oblak BACMBIA-A0000130601
R-649 649 12/9/2008 Charter Collapse Update, Project Groundhog, Countrywide Transition Finance, Ex. 216 oblak
BACMBIA-C0000036785-
R-660 660 01/09/2013 BAC's Oral Argument on BAC's and MBIA's motions for Summary Judgment on Successor liability, MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc.,, Index No. 602825/2008
R-661 661 6/26/2008 BAC/Countrywide Transition Tollgate 3 - integrated plan, Ex. 219 Oblak BACMBIA-A0000068678
R-662 2/23/2011 Depo Transcript of Cynthia Simantel Vol. 1, MBIA v. Countrywide NY state supreme court, Ex. 247 Oblak
R-663 7/22/2008 Bank of America/Countrywide Transition Execution Kick-Offi, Ex. 249 Oblak BACMBIA-A0000071724-
R-664 664 6/23/2010 Minutes of meeting of board of directors of Bank of America corp, ex. 256 Oblak BACMBIA-W0000002052-
R-665 5/15/2008 BAC/Countrywide transition tollgate 2 - target environment, Ex. 287 Oblak BACMBIA-A0000061344
R-666 11/12/2008 Email re charter Collapse update, Ex. 296 oblak BACMBIA-C0000020953
R-667 9/30/2010 Countrywide financial corp selected consolidated financial info (unaudited) Ex. 307 Oblak
CWMBIA0018539255-
R-668 1/9/2009 Email regarding legal entities, Ex. 308 Oblak BacMBIA-P0000094840
R-669 669 3/24/2009 Email re Bank of America S4 ad filed 2-13, ex. 321 Oblak BACMBIA-C0000003236-
R-670 10/6/2008 Email re leadership package - AG agreement, Ex. 347 Oblak BACMBIA-R0000039811-
R-671 7/12/2012 Settlement Agreement BAC and CHL, Syncora, Ex. 349 Oblak BACMBIA-X0000435954-
R-672 672 Countrywide Charter Collapse overview, Ex. 361 Oblak BACMBIA-Y000001036
R-673 5/12/2011 Gissinger Depo trans, Ex. 4 Bea Aff, Doc # 2950R-674 674 5/29/2008 Email from Vincent Gangi to Execution Team LD 1, Subject: Public Policy
document, attachment: Publicpolicy-Briefing_Document.DOC, Ex. 57 Bea affCHL-21-00016490-536;CWMBIA-F000093163-209
Excerpt Page 5 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-675 5/21/2012 Email from Anson Gong to various, Subject: Finalize response back to HUD on their Nov. deadline for same AUS platform for LCWB and LBAC FHA loans; 888-816-1108; code 2134787646, attachment: BAC_Countrywide Transition Timeline_v3.ppt, Ex. 61 Bea Aff
R-676 676 6/16/2008 Barbara Desoer - CRE/ISG Leadership Call - Monday, June 16, 2008, Ex. 89 bea aff
R-677 677 9/15/2008 Draft Remarks for Barbara Desoer at the BAC Investor Conference - San Francisco, California, Ex. 90 bea aff
BACMBIA-P0000015685-
R-678 2/24/2011 Bylaws of BAC, Ex. 32 bea affR-679 6/30/2012 BAC brochure, Lending, investing and giving in New York, ex. 64 bea affR-680 3/28/2012 BOA stockhold letter, ex. 112 bea aff R-681 681 5/18/2012 Ofcharsky depo transcript, Vol. 1, Ex 56 Oblak affR-682 8/2/2012 Winn expert report, Ex. 27 Bea doc 4020R-683 BOA organizational charts, Legal Entity End state, Ex. 254 Oblak affR-684 684 4/7/2008 Email from countrywide to Barbara Desoer, Brian Moynihan, and multiple others,
Subject: BAC/Country 4/8 Steering Committee - Presentation Materials, Ex. 21 Oblak aff
BACMBIA-B0000009907-9924
R-687 Motion to dismiss, Retirement Board of the Policeman's Annuity v. BNYMR-755 09/20/2012 Screenshot of Docket reflecting Butler Affidavit in support of Plaintiff's Motion for
Summary Judgment (DKT 1975) filed Under Seal (MBIA v. Countrywide, Index No. 60825-2008)
R-756 11/23/2012 Butler Affidavit in Support of Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment on Breach of the Insurance Agreements (MBIA v. Countrywide, Index No. 602825-2008, DKT 3338)
R-757 06/24/2011 Excerpt of Expert Report of Murray, (SW Boston Hotel ,et al., Case No. 10-14535, DKT 691)
R-758 06/24/2011 Excerpt of Expert Report of Murray, (SW Boston Hotel ,et al., Case No. 10-14535, DKT 691) (pages 12-13)
R-759 05/04/2011 Complaint (MASTR, by U.S. Bank) (DKT 1)R-760 11/27/2012 Complaint (Deutsche Alt-A Securities v. DB Structured Products, SDNY 12-cv-
08594, DKT 1)
Excerpt Page 6 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-761 03/20/2013 Complaint (Ace Securities Corp. v. DB Structured Products, SDNY 13-cv-01869, DKT 1)
R-762 01/09/2012 Complaint (Bear Stearns v. EMC Mortgage, Delaware Civil Action No. 6861-CS)
R-763 763 12/20/2012 Complaint (J.P. Morgan v. WMC Mortgage, NY Index No. 654464-2012, DKT 1)
R-795 07/03/2012 Godfrey Expert Report (MBI v. Countrywide, Index 602825-2008, Ex. 147 to Holland Aff. in support of Countrywide's MSJ) (redacted)
R-800 03/11/2013 Schloessmann Affidavit in support of Countrywide's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment (MBIA v. Countrywide, Index No. 60825-2008, DKT 4055)
R-820 820 MBIA MSJ decisionR-822 09/28/2012 Plaintiff's Memorandum of Law ISO Mot for Summary Judgment on Successor
Liability Based on De Facto Merger and Assumption of Liabilities, MBIA v. Countrywide, doc no. 2074
R-823 11/27/2012 Plaintiff's Reply Memo of Law ISO Motion for Summary Judgment on Successor Liability Based on De Facto Merger and Assumption Liabilities, MBIA v. Countrywide, doc no 3645
R-830 MBIA’s motion for partial summary judgment was denied in part and granted in part. 34 Misc. 3d 895, 936 N.Y.S.2d 513.
R-831 Crotty opinion Syncora v. EMCR-832 First Department has upheld the portion of Justice Bransten’s opinion rejecting
Countrywide’s loss causation theoryR-934 09/21/2011 Hearing Transcript (Pauley, Retirement Board v. BNYM, SDNY, Case No.
11CIV5459)R-935 11/03/2011 Hearing Transcript (Pauley, Retirement Board v. BNYM, SDNY, Case No.
11CIV5459)R-1051 08/24/2010 MBIA Insurance Corporation v. Countrywide Home Loans, Ins. et al., Amended
Complaint (Index No. 08/602825)R-1052 06/07/2010 FTC v. Countrywide, Complaint (CV104193)R-1053 11/26/2007 Ark. Teachers Ret. Sys. v. Mozilo, Complaint, No. 07-cv-06923 (C.D. Cal.)
Excerpt Page 7 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1054 Argent Classic Conv. Arb. Fund L.P. v. Countrywide Fin. Corp., No. 07-cv-07097 (C.D. Cal.)
R-1055 1/25/2008 N.Y.C. Emp. Ret. Sys. v. Countrywide Fin. Corp., Complaint, No. 08-cv-00492 (C.D. Cal.)
R-1056 2/15/2008 In re Countrywide Fin. Corp. Deriv. Litig., Complaint, No. 07-cv-06923 (C.D. Cal.)
R-1057 4/11/2008 In re Countrywide Fin. Corp. Sec. Litig., Complaint, No. 07-cv-05295 (C.D. Cal.)
R-1065 12/3/2012 Expert Report of J.F. Morrow (ResCap)R-1067 12/27/2010 AllState Insurance Co. et al. v. Countrywide Financial Corp. et al. Complaint
(http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/business/20110428-docs/allstate.pdf)
R-1068 09/08/2011 Ambac Assurance Corp et al. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., Countrywide Securities Corp., Countrywide Financial Corp. (n.k.a. Bank of America Home Loans), and Bank of America Corp., Index No. 651612/2010 Complaint (http://www.ambac.com/pdfs/DocumentDisplayServlet.pdf)
R-1069 3/24/2010 Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Countrywide Financial Corp. et al complaint (http://www.mass.gov/ago/docs/press/2010/2010-03-24-countrywide-agreement -attachement-3.pdf)
R-1073 5/23/2012 Deposition of Joe Price in MBIA Ins. Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., Index. No. 602825/2008 (May 23, 2012)
R-1123 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Assured Guaranty Corp. v. EMC Mortgage Corp.10-5367 SDNY
R-1123A 7/14/2010 Assured Guaranty Corp. v. EMC Mortgage Corp.10-5367 SDNY Complaint
R-1123B 11/18/2010 Assured Guaranty Corp. v. EMC Mortgage Corp.10-5367 SDNY Amended Complaint
R-1124 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Assured Guaranty Corp. v. DB Structured Products, Inc., et al. 651824/2010 NY St. Sup. Ct.
R-1124A Assured Guaranty Corp. v. DB Structured Products, Inc., et al. 651824/2010 NY St. Sup. Ct. Summons
R-1124B Assured Guaranty Corp. v. DB Structured Products, Inc., et al. 651824/2010 NY St. Sup. Ct. Complaint
R-1125 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Insurance Co v. IndyMac Bank, F.S.B. 08-cv-6010 SDNY
Excerpt Page 8 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1125A 7/1/2008 Financial Guaranty Insurance Co v. IndyMac Bank, F.S.B. 08-cv-6010 SDNY - Complaint
R-1126 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Morgan Stanley, et al. NY Supreme Ct- Westchester County 29951-2010
R-1126A 2/2/2011 MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Morgan Stanley, et al. NY Supreme Ct- Westchester County 29951-2010 Summons and Complaint
R-1127 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in PMI Mortgage Insurance Co. v. IndyMac Federal Bank, F.S.B. cv-09-3867 Cent. Dis. Cal.
R-1127A PMI Mortgage Insurance Co. v. IndyMac Federal Bank, F.S.B. cv-09-3867 Cent. Dis. Cal. Complaint
R-1128 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Radian Insurance Inc. v. Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. Inc., et al.
R-1128A 6/23/2009 Radian Insurance Inc. v. Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. Inc., et al. No. 08-cv-2993 ED Penn. First Amended Complaint
R-1129 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. FDIC as conservator and receiver for IndyMac Federal Bank F.S.B. 09-01016 DDC
R-1129A 5/29/2009 Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. FDIC as conservator and receiver for IndyMac Federal Bank F.S.B. 09-01016 DDC Complaint
R-1130 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Bank of the West v. UBS AG, et al. Cal sup. Ct. CGC-09-489590
R-1131 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Bear Stearns Mortgage Funding Trust 2007-AR2, by Wells Fargo, N.A., as Trustee v. EMC Mortgage Corp.
R-1131A 1/18/2011 Bear Stearns Mortgage Funding Trust 2007-AR2, by Wells Fargo, N.A., as Trustee v. EMC Mortgage Corp. Verified complaint
R-1132 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Ambac Assurance Corp. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. 08-Civ-9464
R-1132A 11/5/2008 Ambac Assurance Corp. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. 08-Civ-9464 Complaint
R-1133 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in PMI Mortgage Insurance Co. v. WMC Mortgage Corp., et al. LA county Superior ct. BC381972
R-1134 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Lone Star Fund V (U.S.), LP, et al. v. Barclays Bank PLC, et al. 08-cv-261-l USDC N.D. Tex.
Excerpt Page 9 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1134A Lone Star Fund V (U.S.), LP, et al. v. Barclays Bank PLC, et al. 08-cv-261-l USDC N.D. Tex. Notice of Removal and Original petition (no. 08-00398 Dist. Ct. Dallas County Tex.)
R-1135 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Republic Bank & Trust co. v. Bear, Stearns & Co., Inc., et al. 09-cv-287 WD Ken
R-1135A Republic Bank & Trust co. v. Bear, Stearns & Co., Inc., et al. 09-cv-287 WD Ken Notice of Removal and original Complaint (09-02885 Jefferson Cir. Ct.)
R-1136 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner and Smith, Inc., et al. NY Supreme Ct- NY County 09-601324
R-1136A MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner and Smith, Inc., et al. NY Supreme Ct- NY County 09-601324 summons and complaint
R-1137 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Ambac Assurance Corp. v. DLJ Mortgage Capital, Inc., et al. 600070
R-1137A 2/8/2010 Ambac Assurance Corp. v. DLJ Mortgage Capital, Inc., et al. No. 600070, Summons and Complaint
R-1137B 5/14/2010 Ambac Assurance Corp. v. DLJ Mortgage Capital, Inc., et al. No. 600070, Amended Complaint
R-1138 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Credit Suisse Sec. (USA) LLC, et al. 603751-2009 NY St. Sup. Ct.
R-1138A 2/11/2010 MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Credit Suisse Sec. (USA) LLC, et al. 603751-2009 NY St. Sup. Ct. No. Summons and complaint
R-1139 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. FDIC as conservator and receiver for IndyMac Federal Bank F.S.B.
R-1140 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. GMAC Mortgage, LLC NY Supreme Ct- NY County 600837-2010
R-1140A MBIA Insurance Corp. v. GMAC Mortgage, LLC NY Supreme Ct- NY County 600837-2010 Summons and Complaint
R-1141 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. IndyMac ABS, Inc., et al. CA Superior Court- LA County BC422358
R-1142 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner and Smith Inc. and Merrill Lynch Int'l NY Supreme Ct- NY County 09-601324
R-1143 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Residential Funding Co., LLC NY Supreme Ct- NY County 603552-2008
Excerpt Page 10 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1143A 3/19/2010 MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Residential Funding Co., LLC NY Supreme Ct- NY County 603552-2008 First Amended complaint
R-1144 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. 09-03106 SDNY
R-1144A 3/31/2009 Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. 09-03106 SDNY complaint
R-1145 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. 10-00749 SDNY
R-1145A 2/1/2010 Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. 10-00749 SDNY Complaint
R-1146 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. FDIC as conservator and receiver for IndyMac Federal Bank F.S.B. 09-01016 DDC
R-1147 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. IndyMac Bank F.S.B. S.D.N.Y. 08-05842
R-1147A Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. IndyMac Bank F.S.B. S.D.N.Y. 08-05842 Complaint
R-1148 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Ambac Assurance Corp. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. 650421/2011
R-1148A 7/18/2011 Ambac Assurance Corp. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. 650421/2011 first amended complaint
R-1149 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. DB Structured Products, Inc., et al. 650705/2010
R-1149A 6/23/2010 Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. DB Structured Products, Inc., et al. 650705/2010 Summons and complaint
R-1150 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. Flagstar Bank, FSB, et al. 11-cv-2375 SDNY
R-1150A 2/6/2013 Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. Flagstar Bank, FSB, et al. 11-cv-2375 SDNY Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and order
R-1150B 9/25/2012 Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. Flagstar Bank, FSB, et al. 11-cv-2375 SDNY Memorandum (892 f supp 596 (2012))
R-1150C 8/19/2011 Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. Flagstar Bank, FSB, et al. 11-cv-2375 SDNY First amended complaint
R-1151 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. v. FDIC as receiver for IndyMac Bank, et al. 09-3852
Excerpt Page 11 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1151A 5/29/2009 Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. v. FDIC as receiver for IndyMac Bank, et al. 09-3852 Complaint
R-1152 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in TIAA v. Deutsche Bank AG, et al. Case no. 11-cv-5141 SDNY
R-1152A 2/4/2013 TIAA v. Deutsche Bank AG, et al. Case no. 11-cv-5141 SDNY Amended Complaint
R-1153 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Oklahoma Police Pension Retirement System v. U.S. Bank, NA SDNY 11-cv-8066
R-1153A 3/30/2012 Oklahoma Police Pension Retirement System v. U.S. Bank, NA SDNY 11-cv-8066 Corrected Second Amended Class Action Complaint
R-1154 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MASTR Asset Backed Securities Trust 2006- HE3, by U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION v. WMC Mortgage Corp. et al. No. 11-cv-2542
R-1154A MASTR Asset Backed Securities Trust 2006- HE3, by U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION v. WMC Mortgage Corp. et al. No. 11-cv-2542 complaint and Jury demand
R-1155 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in The Charles Schwab Corp. v. J.P. Morgan Securities, et al. (II) Cal. Sup. Ct. CGC-10-503207
R-115A 8/2/2010 The Charles Schwab Corp. v. J.P. Morgan Securities, et al. (II) Cal. Sup. Ct. CGC-10-503207 Amended Complaint for rescission and Damages
R-1156 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. IndyMac Bank, F.S.B., et al. D. D.C. 09-01011
R-1156A 5/29/2009 MBIA Insurance Corp. v. IndyMac Bank, F.S.B., et al. D. D.C. 09-01011 COMPLAINT
R-1157 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in United States of America v. Deutsche Bank AG, et al. Case No 11-civ-2976 SDNY
R-1157A 8/22/2011 United States of America v. Deutsche Bank AG, et al. Case No 11-civ-2976 SDNY Amended complaint
R-1158 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Impac Funding Corp., et al. No. 11-cv-30127 USDC Mass.
R-1158A 5/6/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Impac Funding Corp., et al. No. 11-cv-30127 USDC Mass. Complaint
R-1159 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in King County, et al. v. IKB Deutsche Industribank AG, et al. 09-cv-8387 SDNY
Excerpt Page 12 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1159A 6/10/2010 King County, et al. v. IKB Deutsche Industribank AG, et al. King County, et al. v. IKB Deutsche Industribank AG, et al. 09-cv-8387 SDNY First Amended consolidated complaint for violations of new york state law
R-1160 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Dexia SA/NV, et al. v. Merrill Lynch & Co., et al. 12-cv-4032
R-1160A 5/22/2012 Dexia SA/NV, et al. v. Merrill Lynch & Co., et al. 12-cv-4032 Notice of Removal and original complaint (651000/2012 NY St. Sup. Ct.)
R-1161 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in DB Structured Products, Inc. v. GreenPoint Mortgage Funding, Inc. N.Y. Sup. Ct. 590783-2010
R-1162 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Deutsche Bank National Trust Co., Solely as Trustee for Morgan Stanley ABS Capital I Inc. Trust 2006-WMC2 v. WMC Mortgage LLC, et al. 12/cv-933 (USDC Conn.)
R-1162A 6/25/2012 Deutsche Bank National Trust Co., Solely as Trustee for Morgan Stanley ABS Capital I Inc. Trust 2006-WMC2 v. WMC Mortgage LLC, et al. 12/cv-933 (USDC Conn.) Complaint
R-1163 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Clark v. Lender Processing Services, Inc.12-cv-2187 ND Ohio eastern div
R-1163A 8/27/2012 Clark v. Lender Processing Services, Inc.12-cv-2187 ND Ohio eastern div Notice of Removal
R-1164 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Bayerische Landesbank v. Bear Stearns & Co., Inc., et al. S.D.N.Y. 653239-2011
R-1164A 3/20/2012 Bayerische Landesbank v. Bear Stearns & Co., Inc., et al. S.D.N.Y. 653239-2011 Amended complaint
R-1165 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Bayerische Landesbank v. Morgan Stanley, et al. 653239/2011
R-1165A 3/20/2012 Bayerische Landesbank v. Morgan Stanley, et al. 653239/2011 Amended Complaint
R-1166 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Bayerische Landesbank v. Merrill Lynch & Co. et al. 651480-2012
R-1166A 5/2/2012 Bayerische Landesbank v. Merrill Lynch & Co. et al. 651480-2012 complaint
R-1167 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in FHFA as Conservator of the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp, on behalf of the Trustee of the Morgan Stanley ABS Capital I Inc. Trust, Series 2006-HE6 v. HSBC Finance Corp., et al. 653373/2012
Excerpt Page 13 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1167A 10/19/2012 FHFA as Conservator of the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp, on behalf of the Trustee of the Morgan Stanley ABS Capital I Inc. Trust, Series 2006-HE6 v. HSBC Finance Corp., et al. 653373/2012 Notice of Removal and Original summons and Notice
R-1168 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. v. FDIC as receiver for Washington Mutual Bank, et al. 09-cv-1656
R-1168A 9/8/2010 Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. v. FDIC as receiver for Washington Mutual Bank, et al. 09-cv-1656 Amended Complaint
R-1169 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Credit Suisse First Boston Mortgage Securities, Inc., et al. 11-cv-30048 USDC Mass.
R-1169A 2/25/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Credit Suisse First Boston Mortgage Securities, Inc., et al. 11-cv-30048 USDC Mass. No. 11-cv-30048
R-1170 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. DB Structured Products, Inc., et al. 11-cv-30039 USDC Mass.
R-1170A 2/29/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. DB Structured Products, Inc., et al. 11-cv-30039 USDC Mass. First Amended Complaint
R-1171 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Cambridge Place Investment Management v. Morgan Stanley & Co, Inc., et al. (II) Commonwealth of Mass. 11-00555 (D.Mass 11-cv-10992)
R-1171A 6/3/2011 Cambridge Place Investment Management v. Morgan Stanley & Co, Inc., et al. (II) Commonwealth of Mass. 11-00555 (D.Mass 11-cv-10992) Notice of Removal
R-1171B 2/11/2011 Cambridge Place Investment Management v. Morgan Stanley & Co, Inc., et al. (II) Commonwealth of Mass. 11-00555 (D.Mass 11-cv-10992) Original Complaint (11-0555 commonwealth of Mass)
R-1172 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Residential Funding Co., LLC, et al. 11-cv-30035 USDC Mass.
R-1172A 2/9/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Residential Funding Co., LLC, et al. 11-cv-30035 USDC Mass. Complaint
R-1173 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. RBS Financial Products, Inc., et al. 11-cv-30044
Excerpt Page 14 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1173A 2/24/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. RBS Financial Products, Inc., et al. 11-cv-30044 Complaint
R-1174 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. DLJ Mortgage Capital, Inc., et al. 11-cv-30047
R-1174A 2/25/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. DLJ Mortgage Capital, Inc., et al. 11-cv-30047 Complaint
R-1175 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., et al. 11-cv-30094
R-1175A 4/8/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., et al. 11-cv-30094 complaint
R-1176 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Goldman Sachs Mortgage Co., et al. 11-cv-30126
R-1176A 5/5/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Goldman Sachs Mortgage Co., et al. 11-cv-30126 Complaint
R-1177 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. HSBC Bank USA, N.A., et al. 11-cv-30141
R-1177A 5/5/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. HSBC Bank USA, N.A., et al. 11-cv-30141 Complaint
R-1178 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC N.Y. Sup. Ct. 651566-2011
R-1178A 6/24/2011 Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC N.Y. Sup. Ct. 651566-2011 First Amended Complaint
R-1179 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in CIFG Assurance North America, Inc. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co., et al. 652286/2011
R-1179A 8/16/2011 CIFG Assurance North America, Inc. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co., et al. 652286/2011 Complaint
R-1180 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. DLJ Mortgage Capital Inc., et al. 652837/2011
R-1180A 10/17/2011 Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. DLJ Mortgage Capital Inc., et al. 652837/2011 Complaint
R-1181 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Residential Funding Company LLC, et al.(I) S.D.N.Y. 11-09736
R-1181A 12/30/2011 Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Residential Funding Company LLC, et al.(I) S.D.N.Y. 11-09736 Notice of removal and Original Summons and Complaint (653303/2011)
Excerpt Page 15 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1182 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Residential Funding Company LLC, et al.(II) S.D.N.Y. 11-09736
R-1183 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. GMAC Mortgage, LLC, et al. 11-cv-9729
R-1183A 3/30/2012 Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. GMAC Mortgage, LLC, et al. 11-cv-9729 Amended Complaint
R-1184 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Ally Financial Inc., et al. 12-1601
R-1184A 3/5/2012 Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Ally Financial Inc., et al. 12-1601 Complaint
R-1185 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Allstate Insurance Co., et al. v. ACE Securities Corp., et al. 650431/2011
R-1185A 9/23/2011 Allstate Insurance Co., et al. v. ACE Securities Corp., et al. 650431/2011 Amended complaint
R-1186 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Allstate Insurance Co., et al. v. Credit Suisse Securities (USA), LLC, et al. 650547/2011
R-1186A 11/16/2011 Allstate Insurance Co., et al. v. Credit Suisse Securities (USA), LLC, et al. 650547/2011 Amended Complaint
R-1187 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Allstate Insurance Co., et al. v. Morgan Stanley, et al. 651840/2011
R-1187A 9/9/2011 Allstate Insurance Co., et al. v. Morgan Stanley, et al. 651840/2011 amended complaint
R-1188 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Allstate Insurance Co., et al. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co., et al. 652273/2011
R-1188A 8/15/2011 Allstate Insurance Co., et al. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co., et al. 652273/2011 Summons and complaint
R-1189 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee Inc. v. EMC Mortgage LLC et al. N.Y. Sup. Ct. 650420-2012
R-1189A 2/14/2012 Syncora Guarantee Inc. v. EMC Mortgage LLC et al. N.Y. Sup. Ct. 650420-2012 Summons and complaint
R-1190 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Ally Financial Inc., et al. 12-1818
R-1190A 3/12/2012 Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Ally Financial Inc., et al. 12-1818 Complaint
Excerpt Page 16 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1191 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in HSH Nordbank AG et al. v. Barclays Bank PLC et al. 652678/2011
R-1191A 4/2/2012 HSH Nordbank AG et al. v. Barclays Bank PLC et al. 652678/2011 Consolidated Complaint
R-1192 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Ally Financial Inc., et al. 12-CIV-0780
R-1192A Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Ally Financial Inc., et al. 12-CIV-0780 Complaint
R-1193 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Assured Guaranty Corp. v. EMC Mortgage LLC, et al. Index No. 650805/2012 NY St. Sup. Ct.
R-1193A 3/15/2012 Assured Guaranty Corp. v. EMC Mortgage LLC, et al. Index No. 650805/2012 NY St. Sup. Ct Complaint
R-1194 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Ambac Assurance Corp. v. EMC Mortgage LLC et al. N.Y. Sup. Ct. 650805-2012
R-1195 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Dexia SA/NV, et al. v. Deutsche Bank AG, et al. 11-civ-5672
R-1195A 8/15/2011 Dexia SA/NV, et al. v. Deutsche Bank AG, et al. 11-civ-5672 Notice of Removal
R-1196 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee, Inc. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., et al. NY Supreme Ct- NY County 650042-2009
R-1197 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in United Guaranty Mortgage Indemnity Co. v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al.
R-1198 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Thrivent Financial For Lutherans, et al. v. Countrywide Financial Corp, et al. 27-cv-11-5830
R-1198A 4/17/2011 Thrivent Financial For Lutherans, et al. v. Countrywide Financial Corp, et al. 27-cv-11-5830
R-1199 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Sealink Funding Ltd v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al. 652679/2011 NY Sup Ct.
R-1199A 9/29/2011 Sealink Funding Ltd v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al. 652679/2011 NY Sup Ct. Summons and complaint
R-1200 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Bayerische Landesbank v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al.
R-1201 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Ambac Assurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, et al. 651013/2012
Excerpt Page 17 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1201A 8/14/2012 Ambac Assurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, et al. 651013/2012 First amended complaint
R-1202 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Insurance Co v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., et al. 650736/2009 NY St. Sup. Ct.
R-1202A 4/30/2012 Financial Guaranty Insurance Co v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., et al. 650736/2009 NY St. Sup. Ct. First amended complaint
R-1203 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., et al.
R-1204 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in USA ex rel. Kyle Laglow v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al. E.D.N.Y. 09-02040
R-1204A 5/13/2009 USA ex rel. Kyle Laglow v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al. E.D.N.Y. 09-02040 Complaint and jury demand
R-1205 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Walnut Place, LLC, et al. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., et al. 650497/2011 NY St. Sup. Ct.
R-1205A 4/12/2011 Walnut Place, LLC, et al. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., et al. 650497/2011 NY St. Sup. Ct. 650497/2011
R-1206 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Bank Hapoalim BM v. Bank of America Corp. 12-cv-4316
R-1206A 8/24/2012 Bank Hapoalim BM v. Bank of America Corp. 12-cv-4316 Amended Complaint
R-1207 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al. No. 11-cv-30215
R-1207A 11/30/2011 Mass. Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al. No. 11-cv-30215 First amended complaint
R-1208 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in US Bank N.A. v. Countrywide Home Loans, et al. 11-cv-6223 (652388)
R-1208A 8/29/2011 US Bank N.A. v. Countrywide Home Loans, et al. 11-cv-6223 (652388) Ex. D Re-underwriting report
R-1209 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Bank of America, N.A., et al. No. 11-4363
R-1209A 12/1/2011 Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Bank of America, N.A., et al. No. 11-4363 Complaint
R-1210 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Ins. Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. et al., Index No. 08/602825
Excerpt Page 18 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1210A 8/24/2009 MBIA Ins. Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. et al., Index No. 08/602825 Amended Complaint
R-1211 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans (N.Y. Sup. Ct.) 602825/2008
R-1212 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Ambac Assurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans (N.Y. Sup. Ct.) 651612/2010
R-1212A 5/6/2010 Ambac Assurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans (N.Y. Sup. Ct.) 651612/2010 Amended Complaint
R-1213 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Financial Guaranty Ins. Co. v. Countrywide Home Loans (N.Y. Sup. Ct.) 650736/2009
R-1214 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee Inc. v. Countrywide Home Loans (N.Y. Sup. Ct.) 650042/2009
R-1214A 5/6/2010 Syncora Guarantee Inc. v. Countrywide Home Loans (N.Y. Sup. Ct.) 650042/2009 Amended complaint
R-1215 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. Flagstar Bank (S.D.N.Y.) Case No. 11-2375 JSR
R-1216 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Syncora Guarantee Inc. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. (S.D.N.Y.) Case No. 09-3106 PAC
R-1216A 3/31/2009 Syncora Guarantee Inc. v. EMC Mortgage Corp. (S.D.N.Y.) Case No. 09-3106 PAC complaint
R-1217 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in United Guaranty v. Countrywide (C.D. Cal) Case No. 09-1888
R-1217A 3/16/2009 United Guaranty v. Countrywide (C.D. Cal) Case No. 09-1888 Complaint
R-1218 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in US Bank v. Countrywide (N.Y. Sup. Ct.) 652388/2011
R-1332 05/26/2011 Complaint filed in Knights of Columbus v. The Bank of New York Mellon, Index No. 651442/2011 (N.Y. Sup. N.Y. County)
Index No. 651442/2011 NYSCEF Doc. No. 1-1
Excerpt Page 19 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1333 08/16/2011 Amended Complaint filed in Knights of Columbus v. The Bank of New York Mellon, Index No. 651442/2011 (N.Y. Sup. N.Y. County) and exhibits
Index No. 651442/2011 NYSCEF Doc. Nos. 20, 21, 21-1, 21-2, 21-3, 21-4
R-1334 05/28/2013 Second Amended Complaint filed in Knights of Columbus v. The Bank of New York Mellon, Index No. 651442/2011 (N.Y. Sup. N.Y. County)
R-1335 04/26/2013 Decision and Order entered in Knights of Columbus v. The Bank of New York Mellon, Index No. 651442/2011 (N.Y. Sup. N.Y. County) denying in part and granting in part defendant The Bank of New York Mellon's Motion to Dismiss
Index No. 651442/2011 NYSCEF Doc. No. 45
R-1336 04/25/2012 Transcript of hearing on the Motion to Dismiss filed by The Bank of New York Mellon in Knights of Columbus v. The Bank of New York Mellon, Index No. 651442/2011 (N.Y. Sup. N.Y. County)
R-1337 10/24/2011 Motion to Dismiss and Stay filed by The Bank of New York Mellon in Knights of Columbus v. The Bank of New York Mellon, Index No. 651442/2011 (N.Y. Sup. N.Y. County)
Index No. 651442/2011 NYSCEF Doc. No. 24, 25, 26
R-1338 11/18/2011 The Knights of Columbus's opposition to the Motion to Dismiss and Stay filed in Knights of Columbus v. The Bank of New York Mellon, Index No. 651442/2011 (N.Y. Sup. N.Y. County)
Index No. 651442/2011 NYSCEF Doc. No. 28, 29, 30, 31, 32
R-1339 12/06/2011 Reply filed by The Bank of New York Mellon in support of its motion to dismiss in Knights of Columbus v. The Bank of New York Mellon, Index No. 651442/2011 (N.Y. Sup. N.Y. County)
Index No. 651442/2011 NYSCEF Doc. No. 38,
R-1340 04/04/2013 Adelson deposition excerpts in 1:11-cv-05459-WHP ("WHP case")R-1341 11/21/2008 Email Bartholomew to Naughton-Carr RE: Privilege w/ Pillsbury letter ("Adelson 4") BNYM_PF_0016489
8-902 ConfidentialR-1342 01/16/2009 Email Fairweather to Bartholomew et al re Privileged w/ FannieMae letter ("Adelson
7")BNYM_PF_00162918-23 Confidential
R-1343 05/21/2008 Bank of America Corp Amendment #3 to Form S-4 Excerpts ("Adelson 9")R-1344 03/25/2009 Email Hermann to Crosson et al re Fw: CWEQ 2006-S7 Mortgage Insurance
Questions ("Adelson 15")BNYM_PF_00159037-43 Confidential
R-1345 06/03/2009 Email Adelson to Hermann re Privileged ("Adelson 16") BNYM_PF_00162882-90 Confidential
Excerpt Page 20 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1346 06/03/2009 Email Hermann to Crosson re Fw: CWEQ, Serie 2006-S1 through S7 w/ BNYM(FT Partners) ("Adelson 17")
BNYM_PF_00150855-59 Confidential
R-1347 4/1/2013 Bartholomew deposition excerpts in WHP caseR-1348 10/27/2008 CWABS Monthly Distribution Summary ("Bartholomew 9")R-1349 09/22/2008 Email Cerchio to Chrysanthis w/ Notification Procedures ("Bartholomew 14") BNYM_PF_0007846
4-78 ConfidentialR-1350 02/11/2009 Email Bartholomew to Cerchio re Fw: Monitoring and Tracking - Tape Cracking
Spreadsheet ABS & MBS - BNYM as Back Up Servicer - January 2009 ("Bartholomew 15")
BNYM_PF_00072674-78
ConfidentialR-1351 06/10/2008 Email Bartholomew to Tadie et al Re: Freddie Mac/Countrywide ("Bartholomew 18") BNYM_PF_0009655
4-55 ConfidentialR-1352 11/06/2008 Email Bartholomew to Hermann re Privileged w/ FannieMae letter ("Bartholomew
19")BNYM_PF_00159928-31 Confidential
R-1353 no date Pooling and Service Agreement: CWALT 2006-OA3 ("Bartholomew 27")R-1354 no date Schedule III-A CWALT 2006-OA3 Excerpts ("Bartholomew 28")R-1355 5/12/2008 Syncora letter (redacted) ("Bartholomew 30") BNYM_PF_0013833
7-72 ConfidentialR-1356 07/11/2008 Email Kurzban to Bartholomew et al Re Fw: Countrywide Outstanding Repurchase
Requests ("Bartholomew 33")BNYM_PF_00052765-66 Confidential
R-1357 06/19/2008 Email Bartholomew to Cerchio et al re: Issues List ("Bartholomew 34") BNYM_PF_00157702-04 Confidential
R-1358 08/11/2008 Email Martinez to Finkenberg et al re Privileged w/ MBIA letter ("Bartholomew 41") BNYM_PF_00157363-72 Confidential
R-1359 04/09/2013 Feig deposition excerpts in WHP caseR-1360 03/19/2009 United Guaranty Mortgage Complaint, Case No. 2:09-cv-01888 ("Feig 1")R-1361 05/15/2008 NY Times Article: Judge Says Countrywide Officers Must Face Suit by Shareholders
("Feig 2")R-1362 7/1/2008 NYT Article: Countrywide whistleblower reports 'liar loans' ("Feig 3")R-1363 6/4/2009 Time Business Article: Is Mozillo's Crime the Liar Loans - or the Lie?("Feig 4")
R-1364 12/9/2009 Email Patton to Chase et al re Fannie Mae Documents w/ attachments ("Feig 5") BNYM_PF_00144664-85 Confidential
R-1365 3/17/2009 Email Hermann to Fudali et al re Fw: Fannie Mae/BoNY/Countrywide - Letter of direction (D&L Comments) w/ Fannie Mae letter draft ("Feig 6")
BNYM_PF_00162902-09 Confidential
R-1366 6/1/2009 Email Hermann to Crowley et al re Privileged w/ attachments ("Feig 7") BNYM_PF_00150083-96 Confidential
Excerpt Page 21 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1367 10/14/2008 Countrywide Form 8-K ("Feig 8")R-1368 7/31/2008 BNYM Del. Complaint Case No. 3935 ("Feig 9")R-1369 8/18/2008 BNYM Del. Memo ("Feig 10")R-1370 5/2/2008 Email Brown to Price et al re FW: S&P downgrade and press release on Countrywide
due to BAC S4/A filing ("Feig 11")BACMBIA-O0000038664-66
R-1371 7/8/2008 Countrywide Form 8-K ("Feig 12")R-1372 11/7/2008 BoA Form 8-K ("Feig 13")R-1373 10/3/2008 Countrywide Action by Unanimous Written Consent of Directors in Lieu of Meeting
of Directors ("Feig 14")BACMBIA-C0000168521-42
R-1374 10/14/2008 Countrywide Action by Unanimous Written Consent of Directors in Lieu of Meeting of Directors ("Feig 15")
CWMBIA-G0000196813-26
R-1375 10/23/2008 Email Wagner to Kurzban et al re CWHEQ 2006-S1, Redacted w/ attachments ("Feig 20")
BNYM_PF_00150490-550 Confidential
R-1376 5/15/2013 Scrivener deposition excerpts in WHP case*R-1377 Scrivener confidential exhibits*R-1378 12/31/2010 BoA SEC Form 10-K Excerpts ("Scrivener 4")R-1379 12/31/2012 BoA SEC Form 10-K Excerpts ("Scrivener 10")R-1380 6/22/2006 Minutes of the Meeting of the Credit Risk Management Committee ("Scrivener 13") CFC2007C006790-96
R-1381 1/25/2007 Email McMurray to Ling et al re MD&A Credit Risk ("Scrivener 15") NYF-SEC 031534-39
R-1382 3/3/2009 Email Baker to Schloessmann et al re Materials for tomorrow morning's R&W/Monoline Meeting w/ attachments ("Scrivener 21")
BACMBIA-X0000006465-506
R-1383 Schloessmann deposition excerpts in WHP case*R-1384 Schloessmann confidential exhibits*R-1385 07/10/2009 Email Baker to Schloessmann et al re Key Ops Deliverables w/ attachment
("Schloessmann 72")CWMBIA0018625735-38
R-1386 12/06/2007 Countrywide Internal Audit Review of Enterprise Wide Asset Securitization ("Schloessmann 75")
CWMBIA0015978401-15
R-1387 11/12/2008 Email Welsh to Sands et al re Fw: Brucker Meeting Follow Up Items ("Schloessmann 76")
BACMBIA-X0000271172-79
R-1388 02/10/2010 Email Schloessmann to Welsh et al re: New Securitization Activity ("Schloessmann 77")
BACMBIA-X0000201139-41
R-1389 09/30/2010 Countrywide Minutes of Special Joint Meeting of BOD ("Schloessmann 78") BACMBIA-X0000099611-14
Excerpt Page 22 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-1390 07/02/2008 Master Services Agreement ("Schloessmann 79") BACMBIA-C0000161203-15
R-1391 Civil Docket for SEC v. Mozilo, Case No. 2:09-cv-03994R-1391A 06/04/2009 SEC v. Mozilo, Case No. 2:09-cv-03994 Complaint
R-1391B 08/16/2010 SEC v. Mozilo, Case No. 2:09-cv-03994 DKT 255-6 Ex. 220
R-1391C 08/16/2010 SEC v. Mozilo, Case No. 2:09-cv-03994 DKT 257-5 Ex. 220
R-1391D 08/16/2010 SEC v. Mozilo, Case No. 2:09-cv-03994 DKT 279-18 Ex. 109
R-1391E 08/16/2010 SEC v. Mozilo, Case No. 2:09-cv-03994 DKT 283-2 Ex. 118
R-1392 03/12/2012 Supplemental Consent Judgment in FTC v. Countrywide Home Loans, Case No. 10-4193-JFW-SSX (C.D. Cal.), available at http://www.ftc.gov/os/caselist/0823205/120209countrywideorder.pdf
R-1393 02/23/2011 Complaint in Walnut Place et al. v. Countrywide Home Loans et al., Index No. 650497/11
R-1394 08/02/2011 Complaint in Walnut Place et al. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. et al., Index No. 652146/11
R-1395 08/29/2011 Complaint in U.S. Bank National Association, as Trustee for Harborview Mortgage Loan Trust, Series 2005-10 v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. et al.
R-1396 02/27/2011 Expert Report of Steven Butler in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. et al.
R-1397 12/18/2012 Complaint in Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust, Series 2006-RM4 and RM5 v. Merrill Lynch Mortgage Lending, Inc. et al.
R-1398 04/07/2011 Complaint in Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. v. Flagstar Bank FSBR-1408 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in In re Residential Capital, LLC, et
al. 12-12020R-1408A 10/05/0212 In re Residential Capital, LLC, et al. 12-12020, Steering Committee Investors'
Statement In Support of Settlement and Response to Settlement Objections (Doc. No. 1739)
R-1412 11/19/2008 Minutes of Special Meeting of Board of Directors of BoA BACMBIA-W0000001964 - 74R-4060 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Luther v. Countrywide Financial
Corp. Cal State Ct. BC 380698 (12-cv-5125)R-4060A Luther v. Countrywide Financial Corp. Cal State Ct. BC 380698 (12-cv-5125)
Consolidated Complaint
Excerpt Page 23 of 24
Hrg. Ex. No.
Dep. Ex. No. Date Description Bates Confidential/AEO
R-4061 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Maine State Retirement Sys v. Countrywide Fin. USDC Cen. Dist. Cal. Case. No. 10-cv-302
R-4061A 6/6/2011 Maine State Retirement Sys v. Countrywide Fin. USDC Cen. Dist. Cal. Case. No. 10-cv-302 Third amended class complaint
R-4062 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in Cambridge Place Invest v. Morgan Stanley & Co. (commonwealth of Mass. No. 10-2741)
R-4062A 7/9/2010 Cambridge Place Invest v. Morgan Stanley & Co. (commonwealth of Mass. No. 10-2741) Complaint and jury demand
R-4063 Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in In re IndyMac Mortgage-Backed Securities Litigation (SDNY 09-civ-04583)
R-4063A 10/29/2009 In re IndyMac Mortgage-Backed Securities Litigation (SDNY 09-civ-04583) Amended Consolidated class action complaint for violations of the securities act of 1933Pleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in any other cases where an RMBS loan file review was conductedPleadings, orders, exhibits, and other papers filed in any other cases in which Countrywide or Bank of America is a Defendant for liabilities related to breaches of representations and warranties or servicing in RMBS.All documents produced under subpoena duces tecum served on William Frey May 20, 2013 in this proceedingTranscripts of any testimony given under oath by any witness appearing in this proceeding
Excerpt Page 24 of 24
~~ss~
REILLYPOZNERLLPA LITIGATION &TRIAL PRACTICE
August 15, 2012
Vin E-Filing and Facsimile
The Honorable Baxbara R. KapnickSupreme Court of the State of New York60 Centre StreetNew York, New York 10007
Re: In re the application of The Bank of New York Mellon(Index No. 651786/2011) ("Article 77 Litigation")
Dear Justice Kapnick:
Daniel M. ReillyTel: 303-893-6100dre i l l y~a~,rp I aw. c om
Enclosed please find a letter submitted by the members of the Steering Committee to
Justice Bransten in MBIA Insurance Corp. v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., et al. (Index No.
602825/2008).
Plaintiff MBIA recently submitted a request to Justice Bransten to remove the
"Confidential" designation from several categories of documents exchanged between MBIA and
Bank of America/Countrywide in that case. The Steering Committee submitted the enclosed
letter to Justice Bransten to support MBIA's request to de-designate those documents so that they
may be publicly filed.
Public access to these documents would streamline discovery in the Article 77
proceeding. Many of the issues that have been litigated in the MBIA litigation relate to Bank of
AmericaJCountrywide's liability for its residential mortgage backed securities and are similar or
identical to disputed issues before Your Honor. Accordingly, if the documents in the MBIA
litigation are made available, it would likely reduce the burden on the parties and the Court in the
Article 77 proceeding.
ectfully submitted,
~~
Daniel M. Reilly
Enclosures
cc: All counsel
1900 SIXTEENTH STREET SUITE 1700 DENVER COLORADO 80202 rHOxs 303 893 6100 F~ 303 893 6110 www.rplaw.com
~.
REILLYPOZNERLLPA LITIGATION &TRIAL PRACTICE
August 15, 2012
Via E-Filing and Hand Delivery
The Honorable Eileen BranstenSupreme Court of the State of New York60 Centre StreetNew York, New York 10007
Re: MBIA Ins. Corp. v. Countywide Home Loans, Inc. et czl.(Index No. 602825/2008)
Dear Justice Bransten:
Daniel M. ReillyTel: 303-893-6100dreilly(c~rplaw.com
I represent American International Group, Inc. and its affiliates (collectively "AIG") in
the Article 77 proceeding currently pending before the Honorable Barbara R. Kapnick, captioned
In re the Application of The Bank of New York Mellon (Index No. 651786/2011) ("Article 77
Litigation"). Through the Article 77 Litigation, the Bank of New York Mellon ("Trustee") seeks
judicial approval of an $8.5 billion proposed settlement with Bank of America over liability
arising from 530 Countrywide-issued residential mortgage backed securities ("RMBS") trusts.
This proposed settlement is a matter of great public importance that will affect thousands of
investors who have holdings in those trusts.
The Intervenor-Respondents and Objectors in the Article 77 Litigation formed a Steering
Committee which consists of my firm, Keller Rohrback LLP, who represents the Federal Home
Loan Banks of Boston, Chicago, and Indianapolis, and Miller & Wrubel, P.C. The members of
the Steering Committee respectfully submit this letter in support of Plaintiff MBIA's Order to
Show Cause why confidentiality restrictions should not be removed from the following
categories of documents in this case: (1) party deposition transcripts; (2) documents used as
e~ibits in party depositions; (3) expert reports; (4) documents used as exhibits to expert reports;
and (5) materials relied upon by expert witnesses. (Order to Show Cause at 2.)
Removing the confidentiality restrictions on the documents would reduce the burdens and
costs on the parties in the Article 77 Litigation and would further the interests of judicial
economy. The documents in question could potentially provide RMBS investors in the 530
trusts with information concerning loan file integrity, putback liability, successor liability,
servicing deficiencies and resulting losses. That type of information would help investors (and
the court) evaluate the reasonableness of the $8.5 billion settlement amount, which is one of the
primary purposes of the Article 77 Litigation. In light of the number of investors implicated by
the proposed settlement, there is a clear public interest in the disclosure of additional facts that
will allow those investors to evaluate the reasonableness of the proposed settlement amount. The
1900 SIXTEENTH STREET SUITE 1700 DENVER COLORADO 80202 rxoNE 303 893 6100 Fnx 303 S93 6110 www.rplaw.com
~'
The Honorable Eileen BranstenAugust 15, 2012Page 2
documents subject to MBIA's request to remove confidentiality restrictions are therefore
important to both the Article 77 Litigation and the public more broadly.
For those reasons, the Steering Committee supports MBIA's request to lift the current
confidentiality restrictions and respectfully requests that this Court grant that request.
ectfully submitted,
•
Daniel M. ReillyOn Behalf of the Members of the Steering Committee
cc: The Honorable Barbara R. KapnickMatt Ingber, Esq.Kathy Patrick, Esq.
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
In the matter of the application of
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON (as Trustee under
various Pooling and Servicing Agreements and Indenture Trustee
under various Indentures), et al.
Petitioners,
for an order, pursuant to C.P.L.R. § 7701, seeking judicial
instructions and approval of a proposed settlement.
To: All counsel of record
Index No. 651786/2011
Assigned to: Kapnick, J.
NOTICE OF SUBPOENA
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that, pursuant to New York Civil Practice Law and Rules
3120(1)(1), the Steering Committee of Intervenor-Respondents and Objectors, by the undersigned
counsel, has requested that documents be produced by Bank of America Corporation at the
offices of Miller & Wrubel, 570 Lexington Avenue, New York, New York 10022 on or before
October 4, 2012.1
A copy of the subpoena is attached hereto as E~ibit A.
'The Steering Committee submits this Subpoena Duces Tecum to Bank of America Corporation
on behalf of all Respondents except: the Delaware Department of Justice; the New York State
Office of the Attorney General; the Federal Housing Finance Agency; the National Credit Union
Administration Board; the Maine State Retirement System; Pension Trust Fund for Operating
Engineers; Vermont Pension Investment Committee; the Washington State Plumbing and
Pipefitting Pension Trust; the Knights of Columbus and the other clients represented by Talcott
Franklin P.C.; Cranberry Park LLC; Cranberry Park II LLC; and Good Hill Partners LP.
955295
DATED: September 14, 2012
REILLY POZNER LLP
By:Daniel ReillyMichael Rollin1900 Sixteenth St., Suite 1700Denver, Colorado 80202Telephone: (303) 893-6100Fax: (303) [email protected]@rplaw.com
MILLER & WRUBEL P.C.
By: _ s/John G. MoonJohn G. MoonClaire L. Huene570 Lexington AvenueNew York, New York 10022Telephone: (212) 336-3500Fax: (212) [email protected]@mw-law.com
Attorneys for AIG Entities AttoNneys for the Triaxx Entities
KELLER ROHRBACK LLP
By: s/Derek W. LoeserDerek W. LoeserDavid J. Ko1201 Third Avenue, Suite 3200Seattle, Washington 98101Telephone: (206) 623-1900Fax: (206) 623-3384dloeser@kellerrohrback. comdko@kellerrohrback. com
Attorneys for Federal Home Loan
Banks of Boston, Chicago, andIndianapolis
-2-955295
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY QF NEW YORK
In the matter of the application of
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON (as Trustee under
various Pooling and Servicing Agreements and Indenture Trustee
under various Indentures), et al.
Petitioners,
for an order, pursuant to C.P.L.R. § 7701, seeking judicial
instructions and approval of a proposed settlement.
TO: Custodian of RecordsBank of America Corporation
One Bryant ParkNew York, New York 1OQ36
Index No. b51786/2011
Assigned to: Kapnick, J.
SUBPOENA DUCESTECUM (pursuant to
CPLR 3120(1)(1))
PURSUAl~TT TO CPLR 3120(1){i}, YOU ARE HEREBY C0~IMANDED to produce
and permit inspection and copying of records, documents, or objects requested in Exhibit A,
which is attached hereto, at the offices of Miller & ~~rubel, 570 Le~ngtan Avenue, New Yark,
New York 10022 on or before October 4, 2012.
YOU ARE FITRTHER COM~~1'IalYDED to produce a privilege log, if necessary and
appropriate, of any documents y ou withhold from this subpoena at the above-referenced date and
place. Each document entry on the privilege log must provide the following information: (1 }the
type of document; (2) the general subject matter of the document; {3) the date of the document;
{4) such other information as is sufficient to identify the document far a subpoena duces tecum;
and (5) the legal ground for withholding the document.
956023
The undersigned parties are issuing this subpoena because you are in possession of
documents relevant to the above-captioned matter which cannot be acquired from parties to this
action. i
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that pursuant to CPLR 2308(b), false swearing or failure to
comply with this subpoena is punishable as a contempt of court and shall make you liable to the
person on whose behalf this subpoena tivas issued for a penalty not to exceed fifty dollars and all
damages sustained by reason of your failure to comply.
1 The Steering Committee submits this Subpoena Duces Tecum to Bank of America, Corp. on behalf of
all Respondents except: the Delaware Department of Justice; the New York State Office of the Attorney
General; the Federal Housing Finance Agency; the National Credit Union Administration Board; the
Maine State Retirement System; Pension Trust Fund for Qperating Engineers; Vermont Pension
Investment Committee; the Washington State Plumbing and Pipefitting Pension Trust; the Knights of
Columbus and the other clients represented by Talcatt Franklin P.C.; Cranberry Park LLC; Cranberry
Fork II LLC; and Good Hill Partners LP.
2956023
DATED: September 14, 2012
REILLY POZNER LLP
By:Daniel Reilly1Vlichael Rollin1900 Sixteenth St., Suite 1700
Denver; Colorado 80202Telephone: (303) 893-6100
Fax: (303) [email protected]
MILLER & WRUBEL P.C.
By: s/John G. MoonJohn G. MoanClaire L. HueneX70 Lexin~ on AvenueNew York, New York 10022
Telephone: (212) 336-3500
Fax: {212} 336-3555Jmoonvm~~-la~~.comchuene@muT-la~T.com
Attorneys for ~4IG Entities ~ttor-neys,for the Triaxx Entities
KELLER ROHRBACK LLP
By: s/Derek ~'. Loeser
Derek W. Loeser
David J. Ko1201 Third Avenue, Suite 3200
Seattle, Washington 9& 101
Telephone: {206) 623-1900
Pax: {206) 623-3384
dloeser@kellerrohrback. com
~tt~rneys for Federal Horne Loan
Banks of Boston, Chicago, and
Indianapolis
3956023
FXHiRiT A
DEFI1vITIONS
"You," "Your," or "BofA," means Bank of America Corporation and BAC Hame
Loans Servicing, LP and each of their successors and assigns, including each of their officers,
employees, agents, and/or any person or entity acting on their behalf.
2. "BNYM" or "Trustee" means The Bank of Nevv York Me11on and its successors
and assigns, including its officers, employees, agents, andlor any person or entity acting on its
behalf.
"Inside Institutional Investor' means each of: BlackRock Financial Management
Inc.; Dore Advisors, L.P.; Maiden Lane; LLC; Metropolitan Life Insurance Company; Trust
Company of the Vest and affiliated companies controlled by The TCW Group, Inc.; Neuberger
Berman Europe Limited; Pacific Investment Management Company LLC; Goldman Sachs Asset
Management, L.P.; Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America; Invesco Advisors.
Inc.; Thri~~ent Financial for Lutherans; Landesbank Baden-Wuerttemberg; LBBW Asset
Management (Ireland) plc, Dublin; ING Bank fsb; ING Capital LLC; ING Investment
Management LLC; Nationwide Mutual Insurance Gampany and its affiliated companies;
AEG~N USA Investment Management LLC, authorized signatory for Transamerica Life
Insurance Company, AEGOltiT Financial Assurance Ireland Limited, Transamerica Life
International (Bermuda) Ltd., Monumental Life Insurance Company, Transamerica Advisors
Life Insurance Company, AEGON Global Institutional Markets, plc, LIICA Re II, Inc., Pine
Falls Re, Inc., Transamerica Financial Life Insurance Company, Stonebridge Life Insurance
Company, and Western Reserve Life Assurance Co. of Ohio; Federal Home Loan Bank of
Atlanta; Ba}~erische Landesbank; Prudential Investment Management Inc.; and Western Asset
4956023
Management Company and each of their successors and assigns, including each of their officers,
employees, agents, and/or any person or entity acting on their behalf.
4. "Countrywide" means Countrywide Financial Corporation and Countrywide
Home Loans, Inc. and each of their successors and assigns, including each of their officers,
employees, agents, and/or any person or entity acting on their behalf.
"Covered Trusts" means the 530 residential mortgage-backed securitization trusts
listed on Exhibit A to the Settlement Agrzement.
6. "Event of Default" means the same as "Event of Default," as defined in Section
7.01 of the Pooling and Servicing Agreements ("PSA"j that govern the majority of the Covered
Trusts. (See; e.g., CWALT 2004-2CB Pooling and Servicing Agreement ~ 7.01, Doc. No.l1-1,
Ex. A-17 to 6/28/11 Ingber Affirfnation).
"Forbearance Agreement" means that letter agreement dated December 9, 2010,
entered into by Theodore I4T. Mirvis, Brian E. Pastuszonski and Marc T.G. Dworsky on behalf of
BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP, Kathy Patrick on behalf of the Inside Institutional Investors,
and Jason H.P. Kravitt on behalf of BNYM, as well as any and all amendments or extensions
thereto.
"Proposed Final Order and Judgment" means the Proposed Final Order and
Judgment attached as Exhibit F to BNYM's Verified Petition filed in the Supreme Court of the
State of Neer York on June 29, 2001 (Doe. No. 7).
4. '`Proposed Settlement" means all terms, provisions, and proposals suggested or
considered in the negotiations, discussions, communications, and deliberations that culminated in
the Settlement Agreement, the Institutional Investor Agreement, and the Proposed Final Order
and Judgment, whether or not incorporated into the Settlement Agreement, the Institutional
956023
Investor Agreement, or the Proposed Final Order and Judgment.
1 Q. "Settlement Agreement'' means the settlement agreement among BNYM, Bank of
America Corporation, BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP, Countrywide Financial Corporation and
Countryv4ide Home Loans, Inc., dated June 2$, 2Q11, which is the subject ~f the Proceeding.
1 1. "Settlement Pa}Tment" means the same as "Settlement Payment" as that term is
defined in Section 3 of the Settlement Agreement.
12. "I~Totice ofNon-Performance" means the October 18, 2010 letter from Kathy
Patrick on behalf of certain undersigned certificate holders sent to Countrywide Hame Loan
Servicing LP and BNYM.
13. The terms "and" and "ar" mean and/or and shall be construed either disjunctively
or conjunctively as necessary to bring tivzthin the scope of this discovery request all responses
that might other~~rise be construed to be outside of its scope.
14. "Concerning" means referring to, containing, relating ta, describing, ofFering
evidence of, or constit~.rting.
l~. "Document" is defined in the broadest possible sense permissible under
applicable laws and/or the CPLR, and shall include, but not be limited ta, any type of written,
typewritten, printed, recorded, computer generated or graphic materials, however produced or
stored, calendars, charges, checks, computer files, e-mails, facsimile transmissions, graphs,
journals, letters, memoranda, notes, projections, spreadsheets, summaries or records of telephone
or in person communications, voice-mail and all other media of electronic storage and
communication. A draft or non-identical copy or copy with marginalia, notes, comments, or
annotations of any kind is a separate document within the meaning of this term.
6956023
INSTRUCTIONS
1. In responding to this suhpaena, please set forth the language of each request
immediately prior to the response given for that request.
2. Your written responses to these requests should respond separately to each
numbered demand for production below by: (1) providing a statement that you have complied
(inclusive of Bates ranges} or will comply with tha particular demand; or (2) providing a
statement that you lack the ability to comply with the particular demand; or (3) providing any
objection to the particular demand.
3. If your response to a particular demand is that you will comply with the demand,
you should state in your response whether the production will be allowed in whole or in part, and
you should state that all documents or things in the demanded category that are in your
possession, custody or control, and to which no objection is being made, will be included in the
production.
~. If your response to a particular demand is a statement that you lack the ability to
comply with that demand, you should affirm in your response that a diligent search and a
reasonable inquiry have been made in an zffort to comply with that demand. This statement
should also specif;7 whether the inability to comply is because the particular item or category
never existed, has been destroyed, has been lost, misplaced; or stolen, or has never been, or is no
longer in your possession, eustodyr, or control, in which case the name and address of any person
or entity known or believed by you to have possession, custody or control of that document or
category of documents should be identified.
5. If you abject to a request for production contained herein, state the basis for your
objection with particularit~~. if you object to part of a request for production contained herein,
7~S56Q23
specify the part to which you object and the basis for your objection with particularity, and
answer the unobjectionable part of the request.
6. In producing any Documents requested herein, please furnish all Documents in
your possession, custody, or control. "Possession, custody, ar control" refers to all Documents,
data compilations, tangible things, and other information obtainable by your order or direction,
including those you have access to through others from tivhom you are entitled to receive the
information, such as accountants, attorneys, consultants, investigators and any of your other
agents, representatives, servants; or employees, or others engaged in any joint enterprise ar
partnership with you.
7. Every Document produced in response to the requests herein shall be produced in
its entirety, without abbreviation; and shall include all attachments and matters affixed thereto;
along with any and all drafts of the Document.
8. If any document responsive to any of these requests was, but is no longer, in your
possession or subject to your custody or control, state whether it is (a} missing or lost, (b) has
been destroyed, (c} has been transferred, voluntarily ar involuntarily to others, or (d} has been
otherwise disposed af, and in each instance explain the circumstances surrounding such
disposition thereof and state the date or approximate date thereof.
9. These requests far production are deemed continuing. If any information or
documents sought by the requests are not learned about, or do not become available until after
the requests are answered, or if the answers for any reason should later become incomplete or
incorrect, there shall be a continuing duty on your part to supplement or change answers
previously submitted pursuant to CPLR 3101(hj.
895&023
10. Documents shall be produced as they are kept in the usual course of business or
the documents shall be organized and labeled to correspond to the categories in these requests.
In the case of documents that were already produced pursuant to federal, state, local government,
or administrative requests, investigations, or subpoenas, those documents should be produced in
the same manner as they were previously produced by You.
11. Documents shall be produced in such fashion as to identify the department,
branch or office in whose possession it was located and, where applicable; the natural person in
whose possession it was found and tree business address of each document's custodian{s).
12. You are required to produce the original of each document requested together
with all non-identical copies and drafts of each document. If the original of any document
cannot be located and,~or produced, provide a copy in lieu thereof, which shall be legible and
bound or stapled in the same manner as the original, and produce all other non-identical copies
that differ from the original and from the other copies produced for any reason, including without
limitation, the making of notes thereon.
13. Documents attached to each other in their original form should not be separated
E~hen produced. Any attachments to email messages should be produced with, and linked to, the
attaching email
14. All documents shall be Bates stamped and include the following nnetadata (to the
extent applicable):
a. Document Date:b. Document Created Date:c. Document Modified Dates:d. Time Sent:e. To:f. From:g. Cc:h. Bcc:i. Subjectj. Filename
9956023
k. Doctype1. Beg Batesm. End Bates
15. All spreadsheets, including, without limitation, documents produced using
Microsoft Excel, shall be produced in native format.
16. Documents not otherwise responsive to these requests shall be produced if such
documents mention, discuss, refer to, or explain the Documents that are called for by these
requests, or if such documents are attached to documents called for by the requests and constitute
routing slips, transmittal memoranda or letters, comments, evaluations ar similar materials.
DOCUMENT REQUESTS
All documents—including but not limited to documents produced or deposition
testimony' in I~LBIA Insurance Corp. v. Countrytivicle Home Loans, Inc., et al., Index No.
08!602825 {~1.Y. Sup. Ct.)—concerning the fallowing topics:
a. Forbearance Agreement. This includes, but is not limited to, aiI information
concerning the drafting, editing, negotiation, and execution of the Forbearance
Agreement.
b. Event of Default. This includes. but is not limited to, all information concerning
any Event of Default, including but not limned to, information concerning the
prevention, curing, waiving, or tolling of any Event of Default.
c. Indemnification. This includes, but is not limited to, all information concerning
any indemnification obligations) of the Inside Institutional Investors, the Trustee
or You pursuant to the terms of the governing Pooling and SerSricing Agreements.
This includes, but is not limited to, all information concerning the release ar
attempted release, or shift or attempted shift; of any such indemnification
obligation(s).
1G956023
d. Settlement Payment. This includes, but is not limited #o, all information
concerning the negotiation of the Settlement Payment, including but not limited
to, information concerning any dollar figure{s) proposed as an alternative to the
agreed upon $8.5 billion Settlement Payment.
e. Notice to Certificateholders. This includes, but is not limited to, all information
concerning any 1~Totice to Certificateholders, including but not limited to, all
communications in which the Settlement Proponents discussed, discouraged, or
attempted to preclude any Notice to Certificateholders.
£ The Number of Covered Trusts. This includes, but is not limited to, all
information concerning the number of trusts coverzd by, or excluded from, the
Proposed Settlement ar the Settlement Agreement. This information includes, but
is not limited to, all deliberations ar negotiations concerning which trusts would
be covered by, ~r excluded from, the Proposed Settlement ar the Settlement
Agreement.
g. Attorneys Fees. This includes, but is not limited to, all information concerning
the fees to be paid to counsel for the Inside Institutional Investors in connection
with the Proposed Settlement or the Settlement Agreement. This also includes,
but is not limited to, all information concerning Your decision to pay any or all of
those fees.
h. The Proposed Final Order and Judgment. This includes, but is not limited to,
all information concerning drafts of the Proposed Final Order and Judgment;
including but not limited to, all information concerning any contemplated ar
proposed terms of the Proposed Final Order and Judgment.
i. Your Liability to the Covered Trusts. This includes, but is not limited to, all
information concerning any analysis or discussion of Your liability as successor to
11956023
Countrywide, breaches of representaxians and warranties, document exceptions,
sen~icing errors, and indemnification of others, including BNYM, with respect to
the Covered Trusts. This also includes, but is not limited to, all information
concerning reserves, and the amount of reserves taken by You with respect to any
potential liability to the Covered Trusts.
2. All documents concerning communications, whether internally at Bof_A or
between You, on the one hand, and any third party other than BNYM' on the other, concerning
the topics listed in Request l.a.-i. This request includes, but is not limited ta, hand-u-ritten or
electronic notes concerning such communications.
Documents sufficient to show all business relationships involving two or mare
corporations or partnerships between You, on the one hand, and BNYM, on the other, between
October 19, 2 10 and the present, including but not Limited to relationships in which B1V'Y1~1
serves ~r served as a trustee, administrator, and/or agent.
4. A random sample of between 4,630 and 6,470 loan files from the Covered Trusts.
For purposes of this request, the terra "loan files" means: (i) the loan origination documents,
including but not limited to, the credit reports, underwriting work sheets, underwriting
zxceptions granted, appraisal or valuation results, title commitment and policy, final AUS
findings, loan approval; loan application (Form lOQB and all supporting documents}, mortgage
note, mortgage or deed of trust, mortgage insurance certificate and HLTDl; (ii) closing loan tapes,
is the extent not publicly available; (iii)1aan servicing records, including, but not limited, call
notes; foreclosure files including communications vs,~ith borrowers;l4an modifications, and loss
Z Third party, as used in this request, includes any experts, accountants or financial advisors retained by
You, BNYM, ar the Inside Institutional Investors. With respect to communications with the Inside
Institutional Investors, the Steering Committee recognizes that the settlement communications dispute is
pending before the Court and that a response to a portion of this Request is dependent upon the Court's
decision with respect to the discoverability of settlement communications betr~een Bank of America and
the Inside Institutional Investors.
12956023
mitigation files; and (iv) entries from the PAT/CLAIMS System reflecting external
communications relating to amortgage-insurance claim denial and/or a repurchase demand on
the loans.3
5. All documents concerning the allegations contained in numbered paragraphs 1-6,
including subparagraphs; on pages 2-4 of the Notice of Non-Performance.
6. All documents concerning Your right andlor option to withdraw from the
Settlement Agreement.
7. All documents concerning any portion of the settlement payment You anticipate
or estimate will be paid to You, whether directly, indirectly, or by withholding any portion of the
settlement payment.
For all modifications to Ioans held by the Covered Trusts, documznts sufficient to
show the pre- and past- modification (i) interest rate and (ii) outstanding principal balance.
X11 communications between or among You, BNYi~/I andlor the Inside
Institutional Investors concerning loan modifications in the Covered Trusts.
1 d. With respecF to loans held by the Covered Trusts that were modified, documents
sufficient to identify the mortgagar(s) or other lenders) holding a mortgage or other lien secured
by the same property, and the servicer of such other mortgage loan{s) or lien(s).
11. Documents evidencing the practices, processes, guidelines, ar requirements for
originating, underwriting, performing due diligence, selling; securitizing, packaging, or bundling
(i) loans offered for sale or sold to Government Sponsored Entities and (ii} loans in private label
RMBS, including any documents comparing or contrasting the practices, processes, guidelines;
ar requirements for originating, underwriting, performing due diligence, selling, securitizing,
3 The Steering Committee recognizes that the loan file dispute is pending before the Court and that a
response to this Request is dependent upon the Court's decision with respect to that dispute.
13956023
packaging, or bundling (i) loans offered for sale or sold to Government Sponsored Entities and
(ii) loans in private label RMBS.
12. Documents sufficient to identify the authors) of the January 27, 201Q, February
1 Q, 2010, and April 11, 2010, presentations to Gibbs &Bruns.
13. All re-under~~riting reports, analyses, and/or any documents related to re-
underwriting conducted by third parties in your possession from litigation in~Tolving
CQUntrywide loans, including but not limited to the following cases: Ambac assurance Corp. v.
Coun~ytia~ide Home Loans, Inc.. et al., Index No. 10(651612 (N.Y. Sup. Ct.); Financial Guar~anty~
Insurance Co. v. Count~yw~ide Home Loans, Inc., Index No. 09/60736 (N.Y. Sup. Ct.);1~~BIA
Itasurance Corp. v. Coz~ntrywide Home Loans, Inc., et al., Index No. 08/602825 {N.Y. Sup. Ct.);
Syjncora Guarantee, Inc, v. Countrywide Home ~aans, Inc., et al.; 09f650042 (N.Y. Sup. Ct.};
United Guaranty l~lortgage Indertznily Co. v. Countrywide Financial Corp., et al.; Case No. 09-
1888 {C.D. Ca1.); and U.S Bank, 1~TA. v. Country-rvide Home Loans, Inc.; et al., Case Na. 11-
6223 {S.D.Iti~.Y.).
1~956023
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that a true and correct copy of the NOTICE OF SUBPOENA was served on
counsel of record for all parties and proposed intervenors, at the address of their counsel of
record, via electronic mail;
On this 14th day of September, 2012.
985704
Je ~ x Musg`~aver\̀_/
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK
In the matter of the application of
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON, (as Trustee under various Pooling and Servicing Agreements and Indenture Trustee under various Indentures), BlackRock Financial Management Inc. (intervenor), Kore Advisors, L.P. (intervenor), Maiden Lane, LLC (intervenor), Metropolitan Life Insurance Company (intervenor), Trust Company of the West and affiliated companies controlled by The TCW Group, Inc. (intervenor), Neuberger Berman Europe Limited (intervenor), Pacific Investment Management Company LLC (intervenor), Goldman Sachs Asset Management, L.P. (intervenor), Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America (intervenor), Invesco Advisors, Inc. (intervenor), Thrivent Financial for Lutherans (intervenor), Landesbank Baden-Wuerttemberg (intervenor), LBBW Asset Management (Ireland) plc, Dublin (intervenor), ING Bank N.V. (intervenor), ING Capital LLC (intervenor), ING Investment Management LLC (intervenor), Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company and its affiliated companies (intervenor), AEGON USA Investment Management LLC, authorized signatory for Transamerica Life Insurance Company, AEGON Financial Assurance Ireland Limited, Transamerica Life International (Bermuda) Ltd., Monumental Life Insurance Company, Transamerica Advisors Life Insurance Company, AEGON Global Institutional Markets, plc, LIICA Re II, Inc., Pine Falls Re, Inc., Transamerica Financial Life Insurance Company, Stonebridge Life Insurance Company, and Western Reserve Life Assurance Co. of Ohio (intervenor), Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta (intervenor), Bayerische Landesbank (intervenor), Prudential Investment Management, Inc. (intervenor), and Western Asset Management Company (intervenor),
Petitioners,
for an order, pursuant to C.P.L.R. § 7701, seeking judicial instructions and approval of a proposed Settlement.
Index No. 651786-2011
Kapnick, J.
FIRST SET OF DOCUMENT REQUESTS TO OBJECTORS
TO: Federal Home Loan Banks of Boston, Chicago, and Indianapolis, by and through attorneys of record, Derek W. Loeser and David J. Ko, Keller Rohrback LLP, 1201 Third Avenue, Suite 3200, Seattle, Washington 98101. PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that, pursuant to Article 31 of the New York Civil Practice
Law and Rules, you are required to, by May 3, 2013, produce and permit the Institutional
Investors, or their undersigned attorneys, or someone acting on their behalf, to inspect and copy
at the offices of Gibbs & Bruns LLP, 1100 Louisiana, Suite 5300, Houston, Texas 77002, the
2
documents and things described in the attached “Exhibit A” which are in your possession,
custody, or control.
Dated: March 11, 2013 WARNER PARTNERS, P.C.
By: /s/_Kenneth E. Warner___________ Kenneth E. Warner 950 Third Avenue, 32nd Floor New York, New York 10022 Phone: (212) 593-8000 GIBBS & BRUNS LLP Kathy D. Patrick (pro hac vice)
Robert J. Madden (pro hac vice) Scott A. Humphries (pro hac vice) Kate Kaufmann Shih 1100 Louisiana, Suite 5300 Houston, Texas 77002 Phone: (713) 650-8805
Attorneys for Intervenor-Petitioners, BlackRock Financial Management Inc., Kore Advisors, L.P., Maiden Lane, LLC, Maiden Lane II, LLC, Maiden Lane III, LLC, Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Trust Company of the West and affiliated companies controlled by The TCW Group, Inc., Neuberger Berman Europe Limited, PIMCO Investment Management Company LLC, Goldman Sachs Asset Management, L.P., as adviser to its funds and accounts, Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America, Invesco Advisers, Inc., Thrivent Financial for Lutherans, Landesbank Baden-Wuerttemberg, LBBW Asset Management (Ireland) plc, Dublin, ING Bank N.V., ING Capital LLC, ING Investment Management LLC, New York Life Investment Management LLC, as investment manager, Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company and its affiliated companies, AEGON USA Investment Management LLC, authorized signatory for Transamerica Life Insurance Company, AEGON Financial Assurance Ireland Limited, Transamerica Life International (Bermuda) Ltd., Monumental Life Insurance Company, Transamerica Advisors Life Insurance Company, AEGON Global Institutional Markets, plc, LIICA Re II, Inc.; Pine Falls Re, Inc., Transamerica Financial Life Insurance Company, Stonebridge Life Insurance Company, and Western Reserve Life Assurance Co. of Ohio, Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta, Bayerische
4
EXHIBIT A
DEFINITIONS AND INSTRUCTIONS 1. “You” and “Your” means each of: Federal Home Loan Bank of Boston, Federal Home
Loan Bank of Chicago, and Federal Home Loan Bank of Indianapolis and each entity’s affiliates and subsidiaries.
2. “Article 77 Proceeding” means the above-entitled case pending in the Supreme Court of the State of New York before Justice Kapnick, under Index No. 651786-2011.
3. “Bank of America” means Bank of America Corporation and BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP and their successors and assigns, including their officers, employees, agents, and/or any person or entity acting on their behalf.
4. “BNY Mellon” means The Bank of New York Mellon and its successors and assigns, including its officers, employees, agents, and/or any person or entity acting on its behalf.
5. “Countrywide” means Countrywide Financial Corporation and Countrywide Home
Loans, Inc. and their successors and assigns, including their officers, employees, agents, and/or any person or entity acting on their behalf.
6. “Covered Trusts” means the 530 residential mortgage-backed securitization trusts listed
on Exhibit A to the Settlement Agreement. 7. “Hearing” means the final hearing on the Settlement, in accordance with the Amended
Scheduling Order entered by the Court on February 26, 2013 [Docket No. 526] in the Article 77 Proceeding.
8. “Ineligible Loans” means loans which breach contractual representations and warranties made regarding those loans in Pooling and Servicing Agreements, Indentures, or similar agreements governing RMBS Trusts.
9. “Object” means Your filing of Your Objection. 10. “Objection” means the brief in opposition to the Settlement and notice of Your objection
to the Settlement filed by You on or before May 3, 2013, in accordance with the Amended Scheduling Order entered by the Court on February 26, 2013 [Docket No. 526] in the Article 77 Proceeding.
11. “Repurchase and Servicing Claims” means contractual claims associated with breaches of
representation and warranties on mortgage loans sold to RMBS Trusts and contractual claims associated with deficient servicing of mortgage loans sold to RMBS Trusts.
12. “RMBS Trusts” means private-label residential mortgage-backed securities trusts.
5
13. “Settlement” means the Settlement Agreement between BNY Mellon, Bank of America, and Countrywide, executed on June 28, 2011, and all exhibits to the Settlement Agreement.
14. “Settlement Proceeds” means the $8.5 billion payment to be distributed among the Covered Trusts in accordance with the Settlement.
15. “Document” is defined in the broadest possible sense permissible under applicable laws and/or the CPLR, and shall include, but not be limited to, any type of written, typewritten, printed, recorded, computer generated or graphic materials, however produced or stored, calendars, charges, checks, computer files, e-mails, facsimile transmissions, graphs, journals, letters, memoranda, notes, projections, spreadsheets, summaries or records of telephone or in person communications, voice-mail and all other media of electronic storage and communication. A draft or non-identical copy or copy with marginalia, notes, comments, or annotations of any kind is a separate document within the meaning of this term.
16. Your written responses to these requests should respond separately to each numbered demand for production below by: (1) providing a statement that you have complied (inclusive of Bates ranges) or will comply with the particular demand; or (2) providing a statement that you lack the ability to comply with the particular demand; or (3) providing any objection to the particular demand.
17. If you object to a request for production contained herein, state the basis for your objection with particularity. If you object to part of a request for production contained herein, specify the part to which you object and the basis for your objection with particularity, and answer the unobjectionable part of the request.
18. In producing any Documents requested herein, please furnish all Documents in your possession, custody, or control. “Possession, custody, or control” refers to all Documents, data compilations, tangible things, and other information obtainable by your order or direction, including those you have access to through others from whom you are entitled to receive the information, such as accountants, attorneys, consultants, investigators and any of your other agents, representatives, servants, or employees, or others engaged in any joint enterprise or partnership with you.
19. Every Document produced in response to the requests herein shall be produced in its entirety, without abbreviation, and shall include all attachments and matters affixed thereto, along with any and all drafts of the Document.
20. If you consider any Document falling within any of these requests to be privileged from discovery, you are directed to file and serve at the time you answer these requests for production a privilege log of all Documents withheld from production, identifying each Document as follows: (a) the type of Document; (b) its date; (c) addressor’s or author’s name, title and address; (d) addressee’s name, title and address; (e) the name and address of each other Person to whom a copy of the Document was sent or shown; (f) a
6
description of the Document, including its general nature or character; (g) the number of pages, the number of attachments or appendices, if any; (h) the present custodian of the document; and (i) the basis on which the Document is considered to be privileged from discovery. Where a requested Document contains allegedly privileged information, you are requested to produce those portions of the Document for which no privilege is claimed and to specifically identify on each such Document where material has been deleted or redacted.
21. If any document responsive to any of these requests was, but is no longer, in your possession or subject to your custody or control, state whether it is (a) missing or lost, (b) has been destroyed, (c) has been transferred, voluntarily or involuntarily to others, or (d) has been otherwise disposed of, and in each instance explain the circumstances surrounding such disposition thereof and state the date or approximate date thereof.
22. These requests for production are deemed continuing. If any information or documents sought by the requests are not learned about, or do not become available until after the requests are answered, or if the answers for any reason should later become incomplete or incorrect, there shall be a continuing duty on your part to supplement or change answers previously submitted pursuant to CPLR 3101(h).
23. Documents shall be produced as they are kept in the usual course of business or the documents shall be organized and labeled to correspond to the categories in these requests. In the case of documents that were already produced pursuant to federal, state, local government, or administrative requests, investigations, or subpoenas, those documents should be produced in the same manner as they were previously produced by You.
24. Documents shall be produced in such fashion as to identify the department, branch or office in whose possession it was located and, where applicable, the natural person in whose possession it was found and the business address of each document’s custodian(s).
25. You are required to produce the original of each document requested together with all non-identical copies and drafts of each document. If the original of any document cannot be located and/or produced, provide a copy in lieu thereof, which shall be legible and bound or stapled in the same manner as the original, and produce all other non-identical copies that differ from the original and from the other copies produced for any reason, including without limitation, the making of notes thereon.
26. Documents attached to each other in their original form should not be separated when produced. Any attachments to email messages should be produced with, and linked to, the attaching email.
27. All documents shall be Bates stamped and include the following metadata (to the extent applicable):
a. Document Date:
7
b. Document Created Date: c. Document Modified Dates: d. Time Sent: e. To: f. From: g. Cc: h. Bcc: i. Subject j. Filename k. Doctype l. Beg Bates m. End Bates
28. All spreadsheets, including, without limitation, documents produced using Microsoft
Excel, shall be produced in native format.
29. Documents not otherwise responsive to these requests shall be produced if such documents mention, discuss, refer to, or explain the Documents that are called for by these requests, or if such documents are attached to documents called for by the requests and constitute routing slips, transmittal memoranda or letters, comments, evaluations or similar materials.
REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION
You are requested to produce the following: 1. All Documents containing information and analyses that were considered by You in
deciding to Object to the Settlement.
2. All Documents reflecting internal communications and communications with Bank of America, BNY Mellon, or any third party regarding Your decision to Object to the Settlement.
3. All Documents reflecting communications between June 1, 2010 and June 28, 2011 between You, on the one hand, and Bank of America, BNY Mellon, or any holder or holders of securities in the Covered Trusts on the other hand, regarding the Covered Trusts.
4. All Documents reflecting Your awareness of the press releases and other publicly available information relating to the negotiations which ultimately led to the Settlement.
5. All Documents reflecting Your communications between November 18, 2010 and June 28, 2011 concerning the negotiations which ultimately led to the Settlement.
8
6. All Documents reflecting communications between June 28, 2011 and the present between You, on the one hand, and any intervenor, proposed intervenor, or objector in the Article 77 Proceeding, on the other.
7. All Documents, information, witnesses, testimony, and analyses that You intend to present at the Hearing in support of your Objection to the Settlement.
8. All Documents reflecting Your analysis, assessment, or valuation, if any, of the claims proposed to be released by Paragraph 9 of the Settlement Agreement, including the Repurchase and Servicing Claims.
9. All Documents reflecting Your analysis or assessment, if any, of the number of Ineligible Loans in the Covered Trusts, and Your analysis or assessment, if any, of the realized and projected losses associated with such Ineligible Loans.
10. All Documents reflecting Your analysis or assessment, if any, of the total realized and projected losses incurred, or expected to be incurred, by the Covered Trusts.
11. All Documents reflecting Your analysis or assessment, if any, of potential legal defenses to the Covered Trusts’ Repurchase and Servicing Claims against Countrywide or Bank of America, including, without limitation, defenses to claims of successor liability against Bank of America and causation defenses.
12. All Documents reflecting Your analysis or assessment, if any, of Countrywide’s financial ability to satisfy a judgment against Countrywide in favor of the Covered Trusts.
13. All Documents reflecting Your analysis or assessment, if any, of the daily, weekly, or monthly cost to the Covered Trusts of delay in the distribution of Settlement Proceeds to the Covered Trusts.
14. All Documents reflecting Your efforts, if any, to resolve Your securities and fraud-related lawsuits and claims against Countrywide or Bank of America, if any, in exchange for Your withdrawal from the Article 77 Proceeding or non-objection to the Settlement.
15. All Documents reflecting Your efforts, if any, to prosecute any of the Covered Trusts’ Repurchase or Servicing Claims against Countrywide or Bank of America, including any instructions, directions, or other correspondence You have provided to BNY Mellon in connection with such efforts, whether undertaken derivatively or in coordination with BNY Mellon. This topic excludes any actions occurring within the Article 77 Proceeding.
16. All Documents reflecting Your efforts, if any, to declare an Event of Default relating to any Covered Trust at any time.
17. All Documents reflecting Your efforts, if any, to prosecute the Repurchase or Servicing Claims held by trustees of RMBS Trusts not included among the Covered Trusts,
9
including any instructions, directions, or other correspondence You have provided to RMBS trustees in connection with such efforts, whether undertaken derivatively or in coordination with the trustees. This topic is not limited to Countrywide-issued RMBS Trusts.
18. Documents sufficient to determine Your holdings of, or control over, securities issued by any of the Covered Trusts, as of June 27, 2011 and the date of Your Objection, including, without limitation, documents, if any, reflecting investment management or advisory agreements governing voting authority with respect to such holdings.