UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
x MARK A. FAVORS, et al.
C.A. No. 11-CV-05632 Plaintiffs, (RR)(GEL)(DLI)(RLM)
v. ECF CASE
ANDREW M. CUOMO, et al.
Defendants. X
DECLARATION OF LEE D. APOTHEKER
Lee D. Apotheker declares pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746:
1. I am an Associate with the law firm of Pannone Lopes Devereaux & West LLC, which
represents Intervenor-Plaintiff Yitzchok Ullman in the above-captioned action. I submit this
declaration in support of Mr. Ullman's claim for relief.
2. Attached hereto as Exhibit A (and mailed to the individual chambers of each judge) is a
true and correct copy of a map which portrays the borders of current Assembly district 95.
Exhibit A also portrays the borders of individual villages and election districts, and contains
the periphery of the surrounding Assembly districts. Exhibit A portrays current Assembly
district 95 in blue. Current Assembly district 95 is represented by the Hon. Ellen C. Jaffee.
Exhibit A was prepared by the Rockland County Planning Department.
3. Attached hereto as Exhibit B are the results of individual Ramapo election districts in and
around the village of New Square. Specifically, Exhibit B contains the results from Ramapo
election districts 10, 21, 23, 30, 42, 55, 58, 63, 87, and 88. These election districts were
overwhelmingly carried by Assemblywoman Jaffee in the 2010 election. Furthermore, upon
information and belief, under the Defendants' redistricting plan, these election districts will
{N0037011V 1}
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334 Filed 04/27/12 Page 1 of 4 PageID #: 6158
be within proposed Assembly district 97. Upon information and belief, Assemblywoman
Jaffee, who also resides within proposed Assembly district 97, will run for re-election as the
member of Assembly from proposed district 97. The election results were provided by the
website of the Rockland County Board of Elections.
4. Attached hereto as Exhibit C are the results of individual election districts in and around
the Village of Kaser and the hamlet of Monsey. Specifically, Exhibit C contains the results
from Ramapo elections districts 18, 21, 24, 28, 35, 36, 41, 49, 56, 64, and 85. In the 2010
election, Ramapo election districts 18, 24, 28, 35, 41, and 56 were carried by
Assemblywoman Jaffee's opponent, Thomas A. Morr. Ramapo election districts 21, 36, 49,
and 64 were carried by Assemblywoman Jaffee but had either a small margin of victory,
significant amounts of under votes, or both. Furthermore, upon information and belief, under
Defendants' redistricting plan, these election districts, which are within current Assembly
district 95, have been cut out of Assemblywoman Jaffee's district and distributed into
proposed districts 96 and 98. The election results were also provided by the website of the
Rockland County Board of Elections.
5. Attached hereto as Exhibit D are the results of the Ramapo election districts from the
2006 Democratic primary election, the 2006 general election, the 2008 Democratic primary
election and the 2008 general election. By way of example, in the 2006 primary election, out
of 609 ballots cast in Ramapo election district 35 (encompassing all of the Village of Kaser),
six were cast in favor of Ms. Jaffee. In the general election, seventy-one votes out of a total
of 677 ballots were cast for Ms. Jaffee.
6. In the 2008 primary, District 35 was similarly hostile to Ms Jaffee. She only garnered
three votes out of 178 ballots that were cast. In the general election, where she ran
{N0037011 V 1}
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334 Filed 04/27/12 Page 2 of 4 PageID #: 6159
unopposed, she only garnered ninety-six votes out of 810 ballots cast. The election results
were also provided by the website of the Rockland County Board of Elections.
7. As stated earlier, the results from the individual election districts submitted as Exhibits B,
and C are in and around the villages of New Square and Kaser and the hamlet of Monsey.
New Square, Kaser, and Monsey are places where the majority of the residents are Chassidic
Jews. The effect of the Defendants' redistricting plan is to separate these Jewish
communities among three different Assembly districts, thereby diluting the community's
ability to elect a member of Assembly who represents its interests. For more than 20 years,
this community has been united in the same Assembly district.
8. Upon information and belief and based upon the attached election results, Defendants'
redistricting plan, as it pertains to proposed districts 96, 97, and 98, was drawn specifically to
protect the incumbent member of assembly and create a "safe" district in order to assist her
re-election campaign. "State legislative plans with population deviations of less than 10%
may be challenged based on alleged violation of the one person, one vote principle." Larios
v. Cox, 300 F. Supp. 2d 1320, 1341 (Three-judge panel, N.D. Ga. 2004). "The proper
judicial approach to a one person, one vote claim is to ascertain whether, under the particular
circumstances existing in the individual State whose legislative apportionment is at issue,
there has been a faithful adherence to a plan of population-based representation, which such
minor deviations only as may occur in recognizing certain factors that are free from the taint
of arbitrariness or discrimination." Id.
9. Upon information and belief, Defendants' apportionment plan as it pertains to proposed
districts 96, 97, and 98 promotes only the protection of an incumbent member of Assembly.
While the State has a legitimate interest in preventing incumbent members from running
{N0037011 V 1}
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334 Filed 04/27/12 Page 3 of 4 PageID #: 6160
against one another, the protection of incumbents generally is a not a legitimate state purpose
which can justify population deviations. Larios at 1348.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the attached exhibits are true and accurate
representations of the geographic areas concerned and the election results. I further declare
under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Dated: White Plains, New York April 27, 2012
Lee D. Apotheker
{N0037011 V 1}
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334 Filed 04/27/12 Page 4 of 4 PageID #: 6161
EXHIBIT
A
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-1 Filed 04/27/12 Page 1 of 2 PageID #: 6162
O O
a
3
rs
tn .7, a a a
n A. •
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-1 Filed 04/27/12 Page 2 of 2 PageID #: 6163
EXHIBIT
B
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 1 of 51 PageID #: 6164
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
10
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 2 of 51 PageID #: 6165
Page 1 of 4
District Summary Rockland County Board of Elections
OFFICIAL RESULTS
11/24/10
0178 Ramapo 10 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 412 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 348 86.57 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 33 8.21 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 5 1.24 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 5 1.24 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 6 1.49 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 2 .50 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 2 .50 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 1 .25 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 402 Over Votes 2 Under Votes 7
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 309 79.43 Harry Wilson (REP) 54 13.88 Harry Wilson (IND) 9 2.31 Harry Wilson (CON) 7 1.80 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 5 1.29 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 4 1.03 John Gaetani (LBT) 1 .26 WRITE-IN 0
Total 389 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 22
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 298 78.22 Dan Donovan (REP) 58 15.22 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 8 2.10 Dan Donovan (CON) 10 2.62 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 5 1.31 Carl E. Person (LBT) 1 .26 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 1 .26 WRITE-IN 0
Total 381 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 30
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 3 of 51 PageID #: 6166
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 336 84.42 Jay Townsend (REP) 40 10.05 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 8 2.01 Jay Townsend (CON) 6 1.51 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 6 1.51 Colia Clark (GRN) 2 .50 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 398 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 14
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 305 81.77 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 44 11.80 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 8 2.14 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 7 1.88 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 8 2.14 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) , 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP), Bruce Blakeman (TRP)
1 0
.27
WRITE-IN 0 Total 373
Over Votes 1 Under Votes 38
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 302 21.92 Linda Christopher (DEM) 299 21.70 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 269 19.52 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 271 19.67 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 43 3.12 James Maisano (REP) 42 3.05 Gerry Klein (REP) 43 3.12 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 41 2.98 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 7 .51 James Maisano (IND) 5 .36 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 6 .44 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 5 .36 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 4 .29 James Maisano (CON) 5 .36 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 7 .51 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 5 .36 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 7 .51 Linda Christopher (WOR) 7 .51 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 5 .36 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 3 .22 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 1 .07 WRITE-IN 1 .07
Total 1378 Over Votes 0
http://www.co.rocidand.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 4 of 51 PageID #: 6167
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 266
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 319 82.22 Anthony Mele (REP) 50 12.89 York Kleinhandler (CON) 8 2.06 Eliot L. Engel (WOR). 11 2.84 WRITE-IN 0
Total 388 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 24
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 324 82.03 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 55 13.92 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 6 1.52 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 2 .51 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 8 2.03 WRITE-IN 0
Total 395 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 16
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 318 82.81 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 45 11.72 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 5 1.30 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 6 1.56 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 10 2.60 WRITE-IN 0
Total 384 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 27
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 304 91.02 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 13 3.89 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 7 2.10 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 10 2.99 WRITE-IN 0
Total 334 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 77
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 281 76.57 Robert Romanowski (REP) 66 17.98 Daniel Friedman (IND) 7 1.91 Daniel Friedman (CON) 5 1.36
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 5 of 51 PageID #: 6168
Page 4 of 4
Daniel Friedman (WOR) 8 2.18 WRITE-IN 0
Total 367 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 44
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 313 82.59 Noah Weinberg (REP) 44 11.61 David J. Stein (IND) 9 2.37 Noah Weinberg (CON) 3 .79 David J. Stein (WOR) 10 2.64 WRITE-IN 0
Total 379 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 32
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.ba 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 6 of 51 PageID #: 6169
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
21
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 7 of 51 PageID #: 6170
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County
OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0189 Ramapo 21 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 548 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 118 34.20 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 202 58.55 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 6 1.74 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 14 4.06 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 2 .58 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 0 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 1 .29 WRITE-IN 2 .58
Total 345 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 191
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 272 62.10 Harry Wilson (REP) 139 31.74 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 .68 Harry Wilson (CON) 16 3.65 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 7 1.60 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .23
Total 438 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 98
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 294 65.48 Dan Donovan (REP) 125 27.84 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 8 1.78 Dan Donovan (CON) 13 2.90 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 6 1.34 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 3 .67
Total 449 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 88
http.//www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.0ct 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 8 of 51 PageID #: 6171
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 173 48.32 Jay Townsend (REP) 158 44.13 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 8 2.23 Jay Townsend (CON) 17 4.75 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 2 .56 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 358 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 190
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 182 37.92 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 257 53.54 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 12 2.50 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 22 4.58 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 5 1.04 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 2 .42 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 480 Over Votes 4 Under Votes 64
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 301 17.59 Linda Christopher (DEM) 298 17.42 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 216 12.62 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 70 4.09 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 195 11.40 James Maisano (REP) 319 18.64 Gerry Klein (REP) 111 6.49 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 92 5.38 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) .41 James Maisano (IND) 16 .94 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 6 .35 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 3 .18 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 14 .82 James Maisano (CON) 19 1.11 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 10 .58 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 12 .70 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 7 .41 Linda Christopher (WOR) 10 .58 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 1 .06 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 0 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 0 WRITE-IN 4 .23
Total 1711 Over Votes 4
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 9 of 51 PageID #: 6172
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 433
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 328 71.62 Anthony Mele (REP) 101 22.05 York Kleinhandler (CON) 16 3.49 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 7 1.53 WRITE-IN 6 1.31
Total 458 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 89
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 57 11.11 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 420 81.87 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 15 2.92 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 18 3.51 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 2 .39 WRITE-IN 1 .19
Total 513 Over Votes 2 Under Votes 22
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 218 57.07 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 138 36.13 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 7 1.83 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 16 4.19 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 2 .52 WRITE-IN 1 .26
Total 382 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 155
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 388 91.29 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 12 2.82 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 19 4.47 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 4 .94 WRITE-IN 2 .47
Total 425 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 112
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 419 83.30 Robert Romanowski (REP) 51 10.14 Daniel Friedman (IND) 13 2.58 Daniel Friedman (CON) 17 3.38
http://wwvv.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 10 of 51 PageID #: 6173
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
2 1
Page 4 of 4
.40
.20 Total 503
Over Votes 1 Under Votes 33
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 378 75.15 Noah Weinberg (REP) 95 18.89 David J. Stein (IND) 9 1.79 Noah Weinberg (CON) 16 3.18 David J. Stein (WOR) 4 .80 WRITE-IN 1 .20
Total 503 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 34
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 11 of 51 PageID #: 6174
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
23
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 12 of 51 PageID #: 6175
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County
OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0191 Ramapo 23 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 252 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 203 82.19 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 25 10.12 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 2 .81 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 6 2.43 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 1 .40 Warren Redlich (LBT) 4 1.62 Charles Barron (FDM) 4 1.62 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 1 .40 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .40
Total 247 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 3
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 163 71.81 Harry Wilson (REP) 42 18.50 Harry Wilson (IND) 4 1.76 Harry Wilson (CON) 7 3.08 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 2 .88 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 6 2.64 John Gaetani (LBT) 3 1.32 WRITE-IN 0
Total 227 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 22
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 175 77.09 Dan Donovan (REP) 39 17.18 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 4 1.76 Dan Donovan (CON) 7 3.08 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 1 .44 Carl E. Person (LBT) 1 .44 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 227 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 23
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 13 of 51 PageID #: 6176
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 201 82.38 Jay Townsend (REP) 28 11.48 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 4 1.64 Jay Townsend (CON) 8 3.28 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 2 .82 Colia Clark (GRN) 1 .41 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 244 Over Votes 2
Under Votes 6
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 180 78.26 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 31 13.48 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 5 2.17 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 7 3.04 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 3 1.30 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 2 .87 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 1 .43 Vivia Morgan (APP) 1 .43 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 230 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 22
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 176 20.66 Linda Christopher ( DEM) 173 20.31 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 157 18.43 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 159 18.66 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 28 3.29 James Maisano (REP) 30 3.52 Gerry Klein (REP) 37 4.34 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 35 4.11 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 2 .23 James Maisano (IND) 2 .23 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 4 .47 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 4 .47 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 7 .82 James Maisano (CON) 8 .94 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 6 .70 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 8 .94 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 3 .35 Linda Christopher (WOR) 5 .59 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 1 .12 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 3 .35 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 4 .47 WRITE-IN 0
Total 852 Over Votes 0
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 14 of 51 PageID #: 6177
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 148
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 189 80.08 Anthony Mele (REP) 33 13.98 York Kleinhandler (CON) 8 3.39 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 6 2.54 WRITE-IN 0
Total 236 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 16
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 180 75.00 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 44 18.33 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 5 2.08 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 7 2.92 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 4 1.67 WRITE-IN 0
Total 240 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 10
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 187 80.26 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 33 14.16 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 5 2.15 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 6 2.58 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 2 .86 WRITE-IN 0
Total 233 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 17
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 174 87.00 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 7 3.50 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 13 6.50 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 6 3.00 WRITE-IN 0
Total 200 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 50
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 174 78.38 Robert Romanowski (REP) 34 15.32 Daniel Friedman (IND) 4 1.80 Daniel Friedman (CON) 6 2.70
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt
4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 15 of 51 PageID #: 6178
Daniel Friedman (WOR) 4
Page 4 of 4
1.80 WRITE-IN 0
Total 222 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 28
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 178 80.18 Noah Weinberg (REP) 26 11.71 David J. Stein (IND) 6 2.70 Noah Weinberg (CON) 7 3.15 David J. Stein (WOR) 5 2.25 WRITE-IN 0
Total 222 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 28
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 16 of 51 PageID #: 6179
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
30
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 17 of 51 PageID #: 6180
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0198 Ramapo 30 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 462 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 67 23.26 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 187 64.93 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 3 1.04 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 16 5.56 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 3 1.04 Warren Redlich (LBT) 2 .69 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 6 2.08 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 1 .35 WRITE-IN 3 1.04
Total 288 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 171
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 178 51.59 Harry Wilson (REP) 141 40.87 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 .87 Harry Wilson (CON) 17 4.93 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 5 1.45 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 1 .29 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 345 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 113
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 212 59.38 Dan Donovan (REP) 121 33.89 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 4 1.12 Dan Donovan (CON) 14 3.92 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 6 1.68 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 357 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 102
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 18 of 51 PageID #: 6181
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 87 32.34 Jay Townsend (REP) 163 60.59 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 1 .37 Jay Townsend (CON) 17 6.32 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 1 .37 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 269 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 193
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 127 33.42 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 228 60.00 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 1 .26 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 21 5.53 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 2 .53 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .26
Total 380 Over Votes 2 Under Votes 80
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 199 15.25 Linda Christopher (DEM) 213 16.32 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 155 11.88 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 20 1.53 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 164 12.57 James Maisano (REP) 284 21.76 Gerry Klein (REP) 107 8.20 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 84 6.44 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 1 .08 James Maisano (IND) 3 .23 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 1 .08 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 1 .08 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 13 1.00 James Maisano (CON) 16 1.23 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 10 .77 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 10 .77 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 5 .38 Linda Christopher (WOR) 6 .46 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 4 .31 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 2 .15 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 1 .08 WRITE-IN 6 .46
Total 1305 Over Votes 4
http://wwvv.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 19 of 51 PageID #: 6182
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 527
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 214 60.62 Anthony Mele (REP) 94 26.63 York Kleinhandler (CON) 39 11.05 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 1 .28 WRITE-IN 5 1.42
Total 353 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 109
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 13 3.00 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 392 90.32 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 6 1.38 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 22 5.07 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .23
Total 434 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 25
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY. 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 161 53.31 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 126 41.72 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 2 .66 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 13 4.30 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 302 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 156
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 316 91.59 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 8 2.32 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 20 5.80 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 1 .29 WRITE-IN 0
Total 345 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 114
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 355 85.34 Robert Romanowski (REP) 36 8.65 Daniel Friedman (IND) 5 1.20 Daniel Friedman (CON) 18 4.33
http.//www.co.rocIdand.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 20 of 51 PageID #: 6183
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
2 0
Page 4 of 4
.48
Total 416 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 42
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 321 78.87 Noah Weinberg (REP) 61 14.99 David J. Stein (IND) 8 1.97 Noah Weinberg (CON) 11 2.70 David J. Stein (WOR) 6 1.47 WRITE-IN 0
Total 407 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 51
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 21 of 51 PageID #: 6184
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
42
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 22 of 51 PageID #: 6185
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County
OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0210 Ramapo 42 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 536 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 1 .19
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 466 88.76 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 27 5.14 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 4 .76 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 7 1.33 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 13 2.48 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 0 Warren Redlich (LBT) 1 .19 Charles Barron (FDM) 6 1.14 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 0 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .19
Total 525 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 9
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 412 84.60 Harry Wilson (REP) 41 8.42 Harry Wilson (IND) 7 1.44 Harry Wilson (CON) 8 1.64 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 13 2.67 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 3 .62 John Gaetani (LBT) 3 .62 WRITE-IN 0
Total 487 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 48
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 420 85.19 Dan Donovan (REP) 40 8.11 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 6 1.22 Dan Donovan (CON) 8 1.62 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 15 3.04 Carl E. Person (LBT) 2 .41 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 2 .41 WRITE-IN 0
Total 493 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 42
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 23 of 51 PageID #: 6186
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1
Page 2 of 4
Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 447 88.69 Jay Townsend (REP) 31 6.15 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 5 .99 Jay Townsend (CON) 7 1.39 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 10 1.98 Colia Clark (GRN) 1 .20 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 3 .60 WRITE-IN 0
Total 504 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 32
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 412 86.92 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 37 7.81 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 4 .84 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 7 1.48 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 10 2.11 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 1 .21 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 2 .42 Vivia Morgan (APP) 1 .21 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 474 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 62
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 397 22.20 Linda Christopher (DEM) 409 22.87 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 379 21.20 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 381 21.31 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 35 1.96 James Maisano (REP) 33 1.85 Gerry Klein (REP) 36 2.01 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 31 1.73 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 5 .28 James Maisano (IND) 7 .39 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 7 .39 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 6 .34 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 6 .34 James Maisano (CON) 5 .28 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 6 .34 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 12 .67 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 9 .50 Linda Christopher (WOR) 9 .50 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 10 .56 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 2 .11 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 3 .17 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1788 Over Votes 0
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 24 of 51 PageID #: 6187
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 352
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 429 87.91 Anthony Mele (REP) 39 7.99 York Kleinhandler (CON) 11 2.25 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 9 1.84 WRITE-IN 0
Total 488 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 48
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 426 85.54 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 49 9.84 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 5 1.00 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 6 1.20 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 12 2.41 WRITE-IN 0
Total 498 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 37
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 437 88.82 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 31 6.30 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 7 1.42 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 6 1.22 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 11 2.24 WRITE-IN 0
Total 492 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 43
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 407 92.71 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 10 2.28 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 12 2.73 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 10 2.28 WRITE-IN 0
Total 439 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 96
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 392 84.30 Robert Romanowski (REP) 56 12.04 Daniel Friedman (IND) 5 1.08 Daniel Friedman (CON) 5 1.08
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 25 of 51 PageID #: 6188
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
7 0
Page 4 of 4
1.51
Total 465 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 70
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 419 89.34 Noah Weinberg (REP) 31 6.61 David J. Stein (IND) 4 .85 Noah Weinberg (CON) 9 1.92 David J. Stein (WOR) 6 1.28 WRITE-IN 0
Total 469 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 66
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 26 of 51 PageID #: 6189
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
55
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 27 of 51 PageID #: 6190
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County
OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0223 Ramapo 55 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 1103 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 1 .09
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 1007 93.41 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 60 5.57 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 7 .65 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 2 .19 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 2 .19 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 0 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 0 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1078 Over Votes 4 Under Votes 21
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 1020 94.62 Harry Wilson (REP) 50 4.64 Harry Wilson (IND) 1 .09 Harry Wilson (CON) 2 .19 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 5 .46 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1078 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 25
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 1033 95.47 Dan Donovan (REP) 41 3.79 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 3 .28 Dan Donovan (CON) 1 .09 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 4 .37 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1082 Over Votes 2
Under Votes 19
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 28 of 51 PageID #: 6191
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 1021 94.71 Jay Townsend (REP) 52 4.82 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 1 .09 Jay Townsend (CON) 0 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 4 .37 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1078 Over Votes 2
Under Votes 23
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 1004 93.48 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 64 5.96 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 0 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 0 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 3 .28 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 1 .09 Joseph Huff (RDH) 1 .09 John Clifton (LBT) 1 .09 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1074 Over Votes 2 Under Votes 27
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 37 .89 Linda Christopher (DEM) 991 23.86 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 987 23.76 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 33 .79 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 982 23.64 James Maisano (REP) 979 23.57 Gerry Klein (REP) 54 1.30 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 38 .91 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 18 .43 James Maisano (IND) 20 .48 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 1 .02 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 2 .05 James Maisano (CON) 2 .05 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 1 .02 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 0 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 0 Linda Christopher (WOR) 4 .10 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 3 .07 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .02 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 1 .02 WRITE-IN 0
Total 4154 Over Votes 84
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 29 of 51 PageID #: 6192
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 174
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 1025 94.91 Anthony Mele (REP) . 36 3.33 York Kleinhandler (CON) 16 1.48 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 3 .28 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1080 Over Votes 2
Under Votes 21
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 27 2.59 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 996 95.49 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 17 1.63 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 2 .19 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 1 .10 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1043 Over Votes 19 Under Votes 41
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 1030 95.28 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 46 4.26 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 2 .19 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 0 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 3 .28 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1081 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 22
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 1019 99.32 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 2 .19 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 2 .19 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 3 .29 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1026 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 77
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 1030 95.55 Robert Romanowski (REP) 42 3.90 Daniel Friedman (IND) 2 .19 Daniel Friedman (CON) 1 .09
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 30 of 51 PageID #: 6193
Page 4 of 4
Daniel Friedman (WOR) 3 .28 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1078 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 24
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 1020 94.53 Noah Weinberg (REP) 53 4.91 David J. Stein (IND) 2 .19 Noah Weinberg (CON) 1 .09 David J. Stein (WOR) 3 .28 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1079 Over Votes 4 Under Votes 20
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 31 of 51 PageID #: 6194
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
58
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 32 of 51 PageID #: 6195
Page 1 of 4
District Summary Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0226 Ramapo 58 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 858 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 800 94.45 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 42 4.96 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 4 .47 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 1 .12 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 0 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 0 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 847 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 10
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 807 96.30 Harry Wilson (REP) 31 3.70 Harry Wilson (IND) 0 Harry Wilson (CON) 0 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 0 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 838 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 20
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 813 96.33 Dan Donovan (REP) 30 3.55 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 1 .12 Dan Donovan (CON) 0 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 0 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 844 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 14
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 33 of 51 PageID #: 6196
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1
Page 2 of 4
Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 805 95.49 Jay Townsend (REP) 38 4.51 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 0 Jay Townsend (CON) 0 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 0 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 843 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 15
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 797 94.88 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 43 5.12 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 0 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 0 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 0 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 840 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 18
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 17 .52 Linda Christopher (DEM) 800 24.25 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 800 24.25 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 18 .55 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 789 23.92 James Maisano (REP) 779 23.61 Gerry Klein (REP) 29 .88 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 19 .58 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 19 .58 James Maisano (IND) 20 .61 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 0 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 1 .03 James Maisano (CON) 3 .09 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 1 .03 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 0 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 0 Linda Christopher (WOR) 1 .03 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .03 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 2 .06 WRITE-IN 0
Total 3299 Over Votes 4
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 34 of 51 PageID #: 6197
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 129
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 816 96.34 Anthony Mele (REP) 18 2.13 York Kleinhandler (CON) 13 1.53 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 847 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 11
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 21 2.55 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 783 94.91 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 18 2.18 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 3 .36 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 825 Over Votes 10 Under Votes 23
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 805 95.83 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 34 4.05 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 1 .12 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 0 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 840 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 17
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 810 99.63 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 2 .25 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 1 .12 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 813 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 45
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 814 96.90 Robert Romanowski (REP) 24 2.86 Daniel Friedman (IND) 1 .12 Daniel Friedman (CON) 1 .12
http.//wvvw.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 35 of 51 PageID #: 6198
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
0 0
Page 4 of 4
Total 840 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 18
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 803 95.71 Noah Weinberg (REP) 35 4.17 David J. Stein (IND) 1 .12 Noah Weinberg (CON) 0 David J. Stein (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 839 Over Votes 2 Under Votes 17
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 36 of 51 PageID #: 6199
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
63
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 37 of 51 PageID #: 6200
Page 1 of 4
District Summary Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0231 Ramapo 63 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 294 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 261 91.90 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 8 2.82 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 2 .70 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 1 .35 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 5 1.76 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 1 .35 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 6 2.11 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 0 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 284 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 7
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 233 91.02 Harry Wilson (REP) 10 3.91 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 1.17 Harry Wilson (CON) 1 .39 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 6 2.34 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 2 .78 John Gaetani (LBT) 1 .39 WRITE-IN 0
Total 256 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 35
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 232 90.27 Dan Donovan (REP) 11 4.28 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 1 .39 Dan Donovan (CON) 2 .78 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 9 3.50 Carl E. Person (LBT) 1 .39 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 1 .39 WRITE-IN 0
Total 257 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 34
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 38 of 51 PageID #: 6201
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 249 92.91 Jay Townsend (REP) 7 2.61 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 1 .37 Jay Townsend (CON) 2 .75 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 8 2.99 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 1 .37 WRITE-IN 0
Total 268 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 26
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 216 90.00 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 8 3.33 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 2 .83 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 4 1.67 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 6 2.50 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 1 .42 Joseph Huff (RDH) 1 .42 John Clifton (LBT) 1 .42 Vivia Morgan (APP) 1 .42 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 240 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 54
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 205 22.68 Linda Christopher (DEM) 223 24.67 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 195 21.57 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 203 22.46 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 7 .77 James Maisano (REP) 8 .88 Gerry Klein (REP) 9 1.00 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 6 .66 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 2 .22 James Maisano (IND) 3 .33 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 2 .22 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 1 .11 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 1 .11 James Maisano (CON) 1 .11 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 1 .11 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 3 .33 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 9 1.00 Linda Christopher (WOR) 10 1.11 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 7 .77 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) . 3 .33 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 5 .55 WRITE-IN 0
Total 904 Over Votes 0
http://www.co.roeldand.ny.us/130E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 39 of 51 PageID #: 6202
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 260
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 235 89.35 Anthony Mele (REP) 12 4.56 York Kleinhandler (CON) 2 .76 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 14 5.32 WRITE-IN 0
Total 263 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 31
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 230 89.15 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 12 4.65 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 4 1.55 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 2 .78 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 10 3.88 WRITE-IN 0
Total 258 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 33
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 250 91.24 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 8 2.92 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 2 .73 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 1 .36 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 13 4.74 WRITE-IN 0
Total 274 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 17
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 215 93.48 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 1 .43 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 1 .43 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 13 5.65 WRITE-IN 0
Total 230 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 61
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 212 88.70 Robert Romanowski (REP) 12 5.02 Daniel Friedman (IND) 2 .84 Daniel Friedman (CON) 3 1.26
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 40 of 51 PageID #: 6203
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
10 0
Page 4 of 4
4.18
Total 239 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 52
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 224 90.69 Noah Weinberg (REP) 9 3.64 David J. Stein (IND) 2 .81 Noah Weinberg (CON) 1 .40 David J. Stein (WOR) 11 4.45 WRITE-IN 0
Total 247 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 44
littp://www.co.rockland.ny.us/BOE/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 41 of 51 PageID #: 6204
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
87
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 42 of 51 PageID #: 6205
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0255 Ramapo 87 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 334 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 269 81.27 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 34 10.27 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 6 1.81 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 7 2.11 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 7 2.11 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 1 .30 Warren Redlich (LBT) 1 .30 Charles Barron (FDM) 5 1.51 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 1 .30 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 331 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 2
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 228 76.25 Harry Wilson (REP) 44 14.72 Harry Wilson (IND) 8 2.68 Harry Wilson (CON) 6 2.01 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 8 2.68 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 5 1.67 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 299 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 33
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 227 75.92 Dan Donovan (REP) 43 14.38 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 8 2.68 Dan Donovan (CON) 12 4.01 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 7 2.34 Carl E. Person (LBT) 1 .33 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 1 .33 WRITE-IN 0
Total 299 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 34
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 43 of 51 PageID #: 6206
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 264 82.24 Jay Townsend (REP) 31 9.66 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 10 3.12 Jay Townsend (CON) 8 2.49 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 7 2.18 Colia Clark (GRN) 1 .31 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 321 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 13
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 238 79.60 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 36 12.04 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 7 2.34 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 7 2.34 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 8 2.68 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 2 .67 Joseph Huff (RDH) 1 .33 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 299 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 35
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 225 20.16 Linda Christopher (DEM) 230 20.61 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 201 18.01 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 211 18.91 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 36 3.23 James Maisano (REP) 35 3.14 Gerry Klein (REP) 48 4.30 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 34 3.05 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 7 .63 James Maisano (IND) 7 .63 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 6 .54 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 9 .81 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 8 .72 James Maisano (CON) 7 .63 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 10 .90 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 11 .99 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 10 .90 Linda Christopher (WOR) 11 .99 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 6 .54 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .09 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 3 .27 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1116 Over Votes 0
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 44 of 51 PageID #: 6207
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 216
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 254 81.67 Anthony Mele (REP) 39 12.54 York Kleinhandler (CON) 8 2.57 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 10 3.22 WRITE-IN 0
Total 311 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 23
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 258 81.13 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 39 12.26 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 3 .94 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 7 2.20 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 11 3.46 WRITE-IN 0
Total 318 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 15
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 243 79.93 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 32 10.53 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 11 3.62 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 7 2.30 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 11 3.62 WRITE-IN 0
Total 304 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 29
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 232 87.55 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 15 5.66 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 11 4.15 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 7 2.64 WRITE-IN 0
Total 265 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 68
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 218 74.40 Robert Romanowski (REP) 57 19.45 Daniel Friedman (IND) 6 2.05 Daniel Friedman (CON) 5 1.71
http://vvww.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 45 of 51 PageID #: 6208
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
7 0
Page 4 of 4
2.39
Total 293 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 40
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 239 82.41 Noah Weinberg (REP) 30 10.34 David J. Stein (IND) 7 2.41 Noah Weinberg (CON) 8 2.76 David J. Stein (WOR) 6 2.07 WRITE-IN 0
Total 290 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 42
http://wwvv.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 46 of 51 PageID #: 6209
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
88
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 47 of 51 PageID #: 6210
Page 1 of 4
District Summary Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0256 Ramapo 88 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 231 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 58 36.02 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 89 55.28 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 1 .62 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 8 4.97 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 2 1.24 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 0 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 1 .62 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 2 1.24
Total 161 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 69
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 103 55.08 Harry Wilson (REP) 69 36.90 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 1.60 Harry Wilson (CON) 10 5.35 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 1 .53 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 1 .53 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 187 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 43
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 115 58.38 Dan Donovan (REP) 63 31.98 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 4 2.03 Dan Donovan (CON) 9 4.57 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 2 1.02 Carl E. Person (LBT) 1 .51 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 3 1.52
Total 197 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 33
http://wwvv.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 48 of 51 PageID #: 6211
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 55 36.67 Jay Townsend (REP) 76 50.67 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 4 2.67 Jay Townsend (CON) 14 9.33 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 0 Colia Clark (GRN) 1 .67 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 150 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 81
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 84 41.79 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 100 49.75 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 2 1.00 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 13 6.47 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 1 .50 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 1 .50 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 201 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 30
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 97 14.88 Linda Christopher (DEM) 104 15.95 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 98 15.03 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 13 1.99 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 71 10.89 James Maisano (REP) 136 20.86 Gerry Klein (REP) 51 7.82 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 43 6.60 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 0 James Maisano (IND) 4 .61 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 0 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 3 .46 James Maisano (CON) 5 .77 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 4 .61 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 2 .31 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 4 .61 Linda Christopher (WOR) 4 .61 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 2 .31 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 2 .31 WRITE-IN 9 1.38
Total 652 Over Votes 4
http://www.co.rocldand.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 49 of 51 PageID #: 6212
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 264
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 122 64.21 Anthony Mele (REP) 45 23.68 York Kleinhandler (CON) 20 10.53 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 3 1.58
Total 190 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 41
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 15 6.82 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 187 85.00 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 3 1.36 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 13 5.91 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 2 .91 WRITE-IN 0
Total 220 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 10
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 103 58.19 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 64 36.16 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 2 1.13 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 7 3.95 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 1 .56 WRITE-IN 0
Total 177 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 53
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 166 88.30 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 5 2.66 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 16 8.51 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 1 .53 WRITE-IN 0
Total 188 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 42
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 171 79.91 Robert Romanowski (REP) 24 11.21 Daniel Friedman (IND) 8 3.74 Daniel Friedman (CON) 10 4.67
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 50 of 51 PageID #: 6213
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
1 0
Page 4 of 4
.47
Total 214 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 16
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 149 73.40 Noah Weinberg (REP) 40 19.70 David J. Stein (IND) 8 3.94 Noah Weinberg (CON) 1 .49 David J. Stein (WOR) 4 1.97 WRITE-IN 1 .49
Total 203 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 27
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-2 Filed 04/27/12 Page 51 of 51 PageID #: 6214
EXHIBIT
C
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 1 of 56 PageID #: 6215
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
18
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 2 of 56 PageID #: 6216
Page 1 of 4
District Summary Rockland County
OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0186 Ramapo 18 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 456 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 95 22.73 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 250 59.81 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 12 2.87 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 30 7.18 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 4 .96 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 1 .24 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 25 5.98 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 1 .24 WRITE-IN 0
Total 418 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 23
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 81 19.76 Harry Wilson (REP) 289 70.49 Harry Wilson (IND) 8 1.95 Harry Wilson (CON) 28 6.83 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 1 .24 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 1 .24 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 2 .49
Total 410 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 32
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 108 25.71 Dan Donovan (REP) 262 62.38 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 12 2.86 Dan Donovan (CON) 32 7.62 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 4 .95 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 1 .24 WRITE-IN 1 .24
Total 420 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 22
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 3 of 56 PageID #: 6217
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 115 27.58 Jay Townsend (REP) 263 63.07 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 8 1.92 Jay Townsend (CON) 25 6.00 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 4 .96 Colia Clark (GRN) 1 .24 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .24
Total 417 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 39
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 86 19.77 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 307 70.57 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 11 2.53 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 24 5.52 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 4 .92 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 2 .46 Joseph Huff (RDH) 1 .23 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 435 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 21
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 82 5.41 Linda Christopher (DEM) 100 6.60 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 76 5.02 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 48 3.17 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 267 17.62 James Maisano (REP) 287 18.94 Gerry Klein (REP) 281 18.55 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 232 15.31 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 8 .53 James Maisano (IND) 4 .26 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 8 .53 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 6 .40 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 26 1.72 James Maisano (CON) 22 1.45 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 23 1.52 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 16 1.06 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 7 .46 Linda Christopher (WOR) 10 .66 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 2 .13 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .07 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 4 .26 WRITE-IN 5 .33
Total 1515 Over Votes 0
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/BOWEL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 4 of 56 PageID #: 6218
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 253
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 155 37.08 Anthony Mele (REP) 236 56.46 York Kleinhandler (CON) 16 3.83 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 11 2.63 WRITE-IN 0
Total 418 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 37
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 87 20.47 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 302 71.06 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 10 2.35 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 16 3.76 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 9 2.12 WRITE-IN 1 .24
Total 425 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 17
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 124 30.62 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 246 60.74 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 15 3.70 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 12 2.96 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 7 1.73 WRITE-IN 1 .25
Total 405 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 37
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 164 66.40 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 34 13.77 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 40 16.19 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 8 3.24 WRITE-IN 1 .40
Total 247 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 195
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 169 41.22 Robert Romanowski (REP) 196 47.80 Daniel Friedman (IND) 23 5.61 Daniel Friedman (CON) 18 4.39
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.0ct 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 5 of 56 PageID #: 6219
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
3 1
Page 4 of 4
.73
.24 Total 410
Over Votes 1 Under Votes 31
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 140 33.57 Noah Weinberg (REP) 230 55.16 David J. Stein (IND) 24 5.76 Noah Weinberg (CON) 19 4.56 David J. Stein (WOR) 3 .72 WRITE-IN 1 .24
Total 417 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 25
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 6 of 56 PageID #: 6220
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
21
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 7 of 56 PageID #: 6221
Page 1 of 4
District Summary Rockland County
OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0189 Ramapo 21 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 548 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 118 34.20 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 202 58.55 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 6 1.74 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 14 4.06 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 2 .58 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 0 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 1 .29 WRITE-IN 2 .58
Total 345 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 191
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 272 62.10 Harry Wilson (REP) 139 31.74 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 .68 Harry Wilson (CON) 16 3.65 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 7 1.60 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .23
Total 438 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 98
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 294 65.48 Dan Donovan (REP) 125 27.84 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 8 1.78 Dan Donovan (CON) 13 2.90 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 6 1.34 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 3 .67
Total 449 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 88
http.//www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 8 of 56 PageID #: 6222
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 173 48.32 Jay Townsend (REP) 158 44.13 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 8 2.23 Jay Townsend (CON) 17 4.75 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 2 .56 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 358 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 190
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 182 37.92 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 257 53.54 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 12 2.50 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 22 4.58 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 5 1.04 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 2 .42 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 480 Over Votes 4
Under Votes 64
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 301 17.59 Linda Christopher (DEM) 298 17.42 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 216 12.62 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 70 4.09 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 195 11.40 James Maisano (REP) 319 18.64 Gerry Klein (REP) 111 6.49 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 92 5.38 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 7 .41 James Maisano (IND) 16 .94 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 6 .35 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 3 .18 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 14 .82. James Maisano (CON) 19 1.11 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 10 .58 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 12 .70 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 7 .41 Linda Christopher (WOR) 10 .58 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 1 .06 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 0 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 0 WRITE-IN 4 .23
Total 1711 Over Votes 4
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 9 of 56 PageID #: 6223
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 433
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 328 71.62 Anthony Mele (REP) 101 22.05 York Kleinhandler (CON) 16 3.49 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 7 1.53 WRITE-IN 6 1.31
Total 458 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 89
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 57 11.11 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 420 81.87 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 15 2.92 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 18 3.51 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 2 .39 WRITE-IN 1 .19
Total 513 Over Votes 2
Under Votes 22
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 218 57.07 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 138 36.13 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 7 1.83 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 16 4.19 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 2 .52 WRITE-IN 1 .26
Total 382 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 155
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 388 91.29 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 12 2.82 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 19 4.47 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 4 .94 WRITE-IN 2 .47
Total 425 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 112
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 419 83.30 Robert Romanowski (REP) 51 10.14 Daniel Friedman (IND) 13 2.58 Daniel Friedman (CON) 17 3.38
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 10 of 56 PageID #: 6224
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
2 1
Page 4 of 4
.40
.20 Total 503
Over Votes 1 Under Votes 33
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 378 75.15 Noah Weinberg (REP) 95 18.89 David J. Stein (IND) 9 1.79 Noah Weinberg (CON) 16 3.18 David J. Stein (WOR) 4 .80 WRITE-IN 1 .20
Total 503 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 34
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 11 of 56 PageID #: 6225
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
24
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 12 of 56 PageID #: 6226
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0192 Ramapo 24 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 200 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 62 34.07 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 100 54.95 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 4 2.20 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 7 3.85 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 1 .55 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 2 1.10 Warren Redlich (LBT) 2 1.10 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 2 1.10 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 2 1.10
Total 182 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 12
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 42 23.20 Harry Wilson (REP) 126 69.61 Harry Wilson (IND) 5 2.76 Harry Wilson (CON) 7 3.87 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 0 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 1 .55 WRITE-IN 0
Total 181 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 13
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 58 31.69 Dan Donovan (REP) 106 57.92 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 9 4.92 Dan Donovan (CON) 10 5.46 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 0 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 183 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 11
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 13 of 56 PageID #: 6227
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 63 34.24 Jay Townsend (REP) 104 56.52 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 7 3.80 Jay Townsend (CON) 8 4.35 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 0 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 2 1.09 WRITE-IN 0
Total 184 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 16
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 51 26.98 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 122 64.55 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 7 3.70 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 8 4.23 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 0 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 1 .53 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 189 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 10
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 45 6.57 Linda Christopher (DEM) 46 6.72 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 44 6.42 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 31 4.53 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 113 16.50 James Maisano (REP) 126 18.39 Gerry Klein (REP) 115 16.79 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 108 15.77 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 6 .88 James Maisano (IND) 4 .58 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 3 .44 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 3 .44 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 10 1.46 James Maisano (CON) 9 1.31 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 9 1.31 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 10 1.46 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 0 Linda Christopher (WOR) 0 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .15 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 2 .29 WRITE-IN 0
Total 685 Over Votes 0
F —
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 14 of 56 PageID #: 6228
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 91
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 79 41.15 Anthony Mele (REP) 98 51.04 York Kleinhandler (CON) 12 6.25 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 3 1.56 WRITE-IN 0
Total 192 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 8
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 33 18.23 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 134 74.03 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 5 2.76 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 8 4.42 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 1 .55 WRITE-IN 0
Total 181 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 12
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 62 34.25 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 103 56.91 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 6 3.31 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 10 5.52 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 181 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 13
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 71 65.74 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 14 12.96 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 23 21.30 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 108 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 86
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 73 40.56 Robert Romanowski (REP) 86 47.78 Daniel Friedman (IND) 12 6.67 Daniel Friedman (CON) 9 5.00
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 15 of 56 PageID #: 6229
Daniel Friedman (WOR) 0
Page 4 of 4
WRITE-IN 0 Total 180
Over Votes 0 Under Votes 14
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 74 39.78 Noah Weinberg (REP) 98 52.69 David J. Stein (IND) 4 2.15 Noah Weinberg (CON) 9 4.84 David J. Stein (WOR) 1 .54 WRITE-IN 0
Total 186 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 8
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 16 of 56 PageID #: 6230
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
28
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 17 of 56 PageID #: 6231
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0196 Ramapo 28 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 455 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 87 22.48 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 242 62.53 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 10 2.58 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 33 8.53 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 2 .52 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 3 .78 Warren Redlich (LBT) 1 .26 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 8 2.07 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .26
Total 387 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 64
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 134 32.68 Harry Wilson (REP) 227 55.37 Harry Wilson (IND) 4 .98 Harry Wilson (CON) 39 9.51 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 3 .73 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 2 .49 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .24
Total 410 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 40
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 167 39.86 Dan Donovan (REP) 196 46.78 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 14 3.34 Dan Donovan (CON) 35 8.35 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 5 1.19 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 2 .48
Total 419 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 31
http.//wvvw.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 18 of 56 PageID #: 6232
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1
Page 2 of 4
Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 125 33.60 Jay Townsend (REP) 207 55.65 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 5 1.34 Jay Townsend (CON) 31 8.33 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 2 .54 Colia Clark (GRN) 2 .54 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 372 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 83
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 118 27.57 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 265 61.92 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 7 1.64 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 31 7.24 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 4 .93 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 3 .70 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 428 Over Votes 4 Under Votes 23
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 161 10.18 Linda Christopher (DEM) 161 10.18 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 118 7.46 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 44 2.78 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 240 15.17 James Maisano (REP) 305 19.28 Gerry Klein (REP) 206 13.02 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 188 11.88 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 5 .32 James Maisano (IND) 4 .25 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 7 .44 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 3 .19 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 30 1.90 James Maisano (CON) 33 2.09 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 23 1.45 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 27 1.71 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 2 .13 Linda Christopher (WOR) 7 .44 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 4 .25 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 3 .19 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 3 .19 WRITE-IN 8 .51
Total 1582 Over Votes 4
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 19 of 56 PageID #: 6233
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 218
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 193 46.39 Anthony Mele (REP) 188 45.19 York Kleinhandler (CON) 27 6.49 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 6 1.44 WRITE-IN 2 .48
Total 416 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 39
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 59 13.53 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 333 76.38 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 3 .69 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 33 7.57 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 6 1.38 WRITE-IN 2 .46
Total 436 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 15
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 139 36.77 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 197 52.12 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 9 2.38 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 28 7.41 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) . . 5 1.32 WRITE-IN 0
Total 378 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 73
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 218 76.49 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 13 4.56 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 49 17.19 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 3 1.05 WRITE-IN 2 .70
Total 285 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 166
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 238 56.00 Robert Romanowski (REP) 132 31.06 Daniel Friedman (IND) 11 2.59 Daniel Friedman (CON) 42 9.88
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 20 of 56 PageID #: 6234
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
2 0
Page 4 of 4
.47
Total 425 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 26
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 208 48.15 Noah Weinberg (REP) 175 40.51 David J. Stein (IND) 12 2.78 Noah Weinberg (CON) 32 7.41 David J. Stein (WOR) 3 .69 WRITE-IN 2 .46
Total 432 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 18
I-
http://vvww.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 21 of 56 PageID #: 6235
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
35
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 22 of 56 PageID #: 6236
Page 1 of 4
District Summary Rockland County
OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0203 Ramapo 35 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 1017 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 78 22.35 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 234 67.05 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 3 .86 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 16 4.58 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 2 .57 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 3 .86 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 5 1.43 Warren Redlich (LBT) 2 .57 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 4 1.15 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 2 .57
Total 349 Over Votes 2 Under Votes 666
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 645 82.17 Harry Wilson (REP) 121 15.41 Harry Wilson (IND) 2 .25 Harry Wilson (CON) 9 1.15 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 5 .64 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 1 .13 WRITE-IN 2 .25
Total 785 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 231
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 562 81.92 Dan Donovan (REP) 96 13.99 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 12 1.75 Dan Donovan (CON) 7 1.02 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 4 .58 Carl E. Person (LBT) 1 .15 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 4 .58
Total 686 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 330
http://www.co.rockland.ny.usBOE/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 23 of 56 PageID #: 6237
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 445 71.31 Jay Townsend (REP) 156 25.00 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 7 1.12 Jay Townsend (CON) 10 1.60 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 4 .64 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 2 .32 WRITE-IN 0
Total 624 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 392
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 76 8.74 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 759 87.24 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 4 .46 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 29 3.33 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 1 .11 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 1 .11 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 870 Over Votes 2 Under Votes 145
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 683 22.09 Linda Christopher (DEM) 668 21.60 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 78 2.52 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 11 .36 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 679 21.96 James Maisano (REP) 742 24.00 Gerry Klein (REP) 95 3.07 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 66 2.13 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 10 .32 James Maisano (IND) 9 .29 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 2 .06 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 1 .03 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 13 .42 James Maisano (CON) 13 .42 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 3 .10 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 8 .26 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 3 .10 Linda Christopher (WOR) 3 .10 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 0 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 0 WRITE-IN 5 .16
Total 3092 Over Votes 4
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 24 of 56 PageID #: 6238
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 972
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 713 88.02 Anthony Mele (REP) 53 6.54 York Kleinhandler (CON) 31 3.83 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 6 .74 WRITE-IN 7 .86
Total 810 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 206
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 5 .52 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 908 94.00 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 24 2.48 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 27 2.80 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 2 .21
Total 966 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 50
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 119 44.91 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 130 49.06 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 4 1.51 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 10 3.77 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 2 .75 WRITE-IN 0
Total 265 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 752
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 847 95.81 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 14 1.58 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 15 1.70 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 6 .68 WRITE-IN 2 .23
Total 884 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 133
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 893 93.80 Robert Romanowski (REP) 21 2.21 Daniel Friedman (IND) 15 1.58 Daniel Friedman (CON) 16 1.68
http://vvww.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 25 of 56 PageID #: 6239
Daniel Friedman (WOR) 6
Page 4 of 4
.63 WRITE-IN 1 .11
Total 952 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 65
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 850 90.62 Noah Weinberg (REP) 53 5.65 David J. Stein (IND) 22 2.35 Noah Weinberg (CON) 6 .64 David J. Stein (WOR) 6 .64 WRITE-IN 1 .11
Total 938 Over Votes 2 Under Votes 77
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 26 of 56 PageID #: 6240
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
36
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 27 of 56 PageID #: 6241
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0204 Ramapo 36 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 178 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 67 42.68 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 72 45.86 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 4 2.55 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 4 2.55 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 1 .64 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 9 5.73 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 157 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 20
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 81 50.00 Harry Wilson (REP) 67 41.36 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 1.85 Harry Wilson (CON) 10 6.17 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 1 .62 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 162 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 16
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 88 55.00 Dan Donovan (REP) 54 33.75 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 6 3.75 Dan Donovan (CON) 11 6.88 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 1 .63 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 160 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 18
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 28 of 56 PageID #: 6242
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 72 49.32 Jay Townsend (REP) 63 43.15 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 6 4.11 Jay Townsend (CON) 5 3.42 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 0 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 146 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 32
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 79 49.38 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 68 42.50 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 7 4.38
• Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 5 3.13 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 1 .63 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 160 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 18
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 79 13.57 Linda Christopher (DEM) 85 14.60 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 77 13.23 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 51 8.76 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 65 11.17 James Maisano (REP) 81 13.92 Gerry Klein (REP) 66 11.34 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 49 8.42 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 2 .34 James Maisano (IND) 6 1.03 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 2 .34 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 1 .17 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 3 .52 James Maisano (CON) 5 .86 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 3 .52 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 3 .52 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 2 .34 Linda Christopher (WOR) 2 .34 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 0 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 582 Over Votes 0
Irttp://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.0ct 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 29 of 56 PageID #: 6243
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 130
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 101 63.13 Anthony Mele (REP) 53 33.13 York Kleinhandler (CON) 2 1.25 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 4 2.50 WRITE-IN 0
Total 160 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 18
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 54 32.73 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 100 60.61 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 5 3.03 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 5 3.03 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 1 .61 WRITE-IN 0
Total 165 Over Votes 3
Under Votes 10
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 90 57.69 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 58 37.18 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 3 1.92 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 4 2.56 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 1 .64 WRITE-IN 0
Total 156 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 22
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 101 85.59 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 8 6.78 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 7 5.93 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 2 1.69 WRITE-IN 0
Total 118 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 60
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 118 77.12 Robert Romanowski (REP) 18 11.76 Daniel Friedman (IND) 9 5.88 Daniel Friedman (CON) 5 3.27
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 30 of 56 PageID #: 6244
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
3 0
Page 4 of 4
1.96
Total 153 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 25
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 111 69.81 Noah Weinberg (REP) 33 20.75 David J. Stein (IND) 10 6.29 Noah Weinberg (CON) 3 1.89 David J. Stein (WOR) 2 1.26 WRITE-IN 0
Total 159 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 19
http://www.cosocIdand.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 31 of 56 PageID #: 6245
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
41
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 32 of 56 PageID #: 6246
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0209 Ramapo 41 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 333 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 71 24.83 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 160 55.94 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 0 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 24 8.39 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 2 .70 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 25 8.74 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 4 1.40
Total 286 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 34
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 63 21.80 Harry Wilson (REP) 177 61.25 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 1.04 Harry Wilson (CON) 44 15.22 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 0 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 2 .69 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 289 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 31
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 96 32.43 Dan Donovan (REP) 149 50.34 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 5 1.69 Dan Donovan (CON) 46 15.54 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 0 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 296 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 24
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 33 of 56 PageID #: 6247
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1
Page 2 of 4
Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 75 26.13 Jay Townsend (REP) 186 64.81 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 1 .35 Jay Townsend (CON) 23 8.01 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 1 .35 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .35
Total 287 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 45
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 94 30.23 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 193 62.06 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 0 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 24 7.72 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 0 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 311 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 21
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 75 6.93 Linda Christopher (DEM) 73 6.74 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 78 7.20 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 26 2.40 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 188 17.36 James Maisano (REP) 225 20.78 Gerry Klein (REP) 189 17.45 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 144 13.30 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 5 .46 James Maisano (IND) 4 .37 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 0 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 2 .18 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 20 1.85 James Maisano (CON) 22 2.03 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 12 1.11 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 19 1.75 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 0 Linda Christopher (WOR) 0 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 0 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .09
Total 1083 Over Votes 0
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 34 of 56 PageID #: 6248
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 197
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 129 42.43 Anthony Mele (REP) 166 54.61 York Kleinhandler (CON) 8 2.63 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 1 .33 WRITE-IN 0
Total 304 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 29
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 35 11.18 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 252 80.51 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 4 1.28 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 19 6.07 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 3 .96 WRITE-IN 0
Total 313 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 6
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 109 38.38 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 153 53.87 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 5 1.76 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 14 4.93 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 2 .70 WRITE-IN 1 .35
Total 284 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 36
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 169 81.25 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 9 4.33 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 28 13.46 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 2 .96 WRITE-IN 0
Total 208 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 112
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 177 60.62 Robert Romanowski (REP) 82 28.08 Daniel Friedman (IND) 10 3.42 Daniel Friedman (CON) 23 7.88
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 35 of 56 PageID #: 6249
Daniel Friedman (WOR) 0
Page 4 of 4
WRITE-IN 0 Total 292
Over Votes 3 Under Votes 25
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 151 51.01 Noah Weinberg (REP) 113 38.18 David J. Stein (IND) 12 4.05 Noah Weinberg (CON) 18 6.08 David J. Stein (WOR) 2 .68 WRITE-IN 0
Total 296 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 24
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 36 of 56 PageID #: 6250
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
49
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 37 of 56 PageID #: 6251
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0217 Ramapo 49 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 282 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 89 40.83 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 109 50.00 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 1 .46 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 9 4.13 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 2 .92 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 3 1.38 Warren Redlich (LBT) 3 1.38 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 1 .46 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .46
Total 218 Over Votes 1
Under Votes 56
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 128 53.78 Harry Wilson (REP) 89 37.39 Harry Wilson (IND) 7 2.94 Harry Wilson (CON) 10 4.20 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 3 1.26 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 1 .42 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 238 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 37
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 132 55.23 Dan Donovan (REP) 86 35.98 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 7 2.93 Dan Donovan (CON) 11 4.60 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 2 .84 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .42
Total 239 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 36
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 38 of 56 PageID #: 6252
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1
Page 2 of 4
Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 95 46.80 Jay Townsend (REP) 92 45.32 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 6 2.96 Jay Townsend (CON) 7 3.45 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 2 .99 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .49
Total 203 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 79
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 122 47.29 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 119 46.12 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 3 1.16 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 11 4.26 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 2 .78 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .39
Total 258 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 23
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 130 14.86 Linda Christopher (DEM) 138 15.77 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 107 12.23 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 40 4.57 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 99 11.31 James Maisano (REP) 154 17.60 Gerry Klein (REP) 83 9.49 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 67 7.66 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 4 .46 James Maisano (IND) 5 .57 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 3 .34 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 2 .23 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 7 .80 James Maisano (CON) 7 .80 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 7 .80 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 8 .91 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 2 .23 Linda Christopher (WOR) 4 .46 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 2 .23 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .11 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 1 .11 WRITE-IN 4 .46
Total 875 Over Votes 8
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 39 of 56 PageID #: 6253
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 217
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 158 63.45 Anthony Mele (REP) 76 30.52 York Kleinhandler (CON) 10 4.02 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 5 2.01 WRITE-IN 0
Total 249 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 33
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 56 20.97 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 192 71.91 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 8 3.00 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 8 3.00 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 2 .75 WRITE-IN 1 .37
Total 267 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 8
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 122 55.45 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 79 35.91 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 9 4.09 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 7 3.18 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 2 .91 WRITE-IN 1 .45
Total 220 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 55
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 172 85.57 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 10 4.98 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 14 6.97 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 3 1.49 WRITE-IN 2 1.00
Total 201 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 74
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 185 69.81 Robert Romanowski (REP) 58 21.89 Daniel Friedman (IND) 12 4.53 Daniel Friedman (CON) 6 2.26
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 40 of 56 PageID #: 6254
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
3 1
Page 4 of 4
1.13 .38
Total 265 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 10
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 177 68.34 Noah Weinberg (REP) 61 23.55 David J. Stein (IND) 10 3.86 Noah Weinberg (CON) 8 3.09 David J. Stein (WOR) 3 1.16 WRITE-IN 0
Total 259 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 16
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 41 of 56 PageID #: 6255
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
56
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 42 of 56 PageID #: 6256
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0224 Ramapo 56 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 402 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 113 30.05 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 211 56.12 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 8 2.13 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 23 6.12 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 3 .80 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 1 .27 Warren Redlich (LBT) 1 .27 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 14 3.72 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 2 .53 WRITE-IN 0
Total 376 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 16
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 81 22.56 Harry Wilson (REP) 234 65.18 Harry Wilson (IND) 5 1.39 Harry Wilson (CON) 34 9.47 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 4 1.11 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .28
Total 359 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 33
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 122 32.71 Dan Donovan (REP) 200 53.62 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 13 3.49 Dan Donovan (CON) 35 9.38 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 3 .80 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 373 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 18
http.//www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 43 of 56 PageID #: 6257
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1
Page 2 of 4
Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 120 32.61 Jay Townsend (REP) 210 57.07 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 10 2.72 Jay Townsend (CON) 23 6.25 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 4 1.09 Colia Clark (GRN) 1 .27 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 368 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 33
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 100 27.47 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 228 62.64 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 7 1.92 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 24 6.59 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 3 .82 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 0 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 1 .27 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 1 .27 WRITE-IN 0
Total 364 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 38
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 95 7.28 Linda Christopher (DEM) 91 6.97 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 81 6.21 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 59 4.52 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 220 16.86 James Maisano (REP) 241 18.47 Gerry Klein (REP) 223 17.09 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 189 14.48 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 4 .31 James Maisano (IND) 1 .08 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 4 .31 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 1 .08 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 18 1.38 James Maisano (CON) 18 1.38 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 19 1.46 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 18 1.38 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 7 .54 Linda Christopher (WOR) 9 .69 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 4 .31 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .08 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 1 .08 WRITE-IN 1 .08
Total 1305 Over Votes 20
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 44 of 56 PageID #: 6258
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 243
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 159 42.74 Anthony Mele (REP) 190 51.08 York Kleinhandler (CON) 20 5.38 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 3 .81 WRITE-IN 0
Total 372 Over Votes 3
Under Votes 27
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 87 23.02 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 262 69.31 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 3 .79 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 21 5.56 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 5 1.32 WRITE-IN 0
Total 378 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 14
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 115 33.24 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 203 58.67 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 6 1.73 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 17 4.91 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 5 1.45 WRITE-IN 0
Total 346 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 46
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 144 70.59 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 16 7.84 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 38 18.63 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 5 2.45 WRITE-IN 1 .49
Total 204 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 188
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 154 42.66 Robert Romanowski (REP) 165 45.71 Daniel Friedman (IND) 13 3.60 Daniel Friedman (CON) 27 7.48
http.//www.co.rockland.ny.us/BOVEL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 45 of 56 PageID #: 6259
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
2 0
Page 4 of 4
.55
Total 361
Over Votes 2 Under Votes 29
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 141 38.21 Noah Weinberg (REP) 198 53.66 David J. Stein (IND) 7 1.90 Noah Weinberg (CON) 16 4.34 David J. Stein (WOR) 6 1.63 WRITE-IN 1 .27
Total 369 Over Votes 2
Under Votes 21
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.ba 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 46 of 56 PageID #: 6260
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
64
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 47 of 56 PageID #: 6261
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS
Board of Elections 11/24/10
0232 Ramapo 64 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 306 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 88 37.29 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 120 50.85 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 2 .85 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 9 3.81 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 3 1.27 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 1 .42 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 2 .85 Warren Redlich (LBT) 2 .85 Charles Barron (FDM) 2 .85 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 5 2.12 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 1 .42 WRITE-IN 1 .42
Total 236 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 68
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 137 49.64 Harry Wilson (REP) 114 41.30 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 1.09 Harry Wilson (CON) 14 5.07 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 4 1.45 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 2 .72 John Gaetani (LBT) 2 .72 WRITE-IN 0
Total 276 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 28
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 160 56.74 Dan Donovan (REP) 100 35.46 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 4 1.42 Dan Donovan (CON) 12 4.26 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 4 1.42 Carl E. Person (LBT) 2 .71 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 282 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 22
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 48 of 56 PageID #: 6262
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1
Page 2 of 4
Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 104 46.85 Jay Townsend (REP) 98 44.14 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 6 2.70 Jay Townsend (CON) 9 4.05 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 2 .90 Colia Clark (GRN) 1 .45 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 2 .90 WRITE-IN 0
Total 222 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 84
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 126 44.21 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 138 48.42 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 5 1.75 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 8 2.81 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 3 1.05 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 1 .35 Joseph Huff (RDH) 1 .35 John Clifton (LBT) 3 1.05 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 285 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 21
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 151 14.69 Linda Christopher (DEM) 145 14.11 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 135 13.13 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 53 5.16 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 114 11.09 James Maisano (REP) 177 17.22 Gerry Klein (REP) 101 9.82 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 81 7.88 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 5 .49 James Maisano (IND) 7 .68 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 5 .49 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 5 .49 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 10 .97 James Maisano (CON) 9 .88 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 9 .88 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 6 .58 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 5 .49 Linda Christopher (WOR) 7 .68 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 2 .19 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .10 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 1028 Over Votes 0
http://vvww.cosocklancl.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 49 of 56 PageID #: 6263
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 188
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 171 62.64 1- Anthony Mele (REP) 85 31.14 ! York Kleinhandler (CON) 14 5.13 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 3 1.10 WRITE-IN 0
Total 273 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 33
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 54 18.37 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 224 76.19 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 6 2.04 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 7 2.38 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 3 1.02 WRITE-IN 0
Total 294 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 10
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 152 58.91 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 96 37.21 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 1 .39 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 7 2.71 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 2 .78 WRITE-IN 0
Total 258 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 46
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 212 90.60 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 10 4.27 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 11 4.70 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 1 .43 WRITE-IN 0
Total 234 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 70
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 219 76.84 Robert Romanowski (REP) 47 16.49 Daniel Friedman (IND) 9 3.16 Daniel Friedman (CON) 9 3.16
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 50 of 56 PageID #: 6264
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
1 0
Page 4 of 4
.35
Total 285 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 19
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 212 74.13 Noah Weinberg (REP) 58 20.28 David J. Stein (IND) 8 2.80 Noah Weinberg (CON) 6 2.10 David J. Stein (WOR) 2 .70 WRITE-IN 0
Total 286 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 18
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 51 of 56 PageID #: 6265
RAMAPO ELECTION DISTRICT
85
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 52 of 56 PageID #: 6266
Page 1 of 4
District Summary
Rockland County OFFICIAL RESULTS Board of Elections 11/24/10
0253 Ramapo 85 VOTES PERCENT
REGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL 0 BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL 223 BALLOTS CAST - BLANK 0
GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 32 18.93 Carl P. Paladino (REP) 109 64.50 Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 3 1.78 Carl P. Paladino (CON) 12 7.10 Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 1 .59 Howie Hawkins (GRN) 0 Jimmy McMillan (RDH) 1 .59 Warren Redlich (LBT) 0 Charles Barron (FDM) 0 Carl P. Paladino (TXP) 10 5.92 Kristin M. Davis (APP) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .59
Total 169 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 54
COMPTROLLER (VOTE FOR) 1 Thomas P. DiNapoli (DEM) 67 34.01 Harry Wilson (REP) 106 53.81 Harry Wilson (IND) 3 1.52 Harry Wilson (CON) 21 10.66 Thomas P. DiNapoli (WOR) 0 Julia A. Willebrand (GRN) 0 John Gaetani (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 197 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 26
ATTORNEY GENERAL (VOTE FOR) 1 Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM) 79 39.90 Dan Donovan (REP) 91 45.96 Eric T. Schneiderman (IND) 3 1.52 Dan Donovan (CON) 24 12.12 Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR) 0 Carl E. Person (LBT) 0 Ramon J. Jimenez (FDM) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .51
Total 198 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 25
http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 53 of 56 PageID #: 6267
Page 2 of 4
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Charles E. Schumer (DEM) 46 27.71 Jay Townsend (REP) 105 63.25 Charles E. Schumer (IND) 1 .60 Jay Townsend (CON) 14 8.43 Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 0 Colia Clark (GRN) 0 Randy A. Credico (LBT) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 166 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 57
UNITED STATES SENATOR (VOTE FOR) 1 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 47 23.04 Joseph J. DioGuardi (REP) 142 69.61 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 1 .49 Joseph J. DioGuardi (CON) 12 5.88 Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 1 .49 Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0 Joseph Huff (RDH) 1 .49 John Clifton (LBT) 0 Vivia Morgan (APP) 0 Bruce Blakeman (TRP) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 204 Over Votes 1 Under Votes 18
STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE 9th Judicial District (VOTE FOR) 4 Colleen D. Duffy (DEM) 73 10.14 Linda Christopher (DEM) 74 10.28 Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM) 43 5.97 J. Emmett Murphy (DEM) 12 1.67 Matthew J. Byrne (REP) 126 17.50 James Maisano (REP) 166 23.06 Gerry Klein (REP) 106 14.72 J. Emmett Murphy (REP) 75 10.42 Matthew J. Byrne (IND) 0 James Maisano (IND) 0 Lawrence H. Ecker (IND) 0 J. Emmett Murphy (IND) 0 Matthew J. Byrne (CON) 10 1.39 James Maisano (CON) 12 1.67 Lawrence H. Ecker (CON) 7 .97 J. Emmett Murphy (CON) 10 1.39 Colleen D. Duffy (WOR) 2 .28 Linda Christopher (WOR) 1 .14 Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR) 1 .14 Matthew J. Byrne (RTL) 1 .14 James Alexander Burke (RTL) 0 WRITE-IN 1 .14
Total 720 Over Votes 0
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 54 of 56 PageID #: 6268
Page 3 of 4
Under Votes 172
REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS 17th Congressional District (VOTE FOR) 1 Eliot L. Engel (DEM) 101 50.75 Anthony Mele (REP) 86 43.22 York Kleinhandler (CON) 11 5.53 Eliot L. Engel (WOR) 1 .50 WRITE-IN 0
Total 199 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 24
STATE SENATOR 38th District (VOTE FOR) 1 David S. Carlucci (DEM) 16 7.58 C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP) 180 85.31 C. Scott Vanderhoef (IND) 3 1.42 C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON) 11 5.21 David S. Carlucci (WOR) 1 .47 WRITE-IN 0
Total 211 Over Votes 2
Under Votes 10
MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95th Assembly District (VOTE FOR) 1 Ellen C. Jaffee (DEM) 61 36.09 Thomas A. Morr (REP) 92 54.44 Ellen C. Jaffee (IND) 2 1.18 Thomas A. Morr (CON) 14 8.28 Ellen C. Jaffee (WOR) 0 WRITE-IN 0
Total 169 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 54
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Patrick J. Withers (DEM) 114 82.61 Patrick J. Withers (IND) 5 3.62 Patrick J. Withers (CON) 16 11.59 Patrick J. Withers (WOR) 3 2.17 WRITE-IN 0
Total 138 Over Votes 0
Under Votes 85
RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL (VOTE FOR) 1 Daniel Friedman (DEM) 125 62.19 Robert Romanowski (REP) 60 29.85 Daniel Friedman (IND) 3 1.49 Daniel Friedman (CON) 11 5.47
http://vvww.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 55 of 56 PageID #: 6269
Daniel Friedman (WOR) WRITE-IN
2 0
Page 4 of 4
1.00
Total 201 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 22
RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE (VOTE FOR) 1 David J. Stein (DEM) 113 55.12 Noah Weinberg (REP) 69 33.66 David J. Stein (IND) 11 5.37 Noah Weinberg (CON) 9 4.39 David J. Stein (WOR) 3 1.46 WRITE-IN 0
Total 205 Over Votes 0 Under Votes 18
http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt 4/27/2012
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-3 Filed 04/27/12 Page 56 of 56 PageID #: 6270
EXHIBIT
D
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 1 of 9 PageID #: 6271
DEMOCRATIC State Legislative District 095 - MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95Th AD
Ramapo - Section 1 Ward: 000
35:114445enther 5114. C Tern Dualrail. illek_Vson.
003 106 80 23 3 006 125 75 42 8 008 63 27 28 8 009 44 33 6 5 010 75 43 18 14 012 124 88 29 7 013 95 42 45 8 017 102 72 /9 11 018 98 29 64 5 019 60 50 4 6 021 214 IS 188 8 023 104 56 36 12 024 29 10 15 4
025 68 12 51 5 026 80 47 28 5 028 53 13 37 3 029 143 76 61 6 030 194 2 188 4 031 74 46 19 9 034 131 82 31 18 035 609 6 598 5 036 46 12 30 4 040 47 7 38 2 041 70 16 49 5 042 120 59 45 16 043 72 46 20 6 045 80 51 27 2 046 50 40 8 2 047 60 26 21 13 049 103 8 91 4 051 /06 41 52 13 053 34 II 21 2 055 410 1 397 12 056 91 37 47 7 057 73 51 12 10 058 342 1 335 6
060 69 28 38 3
09/22/2006 01:03:30 PM Page 75
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 2 of 9 PageID #: 6272
DEMOCRATIC State Legislative District 095 - MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95TH AD
Ramapo - Section 1 Ward: 000
Eludslizoka ElseLlatrs Oriel Pried MIZILYII00.
061 122 82 32 8 062 69 33 33 3 063 106 48 41 17 064 107 20 85 2 065 160 69 81 10 066 138 103 15 20 067 159 III 35 13 068 64 43 16 5 069 114 89 13 12 070 105 51 30 24 071 82 32 35 15 074 75 9 64 2 076 77 55 16 6 077 104 87 13 4 082 49 43 2 4 084 166 65 84 17 085 41 0 40 1 087 88 41 34 13 088 48 3 45 0 090 146 130 16 0 WARD TOTALS 6384 2456 3491 437
09/22/2006 01:03:30 PM Page 76
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 3 of 9 PageID #: 6273
GENERAL ELECTION State Legislative District 095 - MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95TH AD
Ramapo - Section 1
_
Ward: 000 YO/s/c/t Joacs1 Elca-Calks seam 1/14M_Soses
003 379 67 286 26 006 290 23 217 50 008 167 18 124 25 009 269 102 154 13 010 350 43 268 39 012 248 22 187 39 013 283 10 132 141 017 551 203 311 37 018 388 229 145 14 019 369 152 200 17 021 281 III 102 68 023 269 49 175 45 024 170 87 68 15 025 206 119 65 22 026 117 9 87 21 029 531 149 334 48 030 187 105 33 49 031 361 163 172 26 034 393 103 255 35 035 677 114 71 492 036 161 73 72 16 040 170 114 34 22 041 267 169 54 1 43 042 459 42 335 82 043 322 106 192 24 045 187 40 133 14 046 248 78 154 1 15 047 203 18 149 36 049 175 85 58 32 051 329 45 239 1 44 053 132 36 75 21 055 840 IS 789 33 056 324 179 113 32 057 334 114 198 22 058 718 25 660 33 060 326 167 137 22 061 321 86 215 20
11/21/2006 04:30:09 PM Page 98
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 4 of 9 PageID #: 6274
GENERAL ELECTION State Legislative District 095 - MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95TH AD
Ramapo - Section 1
Ward: 000
062 063 064 065 066 067 068 069 070 071 074 076 077 082 084 085 087 088 089 090 WARD TOTALS
3,111thiblElthIL
154 262 200 409 358 580 280 390 239 175 114 311 322 174 387 131 283 100 258 514
17643
1117171h-attiall
21 21 93 66 85
142 63
120 26 25 64
130 100 42
161 91 36 56
142 139
48%
EllsoCalkr. 113 188 79
288 250 394 198 235 165 121 30
157 208 121 179 20
211 32 70
338 10390 4
126a24/15. 20 53 28 55 23 44 19 35 48 29 20 24 14 11 46 20 36 12 46 37
2353
11/21/2006 04:30:09 PM Page 99
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 5 of 9 PageID #: 6275
DEMOCRATIC State Legislative District 095 - MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95TH AD DEM
Ramapo - Section 1 Ward: 000
)Vlualt Nenthor ElitiLC.ktfit ChrlatbaSampano. Sons EmkYakt. 003 229 211 18 006 54 45 9 008 98 78 20 009 199 183 16 010 68 43 19 012 55 44 11 013 76 49 23 017 113 88 14 018 50 39 10 019 45 31 14 021 31 16 15 023 86 56 18 024 94 78 16 025 50 38 12 026 39 23 7 029 119 90 16 030 20 5 15 031 53 50 3 034 128 97 25 035 178 3 175 036 61 44 17 041 24 13 I1 042 141 100 25 1 043 74 62 9 045 64 42 19 047 57 34 13 1 052 5 0 4 053 84 65 19 055 455 454 1 056 45 37 6 057 74 64 7 058 339 338 1 061 170 156 14 063 96 79 11 068 68 62 4 069 95 88 6
09/18/2008 02:12:12 PM Page 4
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 6 of 9 PageID #: 6276
DEMOCRATIC State Legislative District 095 - MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95TH AD DEM
Ramapo - Section 1
Ward: 000
070 071 074 076 077 082 087 WARD TOTALS
9".6 Number 103 103 76 29 40 94 66 63
4108
intancer_ Cluisiaramunan. 78 I I 78 41 17 19 7 31 9 83 7 57 6 49 14
3263 694 0
8tholasta. 14 18
3 0 4 3 0
151
09/18/2008 02:12:12 PM Page 5
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 7 of 9 PageID #: 6277
GENERAL ELECTION State Legislative District 095 - MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95TH AD
Ramapo - Section 1 Ward: 000
wm6N..8.4. 74....m6.4. 8884‘ Bholanto. 003 589 438 151 006 571 430 141 008 336 247 89 009 429 243 186 010 619 487 132 012 513 393 120 013 371 261 110 017 828 539 1 288 018 688 288
1 399
019 581 346 1 234 021 516 189 327 023 467 327 140 024 360 158 202 025 471 174 297 026 231 183 48 028 618 206 412 029 830 530 300 030 465 126 339 031 550 313 237 034 679 457 222 035 810 96 714 036 269 141 128 040 303 122 181 041 474 155 319 042 960 752 208 043 506 337 169 045 296 200 96 046 371 223 148 047 374 270 104 049 420 172 248 051 622 445 177 052 0 0 0 053 268 172 96 055 1083 1068 15 056 668 291 1 376 057 515 298 217
11/19/2008 08:12:03 AM Page 58
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 8 of 9 PageID #: 6278
GENERAL ELECTION State Legislative District 095 - MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY 95TH AD
Ramapo - Section 1 Ward: 000
2.124-11vadur. Ek.Clatfet &Mu_ ZukYnteL 058 857 836 21 060 614 308 1 305 061 453 316 137 062 256 168 88 063 594 496 98 064 491 193 298 065 759 558 201 066 516 358 158 067 839 612 227 068 437 291 146 069 558 366 192 070 473 374 99 071 326 220 106 074 276 1 ❑ 3 156 076 487 286 201 077 433 280 153 082 240 181 59 084 666 323 1 342 085 244 71 173 087 519 410 /09 088 206 75 131 090 689 443 246 WARD TOTALS 29584 18359 9 /1216
11/19/2008 08:12:03 AM Page 59
Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 334-4 Filed 04/27/12 Page 9 of 9 PageID #: 6279