Download - Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
1/30
Module: Managing Change in Organisations
Unit: Identifying, Understanding and Involving Others inChange
Lesson: Understanding Change Through Consulting
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
2/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 1 of 19
Introduction
Change initiatives in complex situations are frequently led by external Change Consultants.
Accelerated globalisation, new business paradigms, constant technology advances and intensified competition
are all leading to increased business complexity. Furthermore, technology has become closely intertwined with
the overall business objectives of a company. In such a complex and dynamic environment, business problems
and opportunities in themselves may be poorly understood by the client. External change consultants can bring
valuable insights without the 'bag and baggage' of the internal organisation. Today many organisations are
engaging external consultants, as trusted advisors, who can be completely objective.
End of Page 1
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
3/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 2 of 19
Skills to Manage Change Consultancy Projects
The skills required for change management are addressed from a Consultancy point of view . What skills must an
external consultant possess to lead a change initiative? However, many of these skills are just as applicable for
those leading internal change programs.
What advantages to the organisation are there in using external consultants, in change initiatives?
Defining and solving complex business problems requires deep industry expertise,
practical tools, research capabilities and innovative thinking. There is now the
recognition that business insights must be gained first and only then can strategic
change solutions be defined. For this reason many companies are engaging external
consultants all the way from business problem definition to change implementation.
Change consultants usually have skills in business transformation and change
across a number of industries and organisational situations. Often it is highly
effective to leverage experience from other situations and industries using the
expertise of such consultants - their expertise is focused on marrying the business
objectives with technology. Frequently companies have gained competitive
advantage by leveraging and applying knowledge from one sector to their ow n
organisation.
Furthermore consultants are independent; as such they are more likely to propose
objective and rational solutions.
Change Consulting engagements are variable in complexity and duration. At one end of the spectrum you have a
project of just a few days undertaken by one consultant, and at the other end, a project involving a large team of
consultants and contractors on a major business transformation undertaking of several months. Whatever the
complexity and duration, consulting engagements demand skills in project management.
Imagine you were leading a team on a major change consulting project. We have just highlighted the
criticality of possessing project management skills to manage the client engagement. But what other
skills and capabilities would you want from your consulting team.
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
4/30
A change consultancy team needs the following skills and capabilities:
Ability to develop rapport with Clients
Positioning w ith clients
Influencing clients and managing client relationships
Situational appraisal
Team working (especially effective collaboration with Client organisation)
Data collection
Problem solving
Solution generation
Managing change
Reporting to Clients
From now on by the term "Consultant" we shall refer to the consultancy team -
which may comprise just one person or a number of persons bringing
complementary and necessary consulting skills.
End of Page 2
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
5/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 3 of 19
Client Relationship
It should be emphasised that change consulting requires the Consultant to work closely with the client and
develop an understanding of their situational context, pains and needs. The client relationship is vital, and
throughout the project the Consultant must be 'connected' and pro-actively work with the Client. There is no
room for working in isolation and prescribing a change solution to the client. The relationship has to be an
empathetic relationship and one of mutual trust for it to succeed. This is true of all consulting engagements, but
especially true in change consulting.
Why then do clients engage consultants?
The key reasons for using consultants are:
The organisation may be lacking in business transformation and change
skills/resources.
Strategic decision to get an independent view
Change is frequently better identified by an outsider
Change can be divisive, and an independent and objective view is more likely
to rally support and commitment from the entire organisation
Risk reduction
Technology transfer (change initiatives increasingly require the marriage of
business and technology skills)
Cross-fertilisation of business transformation experience and know ledge from
other business domains/industries
The client must have the confidence that the Consultant really understands their situational need, their
pains and truly empathises w ith their predicament. Only then does the Consultant have a chance ofsuccessfully defining the business problem and developing solutions for change that gain the 'buy in'
of the Client. As much as 70% of a Consultant's time can be spent in understanding the customer and
the situational context.
End of Page 3
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
6/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 4 of 19
Consultant and the Client
Both the Consultant and the Client have to be pro-actively engaged and collaborate for a change project to be
successful.
Consultants need to exercise persuasive skills in order to lead, motivate, bring about actions and manage
complex situations. It is critical that consultants maintain personal integrity and use sound persuasion
techniques in difficult client situations. Establishing trust is an important success factor.
Consultancy is the ability to apply know -how in a client environment.
End of Page 4
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
7/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 5 of 19
Change Consultancy must marry the unique skills of the Consultant and the Client:
Consultant
The consultant brings know -how in the form of:
Know ledge
Experience
Skills
The consultant's know-how may be in the business domain of the client e.g. banking, insurance,
communications, and energy. But, in some cases, clients are looking for generic cross-industry
know-how that have been gained and applied across a number of sectors.
The Consultant's role throughout the engagement is to be attentive and make time for the client, whilst
at all times managing expectations.
Client
The client has the unique knowledge and understanding of the organisation and business domain.
This knowledge has to be imparted to the consultant and is then known as situational know ledge
The Client's role is to define requirements, monitor progress and meet commitments; commitments in
terms of access to people, access to systems, resourcing etc.
Consultancy
Consultancy is the ability to apply know -how in a client environment. It requires that consultant know-
how and client knowledge be integrated to identify meaningful and realistic change solutions.
Project problems can arise in change engagements as a result of bad client habits. Can you identify
some of these?
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
8/30
Here are some common problems that arise from the Client organisation:
Not taking responsibility for the project
Insufficient resourcing from the Client organisation
Lack of access to the right people
Expecting the Consultant to comply with all their demands (outside of contract)
Not keeping the Consultant informed
Additionally as the Consultant you should understand any unwritten expectations
and issues from the client organisation (e.g. personal objectives, personal w ins, and
politics) and pro-actively manage these.
End of Page 5
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
9/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 6 of 19
A Solutions Approach
Companies are looking for more than "advice" with regard to change. They are looking for total solutions.
"Total solutions" are driven by a business need or a requirement for business transformation. Companies are
not interested in point solutions that tackle just one problem, because it is increasingly recognised that
problems are inter-related and an integrated, total solution is the strategic way forward. This is known as the
Solutions Approach, and is consistent with system modelling.
Given the focus on the Solutions Approach, change consulting efforts should first target the business, and not
supporting functions or IT departments. Consultants should have the ability and credibility to engage at the very
top of the "business" to acquire a thorough understanding of the business need, strategic vision and develop
situational knowledge. Only in this way can consultants define the business problem and make a credible
business case. It is the very top of the business (CEO and Board level) that will be the final decision making
authority on actions following the consultant's recommendations for change/transformation.
To establish change credibly you need to be able to convince the client organisation that you (your
consulting team) possesses the following knowledge/skills/competencies:
Situational fluency (understanding the customer situation, customer pains)
Business domain know ledge
Technical competence
Vision
Collaborative skills
End of Page 6
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
10/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 7 of 19
Developing Situational Fluency
To develop situational fluency it is necessary have some knowledge of the customer domain.
So what is customer domain?
By customer domain (or business domain), we mean the particular industry or sector that the customer
operates in. Let us consider an example. You may be in the business of selling data mining software. This is a
generic product that has application in many industries - pharmaceutical, financial, retailing etc. If your
company is targeting a customer in the oil industry (an industry in w hich data mining has many applications), it
is unlikely that the client will take you seriously unless you demonstrate some knowledge of the industry, and
its particular challenges.
The depth of customer domain knowledge required of the Consultant w ould depend on the complexity of the
business need and the industry. In many technically-oriented sectors (e.g. telecommunications,
pharmaceutical, petroleum, defence) deep domain knowledge is required. In other sectors, e.g. financial
services or insurance, domain knowledge can be acquired (by reading industry publications, learning aboutcustomer workflow , talking to the customer etc) and further developed during the consultancy engagement.
End of Page 7
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
11/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 8 of 19
Situational knowledge
Gaining situational knowledge requires an understanding of the precise circumstances, the state and
environment in which the client currently operates. It requires the Consultant to appreciate the customer pains
and empathise with the customer predicament. By pains we are referring to the client's problems, difficulties or
dissatisfaction with the existing situation; the reason why they are seeking change.
Situational knowledge cannot be established without the Consultant (or selling team) possessing some domain
knowledge.
Situational knowledge is established from the following:
Customer domain1.
Specific business need(s) of the Client. The business need may be an internal or external need.2.
Business workflow3.
Existing products/services that make up the current solution.4.
People in the organisation that perform the tasks relating to the business w orkflow.5.
Customer problems/issues6.
Customer pains7.
Customer vision for the future (if one exists)8.
The term customer pain is used frequently in the context of understanding customer needs. Customer pain is
when the Client experiences (and recognises that it is experiencing) problems, difficulties or dissatisfaction
with the existing situation. The Client knows they have a problem, but may not know the cause and does not
know how to solve it through change.
A simple example of a customer pain w ould be that of a sales team being unable to access customer
relationship information held outside of the sales database.
The Client needs to admit and elaborate the pains with the Consultant before effective solutions can be found.
Turn you attention to your ow n working environment. Can you identify two customer pains that
prevent you from doing your work effectively, or are a source of frustration?
Elaborate. Elaborate the pain (not the solution).
End of Page 8
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
12/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 9 of 19
From Situational Knowledge to Situational Fluency
Situational fluency does not come purely from a situational knowledge. It is a combination of know ledge and
skills, including situational knowledge. Michael Bosw orth Bosworth M (1995) identifies four areas of focus in
gaining situational fluency:
Situation knowledge1.
Capability knowledge2.
People skills3.
Selling skills4.
End of Page 9
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
13/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 10 of 19
Situational Knowledge
Understanding the precise circumstances, the state and environment in w hich the client currently
operates. An understanding of the customer pains and empathy w ith the customer predicament
Capability Knowledge
Capability knowledge is the ability to integrate and map technology know -how and solution
capabilities on to the Client's situational context.
People Skills
People skills are self-explanatory, but are especially important in change consulting. We should
emphasise the importance of establishing sincerity and relationship building
Selling Skills
A Change Consultant must possess selling skills to gain situational fluency. Firstly you must sell the
work you are carrying out, as well as the output of your change engagement to all levels in the Client
Organisation. People are usually sceptical of change consultants and you must be able to persuade
them that you are adding value and that there is business benefit in the engagement. You must be
able to establish a relationship based on mutual trust and respect during your consulting engagement.
Situational fluency is critical in consulting engagements. Situational fluency is made up of:
Situation Know ledge
Capability knowledge
People skills
Selling skills
End of Page 10
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
14/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 11 of 19
Problem Solving and Consultancy Tools for Change Programs
The Consultant's work is largely to do with problem solving; usually ill defined problems. First, you need to
understand and define the problem. Only then can an outline change solution be envisioned.
Data Collection is the most time consuming part of problem solving and needs to be carried out w ith expertise.
We present some of the consulting tools at the disposal of the Change Consultant.
End of Page 11
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
15/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 12 of 19
Questioning Techniques
Listening is at the core of consulting - active listening. But to listen you need to engage the client. Different
types of questions can be posed for this:
Open
Probing
Closed
Reflective
Leading
Hypothetical
Contrast Open and Closed questioning. Give examples, from a technology context, to demonstrate the
questioning techniques.
Why might you pose a (i) hypothetical question and (ii) a leading question when gathering information
on a consulting engagement.
Post your answ ers on the Group Learning Space. Review the submissions of three colleagues and
learn from their responses.
It is said that the thought is in the question posed by the Consultant and the data in the Client's answer.
End of Page 12
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
16/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 13 of 19
Interviews
One-to-one Interviews
Pros:
Personal contact
Flexible agenda
Targeted contribution
Opportunity to clarify context and provides a feel
Cons:
Time-consuming
Are you interviewing the right person?
Can be difficult to analyse data
Group Interviews
Pros:
Meet more people, hence data is more representative
Higher profile
Cons:
Requires careful preparation and management
People may be inhibited to speak in a group forum
May not be able to clarify individual responses
End of Page 13
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
17/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 14 of 19
Other Data Collection Tools
Observation
Pros:
You gather first hand information
Collect data in unanticipated areas of significance
Cons:
Time consuming
Difficult to analyse and put in overall context
Inspection
Pros:
Can inspect at your own pace
Collect data in unanticipated areas of significance
Cons:
Availability of documents/work products to inspect
Very time consuming
Questionnaires
Pros:
Wide reach
Easy analysis
Views may be more considered and honest (especially if anonymous)
Cons:
Close ended
Low response rates
Some participants may be reluctant to express concerns in writing
Hard to achieve strength of feeling and relevance
End of Page 14
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
18/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 15 of 19
Cause-and-Effect diagrams
Cause-and Effect diagrams, also known as Fishbone diagrams or Ishikaw a diagrams, are an excellent w ay of
identifying problems and issues. It is a vital diagnostic tool in Change Consultancy.
Figure 2.0.8 - Generic Cause-and-Effect diagram
Graphical representations of relationships betw een items or factors can stimulate thinking about problems and
issues.
Cause and effect diagrams are frequently used in brainstorming sessions on change consultancy
engagements. It is often best to create an unstructured list of hypotheses by brainstorming and then to map
them on to cause-and-effect diagrams. The cause-and-effect diagram is then effective in stimulating further
ideas about issues and contributory causes.
Details of this technique in the context of change management are addressed in Cause and Effect Analysis
End of Page 15
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
19/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 16 of 19
Diagnostic Surveys and Logic Diagrams
Logic diagrams are a useful structured technique in going from facts to findings to recommendations. In the
consulting context, Client's opinions constitute facts and the Consultant's opinions constitute findings.
Logic diagrams enable Consultants to ask "w hat do w e make of this?" and arrive at recommendations.
Figure 2.0.9 - Logic Diagrams
Facts are the data that can be ascertained from diagnostic surveys (using methods such as questionnaires,
interviews, inspections, observations). Findings are the result of evaluation by the Consultants. Conclusions
can be thought of as the diagnosis, with recommendations the Consultant's view on the change solution.
Judgement is an important factor in going from findings to conclusions to recommendations.
End of Page 16
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
20/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 17 of 19
To complete this know ledge check activity, see the Knowledge Check section at the end of this lesson.
End of Page 17
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
21/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 18 of 19
To complete this know ledge check activity, see the Knowledge Check section at the end of this lesson.
End of Page 18
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
22/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting Page 19 of 19
To complete this know ledge check activity, see the Knowledge Check section at the end of this lesson.
End of Page 19
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
23/30
Module: Managing Change in Organisations
Unit: Identifying, Understanding and Involving Others inChange
Lesson: Understanding Change Through Consulting
Knowledge Checks
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
24/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting - Page 17
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
25/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting - Page 18
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
26/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting - Page 19
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
27/30
Module: Managing Change in Organisations
Unit: Identifying, Understanding and Involving Others inChange
Lesson: Understanding Change Through Consulting
Knowledge Checks - Solutions
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
28/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting - Page 17
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
29/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting - Page 18
-
8/2/2019 Undstndin Change Thru Consultin
30/30
Understanding Change Through Consulting - Page 19