@®® @a:>o:> em:;0o:>
a© 6313@ @e5)) e+:;;;:5'.:D'.:)F.j':,.(f;;'i'.:.E:,r'-" §c)arn
O)e5)<2:i)@J @0ffi.
0acl63@c:.5251 C0-©x>Z:5X)WZ5)J000®c:.52:51 e) Z5J
a1�c010cl0 c0J §{wJm®O c1�0 §{w ....,...,_,..__,...,_,,.,, Be a®J<tztle;®, wb'® va1...1·=...., :£36® �015) fi®-©ii@. Be0cl @Z5)Z5)� e;@O e3 @c:.5J
cn63eJ@® ®c0ti20 - �Z5) §6® c0J 025) 0ti26Jb'C5 e5Z5):25c:.5ztl q0®6.>::fw :£36®
@c:.5J02:51 ®J c0c) e,OZ5)J6 �®d Z5)lZ5)·
gefo w®@OZ5)25J d'0@ztl 0c0ztl®d' <yZ5)J
e;aZ5)0 Z5)() ®<t25J Q)e)z:5:>, �e)ztl @JCJG)c:.5 e.'.:lJ(§'c:.5:JG:'5Z5'cJ filJe)Z5)J Ool5) Oe)z:5:>e)Z5) Q)e)z:5:> qa::>, �25)2:51 "�2:5:f®roZ5) roJ0Z5)J ®w:25-ddJZS)c:.50" ro®c:.5®.
®::> �63 b<mJ 0Z5J e30cl, e,25:f 0c0ztl@d'
Z5)() §)Q),&.
@®e5c:.5 @15) 63§ ®0®(3::>902:5:f ®02518®25:f,
�' Z5)lclZ5)@ Qo�J0cl � ? WO®C::>90 wo®e19®e) � Z5)1ti12.S)@ ei© Qo�J0 q1cl®cl wc:.5
� ?" e,2510c0251®d' gcrl'Z5J Z5)®@ c:.5. ®�c:.5cl 2.S)l'-°l - Clc:.5 @2.S)®Q q1£ eDti:nJ (5.)7.�®cl o�-®:nc;;:;.
@®@cBztl@, e,ztl0c0ztl@cl®c:d qZ5) @oztl0®ztl,
�c:.52.S) Qo�Je) £®ii?)�®� ®�J®'° �. Ow rl'lO\','>HWJ l:5"\@e,)J.25"'1
<;:, Z5)1cl2.S)@ Oc:.5 Wc:.5 qw ®en Sm �@ �ra;,,,-,;'X"\
�wZ5) o�, Q@�£ Qm�wcl o©-®nS, Ow Qo(�Jl;:.J� ....,/,,.JJ,.,, ......
@63CCJ qm clob'� �®@: Z5)lcl25)@, qmcl �@
0�®� 2.S)l'-°l· � �QJ qm i£w�®� �� ©:>znS� -e;cl� QoQ�JOwcl o®-®nS."
c5®@cl ob� 0t5YJ0c) �e)l �
wb'® ®{GaZ5)J02:5:f @0-©iic:.5 Z5)()25)
iii
©�Gd25X)©VZ5) e3cl25:lO ZS)b Z5)0l� qo@GJ ae325:l c03 qe)c) ©(:;:)ZS)(.3
o®m (S)b03 ac3, VV3©c5 025)J525:l3Vc.3 ©Z:530l® C0l253®o cmm�e.)25)
ctli:53 ZS)®@ czrl0c0m®cl ®GJ 6® wb® ®�Gdm3v a. wb®c.3 ®ZS)®o63
@8mcl r.§3-8�3 @ZD3 §3� ��w3e);:5) @®m® cm8c0m@cl @25)@063ctl§3 � qo5®25:l e5:)25)§3c.33�0 ©C0<o08c.3Bm � 8�e) ®® 6�3 O©c025)
8ocl0 q3@8®.
§�oeh©xim e)c0m@cl OeD 6�3 e)l€) Bu Oo-e0 OZ:532::Dc.3, OoclZ5)30
Z53@od'wc.3o oclvm q3Z5)3o@d wb®c.3 @�GdZD3 ZS)OZD e3o, @a3@c0d'
@�m25Jo 33b83-©xi38@ad'w BB®o rolB ®c.3. e3emJS25:l38C5 @c0d'
z§3e)mc) ©c.33� e.)25) g3@C5:)(0ZS) @3()(0C5 ©c0@ ©O©c0@ ZS)O@m
Z5)02t) cam wb®e5m �8-©xic.5 BB®o qvclo38 c� ®c03cl, q�
fjv�, ®ZS)z:D25Jo 330m 90 ®® a®25:l®d�® qcl s65®o c0lB 02t3
ctl25:l.
00925)25:l 3)Z5)3@d "q3&" E@®d @®@cl s;:5) @®. "§�w m3-825:l �. ml�ol �, ml�ol qbo ctlcl25:l3 �, Z53b83-©xi ouoo9m25:l �. C3ez:DJ525:l3 OCJ-e3o8Z:5325:l � ( = filVZD c03 C3ez:DJ525:l3VC5 c03 o@Q)zrlw)
wb®c.3m ®�Gd25)3 25)025) ®o, t!Jv30 ctl�® ZS)@ ®25)3 ®�m 63�m 0c0m®cl (qc.5) qm3C025:l®d � Bu2t3 ctl25:l. 6®o ovlzs3 wb® ®�Gd25)3
qm25:lbw3m vm®m C5."
6@rocl, ge.fo w®®625:lm cl83@zrl 8c0m@cl @m [email protected]@ZS) wb®
©�Gd25)3 qom e3o, tje)lfil wb® ©�Gd25)3 25:)e)@ q�ol�c025) e5
©ZD3®l§3 Q)e) ©ZS)z:D25JO qv@ad'w 82t3 ctl25:l.
ao825)25) 3)Z5)3®d "ZS)cloZS) E@C5" czrl0c0m®cl ®cl25:lo 25)025) ®o, tJ a0 ®o 925)]5� ®c.3. 8Gdvcl§3 @30 �vJS [email protected], §�o�m c0�0
@®@cl 9Z5)3Gd ZS)©@c.3.
"ctl-e5 ©®en, dto ©®en, €h:sf§-e5®�d'-e5e5 ©®en, 0:d§-e5®�d'-e5:>e5�zne5
©®en. ®�J®W zn® ®cmd' �a ©®cnzrl cnl@®0zrlzn t;: ?, "�� ©®en, a:iQ)c;; ®®en ....... , zn:>-e5C5 ®®en, cn� 90� ®®en ............. , �0 ®®en,
6-e5 ©®en ......... , �'5 ©®en, ®OJQQQ)a (�e5c) d'oba:i 0zn ®�€:le)
iv
e'3 ,-,'-<r'-<hcJl-c)
ZSll 2.5), li)o)c) d O:�®WW
ey�6acl ?.5)0 63§ (yi5Xl CSYi®61 'cc0® ?.5)01 � file5J51 DC5 ©e5Ji5)25)
0�@C5zrl' �s-®i>C5 BB®a @e53a25:>:> ®?;S)JcJ, DC5 �s-®i>C5 BB®a
8C586 m63®. @®® @a:>ZS) D@�ZS)�@zrl' D@c:;8£3.
©(:;3?.5)C5J aoo �:Bzrl' �'c8J, £3825:>cJ acl ?.5)08:>{3@ e5�c0J
czrl'0c0zrl@d'a £3�25) QJ8 e1@cD8:>, £3@61&3 w:>8C5 e1@Ql8:>, czrl'
8c0zrl'@d' 01®'c:> 98acl @e58:> !
@®® g-®i>:25 @C5:>®e5 ��e �25)63@d' QJe;@e5zrl' ®:>@m @e5 @e5
®'c®:>8C5zrl'acl; czrl'0c0zrl'@d' c0�e'J®a ca?.5):>o ?.5)@ oa0cli5)
®1&e5zrl'acl; c�® 'cc0® ®m C5:>®a 25)25) q96zrl' ca?.5):>o ?.5)()25)
®@m ©e5J86C5 8'56:>cJcl; £38zrl' ®cs:, m®zrl (S)Z5)25)J 8C5� ®'c25)JC)Z5)
(yZS)@&zrl@ £38zrl' 98 qcl@e58J !
q2t)6:>w @g®6cl25:>
63/2, 96@:25 @J8i5),
8cl@cl@m'c6 a:>6,
®c06m®.
�0?.5)025)C5 : 94 11 2 843062
E-mail : [email protected]
vi
2:5}[i5:l.
G20-t0dc:2:5:)cl ro:1, aem:5)@d -e3®rod £3-8e)Z5)c)e)25') 8@�0Z51 @25)3 2:5)@Z51
® &C;J """"'=''"'1""'"' @®Z5)c) -e.3@325) �t:iDC5�:::U 25)<.eDC:, @® a@w §@&25)@25) @®:125) 33i:.5)J@d <=;: ? " £3wJ qr8@. c2:5:)e)ro25)@-d -825):JS "@®C5 ®ro:1 C5J2:5)@d ,�,��� E@C5Z51" wl8 al0S w. ®eDJC,5:)25) GY[ 25) C5@ '-'Yd''-'v1.;.;1.,.,11.,.;J
vii
- @(S)J@ - ®®i:.5)625) ®a, d
� ®@GJ
(g)ZS):J c5a0cl Z5)eJ @e.5@25) q1.£3 "Gentling the (by Myokyoni)*
25.'r[®l§ ©e.5:Ji5) 09 �25)25) §e3e)25) ®a, o@ q1.£3 Z5)e) 0G qc5oe3
@Z5)i5)(5@ C01.�d1.s8 @c) q0@6)1w ®C3. Boroe e.5:JOZ5)C3m @m
g@C31aZDC3 a�ro:J o® Z5)eJ0G @clc51.® Boro@em (3C3:J, o 8g6)�0
qc5o Z5)0ZDC325) @oc50:J� a®g�3e3c) q�Z52G 0ZD 06� ro:J ®@m qcl siB5® e.5:J�Z5) 25)(5 @CDZD ce3@c) q�rod' @25)@@®. o@rocl @®C3 Z53B@d'cl ® o60CJZ5)25)(,325) @25):) ©eJ. o@d'® o® qbo 25)025)(,3 c0:J @e.5:JZS) qZS)d §B® a®@mwi5):JeJC325) � ZD1.i5).
g:J@C3j@Z5) qcls£!5® e@:J ZD1.£3, @oc50:J� ©C3£J® C07.ZD q0@@jWC,325)
25)7.£3 qe3c) @®@ qbo Z5)025)C3 oc09@8m @clc51® C01.m@a @25):J c01§ ®@a eg,u q7.ZS). o@rocl "aZS)J5 wc5®C3" �@ @oc50:J� - ®ro::>C3:JZD
0oc5C3:J25) cp� ©eD� ®�m@:J25) @25):) e)25) @0 @clc51® G)i5) c01§ 0�
q1.i5). 2530ZD 25):Jc)cl @e.5:J£JC3. @oc50:J� q:J� 025) 025) @Z5):JcJO:JGaC325)
"q@25)25) 00:Jc) e)e):) OC3 cad C31.8" BZS):J CD253@m ce.5:J�:)25) 25)()
@(025) Bc5@® §B® -e5:JW:Jc5-®:o @e)z;s:) ZD1.ZS). t
eg,o@@ ©e.5:J@i5) s25)@e)25) Z5)e) ©e.5@ c0:J 8mZ5Jc5 e'3 q::>25):J()@(,325) @ @®@ q1�@cl §6® a�ro:J, GoUm @am ®wJ5d'O:J25)@C3m q0ao CD:53@. o® d'o:JZDC3c) � @®@ 8aoi5)25) C37. ®C3 8� 253a:J, @®@ Bo roe
@25):Jc)@d q1£3 0::>Z5):is0e qbo c07.§ 5)0@ 5da e'3 q::>Z5):Jc5@C3m ®s25)@0ZD o� OC3 o50c5Z5)ZDC3 @25)@@®. Boroe @25):Jc)@d q0e3:J25)@d,
eg,o@@ Z5)e) ©e.5@5), 80Z5J()5), q0ac5 e@:J �@® <38C35) q1�@5) ©eJ.
@®® q0ac5C3 e@:J £im @az:rl ®o:isd'o:JZDC3c)cl, @®@ ®s-®:o ®C3�®
sc51 gZ5):J(QZ5) - ®roc5CD® q�c5:JW @g®dclZD @c0i5):JQ5) ®@m q0oZ5) dZ5J:53C3 9� Z5)(5@.
�z:rlZ5)z:rl@< w®@c5i5)25) @@
2007 - ®Z5)@i5)j@CJ
* @®® ©0:Jti) @025) @w:i.sd'cl:J25:>c5 58 ®:JCQ)@Qj ©O©�O, coB251 NW8 OPL
(525) (3825:>@(52.5) e3Q):J (025) w·u::s).f @660:J� §� �w® e0125:> ®c0:Jc5:J25:>, 0e30c5:J25:> cp�Z5:I' Q)e3Z5:\'@Z5:I' 25)0@25)
q0ti)ZS)@d'd1063m. o® mo:J oc.5 "6325:>c5:J25:>" 25:i@Z5:I' ®.8� w�Z5:1'0£3. ®i:0:Jc5:JID25)
efc.5 <:j:ti)cl � ocl025:> @®® ©O:J©tD @®c.5 O�i:0Z5:l 25)@@ o® mo:J c.5.
viii
@®&3 o@-�@02:rl @ �25)03 q1cl@d
Cyo@B ©B3©Z5) 1§3� Z5:leJ ©O@,Z5:l '-J.,....., .. ,,, .........
tD3®3@0zd CDC:> GXl®�.
cJc) qb'd Z5:l025)C3 qo@CD ® ...,..,'-,, . ...., ... IJ...., CDCJ q3 e3Gi@c'(.Q25)C3�. e'.)e3 ,_,,,""",_,J .... h, �@25) a®-&. eJd:5)6 0e,g@e3zd
@®C3 cv®a 25)®, q6cS:>cl 6cC3 �25)03 �@025)3 ®cS:>cl ©03:5)25) cv®c:>
Bs @eJ. 0:>Z5:l:i.s@C32:rl 0n5):i.sC3a sg@0czd o® qb'o m6-io�C3
©CD3t:5 en_:5). '-"-''"'""'·..,.,__, 6d'
0nsns� 6�c) ...,y.,1,.u...,,.,, �-
ix
�G.2 ®w Z5)5)0ZS) w25) @GJ:Je5GCJ, @m 8c3, -6@wcl �25)c) @25)J @e.5@25)25) @G)'.)25)'.) @E1'.lc.5C:.5. cn5)c) �e5e)25) ZS)tG)lc) cS)'.) @cS)
WJOJ0251 GJoGJJ qz.5)6251, ®J05) @25)'.) @a@25)25) �§aw ® �@08. Ql(325) Ql(325) 5)125) 0@��� <=;: <=;:25)25)c) @25)'.)
@15). @0@w8251, @oJeJ251 wa �� 0�c) o0d 81@025) @GJJ251®251 @eJCJ@eJ q1@02:D@ZD dc.018wz:D @m 25)J<=;:w a®&.
@5)025) @25)'.) @e.5@25)25) ne>lM",rr\rC, &c®ZD, @G)Je5GCJ <y�6wa ® -6@wcl @GJ aJ �25)c)@cl @e) @GJ:J@WJOZS) -66 q1§ &0 0� �255 <=;: ? 6301 &10 w25) 012:D<=;:l wJ@®, w®J -625) E8�1§E@@m 0� @GJJae'.J f?J5)w @ZS)Z,5)0® 25)@ 0Jo GJ�25)25S qo1cl EZD0 ql5)c) ql5)c) e,5'.)e) e,5'.)e) @G)'.)e.5 q1cl <=;: ?
@CJO®ro@d ®CD wie:.�J·®:DZ::i) � @25)J ®1§ Z5)(3, @ZS)J@ro 25)@ '-'-''--'''--''-'-'.! <=;: ? ®o �e) @G)Je.5 �25) &\;;® ®1�, 0'[25)
@00@25)63 @<=;:aJ a� 25)1§8 0-z.@u. @25)'.) ��0cl0 ® �0 �, @G)'.)25)'.) @m 25)'.)0w qGCJ @GJ25), 0� q�cl5)� @CBZD
a1®@-©:6. GJo <g,�01 o®a 6125S @00@25)63, GJoGJJ 0-z.G 5)(3J ®w:is@d @<=;:::>oZS)JOw 25)10@025) E) @GJJae'.J @5)w @ZS)Ja®� 25)@ @Gc):)ZS)'.)25)e)5) <=;: ?
�·u.,L./1.!:�'D JC,J -6®ro @®®ro @G):)25):) ®e0 a:J @G):JOGC:J @3cj'G)C5
@25\@2::5'1� 25)@ @w& qrod B�2s.> 06
1
�ti25)c) �0 me5cl - @GJJ25)Jc) 5)0 tiducl a1m e5 Bu@O (ye)
Cl@Q)e3 � ?
@1B e3C5� @e5 GJd ql5)5zrl 635 tibGJ �gzrl, 01d� @Jbe0 dJ�C5ZS) @ �d @eJ. &3@z:5) @25)J @1530, 25)105) 25)l0l5)cl ��' 01d� @JbGJ �gzrl GJ@zrl GJcl �@J0 0� �&5 � 9 @GJJ25)J @c:0 tsJ auc0zrl e.sg e.sa �@025) 0� @c:0 tsJ, @GJJ25)J e.sg 'Q)0 @GJJd q1l5) 1 @GJJ25)J l5)0@cl &3�d'@c C5 1
@&J@cS)J qe5 @GJJ25)J @-e5JC5J GJ@zrl ZS)() q1lS). 6@c0cl @(0)25)) �ZS) q1cl@cl qlS)@@Jdaz:5) e.s@� ! 0@J [email protected]) c�d1 �GJ G358@o @5) @cDJ �Z52-®ulS) Q)e5'Q)d1 ZS)� e5J�(3 0�, 0� @c:0 @GJJ25)J @-e5J GJcl@l5)&3 � ? q�dcl qJ@(3J'Q)C5cl @�ZS) @ q153 "6'Q) @ @Jc:5GJ@d" a1@0J@ GJ@zrl 'Q)d53· epe.sg � e.s1®@-®i:i53. @GJJtsCCJ £3e5@ @Jc:5GJC50 &3@d 25)@, 0�0 5)0 tiducl ®o �@J � 01d� @Jc:5GJ @1�zrl @(0)25)) @-e5Je5®zrl �0 C5J@c) q0cg:is @25)) @eJ.
q53 e,d d1ZS) ��25)'Q) Z52d1CCZS2 @(0 ®&35 25)J�C5i:5) EJz:5)00 @ &3o25)::,� @eJ. &361 �d53@cl0 &1&@@. c0@J 625) @� E@@m, ,,, c 8dJ0zrl a®e.s 0a�@C5& �� <353. @GJJ25)Ju l5)0�ducl a1tme5 Bu , ·.;_, l5)125)z:5') @25)) @153 @d C5 ! @G)J25)J @c:0 539� qo a&3l5) @Z))aJzrle3l5) &3a, e3:@ Z52Gd(3l5)J0e5zrl (glz:5')@0J C,525) sgQ)�0z:5') @d �-d @eJ
@25)l5)c) @G)J25)J c0� @eJ. @�a025)u 0� @c:0 lS)gcei@ en@d
6@c0cl c0�0@l5)&3 "c0a� @G)J25)J11 @c:0 @d 610 &3a -80 tsJ �z:s,'0J@ 8gQ)� @eJ �? a®e.s0 &<325) @25)l5)'Q)c) e5 @d 610 ab0 a®gb-®i:i
2
Z5)Je,3 5)�25) @
@Z5)J �C,5 852 ©eJ
� Cy�6 25)15), @2S'\:l@l5'\2S'!
@G)Z5) @G)JZ5)J
@G)JZ5)J '-'.J'--''--''-J.J
Cyt025) Z5)lG eJ C5Z5)
,s:Yl.Bcs 952 @Z5)J @eS.
e)Z5)�
@
C,5,
3
625) @®:J©1:SXJZ5)25)c) � Z5XJe5 C�8 §61C ©25):J 25)@ 85J c5. ©25):J6@d' 25)@, @G):)25):) m�rod'8 �®c ®1�c) �8 c5:J@c) eye:) £3©Q).6@rocl ey88@®251 �@25)c5 25)0 G)cl 25)c&3, @G):JeSCC:J a9 aa@G):J25):J 63ct @C8251 G)@251 @25)@0� q1iS).
@G):J25):Jc) S251 msC@C �25) 25)lCt, 25)�, Z:5)8 ®l�lQ) qZ5)6251 G)@251 25)@ c01B c5. 25)1£325)@, @�@25)cl @25):J @e.5@25)25) 5)0@ �®c@C251 818 @c5 e525):JBb'-®i> @:Jb'G) ZSJ@,251 �8 � c5:J c01B c5. @GJ:)25):) §8 �25)25) q251 qc5 -e55J iS)a-®xJ e52® 25)0:J S251 �8251©251 � 25)li5)• o@c) @rod' c5J@c) §8� 8tc5®25) � q8Gcl).5 ©25):J ©eJ. ©G):Je.5CC:J mac8 ® @G):)25):) sa @d'.
ey88@®251 85J8 25)@ o �@25)©c5251, @G):)25):), ©G):Je.5CC:JQ S251 B25)0l c5. (Q)c525)0l 25):J@ 8b'-®i> 8015251 80 @G):)25):) ©GJ 25)11:'.) e.5:JQ s251 �d' 8251©251 ©oJC©C251 c:,€) a®�. @a9 ©25):Jc)d' E� e5
q1Z5)). �®c @1�a @ @G):)25):) �8 @c5cl, ®� Bgo @25):) @eJ. �b'� 25):JCc525) ey88@®251 25)@ �@25)c5;§3 ! ©G):Je.5CC:J ®� ©GJ 8:J-e525):J8 @cm:J 25)0 @G)25) q1iS). 61zsS ZSJ@:J ZSJ@,251 cieJ - sgc1e, ©�25) ©G):Je.5CC:J @GJ o e56 25):J�c5, q251 qc5c) @ro:J�251 q1@d'.
z;s)@oJcc.5§251 @i5):Jo8, me5 a125)8c@c', @m:Jacc:) @G):)25):) @ro 8a @£3251 8c.5 338-a @�aa G)@251 25)08. a8d' 25)c �8 c.525) ®�® aac ®1�251 ®� @ro @c5:J251®i5) aa25)@:J ro(e) ®ZSJ @eJ. d'[email protected] d'8oc5, Z5):JC©c5251 Z5):JCC5 25)l@G)25):J, ®� ©GJ q8@i5) ac.5 @ q1@d'.
4
s
"€? @(S;; P,-© c�i;;gsz (S;;Q,©�lj �,©CQ,© nns: ;:)l{l 1'3UqlU;:)D ·�@-© *
'Cg@ �Q QG@ CG')(S2QCQ @ f5)0tQ@ CQ@ pcg;b �Q'alCQ0 �QCQ@Cg:)0 'F@QCQ F@G:lm FQCQGd-·�1@ CCQ0 CCQ�G8§ fCQ0 �Gcr§ ·cgl;b cQ CQQ® Q(S2Gd-Q � CG¥ ·cglCQ �QlG;) F�G @QG@@ "G:l PQ? @ FG:l@�,qo@Gd-·cglCQ �G08§11f)0QQQ 11 '�Qcib CCQ�@ CQm@p CCQcm0 FG:l@m,q5 Q0
;_, � �G1G @CQ ,9Q(S2 F;) F89 ·cgl;b ,9(S2 8� Q(S2CQ�1Q Q@fut> i)g G�Q pcCQ 'G:l §lCQ cgm c�� FG@602Q F;1;> 062@ '� GG G@Qb 02@ CQG�Qsl� PP �0 "G') pcm@ Q§® Q8 FG:l@G;??Gd-PQ (Q8 c02 G')(S2 62@ ·G') ($2<:Q@t> cCQcm0 om@ F;1;, ·cgl;b � C(S))'al F;1;> QGd-G� G':l8 F§@ 08 f90 cCQcm0 cQi)Qcm0
·G� g�& c��@ G� ��@� c�cc,� .l
'CQl@ CCQ0 F;) p@ ,QQ0 il�G')P�P(S211
@@CG') 21;g CG')CGd-0 �B(Q QQ;l@ CCQCm@ 'QCQ@ Q C(S))'a)
@ FQ8 ,9(S2 f90 CCQCm@ PGG:l8 FP©GG:l8 'Fgcg;b @5@ PGGd\\3]@'816 �@ i)99 CQG') C@CQ CQQCQ� F@0 'FQCQGd-G':l@ Q8 �(Q
i G:l @Gd-ib G:l9 �GQ Q(S2G:l�c@,q� c;:>19f-B� �G:l�(S2 pGd-? �1G * 1.CG:l-8C@11 6 � �lib �G':l@ @CQ PG(S2 Fh §102
'a)(S2 @Gd-QG:l@@ ·�@pQ@ QG@ �G':l@ G':l� 11@0�@1Q BQc;b11
Q)CQ 0 ¥ '@ QPG �9 ·�@@lQ CQQ0 G:l,9C(S2CQ p@G� CQ@ 'F@P(S2 G')CQ�CG QC'alCQ Q@ 'F21@ Q(Q;Q G':l@ �G° F@?@
i G':l p0 CCQFG:l§ cm Q)CQ @ QQCQ0 �@ G':l�CQpcrnp (S2G:l§pecg §1@ cCQ@ �@� gQ?@ ¥
@CD:JeSCC:J <;25) cpa9 a1®-©xi qv§3 &1e325), &1� &1� "a1® 5)125)@" <;25) �d' 025)@25) "2530a" c.s Bc.s(!J@ @{0c <'c, "q:[email protected]" <'c a®gb'-©[email protected]) ® q@i5)2S) e3 @CD:Jd' q1§ Ba:J, @(!] <'c0a 9cfo ® a125)8@ c)oJ6 e,�6:J 80:JO CD(:;8. "q§ C01@61 owd' ©<'c:J0f2@eJ"
(g)W@, @ @S25) ©e55)5) C0l25) S25) &)�c) a12S)C.S2S) 25)15)· @® @s25) @ad@d "25)00 25)@ acl0c.s�o" @ccl'® e5 25)5)0 e3 Boc.s w1B <'c ?
25):Jd' c�0cl, @G):)25):J aw @Ba:Jd, Be.sec@ ey25)'@ @m:Jd' 925) e5 e325):J(g e3c.s. �d'025) ao25)' @5)025) 25)153 me qao:JZS):J(g ZS)cc.s e3-di5)o BB@o 0025) a®cl 25)15). 025)@25)25) ocl e5 <;@025) c.s2S)e)c.s25)' @5), 63® ©2S)©-e3 25)Q£) ey§B ©eJ <'c ? a16-& e,�® 9{C0cc.sm W:J a® v@c) 25)Q£), @® i5)5)5)0C.Sc) a1®-&c.s 8� c.s.
®wcl c�a:J0B ! @® <'c2S)'83 ® @(!J @C:J025)' q302S)®:J BB®o ®�o q0cg:is e3c.s. <;25) ...... 9s®8 ! q:JO�:J BB@o BB@ ©C;:J025) @25):) @15). @®® e,dio)@ aZS):isc.s qcl sB @w1 qd <'cB25):J qc.s w16, q25) 25)0©025) @®c.s <'ciB) <'c ? 25)0@025) @® a5):l5(5 ey25)'®0:J c.s8 <'c ?
025)'@ 025)' awoB25), <;25) ®� <'c25)25):J qro:is02S):JC5dC.S 25)-e,)3 w1�-& !
@C;'DBZS) @e;1@2S)1d5)6 @<'c@C:J0 ® QJ� 81f2-& ! q§ s®ZS)O ®:Jb'CD©d q0a:J25)(5 @,(G):J e3c.s. aoaco eyw�25) �d§@d 0 a� &1 &@�. �61 qi5)6zd 9@,@m ey@@B 25):J<'cC.S <+15)0 eS:J©eJ. Bc.s(!J@ 11C0oC0:J" 25)105)� @<'c®25), ago acJ ® �@08.
®2] @cd [email protected]::[email protected] C5®0C5 �2]-©:ii a®[email protected] ® qc0a oJCJ aaa8
80. �2]-©:ii 96'.l ® ®86 @c.5 8Z5)c0825) a@Z5)8, ®2] 25)0:> 25)0251@251
@.)o) @Z5)'.) �25)25)'.) eJZ5) ©c03 @®Jo©G)3(3C5251 fil'.l@:>825) e)c.5 c0l25)·
Dc.5 @.)o)c) a®c06 e)c) qa�oa fil:>@:>825.
®2] a�8Z5) @2S)Z5)�c) ®:>@GJ:>@eJ @�:>63 ®8aZ5) @eJ. t8@c0cl ®2]
@.)o) @Z5)'.) �25)25)'.), @.)o) @_(CS) ® £362526(.8 ® 8025)'.) q�cl@i5)25 !
t8a®-©:ii e5 !
8
cl2S')�l:i)'5j<;�CD:)C5o M2S',�@1EJ e:;l,oe:;l'.}@CI:), o,��)J@ZS)j,c:} � O�c;(Z;;ic:J<:5:S) q§ �t:)� OoOJCJ<:525)
@25)@0625)' @�J ®1§0 q8 s25)'.e3�@25)' @® �25)'0J ® a1®-&@c::i�. qeJ�).SJ UJ\..,IV�,:;;,,,JJ\.;.J/ .• ,JJ. 5)-©ifcS)J [email protected]�wi5') 25)0J,
5�@25:)' c'.57(�@-@:o:6) qa @cm ® a0d�J q®�m0 gZ5)c) 0@025) � ,�-�--�· 5)0 0@025)
(g)5)J zs:,e;J�dzs325)' a1@-©3 �t:5� �,'.JC'G'J,c.e. ©25)@0025),
o@ae5@25)' @�::> @1§ �§aw @d' @ �b� w. 6@d' @�::>@w25) ®�@d a1@-& @ad oJ§ 0e� qa s25)' ®�
o(:;;;.,QJ<ccJ t:.:::::,�.i:'.:Si)'®:o �J�51w�� ro�0@cl oDrod e5 �15). @®0d ....,......,,._,.,_,u.....,, @&35
m1@d. @® 253oJ s?.5) oo@d&3 B1� 5)�cDJ0 cD:)
q®�m0 (g)25)@ w:) ©�:) c01Z530, OO©tJ eJ��J s25) 5)0@d 01a25)' @d' ®
o-e:�0-Z5):)25')t5):)0 �::>t)C0(:§'C'.3 t;: @25)@0625)' t;:25)'�c) a0:) 6'25:):::::::0:251 0:)@:)�13 aad�o�
ocl0@w5 @® s25)'a>5) QJwZ5)0l �::;C)CZ'.G·c.e (g)�5w6 ® s0§; q®t;:m @£) @G):)@cD:)01@®, @Z5)@@d' @£) @G):)@cS):)@t:) 65, 6® s25)Q)5) 5)5)5)V@w25) C01@e5®6 @�:) Oo@w3o�w25)@C02:rl q§ZS) ® ooo e5 \..,Is.:;; ,..:;_;t-.;J e:5 5)0@ t;:d@d
ooo m®@d @e:)o®ww25)' m1� 85):) m1d®D t;: @�:) c01Z5). @cD:) e,ac:),::.)@c:J Ow�·� ad' �£)J ro;,-x,A.� @me.3 5)0® CQC 25)0@25)', "@®
@® cJc) @ad q:)cl@@d 8w:)", w�J� 0Gd@wd @0d 25)6, @025) Z5)d 5)l�®0Jcl, @e.5J@@® ad'
9
®� @e'.J; 8c:s0c51 el�aa BBB. (ao. &3:- ad® �;gc:s). r3 �b'� @ac5 w0c:sm C0125) �®m 25)@ @aeJ@25) � ? ®o �@J e3 @® w25) aao m®@m e'.S:>B-6c5:>-0J.SJw-®c5-©i> cp� go:>13) 0cu q8 @�oJ a"®i> 25)l§ @®® oo0d25)mw@d' cf25)Jcl® d0c5iac:s q0@aiw @25)'.) 25)0 acl0@c:s1, @25)'.) s22J0cl0®, @® aaoc) ® 25)105) 25)105) 01®@-©il'. a1®®u® 5)-©:6c0J0 @�01&3 @25)Jc) C025)25)J aad�el25)wJ (" 15)�WJ �i53@wi 96©�:l ��®{wn5) �o�Oo" - @�0125)25)� @d 5)-©:6c0:>0 a@a 25)0 @C025) Bc325)J 5)125)1cl5)J @a:>@c0i 25)G a15 ac58) - (y®u @25):>o
®wJS@d' 25)022) ca25) - al�@ - m10® -- 0 Bo� z§)c:s®m 25)10® ac0 @025)cl @C'D25)25)
q1a25)c) �d0m@m �@:>00 acl 25)025) c:;,cmf3f3 -ca c:s. @25):>o®"®i> a�uz§)m 0 r3 Bc:scc "Oz �-®u®�o
£3d@©� iffO,��,e-5 �25)©'5 w��o 53mo" 5)-©:6c0J o5@,Jc0@wm 25)022) ca25) c01re3f3-01@8c c0J 25)i a@& v@d® Bc:se'.?® 25)10@ a1@@25)m@m 1
' c®®�mzs,®�o £3d@®� q6wd� �25)®d w��o2S')�-00" c.�J-�")_(.,"" 863 v25)c @cB&3.
@(5.)J25)J @av® 8&a a®o ®ada25)J WJ025)J@eJ ®125)e)25) &305) 025)25)'.)c) q®�J.SJ©eJ @a025)1G �d 025) ®Bc:52025) @d s25)w c01z§) w. u©lc0i5\ 25)J@ �alG(325)J2t]©C5:)(5.) @J()(5.)@C525) &3025) c1a3w c01z§) @25)J@eJ. 8@,@05)c) aB@d' 25)@, q®�J.SJ0c) �rom �mo ® a1CC0 ® B0®0 ®€J ei@am@m 25)15). cr®�J.SJ0 0@025) w0:>®@d' @m0a��J25)Ja��J �al@c:525) 25)Go 84,000 25) ® V25) �(5.)c) ® �@J 25)@,25), �0J5-ala, @c0®-ala @�®m 5)00@025) ®cl @25)010cl, a@@3 �oc3w (y�5@d' 5)0 �oucl qa �@J
11
©-e5E e3�CJ(S;)Z5)J �J-®xl e5W@ @0®2:rl ©G)Je.5, "25302:rl e53@c) Z5)® 25)@ 9d@d -8e5e'.) -e5odz:s:,Jo wb'@e5zrl @G:> ;® GZS®-®i>C5 fiJ1.e5® ® 8" e525)Z5) 5)WfiOl 25)0®2:rl, "eso-e5a)@J�esd-e5Z5)J �J-®i>c.5'' en_§zrl q1.@-e5m ®®636 Z5)J�C525) @d q1.BC5 w1.253 0� q1.5). ®zrl es90, -8e5e'.) -e5oe525)J0 @25)@063 ®1�wd @0®2:rl -e5a)@J61@esz;s)@J �J-®x>e5ufiJdZ5)J ®�c) 25)Je5 �od, e3d5) esB@JW 330JGZ5) GdJZ5)5) -e5lZ5)E®90e52:S) qd s253C5 w1253 C5. -e5o�J e3esGGJ-e5 �gztl ®@J 25)@qeJ�me)c) �mzrl �G)c) ® f8e5 25)@ @Z5)J Wl25),q3)5))[email protected] 25)5))5-e5o�J0d, bZS)©@ 9@ -e5o�J0d, qZ5)Ji5)@® qJd® -e5o�J0d,qC5e@fil C5efil -e5o�J0d ®�WJG®zrl, @2.;S)@@d cG w�e)?S)c) q&®zrl,qe3�m0 25)0Z5) @daJztle35) �e5J0, ®�92:rl q1-e525) @Z5)J ®1§@25)Z5)�c) 00Z5) 0(32:rl e3d5)o 25)0 � g5):isZS® 25)00Jf5@ qiB01e5.
gJ@C5:lffi25) g5):isZS®J0@fiJ:fwe5zs3zrl @5)JO � 95)@e5 �JZ5)C5 -e5c50 -e5@gb'-®i> @Z5)J @e'.J. ®�9Z5)u fiJ1-e5, f8Z5) f8Z5) qo®�, ®�0Z5) ®�0Z5) Z5)J@-o-ies wb'® g�J qBesBzrl q£35)5)JSJ� @c-82:rl 2.;S)es 25)e5J, (g)�6e5c) ® C5Z5) ®�c) EZ5)®C5 ©W:l VZ5)5)J@C5 �JZ5) 0(32:rl f85)o® 01BZS) @Z5)J @15). qo®� @25)@o63 szrl q1f5@25) Z5)15); G)10@ZS) � Z5)l5), @®02:rl e3�CJCfclZ5)J -e5®®c5CfclZ5)e525) w�e)ZS)c) ®wd -e5l Z5)E® §Bc.525) (:3QJJ @�8.
"C5©'2:S)l C5®2:S)l �®©�� - @ZS1WJ2S')o e,�C5��C5o Gto� 8� OJ©'W:JOOo - q©zs,o ZS,o e)OJ2S')2:S)o"
(w®®o<c 374)
Z5)J@-01es wb'®C5ztl@G:> ®es1�®d, q£35):ise5 szffi@®ztl �25)25.)J 01C5 e3 �C5l e3 C5J®d @1Z5)VZ5) sg�� e)Z5) e3u, §53-g®�?S) Q]e)ZS) q1B 25)00J e:38. 6® §BC5 602:rl �c5CfclZ5)C525) @Z5)J ®153 @25)25.)�c) �b CQQ)� ®J@ es@&.
12
q§ ®wcl 0ie3®cl q@�£)e) ® a0cl0J@mm C3'.l 8Z52 @�. @mJ 6@d m®, �01� � - @6�� � w0€>J6 � cg25)'§®cl �
�®mc.3 i:§36®c) EZS)O @m'.) � q®�me) ®Bm, 0@0Z5) ZS)camJ @e;::>Z5)C3Z5), Brom @e;::>Z5)C3Z5), EdommJ @e;::>ZS)GSZS) qi5)0 qi5)0 @mm @m'.ld :§3®mm Z5)002t) q15). 5)0 0@oZ5) @ZS)@@d @£) @G)'.)@cS)'.)()ZS), om ®{w e5'.le;'.)e)Z5) ffi{je)'.) ac)ce)'.) BC3GC q@5)Z5) Z5)00JC2t) q15).
a®ae5��C3 mg@ e33@c) <g,£) @m'.)� �G)c) ® ae)ZS)e)'.) @C0m c,3'.) 8Z52C3. �e)Q-®i) q'.)� ®06 5)e)@cl e)e)a5) e5®c) @3m Q)c@m Bo. q2t)CGC3 @G � <g,�6 m15). q®�me) 5)e) �oc)cl ®� mi53 - we)
©c.3::>:§3 - ®��3-®i>uwi53 -(:35)5)'.)e)'.)-(:3 0c <g,a1�e5®c) 5)(.5) ZS)() 2t) en 5).
B5) 8m0m qo@� ®OJ.5@d � ®@crl®@C3m ® a§ a®aeS��C3 u101cl®C3 8Z52 @�. "we) &30a", "@®@ro 6mm, @®@ro 6mm" c.38 q/5) e)m@m Cg)® Z5)02t) q15). q1a - ZS)-®i) - mJOC3 �e) -CG60C3 cD'.l ®ma C3m BC3GC ® ao06 ZS)O c:01 �® a�cD'.l, &3om5)o@e5m ® B@ 2t)0-®:o ZS)@ 8Z52 @�.
"��@�o �o�@�& Szs:f§
��@ �d6b o�e'.)£1£3"
BC5eJ ® (g)�C3C3251 aoe)Q ZS)() G)ZS) 63ZS'.f �e) BC3eJ �;§3251 ®@{.
13
M
-FCJQB. pcggcg�? -FQC<awCQ pcg(;)?J�@ r§CQ CJC?f p@�c�ow @�ct> C<aF)�b r@@�:) CJC?f p@� pccs:zpow �CJS-'cs:z1JrCJ@eDQ �cti @�C<ab-rrcg�t, �;,;;;'"��u'Cn',..,., pccs:zp
0w CS:Z@�CQ€)€) 'cg9 <arO@w c�6 C(Q �@QC@w Q �Q QCS:ZCJQ�C?}Bgco rG@@
"G@ �cg Q p02:;i� cg9 G rG@ rCJ@cs:zfQ@ P0ccq 'r@g02 cgt, Q�c:,9 : Cg@ C<a@ Q§§ wC.�@ <a§QQ r:) CS:ZCJQ��cg 139-gg
ccg® ·c:, §lCQ '@)cs;z r@ffi @ QCJcq_q� cpcs:z FCJ<acop @l<a@ ·cw� ca�@lo® cca@ eD�@F � '�'alcs:z 02cw�? Q@�lm CQ:;>o?@qC? es)�@F �ct> ®f)@ mcp @rQ@@ '(?� §lb CJQ��cg @€>"G@ rc:,pccs:zpow C<a�QQ Q@�€) r:) F<E@-@Q cg9 pcgrg:cqt,@@ ''8QO r@G@ CS:Z@�cc:,@ @ p@pcgrg:cqt, cg9 pcgrg:cqt,'pcm@ C/J'iJ0 CJCS:ZfQ@ pccs:zpow lpcs;zc:,� <E@-qQ Qccs:z pt9ccq.go·cg lea r1J p@Q��cg 1102�cs:z lpcs;zc:,� 11 p@ po@ 'cg9 §lh Q�oQCS:ZCJQC(q @CJ
0w F§CJ<a@) G�@h '@)(£Z QCQB F@@�Q® rG@@
·9pe£Z r@m G2@ @ QCJg3® @ QQw� Gcg�p@?�@�:;, CJQCcqQp-c9c:, J:5)@ �CJ@qC? olp-@c<a <aQ CQ@ <aQ CQ@ ·�m FGO Q@� C£Z@�cc:,@ @ QC£Z0Cw�lp� 'Qpccg@ F@�CJCQ@@ cg9 G�@@ 'G@ �o QCJQ��cg cg0c@w Q ®<a QC@w C£Z�@ cg9 '8Qi3 C<a@ cg9 plCQl@ :8Q8 CQ08 r�<al@ cg9 @ 0CJ@@qC? <aC(;)QO§w pcgw ( <arp@9l02 @ 0P@@fs:2 �@ cc:,g @cg Q @<a CJ<aC(;)QO§w pcgw -11;,@�� F@��o@
F©� G©@Fer OPG11) QG2@ <apwglw @ q@@fs:2 c:,9 ·c:, B.138. G�9 QQC<aQccq :;, QQ FCJ<ac9p �G@�h ®Pcge£Z@ 'G@ §102 '@)(£Z r@ffi p@mqc@ @ Gcg2,olp� 'glm C(a€) '�lh C<a@ (S))@w fs:2Q8§ fCQ@ C£ZQ8§ '(?� §lh C@Q FCJQC(q �Q cg�� �lQ@@
'G@ c:;,? FCJQccq cg�� G�9 'G@ §l<a c:,p:;>pe£Z @@ 0�C£Z Q §lCQ G@�lm CQQ08 r�<al@ cg9·cglb �c:, �lQ cg9 F'iJG 'ii]�� eD�@F 'rQ@��� GGC?}? '@<af-'€>0 C<a@ (a0)€) CQ�QQ @ Qffi3 C'.)���Q@w §w @ Qlpegp�
"@.Q� O�@:> C�CC,�
SI
PQ8 �6;b '(?02@ CQGd-@CQlGd-F0>'a)6 iJ88 C@;Q <2:@-CQh)� •p�
iJ88 �0 pc�p0Gd-'c@;, CQ� CQc�go -99;;, rniJ@F
.G'.) G'.)@�t> f; (?QQ
CQC@ c�o� CQC� ��rnqc;, 6 ;;, g@ FGJQB @CQ pQ� �;i:;, §tlCQ
�� @� QGJQB CQ'�crn fil '8CQQ� Q @PO II o(l;?S o@p� o<!@-C@�� 11 -�;;, E?iGJ Q§� gg CQ'Q;}CQ FGJ@QB cpcbgcQ@ �Q@� Q9 Q�O "),..,,,,,...,
r�-... ':'d".._';...,-d G'.'Q ' Bo Q CCS))� CQQ€> IIG'.'�(;g€>�
<2:@-CQh)�u G'.'8 F31@ G'.'�f0€> §@@� CQQP� pc�ocQ��CQ€);}€) FP�� 'CQ@ CQQP� FQ Q�G'.'CQeDh)@@Gd-CQ'(qCQG'.' @h)C? �@&CQ€>@ ' F§tGJQccgQrn� CQcr,q;;, cCQrnq;;,� .PG@€>
i G'.) p@ CCQ�QO CQ0)€) p� QG'.' @ G'.'�f0€> C?F�?Q-00 'P�@ lpcbgcQ@ f;) CQQ CQ'�? FGJ@<JJCO<i:96 CQcr,q;, lp� g5�
5�CQ@�8 F�� ·g€> cb@ F202 @ Qlpcbp� GJCQrnq;, CQc� CQ'(qCQG'.' fi1 CQQ CQ'�? @ �gcb F<!@-@pt> @£Gd--�;, �Q€>C�6 CQ@ F� Q@ F<!@-@O @h)C? pc�poGd-CQ'�� CQG'.' � §lCQ � <alt> CCQQ @h)('.? @CCQ (;z!G'.'9" CQQ CQ'�? C�� f;) 'CCQ �@pt> f'€>�3C@ CCQ CCQ CQQ P0sm@ GFP�� ·cglt, � cgfu�e 'eCQ1� 'GFBF� CQ'e F§cb QCCQ�CQ pcg_gcg�? �0) p� CCS))� ·§t@CG'.' @F�? Q8 f-0€> CCQC0)€> -�QO QC�€> GJO@ QCQ:;,�;i:;, pc�po� Qrn�cQrn� @(;z!G'.'9"
'@lpcb CQG'.' 9lCQ @FGJ@<!@-qS@� QCQ:;,�;i:;, F�<J m@ �CQP
·@� G�G� Soc�GS p,� c�ca,� ·9
F�CCQ€> CQ@€> QGJ;Q F;b @CO c��S9t> ·�QO F@;,@ GP§8 -GP @ �cb egg GJ:;>CCQ P� pc;,? CQQ fb@ r,..,.rr.,.,rl"'I,..,.... �0)C@Q FQCCQGd-CQ FQQ •cgl;i:;, E?z!>@ ,O� CCS))�
5)()@25)s @25):J 8CJZ51:J @d 81 U@c025) OoV25):J@ 5)ae5�251 @85), 85) @oo @d s251' s8251'@251' 25)15).
11 ©CS):JZ5):J 11 � e5oe525):J0 ®::>:e)c.5255. 85) eJe5o25):J0 (5)5) � e;c), 8c5� aod25)::>0 25301.{w @e'.J. 8c5�® aod25)::>0 q@5)25) e5 @c.53 @d c5 ! 25)c5cl 85)cl ®as v, 85)c v, 253e5 a1Z51 8 oda{[email protected]' 86 ey§6 @d. @®8251' 5)5)5)8c5Z5'l <tl§ 25)(3, @25)@@,e.5 @253 q��8Z51 ®rocl e5oe525):J0 ©(3'.>25)c5 ZSJ@ �. "q8�@c5251 253�::> ©C0Z51" * 8c3c5 c0125). @® �®Z51c5 a�ro::> co@c5d'G5 25)0 CS)� c1@ -e.5cli53d @@&wo::>�25) wb® oc3doda{wc5c) ocl8, O-e.5255251 25)-e.5(38 08�.
c0�85) -e.5@gb-®:ii@c5251' @ GeZ51:B c.5. 63d c.5. d C5eZ51:B5)::> �bcs;iZ51e,5 ZSJ@ &588Z5'l eyB6 @25)::> @e'.J. ZSJ251' @(3325)c5 go::> ® ®86 B@ 8c5� @1® 25)1e3 @e/!J @C0::>d, @�e'.J @e3::>8cl oao®c5cl q5)o 63d qc0-e.5 @d, B5) GzZ51:255)::>8@c5m B@b. eJ "®ccl'8 GzZ51:255)::>8@d'" z§3Bs 0:J(325)@C,525) 25)15).
�� OoVe525)251W -e.5a)@m5) @(3325)c5 ®, e5(3c525)c) 255�::> @c.5 �eJ::> C0G 25)lUc5Z5) @d, zs.i8251' 9@e'.J ©(3:J 255�:J @8. "zs.it:58::>-®:ii - ZSl©eJ-e.5c511
Z511®1B ©C0c5 o®-®:iiZ5'l ey§6 @e'.J. 8c5�® e5oe525)::>0 �c5l e5 G3@d c.5. q::>cl®c.5 Z511clZ51®, q::>cl@ ao�::>0 -e.5@gb-®:ii@c5251'® 2536-l.{w ®c.5. 253b8::>-®:ii a1 Z518® "{:f ®'�·:d 9@0, q@�& 9@0" c5l 8 ccocl @d ®'t5J5 ®'t5J5 c� c�::> oo::>o C0C8. orot5S �BJ @l5)25) 098 -e.5�::>25)::>� 8Z51 q�o:J�@crl'@ 253b8::>-®:ii W::>ZSJ8 C01Z51 cr)�c) &58® -e.5l25)c5Z5) s251' Z5115). q®�:25::>8 &:l-e.5::> -e.5oe525)::>0 q1BJ 25)08®251' &:l6ZSJ618® @c5::>Z55@25)
* (�2S)@, w� -e::i:i®:>2S):is ®m®'�� ®'Q ® @�:>m®� e::i2S) 2S)�m, w� ®'en e;�mZDSZD, tO:>@o' ®'(3l�� ®'o':>l W�®'m ® �oelQ��w� wt;® o'):) (i'2S):) a,te5, ��9�e::i.crc!:>�ZDe) W(i.'� �e)�).
16
� .:;:::.,;::::�:.;::; <: .. .U\,;;;/'VJl.;..11.;;n.; .. U .. .JJ e5of5Z5Xl0 fil©O'.)Wc:50 om8, ��
@i51'8e ��® ®J@c:5i5l oJe)c) �zrl ©00� cf I 5). e'.)@ ��® ®J@c:5, q:835) gb8 t08 a251Z5) ZS)()@c:5 giS)Bc:5 @ZS)Jc) �zn 0883. d a251Z5)
C01251
e'.)@ ��® t;: 25301�w @eJ. 251185) §8t;:JZ5)
52@ §8® acl8 ...,_,v,.._...,_,-..,,....,.,
253evo&we5" c:01251, d "e3�J251
a 1 Z5)c:5i5l 25115). e'.)@ Ge 251J.35)J8e5
t:3of5Z5)J() ao�J82:SI' ©�® ©251:J
253evoiwc:5 ®wB@d l:;5)86 251@ @eJ. ac:58 a®gb� aoe5Z5)J0
e5of5Z5)J()Cjl:;5)c) 018§c:5
25)J.3c:5m, ©C0J251J oJt a��c:5 e55)J.3c:5cl, 251 ® 9e3ac @&&®&c:52:SI'
©eJ. @®e3c)
253®§
e5 ©251:J "63d qwai51'" oJt
@l:;5)@862:SI' qc:02:SI' �e2:SI' 251c.5). 522:n @GiZS)c:5
e5 ©C0Jd qwa o®�i51' <g,§6 @eJ.
17
253®cl5)i5\' B@cl eg,§6 @ t;35))35)J8c:5
81
G©t1CO G'.lcs:2fQ© Ffu '@G'.lcs:2fQ© Ffu '(?� G'.l@ �lcs;:;: @1@ @QG'.l8-
·@� c,��,qQgo@ omc�G? C'QC�G? ·6
.G'.) G2-Q@9 �QFG:lG:l�® 8-GJ@ ........... �QCQ @ FG:l©CQC@ @8H? '@9lib ·�QCQ @ FG:l©CQC@ @��
'@�� -u················ O(g�@(gS. ��s .......... O(g�@ (i"Q2 (i"�G3u ·g@ CCQ© eg�� pccs;:;:poG2-eg�� Qcs:2Q?CG2-�lp� 'a)fu egg-�CQ©(;d
·§G'.l cQrn fQ©@ F@G© §lCQ F@G© §lib fQ©crnorn §l@lCQ c?ic@
(QC�� @QG'.'8-C??@QOG'.l�® ·g@ P2@ p@ po@ @qC? G'.)ra�P
FG:l©CCQ© F�fu G'.lcs:2fQ© ·�GO F� F@'a)@@1@ @ Qlpfup�
egg-p@ CG'.l?FG 9:@GiG2-© :)8@ Qeg� 'G'.l@ 28 F@Qlcs:2 @CG2-©
·9 G'.l@© QC@� p@rnqc@ cpfuQcQ@ "Q@lQ @� 0�0
@ (?CQ�GJ FG:lQCegG? QG'.'8-�cib 11@�CCQiQ -@�cib11 ·Q@lQ CQ-cs:2 @PG F9 G'.lcs:2fQ© cegg:(Q5) 9 '(?� (QG'.) rao@ FS-Q© �g:eg6
(?QC�6 lp@lrn G'.l@© "G'.l G'.l@�CCQiQ G'.l(;d 'G'.l G'.)g:eg�;JJ � G'.l(;d "8
G'.l@© G'.lQ��eg CCQ�QO @ Fg@lrn g@cg:��ib ·�G'.lCQC@ pccs;:;:poGJ
9:CQ5) @ F8e0§iQ �lCQ G'.l�pcs;:;: C'a)@ 9lG'.) IIG'.)CQCG2-Qibll '@68-ceg® cpegF9 CQO G'.)(Qes)q� cegg:CQ5) es)Ccs:2QC9:CQiQ C$:ZQ G'.)(Qes)q� (?�@©
.G'.l �lCQ
CCQ© eg� G'.l@© (?�CQcs:2© §1@ CCQ� FG:lC?f@©QC�g:eg6 ·p@
0'i20 Q�G'.'8-CQC�co? ·egl@ CCQ@ FG:l@qC? egcg�G2-ib fCQ© egcg�GJ
@8-� �lCQ G'.lQ8-�p 'a)fu egg-¥ -(�,P�� aro�cc,��r�QO)
-Q©CQpQib @@© CQG'.) _QlCQ eg;JJ @ Q�G'.'8-Qfulib � G'.l�CQq'e?,
·g@ §lt> FGC��Q
�CQ@ CQlrn QCQ@ §lQlo po@ 'a)fu egg-�© CQ@ '(?� CQQ@
®@ed' esvei ; esJf1@0 ®@ed' esvei. @®®o ZS:,@ c07.
i§3 @c0& B6@c) q255 @�c..525) @2:i)J @7.®255 e5C5CC @ 253@ c.3. [email protected] @ q� o3@5 @zs:,25)2520 010 e9Q)� qo�� 52g255 BB@ aoclzs:,Jdc..525'5 q7.B @25):> @255w25) 8� @G):>es c)f5oc::)l::5)i5) � OJ@B O'.V'��COMlJ @(DJ� -25)(JZS), r"<>f',"'if'."'i?"i"\ _ zs:,7. i5) qJ� r,;,,r-eo,.,o. '""- @2:i)J @(5)25) @Ji@C5i§3255 @ 25)e)e,_ "�cJ@Q �c)o @m'tDo ........ 9@m EtD®i51tDo ...... " "q�d'o::i @e)@tDi ®�d.6)" 25)@ � @® 85) c0�e)i5) 252@255 [email protected] @25):> 07.®-©ii, 663 ® 25305267.0 ® es0§. 663 ZSJUc..5 c..5. w:>86 @(3JZS:,C5 cDJ, LJ.,\,J\.:.A�J G)7.0® ®�J25) @®8255 a5wJ80 @e)c) @0. @®® cUl.:::./-s:::;;JJ1:...lJ @2:i)J @7.5). D8 BB@ 8@:>025) 25)7.5). 663 (g)07.�@2S) � 25)7.5). 25307.�w e;@z:s) � 25)7.5). 6C5 52255 @(33ZS:,@c..5255 ® e) i5)@J @(5) 0Jf1@0 ®@ed' 89® �£5® @Jgc..52550 av§. 6@7.®255 @ 6c..5 qB®i5) c.3. @25)0c c..5. €)25)§ @�Ji5) qJ� {0J6 52@255 G)(3J c.325) ®�J25) @�1i5)@C51, @ao @d'® '--'--'-"'-.-,·--....N..I
<37.@@25) 1"'2,,(,5;\r,)�",'\ �--r,r•�r
e} e}
25)7. §3 e5 G)CJ @e3&zs:,@d ac..56® 6@ca@ avei. @025)-e.5 25)@ ac.36 a��i5) @G)Jt:5, �� �m® @[email protected]) a®-©iizsf @csi@0 ��zs:,e33e) 07.07.cl® a@&. zs:,825:f @cl ® aoBd'zs:,255wc..5 q7.B@0®255 25)7.53@0®255 av§; @®® ®�clB C3e25)J5 @25)a� @025:fv ®@ed' avtsS. esoBclzs:,25:fwc..5 c0J ®�clB 8?5:J q@25))5J25))5 a®@255w?5:JJVC525) 01052-©iicl, DVJ @02550 ® ese)§325), @0255 ® @c..5Jcl@zs:, e)25) @e)c) acl @0.
"q:>[email protected]) q7.?5:J C5 - [email protected]) 25)7.?S) c.3, @cDJ�c.3 25)(JZS)C5, (3e.5-e525)C5 zs:,7.?5:Jc..511 qJ� �0C5?5:JJ0C5255 �255 25)1?5:J. 6®253a:> ®25)1@ qo�-©i>Z;S)
@�a BB@ o3c.3B255 @?5:JJ60 �255 c.3. @®c.3o @ao B@d @cDJ� r-;,,.pt,:,po_')<"\ - 8@?5:J255 ® c�J zs.,6
G)i:>) @e)J G)7.m® ,-,-"=""n-.-., .PO.,A,r-2,r-2, @ 0g0 @G)Je.5 e3gwJd06 ("-e.eia)@©tDJ Otoo ......... ") �£5® @[email protected] a@-©iiz:s) av§.
®25325'5o3Bv q7.B zs.,6 CS)� c@25) @c0& [email protected] @ cn£3025) 9?5:JJ5@0ZS®J c0?5:JO 52@255 ci::i�, §�@ 06�0,
19
VC5, §ro®0t:Je5J0 01-a zn® VC5, 25)@ 8� ©� 25)0 c0®JO C5, @®8251
a9 BB@c::i @<=c<:525)_ 25)15)" <:5�@0251 gi5)B�J0@a1we525) c<=cJ @®.
®t6251c) m1@Q25)J qo�l� @roJ<=c - 25)025), @@ - ®@CD c'fJ� @25)J@C525)
@G8251 CD2n®251, o q6®� 0G a1c::i@c®251, e5oe525)J0 c:1-d 25)0
mzn@251 @@@5)25) 25)(3 ®� [125) @5)61® @CD25:l, tJe5 @25:lJ <=c/5) q®<=cm0
9251 e; e5J@®251 a9 D<:5 qi5)c016 �� maJ @0251 e; a0§25:l "q�daJ
@0@5)3 ®®5)§" 85) �@ 25)(3251 @-d qo®� 0-d@-d e5oe525)J0
CDGJ ©25:lJ <:58. t; a1®251 ® §8® e5oe525)J0C525) 25:lJ<=c @25)J 25)08.
gmJ-d0o, g®�i5), aJ6e5e�w ®�J25) ®Ji@w a@-®:oZ:5) �dBl@<:5251
a1a@@®251 a08. o 85) ©<=ce.5, 68251 es.:,3@00 a0cl25:lJ ®�8c)
8§251 al� a9, "@® 8@cl OJCD - ©<=c3® - @®3c0 c'fJ� §8® 25)©(3Gd
wt:5@<:525) m,® 0cl 25':lli5)l11 8 gi5)B�0® ©e.5�, aoda-da�we5c)
acl @c-d25)251we5cl, aoda-da�we5c) acl0 q1Bl a®Jw - g�J -
®®cl§ <:525:l 025)251Ww�cl 8e5GG ® @® e)25)@ 85) a0c::i �251 acl
e; ctli5)l8 gi5)B�J0@a1we525) ®� � a9 ©GJeJ�OJ ey®@6 90�25),
@GJeJ�OJ ey®@6 oa<:525), c�o c�OJ <=ce.55)@ a1Bl@t:5.
10. ©'CJ��ol 90 8�2S)J �t632rl 8�0�W®oWC5Q CCCOJeJ®.
�c025)25)@, ®Je5J - e5J©c.;:)e5B 2:S)e.5025)@ 25':ll§, "ctl�@ e5@ @-d Cc Bc::icl 6@-d ® C5, 8c)i5) C5® @-d Cc ctl�@i5)Z5) 6@-d ® CB" 25:l® �
5)Z5)Z5)0e.5c) a1®-& 0�c) ®0a5) cD<=c05):d ('fl5)· q�aJ�@C"d@
mt:50J-®:o wJ�0 @<=cac) ® 8CB 25:lCD25:lJ 0� @m aJ, a1�® 0(3251
018 ©c03 al� 25':ll§ 2ne5J ®0a5) C.5. ef251 qe.5c) 2n0251 ®CD ©e.525103
�® a�roJ ®� 0�® ®Jt:5CDw25) �@CD m®251 25)08. ®� �2:rl a®Jese.5c)
a8. @<=c@25)Z5) ctt61 25)0025:l @25)@@-d [i®c 0(§251 018 CBJ c01B
q6®� @®251®, mot:5625) ma61 efe.530 e5o�J @(DJ€) C018 @e.5
20
IZ
i g:, <;@-@Q9 '§CQ©�@b C<aF� C<a@ @@ CG;;l-� 9-lQ rr,,-.., ,-:::-.,r,,..,,,,-,,,,..,-r-,, �CQ©9 'C<aQ8-@ Qlpcgp� CI))� @@ ·c;g@ CQ8Q(g Q,OC�© (g@CG)'gC@ <;wcQ,q� g&i<acsz0 <aQ §02 me@@ F'§CQ g:,<acCQ�Gd fB© C@CQ
·c;g0 C<a0;?@ QC�Q 'g:, @ C?FG')CQFQC�Q @@0 11 �F�pop? r�u-,,:.,�1"¥'\ o�c<a 'f@0@C? o�b fCQ0Q�po 11
·cszlCQ GJ(g C<a0 CQG) @1p�0 (?@@ ,OCQ@Gd � c<aGJ§ F§CQQ;?CQ <aGJ cp('g? FGJ0'e1§ Gd@CP� ·GJ
FGJC?f@0QC�Q:CQQ <aQ <aC@CCT;)(g 'tS)CQ0Q;?CQ fS)© CQ@ 'Q C<a0 CQC@ C�OG;;)_ 5@ CQ� '(g© CQ@ @ F'§CQ CQQ;?CQ CQ@ @ F§<:sz@ FG')CQCQQ � c<arn0l<a F(g@ CQ@ ·g:, F leg Q EzQ f)0Q�g:, � pg:,C?f@©QC�CTCQQ
·�g FG� 62@ G(g9 : <:g@ cgeQg gpc�@ (g0C0)'gC@ <;@-CQQ� CQ(gQ @PQ C<a�QQ cg�cglb '@ Gd-0.)(g Q QGd-0 GJQ�g:, -@QC? f5)0 �0209 ·g:, §lCQ GJ(g C<a0 �f<a0@ @,OCQ9 g:,olpQp ,O'tS)CCQ ·g:, l,OCQ@ @ (?C<a;?0 @lGd ·GJ CQ�p0? @1Q 'pcgb ....,,_., _;=~v_; C<a0 'tS),00CSZ0 ,.,_,.._,..,.,,..,.,.., fCQ0 FG8-§ 62@ ·�§g:,rn}0 a<ab Q @<a (pCQ�fCSZ0fQ0) <aFOCGJQOb 'Qc<a0 F§g:,@CQ olpb -olp -@C<:sz F0FSiY-0@1o p@@@ 62@
11•••••••• ...... 8PCSZ (;)QCQ CQ@ Q(QB FQ0C�OG;;l-CQf3,0(g �&i§g '@<aarnQb g@@ G@S-(g FQ0C�0Gd pccg0 F§Q�g fBSiY-0@pb �&i'gg 11 ............ �,0�� Q�CQ J���(".',O�!;Q •o�.�• ,,'.;',�•�✓r'.,,!J""Cf"l,c,("' �>�� Q�0�gopb'�@��cb Q0� p�011
·g:, f(;'.)0�8Q lp1J Qv? �@ §lCQg:,Q8-(Q§l@ c<a0 pQ&i§g) FGJ0Q�Qopb @<a arnQb f020 FG0c�p0? @<a '<aQFQ© CCQ�(g G'.)Q:CQG;;l-F1J (?CQ@ �@pb �rn pcsz csz� F8Q0 �..vv,��(61J(Jd'
'F9Q0 mrnb 'F9Q0 ,OQ0 ·c;g0 C<a0 �1J �GJp�pcsz 59§ gcg9 F§cg �@pb <aQpc:sz §lb @Qlrn @&11� C<a0 CQ@ @ CG;;l-� GJQCCQ CQ�@(g ('g8 FQCQG:+ Gd@CP� . 11fCQ0GJ CCQ�cgcr���11 'Q8-@ �§8 (?CQGd CQ@ �l@ C<a0 'Ql0) C<a@ CCQ &iQ9§J �G8§ � '(g@ c:::::c::;;:;��:;).('.
""n,-.. P'8
E T U T Charity Registration No 272496
30th April 2007
Dear Venerable Dhammarathana,
Re: Permission to reproduce poems and pictures from Gentling the Bull
Thank you for your letter of the l 71it of April. I am very happy to hear that you found "Gentling the Bull" useful.
Our teacher, the Venerable Myokyo-ni, who wrote the book and translated the poems, passed away at the age of 86 last month, She was a finn believer in the oneness of all Buddhist schools. She would have been delighted to know that the poems will be of benet1t ot your meditation students.
The Zen Trust is happy to give permission for you to include the poems and pictures in your booklet, as specified in your letter, provided that the material is not modified, and is accompanied by a suitable citation.
Please accept the enclosed copy of Gentling the Bull. We would be grateful if you could send us a copy of your booklet when it is published.
Garry Gelade Hon. Treasurer The .2en Trust
22
®'©63 �cl®'02S) So�O WJ ��
Gentling the Bull (by Myokyo-Ni)
2S)@1m ®'oJ£3zrl cs0J C$JZS12S)J e�-
These pictures and the poems
were extracted
from the book - "Gentling the Bull
by Myokyo-Ni".
23
I - SEARCHING FOR THE BULL
The search for what? The bull has never been missing. But without knowing it the herdsman estranged himself from himself and so the bull became lost in the dust. The home mountains recede ever further, and suddenly the herdsman finds himself on entangled paths. Lust for gain and fear of loss flare up like a conflagration, and views of right and wrong oppose each other like spears on a battlefield.
24
POEMS
1
Alone in a vast wilderness, the herdsman searches for his bull in th� tall grass.
Wide flows the river, far range the mountains, and ever deeper into the wilderness goes the path.
Wherever he seeks, he can find no trace, no clue. Exhausted and in despair,
As the evening darkens he hears only the crickets in the maples.
2
Looking only into the distance, the searching herdsman rushes along.
Does he know his feet are already deep in the swampy morass?
How often, in the fragrant grasses under the setting sun,
Has he hummed Hsin�feng [Shinpo], the Song of the Herdsman, in vain?
3
There are no traces in the origin. Where then to search?
Gone astray, he stumbles about in dense fog and tangled growth.
Though unwitting, grasping the nose of the bull, he already returns as a guest,
Yet under the trees by the edge of the water, how sad is his song.
25
II - FINDING THE TRACES
Reading the Sutras and listening to the teachings, the herdsman had an inkling of their message and meaning. He has discovered the traces. Now he knows that however varied and manifold, yet all things are of the one gold, and that his own nature does not differ from that of any other. But he cannot yet distinguish between what is genuine and what fake, still less between the true and the false. He can thus not enter the gate, and only provisionally can it be said that he has found the traces.
26
POEMS
1
Under the trees by the water, the bull's traces run here and there.
Has the herdsman found the way through the high, scented grass?
However far the bull now may run, even up the far mountains,
W ith a nose reaching up to the sky, he cannot hide himself any longer.
2
Many wrong paths cross where the dead tree stands by the rock.
Restlessly running round and round, in his little nest of grass,
Does he know his own error? In his search, just when his feet follow the traces,
He has passed the bull by and has let him escape.
3
Many have searched for the bull but few ever saw him.
Up north in the mountains or down in the south, did he find his bull?
The One Way of light and dark along which all come and go;
Should the herdsman find himself on that Way he need not look further.
27
- FINDING THE BULL
The herdsman recoils startled at hearing the voice and that instant sees into the origin. The six senses are quieted in peaceful harmony with the origin. Revealed, the bull in his entirety now pervades all activities of the herdsman, present as inseparably as is salt in sea water, or glue in paint. When the herdsman opens his eyes wide and looks, he sees nothing but himself.
28
POEMS
1
Suddenly a bush warbler trills high in the tree top.
The sun shines warm, and in the light breeze the willows on the water's edge show their new green.
There is no longer a place where the bull can hide himself;
No painter can capture that magnificent head with its soaring
horns!
2
On seeing the bull and hearing his bellow,
Tai�sung, the painter, surpassed his craft.
Accurately he pictured the heart�bull from head to tail,
And yet, on carefully looking, he is not quite complete.
3
Having pushed his face right against the bull's nose,
He no longer needs to follow the bellowing, This bull is neither white nor blue.
Quietly nodding, the herdsman smiles to himself.
Such landscape cannot be caught in a picture!
29
IV - CATCHING THE BULL
For the first time today he encountered the bull that for so long had been hiding in the wilderness. But his pleasantly familiar wilderness still attracts the bull strongly. He yearns for the sweet�smelling grass and is difficult to hold. Stubborn self � will rages in him and wild animal�nature rules him. If the herdsman wants to make the bull really gentle, he must discipline him with the whip.
30
POEMS
1
With great effort the herdsman succeeded in catching the bull.
But stubborn, wilful and strong; this bull is not easily gentled!
At times he breaks out and climbs up to the high plains,
Or rushes down into foggy marshlands to hide himself there.
2
Hold the rein tight and do not let go.
Many of the subtlest faults are not yet up,rooted.
No matter how gently the herdsman pulls at the nose,rope,
The bull may still rear and try to bolt back to the wild.
3
Though caugh where the sweet,scented grass reaches sky,high,
The herdsman must not let go of the rein tied to the bull's nose.
Though the way home beckons clearly already,
The herdsman must often halt with the bull, by the blue stream or on the green mountain.
31
V - GENTLING THE BULL
If but one thought arises, then another and another follows in an endless round. Through awakening, everything becomes truth; through delusion, it becomes error. Things do not come into being depending on circumstances but arise from the herdsman's own heart. Hold the rein tight and do not allow any wavering.
32
POEMS
1
Not for a moment may the herdsman drop whip and rein,
Or the bull would break free and stampede into the dust.
But once patiently trained and made truly gentle,
He follows the herdsman without halter or chain.
2
Now the bull may saunter through the hill forests,
Or else walk the much travelled roads, covered in dust.
Never will he touch fodder from another man's meadow.
Coming or going requires no effort � the bull quietly carries the man.
3
In patient training the bull got used to the herdsman and is truly gentle.
Should he now walk right into dust, he no longer gets dirty.
Long and patient gentling! In one sudden plunge the herdsman has won his whole fortune.
Under the trees, others encounter his mighty laugh.
33
VI - RETURNING HOME ON THE
BACK OF THE BULL
Now the struggle is over! Gain and loss, too, have fallen away. The herdsman sings an old folk song or plays a nursery tune on his flute. Looking up into the blue sky, he rides along on the back of the bull. If someone calls after him, he does not look back; nor will he stop if tugged on the sleeve.
34
POEMS
1
Without haste or hurry, the herdsman rides home on the back of the bull.
Far through the evening mist carries the sound of his flute,
Note for note, tune for tune, all carry this boundless mood;
Hearing it, no need to ask how the herdsman feels.
2
Pointing ahead towards the dyke where his home is,
He appears out of mist and fog, playing his flute.
Then suddenly the tune changes to the song of return.
Not even Bai,ya' s masterpieces can compare with this song.
3
In bamboo hat and straw coat he rides home through the evening mist,
Sitting back to front on the bull, with joy in his heart.
Step by step along in the cool, gentle breeze,
The bull no longer looks at the once irresistible grass.
35
BULL FORGOTTEN .. MAN REMAINS
are not two Dharmas. Provisionally only has the bull set up, somewhat in nature of a sign�post. He might
L.L.L,._,_,..,. ___ '-'- to a snare for catching rabbits, or to a fishing net. herdsman feels as when the shining gold has been
separated out from the ore, or as when the moon appears from behind a cloud bank. The one cool light has been shining brilliantly since the time before the beginning.
36
POEMS
1
The herdsman has come home on the back of the bull.
Now the bull is forgotten and the man is at ease.
He may still sleep though the hot sun stand high in mid-heaven
Whip and rein are now useless and thrown away under the eaves.
2
Though the herdsman has brought the bull down from the mountain, the stable is empty.
Straw coat and bamboo hat, too, have become useless.
Not bound by anything, and at leisure, singing and dancing.
Between heaven and earth he has become his own master.
3
Now the herdsman has return, home is everywhere,
When both things and self are wholly forgotten, peace reigns all day long.
Believe in the peak 'Entrance to the Deep Secret' �
No man can settle on this peak's summit.
37
VIII - BOTH BULL AND MAN FORG01TEN
When all worldly wanting dropped away, holiness, too, lost its meaning. Do not stay at a place where Buddha is, and pass quickly by where he is not. If one remains unattached to either, not even a thousand eyes can spy him out. Holiness to which birds consecrate flowers is shameful.
38
POEMS
1
Whip and rein, bull and man, are all gone and vanished.
No words can encompass the blue vault of the sky.
How could snow pile up on a red�hot hearth ?
Only when arrived at this place can a man match the old masters.
2
Shame! Up till now I wanted to save the whole world;
Now, surprise! There is no world to be saved!
Strange! Without ancestors or successors,
Who can inherit, who passed on this truth?
3
Space shattered at one blow and holy and worldly both vanished.
the Untreadable the path has come to an end.
bright moon over the temple and the sound of wind in tree,
All rivers, returning their waters, flow back again to the sea.
39
IX - RETURN TO THE ORIGIN,
BACK TO THE SOURCE
In the origin all is pure and there is no dust. Collected in the peace of non,volitional doing (Wu,Wei) he beholds the coming and going of all things. No longer deluded by shifting phantom pictures, he has nothing further to learn. Blue runs the river, green range the mountains, he sits by himself and beholds the change of all things.
40
POEMS
1
Returned to the origin, back at the source, all is completed.
Nothing is better than suddenly being as blind and deaf.
Inside his hermitage, he does not look out.
Boundless, the river runs as it runs. Red bloom the flowers just as they bloom.
2
The great activity does not pander to being or not being.
And so, to see and to hear he need not be as one deaf and blind.
Last night the golden bird flew down into the sea,
Yet today as of old, the red ring of dawn flares up in the sky.
3
Done is what had to be done, and all ways are completed.
Clearest awakening does not differ from being blind and deaf.
The way he once came has ended under his straw sandals.
No bird sings. Red flowers bloom in glorious splendour.
41
X - ENTERING THE MARKET-PLACE
WITH BLISS-BESTOWING HANDS
The brush�wood gate is firmly shut and neither sage nor Buddha can see him. He has deeply buried his light and permits himself to differ from the well�established ways of the old masters. Carrying a gourd, he enters the market; twirling his staff, he returns home. He frequents wine�shops and fish�stalls to make the drunkards open their eyes and awaken to themselves.
42
POEMS
1
Bare�chested and bare�footed he enters the market,
Face streaked with dust and head covered with ashes,
But a mighty laugh spreads from cheek to cheek.
Without troubling himself to work miracles, suddenly dead trees break into bloom.
2
In friendly fashion this fellow comes from a foreign race,
With features like those of a horse, or again like a donkey.
But on shaking his iron staff, all of a sudden
All gates and doors spring wide open for him.
3
From out of his sleeve the iron rod f lies right into the face.
With a great laugh spreads all over his face,
He talks Mongolian, or speaks in Chinese.
Wide open the palace gates to the one who on meeting himself yet remains unknown.
43
iloW© 8�108:zi �o�il
�z)�a)a}{d
English translation of
the Sinhalese Section
44
I r ce
n
m n ip ti
The English translation of the
Sinhalese section
I tried my best to translate the Sinhalese section
of this book, in such a way that it expresses,
as far as posible, the exact ideas of the Sinhalese
sentences; and as such some figurative and I or
verbositive expressions had to be included.
Bhikkhu 41 Dhammaratana
45
46
From the Publisher
I, an accountant by profession, am a pious and devoted Buddhist, and from my childhood, engaged in various religious activities such as worshipping the Lord Buddha
and Scared "Bo" trees, undertaking the observance of
precepts, listening to Dhamma-sermons etc. Though they
helped me to become a virtuous person, none of such
meritorious activities led me to realize the noble truth of
suffering, the cause of suffering, the cessation of suffering or the path leading to the cessation of suffering.
Then, on hearing that Ven. Dhammaratana was explaining the most profound Dhamma in a simple manner, and conducting meditation classes showing the practical way
to Nibbana, I went to the "Dikhena Meditation Centre" to
see him.
When I reached there, he had already commenced his
Dhamma Sermon. Showing a clock on the table, he questioned, "Is this a clock or is it a simple preception
? Is the perception of clock in the clock itself or is it in your mind ?" You know, in reality there is no clock;
it is only a perception of the mind.
Similarly, (showing his hand), "Is this a hand; where is
the perception of hand ? Is it in the hand itself or is it in your mind? "Hand" is only a conventional truth.
In reality, there is no hand. In fact it's only a perception. No hand is visible if there is no
mind-contact ; therefore, "hand" is only a mental
manifestation ... a mental formation.
47
For the first time in my life, I heard such a Dhamma
sermon. It aroused our enthusiasm to observe the truth in
his sayings, not only whilst being listening, but also
thereafter, in comparing it with our lives and also with the
external world. With a heart filled with great faith in
Dhamma, more than ever before, and with a high respect
and honour towards him, I left the place.
Many were able to realize Nibbana, when the Dhamma
leading towards the cessation of formations was explained
by the Buddha and his then disciples. If we get an
opportunity to listen to such Dhamma sermons displaying
the practical approach of experiencing emptiness or
Nibbana, even today, it may be possible for one to realize
Nibbanic-bliss in this very life itself.
The "Ani Sutta" ofSanyutta Nikaya says, that "there will be monks (persons) in the future who would not lend ear when discourses that are the words of the Buddha, deep, deep in their meaning, connected with emptiness or Nibbana are being recited. Then such Dhamma discourses will be disappeared."
When one listens to the practical Dhamma sermons of
Ven. Dhammaratana, one would realize that such Dhamma
discourses had not been disappeared yet.
It became evident to me when he explained "the Kassaka
Sutta" of Samyutta Nikaya. The deity "Vasavatti Mara"
approached Buddha and said, "The eye is mine; visible objects are mine; the eye-contact and its base of consciousness are mine. Where can you go to escape from me?
48
The ear is mine, sounds are mine ... The nose is mine,
odours are mine ...... The tongue is mine, tastes are
mine ...... The body is mine, tacticle objects are mine .... .
The mind is mine, mental phenomena are mine, mind
contact and its base of consciousness are mine. Where
can you go and escape from me ?"
The Lord Buddha replied, "Yes Mara, all those are yours;
not mine. Where there is nothing of them, there is no
place for you ... ''
When Ven. Dhammaratana gave a practical explanation of
this Dhamma, showing the non-self nature of them, and
asking us to relinquish them one by one, I, whilst being
listening, could let go all of them, and it appears over the
top of my head a vision just like the petals of a lotus flower
bloom one by one. Then everything disappeared and I
experienced an emptiness leaving alone only the mind
element, a simple awareness.
Just right at that time, he said, "Now, only the mind
element remains, it is also a mental formation and it, too,
is impermanent and not-self. When I realized that, I
experienced a supreme bliss, calming and cooling down
all formations.
Thereafter, I used to visit him regularly, at least once a
month. In keeping company with him and by following his
instructions, I could develop my faith - virtue - genorosity
- Dhamma knowledge and wisdom, more than ever
before.
Then I happened to read a pamplet written by him - "Gona
49
saha Vimuttiya". Because of the luscious flavour of the
Sinhalese meanings of the poems given in it, and the
profound Dhamma-explanation demonstrating the way,
based on his own experience leading to eradicate
ignorance to realize the Noble Arahantship, I suggested
and thereafter decided to publish it.
May he be happy endowed with good health to guide people
towards Nibbana, and thereby free them from suffering.
By virtue of the merit of this meritorious deed, may my
late parents; Mrs. Rajawatta who helped me to meet him;
My sister Vajira who assists and encourages in various
ways for me to follow this Noble Path; and all others who
follow the path, be able to realize Nibbanic-bliss soon !
May all beings be happy !
Anuradha Premaratna
63/2,Suramya Mawatha,
Wattegedara Rd,
Maharagama.
Tel : 0094 11 2 843 062
E-mail : [email protected]
50
Preface
As a result of my instense and persistent effort in meditation, both
concentration and insight, I came to a certain stage which, I found,
was rather impossible for me to surpass it. Whenever I tried to
concentrate on physical phenomena, the whole universe,
including my body, dissolved away completely, leaving only an
emptiness; and at that time there existed nothing in the mind; it
was completely void. Neither the body nor the mind factor was
visible to concentrate on.
Then searching for some advice to gain some further
advancement, I began to read "Theravada-Tripitaka" books
Sutta, Abhidhamma and Vinaya. But only in one Sutta, the
''Mahavacchagotta Sutta" ofMiddle length sayings, I could find
some instructions. (i.e. Develop further, concentration and insight
meditation). However this advice too did not produce the
desired results.
Then I went to see same eminent meditation masters in Sri Lanka
but none of them could understand exactly what my experience
was. I wrote to some medidation masters in Thailand, and to
some Zen masters in Japan, but I received no reply.
When I met a monk in Colombo and explained my experience to
him, he brought a file and began to read it. Having realized that
my experience had exactly been elucidated in it, I said, "I have
read all suttas, but I never came across a sutta resembling this.
Which section (Nikaya) is it from?" Then he smiled and said,
"This is a hidden sutta in Mahayana." That was how I first gained
some confidence in Mahayana-scripts.
Then I practised "Quan" meditation using some meditation words
such as, "who is a nurse", 'Cow-dung","Who am I", "Buddha",etc.
51
and through all of them I was able to experience a universal
emptiness. Then, my confidence in Mahayana meditation
systems is further developed.
When I read a Mahayana book "Gentling the Bull"* by
Myokyo-ni, which consists some beautiful poems, I perceived
how profound the meanings of those poems were. I was so
impressed that I thought to write in Sinhalese, for the benefit of
the Sinhalese readers, the meaning and the explanation ofit, based
on my own experience and also keeping in line with the Theravadic
tradition. But it does not by no means constitute a direct
translation nor does the explanation given have any relationship
whatsoever with the book.
I had to get the permission from the Zen Centre in London to
reproduce the pictures and the poems in the book "Gentling the
Bull". With the intention of sending a copy to them, I translated
the Sinhalese section into English giving, as far as possible, the
exact ideas of the Sinhalese sentences.
The explanation of the poems might not be easily conceived by
those who possess no pragmatic understanding, or who are not
familiar with the Theravadic Buddhist terms, but they would
understand that the realization of the true Dhamma demonstrates
no discrimination amongst various segments of Buddhists -
Theravada, Mahayana, Vajirayana etc. Nibbana is the same for
all. There is no justification in considering, with an attached
propensity for a particular doctrine, that one school of thoughts is
superior to others.
My sincere thanks are due to the Zen Centre in London for
granting me their courteous permission to reproduce the poems
* This book is available at the "Zen Centre, 58 Marlborough place - Lon
don - Nw 8 OPL
52
the ..., ... ..,., ..... ,.,.,.., of"Gentling , and also to the publisher
Mr. Anuradha Premaratne of Maharagama for his generous
contribution towards the printing costs.
Dhammaratana
August, 2007
Telephone : + 94 779 854 405
Web Site : www. dammwana.org
email: [email protected]
bhikkhu _ [email protected]
53
Introduction
The Sinhalese meaning of the poems in the book "Gentling the
Bull" is first given here. It should not, however, be considered as
a translation.
The explanation given thereafter is my own definition. It is only a
short description. To explain it in details, it would be necessary to
write a large book giving all particulars of insight meditation from
the beginning up to the "Arahantship". The explanation runs
gradually in the same order of the sentences of the first section.
Therefore, it is appropriate to read first, a sentence given in
the first section, and the relevant parts in the explanation
thereafter.
54
Searching for the
The herdsman running on a long deserted way is looking for his
bull, which had been constantly with him, but not to seen now.
The way runs up to the invisible horizon through far away
mountains and through the rivers with brimful of water. Wherever
he looks for, there is not even a trace to be seen. overwhelmed
with fatigue and grief, hears only the sound of cicadas in the twilight
in the afternoon.
runs on ever forward looking at the way with no end in sight.
But does he know his feet have already been sunk in a mire of
mud ? In the sun-setting afternoon, and in the sweet-scented
breeze, how many times has his "heardsman-song" floated, in vain,
further and further away?
When there is not even a trace of the beginning, how and where
does he search for ? Having been running astray, he fells down,
with no life in his feet, amidst dense fog and amongst the shadows
of the trees. Though unwittingly, he returns, as a guest, grasping
the nose of the Bull. How sorrowful is his "herdsman-song" echoing amongst the shadows of the trees and sandy plains ?
(2) Finding the traces
the shadows of the trees by the streams of water, the traces of
the Bull are seen here and there. Has the herdsman found the way through the clumps of fragrant grass ? However far the Bull may
55
run, even up to the plateaus of the far away mountain range, can
it hide itself any longer?
Amongst the dead-trees and the passes of mountains, visible are
many wrong paths. Does he know his deception of running
restlessly round and round along the wrong paths ? His feet
running after the traces of the bull have passed beyond the bull !
The bull has been let loose.
Many have travelled looking for the bull, but only a few have
seen it. On the summits of the cloudy mountains in the north or
beneath the mountains in the south, did he find his bull? All come
and go along the "one and only way" having both light and dark.
If the herdsman enters that path, he needs not run along the
deceptive wrong paths looking any further.
(3) Finding the Bull
Suddenly, a song of a bird resounds on a top of a very high tree.
The sun shines brightly. In the gentle breeze, the trees by the
dampness of water sprout-up. It seems that there is no place for
the bull to hide itself any longer. The bull's majestic head with
sharp horns appears as an image going beyond the talents of a
skilful artist.
He sees the bull, and hears its bellow. But, is the image of the
"heart-bull" reflected from head to tail. When closely looking at,
it appears that it is not quite complete.
56
Having aimed at right against the bull's nose, the herdsman no
longer needs to follow its bellow. Neither white nor dark is the
bull. The herdsman, nodding his head proudly, smiles to himself
How can such a scene be grasped by a painter?
(4) Catching the Bull
With a great and persistent effort, the herdsman succeeded in
catching the bull. But the bull is dreadful, obstinate, wild, strong
and cannot be easily tamed. All at once, it breaks loose and runs
far away with no end in sight, or hides itself sinking in a mire of
mud.
The rein has to be held tightly, and should not be let it loose.
Many subtle rifts have not been closed, nor are the roots
uprooted. However much the herdsman tries to gentle the bull by
holding the rope, the bull, rendering his effort fruitless, still
attempts to break-through towards the wilderness.
Even if the pleasant smell of the sweet-scented grass blows, the
nose-string should not be left out. He sees that the way running
towards home beckons far away. But he should always be close
to the bull. Even at the attractive and delightful blue streams, or
green mountain peaks, he should not depart from the bull.
57
(5) Gentling the Bull
Not even for a moment, the nose-string should be slackened. If
not, the bull would break free, and run far into the dust. But when
it is tamed patiently, it would docitely follow the herdsman.
Now the bull can freely go through dense forests, mountains or
thorny thickets. Or else, it can move through the congested roads
clouded in dust. Never does it now run towards other's
green-fields. To come and go requires no effort. The herdsman
quitely rides on the back of the bull.
Having been patiently tamed, the bull is now admissive. (The
dreadful darkness of the bull now appears only above the neck.
Other parts have now been changed). Even if it runs right into
dust, it does not get dirty. A long and patient gentling ! The
herdsman has achieved his supreme fortune. Others can hear well
his heroic sound reverberating amids the trees.
(6) Returning home on the back of the
Bull.
Peacefully and without any haste, the herdsman rides home on
the back of the bull. The fascinating sound ofhis flute floats amidst
the evening mist. Tune by tune, tone by tone, there pervades the
sound of his triumphal and boundless songs. It seems that his
melodious sound is announcing his enjoyment of his limitless
58
satisfaction to the whole world !
Playing his flute, he reaches home through the sky entwined with
mist and fog. All at once, the tone turns into a victorious "song of
return". Not a single song is there that can be compared with it -
not even with a masterpiece of the great poet "Bai-ya".
In the cool and gentle breeze, and through the evening mist, he
rides home with joy in his heart. And now, the bull does not tease
him as before, running after relish grass.
(7) Bull forgotten ... Man remains
On the back of the bull, the herdsman has now reached home.
The bull is now forgotton. His mind and body have been
tranquillized. Even in the burning hot sun, he can now sleep
comfortably. The nose-string has been thrown away under the
eaves. What is the use of it now?
Though the herdsman has brought the bull down from the
mountain defile, now the cattle-fold is completely empty. Tools
are of no use; and they too are thrown away. Having no
attachment towards anything or anyone, and leisurely singing and
dancing, he has now become, between the earth and celestial
world, his own master.
Since he has now returned, wherever he looks at, he sees home
everywhere. Everything and self have now been dissolved away,
59
and peace overflows through out the whole day. He is now not
sceptical of the higest step of the "Entrance to the deep secret".
Would it be possible for any being to remain there in this highest
peak?
(8) Both Bull and Man forgotten
The nose-string, the bull, and the man, all these have now been
destroyed. The endless blue sky now he sees, is beyond the
expression of the power of words. How could snow be there on a
red-hot iron ? One should achieve this state, if he wishes to be
compared with noble persons in the past.
What a great shame ! Up to now he wanted to safeguard a whole world. But now it is surprising ! No world is there to be
preserved. Who else will be able to see this truth, other than
those who had already experienced or those who will experience it?
Just in one stroke, tumbled down the visible space. And
collapsed down the both worlds - mundane and supra mundane.
Reached is the terminus of the very difficult path.
Over the temple, the moon shines very brightly. Amongst the
trees, the sound of the breeze floats further and further away. All
rivers returning their waters back again to the sea, flow towards the ocean.
60
(9) Return to the origin back to the source.
Nature is returned to nature itself. All is completed. Nothing is
better than suddenly becoming to a state of being as blind and
deaf. He remains in his hermitage without looking out. It is
limitless as well as solitary. Rivers flow just as they had been
flowing before. And as usual, flowers bloom.
In this great activity there is no room for " to being or not-being".
To see or to hear, now he needs not to be one as deaf and blind.
Last night a beautiful bird flew towards the sea. Today ... the red
aurora of dawn shines in the sky.
Done is what had to be done. Everything has been completed.
The clearest awakening does not differ from being as blind and
deaf The way has come to an end. No bird sings. The red flowers
shine beautifully, and the fragrant aroma blows everywhere.
10. Entering the market-place with bliss-
bestowing hands
"Bear-chested" and "bear-footed" he reaches the market-place
with his face clouded with dust and head covered with ashes. But a mighty laugh freely spreads throughout his face. He has no
worries in his mind. Without any miracle, the dead trees begin to
bear flowers.
61
In a friendly manner, this friend comes from a foreign country. His
features may look like those of a horse or a donkey. But, when
he shakes his iron-stick, at once, all doors will be opened for
him
Right against his face, his iron-rod stands straight. With a great
laugh spread all over his face, he speaks in Chinese or Mongolian
language, which may be a jargon for you. To the one who meets
him, the doors of the palace will be opened. He is a stranger who
has been constantly with you. But he remains unknown. That's
all.
62
The xplanation
(1) Searching for the Bull
"Anamataggoyam bhikkhave Samsar� pubbakoti na pafifinayati", Monks, from an inconstruable beginning comes this cycle of birth and death (samsara), ':nd inconceivable is the beginning of it. We have been, so far, transmigrating in this endless "samsaric-joumey" with no beginning or end in sight, experiencing immense suffering, pain and distress. Long we have thus experienced stress, pain and suffering; but enveloped in delusion and fettered by desire, we could not even trace our ignorance that lies in our mind itself. Just as the endless unreachable horizon, so is the long long journey we traversed from one existence to another, being born as hungry ghosts and other woeful states, seldom as humans, and very rarely in divine abodes. Yet, not the slightest trace of the sufferings we encountered in our past lives remains in our mind. In this endless and burning journey, the little sensual pleasure we experienced through pleasant sense- objects such as pleasant sights, pleasant sounds etc., clouds our suffering and makes us still to think, due to the inability to overcome delusion and desire, that the suffering in the samsara i� pleasant and desirable.
No end is even visible in this samsaric geserted way to be fared on in the future. The ordinary worldlings, not realizing the true Dhamma, run on ever forward on this painful and terrible way. Having been sunk in a swamp of delusion and a mire of defilements, and being incapable of getting themselves free from this dreadful destiny, they h,we been tied down by 10 fetters and imprisoned in this samsara. yet they are stil not even aware of it. But amidst the sense-objects that bring some slight pleasure for them, their mind again and again, floats further and further away.
63
Incalculable is the journey of samsara. Even if all the soil of the earth is turned into tiny balls to represent each for one's fathers of the past-lives, so we use up all, but there will still remain more fathers to account for. (Pathavi Sutta - Sanyutta Nikaya). Regarding such perpetual lives of the long past, what is there to be seatched for? In this deluded samsatic journey, we fall down, as if we are lame, mto the p1:ecipice of birth, decay, sickness, death etc. Though unwittingly, living beings, not realizing the non-self nature of these five aggregates, plung again and again into this round of births and deaths. When wisely looking at, it appears that all attachments, aversions, wrigglings and wigglings, singing and dancing and other mundane activities of a worldling who is constantly bound by craving - ( "Tanha dutiyo puriso -dighamadda�a sa�saram" - "with craving his companion, he wanders a long long time") are nothmg but deceptive struggles. However-happily one sings, all those songs are, in this Noble Discipline - (Runna-!llidam bhikkhave Ariyassa Vinaye ya!1idam _gitam") - nothing but cryings, weepings and lamentations made out of the inflammation of craving. And, in this Noble Discipline, dancing, too, - (Ummattakamidam bhikkhav<; Ariyassa Vinaye Yapidam N?ccam") L, considered as dn insamty of the mmd.
(2) Seeing the traces
The one, well engaged in both concentration and insight meditation, is able to see the shadows ofignorance,just like a far off mirage. But indulgence in sensual pleasure never leads one to
64
Nibbana. If one enters the middle path, no longer can ignorance hide itself Even if ignorance misled us by immersing us in the bliss of the 4th formless Brahma-world (Nevasafifianasafifiayatana)
continuously for 84000 aeons, or druged our mind by deceiving us in the pleasure of divine abodes, would it be possible, in the presence of right view, for it to delude us any longer?
Even though one follows the middle path, at the stage of gaining knowledge and vision of what is the path and what is not, an illumination or some other mental image of imperfections of
insight may appear, and such mental manifestations seen as a
beautiful picture drawn on a screen of ignorance would mislead
him so that he, being incapable of deciding the right and the wrong
path, might relish such images and consider them to be Nibbana. So many are there such wrong paths, and other kinds of religious
rites and rituals. Identification and abandoning of them is necessary to move-on along the correct path. The worldling who accumulates volitional formations of wholesome and unwholesome actions due to ignorance is conquered by ignorance itself. He behaves so freely due to the fact that the opponent sword of
discernment has still not been aimed at the head of his own ignorance.
Many have traversed on this path, but only a few have realized
Nibbana. It is only through ignorance that living beings are generated in the higher realm ofBrahma-world, as well as in the precipice of woeful states and other places. Buddhas, Pacceka Buddhas and the noble disciples, all of them have traversed along "the one and only way" of the four foundations of mindfulness. (Ekayano Ayam bhikkhave maggo .... " This is the one and only
way to Nibbana). However, some followers of this path, not being able to realize the true Dhamma, come back again to their usual
way leading to birth and death. If the stage of gaining knowledge and vision of what is the path and what is not, is surpassed, and if
65
one really reaches fruition of the 1st sainthood ( sotapatti
phala ), he would never follow a wrong path again.
Finding
Having surpassed the purification ofknowledge and vision of the
right path, and having gained other insight knowledges thereafter,
he hears the melodious sound of the knowledge of contemplation
of reflexion whispering him that the only thing to be done to
realize Nibbana is to discern the three characteristic features of
all formations. When he enters the knowledge of equanimity about
formations and becomes indifferent and neutral to them, then there
arises in him, tranquillizing and appeasing the rigidity of his body
and the burning sensation of his mind, some happiness, subtle
and peaceful. With the deluded distorted perceptions,
ignorance cannot mislead a person for ever. It is not possible to
convince to a person without an insight-eye, how the mighty
actions of ignorance pierce the heart with the darts of defilements,
and how it distorts perceptions showing all formations that are
impermanent, suffering, and not-self, as being permanent, pleasant
and self
The conceptual knowledge gained through reading and listening
but without practical understanding is considered to be
imperfect. one contemplating and cutting off, with his
supreme mindfulness and wisdom, all sense objects and the
phenomena of and matter arising through them as
impermanent, suffering, not self etc, requires no such conceptial
66
knowledge. When the three characteristic features are practically
and clearly reflected, there arises no attachment or aversion
towards sense-objects, so there is peace and happiness in his
mind
"Yato yato sammasati-Khandhanam Udarabbam Labati Piti pamojjam-AfI\atam tam Vijapatam"
(Dhammapada 374)
"Whenever the rise and fall of the five aggregates is reflected, a
great joy and happiness will arise"
This cannot, however, be comprehended without any practical
understanding.
(4) Catching the Bull
In order to trace ignorance, he must maintain an untiring and
persistent great effort. If not, ignorance-stubborn-very strong
given to becoming-difficult to subdue, will take him into a dream
of fairy-world of thoughts and attachments, or else, will make
him forget everything by immersing him in a mesh of sloth and
torpor.
Mindfulness and wisdom should be constantly well established in
his mind. The clefts such as hindrances have not yet been closed
up. Nor have the roots been uprooted. Ignorance still makes an
effort to generate him in different modes of births, existence,
species, stations of consciousness and abodes ofbeings.
67
Mindfulness and wisdom should be strictly maintained especially
in the presence of the pleasant and enticing sense-objects. The
house of becoming makes gestures and beckons him saying,
"Come over here, come over here". To restrain all six senses,
eye-ear-nose-tongue-body and mind, mindfulness and wisdom
should constantly be developed.
"Sabbattha samvuto bhikkhu
sabba dukkha pamuccati"
(Dhammapada 361)
"The monk restrained all over is freed from all suffring."
(5) Gentling the Bull
In the absence of mindfulness and wisdom, the dust of mental
confusion, flurry and other difilements will cloud his mind. This
problems no longer exists when it becomes possible to train and
concentrate the mind well. Then there arises a mastery of the
mind
When such a mastary of the mind is gained, he can, without any
attachment or aversion towards anything or anyone, and also
without any affliction, move on along the path safely. Then even a
busy place becomes a suitable dwelling for meditation. When he
dwells in his own field - ("Carata bhikkhave sake pettike
visaye ....... " Wander monks in your own paternal field. i.e. four
foundations of mindfulness), his mind will be well settled in the
four foundations of mindfulness, and it becomes stable and still.
Then it enters a stage of serenity called "momentary
68
concentration", and then the mind begins to act effortlessly and
involuntarily. With a calm and equanimous mind, he now moves
on ever forward seeing the reality of the phenomena of
oncoming mind and matter.
The mind thus tamed with a consistant and patient restraint does
not now appear frightful dark as before. The external dreadful
and black formations have now been dissolved away, and the
"inner" mind starts activating only internally. This "internal" mind is
the only formation that remains now. With that experience, no
defilements such as lust, anger etc. would arise in his mind, even
if he makes an effort to generate them forcefully. Hence,
fearlessly he can move on anywhere. The mind now becomes
absolutely pure; and being taintless, it does not get dirty.
It, detached from the external world, isolates itselfleaving aside
everything. The mind thus purified, concentrated and filled with
discernment, realizing all formations of the entire universe as
impermanent, suffering and non - self, experiences a momentary
cessation of all formations and thereby sees the complete
dissolution of the perception of self. And then he experiences the
fortune the greatest - a far exceeding supreme bliss. The sublime
heroic melody that emerges from such a fortunate mind echoes
within the mind itself. Those having super normal powers would
see and hear them well.
69
Returning home on back of the
All wholesome and unwholesome volitional formations depend
on ignorance until it is totally eradicated by the fruiton of
Arahantship. This may be compared to the riding on the bull's
back. The mind has now been calmed down, appeased, cooled,
and tranquillized by the greatest fortune thus gained. Then he
discerns the various kind of sense-objects, and all mental
formations derived through them as mental manifestations rising
and falling instantaneously. This correct knowledge and vision
arising through all sense-objects is emerged continually within his
heart. It seems that the supreme bliss generated through the
correct vision that had never even dreamt before, overwhelms
his world of five aggregates continuously.
He, being adept at such sight of insight, realizing the reality of all
formations of the whole three world's, reaches through the
intoxicating conventional world, ofNibbana". And
abiding in the fruition of the noble path, experiences supreme
and sublime bliss ofNibbana. "Nibbanam '"'01 .. ::..•.1; .. ""' ... :...
"'
.mu .... sukaham"
- "Nibbana is the highest bliss". Nothing surpasses this supra
mundane peace. This cannot, of course, be comprehended with
an intellectual knowledge.
Having appeased the burning sensation of defilements, and the
inflammation of formations, pacifies heart with the cool
gentle breeze ofNibbana. And now does not incline
towards the five-fold sensual pleasures, seeing that such
pleasures are not worth even a bit of dung.
70
(7) Bull forgotten - Man remains
The "bull" is notrung but only a part of mental formations. When the
mind becomes void, all formations will be completely dissolved
away. It is as if we have forgotten the entire w1iverse. The mind and
the body both become entirely soft and light, subtle and peaceful,
and cool and tranquillized. When such a situation exists, even in the
world of formations that kindless the fire of defilements, he can
now be "in a deep sleep whilst being awake".* The 37
enlightenment factors used for this restraint, after becoming a
tranquillized state ofhis mind, remain and lie silently by a side.
The heart is completely empty and nothing can remain there in
that emptiness. And having been shattered all bondages that had
been so far spread throughout the entire universe, the mind, like
the empty space between the earth and divine abodes, is now
filled with complete nothingness. No regulator is there in that
''universal emptiness''.
Like a pebble sunk into water, the world of five aggregates
submerges in the Nibbanic-bliss. There remains only the "house
ofNibbana". All formations have been dissolved away. Self or
the perception of self has completely been ceased away. The
Nibbanic-bliss bubbles and overflows like a fountain sounding
"Oh what-bliss, oh what-bliss". He holds no doubts about
the"Anupadisesa Nibbanadhatu" ( the Nibbana-element with no
residue is left) which becomes eternal after the final passing away
of anArahant.
The mind that had been continuously active accumulating mental
formations due to ignorance has now, having experienced the
cessation of ignorance, turned into a simple empty awareness.
(i.e. He behaves actively just like an ordinary man; his liberated "inner"
mind remains calm, still and completely unaffected with the external world
or with his five aggregates).
7l
That simple awareness depends on the "kammic" formations of
the previous life which generated the re-birth linking conssiousness.
And with the cessation of that "kammic" power, that simple
awareness, too, will be ceased away for ever. Thereafter, never
again will a rebirth linking consuiousness arise. He has no doubts
whatsoever about the cessation of consciousness or the
cessation of becoming. In that emptiness there exists no
perception ofbeings or any other formations.
How can any other mental formation remain there within that total
cessation of all formations.?
(8) Bull and Man both forgotten
He is now capable of shattering and destroying the path like the
nose-string, the cause of suffering like the bull, and suffering like
the man, as if a large bomb is dropped. Then it appears only an
immaterial state of emptiness, devoid of all mental images of forms,
and the all perceptions of matter and resistence. It is boundless
and it akins to the empty universal space with no beginning or
end. In that emptiness the whole universe is completely dissolved
away and there exists only the space. Not a single image of forms
appears within the mind. The authenticity of this could be realized
only through experience.
So far, the whole three worlds were there for him to embrace
with the idea of "me and mine"; hence he had to keep on
safeguarding them continuously. When the idea of "I am"
(Asmimana) is completely destroyed, which world would
72
remain there to be protected ? When this situation is compared
with his past, he would really feel ashamed of his deception that
he had in his mind. When everything including Nibbana is
relinquished ("Patinissagganupassi Viharati" - when
contemplating relinquishment), then there can remain no
formations either conditional or unconditional within the mind.
Then all attachements and clingings towards everything are
totally ceased away. This may not be comprehended by a person
having no pragmatic vision.
The universal emptiness now appearing, too, is simply a ve:ty subtle
mentle formation that would mislead one to assume it to be "the
end". But this is the deepest point of ignorance. This too is
impermanent and not-self. When this is realized with his supreme
wisdom, this universal emptiness at once collapses down. All
dualities including self and non-self are destroyed once and for
all. This is the end of this supra mundane path.
The mind now always shines like the cold luminous moon full of
soft light. Visible are all enticing and charming sense-objects in
the world as before. The streams of simple consciousnesses
-emerging through sense impingements simply flow, rising and
falling. But no other mental formations are produced within the
mind involuntarily.
"Ditthe ditthamattam bhavissati, sute sutamattam
bhavissati .......... " In reference to seen, there will be only seen.
In reference to heard, there will be only heard ..... " and so on,
with regard to the other senses.
73
(9) Return to origin back to the source
Having relinquished all attachments and bondages the mind
remains completely unaffected, and it isolates itself from the
external and internal world of five aggregates. All have been
completed; there is nothing more to be done. The one, born blind
and deaf, experiences no mental formations arising through
visible or audible objects. When one is detached from everything
after destroying all bonds, his mind, as if he suddenly becomes
blind and deaf, just remains at the stage of simple awareness of
sense-objects, without producing mental formations to perceive
them as good-bad-beautiful-ugly etc.
"Ditthe ditthamattam ...... Sute Satamattam ........ "
This mind called - .... !n,.:.,� .. ·"" .... ,..fl-l· ..
0
• ., ceto vimutti" the unshakable
deliverance of the mind, does not come out of the heart and
constantly resides within the heart itself. The heart is its own
residential hut. Then the external world, and the other
consciousnesses arising through the contacts of sense-objects,
all become external to this mind. This liberated mind has no
object-no limit-no arising and no falling. It just leisurely remains
there detached from the whole universe for ever. Therefore, it is
alone and unlimited. Whenever the impingements of sense
objects are there, the streams of simple consciousnesses just arise
and fall without producing no other mental formations
mvoluntarily. Whatever the things there had been in the world,
they all exist as before. The difference is that just a simple
awareness remains alone compltely unaffected and detached from
all conventional realities. The five aggregates continue to rise and
fall as usual. This liberated mind simply remains alone as a
separate entity. Though they are inter-related, they remain and
function separately.
Dualities such as "self-non self, good-bad, beautiful-ugly" etc. are
74
no more there in the mind. Therefore, he can now fearlessly look at any sense-objects. In the past -yesterday- there were some deceptive mental formations such as good - bad etc. in the mind. But today ........ all such things have been slipped off and only the luminous simple awareness remains. "Sabbato pabham ................ " luminous all around ...... "
Through the four reviewing knowledges that arise spontaneously at the time of realizing the final path and fruition, or thereafter, a knowledge arises in him realizing that "Khina jati, vusitam brahma cariyam, katam kar�niyam, naP.aram. ittatthayati pajanati" - birth is now destroyed, the holy life has been led, done what had to be done, there is nothing more to do". Within this unshakable deliverance of the mind, no mental formations glide through sense-objects as before, for it remains alone after destroying ignorance that clouded the sufferings so far experienced by perceiving sense-objects as "good-bad, me -mine" etc. and by getting entangled with such objects and thereby accumulating mental formations. Therefore, mental formations have now becomes absolutely silent. Only the pure delightful and simple awareness radiates brightly. When he peers into this "inner" mind with the "surface or outer" mind of it, he sees that not even a slight trace oflust, anger or delusion is left there.
Also he realizes that the liberated mind and the tranquillized virtue, tranquillized concentration, tranquillized wisdom and the tranquillized deliverance, all of them have now become into one and the same phenomenon. Then there arises in him a supreme happiness calm, cool and peaceful.
75
(10) Entering the market-place with bliss
bestowing hands
Free of all taints and defilements such as dishonesty,
deceitfulness, hypocrisy, treachery etc, he now becomes a
"totally open-hearted" person having no difference between his
"inner" and "outer" mind. Step by step he comes closer and closer
towards "Anupadisesa Nibbana" (Nibbana element without any
substratum), and his feet are "opened" as they are not covered or
shackled by any bondage. He moves on along a supreme path in
order to lead others towards Nibbana. He now moves into
society. He comes across worldlings whose minds are filled with
perceptions that are really worthless, and he sees various
intoxicating sense objects that would cover one's mind with the
dust of defilements. Without any attachment or aversion towards
them, he moves on hapilly. "Santusitatta thito" - owing to his
release and happiness, he is steady. Such objects no longer trouble
his mind. The objects once he perceived as ugly, disgustive and
loathsome, and thereby becoming resentful are now look like trees
with full ofblosoms because they now effortlessly show him the
reality in them. And he can now look at them as he wishes, either
repulsively, or with equanimity.
"So sace akankhati patikkule A p patikkfila sanni
Vihareyyanti, appatikkfila sanni tattha viharati ..... " In the
presence of what is loathsome, ifhe wants, he remains perciepient
of unloathsomeness ..... "
He thus comes, not from a world of sensual pleasure (Kama
bhumi), a world of forms (rupa bhumi), a world of immaterial
( arupa bhumi) but from a supra mundane world ( apariyapanna
bhumi). He does not resist anybody or anything, but he is always
equanimous and friendly to all. His features may not be so
pleasant, but when he shakes his Dhamma-wand, the palace doors
76
of Nibbana will be opened for him. I-Ie then enjoys the Nibbanic
bliss.
That Dhamma-wand with a dear knowledge of realization is not
curve, but straight. The flow of Dhamma comes, with a clear
knowledge of understanding, straight from his heart. They are not
mere perceptions, but the true Dhamma apparent in his heart.
What he says with a delightful heart may not be easily
understood, for it may be so profound to be comprehended.
11Pafifinavat6 ayam dhamm6, nayam dhamm6 duppafiiiassa"
- "This Dhamma is for one who endowed with discernment - not
for one whose discernment is weak". The door of the palace of
Nibbana will be opened for anyone who meets him within his
own mind. He is a stranger who has been always with you, but
you may not aware of him, because of your own ignorance.
That's
77