electrified transportation as a power grid resource itec ieee electrified... · electrified...

96
Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute, University of Hawaii at Manoa E-mail: [email protected] Richard Raustad Florida Solar Energy Center, University of Central Florida Andrew Meintz National Renewable Energy Laboratory Haukur (Hawk) Asgeirsson DTE Energy (Retired) Panel Presentations at: IEEE Transportation Electrification Conference and Expo, iTEC June 2016 The contents of this report reflect the views of the authors, who are responsible for the facts and the accuracy of the information presented herein. This document is disseminated under the sponsorship of the U.S. Department of Transportation’s University Transportation Centers Program in the interest of information exchange. The U.S. Government assumes no liability for the contents or use thereof.

Upload: others

Post on 16-Mar-2020

11 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource

Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute, University of Hawaii at Manoa

E-mail: [email protected]

Richard Raustad Florida Solar Energy Center, University of Central Florida

Andrew Meintz

National Renewable Energy Laboratory

Haukur (Hawk) Asgeirsson DTE Energy (Retired)

Panel Presentations at:

IEEE Transportation Electrification Conference and Expo, iTEC

June 2016

The contents of this report reflect the views of the authors, who are responsible for the facts and the accuracy of the information presented herein. This document is disseminated under the sponsorship of the U.S. Department of Transportation’s University Transportation Centers Program in the interest of information exchange. The U.S. Government assumes no liability for the contents or use thereof.

Page 2: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

iTEC IEEE Dearborn Michigan, June 29, 2016

Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute University of Hawaii at Manoa

Interaction of EVs In a High Renewables Island Grid

hawaiiindependent.net

Page 3: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Hawaii Natural Energy Institute

• At the University of Hawaii Manoa

• Established by the Legislature in 2007

• HNEI leads many significant public-private partnerships

focused on the development, testing & evaluation of

emerging energy technologies to reduce Hawaii’s

dependence on fossil fuels

Programs:

o Alternate fuels

o Renewable generation

o Fuel cells & batteries

o Energy efficiency &

Transportation

o Grid Integration

Page 4: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

1) Renewable

Portfolio

standards

•30% by 2020

•40% by 2030

•70% by 2040

•100% by 2045

3

Objectives

2) Straighten the Duck Curve

Page 5: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

HNEI is partnering with the Florida Solar Energy

Center on a US DOT program to transform the

country’s transportation network into a fully

integrated ‘smart’ EV deployment coupled with a

‘smart’ electric grid.

HNEI’s focus is the technical and economic

benefits and challenges of EVs on an electric grid

characterized by high penetration of intermittent

renewable energy.

Electric Vehicle Transportation Center

(EVTC)

Page 6: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

5

EV Integration on the Grid

Page 7: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Hawaii Today

• All fossil fuels imported

• 77% of electricity is fossil

• Electricity costs over time

follow oil cost

• Highest electricity rates in

the US at $0.28 per kWh

• Renewable produced 23%

electricity

Jet Fuel 34%

Electricity 32%

Petrol/Marine Fuel 27%

Other 7%

Petroleum use in Hawaii

Page 8: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

7

Hawaii’s Electric Rates Track Oil Prices

Source: US DOE online “eGallon”

Page 9: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

8

Source: US DOE eGallon (May 2016)

Even with the low price of oil…

Page 10: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

9

Why Hawaii for EV/Grid Integration?

Page 11: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Wind and Solar Resources High day-to-day variation

Po

we

r o

utp

ut

Wind Solar

10

Day in the year Day in the year

Page 12: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

11

Pathway to a Renewable Energy Future

• Develop models to evaluate future changes to Hawaii

energy systems

• Identify strategies to maximize use of renewable

generation

• Estimate costs and impacts to state economy.

Use quantitative analysis to inform policy.

Page 13: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

• GE Multi Area Production Simulation (GE MAPS) was

used for power grid simulation; fuel use, reduction in

wind and solar curtailment

• Potential, cost effective pathways to 40% wind plus

solar identified

• “Advanced” mitigations needed for higher penetrations

12

Data &

Scenarios

Dispatch &

Cost

HNEI-GE Modeling

Page 14: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

13

Hawaii’s Renewable Portfolio Standards

• 30% by 2020

• 40% by 2030

• 70% by 2040??

• 100% by 2045??

Page 15: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

24 Hour Load Profile with High Renewable Penetration

Leads to

curtailment

14

Page 16: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

15

• Reduce renewable energy output

Option – curtailment

• Increase utility load midday

Option – charge electric EVs midday

• Decrease utility load at peak

Option – reduce EV charging at peak

Teach the Duck to Fly*

*Lazar, J. (2016). Teaching the “Duck” to Fly, Second Edition. Montpelier, VT: The Regulatory

Assistance Project.

Available at: http://www.raponline.org/document/download/id/7956

Page 17: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

16

Analysis Assumptions

• Average plug-in EV uses 30 kWh/100mi

• 11,000 miles traveled per year

• Over 130,000 EVs on Oahu by 2045, and 260,000 with

EIA high oil price (~ 22% of passenger vehicles on

Oahu)

*Update to Factors Affecting EV Adoption: A Literature Review and

EV Forecast for Hawaii, Coffman, M., Bernstein , P. & Wee, S., (2015)

Reduce Curtailment Using EV Charging

Page 18: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Profile 1: 30% daytime, 70% at night

Perfect Tracking

Possible EV Charging Profiles

Uniform Charging

Profile 2: Same as Profile 1, but 0% Peak

Page 19: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

18

Reduction in Curtailed Energy Resulting from EV

Charging

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

Base Case 1500W/100S

Base Case 4500W/300S

Base Case 3500W/500S

Base Case 2700W/300S

Red

ucti

on in

Cur

taile

d En

ergy

Reduction in Curtailed Energy by Base Case: Percent Used

by EV Fleet

Uniform Charging

Perfect Tracking

Profile 1

Profile 2

Page 20: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

19

Progress in EV Mileage On Oahu

32

36

44

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

2012 2016 Scenario 2020 Scenario

W&

S

(MP

Ge)

Page 21: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Conclusions

• Hawaii presents a “Post Card from the Future”

• EVs do not reduce curtailment as much as expected,

especially wind

• Need midday/workplace charging on Oahu

Acknowledgement: work performed under the Electric Vehicle

Transportation Center and funded under a subaward from the

Florida Solar Energy Center, through a grant from the U.S.

Department of Transportation

20

Page 22: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Thank You

For more information:

Katherine McKenzie

[email protected]

www.hnei.hawaii.edu

Page 23: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

EV Workplace ChargingPower Demand … the hidden secret

Richard A. RaustadFlorida Solar Energy Center

1

Page 24: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Workplace Charging Considerations

• Charging rate required for employees

• First cost of equipment

• Fee or non-fee based

• Impact on building energy/demand

2

Page 25: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

EV ChargersElectrical Ratings

• AC Level 1 : 120 VAC, 1.9 kW

• AC Level 2 : 240 VAC, 19.2 kW

3

AC Level 1

Typically 1.3 kW

AC Level 2

Typically 6 kW

Page 26: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

EV ChargersElectrical Ratings

• DC Level 1 : 500 VDC, 40 kW• DC Level 2 : 500 VDC, 100 kW

4

Kia, Nissan, Mitsubishi,Subaru, Toyota

Audi, BMW, Chrysler, Daimler, Ford, GM, Porsche, Volkswagen

CHAdeMO SAE Combo

Page 27: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Equipment Costs5

1 Agenbroad, J., Holland, B., “Pulling Back the Veil on EV Charging Station Cost”,Rocky Mountain Institute, April 2014.

2 Includes permitting

Page 28: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Operating Costs6

1 AC Level 2: 6 kW, DC Level 2: 30 kW avg., $11/kW, 12 months/year (MI: $22/kW)2 35 mi, 3.5 mi/kWh, $0.12/kWh, $0/kW (residential or non-demand electric rate)3 9 hours @ 6 kW, 5 days/week, 50 weeks, $0.06/kWh (commercial electric rate)4 1 hour @ 16 kW avg., 9 times per day, 5 days/week, 50 weeks, $0.06/kWh (comm.)

Charger

Recurring Costs

Energy(sessions) Demand1

AC Level 1 $3002

(250) $0

AC Level 2 $8103

(750) $792

DC Level 2 $2,1604

(2250) $3,960

(1 EV)

(6 EV’s)

(18 EV’s)

$300 /EV/yr

$340 /EV/yr

$267 /EV/yr

Page 29: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Charger Selection7

What type of charger is appropriate for workplace charging?

AC Level 1 (slow):9 hours ≈ 30 miles

fast moderate

Page 30: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

EV Workplace ChargingPower Demand … the hidden secret

• Impact on Building Electrical Demand

• Demand Limiting Strategies

Illustrated by case study

8

Page 31: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

FSEC Building Information9

- 70,000 ft2 - 2 workplace chargers (12 kW)- 200 tons chiller capacity - 2 public Level 2 (12 kW)- 90 employees - 1 public DC Fast charger (45 kW)

- 5 ½ PEV’s ( 5 Leaf, 1 Volt)

Page 32: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Building Demand Impact Example10

$2.42

Page 33: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Charger Impact on Utility CostFeb 6. 2015 – Jun 7, 2016

11

Normal Building Operation:- 370 kW summer peak- 1,500 MWh/yr- $10,000/mo electric

Page 34: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Controllable Workplace Chargers12

Page 35: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Demand Limiting Strategies

• Scheduling (passive)

• Turn off at peak (active)

• Chiller plant capacity reduction

• Auxilliary power interrupt

• EV as storage medium (V2G)

13

Page 36: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

EVs in the Future – World SalesPlug-in Light Vehicles

14

Page 37: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Current Research ActivitiesFSEC Facilities Resource Study

15

Page 38: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Current Research ActivitiesFSEC Charging Station

• Charging Technologies

• Electric Grid Integration

• Environmental Effects

• Transportation Planning

16

Page 39: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Current Research ActivitiesFSEC EV Laboratory

• Charge vs Discharge

• V2G Applications

• Charging Optimization

• Electrical Demand

17

Page 40: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Current Research ActivitiesFSEC EV Laboratory - Wireless Charging

18

Page 41: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Current Research ActivitiesFlorida Turnpike Charging Station Optimization Study

• Infrastructure requirements

• Queueing models

• Siting

19

Page 42: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Thank You

For More Information:Richard Raustad

[email protected]

20

Acknowledgement: work performed under the Electric Vehicle Transportation Center and funded through U.S. Department of

Transportation Federal Grant: DTRT13-G-UTC51

Page 43: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

DTE Electric Large General Service Rate21

http://www.dleg.state.mi.us/mpsc/electric/ratebooks/dtee/dtee1curd1throughend.pdf

Page 44: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Impact on Monthly Demand22

- begin efforts to eliminate demand costs due to workplace charging

Page 45: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Impact on Monthly Energy23

Page 46: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Integrating PEVs with Renewables and the Grid

Andrew Meintz

June 29 2016

Page 47: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

2

18kW Solar PEV Parking Lot with 50 kW Fast Charger

NREL Parking Garage with 36 EVSE’s Charge Research and Visiting Vehicles

VTIF provides interior and exterior areas for systems EVGI communications and power exchange

NREL PIX20104

NREL PIX23458

NREL PIX21661

Vehicle Testing and Integration Facility (VTIF)

Source Andrew Meintz

Page 48: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

3

Energy Systems Integration Facility (ESIF)

• 182,500 sq. ft.

• 1-MVA bi-directional grid simulator

• Low Voltage Distribution Bus

• Medium Voltage Outdoor Test Area

• Full Power Hardware in the Loop (PHIL) testing

• Petascale High Performance Computing (HPC)

Research Electrical

Distribution Bus

(REDB)

DC (±500 V)

• 250 A

• 1600 A

AC (600 V)

• 250 A

• 1600 A

Example microgrid

NREL PIX26198

Page 49: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Residential Transformer

(25KVA)

AV EVSE

AV EVSE

AV EVSE

AV EVSE

AV EVSE

AV EVSE

AV EVSE

AV EVSE

Leviton EVSE

Leviton EVSE

Siemens EVSE

Siemens EVSE

Siemens EVSE

Siemens EVSE

Siemens EVSE

Siemens EVSE

250kW Load Bank

Utility grid power

NREL Internet

MVOTA

X2 Home Circuit Lighting

Appliances HVAC Systems

Electronics EV Charging

SPL

Lab

X2 11kW PV Simulator MillBank EVSE Siemens EVSE

ESL Lab

REDB

Communication line

Power line

REDB

MVOTA: Medium Voltage Outdoor Testing Area SPL: Smart Power Laboratory ESL: Energy Storage Laboratory REDB: Research Electrical Distribution Bus

NREL PIX32467 NREL PIX32467

NREL PIX28198

Page 50: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

5

Electric Vehicle Grid Integration at NREL Vehicles, Renewable Energy, and Buildings Working Together

Vehicle-to-Grid Challenges

Bi-Directional Power Flow

Develop and evaluate integrated V2G systems, which can reduce local peak-power

demands and access grid service value potential

Emergency Backup Power

Explore strategies for enabling the export of vehicle

power to assist in grid outages and disaster-

recovery efforts

Local Power Quality

Leverage charge system power electronics to monitor

and enhance local power quality and grid stability in

scenarios with high penetration of renewables

Managed Charging

Evaluate functionality and value of load management to reduce

charging costs and contribute to standards development

• GE Wattstation in NREL Parking Garage

• Grid2Home EVSE and Gateway with SEP2.0

• Leviton with Modbus

• AV EVSE via Wifi

• Toyota collaboration leverages vehicles and ESIF

• Light and heavy duty wireless charging systems

• Bi-directional fast charge

• Via Motors van with export to loads

• Nissan Leaf with V2H unit for backup

• Mini-E with Univ of Del and NRG

• PGE Utility truck characterization in ESIF

• 2 Smith EV trucks from Ft. Carson microgrid project

• Via Motors van with grid SEP2.0

Life Impacts

Can functionality be added with little or no impact on battery and vehicle performance?

Information Flow and Control

How is information shared and protected within the systems architecture?

Holistic Markets and Opportunities

What role will vehicles play and what value can be created?

• Using BLAST-V for scenario assessment

• Developed data entry and campus connections

• SEAC collaboration on market opportunities report

Achieved

In Process

Page 51: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Managed Charging and Local Power Quality

Page 52: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

7

PEV Charge Management with Renewable Sources

Provide simple interface with least

information necessary to create

managed individual and aggregate

scenarios with status display

RSF = Research Support Facility

NREL PIX21661

Page 53: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

8

On-board Charging Characterization

• Unidirectional control of EVSEs over Modbus using market vehicles:

• 5 to 10 A step-up/down tests to validate dynamic performance

NREL PIX29382

Source NREL, Mithat Kisacikoglu

Source NREL, Mithat Kisacikoglu

Source NREL, Mithat Kisacikoglu

Page 54: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

9

Unidirectional Charging Characterization

• ~0.56s communication delay using Modbus protocol • Different vehicles respond with different transfer functions • SAE J1772 specifies a 5s maximum response time (from CP change)

Page 55: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

10

Unidirectional Charging Characterization

• Different vehicles respond with different transfer functions • iQ ramp response in this example is ~5.3 A/s • Mini-E ramp response in this example is ~ 1.5 A/s

Page 56: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

11

WPT Grid Integration Testing

• Power quality testing for different grid voltage/frequency, receiver alignment, and battery charging power conditions. • Current harmonics • Battery ripple current • Power factor

• Management with renewable and L2 EVSEs • Three-phase implementation in a microgrid study.

DC Electronic Load

Grid Simulator

Infrastructure Inverter

Transmitter Coil

Receiver Coil

Vehicle Rectifier

0 to 400 VDC

0 to 600VAC @ 85 kHz

200 to 240 VAC 50/60 Hz

0 to 600VAC @ 85 kHz

Source NREL, Andrew Meintz

Page 57: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Bi-directional Power Flow and Emergency Power Back-up

Page 58: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

13

Bi-directional System Component Characterization

• Sharp Energy Storage System: 43 kWh, 30 kW IPC interface

• Via Motors Van - Coritech EVSE:23 kWh, 14.4 kW V2G-V2H

• Nissan Leaf - Nichicon EV Power Station 6kW V2H

• Smith EV Truck-Coritech EVSE: 80 kWh, 60 kW

• Transpower School Bus- Milbank EVSE: 90 kWh, 22.6 kW

• Mini-E – Milbank EVSE: 30kWh ,14.4 kW

• PV System (emulated-22 kW and real-18 kW)

• Residential and commercial loads (125kW AC)

• 30kW Grid Simulator and RTDS system

Smith EV Truck

Sharp Storage

Source NREL, Andrew Meintz

Via Motors Van

Source NREL, Andrew Meintz Source NREL, Mithat Kisacikoglu

Smith EV Truck Sharp Stationary Storage

Source NREL, Andrew Meintz

Nissan Leaf Nichicon V2H

Page 59: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

14

Export Power Using PEVs

• Via Motors Van with Coritech EVSE

• 14.4 kW on-board bidirectional charger

• Series hybrid PHEV with 23 kWh battery

• V2H and V2G capable, SEP 2.0 grid link, Homeplug GREEN PHY

• Single phase 120V/240V up to 60A off-grid power generation

• Nichicon EV Power Station

• 6 kW off-board charging capability

• 120V/240V, total 50A@120V V2H power capability

• Runs with Chademo compatible PEVs (Leaf, Mitsibushi i-

MiEV)

• Switching from grid connected to grid-isolated operation

Via export power port So

urce

NR

EL, Mith

at Kisaciko

glu

240V 120V

Research scope • Analysis of powering real home loads with Nissan Leaf and Via Van w/o grid.

• Evaluating the emergency power capability of EV (Leaf) and PHEV (Via-Van).

• Integrating emulated/real solar PV systems with V2H to extend the emergency power duration.

• Investigating microgrid operation of vehicles to power several houses.

Leaf-Nichicon power export

Page 60: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

15

Emergency Power Backup

NREL PIX32681

NREL PIX32465

PV Generation

Home Loads

Relay Box

EVPS AC/DC

Nissan Leaf

Grid

HVAC Water Heater Dryer Stove Refrigerator Washer Dishwasher Lights Television

On Time (Min) 56.6 37.17 65.52 1.12 122.12 45.50 55.50 24.35 20.58

Energy (Wh) 1136.91 3519.60 3014.62 23.16 254.10 204.54 675.98 213.61 37.24

Avg. Power (W) 1205.20 5681.87 2760.78 1244.40 124.85 269.72 730.79 526.36 108.56

Peak Power (W) 4849.15 5776.56 6156.19 1293.11 351.61 1244.24 1033.68 550.13 112.16

Page 61: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

16

Emergency Power Backup

NREL PIX32681

NREL PIX32465

PV Generation

Home Loads

Relay Box

EVPS AC/DC

Nissan Leaf

Grid

HVAC Water Heater Dryer Stove Refrigerator Washer Dishwasher Lights Television

On Time (Min) 56.6 37.17 65.52 1.12 122.12 45.50 55.50 24.35 20.58

Energy (Wh) 1136.91 3519.60 3014.62 23.16 254.10 204.54 675.98 213.61 37.24

Avg. Power (W) 1205.20 5681.87 2760.78 1244.40 124.85 269.72 730.79 526.36 108.56

Peak Power (W) 4849.15 5776.56 6156.19 1293.11 351.61 1244.24 1033.68 550.13 112.16

Page 62: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

17

Emergency Power Backup

NREL PIX32681

NREL PIX32465

PV Generation

Home Loads

Relay Box

EVPS AC/DC

Nissan Leaf

Grid

HVAC Water Heater Dryer Stove Refrigerator Washer Dishwasher Lights Television

On Time (Min) 56.6 37.17 65.52 1.12 122.12 45.50 55.50 24.35 20.58

Energy (Wh) 1136.91 3519.60 3014.62 23.16 254.10 204.54 675.98 213.61 37.24

Avg. Power (W) 1205.20 5681.87 2760.78 1244.40 124.85 269.72 730.79 526.36 108.56

Peak Power (W) 4849.15 5776.56 6156.19 1293.11 351.61 1244.24 1033.68 550.13 112.16

Page 63: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

18

Modeling and Testing of Microgrid

Power hardware in the loop testing

Source NREL, Andrew Meintz

Page 64: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Grid Modernization Efforts

Page 65: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

20

20

Page 66: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

21

• Funding for research at National Labs to define and develop integrated systems supporting Grid Modernization Initiative objectives

• EERE Solar, Wind, Buildings, Vehicles, Fuel Cells program supporting along with Office of Electricity

• Proposals are intended to be multi-year and include collaboration across multiple labs

• Category 1 – Foundational efforts; cross-cutting

• Category 2 – Program-specific technologies with interfaces to Category 1 activities

Grid Modernization Lab Call Overview

Multi-Lab EV Smart Grid Working Group delivers guidance report to DOE - May, 2015

Multi-Lab EV Smart Grid Working Group DOE Vehicle Technologies Office

Page 67: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

22

Vehicle to Building Integration Pathway

Description

• Enable workplace charging and promote broader PEV adoption through the development and demonstration of an interoperable communication pathway and control system architecture that connects

[1] Plug-in Electric Vehicles (PEVs)

[2] PEV drivers

[3] Electric Vehicle Support Equipment (EVSE)

[4] Building Energy Management System (BEMS)

in order to create value for all parties.

• Demonstrate scalable communications and control system will enable managed energy use between dissimilar grid-connected devices that will mitigate demand charges.

• Establish a physical platform to develop and test the technical requirements needed for standards development and interoperability.

Participating labs (lead lab first): PNNL, ANL, INL, LBNL, NREL Partners: AeroVironment, Bonneville Power Administration, University of Delaware, DTE Energy, California Energy Commission

Funding: $3.4M over three years

Multi-Lab EV Smart Grid Working Group DOE Vehicle Technologies Office

M

EVSE

BMS

INV PEV

PEV

EVSE

Driver

Driver

Load Load

Page 68: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

23

Systems Research Supporting Standards and Interoperability

Description

• Develop a distributed vehicle/grid integration platform to determine the feasibility of PEVs providing grid services and renewable energy integration without negatively impacting the PEV customer experience

• Perform distribution-level hardware-in-the-loop demonstrations involving a variety of vehicles and other distributed energy resources at numerous facilities

• Trial multiple communications pathways to accelerate standards development and understand how to prioritize the needs of the PEV customer, facility, third-party aggregator, and grid operator in multiple use cases

Participating labs (lead lab first): INL, ANL, LBNL, NREL, ORNL, PNNL

Partners: Bonneville Power Administration, DTE Energy, Eversource, University of Delaware, Siemens, California Energy Commission, USDRIVE Grid Interaction Technical Team

Funding: $3.6M over three years

Multi-Lab EV Smart Grid Working Group DOE Vehicle Technologies Office

TX

TX

TX

Aggregator

Sub

Grid Ops

Page 69: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

24

Modeling and Control Software to Support V2G Integration

Description:

Develop advanced modeling and simulation tools to:

1. Understand how much renewables integration is enabled by vehicles, and developing operational frameworks so clean vehicles enable a clean grid.

2. Understand the value available for vehicles to serve as a grid resource under different VGI approaches.

3. Provide tools and understanding to guide effective decision-making on VGI pathways for all stakeholders.

Participating labs (lead lab first): LBNL, ANL, INL, NREL, ORNL, PNNL

Partners: Bonneville Power Administration, California Energy Commission

Funding: $2.8M over three years

Road network (mobility)

EV Charging / Availability

Grid network

Simulations & data to quantitatively understand interactions and opportunities

between mobility & grid networks

Multi-Lab EV Smart Grid Working Group DOE Vehicle Technologies Office

Page 70: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Questions: Andrew Meintz,

[email protected]

Energy Benefits from Vehicles, Buildings, and Renewables Working Together

Page 71: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Managing EV Load

Workplace Charging Project

Utility Perspective

Hawk Asgeirsson, Manager Power Systems Technologies (Retired)

June 29, 2016

Page 72: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

DTE Energy is an Integrated Energy

Company

2

Page 73: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Agenda

• Why manage EV load?

• Local level

• System level

• Renewable variability

• Workplace charging

• Interoperability & standards

Page 74: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Day High Temp Low Temp Avg. Temp

1 87 65 76 2 93 65 79 3 93 71 82

Residential Distribution Circuit Load Graph

Summer 2012 high temperature days

Page 75: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Residential Experimental PEV Rate

5

• PEV rate approved in August 2010 – 2,500 limit

• Choice of two Experimental Electric Vehicle Rate

options:

• Option 1- Time of Use Rate

• Option 2 - A Flat Rate (250 customer cap)

• Both options required a separately meter service

• An incentive up to $2,500 was offered to offset the

purchase and installation costs for a Level 2 EVSE

$40 per month + applicable surcharges

and taxes.

Option 2: Flat Rate Option

Option1: Time of Use Rate Option

Time of Use Rate

On-Peak: $0.18195 kWh* Off-Peak: $0.07695 kWh*

On-Peak: All kWh used between 9am and 11pm Monday- Friday Off-Peak: All other kWh used.

*Prices do not include applicable surcharges and taxes

Page 76: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Time of day

Ave

rage

kW

Residential Charging - Pilot PEV Rate

Average Demand - TOU vs Flat Rate

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24

Flat TOD

Page 77: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24

Flat TOD

Date: August 1-3 Wed-Fri

Day High Temp Low Temp Avg. Temp

1 87 65 76 2 93 65 79 3 93 71 82

Distribution circuit load graphs

Summer 2012 high temperature days

8/1/12

8/2/12

8/3/12

Page 78: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Typical system summer load curve – how to

manage morning ramp rate with workplace

chargers

8

Page 79: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

California - SDG&E System Load

9

Page 80: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Wind production is variable

10

-20

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

10/2/2013 0:00 10/3/2013 0:00 10/4/2013 0:00 10/5/2013 0:00 10/6/2013 0:00 10/7/2013 0:00 10/8/2013 0:00 10/9/2013 0:00 10/10/2013 0:00

DTE Energy Wind Park Total MW

Page 81: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Workplace Smart Charging Project - DOE

Funded

• Install 24 charging stations in the DTE Energy HQ parking deck

• Utilize DTE’s Tropos mesh network to communicate with head end software

• Upgraded existing infrastructure to support increased load from EVSEs

• Utility service was not upgraded – New LED lighting installed

11

Page 82: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Delta’s “smart grid-capable” Level-2 EVSE

12

• Bi-directional communications between

EVSE and energy service providers

• Revenue-grade metering

• Advanced metering infrastructure

(AMI)/Ethernet/power line

communications (PLC)/Wi-

Fi/cellular/ZigBee interface capable

• Interface capable with in-home displays

and home energy management systems

• Utility communication messaging

• Controls including direct load control at

fixed percentage of EV load reduction,

remote disconnect, etc.

• Zigbee bi-directional communication

• 0.5% accuracy in operation range

• Zigbee interface to AMI meter / wi-fi

• Display and control through Home Energy

Management System (HEMS) user

interface

• Smart Energy Profile (SEP) 1.1

(Time synchronization, DRLC, Price information)

• Charging current control through J1772

interface

Page 83: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Workplace Charging

13

DOE Project Task #1:

Workplace Charging EVSE Installations, 24 units

Includes the build and installation of 24 units of

the EVSE, for installation and evaluation at DTEs

downtown Detroit site

DOE Project Task #2

Monitoring and Network Software Installation.

This includes monitoring and evaluation of the

EVSE performance in various scenarios

anticipated by power company management,

using the smart grid functions of the EVSEs, and

network management software installed for this

purpose.

• 24 units are in operation

• Software Installed:

• Demand Response

• Real-time monitoring

• Charge Profiling

• Data History

Page 84: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

14

Infrastructure Upgrades

• 50kVA Transformer

upgraded to 225 kVA

• Main breaker upgraded to

600 Amp

• 480/208 Volt transformer

• Upgraded existing service

panel and added second

service panel and bus

• Utility service was not

upgraded – New LED

lighting installed

Service Panel 1 Service

Panel 2

Bus

225 kVA Transformer

Comm Panel

Page 85: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

15

EVSE Site

Total of 24 EVSEs

Four or five EVSEs around each column

Page 86: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

16

EVSE Site

Photo of the 2nd generation EVSE Prototype installed and under field trial at DTE's parking garage in downtown Detroit, MI.

Guests viewing charging of Daimler Smart EV at the October 2014 demonstration event.

Page 87: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Network Architecture

17

WiFi AP for

EVSEs

DTE Energy

Tropos Mesh

Radio System

Tropos

Radio

CAT5e Ethernet

cable

SMS @ DTE

Control Room

Page 88: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

DTE Energy DR-SOC (DERMS)

18

DMS

Sensors, Switches, Capacitors, Regulators

MDMS OMS

DR-SOC

SOLAR BATTERY PEV

Enterprise Integration

GIS

SCADA / Field Networks

Etc.

ICCP

Field Communication Network

or cellular

DNP3

Master

Page 89: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Site Management System

Charger Status

Page 90: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Site Management System

Charger Details

Page 91: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

• Power Profile display in

24 hr overview and close

up view.

• Orange trace – max

power setting

• Blue trace – real-time

power

• Any profile curve can be

entered into software

Site Management System

Charger Power Profile

Control Strategy - Based on Power Command Profile, distribute available

capacity equally to those EVSEs in charging

Page 92: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

Site Management System

Charger Power Profile

Page 93: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

DTE Energy – OnStar Demonstration

• From DTE HQ, uploaded DTE Energy PEV rate schedule to Volts through OnStar telematics

Page 94: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

OEM Central Server Proof of Concept

EPRI-Utility-Auto Demonstration

• Use Case 1 is the B2B internet

connection

– From the Utility Demand Response

Management System to the Central

Server utilizing the OpenADR 2b

protocol.

– Implements DR Events and TOU

Rate Tariff Schedules

communicated via the B2B internet

connection to the Central Server to

the individual OEM servers to the

PEVs.

AT SMUD LOCATION

Internet

Page 95: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,

VTO Systems Research Supporting Standards and Interoperability

• Vehicle to Building Integration Pathway

• Systems Research Supporting Standards and Interoperability

• Modeling and Control Software to Support V2G Integration

• Diagnostic Security Modules for Electric Vehicles to Building Integration

25

Multi-Lab EV Smart Grid Working Group

Page 96: Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource ITEC IEEE Electrified... · Electrified Transportation as a Power Grid Resource Katherine McKenzie Hawaii Natural Energy Institute,