entie commercial bank 2017 annual general meeting of … agm agenda... · 2017. 5. 10. · agenda...
TRANSCRIPT
(This translated document is prepared in accordance with the Chinese version and is for
reference only. In the event of any inconsistency between the English version and the Chinese
version, the Chinese version shall prevail.)
EnTie Commercial Bank
2017 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders
Agenda Handbook
Date: 9:00 a.m., June 16 (Friday), 2017 Venue: 4F, Meeting Hall of Farmers’ Association, No.80, Zhongzheng Rd.,
Xinzhuang Dist., New Taipei City, Taiwan
Stock Code:2849
Agenda of 2017 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders EnTie Commercial Bank
Ⅰ. Announcement of the commencement of the meeting and Chairman’s remarks. 1. Announcement of the commencement of the meeting (report number of shares
represented by attending shareholders)
2. Chairman’s remarksⅡ. Agenda for the meeting
1. Reporting Items:
(1)To note for record the 2016 Business Report.............. (2)To note for record the Audit Committee’s Review Report on the 2016
Financial Statements........................(3)To note for record the Distribution of Employees’ Compensation and
Directors’ and Supervisors’ remuneration for 2016............
(4)To note for record the Revise Report for the “Criteria Governing Codes of
Ethical Conduct” of the Bank...................... (5)To note for record the Revise Report for the “Criteria for Ethical Corporate
Management” of the Bank......................
(6)To note for record the Revise Report for the “Criteria for Corporate SocialResponsibility Best Practice” of the Bank................
(7)To note for record the short-form merger report between An Yin Insurance
Broker Co., Ltd. and the Bank................................ 2. Acknowledgment Items:
(1)Adoption of the 2016 Business Report and Financial Statements.....(2)Adoption of the Proposal for Distribution of 2016 Profits ...........
3. Discussion Items:
(1)To approve the amendments to the Articles of Incorporation of the Bank... (2)To approve the amendments to the “Criteria Governing Assets Acquisition
and Disposal” of the Bank................... (3)To approve the proposal of having the Bank redeem the CPPS upon the 10th
anniversary by issuing new similar capital instruments at current market rates.. 4. Extemporaneous Motions.........................
5. Adjournment..............................
Ⅲ. Appendix 1. The Shareholding Status of all Directors..................
1
2
9
11
12
20
30
34
36 46
50
58
72 73 73
74
2. The Rules and Procedures of Shareholders’ Meeting of EnTie Commercial Bank.3. Articles of Incorporation of EnTie Commercial Bank............4. The Criteria Governing Codes of Ethical Conduct of EnTie Commercial Bank...
5. The Criteria for Ethical Corporate Management of EnTie Commercial Bank..6. The Criteria for Corporate Social Responsibility Best Practice of EnTie Commercial
Bank.......................................
7. The Criteria Governing Assets Acquisition and Disposal of EnTie Commercial Bank...
75 85 99 102
111 119
Ⅰ. Announcement of the commencement of the meeting and
Chairman’s remarks
1. Announcement of the commencement of the meeting (report numberof shares represented by attending shareholders)
2. Chairman’s remarks
1
Ⅱ. Agenda for the meeting
1. Reporting Items:(1) Proposed by the Board of Directors
Proposal: To note for record the 2016 Business Report Explanation: Please see details from pages 3 to 8 of this Agenda
Handbook for the 2016 Business Report.
2
2016 Business Report
Global economic recovery lost steam in 2016 and the economic growth rate hit a new low since the Global Financial Crisis in 2008. Growth Momentum in developed markets
including the US, Japan, and Europe was lower than expected, and the Chinese economy
slowed as the country underwent structural reform. In addition, the Brexit referendum and the US presidential election brought political uncertainties and volatilities, impacting global
investment, consumption, trade, and financial market confidence.
In Taiwan, the economy continued to suffer from a slowing global economy. The first
quarter growth rate fell into negative territory, and the government business monitoring
system flashed “blue”, indicating a recession of ten consecutive months. This ten-month streak was Taiwan’s most protracted recession since the crisis, so for a while the country
struggled to keep its annual GDP growth rate above 1%. Fortunately, the global economy
started to turn for the better in the second half of 2016, and external demand spurred Taiwan’s export growth, pushing the annual GDP growth rate to 1.5%. However, the
economic growth rate was still the second lowest since the crisis, and private consumption
and investment were both slow. Against such a challenging economic backdrop, domestic banks recorded lower net operating incomes and pre-tax net profits compared with 2015,
and the Bank was no exception. Like our peers, our financial performance was lackluster,
and profits were considerably lower than in previous years. Nevertheless, the Bank’s non-financial performance continued to improve, laying a solid foundation for our return to
growth.
Business Performance in 2016
The Bank’s net income after tax in 2016 reached NT$1,055 million, a YOY decrease
of NT$2,240 million. Earnings per share (EPS) was NT$0.63 after tax, a YOY fall of NT$1.33. In the main, both these figures reflect the impact of several factors: a decline in
borrowing demand caused by a sluggish economy and slowing corporate investment,
consumption, and real estate trading; a further squeeze on interest spreads as a result of rate cutting by the central bank, and an increase in bad debt provision following the
target redemption forwards (TRF) trading scandal.
3
The Bank’s net operating profits were NT$6,300 million, while its operating expenses
were NT$3,025 million, giving an operating expense ratio of 48%. Operating profits before bad debt provision came to NT$3,275 million and the budget achievement rate
was approximately 63%. With the deduction of NT$1,565 million in bad debt provision,
pre-tax profits were NT$1,710 million, net income was NT$1,055 million (tax: NT$655 million) and the EPS was NT$0.63. ROAA and ROAE were 0.34% and 3.46%,
respectively.
In terms of asset quality and capital structure, non-performing loans (NPLs),
including collections, amounted to NT$1,658 million, with an NPL ratio of 0.9%. Bad debt
reserves totaled NT$2,604 million, indicating a coverage ratio of 157.08% and a total loan coverage ratio of 1.41%. By the end of 2016, the Bank had a capital adequacy ratio and
Tier 1 Capital of 13.32%, of which 12.75% was common equity. Our robust capital
structure is a strong foundation on which to continue to seek business growth.
It was the Bank’s ample capital levels, moderate asset risks, and well-managed
provision risks that led to our recognition by Fitch, which on September 21, 2016, maintained our long-term national credit rating of A(twn) with a stable outlook.
In the 2016 Services Industry Survey conducted by Taipei-based Global View Magazine, the Bank ranked second among banks that are not part of financial holding
groups and for the third time came fifth among all financial banks. In addition, the official
Bank website received the top AAA certification for accessibility from the National Communications Commission for providing the most friendly financial service
environment for the disabled. Currently, only three financial institutions have received
the top certification, indicating that the Bank’s service quality has been recognized not only by our clients but also by external parties.
As part of our efforts to achieve world-class corporate governance, the Bank has continued to enhance information disclosure, regulatory compliance, risk control,
performance culture, organization, and management systems. As a result, in the last few
years the Bank has been able to establish a brand for itself in the areas of corporate image, product depth, personnel quality, and profitability. In 2016, the Bank also set up
an audit committee to continue to improve the internal monitoring mechanism in the
4
corporate governance regime. In the second corporate governance evaluation conducted by
the Taiwan Stock Exchange, the Bank was ranked among the top 6%–20% bracket among 824 listed companies, a testament to our commitment to enhancing shareholder value.
The Bank has also continued to optimize internal organization in order to enhance efficiency and be ready to tackle market changes. In May 2016, we adjusted the Bank’s
structure and created the positions of Chief Credit Officer and Chief Operating Officer in
order to centralize credit lending and operations and keep these functions separate. By introducing these changes, we have enabled business units to focus more on product
design and client servicing and thus boost business growth momentum. In August 2016,
the Bank merged with its subsidiary An Yin Insurance Brokers Co., Ltd. and set up Insurance Brokerage Department under the Retail Banking Group to take over
operations.
Review of Major Business Operations
As of the end of 2016, the Bank’s total deposits amounted to NT$248.3 billion, a
YOY decrease of approximately NT$0.3 billion owing to strategic adjustments. However, the current account deposit ratio hit a record high. Total loans came to NT$185 billion, a
YOY grow of approximately NT$2 billion, which contributed to a higher loan-to-deposit
ratio and better efficiency for asset liability management. A comprehensive overview of business operations is laid out below.
A. Retail Banking (1) Credit Lending
In 2016, the Bank’s retail loan balances amounted to NT$86.5 billion, roughly the same
level as the previous year. However, a slowing real estate market led to a slight decrease of 2% in our mortgage balances, which came to NT$75.2 billion. In addition to the existing
mortgage business, the Bank has also worked to expand its channels and tap into the
mortgage refinancing market. Personal loan balances (excluding loans under debt relief negotiations) were NT$10.1 billion, a significant YOY increase of 23% thanks to the Bank’s
precise market segmentation and pricing strategy targeting high-quality clients, including
employees of listed companies, government agencies, and medical institutions, and small- and medium-sized enterprises.
5
(2) Wealth Management
Owing to volatilities in financial markets, investors turned conservative and converted most of their assets into insurance policies and fixed-income products. As of the end of 2016,
client asset under management stood at NT$66.6 billion, a YOY growth of 5%. Of these,
insurance assets under management grew by 17%, structured products under management by 32%, while specific money trust investment in domestic and foreign
securities fell by 16%. In addition to cultivating existing clients, we have reached out to a
younger generation of clients by creating a new category of Family Finance Planning Members and continuing to optimize our electronic trading platform. We have also
strengthened our capabilities to design bespoke products in order to expand our base of
professional investors.
(3) Digital Banking
By continuing to enhance our financial infrastructure, the Bank has expanded the accessibility, convenience, diversity, and stability of our financial services. The Bank has a
proven track record in creating a digital financial environment, developing mobile
payments, and pushing for friendly financial services: In 2016, we started offering credit loan and credit card application and wealth management services for our online banking
clients, and the number of applications via online banking and telephone banking grew
by almost 20% on the previous year. In June 2015, our mobile banking app went live and we actively sought to collaborate with electronic payment providers to better serve our
clients’ daily needs in a wider variety of mobile payment scenarios.
B. Corporate Banking and Markets (1) Credit Lending
Our corporate lending balance stood at NT$98.5 billion, a YOY increase of 2%. This growth can be attributed to the Bank’s strategy to reduce real estate lending and increase
lending to general industries as a way to expand the customer base. The Bank was able
to reduce price pressure from competitors by choosing a precise market position and providing customers with professional value-added services. In our main transaction
business, accounts receivable invoice volume reached NT$31.8 billion, the ninth highest in
the market, while trade finance balances amounted to NT$17.8 billion. In addition, the Bank’s Offshore Banking Unit continued to enrich product and service offerings to
comprehensively satisfy customers’ financial needs.
6
(2) Financial Operation Despite a global bond market downturn owing to rising yields in the second half of 2016,
the Bank’s investment and transaction incomes amounted to NT$886 million, thanks to
our flexible asset allocation strategy, rigorous trading discipline, precise forecast of interest rate trends, and gains on disposal of bonds. Of the investment and transaction incomes,
gains on financial assets and liabilities at fair value through profit or loss stood at
NT$708 million, a YOY decrease of 39%, and realized gains on available-for-sale financial assets came to NT$272 million, a YOY increase of 30%.
(3) Financial Marketing Following a sharp decline in the Chinese renminbi, on March 9, 2016, the Bank’s board
approved a decision to suspend high-risk derivatives trading, leading to a significant
decrease in income from our financial marketing operations. The Bank’s derivative transaction volumes amounted to NT$72.7 billion.
Aiming to Reload the Momentum
Looking ahead, the global economy is expected to gradually recover, and according
to forecasts by major international institutions, the 2017 economic growth rate will be slightly higher than that of the previous year, although momentum will be restrained and countries
will not grow in unison. Moreover, there are still a number of downside risks on the
horizon, including the direction of US economic and trade policies, the challenges faced by China as it restructures its economy, the start of the Brexit process, European election
jitters, rising geopolitical tensions, and volatilities in oil and commodity prices. All these
uncertainties may threaten the global economic outlook and financial market stability.
In Taiwan, exports are expected to grow as external demand picks up, and the
government’s projects to push for innovative industries and advanced infrastructure will have a positive impact on domestic demand. On February 15, 2017, the
Directorate-General of Budget, Accounting, and Statistics forecast that the 2017 growth
rate for Taiwan will be 1.92%, outperforming the previous year.
7
As the rate-cutting cycle is nearing an end, the banking industry will get a respite
from the constant squeeze on interest spreads. However, rising labor costs in Taiwan may put a cap on corporate investment, and more stringent regulatory supervision
means more investment of resources in anti-money laundering, anti-terrorist financing,
and IT security operations. All these factors will put pressure on the banking industry; therefore, the Bank will review and analyze the implications of the regulations and
communicate with the regulator as necessary. Overall, the Bank is cautiously optimistic
towards its operational outlook this year. In this volatile politico-economic and business environment, we will continue to strengthen our operational management and business
promotion and use resources in a flexible manner to keep abreast of market trends and
business opportunities and so balance our income structure, reduce risk concentration, and put the Bank firmly on the path to growth.
Faced with these challenges, we will continue to rely on our determination and resilience to keep our team united and put into practice our core philosophy of providing
“speedy, professional, and trustworthy services”. We hope that our core philosophy will
create maximum investment value for our shareholders and help us return to glory with business performance that earns universal acclaim.
Chairman President Head of Accounting Department
8
(2) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: To note for record the Audit Committee’s Review
Report on the 2016 Financial Statements Explanation: The Audit Committee has checked the Bank’s 2016
Financial Statements. The Audit Committee’s Audit Report is submitted to the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders for record (please see details on page 10 of this Agenda Handbook) in accordance with Article 219 of the Company Act as prescribed in paragraph 3 of Article 14-4 of Securities and Exchange Act.
9
Audit Committee’s Review Report
We have checked the business report, Earning Distribution Table, the financial
statements prepared by the Bank and audited in advance by KPMG for the year of
2016 and found no items that are inaccurate. This report is submitted in accordance
with Article 219 of the Company Act as prescribed in paragraph 3 of Article 14-4 of
Securities and Exchange Act.
To: Annual General Meeting of the Shareholders of EnTie Commercial Bank, 2017
Audit Committee of EnTie Commercial Bank, Co. Ltd.
Convener:Philippe Espinasse
April 25, 2017
10
(3) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: To note for record the Distribution of Employees’
Compensation and Directors’ and Supervisors’ remuneration for 2016
Explanation: 1. This proposal is prepared in accordance with Article 39 of the Articles of Incorporation of the Bank.
2. The proposal for Distribution of 2016 Employees’ Compensation and Directors’ & Supervisors’ Remuneration was approved at the 6th board meeting of the 9th term held on April 25, 2017.
3. The profit of the Bank in 2016 is NT$1,735,209,258 (i.e. the Before-Tax Income prior to the deductions of Employees’ Compensation and Directors’ & Supervisors’ Remuneration). The proposed of Employees’ Compensation and Directors’ & Supervisors’ Remuneration of 2016 are NT$19,864,847 and NT$5,182,134 respectively, and will be made at the rate of 1.14% and 0.3% of the profit of the Bank and distributed in cash.
4. The 2016 directors’ compensation declined due to the decreased net income of the Bank, the average total remuneration paid to each director (including the annual compensations, remunerations and travel expenses; exclusion of the salary paid to the director who concurrently serves as an employee) shows a YOY increase of NT$781,000 mainly resulted from the reorganization and the establishment of Audit Committee of the Bank, which requires more responsibilities and participations from the chairman and independent directors on bankwide business. The Bank therefore adjusted the compensations of chairman and independent directors by referencing the industry standard, and the said were approved at the 21st board meeting of the 8th term and the 2nd board meeting of the 9th term respectively.
11
(4) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: To note for record the Revise Report for the “Criteria
Governing Codes of Ethical Conduct” of the Bank (the “Criteria”)
Explanation: 1. This proposal is prepared in accordance with Article 5 of the Criteria which stipulates, “The Criteria, and any amendments to it, shall enter into force after it has been adopted by the board of directors, delivered to each independent directors, and hereby is submitted to a shareholders meeting for record”.
2. In view of the Bank had established the Audit Committee to replace supervisors after the election of the 9th term board of directors on June 8, 2016, we hereby revise the Criteria accordingly. Please refer to pages 13 to 19 of this Agenda Handbook for the comparison table of changes made to the Criteria.
3. The revised proposal of the Criteria was approved by the president with the delegation granted at the 1st extraordinary board meeting of the 9th term held on June 8, 2016 for signing off all necessary revisions and amendments that are related only to the replacement of supervisors’ role with an audit committee to all internal regulations, and is submitted to the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders for record.
12
The Comparison Table of Current and Revised Articles of Current and Revised Articles for Criteria Governing Codes of Ethical Conduct,
Entie Commercial Bank Proposed Revision Current articles Description
Article 1 (Purpose and scope of the Criteria)
The Criteria is adopted for the purpose of encouraging directors and managerial officers (including general managers or their equivalents, assistant general managers or their equivalents, deputy assistant general managers or their equivalents, chief financial and chief accounting officers, and other persons authorized to manage affairs and sign documents on behalf of the Bank) of EnTie Commercial Bank (the “Bank”) to act in line with ethical standards.
Article 1 (Purpose and scope of the Criteria) The Criteria is adopted for the purpose of encouraging directors, supervisors, and managerial officers (including general managers or their equivalents, assistant general managers or their equivalents, deputy assistant general managers or their equivalents, chief financial and chief accounting officers, and other persons authorized to manage affairs and sign documents on behalf of the Bank) of EnTie Commercial Bank (the “Bank”) to act in line with ethical standards.
The Bank had established the Audit Committee to replace supervisors after the election of the 9th term board of directors on June 8, 2016. Thus, the term “supervisors” is deleted.
Article 2 (Content of the Criteria)
Matters to be followed by directors and managerial officers are as follows: 1. Prevention of conflicts of interests
A director and managerial officer of the Bank, and a person authorized to manage affairs and sign documents on behalf of the Bank shall perform their duties in an objective and efficient manner, and shall not take
Article 2 (Content of the Criteria) Matters to be followed by directors, supervisors and managerial officers are as follows: 1. Prevention of conflicts of interests
A director, supervisor, and managerial officer of the Bank, and a person authorized to manage affairs and sign documents on behalf of the Bank shall perform their duties in an objective and
The Bank had established the Audit Committee to replace supervisors after the election of the 9th term board of directors on June 8, 2016. Thus, the term “supervisors” is deleted; also, the phrase
13
advantage of their positions to benefit for either themselves or their spouses, parents, children, or relatives within the second degree of kinship. Should the Bank provide loans of funds or guarantees to, or have major asset transactions or the purchase (or sale) of goods with the affiliated enterprise at which a director and managerial officer works, such persons shall voluntarily explain whether there is any potential conflict between them and the Bank.
2. Minimizing incentives to pursue personal gain
Directors and managerial officers shall not engage in any of the following activities:
(items (1) & (2) omitted) (3) Competing with the Bank.
When the Bank has an opportunity for profit, it is the responsibility of the directors and managerial officers to maximize the reasonable and proper benefits that can be obtained by the Bank.
3. Prevention of unethical behavior
Directors and managerial
efficient manner, and shall not take advantage of their positions to benefit for either themselves or their spouses, parents, children, or relatives within the second degree of kinship. Should the Bank provide loans of funds or guarantees to, or have major asset transactions or the purchase (or sale) of goods with the affiliated enterprise at which a director, supervisor and managerial officer works, such persons shall voluntarily explain whether there is any potential conflict between them and the Bank.
2. Minimizing incentives to pursue personal gain
Directors, supervisors, and managerial officers shall not engage in any of the following activities:
(items (1) & (2) omitted) (3) Competing with the Bank.
When the Bank has an opportunity for profit, it is the responsibility of the directors, supervisors, and managerial officers to maximize the reasonable and proper benefits that can be obtained by the Bank.
“report to a supervisor” is replaced by “report to an independent director”.
14
officers shall perform their duties in an impartial, ethical and fair manner, and shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise, request or receive improper benefits, or have unethical activities in violation of ethical principles, a law or regulation, or breach of fiduciary duty for the purpose of obtaining or maintaining personal gain.
4. Confidentiality
Directors and managerial officers shall be bound by the obligation to maintain the confidentiality of any information regarding the Bank itself or its clients, except when authorized or required by law to disclose such information. Confidential information includes any undisclosed information that, if exploited by a competitor or disclosed, could result in damage to the Bank or its clients.
5. Fair trade
Directors and managerial officers shall treat all clients, competitors, and employees fairly, and may not obtain improper benefits through manipulation, nondisclosure,
3. Prevention of unethical behavior
Directors, supervisors, and managerial officers shall perform their duties in an impartial, ethical and fair manner, and shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise, request or receive improper benefits, or have unethical activities in violation of ethical principles, a law or regulation, or breach of fiduciary duty for the purpose of obtaining or maintaining personal gain.
4. Confidentiality
Directors, supervisors, and managerial officers shall be bound by the obligation to maintain the confidentiality of any information regarding the Bank itself or its clients, except when authorized or required by law to disclose such information. Confidential information includes any undisclosed information that, if exploited by a competitor or disclosed, could result in damage to the Bank or its clients.
5. Fair trade
Directors, supervisors, and
15
or misuse of the information learned by virtue of their positions, or through misrepresentation of important matters, or through other unfair trading practices.
6. Safeguarding and proper use of Bank assets
All directors and managerial officers have the responsibility to safeguard Bank assets and to ensure that they can be effectively and lawfully used for official business purposes.
7. Legal compliance
Directors and managerial officers shall comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and other applicable laws, regulations, and bylaws.
8. Encouraging reporting on illegal or unethical activities
The Bank shall encourage employees to report to an independent director, managerial officer, chief auditor, or other appropriate individual upon suspicion or discovery of any activity in violation of a law or regulation or the Criteria. To encourage employees to report illegal conduct, the Bank shall establish a concrete
managerial officers shall treat all clients, competitors, and employees fairly, and may not obtain improper benefits through manipulation, nondisclosure, or misuse of the information learned by virtue of their positions, or through misrepresentation of important matters, or through other unfair trading practices.
6. Safeguarding and proper use of Bank assets
All directors, supervisors, and managerial officers have the responsibility to safeguard Bank assets and to ensure that they can be effectively and lawfully used for official business purposes.
7. Legal compliance
Directors, supervisors, and managerial officers shall comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and other applicable laws, regulations, and bylaws
8. Encouraging reporting on illegal or unethical activities
The Bank shall encourage employees to report to a supervisor, managerial officer, chief auditor, or other
16
whistle-blowing system and make employees aware that the Bank will use its best efforts to ensure the safety of informants and protect them from reprisals.
9. Disciplinary measures
When a director or a managerial officer violates the Criteria, the Bank shall handle the matter in accordance with the Company Act, Articles of Incorporation of the Bank, and relevant internal regulations, and shall without delay disclose on the Market Observation Post System (MOPS) the date of the violation, reasons for the violation, the provisions of the code violated, and the disciplinary actions taken. A violator penalized for violation of the Criteria could appeal for remedies in accordance with relevant regulations if he/she feels needed.
appropriate individual upon suspicion or discovery of any activity in violation of a law or regulation or the Criteria. To encourage employees to report illegal conduct, the Bank shall establish a concrete whistle-blowing system and make employees aware that the Bank will use its best efforts to ensure the safety of informants and protect them from reprisals.
9. Disciplinary measures
When a director, supervisor, or a managerial officer violates the Criteria, the Bank shall handle the matter in accordance with the Company Act, Articles of Incorporation of the Bank, and relevant internal regulations, and shall without delay disclose on the Market Observation Post System (MOPS) the date of the violation, reasons for the violation, the provisions of the code violated, and the disciplinary actions taken. A violator penalized for violation of the Criteria could appeal for remedies in accordance with relevant regulations if he/she feels needed.
17
Article 3 (Procedures for exemption) Any exemption for directors and managerial officers from compliance with the Criteria shall be adopted by a resolution of the board of directors, and information on the date on which the board of directors adopted the resolution for exemption, objections or reservations of independent directors, and the period of, reasons for, and principles behind the application of the exemption shall be disclosed without delay on the MOPS, in order that the shareholders may evaluate the appropriateness of the board resolution to forestall any arbitrary or dubious exemption from the Criteria, and to safeguard the interests of the Bank by ensuring appropriate mechanisms for controlling any circumstance under which such an exemption occurs.
Article 3 (Procedures for exemption) Any exemption for directors, supervisors, and managerial officers from compliance with the Criteria shall be adopted by a resolution of the board of directors, and information on the date on which the board of directors adopted the resolution for exemption, objections or reservations of independent directors, and the period of, reasons for, and principles behind the application of the exemption shall be disclosed without delay on the MOPS, in order that the shareholders may evaluate the appropriateness of the board resolution to forestall any arbitrary or dubious exemption from the Criteria, and to safeguard the interests of the Bank by ensuring appropriate mechanisms for controlling any circumstance under which such an exemption occurs.
The Bank had established the Audit Committee to replace supervisors after the election of the 9th term board of directors on June 8, 2016. Thus, the term “supervisors” is deleted.
Article 5 (Enforcement) The Criteria, and any
amendments to it, shall enter into force after it has been adopted by the board of directors, delivered to each independent director, and submitted to a shareholders meeting for record.
Article 5 (Enforcement) The Criteria, and any
amendments to it, shall enter into force after it has been adopted by the board of directors, delivered to each supervisor, and submitted to a shareholders meeting for record.
The Bank had established the Audit Committee to replace supervisors after the election of the 9th term board of
18
directors on June 8, 2016. Thus, the term “supervisors” is replaced by “independent director”.
19
(5) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: To note for record the Revise Report for the “Criteria
for Ethical Corporate Management” of the Bank (the “Criteria”)
Explanation: 1. This proposal is prepared in accordance with Article 27 of the Criteria which stipulates, “The Criteria of the Bank shall be implemented after the board of directors grants the approval, and shall be sent to the independent directors and reported at a shareholders’ meeting. The same procedure shall be followed when the Criteria have been amended”.
2. In view of the Bank had established the Audit Committee to replace supervisors after the election of the 9th term board of directors on June 8, 2016, we hereby revise the Criteria accordingly. Please refer to pages 21 to 29 of this Agenda Handbook for the comparison table of changes made to the Criteria.
3. The revised proposal of the Criteria was approved by the president with the delegation granted at the 1st extraordinary board meeting of the 9th term held on June 8, 2016 for signing off all necessary revisions and amendments that are related only to the replacement of supervisors’ role with an audit committee to all internal regulations, and is submitted to the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders for record.
20
The Comparison Table of Current and Revised Articles for the Criteria for Ethical Corporate Management,
Entie Commercial Bank Proposed revision Current articles Description Article 2 (Preventing Unethical Conduct) When engaging in commercial activities, directors, managers, employees, mandataries of the Bank or persons having substantial control over the bank (short as “Substantial Controllers” hereafter) shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise to offer, request or accept any improper Benefits, nor commit unethical acts including breach of ethics, illegal acts, or breach of fiduciary duty (short as “Unethical Conduct” hereafter) for purposes of acquiring or maintaining Benefits. (Paragraph 2 omitted)
Article 2 (Preventing Unethical Conduct) When engaging in commercial activities, directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries of the Bank or persons having substantial control over the bank (short as “Substantial Controllers” hereafter) shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise to offer, request or accept any improper Benefits, nor commit unethical acts including breach of ethics, illegal acts, or breach of fiduciary duty (short as “Unethical Conduct” hereafter) for purposes of acquiring or maintaining Benefits. (Paragraph 2 omitted)
The Bank had established the Audit Committee to replace supervisors after the election of the 9th term board of directors on June 8, 2016. Thus, the term of “supervisors” is deleted.
Article 10 (Forbidding Bribery and Receiving Brides) When conducting business, the Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers, shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise to offer, request, or accept any improper Benefits in other ways from clients, trading counterparties, public servants, or other interested parties.
Article 10 (Forbidding Bribery and Receiving Brides) When conducting business, the Bank and its directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers, shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise to offer, request, or accept any improper Benefits in other ways from clients, trading counterparties, public servants, or other interested parties.
Same as above
21
Article 11 (Forbidding Illegal Political Donations) When directly or indirectly offering a donation to political parties or organizations or individuals participating in political activities, the Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers, shall comply with the Political Donations Act and their own relevant internal operational procedures, and shall not make such donations in exchange for commercial gains or business advantages.
Article 11 (Forbidding Illegal Political Donations) When directly or indirectly offering a donation to political parties or organizations or individuals participating in political activities, the Bank and its directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers, shall comply with the Political Donations Act and their own relevant internal operational procedures, and shall not make such donations in exchange for commercial gains or business advantages.
Same as above
Article 12 (Forbidding Improper Donations and Sponsorship) When making or offering donations and sponsorship, the Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall comply with relevant laws and regulations and internal operational procedures, and shall not surreptitiously engage in bribery.
Article 12 (Forbidding Improper Donations and Sponsorship) When making or offering donations and sponsorship, the Bank and its directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall comply with relevant laws and regulations and internal operational procedures, and shall not surreptitiously engage in bribery.
Same as above
Article 13 (Forbidding Giving out/Receiving Unreasonable Presents, Hospitality or Other Improper Benefits) The Bank and its directors, managers, employees,
Article 13 (Forbidding Giving out/Receiving Unreasonable Presents, Hospitality or Other Improper Benefits) The Bank and its directors, supervisors, managers,
Same as above
22
mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall not directly or indirectly offer or accept any unreasonable presents, hospitality or other improper Benefits to establish business relationship or influence commercial transactions.
employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall not directly or indirectly offer or accept any unreasonable presents, hospitality or other improper Benefits to establish business relationship or influence commercial transactions.
Article 14 (Forbidding Infringing Intellectual Property Rights) The Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall observe applicable laws and regulations, internal operational procedures, and contractual provisions concerning intellectual property, and may not use, disclose, dispose, or damage intellectual property or otherwise infringe intellectual property rights without the prior consent of the intellectual property rights holder.
Article 14 (Forbidding Infringing Intellectual Property Rights) The Bank and its directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall observe applicable laws and regulations, internal operational procedures, and contractual provisions concerning intellectual property, and may not use, disclose, dispose, or damage intellectual property or otherwise infringe intellectual property rights without the prior consent of the intellectual property rights holder.
Same as above
Article 16 (Preventing Products and Services Damaging Stakeholders) In the course of research and development, procurement, provision, or sale of products and services, the Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandatories and Substantial Controllers shall observe applicable laws and regulations
Article 16 (Preventing Products and Services Damaging Stakeholders) In the course of research and development, procurement, provision, or sale of products and services, the Bank and its directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandatories and Substantial Controllers shall observe applicable laws and
Same as above
23
and international standards to ensure the transparency of information about, and safety of their financial products and services. They shall also adopt and publish a policy on the protection of the rights and interests of consumers or other stakeholders, and carry out the policy in their operations, with a view to preventing their products and services from directly or indirectly damaging the rights and interests, health, and safety of consumers or other stakeholders. Where there are sufficient facts to determine that the Bank’s services are likely to pose any hazard to the safety and health of consumers or other stakeholders, the Bank shall in principle, suspend the services immediately.
regulations and international standards to ensure the transparency of information about, and safety of their financial products and services. They shall also adopt and publish a policy on the protection of the rights and interests of consumers or other stakeholders, and carry out the policy in their operations, with a view to preventing their products and services from directly or indirectly damaging the rights and interests, health, and safety of consumers or other stakeholders. Where there are sufficient facts to determine that the Bank’s services are likely to pose any hazard to the safety and health of consumers or other stakeholders, the Bank shall in principle, suspend the services immediately.
Article 17 (Organization and Responsibility)
The directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers of the Bank shall exercise the due care of good administrators to urge the company to prevent Unethical Conduct, always review the results of the preventive measures and continually make adjustments so as to ensure thorough implementation of its
Article 17 (Organization and Responsibility) The directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers of the Bank shall exercise the due care of good administrators to urge the company to prevent Unethical Conduct, always review the results of the preventive measures and continually make adjustments so as to ensure thorough
Same as above
24
ethical corporate management policies. (Paragraph 2 omitted)
implementation of its ethical corporate management policies. (Paragraph 2 omitted)
Article 18 (Legal Compliance of Conducting Business) The Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall comply with laws and regulations and the Prevention Program when conducting business. (Paragraph 2 omitted)
Article 18 (Legal Compliance of Conducting Business) The Bank and its directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall comply with laws and regulations and the Prevention Program when conducting business. (Paragraph 2 omitted)
Same as above
Article 19 (Preventing Conflicts of Interest) The Bank shall promulgate policies for preventing conflicts of interest to identify, monitor, and manage risks possibly resulting from Unethical Conduct, and shall also offer appropriate means for directors, managers, and other stakeholders attending or present at board meetings to voluntarily explain whether their interests would potentially conflict with those of the Bank.
When a proposal at a given board of directors meeting concerns the personal interest of, or the interest of the juristic person represented by, any of the directors, managers, and other stakeholders attending or present at board meetings, the concerned person shall state the
Article 19 (Preventing Conflicts of Interest) The Bank shall promulgate policies for preventing conflicts of interest to identify, monitor, and manage risks possibly resulting from Unethical Conduct, and shall also offer appropriate means for directors, supervisors, managers, and other stakeholders attending or present at board meetings to voluntarily explain whether their interests would potentially conflict with those of the Bank. When a proposal at a given board of directors meeting concerns the personal interest of, or the interest of the juristic person represented by, any of the directors, supervisors, managers, and other stakeholders attending or present at board meetings, the
Same as above
25
important aspects of the relationship of interest at the given board meeting. If his or her participation is likely to prejudice the interest of the Bank, the concerned person may not participate in discussion of or voting on the proposal and shall recuse himself or herself from the discussion or the voting, and may not exercise voting rights as proxy for another director. The directors shall practice self-discipline and must not support one another in improper dealings.
The Bank’s directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall not take advantage of their positions or influence in the Bank to obtain improper Benefits for themselves, their spouses, parents, children or any other person.
concerned person shall state the important aspects of the relationship of interest at the given board meeting. If his or her participation is likely to prejudice the interest of the Bank, the concerned person may not participate in discussion of or voting on the proposal and shall recuse himself or herself from the discussion or the voting, and may not exercise voting rights as proxy for another director. The directors shall practice self-discipline and must not support one another in improper dealings. The Bank’s directors¸ supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall not take advantage of their positions or influence in the Bank to obtain improper Benefits for themselves, their spouses, parents, children or any other person.
Article 21 (Operational Procedures and Code of Conduct) The Bank shall establish operational procedures and code of conduct in accordance with Article 6 hereof to guide directors, managers, employees, and Substantial Controllers on how to conduct business. The
Article 21 (Operational Procedures and Code of Conduct) The Bank shall establish operational procedures and code of conduct in accordance with Article 6 hereof to guide directors, supervisors, managers, employees, and Substantial Controllers on how to conduct
Same as above
26
procedures and guidelines should at least contain the following matters: (Subparagraphs 1 to 8 omitted)
business. The procedures and guidelines should at least contain the following matters: (Subparagraphs 1 to 8 omitted)
Article 22 (Educational Training and Performance Appraisal) The Chairman, the President or the upper level of management of the Bank shall communicate the importance of corporate ethics to its directors, employees, and mandataries on a regular basis. The Bank shall periodically organize training and awareness programs for directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers, so they understand the Bank’s resolve to implement ethical corporate management, the related policies, Prevention Program and the consequences of committing Unethical Conduct. (Paragraph 3 omitted)
Article 22 (Educational Training and Performance Appraisal) The Chairman, the President or the upper level of management of the Bank shall communicate the importance of corporate ethics to its directors, employees, and mandataries on a regular basis. The Bank shall periodically organize training and awareness programs for directors, supervisors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers, so they understand the Bank’s resolve to implement ethical corporate management, the related policies, Prevention Program and the consequences of committing Unethical Conduct. (Paragraph 3 omitted)
Same as above
Article 23 (Reporting and Disciplinary Actions) (Paragraph 1 omitted) When material misconduct or likelihood of material impairment to the Bank comes to its awareness upon investigation, the dedicated personnel or unit handling the whistle-blowing system shall immediately prepare
Article 23 (Reporting and Disciplinary Actions) (Paragraph 1 omitted) When material misconduct or likelihood of material impairment to the Bank comes to its awareness upon investigation, the dedicated personnel or unit handling the whistle-blowing system shall immediately prepare
Same as above
27
a report and notify the independent directors in written form.
a report and notify the independent directors or supervisors in written form.
Article 26 (Review of the Policies and Measures of Ethical Management) The Bank shall at all times monitor the development of relevant local and international regulations concerning ethical corporate management, and encourage directors, managers and employees to make suggestions based on which the adopted ethical corporate management policies and measures taken will be reviewed and improved with a view to achieving better implementation of ethical management.
Article 26 (Review of the Policies and Measures of Ethical Management) The Bank shall at all times monitor the development of relevant local and international regulations concerning ethical corporate management, and encourage directors, supervisors, managers and employees to make suggestions based on which the adopted ethical corporate management policies and measures taken will be reviewed and improved with a view to achieving better implementation of ethical management.
Same as above
Article 27 (Implementation) The Criteria of the Bank shall
be implemented after the board of directors grants the approval, and shall be sent to the independent directors and reported at a shareholders’ meeting. The same procedure shall be followed when the Criteria have been amended.
When the Criteria is submitted for discussion by the board of directors pursuant to the preceding paragraph, the board of directors shall take into full
Article 27 (Implementation) The Criteria of the Bank shall
be implemented after the board of directors grants the approval, and shall be sent to the supervisors and reported at a shareholders’ meeting. The same procedure shall be followed when the Criteria have been amended.
When the Criteria is submitted for discussion by the board of directors pursuant to the preceding paragraph, the board of directors shall take into full consideration each independent
The Bank had established the Audit Committee to replace supervisors after the election of the 9th term board of directors on June 8, 2016. Thus, the term of “supervisors” is deleted and replaced by “independent
28
consideration each independent director’s opinions. If an independent director objects to or expresses reservations about any matter, it shall be recorded in the minutes of the board of directors meeting. An independent director intending to express objection or reservations but unable to attend the meeting in person shall, unless there is some legitimate reason to do otherwise, issue a written opinion in advance, which shall be recorded in the meeting minutes.
director’s opinions. If an independent director objects to or expresses reservations about any matter, it shall be recorded in the minutes of the board of directors meeting. An independent director intending to express objection or reservations but unable to attend the meeting in person shall, unless there is some legitimate reason to do otherwise, issue a written opinion in advance, which shall be recorded in the meeting minutes.
After the Bank establishes the audit committee, the Criteria shall apply mutatis mutandis to the audit committee.
directors” to be in line with the intent of notification; meanwhile, the Sunrise Clause is be deleted since the Audit Committee has been established.
29
(6) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: To note for record the Revise Report for the “Criteria
for Corporate Social Responsibility Best Practice” of the Bank
Explanation: 1. In accordance with the revised “Corporate Social Responsibility Best Practice Principles for TWSE/GTSM Listed Companies”, which was announced by the Taiwan Stock Exchange Corporation (TWSE) per letter No. 1050014103 dated July 28, 2016, we hereby revise the “Criteria for Corporate Social Responsibility Best Practice” (“the Criteria”) of the Bank. Please see details from pages 31 to 33 of this Agenda Handbook for the comparison table of changes made to the Criteria.
2. This proposal was approved at the 3rd board meeting of the 9th term held on Oct. 22, 2016, and is submitted to the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders for record.
30
The Comparison Table of Current and Revised Articles for Corporate Social Responsibility Best Practice, EnTie Commercial Bank
Proposed revision Current articles Description
Article 7 The Board of Directors shall exercise
the due care of good administrators
to urge the Bank to perform its corporate social responsibility
initiatives, examine the results of the
implementation thereof from time to time and continually make
adjustments so as to ensure the
thorough implementation of its corporate social responsibility
policies.
The Board of Directors is advised to consider the interests of interested
parties and uphold corporate social
responsibility by performing the following:
1. Identifying the company's
corporate social responsibility mission or vision, and declaring its
corporate social responsibility
policies, systems or relevant management principles.
2. Making corporate social
responsibility the guiding principle of the company's operations and
development, and approving
concrete plan of corporate social responsibility.
3. Enhancing the disclosure of
corporate social responsibility
Article 7 The Board of Directors shall exercise
the due care of good administrators
to urge the Bank to perform its corporate social responsibility
initiatives, examine the results of the
implementation thereof from time to time and continually make
adjustments so as to ensure the
thorough implementation of its corporate social responsibility
policies.
The Board of Directors is advised to uphold corporate social responsibility
by performing the following:
1. Identifying the company's corporate social responsibility mission
or vision, and declaring its corporate
social responsibility policies, systems or relevant management principles.
2. Making corporate social
responsibility the guiding principle of the company's operations and
development, and approving
concrete plan of corporate social responsibility.
3. Enhancing the disclosure of
corporate social responsibility information timely and correctly.
As for the economy, environment and
social issues resulting from the
1. Article is amended
2. The wording is
amended pursuant to
Article 7 of the
“Corporate Social
Responsibility
Best Practice Principles for
TWSE/GTSM
Listed Companies”
31
Proposed revision Current articles Description
information timely and correctly.
As for the economy, environment and
social issues resulting from the Bank’s operation, the Board of
Directors shall authorize the upper
level of management to deal with the issues and report their processing
situation. The processing
procedure and related accountable persons should be defined concretely
and unequivocally.
Bank’s operation, the Board of
Directors shall authorize the upper
level of management to deal with the issues and report their processing
situation. The processing procedure
and related accountable persons should be defined concretely and
unequivocally.
Article 22-1 The Bank is advised to treat its
customers or consumers fairly by
implementing the following principles: fairness and good faith, due care and
fiduciary duty, truthfulness of
advertising, suitability of products or services, duty of disclosure, duty
regarding sale of complex, high-risk
products, equitable performance-based compensation
plans, protection of complainants,
professionalism of sales personnel etc., and revise related executed
strategy and concrete measures.
1. New article 2. Nine principles
of the
“Principles for Financial
Services
Enterprises to Treat
Customers
Fairly” are included as
part of the
Criteria pursuant to
Article 22-1 of
the “Corporate Social
Responsibility
Best Practice Principles for
TWSE/GTSM
Listed
32
Proposed revision Current articles Description
Companies”
Article 26 The Bank shall consider the impact of
their business operations on the
community and use qualified personnel to enhance community
acceptance.
The Bank may, through equity investment, commercial activities,
donations of goods and materials,
volunteering services or other pro bono services, etc., invest in
organizations that solve social or
environmental issues through business operations, or participate in
events held by citizen groups,
charities, and government agencies for community development and
education to accelerate the
development of community.
Article 26 The Bank shall consider the impact of
their business operations on the
community and use qualified personnel to enhance community
acceptance.
The Bank may, through commercial activities, donations of goods and
materials, volunteering services or
other pro bono services, participate in events held by citizen groups,
charities, and local government
agencies for community development and education to accelerate the
development of community.
1. Article is amended
2. Pursuant to
Article 27 of the “Corporate
Social
Responsibility Best Practice
Principles for
TWSE/GTSM Listed
Companies”,
the article is amended to
stipulate that
the Bank is advised to
participate or
invest in organizations
that solve social
or environmental
issues through
business operations.
33
(7) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: To note for record the short-form merger report
between An Yin Insurance Brokers Co., Ltd. and the Bank
Explanation: 1.Pursuant to paragraph 1 of Article 19 of the Business Mergers and Acquisitions Act (Article 19(1)), in case a parent company merges with its subsidiary company whose ninety percent or more of the total number of the issued shares is held by the parent company, the merger agreement may be concluded upon a resolution to be adopted separately at the Board meeting of each company by a majority vote of the directors present at the meeting attended by directors representing two-thirds or more of the directors of the respective companies. Also, as regulated in paragraph 2 of Article 7 of the same Act, the Board of Directors shall submit reports for matters of the merger/consolidation and acquisition adopted under Article 19(1) at the next closest general meeting. The Bank merged with its 100% held subsidiary company, An Yin Insurance Brokers Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “An Yin Insurance Brokers”), on August 1, 2016 pursuant to the aforementioned regulations. Keynotes of the merger are explained below: (1) To effectively integrate resources and reduce
the management costs, the resolution that the Bank merged with An Yin Insurance Brokers pursuant to Article 19 of the Business Mergers and Acquisitions Act was adopted by the Boards of both companies on June 21, 2016, which resolved that the Bank would be the surviving
34
company and An Yin Insurance Brokers would be the dissolved company. The merger has been completed, and the reference date of the merger was August 1, 2016. As permission for the Bank to engage in insurance brokerage business has been granted, the Insurance Brokerage Department undertook the business formerly conducted by An Yin Insurance Brokers.
(2) The aforementioned merger has been approved and filed pursuant to Letter No. 10501204290 from the Ministry of Economic Affairs.
(3) As An Yin Insurance Brokers was 100% owned by the Bank, the merger was carried out as a short-form merger in accordance with Article 19 of the Business Mergers and Acquisitions Act. Shareholders’ equity was not affected as the Bank neither issued new shares nor distributed cash or other assets for the said merger.
2.The proposal was approved at the 5th board
meeting of the 9th term held on Mar. 2, 2017, and is submitted to the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders for record.
35
2. Acknowledgment Items: (1) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: Adoption of the 2016 Business Report and Financial
Statements Explanation:
1. The Bank’s Business Report and Financial Statements of year 2016 which were approved for submission by Audit Committee at the 5th and 6th audit committee meetings of the 1st term held on March 2, 2017 and April 25, 2017 respectively. The same were approved by the Board at the 5th and 6th board meetings of the 9th term held on March 2, 2017 and April 25, 2017 respectively.
2. The financial documents stated in the proposal include the Business Report, also listed in Reporting Item 1 (please see details from pages 3 to 8 of this Agenda Handbook), the financial statements, inclusive of the auditors’ report, balance sheets, statements of comprehensive income, statements of changes in equity, and statements of cash flows (please see details from pages 37 to 45 of this Agenda Handbook).
Resolution:
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
(2) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: Adoption of the Proposal for Distribution of 2016
Profits (please see details on page 49 of this Agenda Handbook)
Explanation: 1. The Proposal for Distribution of 2016 Profits was approved at the 6th board meeting of the 9th term on April 25, 2017.
2. According to IFRS 7, the Bank had set aside NT$398,786,964 for preferred stock dividend expense. The Bank’s pre-tax net profit for the year of 2016 is NT$1,710,162,277. The net profit after tax is NT$1,054,678,898 after the deduction of tax expenses NT$655,483,379.
3. According to the letters bearing ref. No. 86217699 issued by the Ministry of Economic Affairs dated September 23, 1997, “Before making distribution of earnings after paying tax, the companies should set aside legal reserve”, and ref. No. 0950000507 issued by the Financial Supervisory Commission dated January 27, 2006 “Listed and over-the-counter companies shall recognize or reverse special reserve for deductions of stockholders’ equity, which includes unrealized gains/losses of financial instruments, cumulative translation adjustment, net losses not recognized as pension cost; Unrealized gains can be combined with losses if available.” After the appropriation of a legal reserve of NT$316,403,669, a special reserve of NT$7,298,506 as deduction of stockholders’ equity, and a special reserve of NT$5,273,394 for career transfer education and training in respond to FinTech impact in 2016, the remaining earnings for distribution of the Bank is
46
NT$725,703,329. With the addition to the beginning balance of undistributed retained earnings of NT$5,928,654,241, and actuarial gains/losses on defined benefit plans of NT$595,355 for change in actuarial income/loss in 2016, the total retained earnings of 2016 available for common stock dividend distribution is NT$6,654,952,925.
4. As of December 31, 2016, the total issued and outstanding common shares of the Bank were 1,679,677,506 shares. The total amount of cash dividends which the Bank plans to distribute is NT$1,007,806,504, which in average is approximately NT$0.6 per share.
5. The amount of common share cash dividends and preferred share dividends would be rounded down to the whole NT dollar amount. The combined total of a fraction of NT$1 calculated under the aforementioned method should be included in the Bank’s miscellaneous income account. The dividends would be distributed upon approval from shareholders at the Annual General Meeting of shareholders along with an additional authorization to the board of directors to set the ex-dividend date and dividend distribution methods later on.
6. Please also authorize the board of directors to adjust the payout ratio based on the actual numbers of outstanding shares on the ex-dividend date, and make related adjustments in accordance with the regulations if there is any increment/deduction to the common shares outstanding due to stock repurchasing, transferring, cancellation, or other conditions, which may result in changes in the
47
number of outstanding shares on the ex-dividend date after the earnings distribution plan is approved.
Resolution:
48
Entie Commercial Bank, Ltd.
Earning Distribution Table
For the Year of 2016
Unit: NTD
2016 Current Term Pre-Tax Net Profit
1,710,162,277
Subtract: Tax Expense
(655,483,379) 2016 Current Term After-Tax Net Profit
1,054,678,898
Subtract: 30% of Tax Net Profit as Legal Reserve (316,403,669) Subtract: Special Reserve for Deduction of Stockholders' Equity (7,298,506) Subtract: Special Reserve for Career Transfer Education and
Training in Respond to FinTech Impact (5,273,394)
Total Distributable Amount
725,703,329 Plus: Beginning Undistributed Earning 5,928,654,241 Plus: Change in Actuarial Gains (Losses) on Defined Benefit Plans in
2016 595,355
2016 Distributable Common Stock Dividend Balance 6,654,952,925 Earning Distribution:
Common Stock Cash Dividend-
1,679,677,506 Number of Shares, NT $0.6 per Share (1,007,806,504)
2016 Accumulated Undistributed Earnings 5,647,146,421
Note:
1. The Bank had set aside preferred stock dividends NT $398,786,964 in 2016 in accordance with IFRS 7.
2. For the cash dividends on common stocks and preferred stock dividends distributions, the Bank plans to acquire the authorization from shareholders at the Annual General Shareholders’ Meeting, to delegate to the Board of Directors for setting up the record date and methods of distribution.
49
3. Discussion Items: (1) Proposed by the Board of Directors Proposal: To approve the amendments to the Articles of
Incorporation of the Bank Explanation: 1. Key revisions of AOI are as follows:
(1)Based on the long-term strategic development needs to maintain a sound capital structure, we propose to revise subparagraph 9 of paragraph 1 of Article 5-1 of the AOI to extend the call date of CPPS and delete the step-up clause (i.e. CPPS dividend rate up to 7.75%).
(2)In accordance with Article 3 of “Regulations Governing Procedure for Board of Directors Meetings of Public Companies”, the meeting frequency of the board of directors in Article 27 of AOI is revised.
(3)The Bank has completed the election of the 9th term Board of Directors and established an audit committee in lieu of supervisors. We hereby propose to amend Articles 39 and 44 to delete the sunset provisions concerning the remuneration of supervisors and other transitional clauses.
2. Please refer to pages 51 and 57 of Agenda Book for a comparison table of the changes.
3. This proposal was approved for submission at the 6th board meeting of the 9th term held on April 25, 2017. Your approval is appreciated.
Resolution:
50
The Comparison Table of Current and Revised Articles of 5-1, 27, 39 and
44 of Articles of Incorporation, EnTie Commercial Bank (“AOI”) Proposed revision Current articles Description
Article 5-1This Bank may issue 621,890,000
shares of Series 1 Convertible
Perpetual Preferred Shares, eachwith a par value of NT$10 (the
“Series 1 CPPS”) in one issuance or
in tranches. The major terms andconditions are as follows:
1. If the Bank has any profit after
every year, losses of the previousyears shall first be covered after
the payment of taxes and
adjustment due to accountingrule changes. If there is any
remaining amount, the Bank shall
set aside or add reversal of legaland special reserves in
accordance with Article 40 of the
AOI, and then distribute dividendto the holders of Series 1 CPPS
as described herein.
2. Holders of Series 1 CPPS shallbe entitled to receive annual
cash dividend of a fixed rate of
6.75% (“Annual Dividends”),payable in cash. After the annual
financial statements have been
ratified in the annual generalmeeting of shareholders, the
Board of Director shall set a
record date for distribute AnnualDividends for the preceding fiscal
Article 5-1This Bank may issue 621,890,000
shares of Series 1 Convertible
Perpetual Preferred Shares, each with apar value of NT$10 (the “Series 1
CPPS”) in one issuance or in tranches.
The major terms and conditions are asfollows:
1. If the Bank has any profit after
every year, losses of the previousyears shall first be covered after the
payment of taxes and adjustment
due to accounting rule changes. Ifthere is any remaining amount, the
Bank shall set aside or add reversal
of legal and special reserves inaccordance with Article 40 of the
AOI, and then distribute dividend to
the holders of Series 1 CPPS asdescribed herein.
2. Holders of Series 1 CPPS shall be
entitled to receive annual cashdividend of a fixed rate of 6.75%
(“Annual Dividends”), payable in
cash. After the annual financialstatements have been ratified in the
annual general meeting of
shareholders, the Board of Directorshall set a record date for distribute
Annual Dividends for the preceding
fiscal year. Pro-rata dividend toSeries 1 CPPS will be paid in the
1. Article isamended
2. Based on the
long-termstrategic
development
needs, CPPScall date is
extended
from 10 yearsto 15 years. In
addition, the
annual fix rateof dividend
payments per
share isadjusted from
7.75% to
6.75%.Provisions
related to the
said annualfix portion of
the dividend
payments pershare are
revised
accordingly.
51
Proposed revision Current articles Descriptionyear. Pro-rata dividend to Series
1 CPPS will be paid in the year of
issuance of the Series 1 CPPSbased on actual holding period of
that year from the date of
issuance which shall be therecord date for the capital
increase. Pro-rata dividend will
also be paid to Series 1 CPPS inthe year of redemption of the
Series 1 CPPS based on actual
holding period of that year.3. If there are no earnings or the
earnings are not sufficient for the
full payment of the AnnualDividends of Series 1 CPPS in
any fiscal year, the insufficient
amount will not be accumulatedto the years thereafter.
4. Holders of Series 1 CPPS shall
be entitled, in addition to theAnnual Dividends distributable
under Item 2 of this Article, if so
resolved by the Board ofDirectors, to participate in the
dividends declared on Common
Share at a ratio of every 2 sharesof Series 1 CPPS for each
Common Share dividend;
provided that such participationright shall be available only if,
after the distributions of cash
dividends for Common Share atan amount equal to the cash
year of issuance of the Series 1
CPPS based on actual holding
period of that year from the date ofissuance which shall be the record
date for the capital increase.
Pro-rata dividend will also be paid toSeries 1 CPPS in the year of
redemption of the Series 1 CPPS
based on actual holding period ofthat year.
3. If there are no earnings or the
earnings are not sufficient for the fullpayment of the Annual Dividends of
Series 1 CPPS in any fiscal year, the
insufficient amount will not beaccumulated to the years thereafter.
4. Holders of Series 1 CPPS shall be
entitled, in addition to the AnnualDividends distributable under Item 2
of this Article, if so resolved by the
Board of Directors, to participate inthe dividends declared on Common
Share at a ratio of every 2 shares of
Series 1 CPPS for each CommonShare dividend; provided that such
participation right shall be available
only if, after the distributions of cashdividends for Common Share at an
amount equal to the cash dividends
distributed for Series 1 CPPS pershare, there is any remaining
balance.
5. The Series 1 CPPS will have aliquidation preference per share
52
Proposed revision Current articles Descriptiondividends distributed for Series 1
CPPS per share, there is any
remaining balance.5. The Series 1 CPPS will have a
liquidation preference per share
over the Common Share up tothe Purchase Price of Series 1
CPPS.
6. Voting Rights: Holder of Series 1CPPS shall be entitled to vote
and the right to elect and being
elected together with theCommon Shares on an
as-converted basis. Holder of
Series 1 CPPS shall be entitledto vote in preferred shareholders
meeting.
7. Holder of Series 1 CPPS willhave same preemptive rights as
Common Shares holders with
respect to subscription of newshare issuance.
8. Except for the closed period in
which the share registrar isclosed or the conversion of any
convertible securities is
suspended according to lawsand regulations, at the option of
the holders, the Series 1 CPPS
are convertible into CommonShares on a one-to-one basis, at
any time after one month of the
date of the issuance and theCommon Shares issued upon
over the Common Share up to the
Purchase Price of Series 1 CPPS.
6. Voting Rights: Holder of Series 1CPPS shall be entitled to vote and
the right to elect and being elected
together with the Common Shareson an as-converted basis. Holder of
Series 1 CPPS shall be entitled to
vote in preferred shareholdersmeeting.
7. Holder of Series 1 CPPS will have
same preemptive rights as CommonShares holders with respect to
subscription of new share issuance
8. Except for the closed period inwhich the share registrar is closed
or the conversion of any convertible
securities is suspended according tolaws and regulations, at the option
of the holders, the Series 1 CPPS
are convertible into CommonShares on a one-to-one basis, at
any time after one month of the date
of the issuance and the CommonShares issued upon such
conversion shall have the same
rights and obligations as otheroutstanding Common Shares.
Pro-rata preferred dividend will also
be paid in the year when conversionright is exercised based on holding
period of that year; provided,
however, holders of Series 1 CPPSwho convert their Series 1 CPPS
53
Proposed revision Current articles Descriptionsuch conversion shall have the
same rights and obligations as
other outstanding CommonShares. Pro-rata preferred
dividend will also be paid in the
year when conversion right isexercised based on holding
period of that year; provided,
however, holders of Series 1CPPS who convert their Series 1
CPPS into Common Shares
before the record date fordividends distribution of that year
shall have no rights to participate
in the Annual Dividends forSeries 1 CPPS in the year of
conversion and any year thereafter.
9. Subject to the applicable laws andapproval from the competent
authority, this Company shall have
the right to redeem any part or alloutstanding Series 1 CPPS after
the 15th anniversary of the
Closing, at a redemption price pershare equal to the Issuance Price.
into Common Shares before the
record date for dividends distribution
of that year shall have no rights toparticipate in the Annual Dividends
for Series 1 CPPS in the year of
conversion and any year thereafter.9. Subject to the applicable laws and
approval from the competent
authority, this Company shall havethe right to redeem any part or all
outstanding Series 1 CPPS after the
10th anniversary of the Closing, at aredemption price per share equal to
the Issuance Price. If any of the
Series 1 CPPS are not redeemedafter the 10th anniversary of the Date
of Issuance, the annual fix portion of
the dividend payments per share willbe increased to 7.75%.
Article 27
The Board of Directors calls one
meeting at least quarterly throughthe convening of the chairman. The
chairman can call the meeting at any
time upon contingency or therequest from more than 50% of
directors.
Article 27
The Board of Directors calls one
meeting every three months through theconvening of the chairman. The
chairman can call the meeting at any
time upon contingency or the requestfrom more than 50% of directors.
In addition to the written notification, the
1. Article is
amended
2. Pursuant toArticle 3 of
“Regulations
GoverningProcedure for
Board of
54
Proposed revision Current articles DescriptionIn addition to the written notification,
the Bank’s Board meeting could be
convened by the Chairman via mail,fax notices or notices in electronic
transmission.
If the chairman fails to convene themeeting of directors or the meeting
of managing directors, the vice
chairman shall act on his behalf. Butif the vice chairman fails to convene
or exercise his power and authority
for any cause within 7 days started atthe required day, then the chairman
should appoint one managing
director (director) as the proxy toconvene in advance. Should no
proxy be appointed, the convener
can be chosen among managingdirectors (directors).
When the board meetings are
adjourned, the Managing Directorswill exercise their rights on behalf of
the board, and meetings can be
convened by the Chairman.However any items that concern
greater interests of the Company, the
board has the final decision.
Bank’s Board meeting could be
convened by the Chairman via mail, fax
notices or notices in electronictransmission.
If the chairman fails to convene the
meeting of directors or the meeting ofmanaging directors, the vice chairman
shall act on his behalf. But if the vice
chairman fails to convene or exercisehis power and authority for any cause
within 7 days started at the required
day, then the chairman should appointone managing director (director) as the
proxy to convene in advance. Should no
proxy be appointed, the convener canbe chosen among managing directors
(directors).
When the board meetings areadjourned, the Managing Directors will
exercise their rights on behalf of the
board, and meetings can be convenedby the Chairman. However any items
that concern greater interests of the
Company, the board has the finaldecision.
Directors
Meetings of
PublicCompanies”,
wording of
boardmeeting
frequency is
revised.
Article 39When there is any profit (i.e. the
Before-Tax Income prior to the
deductions of employees’ and board members remunerations) at the end
of each year, the Bank shall allocate
Article 39When there is any profit (i.e. the
Before-Tax Income prior to the
deductions of employees’ and board members remunerations) at the end of
each year, the Bank shall allocate not
1. Article isamended
2. As the Bank
hasestablished
the audit
55
Proposed revision Current articles Descriptionnot less than one percent of the said
profit as employees’ remuneration,
and no more than one percent asremunerations of directors. However,
the Bank’s accumulated losses
should have been coveredbeforehand.
less than one percent of the said profit
as employees’ remuneration, and no
more than one percent asremunerations of directors and
supervisors. However, the Bank’s
accumulated losses should have beencovered beforehand.
The preceding paragraph regarding
supervisors’ remuneration shall no longer be applicable when the Bank
establishes the audit committee in lieu
of supervisors.
committee to
replace the
supervisors,provisions of
remuneration
of supervisorsare deleted.
Article 44The Articles of Incorporations was
developed after approval by the
entire founders on September 26,1991.
.
.
.
The 23rd amendment was made at
the General Shareholders’ Meetingon June 12, 2015.
The 24th amendment was made at
the General Meeting of Shareholderson June 8, 2016.
The 25th amendment was made at
the General Meeting of Shareholderson June 16, 2017.
Article 44The Articles of Incorporations was
developed after approval by the entire
founders on September 26, 1991..
.
.
The 23rd amendment was made at the
General Shareholders’ Meeting on June
12, 2015. All amended and deletedarticles shall be implemented after the
approval of the General Meeting of
Shareholders except for the revisedArticle 15, Subparagraph 2 and 3 of
Paragraph 1 of Article 19, Article 23,
Article 26-1, Article 39, Subparagraph 2of Paragraph 1 of Article 40, and the
deleted Article 31 to Article 34 of
Chapter VI, which will take effect afterthe re-election of the 9th term Board of
Directors.
1. Article isamended
2. The 9th term
Board ofDirectors has
been elected.
We herebydelete the
sunset
provisions.3. To add a
latest revision
date.
56
Proposed revision Current articles DescriptionThe 24th amendment was made at the
General Meeting of Shareholders on
June 8, 2016.
57
(2) Proposed by the Board of Directors
Proposal: To approve the amendments to the “Criteria Governing Assets Acquisition and Disposal” of the Bank (the “Criteria”)
Explanation: 1. The Criteria is amended in accordance with the revised “Regulations Governing the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets by Public Companies” announced by the Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) per letter No. 1060001296 dated February 9, 2017, and in response to the establishment of the Audit Committee of the Bank. We hereby propose to amend the Criteria accordingly. Please refer to pages 59 and 71 of this Agenda Handbook for the comparison table of amendments made to the Criteria.
2. This proposal was approved for submission at the6th board meeting of the 9th term held on April25, 2017, and is submitted to the Annual GeneralMeeting of Shareholders for approval.
Resolution:
58
The Comparison Table of Current and Revised Articles for the Criteria Governing Assets Acquisition and Disposal, EnTie Commercial Bank (the
“Criteria”)
Proposed revision Current articles Description
Article 6 (Restrictions on Acquisition
and Disposal of Assets)
For acquisition or disposal of assets mentioned in Article 3, the Criteria shall
govern unless otherwise specified in
the Bank’s internal rules such as “Criteria for Long-term Investments”,
“Criteria on Funding Operations”,
“Criteria Governing the Operations of Financial Derivatives”, “Criteria for
collateral Management and Disposal”,
“Criteria of NPL Disposal”, “Rules Governing Acquisition and Disposal of
Loan Assets of Corporate Banking
and Markets Group”, “Rules Governing Properties and
Expenditures”, the statements of
stratified responsibilities, and other rules stipulated by the Bank.
Total amounts of real property or
securities acquired by the Bank and limits on individual securities, unless
otherwise specified in the Bank’s
internal rules, shall be handled in compliance with the Banking Act and
the regulations required by the
Competent Authority. The calculation of the transaction
amounts referred to in this Chapter
shall be done in accordance with Item
Article 6 (Restrictions on Acquisition
and Disposal of Assets)
For acquisition or disposal of assets mentioned in Article 3, the Criteria shall
govern unless otherwise specified in the
Bank’s internal rules such as “Criteria for Long-term Investments”, “Criteria
on Funding Operations”, “Criteria
Governing the Operations of Financial Derivatives”, “Criteria for collateral
Management and Disposal”, “Criteria
of NPL Disposal”, “Rules Governing Acquisition and Disposal of Loan
Assets of Corporate Banking Group”,
“Rules Governing Properties and Expenditures”, the statements of
stratified responsibilities, and other
rules stipulated by the Bank. Total amounts of real property or
securities acquired by the Bank and
limits on individual securities, unless otherwise specified in the Bank’s
internal rules, shall be handled in
compliance with the Banking Act and the regulations required by the
Competent Authority.
The calculation of the transaction amounts referred to in this Chapter
shall be done in accordance with Item
5 of Subparagraph 1, Paragraph 1,
1. Names of certain
internal
regulations are revised in
response to the
reorganization of the Bank.
2. Article is revised
in response to the amendments
to Article 15 of
the Criteria. 3. In response to
the
establishment of the Audit
Committee, the
term “supervisor” is
deleted, and the
Audit Committee is included to
take part of the
approval process.
59
Proposed revision Current articles Description
7 of Subparagraph 1, Paragraph 1,
Article 15, and “within the preceding
year” as used herein refers to the year preceding the date of occurrence of
the current transaction. The
transaction amounts stated in Articles 8 to 10 for which an appraisal report
from a professional appraiser or a
CPA’s opinion has been obtained pursuant to the requirements
stipulated in the Criteria need not be
counted toward the transaction amount; the transaction amount
stated in Subparagraph 1, Paragraph
1 of Article 11 for which an approval has been obtained from by the Audit
Committee and the Board of Directors
pursuant to the requirements stipulated in the Criteria need not be
counted toward the transaction
amount.
Article 15, and “within the preceding
year” as used herein refers to the year
preceding the date of occurrence of the current transaction. The
transaction amounts stated in Articles
8 to 10 for which an appraisal report from a professional appraiser or a
CPA’s opinion has been obtained
pursuant to the requirements stipulated in the Criteria need not be
counted toward the transaction
amount; the transaction amount stated in Subparagraph 1, Paragraph 1 of
Article 11 for which an approval have
been obtained from the board of directors and recognized by the
supervisors pursuant to the
requirements stipulated in the Criteria need not be counted toward the
transaction amount.
Article 7 (Approval Procedure for
Major Transactions)
The Bank’s acquisition or disposal of assets for which the approval of the
board of directors is required under
the Criteria or other internal or external regulations is defined as
major transaction; such transactions
shall be approved by more than half of all audit committee members, and
then be submitted to the board for a
resolution.
Article 7(Handling Disagreements
from Board Directors)
The Bank’s acquisition or disposal of assets for which the approval of the
board of directors is required under the
Criteria or other laws or regulations, if a director expresses dissent and it is
contained in the minutes or a written
statement, the Bank shall submit the director’s dissenting opinion to each
supervisor.
1. Article is
amended
2. Define “major transaction”. The
internal
regulations stated in
paragraph 1
shall include but are not limited to
the regulations
listed in Article 6
60
Proposed revision Current articles Description
If approval of more than half of all
audit committee members as required
in the preceding paragraph is not obtained, the procedures may be
implemented if approved by more
than two-thirds of all directors, and the resolution of the audit committee shall
be recorded in the board meeting
minutes. When a major transaction is
submitted for discussion by the board
of directors pursuant to the preceding paragraph, the board of directors shall
take into full consideration each
independent director’s opinions. If an independent director objects to or
expresses reservations on any matter,
it shall be recorded in the board meeting minutes.
The term “all audit committee
members” in paragraph 1 and “all directors” in paragraph 2 shall be
counted as the actual number of
persons holding those positions.
When a transaction involving the acquisition or disposal of assets is
submitted for discussion by the board
of directors pursuant to the preceding paragraph, the board of directors shall
take into full consideration each
independent director’s opinions. If an independent director objects to or
expresses reservations on any matter,
it shall be recorded in the board meeting minutes.
of the Criteria.
3. In response to
audit committee has been
established, any
transaction involving major
assets or
derivatives shall be approved by
more than half of
all audit committee
members and
submitted to the board of
directors for a
resolution.” The procedures for
approving major
asset transactions are
amended
accordingly, adjust the
approval
procedure for major
transactions in
accordance with the Article 8 of
“Regulations
Governing the
61
Proposed revision Current articles Description
Acquisition and
Disposal of
Assets by Public
Companies.”
Article 9 (Procedures for Acquisition and Disposal of Real Property or
Equipment)
(omitted) 1. (omitted)
2. (omitted)
3. Real Property and Equipment Appraisal Reports
In acquiring or disposing real
property or equipment where the transaction amount reaches 20
percent of the Bank’s paid-in capital
or NT$300 million or more, the Bank, unless transacting with a
government institution, engaging
others to build on its own land, engaging others to build on rented
land, or acquiring or disposing of
equipment for business use, shall obtain an appraisal report prior to
the date of occurrence of the event
from a professional appraiser. The appraisal report shall include items
as specified by the regulations of
the Competent Authority and… (omitted)
Article 9 (Procedures for Acquisition and Disposal of Real Property or
Equipment)
(omitted) 1. (omitted)
2. (omitted)
3. Real Property and Equipment Appraisal Reports
In acquiring or disposing real
property or equipment where the transaction amount reaches 20
percent of the Bank’s paid-in capital
or NT$300 million or more, the Bank, unless transacting with a
government agency, engaging
others to build on its own land, engaging others to build on rented
land, or acquiring or disposing of
equipment for business use, shall obtain an appraisal report prior to
the date of occurrence of the event
from a professional appraiser. The appraisal report shall include items
as specified by the regulations of the
Competent Authority and… (omitted)
Amend the wording in response to
revised Article 9 of
“Regulations
Governing the
Acquisition and
Disposal of Assets
by Public
Companies’’.
62
Proposed revision Current articles Description
Article 10 (Procedures for Acquisition
and Disposal of Memberships or
Intangible Assets) Unless the Bank’s Rules Governing
Properties and Expenditures and
other internal rules provide otherwise, the Bank shall acquire or dispose
memberships or intangible assets
pursuant to the Criteria. Where the Bank acquires or disposes
of memberships or intangible assets
and the transaction amount reaches or exceeds 20% of the Bank’s paid-in
capital or NT$300 million, except in
transactions with a government institution, the Bank shall engage a
certified public accountant prior to the
date of occurrence of the event to render an opinion on the
reasonableness of the transaction
price; the CPA shall comply with the provisions of the Statement of
Auditing Standards No. 20 published
by the ARDF.
Article 10 (Procedures for Acquisition
and Disposal of Memberships or
Intangible Assets) Unless the Bank’s Rules Governing
Properties and Expenditures and other
internal rules provide otherwise, the Bank shall acquire or dispose
memberships or intangible assets
pursuant to the Criteria. Where the Bank acquires or disposes
of memberships or intangible assets
and the transaction amount reaches or exceeds 20% of the Bank’s paid-in
capital or NT$300 million, except in
transactions with a government agency, the Bank shall engage a
certified public accountant prior to the
date of occurrence of the event to render an opinion on the
reasonableness of the transaction
price; the CPA shall comply with the provisions of the Statement of Auditing
Standards No. 20 published by the
ARDF.
Amend the wording
in response to
revised Article 10 of “Regulations
Governing the
Acquisition and
Disposal of Assets
by Public
Companies’’.
Article 11 (Procedures for Related
Party Transaction)
(omitted) 1. Appraisal and Operating Procedures
When the Bank engages in any
acquisition or disposal of real property from or to a related party, or engages
in any acquisition or disposal of
assets other than real property from
Article 11 (Procedures for Related
Party Transaction)
(omitted) 1. Appraisal and Operating Procedures
When the Bank engages in any
acquisition or disposal of real property from or to a related party, or engages
in any acquisition or disposal of assets
other than real property from or to a
1. Wording of
Subparagraph 1
of Paragraph 1 is amended in
response to
revised Article 14 of the
“Regulations
Governing the
63
Proposed revision Current articles Description
or to a related party and the
transaction amount reaches 20
percent or more of paid-in capital, 10 percent or more of the Bank's total
assets, or NT$300 million or more,
except in trading of government bonds or bonds under repurchase
and resale agreements, or
subscription or repurchase of domestic money market funds issued
by domestic securities investment
trust enterprises, the Bank may not proceed to enter into a transaction
contract or make a payment until the
following matters have been approved by the audit committee and
the board of directors :
(omitted) 2.Evaluation of the reasonableness of
the real property transaction costs
(1) (omitted) (2) (omitted)
(3) (omitted)
(4) (omitted) (5) (omitted)
A. (omitted)
B. The Audit Committee shall supervise the execution of the said
operations of the Bank in compliance
with Article 218 of the Company Act. (omitted)
related party and the transaction
amount reaches 20 percent or more of
paid-in capital, 10 percent or more of the Bank's total assets, or NT$300
million or more, except in trading of
government bonds or bonds under repurchase and resale agreements, or
subscription or redemption of domestic
money market funds, the Bank may not proceed to enter into a transaction
contract or make a payment until the
following matters have been approved by the board of directors and
recognized by the supervisors:
(omitted) 2. Evaluation of the reasonableness of
the real property transaction costs
(1) (omitted) (2) (omitted)
(3) (omitted)
(4) (omitted) (5) (omitted)
A. (omitted)
B. The Supervisors shall supervise the execution of the said operations of the
Bank in compliance with Article 218 of
the Company Act. (omitted)
Acquisition and
Disposal of
Assets by Public
Companies”.
2. In response to
the establishment of
the Audit
Committee in lieu of the
supervisors, the
term “supervisor” is
deleted, and the
Audit Committee is included to
take part of the
approval process.
3. In response to
the establishment of
the Audit
Committee, the term
“supervisor” is
revised and changed to the
“Audit
Committee”.
64
Proposed revision Current articles Description
Article 12 (Procedures for
Acquisition and Disposal of Claims of
Financial Institutions) When acquiring or disposing debt
rights of financial institutions, unless
the “Criteria of NPL Disposal Procedures”, the “Rules Governing
Acquisition and Disposal of Loan
Assets of Corporate Banking and Markets Group”, and other internal
rules provide otherwise, the Criteria
shall govern.
Article 12 (Procedures for Acquisition
and Disposal of Claims of Financial
Institutions) When acquiring or disposing debt
rights of financial institutions, unless
the “Criteria of NPL Disposal Procedures”, the “Rules Governing
Acquisition and Disposal of Loan
Assets of Corporate Banking Group”, and other internal rules provide
otherwise, the Criteria shall govern.
Names of certain
internal regulations
are revised in response to the
reorganization of
the Bank.
Article 13 (Procedures of Acquisition
and Disposal of Derivatives Products)
1. (omitted) 2. (omitted)
3. Internal Audit System
(1)The internal auditor shall review periodically the suitability of internal
control on derivatives transactions.
If any major violation is found, the Audit Committee shall be notified in
writing and a report shall be
submitted to the Board of directors. (omitted)
Article 13 (Procedures of Acquisition
and Disposal of Derivatives Products)
1. (omitted) 2. (omitted)
3.Internal Audit System
(1)The internal auditor shall review periodically the suitability of internal
control on derivatives transactions. If
any major violation is found, a written report shall be submitted to
notify the Board of directors and the
Supervisors. (omitted)
Article is amended
in response to the
establishment of the Audit Committee
and in accordance
with the practical operation procedure
of the internal audit
system.
Article 14 (Procedures for Mergers,
Demerger, Acquisitions and Transfer
of Shares) 1.Appraisal and Operating
Procedures
(1)When conducting a merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of
shares, prior to convening a board
Article 14 (Procedures for Mergers,
Demergers, Acquisitions and Transfer
of Shares) 1.Appraisal and Operating procedures
(1)When conducting a merger,
demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares, prior to convening a board
meeting to resolve on the matter, the
Article is amended
in response to
revised Article 22 of the “Regulations
Governing the
Acquisition and
Disposal of Assets
by Public
65
Proposed revision Current articles Description
meeting to resolve on the matter,
the Bank shall engage a CPA,
attorney, or securities underwriter to give an opinion on the
reasonableness of the share
exchange ratio, acquisition price, or distribution of cash or other
property to shareholders, and
submit it to the board of directors for deliberation and passage. The
abovementioned opinion can be
exempted if the Bank conducts a merger with its subsidiary whose
entire issued shares or capital are
directly or indirectly held by the Bank, or if the Bank’s subsidiary
conducts a merger with one
another whose entire issued shares or capital are directly or indirectly
held by the Bank respectively.
(omitted)
Bank shall engage a CPA, attorney,
or securities underwriter to give an
opinion on the reasonableness of the share exchange ratio,
acquisition price, or distribution of
cash or other property to shareholders, and submit it to the
board of directors for deliberation
and passage.
(omitted)
Companies”, which
recognizes a
merger between a parent company
and its 100% owned
subsidiary or a merger between
subsidiaries 100%
owned by a parent company
respectively to be
as an reorganization of a Group, and
assumes that such
merger will not involve share
exchange and
computation of share exchange
ratio, distribution of
cash or assets to the shareholders,
etc. Therefore, the
requirement of obtaining an
experts’ opinion is
lifted.
Article 15 (Procedures for Public
Disclosure of Information)
Procedures for Public Disclosure of Information of the Bank are described
below:
1. (omitted)
Article 15 (Procedures for Public
Disclosure of Information)
Procedures for Public Disclosure of Information of the Bank are described
below:
1. (omitted)
1. Item 1 of
Subparagraph
1 of Paragraph 1 is amended in
response to
revised Article
66
Proposed revision Current articles Description
(1)Acquisition or disposal of real
property from or to a related party,
or acquisition or disposal of assets other than real property from or to a
related party where the transaction
amount reaches 20 percent or more of paid-in capital, 10 percent
or more of the company’s total
assets, or NT$300 million or more; provided, this shall not apply to
trading of government bonds or
bonds under repurchase and resale agreements, or subscription or
repurchase of domestic money
market funds issued by domestic securities investment trust
enterprises.
(2) (omitted) (3) (omitted)
(4) Where the type of asset
acquired or disposed is equipment for business use, the trading
counterparty is not a related party,
and the transaction amount is NT$1 billion or more.
(5)Where land is acquired under an
arrangement on engaging others to build on the Bank’s own land,
engaging others to build on rented
land, joint construction and allocation of housing units, joint
construction and allocation of
ownership percentages, or joint
(1)Acquisition or disposal of real
property from or to a related party, or
acquisition or disposal of assets other than real property from or to a
related party where the transaction
amount reaches 20 percent or more of paid-in capital, 10 percent or
more of the company’s total assets,
or NT$300 million or more; provided, this shall not apply to
trading of government bonds, or
bonds under repurchase and resale agreements, or subscription or
redemption of domestic money
market funds.
(2) (omitted)
(3) (omitted)
(4)Where an asset transaction other
14 of
“Regulations
Governing the
Acquisition and
Disposal of
Assets by
Public
Companies”.
2. The following amendments
are made in
response to revised Article
30 of
“Regulations
Governing the
Acquisition and
Disposal of
Assets by
Public
Companies”: (1) For a public
company
whose paid-in capital is over
NT$10 billion,
the amount for non-related-par
ty transactions
to be announced or
reported has
been raised to
67
Proposed revision Current articles Description
construction and separate sale, and
the amount the Bank expects to
invest in the transaction is NT$500 million or more.
(6) Where an asset transaction
other than any of those referred to in the preceding five
subparagraphs, a disposal of
receivables by a financial institution, or an investment in the
mainland China area reaches 20
percent or more of paid-in capital or NT$300 million or more. However,
this requirement does not apply to
the following circumstances: A.Trading of government bonds.
B.Trading of securities by
investment professionals on foreign or domestic securities
exchanges or over-the-counter
markets, subscription/offering/issuance
of ordinary corporate bonds and
general bank debentures that do not involve shareholding
rights in the domestic primary
market, or subscription of securities by a security firm
required for providing
underwriting services or acting as recommending securities
firms for emerging-stock
companies in accordance with
than any of those referred to in the
preceding three items, a disposal of
receivables by a financial institution, or an investment in the mainland
China area reaches 20 percent or
more of paid-in capital or NT$300 million; provided, this shall not apply
to the following circumstances:
A.Trading of government bonds. B.Securities trading by
investment professionals on
foreign or domestic securities exchanges or over-the-counter
markets, or subscription of
securities by a securities firm, either in the primary market or in
accordance with relevant
regulations. C.Trading of bonds under
repurchase/resale agreements,
or subscription or redemption of domestic money market funds.
D.Where the type of asset
acquired or disposed is equipment for business use, the
trading counterparty is not a
related party, and the transaction amount is less than NT$500
million.
E.Where land is acquired under an arrangement on engaging
others to build on the Bank’s own
land, engaging others to build on
NT$1 billion.
Thus the
current Item 4(D) of
Subparagraph
1 of Paragraph 1 is revised and
moved to Item
4 under the same
subparagraph.
(2) The current Item 4(E) of
Subparagraph
1 of Item 1 is amended and
moved to Item
5 under the same
subparagraph.
(3) The current Items 4(A),
4(B), and 4(C)
of Subparagraph
1 of Paragraph
1 are amended and moved to
Items 6(A), 6(B)
and 6(C) under the same
subparagraph.
(4) Item 6(B) of
68
Proposed revision Current articles Description
the regulations of Taipei
Exchange.
C.Trading of bonds under repurchase/resale agreements,
or subscription or repurchase of
domestic money market funds issued by domestic securities
investment trust enterprises.
(7)The amount of transactions stated in the preceding
subparagraphs 1 to 6 shall be
calculated as follows… (omitted) 2. (omitted)
3. (omitted)
(1) (omitted) (2) (omitted)
(3)When the Bank makes an error
or omission in an item required to be publicly announced and so is
required to correct it, all the items
shall be again publicly announced and reported in their entirety within
two days commencing immediately
from the date of acknowledgement of the event.
(omitted)
rented land, joint construction
and allocation of housing units,
joint construction and allocation of ownership percentages, or
joint construction and separate
sale, and the amount the Bank expects to invest in the
transaction is less than NT$500
million. (5)The amount of transactions as
used in Items 1-4 shall be calculated
as follows, (omitted) 2. (omitted)
3. (omitted)
(1) (omitted) (2) (omitted)
(3)When the Bank makes an error or
omission in a required public announcement, such public
announcement shall be corrected,
be again publicly announced and reported in their entirety.
(omitted)
Subparagraph
1 of Paragraph
1 is amended to adopt the
circumstances
exempted from the
requirements of
public disclosure of
information.
(5) Wording for Item 6(C) of
Subparagraph
1 of Paragraph 1 is amended in
response to
revised Article 14 of
“Regulations
Governing the
Acquisition and
Disposal of
Assets by
Public
Companies”.
(6) Item 3 of Subparagraph
3 of Paragraph
1 is amended to adopt the
correction
requirement.
69
Proposed revision Current articles Description Article 19 (Calculation of Total Assets) The 10 percent of total assets referred to in the Criteria shall be calculated based on the total assets stated in the most recent parent company only financial report or individual financial report prepared under the “Regulations Governing the Preparation of Financial Reports by Public Banks”.
Article 19 The 10 percent of total assets referred to in the Criteria shall be calculated based on the total assets stated in the most recent parent company only financial report or individual financial report prepared under the “Regulations Governing the Preparation of Financial Reports by Public Banks”.
Add the intent and purpose of the article.
Article 20 (Implementation and Revision) The Criteria and any amendments thereto shall be discussed by the Audit Committee and the board of directors, and submitted to the shareholders’ meeting for approval. Regarding the approval procedures conducted by the Audit Committee and the Board, Article 7 shall apply.
Article 20 (Implementation and Revision) Once the Criteria are approved by the board of directors, they shall be submitted to each Supervisor and to the shareholders’ meeting for approval; same procedures should be applied for amendments to the Criteria. Regarding the handling of dissent expressed by the board and independent director(s), Article 7 shall apply.
1. Amend the Chinese wording of the intent and purpose of the article.
2. In response to audit committee has been established, and Article 6 of “Regulations Governing the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets by Public Companies’’, which regulates acquisition and disposal of assets shall be approved by more than half of all audit committee members and submitted to the board of directors for a resolution, revising the implementation
70
Proposed revision Current articles Description and revision procedure of the criteria.
Article 21 (Conformity of Matters Not Mentioned) Matters not set forth in the Criteria shall be dealt with in accordance with the applicable laws, rules, regulations or internal rules of the Bank.
Article 21 Matters not set forth in the Criteria shall be dealt with in accordance with the applicable laws, rules, regulations or internal rules of the Bank.
Add the intent and purpose of the article.
71
(3) Proposed by the Shareholder Proposal: To approve the proposal of having the Bank redeem
the CPPS upon the 10th anniversary by issuing new similar capital instruments at current market rates
Explanation: 1. According to Articles 8 & 11 of “Regulations Governing the Capital Adequacy and Capital Category of Banks”, the Bank’ s CPPS included in the regulatory capital (Tier-1 capital) has been reduced by 10% yearly since 2013, and shall not be included in Tier-1 capital after the 10th anniversary of issuance. In short, having CPPS to serve as the Bank’s capital is limited but at very high costs.
2. Also, Article 5-1 of AOI of the Bank stipulates, if any of the CPPS are not redeemed after the 10th anniversary, the annual fix portion of the dividend payments per share will be increased to 7.75%. It’s believed that it would entail heavier burden to the Bank and an adverse effect on business performance of the Bank.
3. In view of the coupon rates of latest preferred shares issued by the peers are set around 3.8%-4.75%, indicating the costs paid to the Bank’s CPPS is way higher than the current market rates, we believe that by issuing the new capital instruments to redeem the expiring CPPs would improve the business performance of the Bank.
Resolution:
72
5. Extemporaneous Motions 6. Adjournment
73
Ⅲ . Appendix:
Appendix 1 The Shareholding Status of all Directors of the 9th term
Title Name Shareholding Shareholding
percentage(%)
Director
Longreach Edith Investment Cooperatief, 3, U.A. Representative: Jesse Ding Representative: Mark Z. Chiba Representative: Claudie Yu
263,709,343 13.47
Director Reng Hsiang Co., Ltd. Representative: Wen-Hsien Tsai Representative: Chien-Hung Liao
17,474,796 0.89
Director Hung Wei Construction Co., Ltd. Representative: Chien-San Yen Representative: Yu-Li Huang
686,575 0.04
Director OLHE Cayman Limited Partnership Representative: Harukazu Yamaguchi
146,565,937 7.49
Independent Director
Henry Lee 0 0
Independent Director
Philippe Espinasse 0 0
Independent Director
Steven P. Thomas 0 0
1. The shareholding is recorded on the Roster of Shareholders up to the book closure date for 2017 AGM (i.e. April 18, 2017). The current number of issued shares of the Bank is 1,957,910,050 shares, including common shares 1,679,677,506 shares, and preferred shares 278,232,544 shares. The shareholding of Longreach Edith Investment Cooperatief, 3, U.A. includes shares under Mega Bank’s custodian.
2. According to Article 26 of “Securities and Exchange Law and Rules and Review Procedures for Director and Supervisor Share Ownership Ratios at Public Companies”, the total shareholdings owned by all directors of the Bank shall not be less than 2.4 percent of the total issued shares (i.e. 46,989,841 shares). The shareholding of all directors of the Bank has met the requirement.
74
Appendix 2 The Rules and Procedures of Shareholders’ Meeting of
EnTie Commercial Bank
Article 1(Purpose of Establishment) To establish an excellent governance system of shareholders’ meeting, and to enhance
the supervision and management of EnTie Commercial Bank (“the Bank”), we hereby
establish the “Rules and Procedures of Shareholders’ Meeting, EnTie Commercial Bank”
(the “Rules and Procedures”), in accordance with Article 5 of Corporate Governance Best-Practice Principles for TWSE/GTSM Listed Companies, and Article 11 of Corporate
Governance Best-Practice Principles for Banks.
Article 2 (Legal Basis)
Unless relevant laws and regulations or the Bank’s Articles of Incorporation provide
otherwise, Shareholders’ Meeting of the Bank shall be conducted in accordance with the Rules and Procedures.
Article 3 (Calling and Meeting Notice of Shareholders’ Meeting) The Bank’s shareholders’ meeting shall, unless otherwise provided in the regulations or
laws, be convened by the board of directors.
Thirty days before the Bank convenes an annual shareholders’ meeting or fifteen days before a special shareholders’ meeting, the Bank shall prepare electronic files of the meeting
notice, proxy form, explanatory materials relating to proposals for ratification, matters for
deliberation, election or dismissal of directors, and other matters on the shareholders’ meeting agenda, and upload them to the Market Observation Post System (“MOPS”). Twenty-one
days before the Bank is to convene an annual shareholders’ meeting, or fifteen days before it
convenes a special shareholders’ meeting, it shall prepare an electronic file of the shareholders’ meeting agenda handbook and the supplemental materials referred to in the preceding
paragraph, and upload it to the MOPS. Fifteen days before the Bank is to convene a
shareholders’ meeting, it shall prepare the shareholders’ meeting agenda handbook and supplemental materials and make them available for the shareholders to obtain and review
at any time. In addition, the handbook shall be displayed at the Bank and its professional
shareholder services agent, and distributed on-site at the meeting.
75
The subject of a meeting of shareholders to be convened shall be stated in the individual
notice and the public announcement. With the consent of the addressee, the meeting notice may be given in electronic form. For those shareholders whose shareholdings are less than
one thousand shares, the prescribed notice may be substituted with a public announcement.
Matters pertaining to election or dismissal of directors, amendment to the Articles of Incorporation, and dissolution, merger, spin-off, or any matters as set forth in paragraph 1,
Article 185 of Company Act, Article 26-1 and Article 43-6 of Securities and Exchange Act,
Article 56-1 and Article 60-2 of Regulations Governing the Offering and Issuance of Securities by Securities Issuers shall be itemized in the subjects of meeting notice, and not
be brought up as extemporary motions.
A shareholder holding one percent or more of the total number of issued shares may submit to the Bank a written proposal for discussion at a regular shareholders meeting.
Such proposals, however, are limited to one item only, and no proposal containing more
than one item will be included in the meeting agenda. In addition, when the circumstances of any subparagraph of Article 172-1, paragraph 4 of the Company Act apply to a proposal
put forward by a shareholder, the board of directors may exclude it from the agenda.
Prior to the book closure date before a regular shareholders meeting is held, the Bank shall publicly announce that it will receive shareholder proposals, and the location and time
period for their submission; the period for submission of shareholder proposals may not be
less than 10 days. Proposals submitted by shareholders are limited to 300 words, and no proposal containing
more than 300 words will be included in the meeting agenda. The shareholder making the
proposal shall be present in person or by proxy at the regular shareholders’ meeting and take part in discussion of the proposal.
Prior to the date for issuance of notice of a shareholders’ meeting, the Bank shall inform
the shareholders who submitted proposals of the proposal screening results, and shall list in the meeting notice the proposals that conform to the provisions of this article. At the
shareholders’ meeting the board of directors shall explain the reasons for exclusion of any
shareholder proposals not included in the agenda.
Article 4 (Proxy appointment and Authorization) A shareholder may appoint a proxy to attend a shareholders’ meeting in his/her/its behalf
by executing a power of attorney printed by the Bank stating therein the scope of power
authorized to the proxy.
76
One shareholder may present one proxy letter and appoint only one proxy. A proxy must
be delivered to the Bank at least five days before the shareholders’ meeting. The first proxy shall have precedence if proxies are repeated and delivered. This restriction shall not apply,
however, to those shareholders who declare to retract their prior appointment of a proxy.
If a shareholder wishes to attend the Shareholders’ meeting in person after delivering a proxy to the Bank, the shareholder must, two business days prior to the shareholders’
meeting at the latest, notify the Bank in writing to retract his or her proxy. In the case a
shareholder fails to make a retraction before the deadline, the voting right exercised by the proxy shall be counted instead.
Article 5 (Principles for Determining Venues and Time of Shareholders’ Meeting) The place for convening a shareholders’ meeting shall be held inside the premises of the
Bank, or any other place convenient for attendance by shareholders, and suitable for holding
of such a meeting. The time for commencing the said meeting shall not be earlier than 9am or later than 3pm. The independent directors’ opinion as to the place and time of such a
meeting shall be taken into consideration.
Article 6 (Preparation of Documents, such as Attendance Book)
The Bank shall specify in its shareholders’ meeting notices the time during which shareholder
attendance registrations will be accepted, the place to register for attendance, and other matters for attention.
The time during which shareholder attendance registrations will be accepted, as stated in
the preceding paragraph, shall be at least 30 minutes prior to the time the meeting commences. The place at which attendance registrations are accepted shall be clearly
marked and a sufficient number of suitable personnel assigned to handle the registrations.
Shareholders and their proxies (collectively, “shareholders”) shall attend shareholders’ meetings based on attendance cards, sign-in cards, or other certificates of attendance. The
Bank may not arbitrarily add requirements for documents of other qualifications beyond the
eligibility showing by shareholders to attend the shareholders’ meetings. Solicitors soliciting proxy forms shall also bring identification documents for verification.
The Bank shall furnish the attending shareholders with an attendance book to sign, or
attending shareholders may hand in a sign-in card in lieu of signing in. The Bank shall provide the agenda handbook of shareholders’ meeting, annual report,
attendance badge, speech request note, voting paper and other materials, to shareholders
77
who are present at the meeting; as for elections of directors, the Bank shall provide ballots
to shareholders separately. When the government or a juristic person is a shareholder of the Bank, its proxy shall not
be limited to one person; an institutional shareholder being entrusted to attend in the
shareholders’ meeting may designate only one representative to attend the meeting.
Article 7(Chairman of Shareholders’ Meeting and Attendees) If the shareholders’ meeting is called by the board of directors, the chairman of the Board
shall preside at the said shareholders’ meeting. In case the chairman is on leave of absence,
or cannot exercise his powers and authority, the vice chairman shall act in lieu of him. If
there is no vice chairman, or the vice chairman is also on leave of absence, or cannot exercise his powers and authority, the chairman shall designate a board director to act in
lieu of him; if the chairman does not designate a board director, directors shall elect one
among themselves to act in lieu of the chairman. It is advisable that shareholders’ meetings convened by the board of directors be
attended by a majority of the directors, and at least one representative from each standing
committee. Such attendance status shall be recorded in the meeting minutes of the shareholders’ meeting.
If the shareholders’ meeting is called by any other person than the board of directors,
who has the right to call the meeting, said person shall preside at that meeting; when there are more than two persons who have the right to call the meeting, the chairman shall be
elected among the said persons.
The Bank may designate its lawyer, certified public accountant or other relevant persons to attend the shareholders’ meeting.
Article 8 (Documentations for Shareholders’ Meeting by Audio or Video) The Bank, beginning from the time it accepts shareholder attendance registrations, shall
make an uninterrupted audio and video recording of the registration procedure, the proceedings
of the shareholders’ meeting, and the voting and vote counting procedures. The recorded materials of the preceding paragraph shall be preserved for at least one
year. If any of shareholders filed a law suit against the Bank based on Article 189 of Company
Act, such tapes shall be preserved till the end of such litigation.
78
Article 9 (Shares Calculation of Quorum and Attendance of Shareholders’ Meeting) The presence of shareholders in the shareholders’ meeting shall be calculated in accordance
with the number of shares and the Article 177 of Company Act.
Chairman shall call the shareholders’ meeting to order at the time scheduled for the
meeting. If the number of shares represented by the attending shareholders has not yet constituted more than one-half of all issued and outstanding shares at the time scheduled
for the meeting, the chairman may postpone the time for the meeting. The postponements
shall be limited to two times at the most and the meeting shall not be postponed for longer than one hour in the aggregate. If the quorum is not met after two postponements and the
attending shareholders still represent less than one third of the total number of issued
shares, the chairman shall declare the meeting adjourned. If after two postponements the number of attending shares represented by the attending
shareholders has not yet constituted more than one-third of all issued and outstanding
shares, provisional resolutions may be made in accordance with Paragraph 1 of Article 175 of the Company Act, all shareholders shall be notified of the tentative resolution and another
shareholders’ meeting shall be convened within 1 month.
If the attending shareholders have constituted more than one-half of all issued and outstanding shares by the end of the meeting, the chairman may submit the foregoing
provisional resolutions to the shareholders’ meeting for approval in accordance with Article
174 of the Company Act.
Article 10 (Proposal Discussions) The agenda of the shareholders’ meeting shall be set by the board of directors if the
shareholders’ meeting is called by the board of directors. Unless otherwise resolved at the
shareholders’ meeting, the shareholders’ meeting shall proceed in accordance with the
agenda. The above provision applies mutatis mutandis to cases where the shareholders’ meeting
is convened by any person, other than the board of directors, which is entitled to convene
such shareholders’ meeting. Unless otherwise resolved at the shareholders’ meeting, the chairman cannot announce
adjournment of the shareholders’ meeting before all the discussion items (including extempore motions) set forth in the agenda are resolved. In the event that the chairman adjourns the shareholders’ meeting in violation of these Rules and Procedures, the other members of the board of directors shall promptly assist the attending shareholders in electing a new
79
chair in accordance with statutory procedures, may designate, by agreement of a majority of votes represented by the attending shareholders, one person as chairman to continue the meeting.
When the chairman considers that the discussion for a motion in the agenda and an amendment or extemporaneous item is raised by the shareholder, he/she shall explain and offer the opportunity sufficiently for discussion, and once it has reached the level for making a resolution, he/she shall announce discontinuance of the discussion and submit the motion for resolution. Article 11 (Speaking at Shareholders’ Meeting)
A present shareholder shall, before taking the floor to speak, submit a Speech Request Note filled out the key points of speech, the shareholder’s code (or code of presence certificate) and name. The sequence of shareholder’s speaking is decided by the chairman.
A present shareholder who only submits a Speech Request Note but without actually speaking shall be deemed as not having spoken. In case of a discrepancy between what is stated on the Speech Request Note and what is actually spoken, the contents actually spoken shall prevail.
Unless otherwise permitted by the chairman, each shareholder shall not, for each discussion item, speak more than two times in excess of 5 minutes each time. In case the speech of any shareholder violates the above provision or exceeds the scope of the discussion item, the chairman may stop the speech of such shareholder.
Unless otherwise permitted by the chairman and the speaking shareholder, no shareholder shall interrupt the speech of the speaking shareholder, otherwise the chairman shall stop such a violation.
If a corporate shareholder designates two or more representatives to attend the shareholders’ meeting, only one representative can speak for each item.
After the speech of a shareholder, the chairman may respond himself/herself or appoint an appropriate person to respond. Article 12 (Calculation of Voting Shares and Recusal System)
The voting of shareholders in the shareholders’ meeting shall be calculated in accordance with the number of shares.
The shareholder who owns a share of the Bank is entitled to one voting power, except when the shares are restricted or are deemed non-voting shares under paragraph 2, Article 179 of the Company Act.
80
The shares held by shareholders having no voting right shall not be counted in the total
number of issued shares while adopting a resolution at a meeting of shareholders. A shareholder who has a personal interest in the matter under discussion at a meeting,
which may have a conflict of interest with the Bank shall not vote nor exercise the voting
right on behalf of another shareholder. In passing a resolution at a shareholders’ meeting, shares for which voting right cannot
be exercised as provided in the prescribed Paragraph shall not be counted in the number of
votes of shareholders present at the meeting. Except for trust enterprises or stock agencies approved by the competent authority, when
a person who acts as the proxy for two or more shareholders, the number of voting power
represented by him/her shall not exceed 3% of the total number of voting shares of the Bank, if so, the portion of excessive voting power shall not be counted.
Article 13 (Ways of Voting, Ballot Counting and Ballot Scrutinizing) When convening the shareholders’ meeting, the Bank shall accept written notice or electronic
votes as means of exercising voting power, the ways of exercising and declaration shall be
done in accordance with Articles 177-1 and 177-2 of Company Act. Except as otherwise provided in the Company Act and in the Bank’s Articles of Incorporation,
the passage of a proposal shall require an affirmative vote of a majority of the voting rights
represented by the attending shareholders. At the time of a vote, for each proposal, the chairman or a person designated by the chairman shall first announce the total number of
voting rights represented by the attending shareholders, followed by a poll of the shareholders.
After the conclusion of the shareholders’ meeting, the voting results for each proposal, including the number of positive votes, negative votes and abstentions, shall be uploaded on
the MOPS.
When there is an amendment or an alternative to a proposal, the chairman shall present the amended or alternative proposal together with the original proposal and decide the
order in which they will be put to a vote. When any one among them is passed, the other
proposals will then be deemed rejected, and no further voting shall be required. The persons for supervising the casting of votes and the counting thereof for resolutions
shall be designated by the chairman, provided, however, that the person supervising the
casting of votes shall be a shareholder. Vote counting for shareholders meeting proposals or elections shall be conducted in
public at the place of the shareholders meeting. Immediately after vote counting has been
81
completed, the results of the voting, including the statistical tallies of the numbers of votes,
shall be announced on the spot, and be placed on record.
Article 14 (Election of Directors) The election of directors at a shareholders meeting shall be held in accordance with the
applicable election and appointment rules adopted by the Bank, and the voting results shall
be announced on-site immediately, including the names of those elected as directors and
the numbers of votes with which they were elected. The ballots for the election referred to in the preceding paragraph shall be sealed with the
signatures of the monitoring personnel and kept in proper custody for at least 1 year. If,
however, a shareholder files a lawsuit pursuant to Article 189 of the Company Act, the ballots shall be retained until the conclusion of the litigation.
Article 15 (Meeting minutes and Signature affixing) Resolutions adopted at the shareholders’ meeting shall be recorded in the minutes of the
meeting, which shall be affixed with the signature or seal of the chairman of the meeting
and shall be distributed to all shareholders of the Bank within twenty days after the close of the meeting. The preparation and distribution of the minutes of shareholders’ meeting may
be conducted by means of electronic transmission.
The prescribed distribution of meeting minutes, it may be conducted by posting the public announcement on Market Observation Post System (“MOPS”) designated by the authorities.
The meeting minutes shall accurately record the year, month, day, and place of the
meeting, the chair's full name, the methods by which resolutions were adopted, and a summary of the deliberations and their results, and shall be retained for the duration of the
existence of the Bank.
Article 16 (Public Announcement)
The shares solicited by the solicitor and shares represented by the proxy agents, and
shares voted in writing or via electronic voting system, shall be publicly disclosed by the Bank in the required format at the place of meeting.
Any resolution of the Shareholders’ meeting, which fits in the required reporting item by the law or the important information stipulated by the TWSE, the Bank shall upload such resolution to the MOPS within required deadline.
82
Article 17 (Maintenance of Meeting Order) Staff handling administrative affairs of a shareholders meeting shall wear identification
cards or arm bands. The chairman may conduct the disciplinary officers or the security guard to assist in
keeping order of the Meeting place. Such disciplinary officers or security guards shall wear badges marked “Disciplinary Officers” for identification.
At the place of a shareholders’ meeting, if a shareholder attempts to speak through any device other than the public address equipment set up by the Bank, the chairman may prevent the shareholder from so doing.
Shareholders who fail to obey the Rules and Procedures, and the correction either from the chairman or disciplinary officers, the chairman may ask the disciplinary officers or security guard to correct such disobedience by escorting them to leave the meeting place. Article 18(Intermission and Resume)
During the meeting, the chairman may, at his discretion, set time for intermission, and in case of incident of force majeure, the chairman may decide to temporarily suspend the meeting and announce, depending on the situation, when the meeting will be resumed.
If the scheduled agenda (including the extemporaneous item) is not discussed fully yet, and the venue is not able to be used at that time, the meeting, by resolution of the shareholders present at the meeting, may be resumed at another venue.
A resolution may be adopted at a shareholders’ meeting to postpone or resume the meeting within 5 days in accordance with Article 182 of Company Act.
Article 19
Any matter not provided in these Rules and Procedures shall be handled in accordance with Company Act, Bank’s Articles of Incorporation, Regulations Governing the Use of Proxies for Attendance at Shareholder Meetings of Public Companies and other relevant laws and regulations. Article 20
These Rules and Procedure shall be effective after being approved by the shareholders’ meeting. The same applies in case of revision.
83
The Rules and Procedures was developed after the inaugural meeting on December 28th
1992. The 1st amendment was made at the Annual General Shareholders’ Meeting on April 16th,
1998.
The 2nd amendment was made at the Annual General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 17th, 2002.
The 3rd amendment was made at the Annual General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 9th,
2006. The 4th amendment was made at the Annual General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 10th,
2011.
The 5th amendment was made at the Annual General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 22nd, 2012.
The 6th amendment was made at the Annual General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 6th,
2014. The 7th amendment was made at the Annual General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 8th,
2016.
84
Appendix 3 Articles of Incorporation of EnTie Commercial Bank
Chapter I. General Provisions
Article 1 The Bank shall be incorporated under the Company Act and the Banking Act of the Republic of China, and shall be named as EnTie Commercial Bank Co., Ltd., (short for “EnTie Bank”.) Article 2 The Bank shall have its head office in Taipei, the Republic of China, and may set up local and overseas branches at suitable locations depending on business needs upon approval of the Board of Directors and the competent authority. Article 3 Public announcement of the Bank shall be made in accordance with Article 28 of the Company Act.
Chapter II. Scope of Businesses Article 4 The Bank’s scope of business includes: H101021 Commercial Banking Business (limited to business items approved by the competent authority), H602011 Personal Insurance Broker, and H602021 Property and Liability Insurance Broker. The Bank is also authorized to conduct other banking related businesses that are approved by the Competent Authority.
Chapter III. Shares Article 5 This Company’s authorized capital shall be NT$ 47.6 billion, dividing to 4.76 billion shares, each with a par value of NT$10, which can be issued in tranches. “Preferred stocks” can be issued. The shares held by “same person” or “same connected person” shall comply with Article 25 of the Banking Act.
85
Article 5-1 This Company may issue 621,890,000 shares of Series 1 Convertible Perpetual Preferred
Shares, each with a par value of NT$10 (the “Series 1 CPPS”) in one issuance or in
tranches. The major terms and conditions are as follows: 1. If the Bank has any profit after every year, losses of the previous years shall first be
covered after the payment of taxes and adjustment due to accounting rule changes. If
there is any remaining amount, the Bank shall set aside or add reversal of legal and special reserves in accordance with Article 40 of the AOI, and then distribute dividend to
the holders of Series 1 CPPS as described herein.
2. Holders of Series 1 CPPS shall be entitled to receive annual cash dividend of a fixed rate of 6.75% (“Annual Dividends”), payable in cash. After the annual financial statements
have been ratified in the annual shareholders meeting, the Board of Director shall set a
record date for distribute Annual Dividends for the preceding fiscal year. Pro-rata dividend to Series 1 CPPS will be paid in the year of issuance of the Series 1 CPPS
based on actual holding period of that year from the date of issuance which shall be the
record date for the capital increase. Pro-rata dividend will also be paid to Series 1 CPPS in the year of redemption of the Series 1 CPPS based on actual holding period of that
year.
3. If there are no earnings or the earnings are not sufficient for the full payment of the Annual Dividends of Series 1 CPPS in any fiscal year, the insufficient amount will not
be accumulated to the years thereafter.
4. Holders of Series 1 CPPS shall be entitled, in addition to the Annual Dividends distributable under Item 2 of this Article, if so resolved by the Board of Directors, to
participate in the dividends declared on Common Share at a ratio of every 2 shares of
Series 1 CPPS for each Common Share dividend; provided that such participation right shall be available only if, after the distributions of cash dividends for Common Share at an
amount equal to the cash dividends distributed for Series 1 CPPS per share, there is
any remaining balance.
5. The Series 1 CPPS will have a liquidation preference per share over the Common Share
up to the Purchase Price. Series 1 CPPS.
6. Voting Rights: Holder of Series 1 CPPS shall be entitled to vote and the right to elect and being elected together with the Common Shares on an as-converted basis. Holder
86
of Series 1 CPPS shall be entitled to vote in preferred shareholders meeting.
7. Holder of Series 1 CPPS will have same preemptive rights as Common Shares holders with respect to subscription of new share issuance
8. Except for the closed period in which the share registrar is closed or the conversion of any
convertible securities is suspended according to laws and regulations, at the option of the holders, the Series 1 CPPS are convertible into Common Shares on a one-to-one
basis, at any time after one month of the date of the issuance and the Common Shares
issued upon such conversion shall have the same rights and obligations as other outstanding Common Shares. Pro-rata preferred dividend will also be paid in the year
when conversion right is exercised based on holding period of that year; provided,
however, holders of Series 1 CPPS who convert their Series 1 CPPS into Common Shares before the record date for dividends distribution of that year shall have no rights
to participate in the Annual Dividends for Series 1 CPPS in the year of conversion and
any year thereafter.
9. Subject to the applicable laws and approval from the competent authority, this
Company shall have the right to redeem any part or all outstanding Series 1 CPPS after
the 10th anniversary of the Closing, at a redemption price per share equal to the Issuance Price. If any of the Series 1 CPPS are not redeemed after the 10th anniversary
of the Date of Issuance, the annual fix portion of the dividend payments per share will be
increased to 7.75%.
Article 5-2 Deleted Article 6
All the share certificates of the Bank shall bear the name of the shareholder who owns such shares and shall be issued after they are signed or sealed by the Chairman of the Board and
at least two Managing Directors (Directors), affixed with the seal of the Bank, and duly
certified per the “Regulations Governing Certification of Corporate Stock and Bond Issued by Public Companies”.
After public issue of the shares, the Bank may be exempted from printing share certificates.
87
Article 7
Shareholders of the Bank shall handle stock-related matters with the Bank or Bank’s stock agent in accordance with the “Guidelines Governing the Processing of Stock Affairs by
Public Company” and related laws and regulations.
Article 8
Deleted
Article 9
Deleted
Article 10
Deleted
Article 11
Deleted
Article 12
Registration for transfer of shares shall be suspended 60 days immediately before the date
of each General Shareholders Meeting, or 30 days immediately before each Special Shareholders Meeting, or within 5 days before the record date for distributing dividends,
bonuses or other benefits.
Article 13
Deleted
Chapter IV. Shareholders Meeting
Article 14 Shareholders Meetings of the Bank are of two types: 1. General Shareholders Meetings: shall be convened by the Board of Directors within six
months after the end of each fiscal year. 2. Special Shareholders Meetings: may be convened in accordance with law when
necessary.
88
Article 15 The Board of Directors shall prepare the following documents and submit the same to the
Audit Committee for audit 15 days prior to the date for the General Shareholders Meeting:
1. Business report;
2. Financial Statements;
3. Proposal for distribution of profits or covering of losses
Article 16
For any shareholder who is unable to attend a Shareholders Meeting in person, it may be handled in accordance with Article 177 of the Company Act.
The attendance of shareholders in a Shareholders Meeting and the relevant Shareholders
Meeting affairs shall be processed pursuant to the “Regulations Governing Use of Proxies by Public Companies for Attending Shareholders Meetings” promulgated by the competent
authority and related laws and regulations such as the Company Act.
Article 17
Where the Shareholders Meeting is convened by the Board of Directors, the chairman shall
be elected per Paragraph 3 of Article 208 of the Company Act. Where the Shareholders Meeting is convened by a person other than the Board of Directors who has such
convening power, the convening person shall act as the chairman; where there are two or
more convening persons, the convening persons shall elect a chairman from among themselves.
Article 18 Resolutions of the shareholders meetings shall be processed in accordance with the
Company Act and related laws and regulations.
Article 19
The functions and powers of the Shareholders Meetings are as follows:
1. to amend the Articles of Incorporation; 2. to elect Directors
3. to audit documents prepared by the Board of Directors and the Audit Committee
89
4. to resolve on distribution of profits or covering of losses
5. to resolve on increase or decrease of capital 6. other important matters and resolutions on matters prescribed under the Company Act
Article 20
Deleted
Article 21
Except otherwise provided in the laws and AOI, the shareholders of the Bank shall be
entitled to one vote for each share, and any fractional vote shall not be counted.
Article 22
Minutes shall be prepared for all resolutions adopted at a Shareholders Meeting, including the date, place, name of chairman, method for resolution, summary of the resolution
process and the result thereof, and shall be duly signed or sealed by the chairman and
forwarded to each shareholder within twenty (20) days after the meeting. The making and distribution of the minutes for Shareholders Meetings as required in the preceding
Paragraph may be executed in electronic format or by a public notice.
The minutes of the preceding paragraph shall be kept together with attendance book (or
attendance cards) signed by the shareholders present at the meeting and the proxies at the
Bank in accordance with laws and regulations.
Chapter V. Board of Directors Article 23
The Bank shall have 9 to 15 Directors to constitute the Board of Directors. The Directors shall
serve for a term of three years and may continue to serve if re-elected. Election of Directors shall adopt the candidate nomination system and Directors shall be elected from among the
list of candidates for Directors at the shareholders’ meeting.
The Bank shall have at least three Independent Directors, which is not less than one-fifth of
the total number of Directors. The professional qualifications, restrictions on shareholdings
90
and concurrent positions, method of nomination and election, and other matters for
compliance with respect to Independent Directors shall follow related regulations prescribed by the competent authority.
The Bank shall establish the Audit Committee composing of the entire number of independent directors and not fewer than three persons in number, one of whom shall be
the convener and at least one of whom shall have accounting or financial expertise.
Exercise of powers or conducts of the audit committee shall follow related regulations prescribed by the competent authority.
Article 23-1
Deleted
Article 24
The Board of Directors could have three to five managing directors, who will be elected among
directors. One chairman and vice chairman should be elected among managing directors (directors). The chairman will represent the Company externally and the chairman’s
authority is limited the provisions of laws and regulations and the Articles of Incorporations
of the company, and the resolutions adopted by the shareholders' meetings and the meetings of the board of directors.
The managing directors shall include no less than one independent director member, and no less than one-fifth of the managing director seats shall be held by independent directors.
Article 25 The remuneration of the chairman, the vice chairman, managing directors and directors should
accord with their respective participation and contribution to the corporate operation, in
addition to be compared with the industrial standard, and then be approved by the meeting of Board of Directors after the Board acquires authorization.
Different but reasonable remuneration from that of other directors may be set forth for the independent directors.
91
Article 26
The functions and powers of the Board of Directors are as follows: 1. to prescribe important rules and organizational bylaws;
2. to approve business plans;
3. to propose increase or decrease of capital; 4. to make decision on establishment, close or change local and overseas branches;
5. to review important contracts;
6. to approve budget and closing of books; 7. to make decision on purchase and disposal of material real properties; provided that
resolution of the Shareholders Meeting is required in case of assignment of all or the
major portion of business or assets to another party or assumption of all or the major portion of business or assets from another party which has material impact on the Bank;
8. to propose distribution of profits or covering of losses;
9. to approve important business decisions; 10. to appoint and discharge the General Manager, Vice General Manager, chief auditor,
Assistant General Manager, chiefs and deputy chiefs of departments, and branch (regional
center) managers; 11. to establish special committees with different kinds of functions and to approve the rules
for committees’ exercise of authority;
12. other functions and powers in accordance with laws and regulations or as authorized by the shareholders meeting.
Article 26-1
The Board of Directors could purchase the liability insurance for directors and key staff with
respect to their liabilities resulting from exercising their duties during their terms of
occupancy.
Article 27
The Board of Directors calls one meeting every three months through the convening of the chairman. The chairman can call the meeting at any time upon contingency or the request
from more than 50% of directors. In addition to the print notification, the Bank’s Board
meeting could be convened by the Chairman via mail, fax notices or notices in electronic transmission. If the chairman fails to convene the meeting of directors or the meeting of
managing directors, the vice chairman shall act on his behalf. But if the vice chairman fails
to convene or exercise his power and authority for any cause within 7 days started at the
92
required day, then the chairman should appoint one managing director (director) as the proxy to convene in advance. Should no proxy be appointed, the convener can be chosen among managing directors (directors). When the board meetings are adjourned, the Managing Directors will exercise their rights on behalf of the board, and meetings can be convened by the Chairman. However any items that concern greater interests of the Company, the board has the final decision. Article 28 At both the meeting of directors and the meeting of managing directors, the chairman of the Company shall act as the chairman of the meeting. In the event that the chairman is on leave or fails to exercise his power and authority for any cause whatsoever, the vice chairman shall act on his behalf. But if the vice chairman is also on leave or fails to exercise his power and authority for any cause, one of managing directors (directors) should be appointed to act on behalf of the chairman. If there is no appointment, a director should be elected among all the directors and act on behalf of the chairman. Article 29 Unless otherwise provided for in the Company Act, the Board meeting shall be attended by a majority of Directors, and resolutions of the Board of Directors shall be adopted by a majority vote of the present Directors. The meeting of Managing Directors shall be attended by a majority of Managing Directors, and resolutions of the meeting of Managing Directors shall be adopted by a majority vote of the present Managing Directors. Minutes shall be prepared for the Board Meeting or meeting of Managing Directors, duly signed or sealed by the chairman, and shall be forwarded to each Director or Executive Director within twenty (20) days after the meeting. Where a Board Meeting is held by videoconference, a Director attending the
videoconference shall be deemed as present in person. The Minutes shall include the date, place, name of chairman, method for resolution, summary of the resolution process and the result thereof, and shall be kept together with attendance book (or attendance cards) signed by the present Directors or Managing Directors and the proxies at the Bank. The making and distribution of the Minutes may be executed in electronic format.
93
Article 30 A Director may designate another Director to act as his proxy at that meeting by a proxy form. A Director may act as proxy for only one absent Director.
Chapter VI. (Deleted)
Article 31
Deleted
Article 32
Deleted
Article 33
Deleted
Article 34
Deleted
Chapter VII. Managers Article 35
The Bank shall have one President to take full charge of business matters of the Bank in
accordance with resolutions of the Board of Directors. Furthermore, the Bank should have several Senior Vice Presidents and Vice Presidents to assist processing business matters of
the Bank. Appointment and discharge of the President is proposed by the Chairman to the
Board of Directors to be approved by a majority of the Directors. Appointment and discharge of the Senior Vice Presidents, Vice Presidents, chiefs of departments, and
branch (regional banking center) managers shall be proposed by the Chairman to the
94
Board of Directors to be approved by a majority of the Directors. Appointment of managers
shall comply with the qualification requirements set by the competent authority.
The Board of Directors is authorized to determine the number of the aforesaid Senior Vice
Presidents and Vice Presidents depending on actual need.
Article 36
Where the President is for a reason not able to execute business, the Chairman of the Board of Directors shall appoint a Senior Vice President to act as the deputy.
Article 37 The Bank due to business necessity may engage consultants, whose appointment and
discharge shall be proposed by the Chairman to the Board of Directors for approval.
Chapter VIII. Accounting
Article 38 The fiscal year of the Bank begins January 1st and ends on December 31st. Upon close of each fiscal year, the board of directors shall prepare the following books and statements and submit the same to the Shareholders’ Meeting for recognition in accordance with the legal procedure: 1. Business report; 2. Financial Statements; 3. Plan for distribution of profits or covering of losses. The aforesaid closing books and statements shall be filed with the competent authority per the Company Act, the Securities and Exchange Law, the Banking Act of the Republic of China and other related laws and regulations and be publicly announced as required.
Article 39 When there is any profit (i.e. the Before-Tax Income prior to the deductions of
employees’ and board members remunerations) at the end of each year, the Bank shall
allocate not less than one percent of the said profit as employees’ remuneration, and no more than one percent as remunerations of directors and supervisors. However, the Bank’s
accumulated losses should have been covered beforehand.
95
The preceding paragraph regarding supervisors’ remuneration shall no longer be applicable when the Bank establishes the audit committee in lieu of supervisors.
Article 40 If the Bank has any profit after every year, after the payment of taxes and adjustment due to
accounting rule changes, losses of the previous years shall be covered first. If there is any
remaining amount, the Bank shall set aside legal reserve based on the Banking Act, and then set aside special reserve or add reversal of special reserve based on relevant
regulations or requests by the competent authority or business needs before the
distribution of the annual cash dividend of the fixed rate to the holders of Series 1 specified in Article 5-1 of the AOI. If there is any remaining amount, the Board may add it up with the
undistributed accumulated profit in the beginning of a fiscal year, and take into
consideration the business environmental changes, appropriate capital adequacy ratio, and capital needs for long-term financial planning, and then come up with a profit-allocation plan,
which shall be sent to the Shareholders’ Meeting for approval.
As to the allocation of shareholders’ bonus, pure stock, pure cash or a mix of stock and
cash may be adopted, and decided by the Shareholders’ Meeting. However if Tier 1 capital
of the Bank doesn’t meet regulatory requirement, stock dividend takes priority. For constraints related to cash dividend, Article 50 of the Banking Act of the Republic of China
shall be followed.
Chapter IX. Supplemental Provisions
Article 41
Deleted
Article 42
If the financial institution and the Bank’s responsible person have been harmed by gossip
or ruin its credit, the Bank’s responsible person should immediately propose to Adjustment Unit in relation to Article 313 and 314 of the Criminal Law, to make the problem replied and
solved earlier.
96
Article 43 Matters not provided for in these Articles of Incorporation shall be dealt with in accordance
with the Banking Act, Company Act, Securities and Exchange Act and other pertinent laws.
Article 44
The Articles of Incorporations was developed after approval by the entire founders on
September 26, 1991.
The 1st amendment was made at the inaugural meeting on December 28, 1992.
The 2nd amendment was made at the 2nd General Shareholders’ Meeting on May 16, 1994.
The 3rd amendment was made at the 3rd General Shareholders’ Meeting on April 20, 1995.
The 4th amendment was made at the 4th General Shareholders’ Meeting on April 12, 1996.
The 5th amendment was made at the 5th General Shareholders’ Meeting on May 7, 1997.
The 6th amendment was made at the 6th General Shareholders’ Meeting on April 16, 1998.
The 7th amendment was made at the 7th General Shareholders’ Meeting on May 18, 1999.
The 8th amendment was made at the 8th General Shareholders’ Meeting on May 18, 2000.
The 9th amendment was made at the 9th General Shareholders’ Meeting on May 8, 2001.
The 10th amendment was made at the 10th General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 17, 2002.
The 11th amendment was made at the Extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting on November
21, 2003.
The 12th amendment was made at the 12th General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 9,
2006.
The 13th amendment was made at the Extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting on March 9, 2007.
The 14th amendment was made at the General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 5, 2007.
The 15th amendment was made at the Extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting on August 6, 2007.
The 16th amendment was made at the Extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting on December
27, 2007.
97
The 17th amendment was made at the Extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting on February 20,
2008.
The 18th amendment was made at the General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 19, 2009.
The 19th amendment was made at the General Shareholders’ Meeting on May 27, 2010.
The 20th amendment was made at the General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 10, 2011.
The 21st amendment was made at the General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 22, 2012.
The 22nd amendment was made at the General Shareholders’ Meeting on March 29, 2013.
The 23rd amendment was made at the General Shareholders’ Meeting on June 12, 2015. All amended and deleted articles shall be implemented after the approval of the General
Meeting of Shareholders except for the revised Article 15, Subparagraph 2 and 3 of
Paragraph 1 of Article 19, Article 23, Article 26-1, Article 39, Subparagraph 2 of Paragraph 1 of Article 40, and the deleted Article 31 to Article 34 of Chapter VI, which will take effect
after the re-election of the 9th term Board of Directors.
The 24th amendment was made at the General Meeting of Shareholders on June 8, 2016.
98
Appendix 4 The Criteria Governing Codes of Ehtical Conduct of
EnTie Commercial Bank
Article 1 (Purpose and scope of the Criteria) The Criteria is adopted for the purpose of encouraging directors and managerial
officers (including general managers or their equivalents, assistant general managers
or their equivalents, deputy assistant general managers or their equivalents, chief financial and chief accounting officers, and other persons authorized to manage affairs
and sign documents on behalf of the Bank) of EnTie Commercial Bank (the “Bank”) to
act in line with ethical standards.
Article 2 (Content of the Criteria) Matters to be followed by directors and managerial officers are as follows:
1. Prevention of conflicts of interests
A director and managerial officer of the Bank, and a person authorized to
manage affairs and sign documents on behalf of the Bank shall perform their
duties in an objective and efficient manner, and shall not take advantage of their positions to benefit for either themselves or their spouses, parents, children, or
relatives within the second degree of kinship.
Should the Bank provide loans of funds or guarantees to, or have major asset transactions or the purchase (or sale) of goods with the affiliated enterprise at
which a director and managerial officer works, such persons shall voluntarily explain
whether there is any potential conflict between them and the Bank. 2. Minimizing incentives to pursue personal gain
Directors and managerial officers shall not engage in any of the following activities:
(1) Seeking an opportunity to pursue personal gain by using property or information of the Bank or taking advantage of their positions;
(2) Obtaining personal gain by using property or information of the Bank or taking
advantage of their positions; (3) Competing with the Bank. When the Bank has an opportunity for profit, it is the
responsibility of the directors and managerial officers to maximize the reasonable
and proper benefits that can be obtained by the Bank. 3. Prevention of unethical behavior
Directors and managerial officers shall perform their duties in an impartial, ethical
99
and fair manner, and shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise, request or receive
improper benefits, or have unethical activities in violation of ethical principles, a law or regulation, or breach of fiduciary duty for the purpose of obtaining or maintaining
personal gain.
4. Confidentiality Directors and managerial officers shall be bound by the obligation to maintain
the confidentiality of any information regarding the Bank itself or its clients, except
when authorized or required by law to disclose such information. Confidential information includes any undisclosed information that, if exploited by a competitor
or disclosed, could result in damage to the Bank or its clients.
5. Fair trade Directors and managerial officers shall treat all clients, competitors, and employees
fairly, and may not obtain improper benefits through manipulation, nondisclosure,
or misuse of the information learned by virtue of their positions, or through misrepresentation of important matters, or through other unfair trading practices.
6. Safeguarding and proper use of Bank assets
All directors and managerial officers have the responsibility to safeguard Bank assets and to ensure that they can be effectively and lawfully used for official
business purposes.
7. Legal compliance Directors and managerial officers shall comply with the Securities and Exchange
Act and other applicable laws, regulations, and bylaws.
8. Encouraging reporting on illegal or unethical activities The Bank shall encourage employees to report to an independent director,
managerial officer, chief auditor, or other appropriate individual upon suspicion
or discovery of any activity in violation of a law or regulation or the Criteria. To encourage employees to report illegal conduct, the Bank shall establish a
concrete whistle-blowing system and make employees aware that the Bank will
use its best efforts to ensure the safety of informants and protect them from reprisals.
9. Disciplinary measures
When a director or a managerial officer violates the Criteria, the Bank shall handle the matter in accordance with the Company Act, Articles of Incorporation
of the Bank, and relevant internal regulations, and shall without delay disclose
100
on the Market Observation Post System (MOPS) the date of the violation, reasons
for the violation, the provisions of the code violated, and the disciplinary actions taken. A violator penalized for violation of the Criteria could appeal for remedies
in accordance with relevant regulations if he/she feels needed.
Article 3 (Procedures for exemption) Any exemption for directors and managerial officers from compliance with the Criteria
shall be adopted by a resolution of the board of directors, and information on the date on which the board of directors adopted the resolution for exemption, objections or
reservations of independent directors, and the period of, reasons for, and principles
behind the application of the exemption shall be disclosed without delay on the MOPS, in order that the shareholders may evaluate the appropriateness of the board resolution
to forestall any arbitrary or dubious exemption from the Criteria, and to safeguard the
interests of the Bank by ensuring appropriate mechanisms for controlling any circumstance under which such an exemption occurs.
Article 4 (Method of disclosure) The Bank shall disclose the Criteria it has adopted, and any amendments to it, on
its company website, in its annual reports and prospectuses and on the MOPS.
Article 5 (Enforcement) The Criteria, and any amendments to it, shall enter into force after it has been
adopted by the board of directors, delivered to each independent director, and submitted
to a shareholders meeting for record.
The Rules and Procedures was established at the 18th meeting of the 8th board of directors on
December 18, 2015.
The 1st amendment was made and approved by the president on June 29, 2016 with the authorization
granted at the 1st extraordinary board meeting of the 9th board of directors
101
Appendix 5 The Criteria for Ethical Corporate Management,
EnTie Commercial Bank
Article 1 (Purpose) In order to establish a corporate culture of ethical management and strengthen
the Bank’s management, and pursuant to TWSE/GTSM the “Ethical Corporate Management
Best Practice Principles for TWSE/GTSM-Listed Companies,” EnTie Commercial Bank
(short as “the Bank” hereafter) hereby establishes the Criteria accordingly. Article 2 (Preventing Unethical Conduct)
When engaging in commercial activities, directors, managers, employees, mandataries of the Bank or persons having substantial control over the Bank (short as “Substantial
Controllers” hereafter) shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise to offer, request or
accept any improper Benefits, nor commit unethical acts including breach of ethics, illegal acts, or breach of fiduciary duty (short as “Unethical Conduct” hereafter) for
purposes of acquiring or maintaining Benefits.
Parties referred to in the preceding paragraph include civil servants, political candidates, political parties or members of political parties, state-run or private-owned
businesses or institutions, and their directors, supervisors, managers, employees or
Substantial Controllers or other interested parties. Article 3 (Types of Benefits)
“Benefits” in the Criteria means any valuable things, including money, endowments, commissions, positions, services, preferential treatment or rebates of any type or in
any name. Benefits received or given occasionally in accordance with accepted social
customs and that do not adversely affect specific rights and obligations shall be excluded.
Article 4 (Legal Compliance) The Bank shall comply with the Company Act, Securities and Exchange Act,
Business Entity Accounting Act, Political Donations Act, Anti-Corruption Statute,
Government Procurement Act, Act on Recusal of Public Servants Due to Conflicts of
Interest, TWSE/GTSM-listing rules, or other laws or regulations regarding commercial activities, as the underlying basic premise to facilitate ethical corporate management.
102
Article 5 (Policy) The Bank shall abide by the operational philosophies of honesty, transparency
and responsibility, base policies on the Criteria of good faith and establish good
corporate governance and risk control and management mechanism so as to create
an operational environment for sustainable development.
Article 6 (Prevention Program) The Bank shall in their own ethical management policy clearly and thoroughly
prescribe the specific ethical management practices and establish in their own ethical
corporate management best practice criteria comprehensive programs to forestall
Unethical Conduct (“Prevention Program”), including operational procedures, code of conduct, and training.
When establishing the Prevention Program, the Bank shall comply with relevant
laws and regulations of the territory where the Bank is operating. In the course of developing the prevention program, the Bank is advised to negotiate
with staff, labor unions members, important trading counterparties, or other stakeholders.
Article 7 (Scope of Prevention Program)
When establishing the Prevention Program, the Bank shall analyze which business
activities within its business scope which are possibly at a higher risk of being involved in an Unethical Conduct, and strengthen the preventive measures.
The Prevention Program established by the Bank shall at least include preventive
measures against the following: 1. Offering and acceptance of bribes
2. Illegal political donations
3. Improper charitable donations or sponsorship 4. Offering or acceptance of unreasonable presents or hospitality, or other improper
Benefits
5. Misappropriation of trade secrets and infringement of trademark rights, patent rights, copyrights, and other intellectual property rights
6. Engaging in unfair competitive practices
7. Damage directly or indirectly caused to the rights or interests, health, or safety of consumers or other stakeholders in the course of research and development,
procurement, provision, or sale of products and services
103
Article 8 (Promise and Enforcement) The Bank shall clearly specify in their rules and external documents the ethical
corporate management policies and the commitment by the board of directors and the
management on rigorous and thorough implementation of such policies, and shall carry out the policies in internal management and in commercial activities.
Article 9 ( Ethical Management in Commercial Activities) The Bank shall engage in commercial activities in a fair and transparent manner
on the principle of ethical management.
Prior to any commercial transactions, The Bank shall take into consideration the legality of its agents, suppliers, clients, or other trading counterparties and whether any
of them are involved in Unethical Conduct, and shall avoid any dealings with persons
so involved. When entering into contracts with agents, suppliers, clients, or other trading
counterparties, The Bank shall include in such contracts provisions demanding ethical
corporate management policy compliance and which in the event the trading counterparties are suspected of engaging in Unethical Conduct, The Bank may at any time terminate
or cancel the contracts.
Article 10 (Forbidding Bribery and Receiving Brides)
When conducting business, the Bank and its directors, managers, employees,
mandataries and Substantial Controllers, shall not directly or indirectly offer, promise to offer, request, or accept any improper benefits in other ways from clients, trading
counterparties, public servants, or other interested parties.
Article 11 (Forbidding Illegal Political Donations)
When directly or indirectly offering a donation to political parties or organizations
or individuals participating in political activities, the Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers, shall comply with the Political
Donations Act and their own relevant internal operational procedures, and shall not
make such donations in exchange for commercial gains or business advantages.
104
Article 12 (Forbidding Improper Donations and Sponsorship) When making or offering donations and sponsorship, the Bank and its directors,
managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers shall comply with
relevant laws and regulations and internal operational procedures, and shall not
surreptitiously engage in bribery.
Article 13 (Forbidding Giving out/Receiving Unreasonable Presents, Hospitality or Other Improper Benefits)
The Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial
Controllers shall not directly or indirectly offer or accept any unreasonable presents,
hospitality or other improper Benefits to establish business relationship or influence commercial transactions.
Article 14 (Forbidding Infringing Intellectual Property Rights)
The Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial
Controllers shall observe applicable laws and regulations, internal operational procedures,
and contractual provisions concerning intellectual property, and may not use, disclose, dispose, or damage intellectual property or otherwise infringe intellectual property
rights without the prior consent of the intellectual property rights holder. Article 15 (Forbidding Engaging in Unfair Competitive Practices)
The Bank shall engage in business activities in accordance with applicable
competition laws and regulations, compliance with the Fair Trade Commission’s regulations to finance enterprises.
Article 16 (Preventing Products and Services Damaging Stakeholders) In the course of research and development, procurement, provision, or sale of
products and services, the Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandatories
and Substantial Controllers shall observe applicable laws and regulations and international standards to ensure the transparency of information about, and safety of their financial
products and services. They shall also adopt and publish a policy on the protection of
the rights and interests of consumers or other stakeholders, and carry out the policy in their operations, with a view to preventing their products and services from directly or
indirectly damaging the rights and interests, health, and safety of consumers or other
105
stakeholders. Where there are sufficient facts to determine that the Bank’s services are
likely to pose any hazard to the safety and health of consumers or other stakeholders, the Bank shall in principle, suspend the services immediately.
Article 17 (Organization and Responsibility)
The directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers
of the Bank shall exercise the due care of good administrators to urge the company to
prevent Unethical Conduct, always review the results of the preventive measures and continually make adjustments so as to ensure thorough implementation of its ethical
corporate management policies.
To achieve sound ethical corporate management, the Bank shall establish a dedicated unit that is under the board of directors and responsible for establishing and
enforcing the ethical corporate management policies and Prevention Program. The
dedicated unit shall be in charge of the following matters, and shall report to the board of directors on a regular basis:
1. Assisting in incorporating ethics and moral values into the company's business
strategy and adopting appropriate prevention measures against corruption and malfeasance to ensure ethical management in compliance with the requirements of
laws and regulations.
2. Adopting programs to prevent Unethical Conduct and setting out in each program the standard operating procedures and conduct guidelines with respect to the
company's operations and business.
3. Planning the internal organization, structure, and allocation of responsibilities and setting up check-and-balance mechanisms for mutual supervision of the business
activities within the business scope which are possibly at a higher risk for Unethical
Conduct. 4. Promoting and coordinating awareness and educational activities with respect to
ethics policy.
5. Developing a whistle-blowing system and ensuring its operating effectiveness. 6. Assisting the board of directors and management in auditing and assessing
whether the prevention measures taken for the purpose of implementing ethical
management are effectively operating, and preparing reports on the regular assessment of compliance with ethical management in operating procedures.
106
Article 18 (Legal Compliance of Conducting Business) The Bank and its directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial
Controllers shall comply with laws and regulations and the Prevention Program when
conducting business.
If the Bank is fined by the competent authorities due to the violation of provision stipulated in paragraph 1, Article 133 of Banking Act, it shall propose a compensation
claim to the person in charge of the corresponding matters at the Personnel Evaluation
Committee meeting for discussion.
Article 19 (Preventing Conflicts of Interest) The Bank shall promulgate policies for preventing conflicts of interest to identify,
monitor, and manage risks possibly resulting from Unethical Conduct, and shall also
offer appropriate means for directors, managers, and other stakeholders attending or
present at board meetings to voluntarily explain whether their interests would potentially conflict with those of the Bank.
When a proposal at a given board of directors meeting concerns the personal
interest of, or the interest of the juristic person represented by, any of the directors, managers, and other stakeholders attending or present at board meetings, the concerned
person shall state the important aspects of the relationship of interest at the given
board meeting. If his or her participation is likely to prejudice the interest of the Bank, the concerned person may not participate in discussion of or voting on the proposal
and shall recuse himself or herself from the discussion or the voting, and may not
exercise voting rights as proxy for another director. The directors shall practice self-discipline and must not support one another in improper dealings.
The Bank’s directors, managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers
shall not take advantage of their positions or influence in the Bank to obtain improper Benefits for themselves, their spouses, parents, children or any other person.
Article 20 (Accounting and Internal Control) The Bank shall establish effective accounting systems and internal control systems
for business activities which may at a higher risk of being involved in an Unethical
Conduct, not have under-the-table accounts or keep secret accounts, and conduct reviews regularly so as to ensure that the design and enforcement of the systems are
showing results.
107
Auditing Dep. shall periodically examine the Bank’s compliance with the foregoing
and prepare audit reports and submit the same to the board of directors. Auditing Dep. may engage a certified public accountant to carry out the audit, and may engage
professionals to assist if necessary.
Article 21 (Operational Procedures and Code of Conduct)
The Bank shall establish operational procedures and code of conduct in
accordance with Article 6 hereof to guide directors, managers, employees, and Substantial Controllers on how to conduct business. The procedures and guidelines
should at least contain the following matters:
1. Standards for determining whether improper Benefits have been offered or accepted
2. Procedures for offering legitimate political donations
3. Procedures and the standard rates for offering charitable donations or sponsorship 4. Rules for avoiding work-related conflicts of interests and how they should be
reported and handled
5. Rules for keeping confidential trade secrets and sensitive business information obtained in the ordinary course of business
6. Regulations and procedures for dealing with clients and business transaction
counterparties suspected of Unethical Conduct 7. Handling procedures for violations of the Criteria for Ethical Management
8. Disciplinary measures on offenders
Article 22 (Educational Training and Performance Appraisal)
The Chairman, the President or the upper level of management of the Bank shall
communicate the importance of corporate ethics to its directors, employees, and mandataries on a regular basis.
The Bank shall periodically organize training and awareness programs for directors,
managers, employees, mandataries and Substantial Controllers, so they understand the Bank’ resolve to implement ethical corporate management, the related policies,
Prevention Program and the consequences of committing Unethical Conduct.
The Bank shall apply the policies of ethical corporate management when creating its employee performance appraisal system and human resource policies to establish
a clear and effective reward and discipline system.
108
Article 23 (Reporting and Disciplinary Actions) The Bank shall adopt a concrete whistle-blowing system and scrupulously operate
the system. The whistle-blowing system shall include at least the following:
1. An independent mailbox or hotline, either internally established and publicly announced or provided by an independent external institution, to allow internal and external
personnel of the Bank to submit reports
2. Dedicated personnel or unit appointed to handle whistle-blowing system. Any tip involving a director or senior manager shall be reported to the independent directors.
Categories of reported misconduct shall be delineated and standard operating
procedures for the investigation of each shall be adopted 3. Documentation of case acceptance, investigation processes, investigation results,
and relevant documents
4. Confidentiality of the identity of whistle-blowers and the content of reported cases 5. Measures for protecting whistle-blowers from inappropriate disciplinary actions due
to their whistle-blowing
6. Whistle-blowing incentive measures When material misconduct or likelihood of material impairment to the Bank comes
to its awareness upon investigation, the dedicated personnel or unit handling the
whistle-blowing system shall immediately prepare a report and notify the independent directors in written form
Article 24 (Disciplinary and Complaint System)
The Bank shall establish a well-defined disciplinary and complaint system to
handle violation of the ethical corporate management rules, and immediately disclose
on the Bank’s internal website the offender’s job title, name, date the violation was committed, violating act and how the matter was handled.
Article 25 (Information Disclosure)
The Bank shall collect quantitative data about the promotion of ethical management and continuously analyze and assess the effectiveness of the promotion of ethical management policy. It shall also disclose the measures taken for implementing ethical corporate management, the status of implementation, the foregoing quantitative data, and the effectiveness of promotion on its websites, annual reports, and prospectuses, and shall disclose the Criteria on the Market Observation Post System.
109
Article 26 (Review of the Policies and Measures of Ethical Management)
The Bank shall at all times monitor the development of relevant local and
international regulations concerning ethical corporate management, and encourage
directors, managers and employees to make suggestions based on which the adopted ethical corporate management policies and measures taken will be reviewed and
improved with a view to achieving better implementation of ethical management.
Article 27 (Implementation)
The Criteria of the Bank shall be implemented after the board of directors grants
the approval, and shall be sent to the independent directors and reported at a shareholders’ meeting. The same procedure shall be followed when the Criteria have
been amended.
When the Criteria is submitted for discussion by the board of directors pursuant to the preceding paragraph, the board of directors shall take into full consideration each
independent director’s opinions. If an independent director objects to or expresses
reservations about any matter, it shall be recorded in the minutes of the board of directors meeting. An independent director intending to express objection or reservations
but unable to attend the meeting in person shall, unless there is some legitimate
reason to do otherwise, issue a written opinion in advance, which shall be recorded in the meeting minutes.
The Criteria was established and approved at the 17th board meeting of the 7th term on Nov. 22, 2011
The 1st amendment was made and approved at the 13th board meeting of the 8th term on Feb. 8, 2015
The 2nd amendment was made and approved by the president on June 29, 2016 with the authorization granted at the 1st
extraordinary board meeting of the 9th term board of directors
110
Appendix 6 The Criteria for Corporate Social Responsibility Best Practice of
EnTie Commercial Bank
Chapter 1 General Provisions Article 1 In order to fulfill corporate social responsibility initiatives, to promote economic,
environmental and social advancement, to achieve sustainable development, and to manage the economic, environmental and social impacts, EnTie Commercial Bank ("the Bank" hereafter) hereby establishes the Criteria pursuant to "Corporate Social Responsibility Best Practice Principles for TWSE/GTSM-Listed Companies”.
Article 2 The Criteria applies to the entire business, including the Bank and subsidiary
companies. The Bank shall actively fulfill its corporate social responsibility in the course of business operations. Therefore, the Bank shall follow the development of international norms, foster corporate citizenship, and enhance its competitive edges built on corporate social responsibility in order to contribute the economic development to the country, and improve the quality of lives of employees, communities and the whole society.
Article 3 To fulfill corporate social responsibility initiatives, the Bank shall, in its corporate
management policies and operation, give due consideration the rights and interests of the stakeholders and while pursuing sustainable operations and profits, also give due consideration to the environment, society and corporate governance.
Article 4 To implement corporate social responsibility initiatives, the Bank shall follow
the principles below: 1. Implement corporate governance. 2. Foster a sustainable environment. 3. Protect employee’s legal rights and interests. 4. Preserve public welfare. 5. Enhance disclosure of corporate social responsibility information.
Article 5 The Bank shall pay close attention to the development of domestic and
international corporate social responsibility principles and to its connection
111
to the core of the Bank’s business, and to the influence of the operation of EnTie and its subsidiary companies on the stakeholders. The Bank shall establish policies, systems or relevant management principles and concrete plans for corporate social responsibility programs. They shall be approved by the Board of Directors and reported at a shareholders' meeting. When the shareholders put forth a related proposal involving the corporate social responsibility, the Board of Directors are advised to put it on the agenda of the shareholder's meeting.
Chapter 2 Implementing Corporate Governance Article 6 The Bank shall follow “Corporate Governance Best Practice Principles for Banks”,
“Ethical Corporate Management Best Practice Principles for TWSE/GTSM-Listed Companies” and “Code of Ethical Conduct for TWSE/GTSM-Listed Companies” to establish effective corporate governance framework and relevant ethical standards so as to enhance corporate governance.
Article 7 The Board of Directors shall exercise the due care of good administrators to
urge the Bank to perform its corporate social responsibility initiatives, examine the results of the implementation thereof from time to time and continually make adjustments so as to ensure the thorough implementation of its corporate social responsibility policies. The Board of Directors is advised to consider the interests of interested parties and uphold corporate social responsibility by performing the following: 1. Identifying the company's corporate social responsibility mission or vision,
and declaring its corporate social responsibility policies, systems or relevant management principles.
2. Making corporate social responsibility the guiding principle of the company's operations and development, and approving concrete plan of corporate social responsibility.
3. Enhancing the disclosure of corporate social responsibility information timely and correctly.
As for the economy, environment and social issues resulting from the Bank’s operation, the Board of Directors shall authorize the upper level of management to deal with the issues and report their processing situation. The processing procedure and related accountable persons should be defined concretely and unequivocally.
112
Article 8 The Bank is advised to, on a regular basis, organize training on implementation
of corporate social responsibility, including promotion of matters prescribed in the paragraph 2 of the preceding Article.
Article 9 For the purpose of managing corporate social responsibility initiatives, the
Bank is advised to establish an exclusively (or concurrently) dedicated unit to be in charge of proposing and enforcing the corporate social responsibility policies, systems or relevant management principle and concrete plan and to report those to the board of directors on a periodic basis. The Bank is advised to establish reasonable remuneration policy to ensure that the remuneration program could match the organization’s target and stakeholders' benefit. Performance review and compensation system of employees are advised to incorporate corporate social responsibility policy, and should establish a clear and effective reward/discipline system.
Article 10 The Bank shall respect the rights and interests of any stakeholders, set up
a stakeholders’ page in the official website, identify and understand the reasonable expectations and demands of such parties through proper communication and allowing their participation, and shall adequately respond to the important corporate social responsibility issues which they are concerned about.
Chapter 3 Fostering a Sustainable Environment Article 11 The Bank shall follow relevant environmental laws and regulations and
international criteria properly protect the environment and shall endeavor to promote a sustainable environment when engaging in business operation and internal management.
Article 12 The Bank shall endeavor to utilize all resources more efficiently and try to
use renewable and low-impact materials to improve sustainability of natural resources.
Article 13 The Bank shall assign a dedicated unit, ask personnel to maintain the
environment management, hold environment education for its managerial officers and other employees on a periodic basis, establish proper environment
113
management goals based on the characteristics of financial industries, and examine whether such goals should be maintained and whether they are still relevant on a regular basis.
Article 14 The Bank shall take into account the effect of operation on ecological
efficiency, promote and promote the concept of sustainable consumption, and to operate in accordance with the following principles to reduce the impact on the natural environment from their business operations: 1. Reduce resource and energy consumption, emission of pollutants,
toxins and waste, and dispose of waste properly. 2. Maximize the sustainability of renewable resources under the condition
that the Bank should not violate customers’ data protection. 3. Provide “e-finance” service to improve efficiency of financial products and
service. 4. Encourage the Bank’s suppliers and clients to implement environmental
protection and carbon-reducing measures. Article 15 To improve water use efficiency, the Bank shall properly and sustainably
use water resources and use their best efforts to lessen any adverse impacts on human health and the environment.
Article 16 The Bank shall monitor the impact of climate change on their operations
and should promote energy conservation and carbon or greenhouse gas reduction according to the result of regular checks of greenhouse gas volume, so the impact of their business operations on the climate change can be reduced.
Chapter 4 Protecting employee’s legal rights and interests Article 17 The Bank shall comply with laws and “International Bill of Human Rights”
to protect the rights to gender equality, work and prohibition of discrimination, etc. In order to fulfill the responsibility of protecting human rights, the Bank shall establish related management policies and procedure, including 1. To propose human rights policy of the enterprise and pronouncement 2. To evaluate the influence of operation activities and inner management
upon human rights, and establish related handling procedure
114
3. To regularly review the results of the human rights policy or pronouncement.4. If any violation of human rights occurs, the Bank shall disclose the handling
procedure involving its stakeholders.The Bank shall comply with internationally recognized labor force's human rights, just as the freedom of association, the right to collective bargaining, caring vulnerable groups, forbidding child labors, eliminating all forms of forced labor, eliminating recruitment and employment discrimination, etc., and shall assure that the human resource policies do not contain differential treatments based on gender, race, social and economic status, age, marital and family status, and shall achieve equality in terms of employment, employment requirement, remuneration, welfare, training, evaluation and promotion opportunities. As for violation of the labors’ rights, the Bank shall provide an effective and proper mechanism for complaints to ensure the equality and transparency in the process. The procedure for complaints shall be clear, convenient and unimpeded. Furthermore the Bank shall respond to the employee's complaints properly.
Article 18 The Bank shall provide information for their employees so that the employees have knowledge of their rights and the labor laws of the countries where the companies have business operations.
Article 19 The Bank shall provide a safe and healthy work environment for their employees, including necessary health and first-aid facilities and shall endeavor to protect employees’ safety and health from dangers and occupational accidents. The Bank shall organize training on safety and health for their employees on a regular basis.
Article 20 The Bank shall create an environment conducive to the development of their employees' careers and establish effective training programs to foster professional skills. To ensure the effectiveness of recruitment, retaining the talents and motivating employees, the Bank shall reflect its profits or achievement appropriately in the employee's remuneration policy.
115
Article 21 The Bank shall establish a platform to facilitate regular two-way communication between the management and the employees for the employees to obtain relevant information and express their opinions on the company's operations, management and decisions. The Bank shall respect the employee representatives' rights to bargain for the working conditions, and shall provide the employees with necessary information and hardware equipment, in order to improve the negotiation and cooperation among employers, employees and employee representatives. The Bank shall, by reasonable means, inform employees of operation changes that might have serious impacts.
Chapter 5 Preserving Public Welfare Responsibility Article 22 To embrace product and service responsibility, and uphold marketing ethics,
the operating procedures should ensure the transparency of information and safety of products and services, the Bank shall establish and disclose its consumer protection policy and enforce the procedures to prevent product or service from harming consumer's rights, health and security.
Article 22-1 The Bank is advised to treat its customers or consumers fairly by implementing the following principles: fairness and good faith, due care and fiduciary duty, truthfulness of advertising, suitability of products or services, duty of disclosure, duty regarding sale of complex, high-risk products, equitable performance-based compensation plans, protection of complainants, professionalism of sales personnel etc., and revise related executed strategy and concrete measures.
Article 23 The Bank shall ensure the quality of their products and services by following the laws and regulations of the government and relevant standards of their industries. The Bank shall follow the laws, regulations and relevant international guidelines when marketing or advertising its financial products or services and shall not deceive, mislead, commit fraud or engage in any other acts which would lose customers’ trust or damage customers’ rights or interests.
Article 24 The Bank is advised to evaluate and manage the risks caused by business interruption to reduce the impacts on consumers and the society. The Bank shall provide a clear and effective procedure for responding to
116
customers’ complaints in order to fairly and timely deal with their complaints, and shall comply with Personal Information Protection Act etc. relevant laws and regulations for respecting consumers’ rights to privacy and securing their personal data.
Article 25 The Bank shall cooperate with their suppliers to foster a stronger sense of corporate social responsibility. The Bank is advised to evaluate whether the suppliers have a record of causing harms to the environment and society and should avoid dealing with those suppliers who violate the Bank’s social responsibility policy. When the Bank signs a contract with the main supplier, its content is advised to include compliance with both parties' corporate social responsibility policies, and if the supplier violates the policies and has major influence on the environment or society, the Bank can terminate or annul the contract at any time.
Article 26 The Bank shall consider the impact of their business operations on the community and use qualified personnel to enhance community acceptance. The Bank may, through equity investment, commercial activities, donations of goods and materials, volunteering services or other pro bono services, etc., invest in organizations that solve social or environmental issues through business operations, or participate in events held by citizen groups, charities, and government agencies for community development and education to accelerate the development of community.
Chapter 6 Enhancing Disclosure of Corporate Social Responsibility Information Article 27 The Bank shall disclose information according to relevant laws and
regulations such as “the Corporate Governance Best Practice Principles for TWSE/GTSM-Listed Companies” and shall properly disclose relevant and reliable information relating to their corporate social responsibility initiatives to improve information transparency. The disclosed information relating to corporate social responsibility includes:
1. The policies, systems or relevant management principles and concreteplans for corporate social responsibility initiatives resolved by theboard of directors
2. The risks and the impact on the corporate operations and financial
117
condition arising from exercising corporate governance, fostering a sustainable environment and preserving social public welfare
3. Goals and measures for realizing the corporate social responsibility initiatives established by the companies, and the results of them.
4. The main stakeholders and their concerns. 5. The information on environmental and social issues disclosed by the
main supplier and their management on those issues 6. Other information relating to corporate social responsibility initiatives.
Article 28 The Bank shall adopt internationally-recognized criteria or guideline to
produce corporate social responsibility reports to disclose the status of the implementation of the policies. Furthermore, the Bank is advised to obtain the third party’s confirmation or guarantee to enhance information’s reliability. The reports are advised to include: 1. The policies, systems or relevant management principles and concrete
plans of implementing corporate social responsibility initiatives 2. Major interested parties and their concerns 3. Results and a review of the implementation of corporate governance,
fostering of a sustainable environment, preservation of public welfare and promotion of economic development
4. Future improvement and goals. Chapter 7 Supplementary Provisions Article 29 The Bank shall at all times monitor the development of domestic and
international corporate social responsibility criteria and the change of business environment so as to examine and improve their own framework and to obtain better results from the implementation of the policies.
Article 30 The Criteria and any amendments hereto, shall be implemented after
approval from the board of directors.
The Criteria was established and approved at the 11th board meeting of the 8th term on Oct. 23, 2014.
The 1st amendment was made and approved at the 12th board meeting of the 8th term on Dec. 22, 2014.
The 2nd amendment was made and approved at the 3rd board meeting of the 9th term on Oct. 20, 2016.
118
Appendix 7
The Criteria Governing Asset Acquisition and Disposal, EnTie Commercial Bank
Chapter 1 General Principles Article 1 (Purpose)
To protect assets and to increase the information transparency of the Bank,
we hereby establish the “Criteria Governing Asset Acquisition and Disposal,
EnTie Commercial Bank” (the “Criteria”). Article 2 (Legal Basis)
The Criteria is set up in accordance with “Regulations Governing the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets by Public Companies” promulgated by the Financial
Supervisory Commission (the “FSC”).
Article 3 (Assets Scope)
The term “assets” as used in the Criteria includes the following:
1. Securities, including investments in stocks, government bonds, corporate bonds, financial debentures, securities representing interest in a fund,
depositary receipts, call (put) warrants, beneficial interest securities, and
asset-backed securities. 2. Real property (including land, houses and buildings, investment property,
and rights to use land) and equipment.
3. Memberships. 4. Intangible assets, including patents, copyrights, trademarks, franchise rights,
and other intangible assets.
5. Claims of financial institutions (including receivables, bills purchased and discounted, loans, and overdue receivables).
6. Derivatives.
7. Assets acquired or disposed of in connection with mergers, spin-offs, acquisitions, or transfer of shares in accordance with the law.
8. The above assets acquired or disposed due to exercising rights to collaterals.
9. Other major assets.
119
Article 4 (Definition of Terms) Terms used in the Criteria are defined as follows: 1. Derivatives: Forward contracts, options contracts, futures contracts, leverage
contracts, and swap contracts, and compound contracts combining the
above products, whose value is derived from assets, interest rates, foreign exchange rates, indexes or other interests. The term “forward contracts”
does not include insurance contracts, performance contracts, after-sales
service contracts, long-term leasing contracts, or long-term purchase (sales) agreements.
2. Assets acquired or disposed through mergers, spin-offs, acquisitions, or
transfer of shares in accordance with law: Refers to assets acquired or disposed through mergers, spin-offs, or acquisitions conducted under the
Business Mergers and Acquisitions Act, Financial Holding Company Act,
Financial Institution Merger Act and other acts, or to transfer of shares from another company through issuance of new shares of its own as the
consideration therefor (hereinafter called “transfer of shares”) under Paragraph
8 of Article 156 of the Company Act. 3. Related party or subsidiary: As defined in the “Regulations Governing the
Preparation of Financial Reports by Public Banks”.
4. Professional appraiser: Refers to a real property appraiser or other person duly authorized by law to engage in the value appraisal of real property or
equipment.
5. Date of occurrence: Refers to the date of contract signing, date of payment, date of consignment trade, date of transfer, dates of boards of directors
resolutions, or other date that can confirm the counterpart and monetary
amount of the transaction, whichever date is earlier; provided, for investment for which approval of the competent authority is required, the earlier of the
above date or the date of receipt of approval by the competent authority
shall apply. 6. Investments in Mainland China: Refers to engaging in Mainland investments
as defined by the “Regulations Governing Approval for Investments and
Technical Cooperation in Mainland Area” as promulgated by the Investment Committee under the Ministry of Economic Affairs Investment Commission.
120
Article 5 (Related Party Prohibition) Professional appraisers and their officers, certified public accounts, attorneys, and securities underwriters that provide the Bank with appraisal reports,
certified public accountant’s opinions, attorney’s opinions, or underwriter’s
opinions shall not be a related party of any party to the transaction.
Chapter 2 Disposition Procedures
Article 6 (Restrictions on Acquisition and Disposal of Assets) For acquisition or disposal of assets mentioned in Article 3, the Criteria shall govern unless otherwise specified in the Bank’s internal rules such as “Criteria
for Long-term Investments”, “Criteria on Funding Operations”, “Criteria Governing
the Operations of Financial Derivatives”, “Criteria for collateral Management and Disposal”, “Criteria of NPL Disposal”, “Rules Governing Acquisition and
Disposal of Loan Assets of Corporate Banking Group”, “Rules Governing
Properties and Expenditures”, the statements of stratified responsibilities, and other rules stipulated by the Bank.
Total amounts of real property or securities acquired by the Bank and limits on
individual securities, unless otherwise specified in the Bank’s internal rules, shall be handled in compliance with the Banking Act and the regulations
required by the Competent Authority.
The calculation of the transaction amounts referred to in this Chapter shall be done in accordance with Item 5 of Subparagraph 1, Paragraph 1, Article 15,
and “within the preceding year” as used herein refers to the year preceding
the date of occurrence of the current transaction. The transaction amounts stated in Articles 8 to 10 for which an appraisal report from a professional
appraiser or a CPA’s opinion has been obtained pursuant to the requirements
stipulated in the Criteria need not be counted toward the transaction amount; the transaction amount stated in Subparagraph 1, Paragraph 1 of Article 11
for which an approval have been obtained from the board of directors and
recognized by the supervisors pursuant to the requirements stipulated in the Criteria need not be counted toward the transaction amount.
121
Article 7 (Handling Disagreements from Board Directors) The Bank’s acquisition or disposal of assets for which the approval of the board of directors is required under the Criteria or other laws or regulations, if
a director expresses dissent and it is contained in the minutes or a written
statement, the Bank shall submit the director’s dissenting opinion to each supervisor.
When a transaction involving the acquisition or disposal of assets is submitted
for discussion by the board of directors pursuant to the preceding paragraph, the board of directors shall take into full consideration each independent director’s
opinions. If an independent director objects to or expresses reservations on
any matter, it shall be recorded in the board meeting minutes.
Article 8 (Procedures for acquisition or disposal of securities) Unless “Criteria for Long-term Investment”, “Criteria for Funding Operation”, “Criteria Governing the Operation of Financial Derivatives”, “Criteria of Collateral
Management and Disposal”, and other relevant internal rules provide otherwise,
the Bank shall acquire or dispose securities based on the following procedures: 1. Procedures for setting transaction terms and authorized amount
(1) Acquiring and disposing of investments as mentioned in the Article
74-1 of the Banking Act, the Bank’s responsible department shall decide based on market conditions, and the transaction amount shall be decided
based on the Bank’s “Criteria for Funding Operation” and its relevant
rules. (2) The Bank’s responsible department shall come up with an assessment
report and get approval from the Board before it acquires and disposes
of the Bank’s investments as defined in Article 74 of Banking Act. 2. Professional opinion
(1) The Bank acquiring or disposing of securities shall, prior to the date of
occurrence of the event, obtain financial statements of the issuing company for the most recent period, certified or reviewed by a certified
public accountant, for reference in appraising the transaction price,
and if the dollar amount of the transaction is 20 percent of the company’s paid-in capital or NT$300 million or more, the company shall additionally
engage a certified public accountant prior to the date of occurrence of
122
the event to provide an opinion regarding the reasonableness of the
transaction price. If the CPA needs to adopt an expert report as evidence, the CPA shall do so in accordance with the provisions of
Statement of Auditing Standards No. 20 published by the Accounting
Research and Development Foundation (ARDF) of the ROC. This requirement does not apply, however, to publicly quoted prices of
securities that have an active market, or where otherwise provided by
regulations of the FSC. (2) Where the Bank acquires or disposes of assets through court auction
procedures, the evidentiary documentation issued by the court may
be substituted for the appraisal report or CPA opinion.
Article 9 (Procedures for Acquisition and Disposal of Real Property or Equipment)
Unless the “Criteria of Collateral Management and Disposal”, “Rules Governing
Properties and Expenditures”, and other relevant internal rules provide otherwise,
the Bank shall acquire or dispose real property or equipment based on the procedures as follows:
1. Decision process for transaction terms and authorized amount
(1) In the event of acquisition or disposal of real property, the Bank shall refer to the publicly announced land value, appraised value, actual
transaction prices of neighboring properties, and propose transaction
terms and price. An analysis report is presented to the Board for approval before execution.
(2) When the Bank acquires or disposes of equipment, all procedures
shall be conducted in accordance with the “Rules Governing Properties and Expenditures” of the Bank.
2. Unit for Execution
In acquiring or disposing real property or equipment, the responsible department will execute after the approval level approves as mentioned
above.
3. Real Property and Equipment Appraisal Reports In acquiring or disposing real property or equipment where the transaction
amount reaches 20 percent of the Bank’s paid-in capital or NT$300 million
123
or more, the Bank, unless transacting with a government agency, engaging
others to build on its own land, engaging others to build on rented land, or acquiring or disposing of equipment for business use, shall obtain an
appraisal report prior to the date of occurrence of the event from a
professional appraiser. The appraisal report shall include items as specified by the regulations of the Competent Authority and shall also comply with
the following provisions:
(1) Where due to special circumstances it is necessary to give a limited price, specified price, or special price as a reference basis for the
transaction price, the transaction shall be submitted for approval in
advance by the board of directors, and the same procedure shall be followed for any future changes to the terms and conditions of the
transaction.
(2) When the transaction amount is NT$1 billion or more, appraisals shall be obtained from two or more professional appraisers.
(3) Where any one of the following circumstances applies with respect to
the professional appraiser’s appraisal results, unless all the appraisal results for the assets to be acquired are higher than the transaction
amount, or all the appraisal results for the assets to be disposed of
are lower than the transaction amount, a certified public accountant shall be engaged to perform the appraisal in accordance with the
provisions of Statement of Auditing Standards No. 20 published by
the Accounting Research and Development Foundation (ARDF) of the ROC and render a specific opinion regarding the reason for the
discrepancy and the appropriateness of the transaction price:
A. The discrepancy between the appraisal result and the transaction amount is 20 percent or more of the transaction amount.
B. The discrepancy between the appraisal results of two or more
professional appraisers is 10 percent or more of the transaction amount.
(4) No more than 3 months may elapse between the date of the appraisal
report issued by a professional appraiser and the contract execution date; provided, where the publicly announced current value for the
same period is used and not more than 6 months have elapsed, an
124
opinion may still be issued by the original professional appraiser.
(5) Where the Bank acquires or disposes of assets through court auction procedures, the evidentiary documentation issued by the court may
be substituted for the appraisal report or CPA opinion.
Article 10 (Procedures for Acquisition and Disposal of Memberships or Intangible Assets)
Unless the Bank’s Rules Governing Properties and Expenditures and other internal rules provide otherwise, the Bank shall acquire or dispose memberships
or intangible assets pursuant to the Criteria.
Where the Bank acquires or disposes of memberships or intangible assets and the transaction amount reaches or exceeds 20% of the Bank’s paid-in
capital or NT$300 million, except in transactions with a government agency,
the Bank shall engage a certified public accountant prior to the date of occurrence of the event to render an opinion on the reasonableness of the
transaction price; the CPA shall comply with the provisions of the Statement
of Auditing Standards No. 20 published by the ARDF.
Article 11 (Procedures for Related Party Transaction) The Bank that acquires or disposes of assets from a related party shall ensure that the necessary resolutions are adopted the reasonableness of
the transaction terms is appraised, and other relevant matters are carried
out, in compliance with the provisions of the preceding three Articles and this article. If the transaction amount reaches 10 percent or more of the
Bank’s total assets, the Bank shall also obtain an appraisal report from a
professional appraiser or a CPA’s opinion in compliance with the provisions of the preceding three Articles. When judging whether a trading counterparty
is a related party, in addition to legal formalities, the substance of the
relationship shall also be considered: 1. Appraisal and Operating procedures
When the Bank engages in any acquisition or disposal of real property
from or to a related party, or engages in any acquisition or disposal of assets other than real property from or to a related party and the transaction
amount reaches 20 percent or more of paid-in capital, 10 percent or
125
more of the Bank's total assets, or NT$300 million or more, except in
trading of government bonds or bonds under repurchase and resale agreements, or subscription or redemption of domestic money market
funds, the Bank may not proceed to enter into a transaction contract or
make a payment until the following matters have been approved by the board of directors and recognized by the supervisors:
(1) The purpose, necessity and anticipated benefit of the acquisition or
disposal of assets. (2) The reason for choosing the related party as a trading counterparty.
(3) With respect to the acquisition of real property from a related party,
information regarding appraisal of the reasonableness of the preliminary transaction terms in accordance with the provisions of Subparagraph
2 Items 1-4 and Item 6.
(4) The date and price at which the related party originally acquired the real property, the original trading counterparty, and that trading
counterparty’s relationship to the Bank and the related party.
(5) Monthly cash flow forecasts for the year commencing from the anticipated month of signing of the contract, and evaluation of the
necessity of the transaction, and reasonableness of the funds utilization.
(6) An appraisal report from a professional appraiser or a CPA’s opinion obtained in compliance with this article.
(7) Restrictive covenants and other important stipulations associated
with the transaction. 2. Evaluation of the reasonableness of the real property transaction costs
(1) The Bank acquires real property from a related party shall evaluate
the reasonableness of the transaction costs by the following means: A. Based upon the related party’s transaction price plus necessary
interest on funding and the costs to be duly borne by the buyer;
Necessary interest on funding is imputed as the weighted average interest rate on borrowing in the year the Bank purchases the
property; provided, it may not be higher than the maximum non-financial
industry lending rate announced by the Ministry of Finance. B. Total loan value appraisal from a financial institution where the
related party has previously created a mortgage on the property
126
as security for a loan; provided, the actual cumulative amount
loaned by the financial institution shall have been 70 percent or more of the financial institution’s appraised loan value of the property
and the period of the loan shall have been 1 year or more. However,
this shall not apply where the financial institution is a related party of one of the trading counterparties.
(2) Where land and structures thereupon are combined as a single
property purchased in one transaction, the transaction costs for the land and the structures may be separately appraised in accordance
with either of the means listed in the preceding item.
(3) A public company that acquires real property from a related party and appraises the cost of the real property in accordance with the provisions
of Item 1 and Item 2 shall also engage a CPA to check the appraisal
and render a specific opinion. (4) When the results of the Bank’s appraisal conducted in accordance
with the provisions of Item 1 and Item 2 are uniformly lower than the
transaction price, the matter shall be handled in compliance with the provisions of Item 5. However, where the following circumstances
exist, objective evidence has been submitted and specific opinions
on reasonableness have been obtained from a professional real property appraiser and a CPA have been obtained, this restriction
shall not apply:
A. Where the related party acquired undeveloped land or leased land for development, it may submit proof of compliance with one
of the following conditions:
(A) Where undeveloped land is appraised in accordance with the means regulated in Items 1-3 and 6, and structures according
to the related party’s construction cost plus reasonable
construction profit are valued in excess of the actual transaction price. The reasonable construction profit shall be deemed
the average gross operating profit margin of the related party’s
construction division over the most recent 3 years or the gross profit margin for the construction industry for the most
127
recent period as announced by the Ministry of Finance,
whichever is lower. (B) Completed transactions by unrelated parties within the preceding
year involving other floors of the same property or neighboring
or closely valued parcels of land, where the land area and transaction terms are similar after calculation of reasonable
price discrepancies in floor or area land prices in accordance
with standard property market practices. (C) Completed leasing transactions by unrelated parties for
other floors of the same property from within the preceding
year, where the transaction terms are similar after calculation of reasonable price discrepancies among floors in accordance
with standard property leasing market practices.
B. Where the Bank acquiring real property from a related party provides evidence that the terms of the transaction are similar to
the terms of transactions completed for the acquisition of
neighboring or closely valued parcels of land of a similar size by unrelated parties within the preceding year.
Completed transactions for neighboring or closely valued parcels
of land in the preceding paragraph in principle refers to parcels on the same or an adjacent block and within a distance of no
more than 500 meters or parcels close in publicly announced current
value; transaction for similarly sized parcels in principle refers to transactions completed by unrelated parties for parcels with a
land area of no less than 50 percent of the property in the planned
transaction; within the preceding year refers to the year preceding the date of occurrence of the acquisition of the real property.
(5) Where the Bank acquires real property from a related party and the
results of appraisals conducted in accordance with the provisions of Items 1-4 and Item 6 are uniformly lower than the transaction price,
the following steps shall be taken:
A. A special reserve shall be set aside in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph 1 of Article 41 of the Act against the
difference between the real property transaction price and the
128
appraised cost, and may not be distributed or used for capital
increase or issuance of bonus shares. B. The Supervisors shall supervise the execution of the said operations
of the Bank in compliance with Article 218 of the Company Act.
C. Actions taken pursuant to the previous points shall be reported to the Shareholders’ Meeting, and the details shall be disclosed in
the annual report and the prospectus.
The Bank that has set aside a special reserve under this item may not utilize the special reserve until it has recognized a loss on
decline in market value of the assets it purchased at a premium, or
they have been disposed of, or adequate compensation has been made, or the status quo ante has been restored, or there is other
evidence confirming that there was nothing unreasonable about the
transaction, and the competent authority has given its consent. (6) Where the Bank acquires real property from a related party and one
of the following circumstances exists, the acquisition shall be conducted
in accordance with the provisions of the preceding Subparagraph, and the provisions of Items 1-3 do not apply:
A. The related party acquired the real property through inheritance
or as a gift. B. More than 5 years have elapsed from the time the related party
signed the contract to obtain the real property to the signing date
for the current transaction. C. The real property is acquired through signing of a joint development
contract with the related party, or through engaging a related party
to build real property, either on the company’s own land or on rented land.
(7) When the Bank obtains real property from a related party, it shall also
comply with the provisions of Item 5 if there is other evidence indicating that the acquisition was not a normal transaction.
Article 12 (Procedures for Acquisition and Disposal of Claims of Financial Institutions)
129
When acquiring or disposing debt rights of financial institutions, unless the
“Criteria of NPL Disposal Procedures”, the “Rules Governing Acquisition and Disposal of Loan Assets of Corporate Banking Group”, and other internal
rules provide otherwise, the Criteria shall govern.
Article 13 (Procedures of Acquisition and Disposal of Derivatives Products)
Unless the “Criteria for Funding Operation”, the “Criteria Governing the
Operation of Financial Derivatives”, and other internal rules provide otherwise, the Bank shall acquire or dispose derivatives products based on the following
procedures:
1. Trading principles and guidelines: Shall include the types of derivatives that may be traded, operating or hedging strategies, segregation of
duties, essentials of performance evaluation, total amount of derivatives
contracts that may be traded, and the maximum loss limit on total trading and for individual contracts.
2. Risk Management Measures
When the Bank is engaging in derivatives trading shall adopt the following risk management measures:
(1) Risk management shall address credit, market, liquidity, cash flow,
operational, and legal risks. (2) Personnel engaged in derivatives trading may not serve concurrently
in other operations such as confirmation and settlement.
(3) Risk measurement, monitoring, and control personnel shall verify that the personnel responsible for trading, deal confirmation and settlements
are from different departments, and shall report to the board of
directors or senior management personnel with no responsibility for trading or position decision-making.
(4) Derivatives trading positions held shall be evaluated at least once
per week; however, positions for hedge trades required by business shall be evaluated at least twice per month. Evaluation reports shall
be submitted to senior management personnel authorized by the
board of directors. (5) Other important risk management measures.
130
3. Internal Audit System
(1) The internal auditor shall review periodically the suitability of internal control on derivatives transactions. If any major violation is found, a
written report shall be submitted to notify the Board of directors and
the Supervisors. (2) The internal auditors shall file a report which includes the auditing
report and the annual internal auditing operation report to the local
authorities no later by end of February in the following year, and shall report to the local authorities for the improvements made by the Bank
for the unusual issues no later by end of May in the following year.
4. When the Bank is engaging in derivatives trading shall establish trading sheets or all types of evaluation reports for record to replace the log
book in which details of the types and amounts of derivatives trading
engaged in, approval dates from board of directors, and the matters required to be carefully evaluated under this article.
5. Where the Bank engaging in derivatives trading, the board of directors
shall faithfully supervise and manage such trading in accordance with the following principles:
(1) Designate senior management personnel to pay continuous attention
to monitoring and controlling derivatives trading risk. (2) Periodically evaluate whether derivatives trading performance is
consistent with established operational strategy and whether the risk
undertaken is within the Bank’s permitted scope of tolerance. 6. Senior management personnel authorized by the board of directors shall
manage derivatives trading in accordance with the following principles:
(1) Periodically evaluate the risk management measures currently employed are appropriate and are faithfully conducted in accordance with the
“Regulations Governing the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets by Public
Companies” formulated by the FSC , the said “Criteria”, the “Criteria Governing Operations of Financial Derivatives”, and other internal
rules provide otherwise.
(2) When irregular circumstances are found in the course of supervising trading and profit-loss circumstances, appropriate measures shall be
adopted and a report immediately made to the board of directors; an
131
independent director shall be present at the board meeting and express
an opinion. 7. The Bank shall report to the next upcoming meeting of the board of
directors after it authorizes the relevant personnel to handle derivates
trading in accordance with its internal procedures for engaging in derivatives trading.
Article 14 (Procedures for Mergers, Demergers, Acquisitions and Transfer of Shares)
The Bank’s Procedures for Mergers, Demergers, Acquisitions and Transfer of Shares are as follows: 1. Appraisal and Operating procedures
(1) When conducting a merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares, prior to convening a board meeting to resolve on the matter, the Bank shall engage a CPA, attorney, or securities underwriter to give an opinion on the reasonableness of the share exchange ratio, acquisition price, or distribution of cash or other property to shareholders, and submit it to the board of directors for deliberation and passage.
(2) The Bank participating in a merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares shall prepare a public report to shareholders detailing important contractual content and matters relevant to the merger, demerger, or acquisition prior to the shareholders meeting and include it along with the expert opinion referred to the preceding Item when sending shareholders notification of the shareholders meeting for reference in deciding whether to approve the merger, demerger, or acquisition. Provided, where a provision of another act exempts a company from convening a shareholders meeting to approve the merger, demerger, or acquisition, this restriction shall not apply. Where the shareholders meeting of any one of the companies participating in a merger, demerger, or acquisition fails to convene or pass a resolution due to lack of a quorum, insufficient votes, or other legal restriction, or the proposal is rejected by the shareholders meeting, the companies participating in the merger, demerger or acquisition shall immediately publicly explain the reason, the follow-up measures, and the preliminary date of the next shareholders meeting.
132
(3) A company participating in a merger, demerger, or acquisition shall
convene a board of directors meeting and shareholders meeting on the day of the transaction to resolve matters relevant to the merger,
demerger, or acquisition, unless another act provides otherwise or the
competent authority is notified in advance of extraordinary circumstances and grant consent. A company participating in a transfer of shares
shall call a board of directors meeting on the day of the transaction,
unless another act provides otherwise or the competent authority is notified in advance of extraordinary circumstances and grant consent.
(4) When participating in a merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of
another company’s shares, a company that is listed on an exchange or has its shares traded on an OTC market shall prepare a full written
record of the following information and retain it for five years for
reference: A. Basic identification data for personnel, including the occupational
titles, names, and national ID numbers (or passport numbers in
the case of foreign nationals) of all persons involved in the planning or implementation of any merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer
of another company’s shares prior to disclosure of the information.
B. Dates of material events, including the signing of any letter of intent or memorandum of understanding, the hiring of a financial or legal
advisor, the execution of a contract, and the convening of a board
of directors meeting. C. Important documents and minutes, including merger, demerger,
acquisition, and share transfer plans, any letter of intent or
memorandum of understanding, material contracts, and minutes of board of directors meetings.
(5) When participating in a merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of another company’s shares, the Bank shall, within 2 days commencing immediately from the date of passage of a resolution by the board of directors, report (in the prescribed format and via the Internet-based information system) the information set out in A and B of the preceding Item to the competent authority for recordation.
(6) Where any of the companies participating in a merger, demerger,
133
acquisition, or transfer of another company’s shares is neither listed on an exchange nor has its shares traded on an OTC market, the Bank shall sign an agreement with such company whereby the latter is required to abide by the provisions of Item 4 and Item 5.
2. Other attentions (1) Prior confidentiality: Every person participating in or with knowledge
of the plan for merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares shall issue a written undertaking of confidentiality and may not disclose the content of the plan prior to public disclosure of the information and may not trade, in their own name or under the name of another person, in any stock or other equity security of any company related to the plan for merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares.
(2) Principles of setting and changing share exchange ratio or merger prices: The Bank participating in a merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares may not arbitrarily alter the share exchange ratio or acquisition price unless under the circumstances below, and shall stipulate the circumstances permitting alteration in the contract for the merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares: A. Cash capital injection, issuance of convertible corporate bonds, or
the issuance of bonus shares, issuance of corporate bonds with warrants, preferred shares with warrants, stock warrants, or other
equity based securities.
B. An action, such as a disposal of major assets that affects the company’s financial operations.
C. An event, such as a major disaster or major change in technology
which affects shareholder equity or share price. D. An adjustment where any of the companies participating in the
merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares from another
company, buys back treasury stock. E. An increase or decrease in the number of entities or companies
participating in the merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares.
F. Other terms/conditions that the contract stipulates may be altered and that have been publicly disclosed.
(3) Information to be noted in the contract: Besides the following Article
317-1 of the Company Act and Article 22 of the Business Mergers
134
And Acquisitions Act, and relevant rules and regulations in Financial
Institutions Merger Law, the following information shall be noted in the contracts:
A. Handling of breach of contract.
B. Principles for handling of equity-type securities previously issued or treasury stock previously bought back by any company that is
extinguished in a merger or that is demerged.
C. The amount of treasury stock participating companies are permitted under law to buy back after the record date of calculation of the
share exchange ratio, and the principles for handling thereof.
D. The manner of handling changes in the number of participating entities or companies.
E. Progress of Project Plan and Projected Finish Date.
F. Scheduled date for convening the legally mandated shareholders meeting if the plan exceeds the deadline without completion, and
relevant procedures.
(4) Procedures when number of the companies participating in a merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares has changes:
After public disclosure of the information, if any company participating
in the merger, demerger, acquisition, or share transfer intends to carry out another merger, demerger, acquisition, or share transfer with
another company, all of the participating companies shall carry out
anew the procedures or legal actions that had originally been completed toward the merger, demerger, acquisition, or share transfer; except
that where the number of participating companies is decreased and a
participating company’s shareholders meeting has adopted a resolution authorizing the board of directors to alter the limits of authority, such
participating company may be exempted from calling another shareholders
meeting to resolve on the matter anew. (5) Any of the companies participating in a merger, demerger, acquisition,
or transfer of shares is not a public company:
Where any of the companies participating in a merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares is not a public company, the Bank
shall sign an agreement with the non-public company, and abide by
135
the provisions of Items 3-6 of the preceding Subparagraph and Items
1 and 4.
Chapter 3 Public Disclosure of Information
Article 15 (Procedures for Public Disclosure of Information) Procedures for Public Disclosure of Information of the Bank are described below:
1. Items and Standards of Public Announcement and Reporting
(1) Acquisition or disposal of real property from or to a related party, or acquisition or disposal of assets other than real property from or to a
related party where the transaction amount reaches 20 percent or
more of paid-in capital, 10 percent or more of the company’s total assets, or NT$300 million or more; provided, this shall not apply to trading
of government bonds, or bonds under repurchase and resale agreements,
or subscription or redemption of domestic money market funds. (2) Merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares.
(3) Losses from derivatives trading reaching the limits on aggregate
losses or losses on individual contracts set out in the procedures adopted by the Bank.
(4) Where an asset transaction other than any of those referred to in the
preceding three items, a disposal of receivables by a financial institution, or an investment in the mainland China area reaches 20 percent or
more of paid-in capital or NT$300 million; provided, this shall not
apply to the following circumstances: A. Trading of government bonds.
B. Securities trading by investment professionals on foreign or
domestic securities exchanges or over-the-counter markets, or subscription of securities by a securities firm, either in the primary
market or in accordance with relevant regulations.
C. Trading of bonds under repurchase/resale agreements, or subscription or redemption of domestic money market funds.
D. Where the type of asset acquired or disposed is equipment for
136
business use, the trading counterparty is not a related party, and
the transaction amount is less than NT$500 million. E. Where land is acquired under an arrangement on engaging
others to build on the Bank’s own land, engaging others to build
on rented land, joint construction and allocation of housing units, joint construction and allocation of ownership percentages, or
joint construction and separate sale, and the amount the Bank
expects to invest in the transaction is less than NT$500 million. (5) The amount of transactions as used in Items 1-4 shall be calculated
as follows, and “within one year” refers to the year preceding the base
date of occurrence of the current transaction. Items duly announced in accordance with the rules need not be entered.
A. The amount of any individual transaction.
B. The cumulative transaction amount of acquisitions or disposals of the same type of underlying asset with the same trading
counterparty within the preceding year.
C. The cumulative transaction amount of real property acquisitions or disposals (cumulative acquisitions and disposals, respectively)
within the same development project within the preceding year.
D. The cumulative transaction amount of acquisitions or disposals (cumulative acquisitions and disposals, respectively) of the same
security within the preceding year.
2. Deadline for Public Announcement and Reporting The assets acquired or disposed that need to be publicly announced based
on the proceeding Subparagraph and transaction amount reaches the
standards that need to be publicly announced, public announcement/reporting shall be made within 2 days commencing immediately from the date of
occurrence.
3. Procedures for Public Announcement and Reporting (1) The Bank shall make public announcement or reporting via the website
as designated by the competent authority.
(2) The Bank shall compile monthly reports on the status of derivatives trading engaged in up to the end of the preceding month by the Bank
and any of its subsidiaries that are not domestic public companies
137
and enter the information in the prescribed format into the information
reporting website designated by the competent authority by the tenth day of each month.
(3) When the Bank makes an error or omission in a required public
announcement, such public announcement shall be corrected, be again publicly announced and reported in their entirety.
(4) The Bank acquiring or disposing of assets shall keep all relevant contracts,
meeting minutes, log books, appraisal reports and CPA, attorney, and securities underwriter opinions at the Bank, where they shall be
retained for 5 years except where another act provides otherwise.
(5) Where any of the following circumstances occurs with respect to a transaction that the Bank has already publicly announced and reported
based on rules, a public report of relevant information shall be made
on the information reporting website designated by the competent authority within 2 days commencing immediately from the date of
occurrence:
A. Change, termination, or rescission of a contract signed in regard to the original transaction.
B. The merger, demerger, acquisition, or transfer of shares is not
completed by the scheduled date set forth in the contract. C. Changes to the originally publicly announced and reported information.
4. Format of Public Announcement
Following the items and content of Public Announcement and Reporting as set in the Criteria, the Bank will follow the format set by the competent
authority.
Article 16 (Procedures of Public Announcement and Reporting by the Subsidiaries)
Information required to be reported in accordance with the provisions of
Article 15 on acquisitions and disposals of assets by any subsidiary of the Bank that is not itself a domestic public company shall be reported by the
Bank.
The paid-in capital or total assets of the Bank shall be the standard for determining whether or not a subsidiary under the preceding Paragraph
requires a public announcement and filing with the authority in the event
138
when the type of transaction specified therein reaches 20 percent of paid-in
capital or 10 percent of the total assets. In the case of the subsidiary of the Bank whose shares have no par value
or a par value other than NT$10, for the calculation of transaction amounts
of 20 percent of paid-in capital stipulated in Articles 8 to 11, 15 and 16 under the Criteria, 10 percent of the Bank’s equity shall be substituted.
Chapter 4 Penalties
Article 17 (Penalties) For staffs who violate the provisions stipulated in the Criteria, they shall be punished in accordance with the personnel rules of the Bank; for those who
are involving in illegal conduct shall be reported to the juridical institutions
for further investigation.
Chapter 5 Additional Provisions Article 18 (Procedures for Control and Management of Subsidiaries)
The Bank shall urge its subsidiaries to adopt and implement the “Criteria
Governing the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets” based on the “Regulations Governing the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets by Public Companies”.
The Bank shall urge its subsidiaries to self-examine whether the procedures
it uses to acquire or dispose assets comply with the “Regulations Governing the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets by Public Companies” and the “Criteria
Governing the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets”.
Internal audit shall review the audit reports or self-examination reports submitted by the subsidiaries.
Article 19 The 10 percent of total assets referred to in the Criteria shall be calculated
based on the total assets stated in the most recent parent company only
financial report or individual financial report prepared under the “Regulations Governing the Preparation of Financial Reports by Public Banks”.
139
Article 20 (Implementation and Revision) Once the Criteria are approved by the board of directors, they shall be submitted to each Supervisor and to the shareholders’ meeting for approval;
same procedures should be applied for amendments to the Criteria. Regarding
the handling of dissent expressed by the board and independent director(s), Article 7 shall apply.
Article 21 Matters not set forth in the Criteria shall be dealt with in accordance with
the applicable laws, rules, regulations or internal rules of the Bank.
The Criteria was established and approved at the 7th board meeting of the 4th
term on Feb. 24, 2003
The 1st amendment was made and approved at the 24th board meeting of the
5th term on April 23, 2007
The 2nd amendment was made and approved at the Annual General Meeting of
Shareholders on May 27, 2010
The 3rd amendment was made and approved at the Annual General Meeting of
Shareholders on June 10, 2011
The 4th amendment was made and approved at the Annual General Meeting of
Shareholders on June 22, 2012
The 5th amendment was made and approved at the Annual General Meeting of
Shareholders on June 6, 2014
The 6th amendment was made and approved at the Annual General Meeting of
Shareholders on June 12, 2015
140