© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Dr Sama Bilbao y LeonHead of the Division of Nuclear Technology Development and Economics
Nuclear Energy Agency (NEA)
16th INPRO Dialogue Forum on Opportunities and Issues in Non-Electric Applications of Nuclear Energy
12-14 December 2018, Melia Vienna, Austria
Use of Nuclear Energy for Non-Electric ApplicationsSummary of OECD NEA Activities and Findings
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
NEA: A forum for co-operation
Helping Governments Address Global Challenges
• To assist its member countries in maintaining and further developing, through international co-operation, the scientific, technological and legal bases required for a safe, environmentally sound and economical use of nuclear energy for peaceful purposes.
• To provide authoritative assessments and to forge common understandings on key issues as input to government decisions on nuclear energy policy and to broader OECD policy analyses in areas such as energy and the sustainable development of low-carbon economies.
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Global CO2 emissions have continued to grow
Source: OECD/IEA
Global energy-related CO2 emissions
CO2 emissions
Increase in 2017
5
10
15
20
25
30
35Gt CO2
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Even though renewable generation has steadily increased
Source: OECD/IEA
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
• Low carbon electricity to play a key role in future energy markets– Electrification of transportation – Electrification of the industrial sector– Electrification of buildings (heating/cooling)
• New narrative: Decarbonization of electricity markets– All fuels and all technologies – Energy efficiency– Carbon capture utilization and sequestration (CCUS)– Storage– Nuclear power– Yet, renewables (Wind and Solar) are expected to lead
• New challenges– Need for improved infrastructures to ensure interconnectivity – Need flexibility - interconnectivity is not enough– Need market mechanisms/signals to invest in new flexibilities & capacity– Large level of coordination in policy and regulation
Future of energy markets: Integration
Graphic: Courtesy of EPRI
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Nuclear power plants can be flexible …
Courtesy of Électricité de France (EDF)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
11/07/2008 30/08/2008 19/10/2008 08/12/2008 27/01/2009 18/03/2009 07/05/2009 26/06/2009 15/08/2009
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
18/12/2008 19/12/2008 20/12/2008 21/12/2008 22/12/2008 23/12/2008 24/12/2008 25/12/2008 26/12/2008 27/12/2008
Courtesy of Électricité de France (EDF)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
11/07/2008 30/08/2008 19/10/2008 08/12/2008 27/01/2009 18/03/2009 07/05/2009 26/06/2009 15/08/2009
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
18/12/2008 19/12/2008 20/12/2008 21/12/2008 22/12/2008 23/12/2008 24/12/2008 25/12/2008 26/12/2008 27/12/2008
Power history of a sample French PWR reactor
Whole cycle 10-day period around Christmas
Source: EDF and OECD/NEA
Fresh WaterDistrict
Heating
Industrial
HeatHydrogen
… but need revenue when not producing electricity
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Attribute Sub-Attribute Benefits
Operational Flexibility
Maneuverability Load following
Compatibility with Hybrid Energy Systems and Polygeneration
Economic operation with increasing penetration of intermittent generation, alternative missions
Diversified Fuel Use Economics and security of fuel supply
Island OperationSystem resiliency, remote power, micro-grid,
emergency power applications
Deployment Flexibility
Scalability Ability to deploy at scale needed
Siting Ability to deploy where needed
Constructability Ability to deploy on schedule and on budget
Product Flexibility
Electricity Reliable, dispatchable power supply
Industrial Heat Reliable, dispatchable process heat supply
District Heating Reliable, dispatchable district heating supply
Desalination Reliable, dispatchable fresh water supply
Hydrogen Reliable, dispatchable fresh water supply
Radioisotopes Unique or high demand isotopes supply
Expanded Concept of Flexibility for Future Nuclear Reactors
Source: Adapted from EPRI
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Summary of Recent OECD NEA Work
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
• Findings and Recommendations:
– If the potential of non-electric applications of nuclear energy is so high,
why has its deployment been so limited?
– Limited data, market information, technology assessment not
comprehensive preliminary findings & recommendations.
1. Need to understand better the markets & increase communication with
stakeholders
2. Establishing a interest group (with links to developing countries/markets)
3. Depending on demand (distributed vs. centralised), nuclear technology
solutions will vary (small (modular) reactors vs large units). Nuclear energy
sector needs to be involved in the development of “end applications”.
4. Need for demonstration projects.
5. Competitiveness of non-electric products is essential
6. Involvement of governments & international co-operation
Non-electricity products of Nuclear Energy (2004)
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
• Proceedings of 4 Information
Exchange Meetings:– 2000, 2003, 2005 and 2009
– 2009: Contents:
I. Programme Overview
II. High-Temperature Electrolysis
III. Thermochemical sulphur process
IV. Thermochemical copper chloride and calcium
bromide processes
V. Economics and market analysis of
hydrogen production and use
VI. Safety aspects of nuclear hydrogen production
Nuclear production of Hydrogen (2000-2009)
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
• Nuclear H2 production – a utility perspective. (US Utility Entergy)• Belief that HTGR can compete with fossil fuel for process heat supply, and that
nuclear H2 production can become competitive on the bulk market (with respect to
steam methane reforming)
• Interest of Entergy also related to fact that its NPP sites are located near existing H2
pipeline infrastructures.
• Market assessment for process heat applications justify further RD&D
• BUT commercial viability nuclear H2 production still unclear (lack of specificity in cost
and economic modelling) uncertainties in investment and O&M cost assumptions
AND operational & deployments risks.
Economics and market analysis of hydrogen production and use
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 12
2015 IEA/NEA Nuclear Technology Roadmap on nuclear cogeneration
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 13
Enhance security of energy supply
Improve energy (fuel) efficiencies
Reduce CO2 emissions and air pollution
Minimize heat losses (2/3 heat wasted in current
nuclear steam cycles)
(non-nuclear) CHP since long applied in
many industrial sectors
Why nuclear cogeneration?
Potential in 4 areas: (i) desalination (ii) district
heating in residential/commercial areas (iii) industrial
process heat (iv) fuel synthesis (e.g. Hydrogen)
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Application Level of maturity Possible new projects & recent activity
Challenges
District Heating Demonstrated at industrial scale & currently operating (Russia, Switzerland, …)
Option for future new build in Finland or Poland, feasibilitystudies in France for coupling existing NPPs to DH systems
Differences between electricity & heat markets. Economic assessment.
Desalination Tested at industrial scale in the past (BN-350)Small small scale applications in NPPs to supply fresh water to plant
Huge needs in the future (projects in the MENA region: Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia)
Complexity and scale of investments in water infrastructures.Public acceptance?Long term?
High temperature process heat
Demonstrated at industrial scale for low temp. steamapplications.
R&D HTR and cogeneration
NHDD project in Korea “clean steel”, NGNP Alliance & EU’s NC2I collaboration, PolandSynthetic fuel production
Business model (nuclear operator industrial application operator)Licensing, safety, public acceptance, Long term
Hydrogen production
Demonstrated at lab scale for thermochemical cycles (HTTR) and HTE
NHDD in Korea, HTTR in Japan, on-going R&D (Gen IV)
Hydrogen economy?Competition with electric mobility?
Nuclear hybridenergy system
R&D on low carbon energy systems involving nuclear & variable renewables
Assessment of services provided by nuclear (electricity, storage, heat)
Economic assessmentLong term prospects
14
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
NEA Nuclear Cogeneration Activities
15
April 2013 – the joint NEA and IAEA workshop on the technical and economic assessment of non-electric applications of nuclear energy (http://www.oecd-nea.org/ndd/workshops/nucogen/)
November 2014 – the NDC supported an activity to assess the role and economics of nuclear cogeneration in a low carbon energy future NEA Programme of Work
Objective and Scope• To develop a methodology for assessing the economics of nuclear cogeneration and to
identify major challenges (technical, economic, regulatory and societal) that the development/deployment of nuclear cogeneration face (and the costs to overcome these).
• The methodology to assess the costs and benefits of cogeneration processes should be generic as much as possible, to be applied to various applications (district heating, desalination, high temperature applications, hydrogen production) and to various nuclear reactor technologies (LWR, HTR etc.).
• The benefits of the reduction of GHG emissions from nuclear cogeneration will be assessed.
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Experts Group• The first meeting was held on the 30 June-1 July 2015 at the NEA Headquarters.
Representatives from Canada, Czech Republic, Finland, France, Hungary, Poland, Korea, Slovenia, and the United States as well as the International Atomic Energy Agencyattended the meeting.
• The 2nd meeting was held on 3-4 February 2016 at the OECD Conference Centre.
Representatives from Canada, Finland, France, Japan, Poland, Slovenia, Turkey (observer), the United Kingdom and the United States as well as the International Atomic Energy Agency and International Energy Agency attended the meeting.
• The 3rd meeting was held on 22-23 September 2016 at the NEA in Boulogne.
Canada, Finland, France, Hungary, Japan, Korea, Poland, Russian Federation, Slovenia,Spain (observer), Switzerland and IAEA (new members)
Sent their apologies: Czech Republic, United Kingdom, United States, IEA
16
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Overall summary
▪ Proven record of operating non-electric applications of NE (district heating
& desalination)
▪ In other areas, feasibility studies, lab scale or prototype testing exist – but
no significant industrial experience
▪ Overall efficiency & economics of NE can be improved by developing &
selling non-electric products.
▪ Also benefit in terms of reduction in GHG emissions (but needs to be
quantified)
▪ Indications that markets for non-electric products exist
▪ But work needed:▪ economic modelling
▪ licensing issues, safety considerations
▪ operational issues
▪ assessment of hybrid systems involving NPPs and RES, with NPPs operating
at full power, producing electricity & other products
▪ lack of information to general public & decision-makers
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
District Heating
18
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Process Heat (chemical, oil, bio-refineries, H2)
19
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Desalination
20
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 21
SAFETY
ECONOMICS
PUBLIC
ACCEPTANCE
SUSTAINABILITY
Key factors for nuclear cogeneration success
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Conclusions (1)
▪ Over 750 reactor-years of non-electric applications of nuclear
energy– though not always in a commercial / liberalised
market environment.
▪ Selling commercially both electricity and non-electric
products remains a challenge. Some economic assessment
tools exist but standardised methodologies for non-electric
applications missing.
▪ Significant development of non-electric applications of nuclear
energy are not expected in the short to mid-term, especially
if/where fossil-based alternatives (gas) remain cheap.
▪ Carbon constraints / pricing will help improve the
competitiveness of nuclear cogeneration
22
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Conclusions (2)
▪ Cogeneration:
o Can improve the overall efficiency of NPPs;
o Opens different streams of revenues to operators
(economic assessment)
o Has a potential to play in future low carbon energy
systems, where nuclear would provide electricity & storage
through production of fuels.
▪ New issues associated with this flexible mode of operation
would need to be addressed (safety, operational, licensing)
▪ Work needed to provide information to general public and
policy makers
23
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Ongoing Work
• “On the role and economics of nuclear cogeneration in a low carbon
energy future”
– Report expected early 2019
• “Advanced reactors and future energy market needs”
– A workshop involving industry stake-holders (including from the grid, storage and
renewable technology sectors) - 2-3 April 2019
– Final meeting of Expert Group - 4-5 April 2019.
– Target report by end 2019.
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
• Funded by Voluntary Contributions
• Preparation and publication of the annual
Mo-99 Demand and Capacity Projection
report series
• Coordinate communications among the
current members of the group should the
need arise
• Follow-up work & analysis on the joint HLG-
MR & OECD Health Division project of
Medical Uses and Full Cost Recovery
High Level Group on Medical Radioisotopes (HLG-MR)
25
© 2018 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Thank you for your attention
Follow the NEA