economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · evaluation of grass available for...

33
.,· New Technic.al -Basis for Et.imination.-of BWR RPV Circumferential Wel:d lnspectio·ns (BVVRVIP-329) [ C~©$ed ~e$$~(0)ITil] Wayne Lunceford ·and Nathan Palm EPRI, BWRVIP NRC Public Meeting May 29, 2019 W in f WWW. e pr j C O m © 2019 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved. '·_,, ; '.:, ': . ·, . ' , 1 ! ' : l ' •i ' , r '·l ·;- , ~' ~~-1211 ELECTRIC POWER -=·- _- RESEARCH INSTITUTE

Upload: others

Post on 07-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission © AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013

SME Farm DK

Thure and Susanne Worm

SME Farm IE

Economical evaluation of feeding

costs in pilot farms at grazing

F. Lessire – I. Dufrasne

University of Liège

Page 2: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Economical evaluation of feeding

costs in pilot farms at grazing

• How to evaluate ingested grass?

Evaluation of grass available for the cows

Evaluation of grass ingested by the cows

Page 3: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Evaluation of grass available for the cows

• Estimation of grass height

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

June - Grass Height: measurements in/out

In

Out

Page 4: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Evaluation of grass available for the

cows

• Estimation of grass cover

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

1800

May June July August September

Grass cover (kg DM/Ha)

Série1

Page 5: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Evaluation of grass available for

the cows

• Door opening at 6 AM

• Distribution TMR: 6 PM

• TMR = 13 kg DM

(without conc.)

• In average:

4 kg conc./cow/day

Parcel Kg DM /cow/day

1 5,71

2 8,33

3 5,80

4 3,30

5 4,05

Mean 5,4

Page 6: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Evaluation of grass ingested

How much grass ingested?

22 kg DM*– DM TMR – DM concentrates = DM

ingested grass

*: reference value based on feed consumption

in winter

Page 7: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Evaluation of grass ingested

DM TMR DM TMR +

conc Grass

ingested? % grass

April 17,2 21,9 0,1 0,5%

7/5/2013 - 17/6/2013

12,6 17,2 4,8 22%

17/6/2013-16/7/2013

11,7 15,5 6,5 30%

17/07/2013-22/8/2013

13,2 17,2 4,8 22%

22/8/2013-16/9/2013

13,7 16,9 5,1 23%

17/09/2013 15,6 18,7 3,3 15%

October 17,9 21,1 0,9 4%

Page 8: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Feeding costs

• 2 methods for estimation:

Addition of costs of TMR + concentrates (1)

Addition of costs of TMR + concentrates +

grass production (2)

Page 9: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Feeding costs

Method 1 Method 2

Forages Compensation wildlife

Compensation wildlife

Other feeds (wheat, corn, alfafa, …)

Accountancy Accountancy

Concentrates Accountancy Accountancy

Grass - % of grass valorised for grazing cows

% applied to costs (seeds, fertilizers, energy, lease,..)

Page 10: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Feeding costs

Feeding costs method 1 et 2

Month TMR

(kg DM) 1 2

4 17,2 5,58 5,59

5 12,6 4,87 5,16

6 11,7 3,52 3,92

7 13,2 3,84 4,13

8 13,7 3,73 4,03

9 15,6 3,67 3,87

10 17,9 4,02 4,07

0

0,02

0,04

0,06

0,08

0,1

0,12

0,14

0,16

0,18

0,2

4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Month

Feeding costs (€/kg milk)

calcul 1

calcul 2

Page 11: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Feeding costs: comparison of 2 pilot

farms

0

0,02

0,04

0,06

0,08

0,1

0,12

0,14

0,16

0,18

0,2

May June July August September January

Feeding costs (€/kg lait) in relationship with % grass during grazing

90% grass

30% grass

Page 12: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

© AUTOGRASSMILK, 2013 FP7-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK is co-funded by the European Commission

Conclusion

• Calculation methods require a good

evaluation of

TMR

Quantity,

Refusals,…

Animal

Behaviour!

Pasture

Refusals

Palatability?

Page 13: Economical evaluation of feeding costs in pilot farms at ... · Evaluation of grass available for the cows Parcel • Door opening at 6 AM • Distribution TMR: 6 PM • TMR = 13

The research has received funding from the European

Union’s Seventh Framework Program under Grant Agreement

FP/-SME-2012-314879-AUTOGRASSMILK