eohazards mitigating the risks learning from ancient ......baelo claudia 2009 corinth 2011...

43
GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient Earthquakes IGCP 567 (2008-2012) Earthquake Archaeology in the Alpine-Himalayan Seismic Zone Manuel Sintubin (Belgium) Iain Stewart (U.K.), Tina Niemi (U.S.A.), Erhan Altunel (Turkey) 40 th Anniversary IGCP, UNESCO, Paris, 22 February 2012

Upload: others

Post on 01-Jan-2021

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

Learning from Ancient Earthquakes

IGCP 567 (2008-2012)

Earthquake Archaeology in the Alpine-Himalayan Seismic Zone

Manuel Sintubin (Belgium)

Iain Stewart (U.K.), Tina Niemi (U.S.A.), Erhan Altunel (Turkey)

40th Anniversary IGCP, UNESCO, Paris, 22 February 2012

Page 2: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

World Press Photograph 2012

Toshiyuki Tsunenari

GEOHAZARDS

Page 3: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

World Press Photograph 2012

Toshiyuki Tsunenari

GEOHAZARDS

very low- to low-frequency events

Page 4: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

World Press Photograph 2012

Toshiyuki Tsunenari

GEOHAZARDS

very low- to low-frequency events

high-impact events

Page 5: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

World Press Photograph 2012

Toshiyuki Tsunenari

GEOHAZARDS

very low- to low-frequency events

high-impact events

highly unpredictable events

Page 6: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

M6.1 February 21th, 2011 Christchurch earthquake

Page 7: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS San Andreas Fault, California

Page 8: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

HAZARD NATURAL PHENOMENON

San Andreas Fault, California

Page 9: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

HAZARD NATURAL PHENOMENON

RISK

San Andreas Fault, California

San Francisco 1906

Page 10: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

M7.0 January 12th, 2010 Haiti earthquake

Page 11: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

HAZARD NATURAL PHENOMENON

San Andreas Fault, California

Page 12: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

HAZARD NATURAL PHENOMENON

working on exposure, a ‘mission impossible’?

Page 13: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

HAZARD NATURAL PHENOMENON

working on reducing vulnerability! UC Berkeley University Hall

Page 14: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

HAZARD NATURAL PHENOMENON

working on strenghtening resilience!

© Getty Images

© telegraph.co.uk

Page 15: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

World Press Photograph 2012

Yasuyoshi Chiba

M9.0 March 11th, 2011 Tohoku earthquake & tsunami

Page 16: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

M6.3 April 6th, 2009 L’Aquila earthquake

Page 17: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

EARTHQUAKE THREAT?

ICSU, 2005

Page 18: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

EARTHQUAKE THREAT?

Jackson 2006

Page 19: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

EARTHQUAKE THREAT

Bartels & Van Rooyen

2011

Page 20: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

EARTHQUAKE THREAT

2011, highest economic loss ever caused by earthquakes! 133 earthquakes causing losses

~21.000 casualties (~70% of total)

~365 billion USD economic loss

World Press Photograph 2012

Lars Lindqvist

Page 21: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

EARTHQUAKE THREAT

© Columbia University

megacities in the Alpine-Himalayan seismic zone!

Page 22: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

Mycenea, Greece LETHAL ATTRACTION

Page 23: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

LETHAL ATTRACTION Bam, Iran

© Roozbeh Shivayi

M6.6 December 26th, 2003 earthquake

Page 24: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

Delphi, Greece

IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY

IN THE ALPINE-HIMALAYAN SEISMIC ZONE

Page 25: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra, Jordan

Page 26: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Dholavira, Gujarat, India

Page 27: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY

Baelo Claudia 2009

Corinth 2011

Geological Society of America

Special Paper 471

Page 28: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra, Jordan

Page 29: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

Knossos, Crete

IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY

Page 30: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

Nature, 15 September 2011

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

risk communication?

risk literacy?

Page 31: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

Page 32: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, STRENGHTENING SOCIETY’S RESILIENCE

World Press Photograph 2012

Yasuyoshi Chiba

Page 33: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

World Press Photograph 2012

Yasuyoshi Chiba

Page 34: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

ees.kuleuven.be/igcp567/

Page 35: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,
Page 36: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

World Press Photograph 2012

Toshiyuki Tsunenari

Page 37: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

Qutb Minar, Delhi Angkor Wat

Abdullah Khan Madrassa, Bikhara Hagia Sophia, Istanbul

Page 38: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

Nimrod, Golan Heights

Susita, Golan Heights

Hierapolis, Turkey Phaestos, Crete

Susita, Golan Heights

Page 39: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY

Crete 2008

Baelo Claudia 2009

DSF 2009

Thessaloniki 2010

Vienna 2010

Bhuj 2011

Kobe 2010

Santa Fe 2008

Memphis 2011

Corinth 2011

Morelia 2012?

Brisbane 2012

Leuven 2012

San Diego 2012

Aachen 2013?

Page 40: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY

Seismological Research Letters 79(6) 2008 “In establishing such an

earthquake culture,

telling ‘a good story’

may be good enough!” Sintubin et al., SRL 79(5), nov/dec 2008

Page 41: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS Eyjafjallajökul 2010

Page 42: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS Laki 1783

Page 43: EOHAZARDS MITIGATING THE RISKS Learning from Ancient ......Baelo Claudia 2009 Corinth 2011 Geological Society of America Special Paper 471 . IGCP 567 EARTHQUAKE ARCHAEOLOGY Petra,

GEOHAZARDS, MITIGATING THE RISKS

Thordarson & Self 2003

working on exposure?