![Page 1: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Warped Penguins
Based on arXiv:1004.2037In collaboration with Csaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo
CornellUniversity
LEPP Particle Theory Seminar
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 1 / 32
![Page 2: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Why are Penguins important in RS ?
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 2 / 32
![Page 3: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Randall-Sundrum in one slide
ds2 =
(Rz
)2 (dx 2 − dz2
)Randall, Sundrum (99);
Davoudiasl, Hewett, Rizzo (99); Grossman, Neubert(00); Gherghetta, Pomarol (00); Bulk Higgs: Agashe, Contino, Pomarol (04);Davoudiasl, Lille, Rizzo (05)
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 3 / 32
![Page 4: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Randall-Sundrum in one slide
Gauge Boson
ds2 =
(Rz
)2 (dx 2 − dz2
)Randall, Sundrum (99); Davoudiasl, Hewett, Rizzo (99);
Grossman, Neubert(00); Gherghetta, Pomarol (00); Bulk Higgs: Agashe, Contino, Pomarol (04);Davoudiasl, Lille, Rizzo (05)
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 3 / 32
![Page 5: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Randall-Sundrum in one slide
Gauge Boson
Fermion
ds2 =
(Rz
)2 (dx 2 − dz2
)Randall, Sundrum (99); Davoudiasl, Hewett, Rizzo (99); Grossman, Neubert(00); Gherghetta, Pomarol (00); Bulk Higgs: Agashe, Contino, Pomarol (04);Davoudiasl, Lille, Rizzo (05)
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 3 / 32
![Page 6: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Flavor changing & the wavefunction overlap
4D Yukawa Coupling: Y ij∗ Li HEj ×fLi
(R ′)
fEj(R ′)
4D Gauge Coupling: gii Li 6ZLi ×∫ R′
Rdz(
Rz
)4
fLi (z)fZ (z)fLi (z)
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 3 / 32
![Page 7: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Before we proceed,
Two assumptions for an interesting model:
Mkk is not too heavy. Give me a number! Mkk ∼ 3TeV.
⇒ Can be seen in LHC!
Y ij∗ are ancharic, O(1) numbers.
⇒ No tuning is required!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 4 / 32
![Page 8: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
FCNC from the loop & tree
µ→ eγ:
µ eγ
µ eγ
∝ Y 3∗
µ→ 3e & µ→ e:
e
ee
zµ
z
eµ
∝ Y −1∗
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 5 / 32
![Page 9: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
The opposite Y∗ bounds
For Y∗ ,
e
ee
µe
µ
gives a lower bound.
µ e
γ
µ e
γ
gives an upper bound.
Constraint Y∗ from both sides!
Want to get the precise bounds!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 6 / 32
![Page 10: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
The opposite Y∗ bounds
For Y∗ ,
e
ee
µe
µ
gives a lower bound.
µ e
γ
µ e
γ
gives an upper bound.
Constraint Y∗ from both sides!
Want to get the precise bounds!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 6 / 32
![Page 11: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Tree level constraints from
e
e
eµ
e
µ
K. Agashe, A. E. Blechman, and F. Petriello, hep-ph/0606021.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 7 / 32
![Page 12: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
The origin of the flavor changing
Taking the zero mode Z as an example, the nonuniversal partof the wave function h(0)(z) near IR gives the flavor changing,
Wave function:
h(0)(z) =1√
R ln R ′/R
[1 +
M2Z
4z2(
1− 2 lnzR
)]
Gauge coupling:
gzfi fj = gzSM
[1 +
(MZ R ′)2 ln R ′/R2(3− 2c)
fi fj
]The γ′ and Z ′have the similar form.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 8 / 32
![Page 13: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
The Yukawa bound
The tree level result,
Br (µ→ 3e) ' 10−13(
3TeVMKK
)4( 2Y∗
)2
Br (µ→ e)Ti ' 2 · 10−12(
3TeVMKK
)4( 2Y∗
)2
Comparing to the experimental bounds,
Br (µ→ 3e) < 10−12
Br (µ→ e)Ti < 6.1 · 10−13
The µ→ e gives the most stringent bound (for MKK = 3TeV).
Y∗ > 3.7
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 9 / 32
![Page 14: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
µ→ e γ in a warped XD
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 10 / 32
![Page 15: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Warped penguins
Warped Penguin looks weird...They live in 5D.Previous analyses suggestedthe brane Higgs case islog-divergent.
e
γ
µ
H
Mi
People thought they are divergent because of the KK sum.
Want to do a full 5D calculation to check thefiniteness!
Can show µ→ eγ is finite!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 11 / 32
![Page 16: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Warped penguins
Warped Penguin looks weird...They live in 5D.Previous analyses suggestedthe brane Higgs case islog-divergent.
e
γ
µ
H
Mi
People thought they are divergent because of the KK sum.
Want to do a full 5D calculation to check thefiniteness!
Can show µ→ eγ is finite!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 11 / 32
![Page 17: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
µ→ e γ in 5D
The diagrams of µ→ e γ:
Get the leading order result by doing mass insertions.
Rotate all the flavor mixing to the Yukawa.
It is an L-R operator: a LσµνFµνE
From the gauge symmetry:
εµMµ ∼ εµu ( pµ + pµe − (mµ + me)γµ ) u
To get a, we only need to calculate the coefficient of pµ.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 12 / 32
![Page 18: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
µ→ e γ in 5DThe diagrams:
µ e
γ
µ e
γ
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 13 / 32
![Page 19: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
The Result
The result of the amplitude can be written as follows:
ak`×R ′2e
16π2v√2
(fLi Yik Y †k`Y`j f−Ej
)L(0)
i σµνE (0)j F (0)
µν
The loop integral gives ak` ' 0.5.
Br(µ→ e γ)thy > 8.2 · 10−7a2„
3TeVMKK
«4„Y∗2
«4
Br(µ→ e γ)exp < 1.2 · 10−11
for Mkk = 3 TeV, we have
Y∗ < 0.2
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 14 / 32
![Page 20: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
The Yukawa bounds
There is a tension between the two bounds!
Y∗(µ→ e) > 3.7 Y∗(µ→ e γ) < 0.2
To release the tension:Make MKK heavier. MKK ∼ 10 TeVGive some structure to Y ij
∗ .Introduce some symmetry to suppress the FCNC.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 15 / 32
![Page 21: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Custodially protected model
K.Agashe, R.Contino, L. Da Rold, and A. Pomarol, hep-ph/0605341.M.E.Albrecht, M.Blanke, A.J.Buras, B.Duling, and K.Gemmler, 0903.2415.
Introducing a custodial symmetry for leptons
SU(2)L × SU(2)R × U(1)X × PL,R
This model gives:γ, Z , γ′, Z ′ & ZH .The coupling of Z , Z ′ to the LH fermions becomes flavoruniversal.
The LH FCNC is suppressed.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 16 / 32
![Page 22: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Custodially protected model
K.Agashe, R.Contino, L. Da Rold, and A. Pomarol, hep-ph/0605341.M.E.Albrecht, M.Blanke, A.J.Buras, B.Duling, and K.Gemmler, 0903.2415.
Introducing a custodial symmetry for leptons
SU(2)L × SU(2)R × U(1)X × PL,R
This model gives:γ, Z , γ′, Z ′ & ZH .The coupling of Z , Z ′ to the LH fermions becomes flavoruniversal.
The LH FCNC is suppressed.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 16 / 32
![Page 23: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Custodially protected model
This reduces the Y∗ bound to
Y∗ > 1
Y∗ > 3.7 for the non-custodialcase.
StrategyMake the RH leptons towards UV.Make the LH leptons towards IR.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 17 / 32
![Page 24: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Custodially protected model
This reduces the Y∗ bound to
Y∗ > 1
Y∗ > 3.7 for the non-custodialcase.
StrategyMake the RH leptons towards UV.Make the LH leptons towards IR.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 17 / 32
![Page 25: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Tension between the two bounds
It’s not enough...
Y∗(µ→ e) > 1 Y∗(µ→ e γ) < 0.2
A mild tension still exists.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 18 / 32
![Page 26: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Very interesting detail for the 5D loops!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 19 / 32
![Page 27: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
The fermion propagator in 5D
(−/p + iγ5∂5 + m
)∆(p, z , z ′) = iδ(z − z ′)
Trick: (p2 − ∂2
5 + m2)
F (p, z , z ′) = iδ(z − z ′)
∆(p, z , z ′) =(/p − iγ5∂5 + m
)F (p, z , z ′)
In flat XD case:
F (p, z , z ′) = A(p, z ′) cos(p z) + B(p, z ′) sin(p z)
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 20 / 32
![Page 28: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
The chiral BC
The chiral BC constraints the form of the amplitude!
ψR
χL χL/k
ψR
ψR/k
D−F+
χL ψR
ψR/k ′
D+F−
χL
χL
ΨL =
(χLψL
)ΨR =
(χRψR
) ∆ =
(∆ψχ ∆ψψ
∆χχ ∆χψ
)=
(D+F− σµpµF+
σµpµF− D−F+
)
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 21 / 32
![Page 29: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
How to calculate the 5D loop?
Feynman’s trick with Bessel functions?? We don’t know that...
However, we can
Tayler expand the propagator into powers of the external
momentum (pµ, qµ). 1(k 2 + 2k · q)
=1k 2
„1− 2k · q
k 2 + ...
«.
Isolate the pµ terms. Get the coefficient. /pγµ = 2pµ − γµ/p.
Solve the numerical integral, get the coefficient of µ→ e γ.a × R ′2
e16π2
v√2
“fLYY †YfE
”u/εu; a =
ZdxZ
dy (scalar function).
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 22 / 32
![Page 30: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Why is µ→ e γ is finite?Lorentz invariance + chiral BC gives the finiteness:
The propagators are composed of two partsThe Dirac operator part (gives the γµ structure).
The Bessel function part (contains the 5D profile).
In the UV limit, the photon vertex is pulled back to the IR brane.Can just look at the Dirac operator part.
Each loop contains two sectors:
photon emission
mass insertion
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 23 / 32
![Page 31: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Why is µ→ e γ is finite?
γ emission: Lorentz inv + chiral BC gives(/kγµ/k − k 2γµ
)mass insertion: The chiral BC gives /k .
Combining the two m-insertion amp, the leading order becomes
M(a) +M(b) ∼ /k(/kγµ/k − k 2γµ
)+(/kγµ/k − k 2γµ
)/k = 0
From NDA, only the leading order term can be divergent.
µ→ e γ is finite!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 24 / 32
![Page 32: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
5D V.S. KK
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 25 / 32
![Page 33: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
The KK result should be the same as 5D
The mass matrix:
M =
m11 0 m13
m21 MKK,1 m23
0 0 MKK,2
In the mass basis, the Yukawa takes the form (ε = m/MKK )
y ∼
1 1 + ε −1 + ε1 + ε · · · · · ·1− ε · · · · · ·
M∝ (1 + ε)(1 + ε) + (−1 + ε)(1− ε) ∼ ε
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 26 / 32
![Page 34: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
The KK result should be the same as 5DFor the finiteness:
In the mass basis, naive NDA givesM∝ M−1KK . The Yukawa
gives additional ε = m/MKK and ensures finiteness.
⇒M∝∑KK
1
(MKK )2
In the MKK basis, treat m as the mass insertion. The chiral BCeffect becomes obvious.
e
γ
µ
H
MiψR
γ
χL
H
ψR χL
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 27 / 32
![Page 35: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
The KK result should be the same as 5DFor the a value:Do the momentum integral to infinity and sum the KKs.
M =N∑
n=1
∫ ∞0
d 4k M(n)(k )
The leading order result is
M∝ 1(MKK )4 !?
which is different from the 5D resultM∝ R ′2 !
5D 6= KK !?
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 28 / 32
![Page 36: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
The KK result should be the same as 5DFor the a value:Do the momentum integral to infinity and sum the KKs.
M =N∑
n=1
∫ ∞0
d 4k M(n)(k )
The leading order result is
M∝ 1(MKK )4 !?
which is different from the 5D resultM∝ R ′2 !
5D 6= KK !?
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 28 / 32
![Page 37: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
The KK result should be the same as 5D
The reason is,
Wrong UV limit!To match the 5D & KK, the momentum cutoff . KK cutoff.
The correct way of doing the sum and the integral is
limN→∞
N∑n=1
∫ N MKK
0d 4k M(n)(k )
This gives the same leading order contribution ∝ M−2KK as in 5D.
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 29 / 32
![Page 38: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
The 5D & KK results do match!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 30 / 32
![Page 39: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Outlook & Conclusion
One loop µ→ eγ for brane Higgs case is finite.
The bulk higgs is also finite.
How about the finiteness for higher loops?
A tension between the tree-level & loop-induced Yukawa bounds.
Only having the custodial symmetry is not enough.
Need some structure on Y∗.
How about b → sγ?
The nontrivial UV limit for KK is important for mathcing the 5D.
Does this happen in other loop-induced processes?
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 31 / 32
![Page 40: Warped Penguins - Cornell University · 2010. 5. 14. · Warped Penguins Based onarXiv:1004.2037 In collaboration withCsaba Csáki, Yuval Grossman, Philip Tanedo Cornell University](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022071402/60f18f6e35077c79ef5dbc96/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
A long journey for Warped Penguins...
Yes, we worked very hard!
Yuhsin Tsai, Cornell University/LEPP Warped Penguins 32 / 32