effects of global economic crisis on mineral exploration
DESCRIPTION
Effects of Global Economic Crisis on Mineral Exploration. April, 23 rd 2009. Scope of presentation. Introduction – Votorantim Group and Votorantim Metais Irrational exuberance Metal prices Aluminum, Zinc and Nickel Industry Fundamentals Price forecast Capital erosion after crisis - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Effects of Global Economic Crisis on Mineral Exploration
April, 23rd 2009
Scope of presentation
1. Introduction – Votorantim Group and Votorantim Metais
2. Irrational exuberance
3. Metal prices
4. Aluminum, Zinc and Nickel Industry Fundamentals
5. Price forecast
6. Capital erosion after crisis
7. Exploration budget estimates for 2009
8. Opportunities on the new global scenario
9. Concluding remarks
Votorantim Group
60,000 EmployeesNet Revenue in 2008
US$18.7 BillionsRevenue Distribution -
2007
Metals 31%
Finance 26%
Cement 19%
Pulp & Paper 11%
Energy 5%
Agribusiness 5%
New Business 2% Chemicals 1%
4.05.1
6.4
9.7
13.3 15.6
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
18.7
2008
Integrated industrial conglomerate with 08 business, operating since 1918.
Among the largest zinc and aluminum producers in the world.
Among the ten largest cement producers in the World.
World leader producer in pulp and paper.
Second largest (non governmental) electrical energy producer in Brazil.
Started the internationalization process in 2001 with the cement business.
The metals division started internationalization in 2004 with acquisition of Cajamarquilla in Peru.
Votorantim is present in 15 countries with industrial operations in 07 countries.
Internationalization process is still active and is part of the growth strategy.
Votorantim Group – 8 Business in the Portfolio
Votorantim Metais
Exploration Offices: Brazil, Argentina, Peru, Bolivia, Colombia, Mexico and Canada.
Votorantim Metais – Business Units
ALUMINUM ENERGY
NICKEL ZINC
Integrated business from mining to smelting.
Three metals in the portfolio.
Energy generation to increase competitiveness.
Mineral exploration intense for the three metals with 12 advanced projects in the portfolio. Investments of US$85MM in 2008 and US$30MM in 2009.
Copper is the target metal for the near future.
ENERGY
* Data: 2008
12 ADVANCED PROJECTS IN 6 COUNTRIES
5 PROJECTS IN BRAZIL
7 PROJECTS ABROAD
CONTINUOUS INVESTIMENT IN MINERAL EXPLORATION
Acquisitions (US$ MM)Paraibuna (2002) 100
MSF (2003) 73
Cajamarquilla (2004) 210
Milpo (2005/2008) 288
Paz del Río (2007) 491
U.S.ZINC (2007) 295
Acerbrag (2007) Not released
Atacocha (2008) 145
Votorantim Metais main figures
Revenue (US$ Billions)
Revenue Distribution – 2008 Investments
(US$ MM)
AcquisitionsGreenfield projects & expansions
0.47 0.631.03
1.45
2.48
3.34 3.50
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
673
1,600
62157 158
244 270100
73210
100
786
333
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Aluminum 46%
Zinc 36%
Nickel 18%
Mining industry is complacent to cycling periods
“Clearly, sustained low inflation implies less uncertainty about the future, and lower risk premiums imply higher prices of stocks and other earning assets. We can see that in the inverse relationship exhibited by price/earnings ratios and the rate of inflation in the past. But how do we know when irrational exuberance has unduly escalated asset values, which then become subject to unexpected and prolonged contractions as they have in Japan over the past decade? And how do we factor that assessment into monetary policy? We as central bankers need not be concerned if a collapsing financial asset bubble does not threaten to impair the real economy, its production, jobs, and price stability. Indeed, the sharp stock market break of 1987 had few negative consequences for the economy. But we should not underestimate or become complacent about the complexity of the interactions of asset markets and the economy. Thus, evaluating shifts in balance sheets generally, and in asset prices particularly, must be an integral part of the development of monetary policy. “
Allan Greenspan
Metal prices 1989 – 2009 daily
-
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
8,000
9,000
10,000
J an-
89
J ul-8
9
J an-
90
J ul-9
0
J an-
91
J ul-9
1
J an-
92
J ul-9
2
J an-
93
J ul-9
3
J an-
94
J ul-9
4
J an-
95
J ul-9
5
J an-
96
J ul-9
6
J an-
97
J ul-9
7
J an-
98
J ul-9
8
J an-
99
J ul-9
9
J an-
00
J ul-0
0
J an-
01
J ul-0
1
J an-
02
J ul-0
2
J an-
03
J ul-0
3
J an-
04
J ul-0
4
J an-
05
J ul-0
5
J an-
06
J ul-0
6
J an-
07
J ul-0
7
J an-
08
J ul-0
8
J an-
09
-
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
Lead Zinc Aluminum Copper Nickel
LME - Forward 3 months
(Secondary scale)
Period of irrational exuberance
Today’s metal prices are in historical levels with unrealistic operational and project costs.
Metal prices return to 2004 scenario
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Jan
-03
Ap
r-03
Jul-
03
Oct
-03
Jan
-04
Ap
r-04
Jul-
04
Oct
-04
Jan
-05
Ap
r-05
Jul-
05
Oct
-05
Jan
-06
Ap
r-06
Jul-
06
Oct
-06
Jan
-07
Ap
r-07
Jul-
07
Oct
-07
Jan
-08
Ap
r-08
Jul-
08
Oct
-08
Jan
-09
Ap
r-09
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Copper
Nickel
Zinc
Aluminum
Lead
LME – Forward 03 months (US$x1000)
Hedge funds acting intensely in the metals market combined with strongly demanding
Chinese market.
Metal prices to date are leveled at historical averages of the early 2000 years or above.
In comparison to the years previous to 2003 nickel and copper are performing at considerably better prices.
Operation and project costs were drastically inflated recently cutting down margins.
This month, metal prices started climbing up, but fundamentals to support this recovery are very poor.
Metal prices apparently will stable in the present level and will not recover before clear signs of USA economy recovery.
Aluminum fundamentals indicate poor price recovery
ALUMINUM PRICE FORECAST (US$/)
Institution 2008 2009F 2010F 2011F
Barclays - 1,433 1,896 2,293
BMO Capital Markets - 1,698 1,984 2,425
Commerzbank - 1,653 2,094 -
Deutsche Bank - 1,367 1,477 1,742
Economist Intelligence Unit - 1,367 1,587 -
Societe Generale - 1,433 1,742 2,491
Standard Chartered - 1,499 1,742 -
UniCredit - 1,499 1,698 -
Westpac - 1,257 1,323 2,557
Average 2,557 1,467 1,727 2,302
Continued global demand weakness, particularly in aluminum intensive automotive and constructions sectors.
Lower raw material pricing significantly reducing marginal production costs.
Production cuts logging decline in demand globally.
~ 6 million tones production cut to date (50% Western producers, 50% China).
Lower production costs encouraging some to continue output.
LME inventories record approaching 4 million tones (10% of annual production).
Chinese Government intervening to pop up prices and protect domestic markets.
End-market demand expected to begin recovery in 2010, in line with global economic growth.
Substantial capacity overhang expected to limit meaningful price recovery over medium-term.
Aluminum
0
500,000
1,000,000
1,500,000
2,000,000
2,500,000
3,000,000
3,500,000
4,000,000
To
nn
es
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
US
$/tStocks
Price
Zinc fundamentals indicates poor price recovery
ZINC PRICE FORECAST (US$/)
Institution 2008 2009F 2010F 2011F
Barclays 1,345 2,403 2,998 BMO Capital Markets 1,433 1,874 2,205
Commerzbank 1,367 1,609 - Deutsche Bank 1,146 1,345 1,786 Societe Generale 1,213 1,521 1,742
Standard Chartered 1,190 1,323 - Westpac 1,058 1,080 1,543
Average
1,874 1,250 1,594
2,055
Zinco
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
300,000
350,000
400,000
To
ne
lad
as
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
4,500
US
$/t
StocksPrice
Continued global weakness in automotive and construction markets limiting demand.
Inventories continue to increase, currently at 413kt tones globally.
Global producers are reacting strongly, with 1.1 million-tones annual production cuts announced to date and an additional 300kt tones expected by end of 2009.
Timing of demand recovery in question given continued uncertainty in global galvanized steel market.
Market projected to remain in surplus through 2012 given supply rigidity.
Price recovery expected to benefit from potential concentrate shortage as permanent mine closures take effect in 2010.
Nickel fundamentals indeicates poor price recovery
NICKEL PRICE FORECAST (US$/)
Institution 2008 2009F 2010F 2011F
Barclays - 10,869 13,007 13,999
BMO Capital Markets - 12,258 15,432 17,637
Commerzbank - 12,919 17,394 -
Deutsche Bank - 9,634 9,921 11,244
Societe Generale - 10,031 12,632 14,506
Standard Chartered - 10,604 11,993 -
Westpac - 9,987 10,097 13,492
Average 21,010 10,900 12,925 14,176
Níquel
0
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
120,000
To
nn
es
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
US
$/t
Depressed global real estate, automotive, tool and appliance markets continue to limit nickel demand.
Majority of producers losing money at current price levels.
Supply rigidity has led to record inventories.
LME inventory higher than 100kt (highest since 1995).
Global producers are reacting with sizeable production cuts in 2009.
360kt annual cuts announced to date (25% of 2008 production).
Major expansion projects, particularly those with high production costs, being dalayed or canceled.
Market projected to remain in surplus through 2012.
Cash costs and operations globally – January 2009 scenario
NICKEL ZINC MINES
ZINC SMELTERS ALUMINUM
30% cash cost above price 40% cash cost above price
16% cash cost above price 70% cash cost above price
US$10,500US$1,100
US$1,100US$1,750
Price forecast indicate very slow recovery
ALUMINUM ($/t)ZINC ($/t)
NICKEL ($/t) WTI ($/barrel)
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
Source: LME (Mitsui Bussan), Bloomberg
Months
Market Capitalization Erosion
225.3
179.5 176.8
93.179.5
52.4
28.621.41
126.4
48.8
79.9
27.8 25.718
8.9 5.6
BHP Biliton Rio Tinto Vale AngloAmerican
Xstrata Freeport Alcoa Teck Cominco
US
$ B
illio
ns
-44%
-73%
-55%
-70% -68%-66%
-69% -74%
US$515 billions of capital erosion
Average erosion of 65%
The market cap in April 2009 is considerably better than some positions between this period.
Several Companies recovered part of the bottom erosion position of this period.
June 2008 April 2009
Source: Bloomberg and internal research in Companies information.
Budgets estimates for 2009 are substantially lower
455
326
247
240
225
180
153
115
110
89 85 85 84 80 74
63 57
53 50 49
39
34
28 28 27 26
25
20 20 15 14 8 5
334
334
240
170
75
155
95 100
100
112
44
30
48 56
10 40
18
65 54
17
0 20
34 14 10 18 11
25
5 15 8 14 12 11
BH
P B
illito
n
Va
le
Ne
wm
on
t M
inin
g
Fre
ep
ort
-McM
oR
an
Ba
rric
k G
old
Go
ldco
rp
Rio
Tin
to
Go
ld F
ield
s
Alro
sa
Po
lyu
s G
old
Min
ing
Vo
tora
ntim
Me
tais
Iam
go
ld
Ya
ma
na
Go
ld
FN
X M
inin
g
Ne
wcr
est
Min
ing
Sh
ore
Go
ld
Kin
ross
Go
ld
Ag
nic
o-E
ag
le M
ine
s
Fre
snill
o
Zin
ifex
Lu
nd
in M
inin
g
Ra
nd
go
ld R
eso
urc
es
Lo
nm
in
Firs
t Q
ua
ntu
m M
ine
rals
Co
eu
r d
'Ale
ne
Min
es
We
ste
rn A
rea
s
Ce
nte
rra
Go
ld
Pe
tra
Dia
mo
nd
s
Zh
ao
jin M
inin
g
Sin
o G
old
MA
G S
ilve
r
Ce
ntr
al A
fric
an
Min
ing
Min
ero
s
US
$ M
illio
ns
2008 Budgets
2009 Budget estimates
Budget estimates for 2009 indicate a minimum reduction of 37% base on research developed internally by Votorantim Metais team.
Only the Companies listed here represent a cut of US$1.15 billion.
Taking into account the reduction observed in the 33 Companies listed in the research, total World Exploration Budget would reach a maximum of US$9.2 billions against to US$13.9 billions in 2008.
For the coming years, taking into account, the effects of metal prices for the long term, total World Exploration Budget would return to levels of 2005-2007 in the order of US$5-8.0 billions.
Cash crunch in the TSE and ASX also indicate much lower levels of budgets for the next three years.
Copper and gold might have better scenarios for exploration for the next 03 years.
More positive scenarios for the mineral exploration sector will start in 2012 together with USA economy recovery.
Source: 2008 Metals Economics Group.
2009 estimates based on research develop by Votorantim Metais exploration team. Low level of accuracy is considered for this data.
Investments in mineral exploration in Brazil
Major 64.7%
Junior 33.4%
Intermediate 1.5% Government 0.4%
Gold 62%
Base Metals
17%
Diamond 15%
PGM 3%
Other 2%Uranium 1%
Base Metals 69%
Gold 23%
Other 7% PGM 1%
Company Class METAL Grass Roots Late Stage Mine TOTAL
Base Metals 71.70 88.20 19.20 179.10Gold 17.30 9.40 32.40 59.10Other 4.40 12.80 0.00 17.20PGM 1.30 0.00 0.00 1.30Diamond 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Uranium 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00TOTAL 94.70 110.40 51.60 256.70Gold 41.50 28.00 13.10 82.60Base Metals 9.70 7.60 5.20 22.50Diamond 7.70 10.30 1.50 19.50PGM 2.20 2.20 0.00 4.40Other 2.20 0.30 0.00 2.50Uranium 0.80 0.00 0.00 0.80TOTAL 64.10 48.40 19.80 132.30Gold 1.00 0.00 4.90 5.90TOTAL 1.00 0.00 4.90 5.90Base Metals 1.10 0.00 0.00 1.10Other 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.50TOTAL 1.60 0.00 0.00 1.60
GRAN TOTAL 161.40 158.80 76.30 396.50
GOVERNMENT
MAJOR
JUNIOR
INTERMEDIATE
CLASSES OF COMPANY JUNIOR INVESTMENT MAJOR INVESTMENT
Junior Company exploration market in Brazil is strongly affected and will remain for next 03 years.
Gold will be an exception to this cycle, but cash crunch will still affect Junior players.
Major Companies are cutting investments in Brazil, with Rio Tinto, Teck Cominco, and Xstrata reducing activities in the country.
The 2008 investment of US396.5 millions will reach at most of US$220 millions in 2009.
Opportunities in the new Global scenario.
The economic crisis is an excellent opportunity to improve your competitiveness cutting cost and increasing productivity.
A extremely aggressive/competitive and booming market in mineral exploration, in recent years, turned a large source of deals to improve future project pipeline.
It is time to improve the quality of your team. The shortage of people from the recent years turned into professionals surplus.
Improve your commercial relations to gain new markets.
Market will have to consolidate even more and to survive Companies must improve competitiveness.
Continues investing in training your team. That is the most valuable asset of the Company and will make things happen.
Increase and improve communication efficiency using your expensive remote conference system you already have and save costs.
Concluding remarks
Metal price cycle will become virtuous soon. Companies that improve efficiency in the crisis will take better advantage of it.
Recent reaction of metal prices is caused by China optioning to metals instead American Bonds (similar to Hedge Funds). Industry fundamentals does not support this price recovery.
Production cuts causing operation shut downs, project delays and cancellation will cause a shortage of metal when economy reacts.
Operations restart and project development takes long to happen and demand will not be supplied on time, once economy recovers.
Around 2015 or before another high price cycle might happen but will not last long.
Major Companies with cash are taken great advantage of the present crisis to create an excellent future project pipeline with Juniors insolvency.
Mining sector will consolidate even more, and this process will start along the coming years once the fog goes down.