ecs college graduate survey report final
TRANSCRIPT
1
EDELMAN INTELLIGENCE
Experian College GraduateSurvey Report
April 2016
2
WHO HOW MANY ACCURACY WHEN HOW
Soon-to-Be College
Graduates(College
students ages 18-25
graduating in the next 6 months)
n=1,000 Margin of Error = +/- 3.1%
Data Collection Occurred
April 11-19, 2016
Online Survey
RESEARCH OBJECTIVE: Better understand soon-to-be college graduates’ experiences, knowledge and
perceptions related to personal finance and credit and debt management
Research Methodology
3
Key Findings
Soon-to-be college graduates feel “stressed” and “worried” about their current financial status
They expect their financial stability to improve after graduation but still feel the odds are stacked against them
Majorities wish they had taken on less student loan debt and already expect to defer payments on student loans
Students say that their colleges did not prepare them to manage credit, and most have questions about credit scores
CURRENT FINANCE PERCEPTIONS
5
Many college students do not feel financially secure, driven by low earnings and reliance on student loans
Excellent Very good Good Fair
Current Financial Security
40%Rate their CURRENT
financial security as POOR/FAIR
Work study doesn't pay enough
Not earning any money
Not putting money into savings
Relying on my parents
Relying on student loans
14%16%
20%23%
36%40%42%42%43%
49%
Reasons for Current Financial Insecurity
Q3. Thinking about your life while enrolled in college, how would you rate your financial security?Q4: Why did you rate your financial security while enrolled in college as [poor/fair]? (Asked if rated current financial security as poor/fair; n=403)
6
Those with student loan debt are especially concerned about their current financial security
Subgroups More Likely to Rate their Current
Financial Security as “POOR/FAIR”
Subgroups More Likely to Rate their Current
Financial Security as “EXCELLENT/VERY GOOD”
TOTAL 40%
TOTAL 29%
Those with $20K+ in student loans
54% Those with no student loans 45
%
Those with any student loans 46% Those without any type of debt 44
%
Women 45% Men 34
%Those who do not know their credit score
45%
Those who do know their credit score
32%
Q3. Thinking about your life while enrolled in college, how would you rate your financial security?
7
Q14. In general, how do you feel about your current financial status? Q15. Which, if any, of the following issues are you worried about? (Asked if worried about current financial status; n=330)
Students feel stressed and worried about not having enough money and being reliant on others or loansEmotions about Current Financial Status
EmpoweredInformedConfident
SecureSatisfiedHopeful
8%16%17%18%
20%31%
ConfusedHelpless
FrustratedOverwhelmed
WorriedStressed
13%16%
26%30%
33%37%
Current Financial Status Concerns
Having bad creditNot establishing a credit history
Spending beyond my meansNot being able to stick to budget
Carrying too much debtFinancial dependence on parents
Not having enough to spendNot earning enough money
Not having enough in savings
30%30%
35%38%
50%52%
63%63%
70%
FUTURE FINANCE PERCEPTIONS
9
* Nets may not add up due to roundingQ1. In general, how do you feel when thinking about your life after graduation? Q3. Thinking about your life while enrolled in college, how you would rate your financial security?Q5. Thinking about your life after graduation, how do you anticipate rating your financial security?
Students are excited about life after graduation and expect their financial security to improve
Financial Security Pre- and Post-Graduation
Pre-Graduation
Post-Graduation
11%
5%
30%
22%
30%
34%
17%
23%
11%
14%
Poor Fair Good Very good Excellent
Emotions about Life Post-Graduation
40% POOR/FAIR*
27% POOR/FAIR
10
College major and amount of student loan debt are factors in graduates’ feelings of future financial security
Q5. Thinking about your life after graduation, how do you anticipate rating your financial security?
Subgroups More Likely to Rate their Future Financial Security
as “POOR/FAIR”
Subgroups More Likely to Rate their Future Financial Security as “EXCELLENT/VERY GOOD”
TOTAL 27% TOTAL 37%Those majoring in social sciences / services 34% Those majoring in business 44%
Those with $20K+ in student loans 34% Those majoring in S.T.E.M. 44%Those who do not know their credit score 33% Those who do know their credit
score 43%
Private university graduates 32% Those with no student loans 42%
Women 30% Those majoring in health and medicine 42%
Those majoring in arts & humanities 29% Men 40%Those with student loans 29% Those with < $20K in student loans 39%
11
Q6. Why do you anticipate rating your financial security after graduation as poor/fair? (Asked rated current financial security as poor/fair; n=267)Q7. Which of the following best describes where you are in your employment search? (Asked if planning to get a job after graduation; n=844; Shown off total base)
Student loan debt is a major concern among those who feel insecure about their post-graduate financial status
Reasons for Post-Graduation Financial Insecurity(Shown: Top 10 Reasons for Rating Post-Graduation Financial Security as Poor/Fair)
Will have to pay off other debt May need to take out additional loans
No high-paying jobs for my degreePlan to continue my education post-grad
May have to move back homeMay not earn enough to support myself
May not earn enough to spend beyond basicsMay not earn enough to add to savings
May not have a full-time job lined upWill have to start paying off my student loans
25%25%25%27%
31%47%47%
52%54%55%
Just 16% of soon-to-
be graduates
already have a job lined up
12
53%47%
Financial Perceptions(Shown: % Agree)
Despite general optimism, many feel that achieving financial security will be an uphill battle
Q18. To what extent do you agree or disagree with each of the following statements? Q19. What life goals do you think your finances will hold you back from pursuing after graduation? (Asked if agree that finances will hold back from pursuing life goals after graduation; n=468)
Changing careers
Starting a businessGoing back to school
Getting marriedHaving children
Buying a car
Traveling the worldBuying a home
25%
32%38%
39%41%
50%
59%63%
Life Goals Hindered by Finances
13
Ultimately, many are hopeful about their financial future, but worried about salaries and loan payments
Concerns about Financial FutureEmotions about Financial Future
Q16. Generally, how do you feel when thinking about your financial future?Q17. Which, if any, of the following issues are you worried about? (Asked if worried about financial future; n=270)
Protecting my identity
Being able to establish good credit
Saving enough money to retire
Being able to own a home
Becoming financially independent
27%43%45%
53%55%
61%66%66%68%
73%
FINANCIAL SNAPSHOT
15
Q21. Below is a list of different types of loans and debts. Please indicate whether you currently have any of the following.Q22. To the best of your knowledge, approximately how much debt do you currently have…? (Asked for each type of debt held)
Student loans are the most pervasive type of debt for soon-to-be graduates
Student Loan Debt
Credit Card Debt
Auto Loan Debt
Home Loan Debt
Other Type of Debt
Currently Have 69% 30% 23% 12% 6%
Average Amount
$22,813 $2,573 $10,37
9$36,39
8 $6,771
16
Familiar Heard the term Unfamiliar
Q28. Prior to this survey, were you familiar with the concept of co-signing? Q29. To the best of your knowledge, have you ever needed a co-signer for any of the following types of contracts? Please select all that apply.
Many college students have personal experience with cosigning, specifically for student loans
77%Familiar with co-signing
Cosigning Familiarity
Home loan
Legal agreement for credit card
Car lease
Car loan
Home/apartment lease
Loan for tuiton
9%
12%
16%
22%
26%
30%
Personal Cosigning Experiences
68%Have
needed a co-signer
17
Q23. Which of the following statements comes closest to your opinion?Q25. In general, how concerned are you about paying back your debt? (Asked if have debt; n=838)
College grads are split on whether being “debt free” is attainable; most are concerned about loan payments
Debt Perceptions Concern about Repaying Debt
72%Concerned
about paying
back debt
53%Being “debt free” is an attainable goal
47%Debt is a
necessary evil
In today’s economy…
VS.
Those with < $20Kin student loans:
69%Those with $20K+in student loans:
81%
18
Q27. Which, if any, of the following concerns about debt are a source of anxiety for you personally? (Asked if have debt; n=838)
They worry about about how long they will be paying back their debt and potential impacts on their future
My debt will hold me back from getting another loan
My debt will hold me back from continuing my education
My debt will hold me back from starting a family
I don’t fully understand all of my payment options
My debt will negatively affect my credit score
My debt will hold me back from making a big purchase
I will be paying back my debt for a long time
31%
31%
32%
33%
42%
47%
59%
Concerns about Debt
Those with $20K+ in student loans:
60%
19
Most wish they had taken out less in student loans, and more than half are likely to defer payment
Student LoanPerceptions
Likelihood to Defer Student Loans
54%Likely to
defer student loans
43%I am
comfortable with the
amount of my student loan
debt
57%I wish I had taken on less student loan debt
Q33. Which of the following statements comes closest to your opinion? (Asked if have student loans; n=690)Q32. How likely are you to need to defer payment on your student loans? (Asked if have student loans; n=690)
VS.
74% among those with $20K+ in student loans
20
Q33. Which of the following statements comes closest to your opinion? (Asked if have student loans; n=690)Q32. How likely are you to need to defer payment on your student loans? (Asked if have student loans; n=690)
Those getting a degree in business or S.T.E.M. feel most comfortable with their student loan debt
Placeholde
r
Arts & Humaniti
es
Social Sciences
& Services
Health & Medicine S.T.E.M. Business
n=124 n=165 n=136 n=157 n=184Likely to
Defer Student Loans
52% 71% 53% 50% 52%Comfortable with Student
Loan Debt34% 39% 38% 53% 49%
Wish I Had Taken on Less in Student Loans
66% 61% 62% 47% 51%
21
Personal Experiences with Credit
Cards
Q20. Please indicate how many credit cards you currently have. (Shown: % Have at least one credit card; Mean number of credit cards)Q31. On average, how much do you charge to credit cards (not debit cards) each month? (Asked of credit card users; n=578)Q32. Which, if any, of the following have you ever experienced regarding a credit card in your name? (Asked of credit card users; n=578) Q30. When you sign up for a credit card, which of the following best describes how you interact with the Terms & Conditions? (Asked of credit card users; n=578)
Credit card spending is another main source of debt for soon-to-be college graduates
Missed a payment
Had card declined
Maxed out a card
Made a late payment
15%
23%
31%
33%
Approach to Credit Card Terms and Conditions
15%
46%
39%
Read entirelySkim terms then accept
% Have a credit card
58%Average number of credit cards
1.35Average monthly charges
$531
CREDIT & DEBT EDUCATION
23
Q9. While you were enrolled in college, how would you rate your…?
Students feel that colleges provide them with subpar opportunities to learn about credit and personal finance
Excellent Very good Good Fair Poor
48%Rate their access to
information on credit & finance as POOR/FAIR
Access to Information about Credit & Personal
FinanceExcellent Very good Good Fair Poor
50%Rate their
opportunities to learn about credit
& finance as POOR/FAIR
Opportunities to Learn More about Credit &
Personal Finance
24
Q12-13. Which of the following sources have you used in the past for information about personal finance/credit & debt management? Q18: To what extent do you agree or disagree with each of the following statements? “When it comes to my finances I feel like I’m going it alone.”
Instead, they look to their parents or search engines for this information; many feel they are “going it alone”
My parentsAn internet search
FAFSA My friends
A bank representativeA mobile application
My spouse / significant otherA financial advisorMy social network
My coworkers
70%45%
39%38%
27%21%21%
17%16%16%
55%27%
17%23%
20%13%15%
11%12%
11%
Credit & Debt Info
Information Sources(Shown: Top 10 Information Sources)
Agree Disagree
55%When it comes to my finances I feel like I’m going it
alone
Finance Perceptions
25
Q8. Next, we would like for you to grade your college or university on a few attributes. For each of the following, please give your college a grade, from A-F, on how well you think your college prepared you for…?
Knowing how credit scores work
Managing credit & debt
Managing a personal budget
Life after graduation
21%
20%
20%
32%
22%
26%
32%
35%
21%
25%
26%
23%
15%
15%
12%
6%
19%
12%
9%
2%
College Report CardA B C D F Median
Grade
B
B
C
C
One in five college grads gives their college an “F” on preparing them to understand how credit scores work
26
40% 38% 38%31% 29%
26% 24%21%
31%25%
34%29%
36%41%
37%
27%
Learned about in college… Wish I had been able to take a college course in…
Q10. Which, if any, of the following topics did you learn about in college?Q11. Which, if any, of the following topics do you wish that you had been able to take a college course in? (Asked for each subject not learned about in college)
Students have an appetite for college courses on credit scores, reports and overall management
Teaching Financial Literacy in College(Shown: % Learned in College, % Wish I had Learned in
College)
27
I understand which financial factors are currently helping or hurting my credit
My credit history could affect my ability to get a good interest rate
I have questions about the different types of credit scores
My credit history could affect my ability to get a loan
I have questions about what my credit score means
69%
67%
67%
65%
59%
Credit Understanding Statement Agreement(Shown: % Agree)
Q38. Below is a series of statements about credit. To what extent do you agree or disagree with each of the following statements?
While they may overstate their credit savvy, most acknowledge they have questions about credit scores
28
Q35. To the best of your knowledge, have you ever seen your…?Q36. Do you know your credit score? Q37. And, do you think your credit status is…?
Most soon-to-be grads have never seen their credit report and do not know their credit score
Credit score Credit report
37%46%
58%43%
11%
Yes No Unsure
Ever Seen CreditScore or Report
PerceivedCredit Status
8%
24%
29%
21%
10%7%
Excep-tionalVery goodGoodAverage
Yes No Unsure
47%Know their credit score
Know TheirCredit Score
DEMOGRAPHICS
30
Category Subcategory %
GenderMale 40%
Female 60%
Age
18-19 8%20-21 26%22-23 37%24-25 29%
Region
Northeast 20%South 36%West 22%
Midwest 21%
Race/Ethnicity
White 63%African American 14%Hispanic/Latino 11%Asian American 7%
Other/Multi-racial 5%
Category Subcategory %
Know Credit ScoreYes 47%No 43%
Unsure 10%
Perceived Credit Score
Exceptional 8%Very good 24%
Good 29%Average 21%
Poor 10%Unsure 7%
2-Year vs. 4-Year College
2-Year 29%4-Year 71%
Public vs. Private College
Public 72%Private 26%Unsure 2%
Anticipated Graduation Date
In the next 3 months 62%In the next 4-6
months 38%
Student Loan Debt
Yes 69%No 31%
DemographicsRespondent Demographics
Totals may not add up to 100 due to rounding
THANK YOU