efficacy cardiac sympathectomy treatment with qt · 2017. 10. 5. · bhandariet al. after surgery (

7
THERAPY AND PREVENTION Efficacy of left cardiac sympathectomy in the treatment of patients with the long QT syndrome ANIL K. BHANDARI, M.D., MELVIN M. SCHEINMAN, M.D., FRED MORADY, M.D., JOHN SVINARICH, M.D., JAY MASON, M.D.. AND ROGER WINKLE, M.D. ABSTRACT Ten patients with the long QT syndrome and recurrent syncope and/or cardiac arrest caused by ventricular arrhythmias underwent left stellate (one patient) or left cervicothoracic sympa- thectomy (nine patients) after failing to respond to high-dose /3-blocker therapy. The syndrome was familial in four and idiopathic in six. All patients had a prolonged resting QT interval (548 -+ 51 msec, mean SD) and corrected QT interval (QTc) (556 + 43 msec). After sympathectomy the mean QTc shortened significantly from 556 -+ 43 to 508 + 65 msec (p < .05) but the QTc remained abnormal in all but one patient. Over a mean follow-up period of 38.6 + 19 months, eight patients developed recurrent symptoms that included cardiac arrest in three (one fatal, two nonfatal), syncope in four, and presyncope in six. The addition of /3-blockers was ineffective in suppressing the recurrent symptoms. The control of symptoms required more extensive sympathectomy (three patients), chronic atrial pacing (three patients), and implantation of an automatic internal defibrillator (one patient). Only one patient has remained asymptomatic without drug or pacemaker therapy. In conclusion, left cervicotho- racic sympathectomy proved inadequate for long-term control of symptoms in most patients with the long QT syndrome. These patients usually required concomitant drugs, more extensive surgery. or long-term cardiac pacing for symptomatic relief. Circulation 70, No. 6, 1018-1023, 1984. THE ASSOCIATION of idiopathic prolongation of the QT interval with recurrent attacks of syncope and cardiac arrest is known as the long QT syndrome. 6 The mortality rate in untreated patients is thought to be as high as 78%.) Although /3-blockers have proved valuable in the long-term management of patients with this syndrome, at least 6% of patients fail to respond to 13-blockade., 23.5 Left cervicothoracic sympathectomy has been re- ported to be the treatment of choice for patients with this syndrome who do not respond to pharmacologic treatment.7-' Although the available data suggest that sympathectomy is highly effective in suppressing epi- sodes of syncope and cardiac arrest caused by ventricu- lar tachycardia, long-term follow-up data for patients with the long QT syndrome who have undergone sym- pathectomy are scanty. In prior reports, changes in the QT interval after sympathectomy were variable and were not predictive of clinical outcome. From the Department of Medicine and the Cardiovascular Research Institute, University of California, San Francisco, and Stanford Univer- sity Medical Center, Stanford; the University of Utah Medical Center, Salt Lake City; and the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. Address for correspondence: Anil K. Bhandari, M.D., University of Southern California School of Medicine, Section of Cardiology, 2025 Zonal Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90033. Received April 30, 1984; revision accepted Aug. 23, 1984. 1018 This report deals with 10 consecutive patients with the long QT syndrome who underwent sympathectomy over a 6 year period. The study aimed to assess the long-term effects of sympathectomy on changes in the corrected QT interval (QTc), ventricular arrhythmias, and symptoms. Materials and methods The study was a retrospective analysis of 10 patients with the long QT syndrome who underwent left cervicothoracic sympa- thectomy during the years 1977 to 1982 at either the University of California Medical Center, San Francisco (six patients), or Stanford Medical Center (four patients). During this period we evaluated a total of 18 symptomatic patients with a definite diagnosis of the long QT syndrome: eight responded to the /- blockers but 10 required sympathectomy because of a poor response to the /3-blockers or severe manifestations of the syn- drome. The study population comprised the latter 10 patients. The clinical characteristics of the 10 patients are summarized in table 1. There were nine women and one man, with an age range of 13 to 56 years (30.5 + 12). The syndrome was familial in four and idiopathic in six. All patients had a history of cardiac arrest (nine patients), syncope (nine patients), or both (eight patients). Polymorphous ventricular tachycardia or fibrillation was documented as the cause of symptoms in each patient. Based on the history, physical examination, electrocardiogram, chest x-ray, two-dimensional echocardiogram (three patients), and cardiac catheterization with coronary angiography (three patients), seven patients had no demonstrable structural heart disease, two had mild systemic hypertension without left ven- tricular hypertrophy, and one had mitral valve prolapse. Seven CIRCULATION by guest on October 5, 2017 http://circ.ahajournals.org/ Downloaded from

Upload: others

Post on 04-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Efficacy cardiac sympathectomy treatment with QT · 2017. 10. 5. · BHANDARIet al. after surgery (

THERAPY AND PREVENTION

Efficacy of left cardiac sympathectomy in thetreatment of patients with the long QT syndromeANIL K. BHANDARI, M.D., MELVIN M. SCHEINMAN, M.D., FRED MORADY, M.D.,JOHN SVINARICH, M.D., JAY MASON, M.D..AND ROGER WINKLE, M.D.

ABSTRACT Ten patients with the long QT syndrome and recurrent syncope and/or cardiac arrestcaused by ventricular arrhythmias underwent left stellate (one patient) or left cervicothoracic sympa-thectomy (nine patients) after failing to respond to high-dose /3-blocker therapy. The syndrome was

familial in four and idiopathic in six. All patients had a prolonged resting QT interval (548 -+ 51 msec,mean SD) and corrected QT interval (QTc) (556 + 43 msec). After sympathectomy the mean QTcshortened significantly from 556 -+ 43 to 508 + 65 msec (p < .05) but the QTc remained abnormal inall but one patient. Over a mean follow-up period of 38.6 + 19 months, eight patients developedrecurrent symptoms that included cardiac arrest in three (one fatal, two nonfatal), syncope in four, andpresyncope in six. The addition of /3-blockers was ineffective in suppressing the recurrent symptoms.The control of symptoms required more extensive sympathectomy (three patients), chronic atrialpacing (three patients), and implantation of an automatic internal defibrillator (one patient). Only one

patient has remained asymptomatic without drug or pacemaker therapy. In conclusion, left cervicotho-racic sympathectomy proved inadequate for long-term control of symptoms in most patients with thelong QT syndrome. These patients usually required concomitant drugs, more extensive surgery. or

long-term cardiac pacing for symptomatic relief.Circulation 70, No. 6, 1018-1023, 1984.

THE ASSOCIATION of idiopathic prolongation ofthe QT interval with recurrent attacks of syncope andcardiac arrest is known as the long QT syndrome. 6

The mortality rate in untreated patients is thought to beas high as 78%.) Although /3-blockers have provedvaluable in the long-term management of patients withthis syndrome, at least 6% of patients fail to respond to13-blockade.,23.5

Left cervicothoracic sympathectomy has been re-ported to be the treatment of choice for patients withthis syndrome who do not respond to pharmacologictreatment.7-' Although the available data suggest thatsympathectomy is highly effective in suppressing epi-sodes of syncope and cardiac arrest caused by ventricu-lar tachycardia, long-term follow-up data for patientswith the long QT syndrome who have undergone sym-pathectomy are scanty. In prior reports, changes in theQT interval after sympathectomy were variable andwere not predictive of clinical outcome.

From the Department of Medicine and the Cardiovascular ResearchInstitute, University of California, San Francisco, and Stanford Univer-sity Medical Center, Stanford; the University of Utah Medical Center,Salt Lake City; and the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.

Address for correspondence: Anil K. Bhandari, M.D., University ofSouthern California School of Medicine, Section of Cardiology, 2025Zonal Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90033.

Received April 30, 1984; revision accepted Aug. 23, 1984.

1018

This report deals with 10 consecutive patients withthe long QT syndrome who underwent sympathectomyover a 6 year period. The study aimed to assess thelong-term effects of sympathectomy on changes in thecorrected QT interval (QTc), ventricular arrhythmias,and symptoms.

Materials and methodsThe study was a retrospective analysis of 10 patients with the

long QT syndrome who underwent left cervicothoracic sympa-thectomy during the years 1977 to 1982 at either the Universityof California Medical Center, San Francisco (six patients), orStanford Medical Center (four patients). During this period weevaluated a total of 18 symptomatic patients with a definitediagnosis of the long QT syndrome: eight responded to the /-blockers but 10 required sympathectomy because of a poorresponse to the /3-blockers or severe manifestations of the syn-drome. The study population comprised the latter 10 patients.The clinical characteristics of the 10 patients are summarized

in table 1. There were nine women and one man, with an agerange of 13 to 56 years (30.5 + 12). The syndrome was familialin four and idiopathic in six. All patients had a history of cardiacarrest (nine patients), syncope (nine patients), or both (eightpatients). Polymorphous ventricular tachycardia or fibrillationwas documented as the cause of symptoms in each patient.Based on the history, physical examination, electrocardiogram,chest x-ray, two-dimensional echocardiogram (three patients),and cardiac catheterization with coronary angiography (threepatients), seven patients had no demonstrable structural heartdisease, two had mild systemic hypertension without left ven-tricular hypertrophy, and one had mitral valve prolapse. Seven

CIRCULATION

by guest on October 5, 2017

http://circ.ahajournals.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 2: Efficacy cardiac sympathectomy treatment with QT · 2017. 10. 5. · BHANDARIet al. after surgery (

THERAPY AND PREVENTION-ARRHYTHMIA

TABLE 1Clinical characteristics of 10 patients with the long QT syndrome who underwent left cervicothoracic sympathectomy

Duration ofSymptoms Cardiac symptoms Therapy QT/QTc

Patient Age (yr)/sex Syndrome Presync. sync. arrest (mo) (mg/day) (msec) DOS

IA 58/F Idio. + + + + + + 48 Prop. (160) 600/600 3/772 13/F Fam. + + + + + + + 12 Prop. (160) 520/600 10/783 30/F Fam. + + ++-I + + 12 Prop. (160) 520/610 2/79

DPH (300)4A 26/F Idio. + + + +++ 10 Prop. (360) 500/540 3/795A 22/M Fam. + + + + + + + 3 Prop. (160) 6001550 8/796 25/F Idio. + + + + + + 4 Prop. (240) 520/515 11/807A 34/F Idio. + + + + + 12 Prop. (160) 620/600 11/81

HTN8A 33/F Fam. + + + +++ + 96 Nad. (360) 480/500 5/829A 30/F Idio. + + + + + + 72 NAD. (360) 600/550 9/82

MVPI oA 34/F Idio. + + 2 520/500 10/82

HTN

Idio. idiopathic; Fam = familial; Presync. = presyncope; Sync syncope; Prop = propranolol; Nad = nadolol; DOS =date of left cervicothoracic sympathectomy; HTN = systemic hypertension; MVP = mitral valve prolapse; DPH = diphenyl-hydantoin; + = 1 episode; + + = two to five episodes; + + + = more than five episodes.

APatients underwent electrophysiologic testing before sympathectomy.

of the 10 patients had also undergone electrophysiologic stimu-lation studies before sympathectomy; none had inducible sus-

tained ventricular tachycardia or fibrillation although nonsus-

tained polymorphic ventricular tachycardia was induced in fourpatients. We have previously reported detailed findings on theresults of electrophysiologic testing.`2

All patients demonstrated prolongation of the resting QTinterval (mean 548 + 51 msec, range 480 to 620) and the QTc(mean 556 + 43 msec, range 500 to 610). The prolongation ofthe QT interval was unrelated to drugs, electrolyte abnormali-ties, myocardial ischemia, or a central nervous system lesion.The upper limit of normal for the QT interval was determined bythe frequency distribution table of Simonson et al.13 The QTcinterval was obtained by dividing the measured QT interval bythe square root of the preceding R-R interval in seconds(Bazett's formula).'4 The upper limit of normal of QTc was

defined as 450 msec.The indications for sympathectomy were the following:

seven patients (Nos. 1 to 3, 5 to 7, and 9) underwent surgery

because of symptoms refractory to full doses of fl-blockers(table 1). Two patients (Nos. 8 and 10) underwent sympathecto-my after their first episode of cardiac arrest before an adequatetrial of fl-blockers. The remaining patient (No. 4) underwentsympathectomy because of severe central nervous system intol-erance (fatigue, nightmares, and depression) to propranolol(800 mg/day) and because lower doses of propranolol failed tocontrol symptoms.A left cervicothoracic sympathectomy was performed via the

supraclavicular approach in all patients. The dissection was

carried out posteriorly to the transverse process of the lowercervical spine where the stellate ganglion was identified. Thedissection was then carried inferiorly to the limits of exposure toidentify the upper thoracic sympathetic ganglia. The left stellateganglion in its entirety and the first three to four thoracic sympa-thetic ganglia were excised in all but one patient (No. 2), inwhom only the left stellate ganglion was resected. Postopera-tively, all patients developed a left-sided Horner's syndrome.No complications were encountered.

Vol. 70, No. 6, December 1984

All patients were followed by one of the authors or the refer-ring physicians at intervals of 3 to 6 months.

Values are expressed as mean + 1 SD. The two-tailed t testfor paired data was used to compare QTc values before and aftersurgery in the same patient.

ResultsThe response of QTc to sympathectomy is shown in

table 2. The mean QTc shortened significantly from abaseline of 556 ± 43 to 508 ± 65 msec immediately

TABLE 2QTc before and after sympathectomy in 10 patients with the longQT syndrome

Preop. Early postop. Late postop.

Patient SCL QTc SLC QTc SCL QTc

1 1000 600 860 520 1080 5802 750 600 700 510 1000 6003 730 610 600 590 840 5204 850 540 1000 400 1250 4305 1200 550 925 625 1200 4806 1030 515 750 530 900 5057 1070 600 1400 445 890 4858 1200 550 1000 480 1395 5059 920 500 900 510 800 54010 1080 500 1000 470 1100 490

Mean 983 556 913 508A 1045 513ASD ±167 +43 +219 +65 + 194 +49

Values expressed in milliseconds.SCL = sinus cycle length.Ap < .05 vs preoperative value.

1019

by guest on October 5, 2017

http://circ.ahajournals.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 3: Efficacy cardiac sympathectomy treatment with QT · 2017. 10. 5. · BHANDARIet al. after surgery (

BHANDARI et al.

after surgery (<6 weeks). Although the postoperativemean QTc value was shorter, the QTc interval re-mained abnormal in all patients except one (No. 4)(430 msec). There was no significant difference in themean QTc between the early and late postoperativeperiods (>6 weeks).

After sympathectomy, nine of the 10 patients wereinitially discharged on no medication. One patient(No. 10) was treated with propranolol (160 mg/day) atthe discretion of the referring physician.The patients have been followed over a period of 17

to 65 months (mean 38.6 ± 19). After a mean symp-tom-free interval of 15. 1 ± 12 months (range 1 to 36)recurrent symptoms developed in eight patients (table3). Only two patients (Nos. 7 and 8) have remainedasymptomatic after a follow-up period of 27 and 22months, respectively. One of them (No. 8) has been onno drug therapy and the other (No. 7) has been treatedwith nadolol (240 mg/day) because of frequent (>30/hr) premature ventricular contractions (PVCs) on sev-eral 24 hr Holter monitor recordings.Among the eight symptomatic patients, cardiac ar-

rest recurred in three (30%), syncope in four (40%),and presyncope in six (60%). Cardiac arrest occurredat an interval of 24 (patient 1), 44 (patient 2), and 7

TABLE 3Treatment and follow-up data on 10 patients with the long

months (patient 10) from the date of surgery andproved fatal in one patient (No. 1). At the time ofrecurrent cardiac arrest, all three patients were takingmaximally tolerated doses of ,3-blockers. Patient 1took propranolol (160 mg/day) because of recurrentsyncope that occurred 6 months before the fatal cardiacarrest. A 24 hr Holter monitor recording done 3months before the cardiac arrest in this patient haddemonstrated only three isolated PVCs. Patient 2 tooknadolol (320 mg) and diphenylhydantoin (300 mg)because of symptoms of frequent syncope and presyn-cope that had developed 20 months before the cardiacarrest. Patient 10 took propranolol (160 mg/day) sincethe time of surgery and had been asymptomatic beforecardiac arrest. No Holter recordings were available inthe latter two patients. Only one of the patients withrecurrent cardiac arrest (patient 2) showed evidence ofregeneration of left adrenergic nerves (disappearanceof Homer's syndrome).Of the remaining five symptomatic patients, two

(patients 4 and 5) developed frequent syncopal andpresyncopal episodes after symptom-free intervals of 1and 6 months, respectively, and three (patients 3, 6,and 9) had frequent presyncopal episodes. The symp-toms were identical to those experienced preoperative-

QT syndrome who underwent sympathectomv

Post-LCTSsymptom- Recurrent Final Total

free interval symptoms during therapy follow-up FinalPatient (mo) tollow-up (mg/day) (mo) outcome

1 18 Syncope. cardiac Prop. (160) 24 Sudden deatharrest

2A 9 Syncope, presyncope. LCTSB 65 Asymptomaticcardiac arrest Nad. (160)

Atrial pacing3 36 Presyncope Prop. (160) 61 Asymptomatic

Atrial pacing4A I Syncope. presyncope Repeat LCTS 61 Asymptomatic

Prop. (360)5A 6 Syncope Repeat LCTS 52 Asymptomatic

Presyncope Aten. (100)6 24 Presyncope Nad. (80) 39 Presyncope7 27 None Nad. (240)' 27 Asymptomatic8A 22 None None 22 Asymptomatic9 1 Presyncope Nad. (360) 18 Asymptomatic

Atrial pacing10 7 Cardiac arrest AID 17 Cardiac arrest

Prop. 160 (nonfatal)

LCTS left cervicothoracic sympathectomy: Nad. = nadolol; Prop. = propranolol; Aten.internal defibrillator.

AHomer's syndrome disappeared during the follow-up period.BInitial surgery was limited to left stellectomy.CNadolol started because of frequent PVCs on Holter recordings.

= atenolol; AID = automatic

CIRCULATION1 020

by guest on October 5, 2017

http://circ.ahajournals.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 4: Efficacy cardiac sympathectomy treatment with QT · 2017. 10. 5. · BHANDARIet al. after surgery (

THERAPY AND PREVENTION-ARRHYTHMIA

ly but could be documented to be secondary to ventric-ular tachyarrhythmia in only one patient (No. 9). Thesymptoms were not responsive to the addition of 3-blockers in any patient although they became less fre-quent than before sympathectomy.

In comparing the asymptomatic patients with thosewho had a recurrence of symptoms, we found no dif-ference in the response of the QTc after surgery or thefrequency of PVCs on the postsympathectomy Holterrecordings. Among the six symptomatic patients withavailable Holter recordings, only one patient (No. 9)demonstrated frequent multifocal PVCs, often in pairsand triplets. The other five patients had either no orrare PVCs on numerous 24 hr recordings. One of thetwo asymptomatic patients (No. 7) also had frequentPVCs on Holter recordings.

Four patients (Nos. 2, 4, 5, and 8) experiencedcomplete resolution of Horner's syndrome after amean interval of 16 ± 9 months (range 4 to 24) fromthe time of surgery. During follow-up the recurrentsymptoms developed in three of them. One patient(No. 8), however, continues to be asymptomatic with-out drug therapy.

Therapeutic intervention after sympathectomy. One ofthe two survivors of cardiac arrest (patient 10) under-went implantation of an automatic internal defibrilla-tor. The other patient (No. 2) underwent both perma-nent atrial pacemaker insertion and a sympathectomy.The previous surgery in this patient had been limited to

removal of the left stellate ganglion with subsequentdisappearance of Horner's syndrome. Both patientshave also continued :-blocker therapy. Patient 2 hashad no recurrent symptoms since then (22 months) butpatient 10 had another episode of syncope 3 monthslater that responded successfully to one shock deliv-ered from the automatic internal defibrillator.The control of symptoms in four of the other five

symptomatic patients required, in addition to /3blockers, implanitation of permanent atrial pacemakersin two (patients 3 and 9) and more extensive left tho-racic sympathectomy up to the level of sixth ganglion(via transaxillary approach) in the other two patients(Nos. 4 and 5). One patient (No. 9) showed both reliefof symptoms as well as dramatic decrease in both thefrequency and complexity of ventricular arrhythmiasafter long-term atrial pacing (figure 1). This patienthad significant sinus bradycardia with resting heartrate ranging from 42 to 55 beats/min. In the othertwo patients (Nos. 4 and 5) Hormer's syndrome hadresolved after an interval of 4 and 16 months, respec-tively, from the first surgery. One patient (No. 6) con~tinues to have infrequent presyncopal episodes on /3blockers alone.

DiscussionLeft cervicothoracic sympathectomy was first used

successfully in 1970 by Moss and MacDonald7 in apatient with the long QT syndrome who had symptoms

H- l U-H F i -9- : JF1.XI-4 7C 6 HiMi

/~~~~~n

7r ....,.. .7.

p t.Si ^2a ,0.

is ,, 0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. .. .... ...

~ ~ .....**.

f j . . 0 . . . . . . - s . ; - . , . . i; * * S F , F ~~~~~~i, Si-.Ah; njvJ;s,:&

- I i-

FIGURE 1. Rhythm strips from patient 9 before and during long-teim atrial pacing. The top two strips (simultlaneous) wereobtained 6 months after sympathectomy with the patient oni nadolol (360 mg/day) and show frequent multiform PVCs andventricular tachycardia. The QT interval is prolonged to 520 msec. The rhythm in the bottom strip is cmpletely atrial paced at 88beats/min. Note the absence of PVCs and normalization of the QT interval.

Vol. 70, No. 6, December 1984

E -, v :x:;-:,:-i: I::- -4 i

1021

by guest on October 5, 2017

http://circ.ahajournals.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 5: Efficacy cardiac sympathectomy treatment with QT · 2017. 10. 5. · BHANDARIet al. after surgery (

BHANDARI et al.

refractory to medical therapy. To date, the single larg-est surgical experience has been provided by theworldwide prospective registry started in 1979 bySchwartz, Moss, and Crampton. A total of 43 report-ed patients underwent sympathectomy because ofsymptoms refractory to /3-blockers, and surgery wasassociated with a near total abolition of symptoms inall. Symptoms of recurrent syncope or presyncopewere uncommon and appeared to resolve with /3-blocker therapy.Our experience with sympathectomy was not as fa-

vorable as that reported by others.7-1 Our patients werecomparable to those previously reported in both themagnitude of QT prolongation as well as in clinicalmanifestations of the syndrome. However, the sympa-thectomy provided long-term relief of symptoms inonly two patients (20%), while the other eight patients(80%) developed recurrent symptoms that includedcardiac arrest in three (30%), repetitive syncope in four(40%), and presyncope in six (60%). One patient ex-perienced sudden death at an interval of 24 monthsafter surgery. Therefore, left stellectomy or standardleft cervicothoracic sympathectomy does not by itselfprovide permanent relief of symptoms to all patientswith this syndrome.The addition of /3-blockers has been reported to be

beneficial in stellectomized patients with recurrentsymptoms.3' 11 However, /3-blockers proved relativelyineffective in the control of recurrent symptoms in ourpatients. All three episodes of cardiac arrest occurredwhile patients were taking maximally tolerated dosesof /3-blockers. /3-Blockers also failed to abolish syn-cope and presyncope in the other four patients, al-though the frequency of the symptoms diminished sig-nificantly. The control of symptoms often requiredother therapeutic modalities such as long-term atrialpacing or use of an automatic internal defibrillator.

The reasons underlying the difference between ourexperience and that of others are unclear. Althoughthere was an initial period (mean 15.1 + 12 months) ofsymptom control in the majority of patients, this bene-ficial effect was not sustained over a longer follow-upperiod. Conceivably, failure of sympathectomy to pro-vide sustained benefit was related to regeneration ofthe cardiac sympathetic nerves. Among the sympto-matic patients, the initial Horner's syndrome resolvedin three patients despite complete removal (histologi-cally documented) of the left stellate ganglion in each.One of them had undergone left stellectomy alone (pa-tient 2), and the development of syncope and cardiacarrest miay have been caused by an inadequate sympa-thectomy. The two other patients who showed evi-

dence of regeneration (Nos. 4 and 5) also appeared torespond to more extensive thoracic sympathectomywith removal of up to sixth thoracic ganglion. Howev-er, recurrence of symptoms in the other five patientswho had undergone adequate sympathectomy with' re-

moval of the first three to four thoracic ganglia was notassociated with any clinical evidence of regenerationof sympathetic nerves. The clinical significance of dis-appearance of Horner's syndrome in one of the asymp-tomatic patients (No. 9) also remains unclear.The inability of sympathectomy to provide sus-

tained protection against cardiac arrest and syncope inall patients with the long QT syndrome was an unex-

pected finding. The rationale for unilateral sympathec-tomy is based on the presumption of relative domi-nance of the left-sided cardiac adrenergic activity."-"The evidence in favor of this hypothesis comes fromthe observation that the stimulation of the left-sided or

ablation of the right-sided stellate ganglion is associat-ed with prolongation of the QT interval as well as an

induction of ventricular arrhythmias in dogs. Left stel-lectomy not only prevents QT prolongation but alsodecreases the ventricular arrhythmias and increases theventricular fibrillation threshold. 1921 The inefficacy ofsympathectomy in most of our patients raises impor-tant questions regarding the pathogenesis of the syn-

drome. A mechanism other than congenital sympathet-ic imbalance may be operative in some patients. Forexample, the fundamental problem may be at themyocardial level, involving electrophysiologic mecha-nisms that are merely modulated, to an extent by neu-

ral activity.2' 24 In that case, empiric therapy with sym-

pathectomy may prove to be of limited value for somepatients with the long QT syndrome.

In summary, standard sympathectomy alone or in

combination with /3-blockers proved to be disappoint-ing in providing sustained relief of symptoms for mostpatients with the long QT syndrome. Neither changesin the QT interval nor Holter recordings were predic-tive of the clinical response. Limited experience withthe use of long-term atrial overdrive pacing for thosewho failed to respond with sympathectomy and hadsignificant sinus bradycardia appears to be promising.

The role of long-term atrial pacing or automatic inter-nal defibrillators without sympathectomy remains tobe determined.

References1. Vincent FM, Abildskov JA, Burges MJ: QT interval syndromes.

Prog Cardiovasc Dis 16: 523, 19742. Moss AJ, Schwartz PJ: Delayed repolarization (QT or QTU pro-

longation) and malignant ventricular arrhythmias. Mod ConceptsCardiovasc Med 51: 85, 1982

3. Schwartz PJ: The long QT syndrome. In Kulbertus HE, Wellens

1022 CIRCULATION

by guest on October 5, 2017

http://circ.ahajournals.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 6: Efficacy cardiac sympathectomy treatment with QT · 2017. 10. 5. · BHANDARIet al. after surgery (

THERAPY AND PREVENTION-ARRHYTHMIA

HJJ, editors: Sudden death. The Hague, 1980, M. Nijhoff, p 3584. Schwartz PJ, Periti M, Malliani A: The long Q-T syndrome. Am

Heart J 89: 378, 19755. Moss AJ, Schwartz PJ: Sudden death and the idiopathic long QT

syndrome. Am J Med 66: 6, 19796. Ratshin RA, Hunt D, Russell RO, Rackley CE: QT interval prolon-

gation, paroxysmal ventricular arrhythmia and convulsive syn-cope. Ann Intern Med 75: 919, 1971

7. Moss AJ, MacDonald J: Unilateral cervicothoracic sympatheticganglionectomy for the treatment of long Q-T syndrome. N Engl JMed 285: 903, 1970

8. Baudouy PH, Andreassian B, Attuel P, Greze M, Soulie J, Fru-chaud J: Syndrome de Romano-Ward et stellectomie gauchie: re-vue g6n6rale a propos d'un nouveau cas. Arch Mal Coeur 70: 645,1977

9. Chaudron J, Lebacq E: Romano-Ward syndrome treated by leftstellectomy and intracavitary stimulation. Am Heart J 100: 131,1980

10. Coyer B, Pryor R, Kirsch WL, Blount S: Left stellectomy in thelong QT syndrome. Chest 74: 584, 1978

11. Schwartz PJ: The idiopathic long Q-T syndrome. Ann Intern Med99: 561, 1983

12. Bhandari A, Shapiro W, Morady F, Shen E, Mason J, ScheinmanM: Electrophysiologic testing in patients with the long QT syn-drome. Circulation (in press)

13. Simonson E, Cady L, Woodbury M: The normal QT interval. AmHeart J 63: 747, 1962

14. Bazett MC: An analysis of the time-relations of electrocardio-grams. Heart 7: 353, 1920

15. Schwartz PJ, Malliani A: Electrical alternation of the T wave:clinical and experimental evidence of its relationship with the sym-pathetic nervous system and with the long QT syndrome. Am HeartJ 89: 45, 1975

16. Schwartz PJ: Experimental reproduction of the long Q-T syn-drome. Am J Cardiol 41: 374, 1978

17. Crampton R: Preeminence of the left stellate ganglion in the longQ-T syndrome. Circulation 59: 769, 1979

18. Yanowitz F, Preston JB, Abildskov JA: Functional distribution ofright and left stellate innervation to the ventricles. Circ Res 18:416, 1966

19. Schwartz PJ, Snebold NG, Brown AM: Effects of unilateral cardiacsympathetic denervation on the ventricular fibrillation threshold.Am J Cardiol 37: 1034, 1976

20. Schwartz PJ, Stone HL, Brown AM: Effects of unilateral stellateganglion blockade on the arrhythmias associated with coronaryocclusion. Am Heart J 92: 589, 1976

21. Schwartz PJ, Stone ML: Unilateral stellectomy and sudden death.In Schwartz PJ, Brown AM, Malliani A, Zanchetti A, editors:Neural mechanisms in cardiac arrhythmias. New York, 1978, Ra-ven Press, p 107

22. Bonatti V, Rolli A, Botti G: Recording of monophasic actionpotentials of the right ventricle in long QT syndromes complicatedby severe ventricular arrhythmias. Eur Heart J 4: 168, 1983

23. James T: Primary and secondary cardioneuromyopathies and theirfunctional significance. J Am Coll Cardiol 2: 1003, 1983

24. Brachmann J, Scherdag B, Rosenshtraukh, Lazzara R: Bradycar-dia dependent triggered activity relevance to drug induced multi-form ventricular tachycardia. Circulation 68: 846, 1983

Vol. 70, No. 6, December 1984 1023

by guest on October 5, 2017

http://circ.ahajournals.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 7: Efficacy cardiac sympathectomy treatment with QT · 2017. 10. 5. · BHANDARIet al. after surgery (

A K Bhandari, M M Scheinman, F Morady, J Svinarich, J Mason and R Winklesyndrome.

Efficacy of left cardiac sympathectomy in the treatment of patients with the long QT

Print ISSN: 0009-7322. Online ISSN: 1524-4539 Copyright © 1984 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved.

is published by the American Heart Association, 7272 Greenville Avenue, Dallas, TX 75231Circulation doi: 10.1161/01.CIR.70.6.1018

1984;70:1018-1023Circulation. 

http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/70/6/1018the World Wide Web at:

The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on

  http://circ.ahajournals.org//subscriptions/

is online at: Circulation Information about subscribing to Subscriptions: 

http://www.lww.com/reprints Information about reprints can be found online at: Reprints:

  document. Permissions and Rights Question and Answer information about this process is available in the

located, click Request Permissions in the middle column of the Web page under Services. FurtherEditorial Office. Once the online version of the published article for which permission is being requested is

can be obtained via RightsLink, a service of the Copyright Clearance Center, not theCirculationpublished in Requests for permissions to reproduce figures, tables, or portions of articles originallyPermissions:

by guest on October 5, 2017

http://circ.ahajournals.org/D

ownloaded from