dr dina fisher md, msc, frcpc nar iuatld chicago march 2018 - dina fisher nar2018df (1).pdf · 38...

28
Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018

Upload: others

Post on 10-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC

NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018

Page 2: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent

IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

assessment

Pregnancy was complicated by◦ Premature rupture of membranes

◦ Oligohydraminos

Presented to hospital with new onset seizures

Page 3: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic
Page 4: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic
Page 5: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic
Page 6: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic
Page 7: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Urine smear positive and culture positive for fully-

susceptible mycobacterium tuberculosis

Sputum smear negative, culture positive for fully

susceptible mycobacterium tuberculosis

Started on standard TB treatment/steroids with good

clinical outcome

Page 8: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic
Page 9: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Infant born at 24 weeks gestation

Treated for congenital TB without culture confirmation

Multiple complications with 14 month hospitalization

Page 10: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Sharma 2015, J Obst Gyn India

15-20 % of cases of EPTB are GU TB

◦ Fallopian tube involvement (90%)

◦ Endometrial dysfunction (50-70%)

◦ Ovarian dysfunction (20-30%)

10-85 % are infertile (40-60%)

Page 11: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Sharma 2015, J Obst Gyn India

Attending Infertility Clinics

◦ 1 % in United states

◦ 3 – 26 % High incidence TB countries

◦ 48.5 % tubal factor infertility in high incidence countries

Page 12: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Several studies have failed to identify history/physical

exam findings that differentiate between TB and non-TB

causes of infertility

Page 13: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Older, small studies in TB endemic countries have

demonstrate high yield of menstrual fluid sampling for

mycobacterial culture

Margolis et al 1992, SAMJ

Page 14: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Consider diagnosis based on diagnostic imaging

abnormalities, specifically tubal involvement

Consider diagnosis based on hysteroscopy/laparoscopy

appearance

Page 15: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Sharma 2015, J Obst Gyn India

Page 16: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Sharma 2015, J Obst Gyn India

Page 17: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Sharma 2015, J Obst Gyn India

Page 18: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Sharma 2015, J Obst Gyn India

Page 19: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Neelam et al 2005, J Obst Gyn India

Page 20: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Infertility Clinic India (endometrial and laparoscopic)◦ 40% diagnosed on histopathology

◦ 16% diagnosed on AFB smear

◦ 40% on mycobacterial culture result

◦ 50 % on PCR result

Radhika et al 2016, J of Obstet and Gynaecol

Page 21: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Al eryani et al 2015, Alexandria Medical Joural

Page 22: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Variability in incidence of FGTB

Lack of data in best testing/screening strategy for FGTB

Invasive diagnostics to obtain confirmed diagnosis

Treatment of FGTB does not lead to improved fertility

and may delay IVF-ET treatment

Page 23: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

CDC2015 Report ART

Page 24: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Neelam et al 2005, J of Ob Gyne India

Page 25: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

ASRM ( American Society for Reproductive Medicine)

◦ No comment on investigations for FGTB

◦ No role for routine hysteroscopy/laparoscopy/endometrial biopsy in the assessment of the

infertile female

IFFS (International Federation of Fertility Societies)

◦ Test for infectious diseases associated with infertility

FIGO (International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics)

◦ Test for infectious diseases associated with infertility

ICMR (Indian Council for Medical Research)

◦ Consider hysteroscopy/laparoscopy and sampling for MTB

ESHRE (European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology)

Page 26: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Flibotte et al 2016, J of Periton

Page 27: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Better data to inform recommendations

Need to consider pre-test probability of FGTB when

developing guidelines◦ Difficult to develop international guidelines that are applicable to

all countries

l

Page 28: Dr Dina Fisher MD, MSC, FRCPC NAR IUATLD Chicago March 2018 - Dina Fisher NAR2018DF (1).pdf · 38 year old female from SouthEast Asia underwent IVF/ET after standard infertility diagnostic

Who to Screen◦ Individuals from high TB incidence countries

◦ Tubal factor infertility

How to Screen◦ Limit invasiveness of testing

Number needed to screen to detect one case of FGTB

Cost of Screening◦ In many countries cost of infertility treatment is borne by infertile

couple and not included in public-payer systems

l