DUSEL Development Process:

The Roadmap from Science & Engineering Plan to the Facility Description

Lee PetersenCNA Consulting Engineers

Nov 2004

What is “infrastructure”?

• Traditional definition:– Grouping of science & engineering functions

into modules– Sequence, expansion, reuse– Excavations, systems & services to support

science• But “infrastructure” also includes:

– Site characteristics necessary for conducting science & engineering

Nov 2004

Site Characteristics for Research

EXPT DEPTH SIZE WET TEMP LITHOLOGY FRACTURED WATER CHEM

MINE-BACK PRISTINE HETEROGEN COMPAT-

IBILITY

BIO- STIMULATION ANY 20M Y AMBIENT + ANY EITHER OLDER Y/BH Y Y ALL - 2CLOUD PHYSICS MICROGRAVITY ANY .5 - 1 KM Y AMBIENT - ANY EITHER NA N NA NA ?AQUIFER DYNAMICS & TRANSPORT DIFFERING M- KM Y AMBIENT + ANY Y ANY LIMITED EITHER Y ALL - 2HYDROCARBON DEEP KM Y AMBIENT + SED PREF. Y ANY Y Y Y 1,3,4ROCK MASS MECHANICS ALL 100M Y/N AMBIENT + ANY Y ANY Y EITHER EITHER ALL - 2ORE DEPOSIT DEPENDS KM Y CONTROLLED ANY EITHER ANY Y Y EITHER ALL - 2THERMAL TEST DEEP 100M+ Y CONTROLLED ANY Y ANY Y Y Y ALL - 2MINING EXTRACTION TECHNOLOGY ANY KM Y AMBIENT ANY EITHER DILUTE Y EITHER EITHER 1,6,4FRACTURE PROPOGATION DIFFERING 10- 100M Y/N AMBIENT ANY EITHER ANY Y EITHER EITHER ALL - 2CARBON MANAGEMENT DEEP KM Y AMBIENT ANY Y ANY Y EITHER Y ALL- 2,6

Nov 2004

Technical Requirements Matrix

ExperimentDepth /

Shielding (mwe)

Space, area or volume (m^2 or

m^3)l*w*h unless

specified

Radon Background (mBq/m^3)

Occupancy Hazardous Materials Crane Chilled Water Ventilation

Stable Temp.

(A/C Reqd.)

Electrical Power (kW)

"Clean" Areas(class)

General solar neutrino2500 to

4500 500 to 27000 m^3 <10 to < 1Flammable gases, cryogenic liquids (Ne, He, N)

300

MOON >2500 11x8x6 10 Toxic, flammable liquids/cryogens

80 Yes

LENS >3800 16x16x16 1 Fammable scintillation materials

250 Yes

HYBRID 7000 80x18x19 None None Modest No

HERON 4500 7m radius, 20m high cyl. None Large volume cryogens 600 Peak, 125 Avg.

Yes

CLEAN 4500 4.5m radius, 20m high cyl. None Large volume cryogens 100 Avg. Yes

Nov 2004

DUSEL Development Sequence

• Develop Science & Engineering Research Plan• Collect Technical Requirements

– Site character, grouping, sequence & infrastructure)• Identify Primary TR

– Top ten list• Identify TR Relationships

– Synthesize top ten list• Relationship Matrix

– Illustrates compatibilities and incompatibilities• Relationship Diagramming

– Illustrates spatial relationships

Nov 2004

DUSEL Development Sequence

• Develop Science & Engineering Research Plan• Collect Technical Requirements

– Site character, grouping, sequence & infrastructure)• Identify Primary TR

– Top ten list• Identify TR Relationships

– Synthesize top ten list• Relationship Matrix

– Illustrates compatibilities and incompatibilities• Relationship Diagramming

– Illustrates spatial relationships

Nov 2004

DUSEL Development Sequence

• Develop Science & Engineering Research Plan• Collect Technical Requirements

– Site character, grouping, sequence & infrastructure)• Identify Primary TR

– Top ten list• Identify TR Relationships

– Synthesize top ten list• Relationship Matrix

– Illustrates compatibilities and incompatibilities• Relationship Diagramming

– Illustrates spatial relationships

Nov 2004

DUSEL Development Sequence

• Develop Science & Engineering Research Plan• Collect Technical Requirements

– Site character, grouping, sequence & infrastructure)• Identify Primary TR

– Top ten list• Identify TR Relationships

– Synthesize top ten list• Relationship Matrix

– Illustrates compatibilities and incompatibilities• Relationship Diagramming

– Illustrates spatial relationships

Nov 2004

DUSEL Development Sequence

• Develop Science & Engineering Research Plan• Collect Technical Requirements

– Site character, grouping, sequence & infrastructure)• Identify Primary TR

– Top ten list• Identify TR Relationships

– Synthesize top ten list• Relationship Matrix

– Illustrates compatibilities and incompatibilities• Relationship Diagramming

– Illustrates spatial relationships

Nov 2004

Relationship Matrix

Nov 2004

DUSEL Development Sequence

• Develop Science & Engineering Research Plan• Collect Technical Requirements

– Site character, grouping, sequence & infrastructure)• Identify Primary TR

– Top ten list• Identify TR Relationships

– Synthesize top ten list• Relationship Matrix

– Illustrates compatibilities and incompatibilities• Relationship Diagramming

– Illustrates spatial relationships

Nov 2004

Relationship Diagram

BOR

WAITING ROOM

DRESSING ROOM

DRESSING ROOMMIKVAH POOL

BOR

PARKING AREA AND TRASH

LAUNDRYSTORAGESTORAGE

J. C. VESTIBULEVESTIBULE J. C.J. C.

FUTUREDRESSINGROOM

FUTUREDRESSINGROOM