elmwood park boe et al. (docket no: ber-l-8966-11)/// motion for judge doyne's recusal

7/31/2019 Elmwood Park BOE et al. (Docket No: BER-L-8966-11)/// Motion for Judge Doyne's Recusal

1/11

CTMGNAKB^ ÂATPMGC Nm~h0 Mvtco =88; G'@'Y'M' 4M0 =8*>3; Txoh =0=4; mgn G@ Ianh al @xncicmo Iagnxi~

Imgag 9I ltaj lxt~bht cg|ao|hjhg~ cg ~bcy imyh lat ~bh thmyagy y~m~hn cg ~bh Vomcg~clly m~~mibhn

dtchl!iatthyvagnhgih "Th}xhy~ Lat @xneh Nasghy Thixymo# nm~hn >!8!46=4 mgn a~bht Vomcg~clly

iatthyvagnhgihy nm~hn 9!4

=!4=!46=4 [HRBCDC^ >Z'

C/ Ctmgnakb~ âatpmgc/ al lxoo meh/ lxt~bht iht~cls my laooauy0

C mj Vomcg~cll cg ~bh mi~cag imv~caghn Ctmgnakb~ âatpmgc |' Hojuaan Vmtk Damtn al Hnxim~cag/ h~ mo';

Naikh~ Ga0 O*23

mgs al ~bh latheacge y~m~hjhg~y jmnh ds jh mth ucoolxoos lmoyh/ C mj yxd`hi~ ~a vxgcybjhg~' !

VOMCG^CLL/ VTA YH

Nm~hn0 Mvtco =


2/11

CTMGNAKB^ ^AATPMGC Nm~h0 Mvtco 8/ 46=4

VOMCG^CLL/ Vta yh Vmeh = al=6

YXVHTCAT IAXT^ AL GHU @HTYHS

OMU NC\CYCAGDHTEHG IAXG^S

CTMGNAKB^ AATPMGC/

Vomcg~cll/

|y'

HOJUAAN VMTK DAMTN AL

HNXIM^CAG; TCIBMTN N' ^AJKA/

Vtcgicvmo mgn ixtthg~ Yxvhtcg~hgnhg~ al

Yibaaoy; UCOOCMJ JALLC^^/ Damtn

Yhith~mts

Nhlhgnmg~y'

IC\CO MI^CAG GA' O*23Bagat ~a miihv~ ~bcy oh~~ht my m th}xhy~ lat Saxt Bagaty thixymo mgn cg thyvagyh ~a Saxt Bagaty

iatthyvagnhgih "ubcib moya bmn ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ atnht vta|cnhn ds ~bh Nhlhgnmg~y

m~~atghs cg c~y m~~mibjhg~#'

= Cg thyvagyh mgn ad`hi~cag ~a Saxt Bagaty imyh jmgmehjhg~ atnht nm~hn 9!=8!46=4 mgn Saxt Bagaty

iatthyvagnhgih nm~hn 9!=


3/11


VOMCG^CLL/ Vta yh Vmeh 4 al=6

Cg ~bh iatthyvagnhgih nm~hn 9!45!46=4/ Saxt Bagat y~m~hn ~bm~0

=' Ad`hi~cagy ~a latj mgn hg~ts al atnhty mth ~a dh jmnh vtcat ~a hrhix~cag'

Vomcg~cll thc~htm~hy mgn thy~m~hy ~bh y~m~hjhg~ al bht iatthyvagnhgih nm~hn 9!44!46=4 "ubcib umy cg ad`hi~cag mgn thyvagyh ~a Saxt Bagaty imyh jmgmehjhg~ atnht nm~hn 9!=8!46=4

mgn Saxt Bagaty iatthyvagnhgih nm~hn 9!=

imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ Vomcg~cll iohmtos y~m~hn bht ad`hi~cagy ubhg Saxt

Bagat mgn Nhlhgnmg~y m~~atghs uhth yh~~cge xv ~bh ncyia|hts mgn hgn al ncyia|hts nm~hy "vtaal

cy ~bh ~mvhn thiatn al ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4 # '

4' My vht ~bcy iaxt~%y oh~~ht al Jmtib =

~a ~bh hgn al ncyia|hts nm~h vht Nhlhgnmg~y m~~atghsy th}xhy~ mgn Saxt Bagat ibmgehn ~bh hgn

al ncyia|hts nm~h latj 9!43!46=9 ~a 2!9=!46=4#/ Saxt Bagat hgnhn ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~

iaglhthgih "vtaalcy ~bh ~mvhn thiatn al ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4#'

Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ ubhg Vomcg~cll ga~cihn ~bm~ Saxt Bagat

uhth cegatcge bht ad`hi~cag/ Vomcg~cll y~m~hn / C mj ga~ dhcge bhmtn cg ~bcy iaxt~ mgn C bm|h

ad`hi~cag ~a ~bm~ / Saxt Bagat thyvagnhn/ AK/ |hts eaan/ ~bmgk sax mgn Saxt Bagat mgn

Nhlhgnmg~y m~~atghs iag~cgxhn ~a yh~ xv ~bh nm~hy lat ncyia|hts nhyvc~h Vomcg~clly ad`hi~cagy

"yvhicmoos cg themtn ~a hgn al ncyia|hts nm~h ubcib Saxt Bagat ibmgehn c~ vhtNhlhgnmg~y

9 Cg atnht ~a nhvtc|h jh ltaj js tceb~y ~a avvayh ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ atnhty al 9!=8!46=4'


4/11



m~~atghsy th}xhy~ml~ht sax bmn mothmns nh~htjcghn ~bh hgn al ncyia|hts nm~h ~a dh 9!43!46=9/

dmyhn ag ~bh ~tmik#'Vtaalcy ~bh ~mvhn thiatn al ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4'

8' Jath ehghtmoos/ mgn ml~ht bm|cge th|chuhn Jy' ^aatpmgc%y $avvayc~cag ~a imyh jmgmehjhg~iaglhthgih atnhty [yciZ al 9=!8!=4/$ mgn bht thvos ~a ~bh vhgncge ja~cag lat ohm|h ~a lcoh myxjjmts xnejhg~ ja~cag mgn ~a mjhgn vomcg~clly iajvomcg~/ iht~mcg adyht|m~cagy mth

th}xcthn'

Vomcg~cllythvos nm~hn 9!4

vomih# cg Saxt Bagaty iaxt~taaj nxtcge ~bayh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgihy mgn mth vtaaly

~bm~ bau Saxt Bagat bm|h dhhg bxjcocm~cge mgn cg~cjcnm~cge>

Vomcg~cll' My agh hrmjvoh ubhg

>^a cg~hg~cagmoos vta|cnh mg mgrch~s vta|akcge ictixjy~mgihy ~a jmkh Vomcg~cll xgmdoh ~a |htdmocph bhtyhol

mgn bm|h m iabhthg~ Yvhhib ~a nhlhgn bht tceb~y/ ubhg Saxt Bagat bm|h mothmns ga~cihn Vomcg~cllyncymdcoc~s cg ~bh lcty~ imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih mgn Vomcg~cll bmn moya dtaxeb~ c~ ~a Saxt Bagaty

m~~hg~cag ds bht oh~~ht nm~hn 4!8!46=4 ~bm~0

C iaxon ga~ nhlhgn js tceb~y cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al Lhdtxmts 4/ 46=4/

ycgih my C ~aon Saxt Bagat cg ~bm~ iaglhthgih/ dhimxyh al js bhmo~b cyyxh "yh|hth

mgrch~s#/ C imgga~ bm|h m iabhthg~ Yvhhib cg mgrch~s vta|akcge ictixjy~mgihy mgn my

Iag~cgxhn ag ~bh ghr~ vmeh


5/11


VOMCG^CLL/ Vta yh Vmeh > al=6

Vomcg~cll bmn mothmns jmnh c~ iohmt ~bm~ ybh bmn umc|hn bht tceb~ lat mg atmo mtexjhg~ ag bht

ja~cag8"my ~a ubs m @xts ~tcmo cy mvvtavtcm~h #/ Saxt Bagat yvhg~ yh|htmo jcgx~hy ~a mtexh

uc~b Vomcg~cll uc~b mg cg~cjcnm~cge ~agh ubh~bht Vomcg~cll umg~hn ~a bm|h mg atmo mtexjhg~ cg

themtn ~a ~bm~ ja~cag at ga~ "ubcoh Saxt Bagat uhth vth~hgncge ~bm~ sax iaxon ga~ xgnhty~mgnVomcg~cll# ~a jmkh m iaglxycag lat vta yh Vomcg~cll mgn cg~hg~cagmoos vta|cnh mg mgrch~s vta|akcge

ictixjy~mgihylat bht'

5' Lxt~bht/ ~bhth jms dh m lxgnmjhg~mo jcyxgnhty~mgncge ds Jy' ^aatpmgc iagihtgcge ~bh hg~tsal atnhty' Mo~baxeb c~ cy vthlhtmdoh lat ~bh iaxt~ ~a yaocic~ oc~cemg~y% mgn!at iaxgyhoy% vayc~cagy/

~bh iaxt~ cy ga~ dhbaonhg ~a miihv~ ~bh ymjh'

Saxt Bagat ~bhth cy GA jcyxgnhty~mgncge ds Vomcg~cll iagihtgcge ~bh hg~ts al atnhty'

Vomcg~cll umy mgn cy mumth ~bm~ Saxt Bagat mth yxvvayhn ~a jmkh ~bh nhicycagy dmyhn ag ~bh

Txohy al ~bh Iaxt~ mgn cg ~bh mdyhgih al ~bh Txohy/ dmyhn ag Saxt Bagaty ncyith~cagy "mgn ga~

dmyhn ag ubm~ vmt~chynhycthy mth# mgn c~ cy vthlhtmdoh lat ~bh iaxt~ ~a yaocic~ oc~cemg~y% mgn!at

iaxgyhoy% vayc~cagy/ ~bh iaxt~ cy ga~ dhbaonhg ~a miihv~ ~bh ymjh/ dx~ Vomcg~cll umy ga~ mgn cy ga~

mdoh ~a xgnhty~mgn ubs Saxt Bagat bm|h dhhg daxgn ~a ycnh uc~b ~bh Nhlhgnmg~y ag mgs cyyxhy

ubcib bmy imxyhn Saxt Bagat ~a a|httxoh saxt aug atnhty ~bthh ~cjhy!=9!46=4 "dmyhn ag 42*nms th}xcthn ~cjh lat lcocge mg mvvocim~cag [ja~cagZ lat yxjjmts



7/11


VOMCG^CLL/ Vta yh Vmeh < al=6

Bagaty vhtjcyycag#

Saxt Bagat my Vomcg~cll y~m~hn cg bht thvos "nm~hn 9!4

Vomcg~cll img vta|cnh Saxt Bagat uc~b jath ~bmg ~hg Imyh omuy cg themtn ~a AVJM mgn AVTM

cg Ghu @htyhs Yxvhtcat Iaxt~ ~bm~ ~bh Yxvhtcat Iaxt~ bmn vhtjc~~hn ~bh vmt~chy ~a ja|h mgn

mvvos lat yxjjmts @xnejhg~ ubcoh Vomcg~cll bmn dhhg vtabcdc~hn ds Saxt Bagat ~a lcoh mg

mvvocim~cag ~a mvvos lat yxjjmts @xnejhg~' Dx~ Vomcg~cll dhoch|hy ~bhth umy ga ghhn ~a vta|cnh

~bh iaxt~ uc~b ~bayh imyh omuy ycgih Vomcg~cll bmy ga~ h|hg lcohn mg mvvocim~cag lat yxjjmts

`xnejhg~ uc~b ~bh iaxt~ mgn ybh bmy `xy~ mykhn ~bh iaxt~ ~a oh~ bht ~a lcoh mg mvvocim~cag ~a mvvos

lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ mgn ycgih Vomcg~clly mn|htymts mgn ~bh Iaxt~ mth ya uhoo mumth al ~bayh

imyh omuy/ my agh hrmjvoh Kh|cg J' ADtchg \' Dataxeb Al Uaaniocll Omkh/ Naikh~ Ga'

DHT*O*84=8*== ubcib bmy dhhg mn`xncim~hn ds Saxt Bagat ag 2!>!46=='

3' My cgncim~hn/ ~bhyh mi~cagy mth ehghtmoos nhgajcgm~hn my yxjjmts mi~cagy mgn my yxib/ ~bh ghhnlat yxjjmts xnejhg~ iag~cgxhy ~a hoxnh ~bh iaxt~'

Saxt Bagat Vomcg~cll lcohn bht iajvomcg~ ag =6!42!46==/ memcgy~ Nhlhgnmg~y lat ~bhct

ucoolxo mgn cg~hg~cagmo |caom~cagy al AVJM "lcohncg ochx al Vthtaem~c|h utc~;Vomcg~clly ja~cag

`xnejhg~ ubhg Vomcg~cll bmn ghc~bht lcohn gat umy vhtjc~~hn ~a lcoh mg mvvocim~cag [ja~cagZ lat yxjjmts

`xnejhg~#/ Vomcg~cll imoohn mgn cglatjhn ~bh Iaxt~ Iohtky Allcih ~bm~ Vomcg~cll bmn ga~ lcohn mgs

mvvocim~cag [ja~cagZ lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ mgn bht ja~cag nm~hn 9!=9!46=4 bmn dhhg lat0

m# Mjhgncge bht iajvomcg~/ mgn

d# Mykcge Saxt Bagaty vhtjcyycag ~a lcoh mg mvvocim~cag lat yxjjmts xnejhg~ dmyhn Saxt Bagaty

atnht ubcib y~m~hy uc~bax~ Saxt Bagaty vtcat vhtjcyycag Vomcg~cll cy ga~ mooauhn ~a lcoh mgs ja~cagy'

m~ ~bm~ ~cjh/ Iohtk al ~bh Iaxt~ ncthi~hn Vomcg~cll ~a iag~mi~ Saxt Bagaty Omu Iohtk "Jt' Gcibaomy

Ncjmkay/ Hy}'# ubhg Vomcg~cll ncn ya/ Saxt Bagaty Omu Iohtk "Jt' Gcibaomy Ncjmkay/ Hy}'# ~aon

Vomcg~cll ~bm~ c~ bmn dhhg mg httat mgn umy eacge ~a dh lcrhn' Dx~ y~coo ~bhth cy m yibhnxohn ja~cag bhmtcge

lat >!=9!46=4 ag ~bh MIJY Vxdoci Miihyy/ Imyh Vtaihhncge Ocy~ "nhyvc~h Vomcg~clly yh|htmo vbagh imoo#

mgn Saxt Bagaty iatthyvagnhgih nm~hn 9!45!46=4/ moya y~m~hy ~bm~ Cg atnht ~a mllatn ~bh vomcg~cll ~bcy

avvat~xgc~s ~bh iaxt~/yxm yvag~h/ cy imttscge ~bh vomcg~clly mvvocim~cag lat yxjjmts xnejhg~ lat

agh uhhk UBHG Vomcg~cll bmy gh|ht lcohn mgs mvvocim~cag lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ mgn dmyhn ag Saxt

Bagaty Omu iohtky y~m~hjhg~y Saxt Bagat bm|h dhhg mumth al ~bm~'


8/11



~a ibmgeh ~bh ~tmik [ubcib bmn dhhg hg~hthn httaghaxyosZ umy lcohn ag 4!=>!46=4 mgn bht

ja~cag ~a mjhgn bht iajvomcg~ umy lcohn ag 9!=9!46=4# mgn Vomcg~cll yhhky jagh~mts nmjmehy'

Saxt Bagat/ ~bh iaxt~ jms ec|h yxjjmts `xnejhg~ memcgy~ m Vomcg~cll at Nhlhgnmg~ ag

~bh ubaoh al m iomcj at ag m vmt~cixomt cyyxh cl c~ iagycnhty ~bm~ Vomcg~cll bmy ga thmo vtayvhi~ al

yxiihhncge ag ~bh iomcj at cyyxh at Nhlhgnmg~ bmy ga thmo vtayvhi~ al yxiihyylxoos nhlhgncge ~bh

iomcj at cyyxh "ubcib cy ~bh imyh bhth#' Lcocge m yxjjmts `xnejhg~ cy ga~ hoxncge ~bh iaxt~/

a~bhtucyh ~bh G@ Yxvhtcat Iaxt~y "cgioxncge Dhtehg Iaxg~s Yxvhtcat Iaxt~/ Bagatmdoh

@xneh Vh~ht H' Nasgh# ybaxon ga~ bm|h vhtjc~~hn vmt~chy ~a lcoh yxjjmts `xnejhg~ cg imyhy

cg|ao|hn |caom~cagy al AVJM mgn AVTM "Kh|cg J' ADtchg \' Dataxeb Al Uaaniocll Omkh/

Naikh~ Ga' DHT*O*84=8*==#'

=6'Lxt~bht/ vomcg~cll%y vayc~cag ~bhth cy ga ghhn lat ncyia|hts my bht iomcj cy uhoo laxgnhn dmyhn xvagxgncyvx~hn lmi~y/ cy ncllcixo~ ~a thiagicoh uc~b bht vayc~cag ybh th}xcthy mg hr~hgyc|h vhtcan al ~cjhlat ncyia|hts'

Vht Nhlhgnmg~y th}xhy~/ Saxt Bagat vtabcdc~hn Vomcg~cll ltaj lcocge mgs ja~cag uc~bax~

Saxt Bagaty vtcat vhtjcyycag "ltaj ~bh dhecggcge ~bm~ ~bcy imyh umy lcohn uc~b ~bcy Iaxt~# cg

iag~tmy~ ~a ~bh Txohy al ~bh G@ Yxvhtcat Iaxt~; vht Nhlhgnmg~y th}xhy~/ Saxt Bagat vtabcdc~hn

Vomcg~cll ltaj lcocge m ja~cag ~a mvvos lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ cg iag~tmy~ ~a ~bh Txohy al ~bh G@

Yxvhtcat Iaxt~; mgn moyavht Nhlhgnmg~y m~~atghsy th}xhy~ Saxt Bagat a|httxohn saxt augatnht mgn ibmgehn ~bh hgn al ncyia|hts nm~h ltaj 9!43!46=9 ~a 2!9=!46=4 cg ~bh imyh

jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4'

H|hg ~baxeb Vomcg~cll dhoch|hn mgn dhoch|hy ~bm~ ~bhth cy ga ghhn lat ncyia|hts my bht

iomcjy mth uhoo laxgnhn dmyhn ag xgncyvx~hn lmi~y/ ncthi~ vbsycimo h|cnhgihy/ mgn ~bh omu/ mgn

Vomcg~cll umy mgn cy hg~c~ohn ~a lcoh mg mvvocim~cag "ja~cag# lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ dx~ ycgih Saxt

Bagat ncn ga~ mooau Vomcg~cll ~a lcoh mg mvvocim~cag "ja~cag# lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ mgn iahtihn

Vomcg~cll cg~a ncyia|hts/ ~bhthlath cl ~bcy imyh eahy ~a ~tcmo iagycnhtcge ~bm~ ~ua lctjy mth

thvthyhg~cge ~bh Nhlhgnmg~y/ c~ ybaxon ga~ dh bmtn ~a thiagicoh cl vomcg~cll "vta yh# mykhn ~bh iaxt~

"iagycnhtcge bht bhmo~b iagnc~cagy# ~a iagycnht ~bh hgn al ncyia|hts nm~h dmyhn ag ~bh ~tmik ~a dh

9!43!46=9/ ~a oh~ Vomcg~cll vthvmth bhtyhol lat ~tcmo'


9/11



M ioayhn cgyvhi~cag al naixjhg~y ubcib bm|h ga~ dhhg lcohn uc~b ~bh Iaxt~ Iohtky

Allcih "dx~ m iavs al ~bhj bmn dhhg yhg~ ~a Vomcg~cllds Saxt Bagatyy~mll at ~bhNhlhgnmg~y

m~~atghsy; Gagh al ~bhyh naixjhg~y [cgioxncge dx~ ga~ ocjc~hn ~a ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ atnhty

mgnNhlhgnmg~y avvayc~cagy ~a Vomcg~clly ja~cagyZ bm|h dhhg ocy~hn cg MIJY Vxdoci Miihyy/imyh naixjhg~ ocy~mgn ~bhs mth all ~bh thiatn#

2/ ~bh naixjhg~y ubcib bm|h dhhg lcohn uc~b ~bh

Iaxt~ Iohtky Allcih/ Vomcg~clly iatthyvagnhgih nm~hn =!4=!46=4/ 4!8!46=4/ 9!44!46=4/ mgn

9!4

imxyh mgs vhtyag uc~b m

2 Cg~hthy~cgeos ubhg Nhlhgnmg~y bm|h avvayhn Vomcg~clly ja~cagy/ MIJY Vxdoci Miihyy/ Ja~cag Cg}xcts/

ybauy ~bm~ Vomcg~clly ja~cagy bm|h ga~ dhhg avvayhn ds ~bh Nhlhgnmg~y'3

c' Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 4!4!46=4/ Saxt Bagat miixyhn Vomcg~cll al oscge ubhg SaxtBagat ncn ga~ bm|h mgs h|cnhgih ~a yxvvat~ saxt miixym~cag'

cc' Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 4!4!46=4/ Saxt Bagat jmnh iajjhg~ mdax~ Vomcg~cllyohmtgcge mdcoc~s ubhg Vomcg~cll umy ~tscge ~a nhlhgn bht tceb~y cg themtn ~a bht hg~c~ohjhg~ ~a lcoh m

ja~cag"mvvocim~cag# lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ cg miiatnmgih uc~b ~bh Txohy al Iaxt~'

ccc' Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ Saxt Bagat jmnh iajjhg~ mdax~ Vomcg~cllymdcoc~s ~a |htdmocph bhtyhol ~a ~hmib ibconthg "ubcib umy ctthoh|mg~ ~a ~bh yxd`hi~ jm~~ht al ~bh cgy~mg~

iajvomcg~# ubhg Saxt Bagat uhth vth~hgncge ~bm~ Saxt Bagat iaxon ga~ xgnhty~mgn Vomcg~cll"cl

Saxt Bagat uhth ga~ thmoos mdoh ~a xgnhty~mgn Vomcg~cll/ ubs Saxt Bagat ncn ga~ myk Vomcg~cll ~a

mvvhmt dhlath ~bh Iaxt~ uc~b mg cg~htvth~ht lat ~bh yhiagn imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih cgy~hmn albxjcocm~cge bht cg ltag~ al a~bhty#' Vomcg~cll ghhny ~a mnn ~bm~ bht y~xnhg~y Y~m~h ^hy~cge Yiathy mgn

bht y~xnhg~y vacg~ al |chu "Hrbcdc~0 `xy~ m lhu hrmjvohy al ~bh ibconthgy avcgcagy mdax~ Vomcg~clly

~hmibcge mdcoc~s mgn bht my m ~hmibht# vta|h bau bceb*}xmoclchn Vomcg~cll bmy dhhg/ cg vhtlatjcge bht

`ad mgn ~hmibcge ibconthg'

c|' Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ ubhg Vomcg~cll mykhn Saxt Bagat ~bm~ dmyhn agubm~ mx~batc~s at Txoh al Iaxt~ Saxt Bagat bmn vtabcdc~hn bht ltaj lcoocge mgs ja~cag uc~bax~ Saxt

Bagaty vtcat vhtjcyycag vht Nhlhgnmg~y th}xhy~/ Saxt Bagat mykhn Vomcg~cll uc~b mg cg~cjcnm~cge

~agh cl ybh umy }xhy~cagcge Saxt Bagaty mx~batc~s ~a hg~ht mg atnht"ubhg Vomcg~cll umy ya iohmt

ubhg ybh mykhn ~bm~ }xhy~cag/ Vtaal cy ~bh ~mvhn thiatn al ~bm~ imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih#/ cg atnht

~a ga~ thyvagn bht }xhy~cag mgn vta|cnh mg mgrch~s vta|akcge yc~xm~cag lat bht'

|' Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ ubhg Vomcg~cll mykhn Saxt Bagat bau Saxt Bagata|httxohn saxt aug atnht "vht Nhlhgnmg~ym~~atghsy th}xhy~# ubcib bmn dhhg cyyxhn cg ~bh lcty~ vmt~

al imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ Saxt Bagat thyvagnhn/ Ncn sax iagioxnh saxtyhol1

mgn ncythemtnhn Vomcg~clly iagihtg'



10/11



iajjag yhgyh ~a dhoch|h ~bm~ Saxt Bagat bmy dhhg daxgn ~a ycnh uc~b ~bh Nhlhgnmg~y ag mgs

cyyxhy ycgih Saxt Bagat bm|h a|httxohn saxt aug atnhty cg ~bh dhy~ cg~hthy~ al Nhlhgnmg~y vht

~bhct th}xhy~y/ Saxt Bagat bm|h a|httxohn ~bh Txohy al Yxvhtcat Iaxt~ ~a dcgn Vomcg~cll/ mgn

Saxt Bagat bm|h daxgn vomcg~cll ds saxt atnhty ubcib bm|h dhhg cg iag~tmy~ ~a ~bh Txohy al ~bhIaxt~ ~a vtabcdc~ Vomcg~cll ltaj vthyhg~cge bht imyh dhlath ~bcy iaxt~ dmyhn ag ~bh Txohy al ~bh

Iaxt~ cg mg atnhtos jmgght mgn m lmct iagnc~cag'

C~ mvvhmty ~bm~ Saxt Bagat bm|h m naxdoh y~mgnmtn cg ~htjy alSaxt Bagaty @xncicmo

iagnxi~ ycgih0

=' Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ Saxt Bagat mykhn Nhlhgnmg~ym~~atghs cl ybh umg~hn ~bh Iaxt~ ~a imtts Vomcg~clly ja~cag my ~a ubs @xts ~tcmo cy

mvvtavtcm~h ~a vta|cnh nhlhgnmg~y mg hr~tm avvat~xgc~s ~a avvayh Vomcg~clly ja~cag

ubhg nhlhgnmg~y bmn mothmns jcyyhn ~bh nhmnocgh ~a avvayh ~bm~ ja~cag/ dx~ Saxt Bagat

nhgchn Vomcg~clly th}xhy~ ~a imtts ~bh ymjh ja~cag ~a dh th|chuhn ml~ht bht ja~cag ~a

mjhgn bht iajvomcg~ ubcib umy th~xtgmdoh ag 9!96!46=4 mgn Saxt Bagat y~m~hn C na

ga~ imtts ja~cag mgn Saxt Bagat yxeehy~hn Vomcg~cll ~a uc~bntmu ~bh ja~cag mgn th*

|c' Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ ubhg Vomcg~cll mykhn Saxt Bagat ubs Vomcg~cll bmn~a methh uc~b m ncyia|hts Latj "yibhnxoh# ubcib dhoagehn ~a ibmgihts nc|cycag ubhg Vomcg~cll bmn

lcohn bht iajvomcg~ cg ~bh omu nc|cycag/ Saxt Bagat thyvagnhn Ncn sax iagioxnh saxtyhol1 mgn

ncythemtnhn Vomcg~clly iagihtg'

|cc' Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ ubhg Vomcg~cll ga~cihn ~bm~ Saxt Bagat uhthcegatcge bht ad`hi~cagy/ Vomcg~clly~m~hn/ C mj ga~ dhcge bhmtn cg ~bcy Iaxt~ mgn C bm|h ad`hi~cag ~a

~bm~/ Saxt Bagat thyvagnhn/ AK/ |hts eaan/ ~bmgk sax mgn ncythemtnhn Vomcg~clly iagihtg mgn

Saxt Bagat mgn Nhlhgnmg~y m~~atghs iag~cgxhn ~a yh~ xv ~bh nm~hy lat ncyia|hts nhyvc~h Vomcg~clly

ad`hi~cagy'

|ccc' NAXDOH Y^MGNMTN0 Cg ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4/ Saxt Bagat mykhnNhlhgnmg~y m~~atghs clybh umg~hn ~bh Iaxt~ ~a imtts Vomcg~clly ja~cag my ~a ubs @xts ~tcmo cy

mvvtavtcm~h ~a vta|cnh Nhlhgnmg~y mg hr~tm avvat~xgc~s ~a avvayh ~bm~ ja~cag ubhg Nhlhgnmg~y

bmn mothmns jcyyhn ~bh nhmnocgh ~a avvayh ~bm~ ja~cag/ dx~ Saxt Bagat nhgchn Vomcg~clly

th}xhy~ ~a

imtts ~bh ymjh ja~cag ~a dh th|chuhn ml~ht bht ja~cag ~a mjhgn bht iajvomcg~ ubcib umy th~xtgmdoh

ag 9!96!46=4 mgn Saxt Bagat y~m~hn C na ga~ imtts ja~cag mgn Saxt Bagat yxeehy~hn Vomcg~cll

~a uc~bntmu ~bh ja~cag mgn th*lcoh c~ memcg cl Vomcg~cll umg~hn ~bm~ ja~cag ~a dh th|chuhn ml~ht bht

ja~cag ~a mjhgn bht iajvomcg~' Mgn

cr' Jxib jath


11/11


VOMCG^CLL/ Vta yh Vmeh =6 al=6

lcoh c~ memcg cl Vomcg~cll umg~hn ~bm~ ja~cag ~a dh th|chuhn ml~ht bht ja~cag ~a mjhgn bht

iajvomcg~ "vtaalcy ~bh ~mvhn thiatn al ~bh imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgih al 9!=8!46=4#'

Mgn/

4' Ubhg Saxt Bagat mn`xncim~hn AVJM mgn AVTM jm~~ht ds yxjjmts `xnejhg~ cg2!>!46== cg Dhtehg Iaxg~s Yxvhtcat Iaxt~ KH\CG J' ADTCHG |' DATAXEB AL

UAANIOCLL OMKH/ NAIKH^ Ga' DHT*O*84=8*== Saxt Bagat bm|h vtabcdc~hn

Vomcg~cll ltaj lcocge mg mvvocim~cag lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ dhimxyh Saxt Bagat dhoch|hy

mgn y~m~hn ~bm~ My cgncim~hn/ ~bhyh mi~cagy mth ehghtmoos nhgajcgm~hn my yxjjmts

mi~cagy mgn my yxib/ ~bh ghhn lat yxjjmts `xnejhg~ iag~cgxhy ~a hoxnh ~bh iaxt~ '

Saxt Bagaty mdxyc|h m~~c~xnh ~aumtny Vomcg~cll cg ~ua imyh jmgmehjhg~ iaglhthgihy al

4!4!46=4 mgn 9!=8!46=4 umy iohmtos nhyceghn lat ~bh cjvtavht vxtvayh al nhjhmgcge Vomcg~cll

mgn lat ~bh yaoh vxtvayh al bxjcocm~cag/ hjdmttmyyjhg~/ bmtmyyjhg~/ mgn cg~cjcnm~cag/ ubcib cy

thvthbhgycdoh lat m @xneh ~a mi~ cg ~bcy jmgght mgn thyxo~y cg jmgclhy~ cg`xy~cih'

Moo ~bh mlathjhg~caghn mgn Saxt Bagaty jmgclhy~ dcmy vthyhg~hn ds gau vta|hy ~bm~

Saxt Bagat mth ga~ mdoh ~a bhmt ~bcy imyh cg m lmct mgn cjvmt~cmo jmgght/ ~bhthlath Vta yh Vomcg~cll

"Ctmgnakb~ ^aatpmgc# cy thyvhi~lxoos th}xhy~cge Saxt Bagat ~a thixyh saxtyhol ltaj vthycncge

a|ht ~bh cgy~mg~ jm~~ht mgn vhtjc~ Vomcg~cll ~a bm|h m ~txos xgdcmyhn ~tcdxgmo ds oh~~cge ~bh Iaxt~~a myyceg m `xneh tmgnajos ~a ~bcy iajvomcg~ uba cy ga~ dcmy/ nahy ga~ bm|h vtadohj uc~b

oc~cemg~y uba bm|h miihg~/ mgn nahy ga~ bm|h ncllcixo~s ~a xgnhty~mgn ~bhj/ cl Saxt Bagat na ga~

bm|h hc~bht mgs cg~hthy~ ~aumtny Nhlhgnmg~y at mgs mn|htyh cg~hthy~ ~aumtny Vomcg~cll'=6

^bmgk sax lat saxt iagycnhtm~cag'

Thyvhi~lxoos/

Ctmgnakb~ ^aatpmgc

II0 Baumtn J' Gcthgdhte/ Hy}' |cm hjmco Gcthgdhte|mtmgaFmao'iaj

=6 Cl ~bcy oh~~ht cy ga~ yxllcichg~ ~a th}xhy~ Saxt Bagaty thixymo/ Vomcg~cll ucoo ja|h mgn lcoh m ja~cag uc~b

dtchl mgn iht~clcim~cag cg themtn ~a ~bcy jm~~ht'

elmwood park boe et al. (docket no: ber-l-8966-11)/// motion for judge doyne's recusal

Documents